2aHawaii

General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: groveler on October 16, 2019, 06:48:34 AM

Title: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: groveler on October 16, 2019, 06:48:34 AM
"Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun confiscation."
Proposed at the Democrat debate.

Pretty easy to do in Hawaii.
Everybody registers their guns here.
I'm curious how many HPD( yours and mine)will
show up at your door and demand your
AR, AK, or 10/22?
They have anything better to do?
You are easy targets,  you obey the laws.
Real criminals shoot back.
Aloha.

Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 16, 2019, 09:24:03 AM
I would say 100% of HPD will comply with "orders".  Not only if there was a buy back, but also any red flag orders as well.

Man in WA recently had his guns confiscated.  He posted a pic of himself holding an AK and talking about the Joker movie.  He didn't say he was going to do anything violent.  But they looked at previous tweets and found some in 2017 when he was "threatening" females.  They didn't use his Joker tweet for reasons of red flag, but the 2017 tweets.
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: mrgaf on October 16, 2019, 04:48:46 PM
What’s sad about it is that 90% will cower at the presence of the “pigs” and give them up without so much as a “f-off you, pig” to their faces. I’m getting all mine outta here with just a shotgun or two so I can shoot trap and skeet. HPD told me in a letter that they could care less where I take my guns as long as it was out of the state, no paperwork was needed as long as they’re gone. If they ever come to my home while I’m still here and ask where all my registered firearms are I’ll shove the letter in their faces and tell them to go find them back in mainland. ;)

Just remember law enforcement in any form are not you friends....
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: ren on October 19, 2019, 08:24:50 AM
(http://www.usrifleteams.com/forums/uploads/monthly_2019_08/Saul.JPG.12c59cea6ecae886d2226b591479837c.JPG)
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 22, 2019, 08:27:03 PM
I would say 100% of HPD will comply with "orders".  Not only if there was a buy back, but also any red flag orders as well.

A "buy back" (confiscation) is a bit different than a red flag order though.
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 22, 2019, 08:40:22 PM
A "buy back" (confiscation) is a bit different than a red flag order though.
Yeah, 1 law abiding are forced to drive to the police station or become a felon by a certain date which is known by the law abiding citizen.

Other SSD kicks the door in and takes it from its legal owner with zero notice to said owner.

A few police unions stated they will not participate in any buy back if beto wins presidency. 

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: RSN172 on October 23, 2019, 04:43:06 AM
There is zero chance of Beto getting elected so no need worry about his stupid plan which also violates more than
just the 2nd amendment.
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: 6716J on October 23, 2019, 09:43:53 AM
The dark side of this is that Beto calls for the mandatory buyback and as far reaching policies as "he" can think of. Everyone gets riled up and says no to that, but a little while later, halfway there is acceptable. It's the Cass Sunstein method of 'Nudge". Throw a fit on the outrageous and then the "sane" one comes in to save the day with a "reasonable" proposal and everyone loves it...

F government
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 24, 2019, 09:02:29 PM
Yeah, 1 law abiding are forced to drive to the police station or become a felon by a certain date which is known by the law abiding citizen.

Other SSD kicks the door in and takes it from its legal owner with zero notice to said owner.

A few police unions stated they will not participate in any buy back if beto wins presidency. 

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

The difference is that an officer doesn't always know the content of a judge's order. The judge issues an order and the cops make an arrest based on the order without knowing the facts and circumstances of the case. That's where the difference lies, any officer can know confiscation is unconstitutional but your average patrol officer may not know that the judge's order to take a firearm was constitutional or not. For example, a cop stops a speeder and the computer shows there is a warrant for an arrest. The cop doesn't research the case first and determine whether the judge was right, they just act on good faith on the judge's order.
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 24, 2019, 10:57:16 PM
The difference is that an officer doesn't always know the content of a judge's order. The judge issues an order and the cops make an arrest based on the order without knowing the facts and circumstances of the case. That's where the difference lies, any officer can know confiscation is unconstitutional but your average patrol officer may not know that the judge's order to take a firearm was constitutional or not. For example, a cop stops a speeder and the computer shows there is a warrant for an arrest. The cop doesn't research the case first and determine whether the judge was right, they just act on good faith on the judge's order.
This is where the problem is. Im sure red flag has come up recently amongst  hpd. So when an order is given after jan 1, maybe they should question it. Or have higher ups state they will not enforce an unconstitutional law and stand up for the people.

And everyone knows our judges will hand them out like candy and a rubber stamp. See FL as an example. Since it was enacted, 2600 people have been red flagged.  Law abiding with zero felonies had their guns and ammo taken away.

How many of these orders took guns out of the hands of drug dealers, gang memebers, or any other felons? Im betting slim to none.

And im willing to assume that to get any guns back, the permit to acquire process will have to be done all over again. And no ammo will be returned or monetary comensation given.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 25, 2019, 10:42:18 PM
This is where the problem is. Im sure red flag has come up recently amongst  hpd. So when an order is given after jan 1, maybe they should question it. Or have higher ups state they will not enforce an unconstitutional law and stand up for the people.

And everyone knows our judges will hand them out like candy and a rubber stamp. See FL as an example. Since it was enacted, 2600 people have been red flagged.  Law abiding with zero felonies had their guns and ammo taken away.

How many of these orders took guns out of the hands of drug dealers, gang memebers, or any other felons? Im betting slim to none.

And im willing to assume that to get any guns back, the permit to acquire process will have to be done all over again. And no ammo will be returned or monetary comensation given.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

If the beat officer gets to read the whole case before serving the order then the argument can be made that he/she can see the case and know the order is not lawful but if all the officer has access to is a plain order from a judge that does not provide details then it is harder to say they should know it unconstitutional as all they would have is the judge's order. I think that's where the good faith argument comes in.

I don't know where you get the idea that ammo will not be returned. Does a red flag order even confiscate ammo at all?
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 25, 2019, 11:38:25 PM
Yes ammo and it wont be returned or monetary compensation.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 26, 2019, 12:08:57 AM
When an arrest warrant is executed, there is a charge/conviction listed as to the legal justification for the warrant. The Cops need to know what they are walking into when they execute warrants.  Searching a gang member's apartment for drugs or guns is a little different than placing a soccer mom under arrest for failing to appear for jury duty.

When a "red flag" warrant is executed, there can be no criminal statute or conviction listed since there has been no crime committed.  The only legal justification on the warrant would be the statute that permits confiscating guns.  The Cops don't have to know the details of the case, as in what the reported triggering behavior or worrisome comments were.  If the Cops are going to refuse to execute red flag warrants, it'll be for ALL warrants issued under the red flag statute.

It'll be pretty obvious to any officer executing a firearm confiscation order that it's red flag related.  No associated arrest, no criminal charges, no criminal convictions. 

It's pre-crime in its most unconstitutional form -- they will take your guns before you commit any crime even though they have no psychics predicting you will.
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 26, 2019, 09:50:07 AM
When an arrest warrant is executed, there is a charge/conviction listed as to the legal justification for the warrant. The Cops need to know what they are walking into when they execute warrants.  Searching a gang member's apartment for drugs or guns is a little different than placing a soccer mom under arrest for failing to appear for jury duty.

When a "red flag" warrant is executed, there can be no criminal statute or conviction listed since there has been no crime committed.  The only legal justification on the warrant would be the statute that permits confiscating guns.  The Cops don't have to know the details of the case, as in what the reported triggering behavior or worrisome comments were.  If the Cops are going to refuse to execute red flag warrants, it'll be for ALL warrants issued under the red flag statute.

It'll be pretty obvious to any officer executing a firearm confiscation order that it's red flag related.  No associated arrest, no criminal charges, no criminal convictions. 

It's pre-crime in its most unconstitutional form -- they will take your guns before you commit any crime even though they have no psychics predicting you will.

You are assuming that all of this information is indicated on the warrant.

Maybe it is and the cop can tell but maybe very little is given. There could be a risk that the judge's order was entirely justified and the officer refuses on just the label of red flag, in which case the officer would have a hard time defending his decision to refuse the order. Patrol officers aren't constitutional scholars as much as we would like them to be so I think it is a little harsh to put this entirely at the feet of your average cop.
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 26, 2019, 10:25:52 AM
You are assuming that all of this information is indicated on the warrant.

Maybe it is and the cop can tell but maybe very little is given. There could be a risk that the judge's order was entirely justified and the officer refuses on just the label of red flag, in which case the officer would have a hard time defending his decision to refuse the order. Patrol officers aren't constitutional scholars as much as we would like them to be so I think it is a little harsh to put this entirely at the feet of your average cop.

"Maybe" is not a valid argument.

I've looked at samples of arrest warrants. There is a line for the offense (code #) and a separate section for a more complete description.  There will be more information in the warrant application and affidavit, but the specific crime/justification for the warrant is listed on its face.

Cops are not robots. They are given information they need to know when arresting people.  Warrants are not given to any street cop to execute. They are sent to a warrant service office, usually at the Sheriff's office.  They, in turn, can enlist a street cop's assistance, but the warrant has to be in hand to be given to the person being arrested, property searched, or property seized.
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: macsak on October 26, 2019, 10:34:43 AM
You are assuming that all of this information is indicated on the warrant.

Maybe it is and the cop can tell but maybe very little is given. There could be a risk that the judge's order was entirely justified and the officer refuses on just the label of red flag, in which case the officer would have a hard time defending his decision to refuse the order. Patrol officers aren't constitutional scholars as much as we would like them to be so I think it is a little harsh to put this entirely at the feet of your average cop.

good thing you are not an average cop...
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 27, 2019, 09:52:24 PM
"Maybe" is not a valid argument.

I've looked at samples of arrest warrants. There is a line for the offense (code #) and a separate section for a more complete description.  There will be more information in the warrant application and affidavit, but the specific crime/justification for the warrant is listed on its face.

Cops are not robots. They are given information they need to know when arresting people.  Warrants are not given to any street cop to execute. They are sent to a warrant service office, usually at the Sheriff's office.  They, in turn, can enlist a street cop's assistance, but the warrant has to be in hand to be given to the person being arrested, property searched, or property seized.

"maybe" was never an argument, it is considering both sides of the issue in the face of the unknown. If I assume to know what a red flag order from a judge looks like I have a very real chance at being wrong.

Warrants are regularly given to street cops to execute. The Sherriffs also do serve them as well. Street cops serve all sorts of judges orders from arrest warrants to restraining orders to mental health detainment orders, to penal summons.
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 27, 2019, 09:52:55 PM
good thing you are not an average cop...

Is that a compliment?
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: macsak on October 28, 2019, 07:41:06 AM
Is that a compliment?

perhaps one might be inclined to possibly perceive that might be true
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 28, 2019, 08:51:36 AM
"maybe" was never an argument, it is considering both sides of the issue in the face of the unknown. If I assume to know what a red flag order from a judge looks like I have a very real chance at being wrong.

Warrants are regularly given to street cops to execute. The Sherriffs also do serve them as well. Street cops serve all sorts of judges orders from arrest warrants to restraining orders to mental health detainment orders, to penal summons.

HOw many gun consification warrants have been issued in the past few years?  The most recent related one was the pakalolo letter many got.  But even those said they had to surrender firearms by X date.  Not kicking the door in at 3am. 

I'm willing to bet that that number will increase 10 fold starting Jan 1st.  So any LE with some problem solving skills can assume that "hey this might be a red flag warrant".  Maybe we should dig deeper or not enforce.  But then again, everyone will blindly follow, so it's just wishful hopes.
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 28, 2019, 11:40:53 AM
Is that a compliment?

Maybe.
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 28, 2019, 10:10:10 PM
HOw many gun consification warrants have been issued in the past few years?  The most recent related one was the pakalolo letter many got.  But even those said they had to surrender firearms by X date.  Not kicking the door in at 3am. 

I'm willing to bet that that number will increase 10 fold starting Jan 1st.  So any LE with some problem solving skills can assume that "hey this might be a red flag warrant".  Maybe we should dig deeper or not enforce.  But then again, everyone will blindly follow, so it's just wishful hopes.

Not sure. The law has a few different ways in which someone can lose their right to possess a firearm and not sure if they all are done through the same process.

I recall a friend bought his friends firearms due to a TRO (or abuse?) case against him. The guy had time to transfer the firearms without cops coming in and searching his house. But the nature of the red flag issue really doesn't make any sense to request the voluntary request to turn in a firearm. Part of the red flag law is to deal with immediate threats so sending a letter and giving someone a week would hardly be effective.

But like I said, maybe the cop can dig and find something but maybe he won't have access to the full case. Until it starts happening, we won't know. I wouldn't call it blind following, I think most cops just try to make a good faith action. Plus consider the repercussions for the officer if they didn't act and that was the one instance where they really should have(guy kills a bunch of people). Officer gets fired and sued for millions of dollars and potentially jailed for contempt. Then he has to hire his own lawyer and defend all of that on the idea that red flag laws are unconstitutional which he really has no way of knowing whether he can win at the supreme court level.
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 29, 2019, 09:21:23 AM
Not sure. The law has a few different ways in which someone can lose their right to possess a firearm and not sure if they all are done through the same process.

I recall a friend bought his friends firearms due to a TRO (or abuse?) case against him. The guy had time to transfer the firearms without cops coming in and searching his house. But the nature of the red flag issue really doesn't make any sense to request the voluntary request to turn in a firearm. Part of the red flag law is to deal with immediate threats so sending a letter and giving someone a week would hardly be effective.

But like I said, maybe the cop can dig and find something but maybe he won't have access to the full case. Until it starts happening, we won't know. I wouldn't call it blind following, I think most cops just try to make a good faith action. Plus consider the repercussions for the officer if they didn't act and that was the one instance where they really should have(guy kills a bunch of people). Officer gets fired and sued for millions of dollars and potentially jailed for contempt. Then he has to hire his own lawyer and defend all of that on the idea that red flag laws are unconstitutional which he really has no way of knowing whether he can win at the supreme court level.

At least your friend had time.  They changed the law so now you have less time.  Which pretty much means you have to walk into HPD and surrender them.  Still get a letter, and not a kick in the door by SSD at 3am.  Do you see the difference now? Letter vs. flashbang.

You're "what ifs" hold no merit.  Because if we went by "what ifs", then someone can take your car away because what if you drink and drive and injure someone?  Someone can also assign you to desk duty because what if you injure an unarmed/no threat civilian.  This is excatlly what red flags do is try and predict the future.
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: ren on October 29, 2019, 09:57:50 AM
I wont trust my right to a police officer "who may do the right thing". Ill err on the side of the argument that a police officer would just follow orders or directions to take away your guns.
All these laws are designed to transfer your right to defend yourself and have or hopefully have the government do that for you.
Same red flag concept can be applied to clumsy people, DUI, reckless people, people of a certain race who  are statistically represented in crimes etc.
Red flag laws circumvent the very principle of our justice system; you are INNOCENT UNTIL PROVEN GUILTY.
This is just one step in turning our system into a socialist one.
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 29, 2019, 10:13:43 AM
Maybe ....

.... someone is just venting and says something another person takes as "worrisome" and reports him under the red flag law.

After he's had his guns forcibly seized with no notice, has to appear before a judge to prove he's not a threat (prove a negative -- accused of no crime with no evidence?  So much for burden of proof being on the state.).

He loses time from work (income), pays to hire a lawyer, is being gossiped about by all his neighbors after seeing 6 police cars and a tactical unit storm his apartment and leave with several firearms, and may be hearing his coworkers also know what happened and are talking.


Maybe ... he wasn't a threat BEFORE he underwent this stressful, expensive and embarrassing invasion of his privacy, but perhaps it is enough to push him to retaliate against the person who reported him, the police, and/or the neighbors/coworkers?
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: groveler on October 29, 2019, 12:52:11 PM
Looks like Joe Biden has jumped on the band wagon, AR's, AK's, and like type rifles will
have to be surrendered to the government or registered as NFA weapons( kind of pricey!),
should he be elected President.
Make your plans.


Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 29, 2019, 01:10:59 PM
Looks like Joe Biden has jumped on the band wagon, AR's, AK's, and like type rifles will
have to be surrendered to the government or registered as NFA weapons( kind of pricey!),
should he be elected President.
Make your plans.

Aren't they all on the ban wagon?
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on October 29, 2019, 01:41:32 PM
Aren't they all on the ban wagon?

I see what you did there.   :geekdanc:
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: RSN172 on October 29, 2019, 04:41:12 PM
That will assure them of NOT being elected POTUS
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 29, 2019, 08:58:51 PM
At least your friend had time.  They changed the law so now you have less time.  Which pretty much means you have to walk into HPD and surrender them.  Still get a letter, and not a kick in the door by SSD at 3am.  Do you see the difference now? Letter vs. flashbang.

You're "what ifs" hold no merit.  Because if we went by "what ifs", then someone can take your car away because what if you drink and drive and injure someone?  Someone can also assign you to desk duty because what if you injure an unarmed/no threat civilian.  This is excatlly what red flags do is try and predict the future.

I don't think you are grasping the seriousness of the decision that the officer faces. Officers regularly do what they think is legal only to end up making case law down the road. An officer disobeying an order from a judge is going to face some serious potential issues.

Imagine an order to a soldier in the military. The superior tells the subordinate to shoot into a house but the subordinate sees someone innocent in the window. The soldier is faced with a decision to do what he thinks is right vs what he is ordered to do. If he refuses the order he could be court-martialed but is the court going to uphold his decision as refusing an unlawful order or is  the court going to punish the soldier because it turned out there was a good reason to shoot into the building regardless of the collateral damage?


Let me ask you this: Can you envision a better system that would deal with how to address individuals who exhibit multiple warning signs that they are about to commit an atrocity?

Personally I haven't come up with a better way yet though I am pushing towards amending the red flag law to provide more protections to the accused.
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: macsak on October 29, 2019, 09:13:39 PM
Officers regularly do what they think is legal only to end up making case law down the road.

please list instances where this has taken place
if it happens "regularly" you should have no problem listing 10-12 cases easily...
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 29, 2019, 09:34:11 PM
please list instances where this has taken place
if it happens "regularly" you should have no problem listing 10-12 cases easily...

https://www.policeone.com/legal/articles/policeone-analysis-12-supreme-court-cases-affecting-cops-vITaFgCmjhrJX7Gw/

In some of these cases the SCOTUS upheld the action of the officer but in other cases ruled the officer was wrong.

On top of that there are probably a lot more state supreme court cases.
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: macsak on October 29, 2019, 09:51:46 PM
https://www.policeone.com/legal/articles/policeone-analysis-12-supreme-court-cases-affecting-cops-vITaFgCmjhrJX7Gw/

In some of these cases the SCOTUS upheld the action of the officer but in other cases ruled the officer was wrong.

On top of that there are probably a lot more state supreme court cases.

those are cases which resulted in case law due to the officer's actions
please list cases where officers made case law
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: changemyoil66 on October 29, 2019, 09:53:40 PM
I don't think you are grasping the seriousness of the decision that the officer faces. Officers regularly do what they think is legal only to end up making case law down the road. An officer disobeying an order from a judge is going to face some serious potential issues.

Imagine an order to a soldier in the military. The superior tells the subordinate to shoot into a house but the subordinate sees someone innocent in the window. The soldier is faced with a decision to do what he thinks is right vs what he is ordered to do. If he refuses the order he could be court-martialed but is the court going to uphold his decision as refusing an unlawful order or is  the court going to punish the soldier because it turned out there was a good reason to shoot into the building regardless of the collateral damage?


Let me ask you this: Can you envision a better system that would deal with how to address individuals who exhibit multiple warning signs that they are about to commit an atrocity?

Personally I haven't come up with a better way yet though I am pushing towards amending the red flag law to provide more protections to the accused.
Take your soldier example and add in children also in the home. LT orders solder to toss a grenade through the window and soldier says no. Or he does it and someone  narcs on him in the after action of what they saw. 

They teach an ethics course at Annapolis. A pilot is given orders to bomb an enemy convoy. As he makes his bomb run, the vehilces stop and all occupants exit and raise their hands and a white flag. Does the pilot folllow orders or wave off? Say he waves off, now anytime an aircraft approaches, the enemy does the same thing. Only to wait for the plane to run out of fuel, then continue fighting. This was on Nat Geo, a show about the naval academy.

 Remember the orders given to german solders in 1936. That almost all obeyed. The courts even ruled that the law was changed and jews were bad. Politicians changed the law and judges upheld the unjust laws.

So cops shouldnt follow orders blindly. The sheriffs in many states said they wont enforce red flags and theyre all still employed.

What shall we do to prevent a mental person from shooting somewhere up? Remove gun free zones and have HPD issue ccw/oc permits. Problem greatly reduced.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 31, 2019, 10:13:29 PM
those are cases which resulted in case law due to the officer's actions
please list cases where officers made case law

Thats what I meant by made case law. Sorry if there was any confusion.
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 31, 2019, 10:20:31 PM
Take your soldier example and add in children also in the home. LT orders solder to toss a grenade through the window and soldier says no. Or he does it and someone  narcs on him in the after action of what they saw. 

They teach an ethics course at Annapolis. A pilot is given orders to bomb an enemy convoy. As he makes his bomb run, the vehilces stop and all occupants exit and raise their hands and a white flag. Does the pilot folllow orders or wave off? Say he waves off, now anytime an aircraft approaches, the enemy does the same thing. Only to wait for the plane to run out of fuel, then continue fighting. This was on Nat Geo, a show about the naval academy.

 Remember the orders given to german solders in 1936. That almost all obeyed. The courts even ruled that the law was changed and jews were bad. Politicians changed the law and judges upheld the unjust laws.

So cops shouldnt follow orders blindly. The sheriffs in many states said they wont enforce red flags and theyre all still employed.

What shall we do to prevent a mental person from shooting somewhere up? Remove gun free zones and have HPD issue ccw/oc permits. Problem greatly reduced.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

All I am saying is we should give a little leeway to patrol officers who, most of the time, are doing their job on good faith. The anger should reside more with the judges, who should know best, over some beat cop who gets a warrant and enforces it in good faith.

Don't get me wrong, it is a complicated issue, sometimes with no clear right or wrong as in the order given to the pilot, there is just a decision that could have grave consequences either way.



Personally I see no reason to believe that issuing concealed carry permits and getting rid of gun free zones will reduce the number of people who go on shooting sprees. There are many examples where their sprees are cut short by a good samaritan but CCW is much more of a responsive measure than a preventive measure. So CCW good but lets also think about prevention measures as well.
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: macsak on October 31, 2019, 10:23:21 PM
Thats what I meant by made case law. Sorry if there was any confusion.

I am not confused
perhaps you could have possibly maybe added in a few modifiers that would make it more than likely that your statements might be within the realm of truth like you normally may be inclined to do
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 31, 2019, 10:45:35 PM
I am not confused
perhaps you could have possibly maybe added in a few modifiers that would make it more than likely that your statements might be within the realm of truth like you normally may be inclined to do

It is a saying, a phrase. Obviously police officers don't make the law themselves, they don't set precedent, the courts do with the case the officer took some action on.
Glad we can clear that up. I also won't tell you I am going to run some errands since I will really only just walk and drive.
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: 6716J on November 01, 2019, 08:27:35 AM
Personally I see no reason to believe that issuing concealed carry permits and getting rid of gun free zones will reduce the number of people who go on shooting sprees. There are many examples where their sprees are cut short by a good samaritan but CCW is much more of a responsive measure than a preventive measure. So CCW good but lets also think about prevention measures as well.

It's been fairly well documented that roughly 95% of mass shootings occur in "gun free" zones. Eliminate the GFZs and you will stop a majority of mass shootings. Will it stop every crazy? No... But it will stop the majority of them


https://spectator.org/mass-shootings-in-gun-free-zones/
https://crimeresearch.org/2018/06/more-misleading-information-from-bloombergs-everytown-for-gun-safety-on-guns-analysis-of-recent-mass-shootings/
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/fact-checker/wp/2018/05/10/do-98-percent-of-mass-public-shootings-happen-in-gun-free-zones/

But the root of it really is for us as it is in nature.
Does the predator attack the weakest and least defended or the most defended?
(https://i1.wp.com/planandprepared.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/JZnnyCI.gif)
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: changemyoil66 on November 01, 2019, 09:30:49 AM
All I am saying is we should give a little leeway to patrol officers who, most of the time, are doing their job on good faith. The anger should reside more with the judges, who should know best, over some beat cop who gets a warrant and enforces it in good faith.

Don't get me wrong, it is a complicated issue, sometimes with no clear right or wrong as in the order given to the pilot, there is just a decision that could have grave consequences either way.



Personally I see no reason to believe that issuing concealed carry permits and getting rid of gun free zones will reduce the number of people who go on shooting sprees. There are many examples where their sprees are cut short by a good samaritan but CCW is much more of a responsive measure than a preventive measure. So CCW good but lets also think about prevention measures as well.

It's very difficult to stop a motivated person who has evil intentions.  But what you can do is reduce the amount of damage this person does by having someone armed respond quicker than when the police show up.  There are only select places where no one is evil enough to start an active shooting, a gun show.  Even police stations have crazys come in who want the death by cop suicide and every person there is armed.

But having gun free zones do not help because that forces someone who could have been armed, to leave their gun in the car or at home.  This is what's known as a soft target and according to the FBI/CDC 96% of active shootings happen in these places.  So logic would dictate that a gun free zone sign doesn't work at all.  So let someone carry if they wish.  I remember watching an old clip of a mother in the 90's talking at a hearing in DC.  She and her family went to a TGIF to eat dinner.  They had a no guns allowed sign.  So her and her husband disarmed and left their guns in the car.  Someone came to rob the place and shot it up instead.  Her husband was killed and 2 children.  Her testimony was if she or him were armed, her husband and 2 children would be alive today.

Regarding the good faith of HPD, red flags have been a nation wide issue and they should be aware that it's a violation of the 4th amendment.  Thus not enforce.  But like I mentioned before, not 1 officer will have the balls to say no because they would either get fired or be passed up for promotions. I'm sure there are pro 2a orgs that will go to HPD to let them know to educate them if they believed it would work.  Because educating senators/reps don't work.  They could care less about rights.
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: groveler on November 01, 2019, 10:28:46 AM
Take your soldier example and add in children also in the home. LT orders solder to toss a grenade through the window and soldier says no. Or he does it and someone  narcs on him in the after action of what they saw. 

They teach an ethics course at Annapolis. A pilot is given orders to bomb an enemy convoy. As he makes his bomb run, the vehilces stop and all occupants exit and raise their hands and a white flag. Does the pilot folllow orders or wave off? Say he waves off, now anytime an aircraft approaches, the enemy does the same thing. Only to wait for the plane to run out of fuel, then continue fighting. This was on Nat Geo, a show about the naval academy.

 Remember the orders given to german solders in 1936. That almost all obeyed. The courts even ruled that the law was changed and jews were bad. Politicians changed the law and judges upheld the unjust laws.

So cops shouldnt follow orders blindly. The sheriffs in many states said they wont enforce red flags and theyre all still employed.

What shall we do to prevent a mental person from shooting somewhere up? Remove gun free zones and have HPD issue ccw/oc permits. Problem greatly reduced.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
This was an interesting back and forth.
One issue is that Police are not soldiers in a war zone.
We don't pay Cops to destroy "stuff" and peoples lives.
We pay them to enforce laws and hopefully,  sometimes
assist those in need of help.
We pay soldiers to break things.  In my military ethics training,
I was taught to use my best judgement when given an
order to do something out of the ordinary, such as lining
up women and children and shooting them when they were
unarmed.
On the Annapolis ethics anecdote you shared,  I would have
destroyed the vehicles, but not strafed the personnel.
Title: Re: Beto O'Rourke's proposal of a mandatory "assault weapon" buyback, aka, gun /snip
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on November 01, 2019, 11:29:03 AM
This was an interesting back and forth.
One issue is that Police are not soldiers in a war zone.
We don't pay Cops to destroy "stuff" and peoples lives.
We pay them to enforce laws and hopefully,  sometimes
assist those in need of help.
We pay soldiers to break things.  In my military ethics training,
I was taught to use my best judgement when given an
order to do something out of the ordinary, such as lining
up women and children and shooting them when they were
unarmed.
On the Annapolis ethics anecdote you shared,  I would have
destroyed the vehicles, but not strafed the personnel.

The hypothetical requires more information for me to form an opinion/decision.

If there are friendly units near enough, hold the convoy at bay. When the friendlies arrive, they can take prisoners and confiscate the vehicles and cargo.

If you don't have enough fuel to wait, is there another jet/jets on station who can take over while you refuel -- possibly a mid-air refuel?

In combat, air units have many aircraft on station, either as support or for escorting those support craft that have no means of defense if attacked.

If the planners knew there was a convoy scheduled for that time and place, and they only had one plane to send, then the choice is simpler.  Take out the convoy.  "Any man don't wanna get killed, better clear on out the back."

Timemark 4:11 ....

https://youtu.be/KmhGYB4NdYc