2aHawaii

General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: Tom_G on June 01, 2012, 05:43:05 AM

Title: No serial #?
Post by: Tom_G on June 01, 2012, 05:43:05 AM
One of the guns I am bringing home has no serial number.  I don't see anywhere in HRS that a SN is required, but I know several people who have tried to register such guns only to have HPD refuse to process the gun until it was stamped.  This piece has some collector's value, so I don't want to stamp it if I don't have to.  Thoughts?
Title: Re: No serial #?
Post by: Funtimes on June 01, 2012, 06:05:20 AM
One of the guns I am bringing home has no serial number.  I don't see anywhere in HRS that a SN is required, but I know several people who have tried to register such guns only to have HPD refuse to process the gun until it was stamped.  This piece has some collector's value, so I don't want to stamp it if I don't have to.  Thoughts?

Guns without serial numbers could probably be considered unusual. Are there *ANY* markings on it that could be used as the 'serial' number?
Title: Re: No serial #?
Post by: jc2721 on June 01, 2012, 06:25:03 AM
I know for a fact that HPD will require a serial number on a firearm in order to register it.  I have seen the guys at a LGS hand-engrave a "G number" (from the HPD permit forms) on a gun.  This has usually been on cheap .22 rifles where no serial numbers were ever stamped.  Call Security Equipment and talk to Richard.

You might be able to engrave the numbers in an inconspicuous area like under the stock line.  If not, how about engraving serial number 001 on the piece?
Title: Re: No serial #?
Post by: Colt808 on June 01, 2012, 06:47:31 AM
I know for a fact that HPD will require a serial number on a firearm in order to register it.  I have seen the guys at a LGS hand-engrave a "G number" (from the HPD permit forms) on a gun.  This has usually been on cheap .22 rifles where no serial numbers were ever stamped.  Call Security Equipment and talk to Richard.

You might be able to engrave the numbers in an inconspicuous area like under the stock line.  If not, how about engraving serial number 001 on the piece?

Sorry, but this is incorrect. HPD does not  require a serial number (nor does HRS). I have registered 4 firearms (2 pistols, 1 rifle, 1 shotgun) WITHOUT serial numbers. All are collectible pieces and HPD did not "force" me to serialize them. They simply put "PRE-1968" on the registration and detailed info in the description box. And they still do this because just 3 weeks ago I saw a guy register a shotgun he got from his father's estate...pre-1968, no serial, no problem.

***I don't doubt what you say, but it's likely that the serial numbers you've seen engraved were at the request of the owner OR because it was a "homemade" firearm.

Tom: As long as it was made before Federal law required it (1968), you do not need to number it.
Title: Re: No serial #?
Post by: Funtimes on June 01, 2012, 11:03:35 AM
Hrm, I need to look at the 68 stuff, sounds interesting.

My next adventure is with registration, HDF just got it's collectors and curio FFL. It will be interesting for them to try and not register my guns to the company now.
Title: Re: No serial #?
Post by: Colt808 on June 01, 2012, 03:30:31 PM
Hrm, I need to look at the 68 stuff, sounds interesting.

My next adventure is with registration, HDF just got it's collectors and curio FFL. It will be interesting for them to try and not register my guns to the company now.

18 U.S.C. Chapter 44 only requires serial numbers by those who manufacture or import (regardless of manufacture date). I don't see anything in in 18 U.S.C. or ATF 5300 requiring a C&R licensee to mark/serialize.
Title: Re: No serial #?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on June 01, 2012, 09:19:24 PM
One of the guns I am bringing home has no serial number.  I don't see anywhere in HRS that a SN is required, but I know several people who have tried to register such guns only to have HPD refuse to process the gun until it was stamped.  This piece has some collector's value, so I don't want to stamp it if I don't have to.  Thoughts?

Call HPD and report back what they say. I cannot think they would necessarily deny it based on state law. It is conceivable that there are older firearms still in existence that were made before serial numbers were required or before they were common.
Title: Re: No serial #?
Post by: Dblnaknak on June 02, 2012, 11:25:06 AM
They made me stamp a serial number on a .22 I got from my grandfather. All firearms require a serial number in Hawaii. If it is still able to fire a projectile you need a serial number. Call HPD for verification.
Title: Re: No serial #?
Post by: Tom_G on June 28, 2012, 04:25:12 PM
No serial number needed.  Oddly, though, in the registration form, they put my G-number from my permit as the serial number.  Should present a conundrum if I try to sell it in state.  Not to worry, they made an impressive number of mistakes besides that one.  A FN mauser became a CZ, an 8mm mausrr became a 7.92, any other fun.
Title: Re: No serial #?
Post by: Colt808 on June 29, 2012, 11:09:44 PM
No serial number needed.  Oddly, though, in the registration form, they put my G-number from my permit as the serial number.  Should present a conundrum if I try to sell it in state.  Not to worry, they made an impressive number of mistakes besides that one.  A FN mauser became a CZ, an 8mm mausrr became a 7.92, any other fun.

They'll just use the G-number from the next guy. (Glad you didn't go out and deface it with an unnecessary serial number.)

Whenever mistakes are made on my registrations, I make them redo it. Doesn't matter how minor or silly. If it's going to be required, it's damn well going to be accurate. The "record" so far has been 4 redo's...Needless to say, I was their least favorite person that day.
Title: Re: No serial #?
Post by: bass monkey on June 30, 2012, 07:44:59 AM
You make them redo it? I think the guys at hpd are stating to not like me because of my bad chicken scratch handwriting. I fill out the form, the guys looks it over and Perry much asks me what does this say, what does this say and writes it in himself. Once, the guy told me I need to write clearly, because whatever I put is what they will type, or whatever they think it is. I told him I'm fine with that. He didn't seem happy with my response.
Title: Re: No serial #?
Post by: 230RN on July 01, 2012, 06:31:01 AM
Back in the late 70s I spent almost an hour cooling my heels while a game warden had to radio in to HQ for verification of the fact that the unserialized pre-GCA68.22 I was using was legal.  I couldn't hear what was said over the radio, but it looked like there was a lot of dialog and a lot of waiting until they found someone at HQ knowledgeable about it.  Damned waste of good and valuable  daylight huntin' time, to my mind.

I have a few guns that have no serial numbers including a pump shotgun.  Serial numbers were used mainly for process and inventory and quality control by the manufacturers, like the serial number on your refrigerator.

G-d only knows how many thousands of 6.5 Carcanos are running around loose in the US without serial numbers because some refurbishing company in Italy re-barreled them for export to the US, and the SNs on Carcanos were originally stamped on the barrels.  The new barrels were unserialized. OMG, noooo!(http://gunrightsmedia.com/images/smilies/eek.gif) !

I bought a pristine Mosin-Nagant 91/30 which looked as if it was never used, but apparently nowadays imported Curio and Relic (C&R) guns have to have "fresh" serial numbers scratched onto them, and I was pretty POed when I discovered this defacement. 

Ah, but now it can never be used in a crime, 'cause, after all, it now has a fresh, new importer's serial number! 

Right? 

Right.

I feel soooo much better about it now knowing that it's been purified and sanctified by the good ole US of A goobermint.

Terry, 230RN
Title: Re: No serial #?
Post by: Tom_G on July 31, 2012, 11:38:57 AM
Update.

Turns out I should have read my HRS more carefully. 
Quote from: HRS 134-4
If the firearm has no serial number, the permit number shall be entered in the space provided for the serial number, and the permit number shall be engraved upon the receiver portion of the firearm prior to registration.

So, when you show up to register it, they don't actually force you to have it stamped first.  After all, they are only just then assigning the new serial number.  However, if you bring that gun back (for example, to joint register it with your spouse) they will refuse to process the gun until it has the serial number engraved.  So, while you can register it without modifying it, you're now stuck with it.  You can't sell it in state, transfer it in state, or joint register it without first stamping it.

Soooo.... anyone care to lend me a set of stamps?

I discovered this today, trying to joint register an un-serialzed Mossberg .22 rifle.  What is weird is that I bought this gun as a consignment from Young Guns. 
Title: No serial #?
Post by: hnl.flyboy on July 31, 2012, 11:56:35 AM
Update.

Turns out I should have read my HRS more carefully. 
So, when you show up to register it, they don't actually force you to have it stamped first.  After all, they are only just then assigning the new serial number.  However, if you bring that gun back (for example, to joint register it with your spouse) they will refuse to process the gun until it has the serial number engraved.  So, while you can register it without modifying it, you're now stuck with it.  You can't sell it in state, transfer it in state, or joint register it without first stamping it.

Soooo.... anyone care to lend me a set of stamps?

I discovered this today, trying to joint register an un-serialzed Mossberg .22 rifle.  What is weird is that I bought this gun as a consignment from Young Guns.

I'd say just keep it registered only to yourself. It's not a handgun, so you don't need to be around when it's used.
Title: Re: No serial #?
Post by: Tom_G on July 31, 2012, 12:36:37 PM
I'd say just keep it registered only to yourself. It's not a handgun, so you don't need to be around when it's used.

This is more of a "being prudent" thing than worrying about whether or not we both can use the guns.  Odds are, they won't ever leave the house without me, I'm the shooter in the family.  But in the non-zero chance that I get shuffled off this mortal coil abruptly, it's a hassle that won't have to be endured during an awful time.
Title: Re: No serial #?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 25, 2012, 02:25:55 AM
I think I found the answer ins section 134-4 section b.
It says, referring to the registration process,
"If the firearm has no serial number, the permit  benumber shall be entered in the space provided for the serial number (on the form) and the permit number shall be engraved upon the receiver portion of the firearm prior to registration."

So it doesn't really explain the engraving process but it looks like you do have to get the firearm engraved.

Does the firearm still work? Does anyone actually make ammunition it can use? There might be another way that you don't have to register it but it sounds kind of like you don't have a choice at this point.
Title: Re: No serial #?
Post by: Tom_G on September 25, 2012, 06:36:25 AM
I think I found the answer ins section 134-4 section b.
It says, referring to the registration process,
"If the firearm has no serial number, the permit  benumber shall be entered in the space provided for the serial number (on the form) and the permit number shall be engraved upon the receiver portion of the firearm prior to registration."

So it doesn't really explain the engraving process but it looks like you do have to get the firearm engraved.

Does the firearm still work? Does anyone actually make ammunition it can use? There might be another way that you don't have to register it but it sounds kind of like you don't have a choice at this point.

I had quoted HRS 134-4 earlier, so I agree, I don't have a choice. 

The gun is a .303 British, so yes, it still works, and ammunition is still available for it.  It's a jungle carbine, and was imported as such, not modified by an importer, so it has a pretty decent value.  Thus my reluctance to deface it.  Additionally, these buggers are pretty hard to disassemble, so stamping it under the furniture isn't really a practical option.

There is one slim thread of hope.  One of the manufacturers of thee guns used electropencil to etch serial numbers.  This gun has been refinished.  There's a pretty good chance that, were I to strip the finish off, I'd find the serial number underneath.  Then I could haul it back to HPD and try to make them re-register it.  I just have to decide if I think restoring the gun is a worthwhile project, and if so, if I'm likely to do it in the next decade.