2aHawaii
General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: macsak on November 26, 2019, 08:51:31 PM
-
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QzBFjTOliZY
-
In the end does it really matter? As Gerald Ford said, an impeachable offense is whatever the House wants it to mean. So if congress wants to remove the president then they can whether they prove a crime or not. They could remove him for wearing the wrong color tie if they so felt.
-
In the end does it really matter? As Gerald Ford said, an impeachable offense is whatever the House wants it to mean. So if congress wants to remove the president then they can whether they prove a crime or not. They could remove him for wearing the wrong color tie if they so felt.
what Gerald Ford says does not "trump" the Constitution...
-
In the end does it really matter? As Gerald Ford said, an impeachable offense is whatever the House wants it to mean. So if congress wants to remove the president then they can whether they prove a crime or not. They could remove him for wearing the wrong color tie if they so felt.
Wearing a wrong colored tie is equivalent to a “high crime or misdemeanor”? Right...
-
Wearing a wrong colored tie is equivalent to a “high crime or misdemeanor”? Right...
"high crimes" are not clearly defined in the constitution and in this case congress makes the call so absent a constitutional definition yes, it means whatever congress decides it to mean.
-
what Gerald Ford says does not "trump" the Constitution...
There is nothing in the constitution to Trump here. The constitution outlines a removal process for the president and lists an undefined "high crimes" as one of the justifications. Since congress has the ultimate job of deciding what a high crime amounts to then congress can interpret it to mean whatever they want it to mean. On top of that this power belongs to congress alone so even the SCOTUS couldn't overturn an impeachment and removal. So Gerald Ford was basically correct.
-
In the end does it really matter? As Gerald Ford said, an impeachable offense is whatever the House wants it to mean. So if congress wants to remove the president then they can whether they prove a crime or not. They could remove him for wearing the wrong color tie if they so felt.
For some act to be deemed a crime requires that a LAW defining the act as a crime exist. Are you that ignorant of basic English? Try Googling "crime" and see if it says "...or whatever Congress decides is a crime after the fact."
Yes, it really does matter.
Even Adam "The Evidence is Ironclad!" Schiff said he's not sure if he'll vote for impeachment. Really?? That tells you how much of a sham this whole mock investigation has been.
There's a reason only 2 presidents have been impeached in 231 years. There's a reason ZERO presidents have ever been removed from office through impeachment.
For you to even ask that question, and then say Congress can remove the President for anything they feel like, demonstrates you really don't have a firm grasp on the facts.
No, they can't remove the president for "no crime." They can't remove him for wearing the wrong color anything.
Is this really the state of our education system? READ THE CONSTITUTION!!
In addition to Johnson and Clinton, only two other U.S. presidents have faced formal impeachment inquiries in the
House of Representatives: Richard Nixon and Donald Trump. Many other presidents have been threatened with
impeachment by political foes without gaining any real traction in Congress.
The framers of the Constitution intentionally made it difficult for Congress to remove a sitting president. The impeachment
process starts in the House of Representatives with a formal impeachment inquiry. If the House Judiciary Committee finds
sufficient grounds, its members write and pass articles of impeachment, which then go to the full House for a vote.
A simple majority in the House is all that’s needed to formally impeach a president. But that doesn’t mean he or she is out
of a job. The final stage is the Senate impeachment trial. Only if two-thirds of the Senate find the president guilty of the
crimes laid out in the articles of impeachment is the POTUS removed from office.
Although Congress has impeached and removed eight federal officials—all federal judges—no president has ever been found
guilty during a Senate impeachment trial. Andrew Johnson came awfully close, though; he barely escaped a guilty verdict by
one vote.
Johnson was impeached in the House of Representatives by 126 votes to 47, but narrowly avoided a two-thirds guilty verdict
in the Senate by a single vote. After his acquittal, he served out the rest of his term and became the first (and only) former U.S.
president to be elected to the Senate.
Clinton was plagued by legal troubles and scandals from the moment he entered the White House. In 1993, Clinton and his First Lady,
Hillary, were the subject of a Justice Department investigation into the so-called Whitewater controversy, a botched business deal
from their days in Arkansas. And in 1994, Clinton was sued for sexual harassment by Paula Jones, who claimed Clinton exposed
himself to her in a hotel room in 1991.
Interestingly, it was a combination of both legal cases that would ultimately lead to Clinton’s impeachment. Independent counsel
Kenneth Starr was appointed by the Justice Department to investigate the Whitewater affair, but he couldn’t find any impeachable
evidence. Meanwhile, lawyers for Jones got a tip that Clinton had an affair with a 21-year-old White House intern named Monica Lewinsky,
a claim that both Lewinsky and Clinton denied under oath.
Starr switched the focus of his investigation when he received 20 hours of taped phone conversations between Lewinsky and Linda Tripp,
a former White House colleague, in which Lewinsky alludes to the affair. Starr then got the FBI to fit Tripp with a wire to meet with Lewinsky
at a Ritz-Carlton hotel outside Washington, DC, when Lewinsky again admitted to a sexual relationship with the president.
When the story went public, Clinton was forced to address the accusations on national television.
“I want you to listen to me,” Clinton famously said. “I did not have sexual relations with that woman, Miss Lewinsky. I never told anybody to
lie, not a single time, never.”
Starr’s investigative team ended up producing a long and lurid report detailing Clinton’s sexual dalliances with Lewinsky and providing
evidence that Clinton lied under oath (perjury) in an effort to obstruct the Starr investigation.
On December 19, 1998, the House of Representatives voted along party lines to impeach Clinton on two separate counts: perjury and
obstruction of justice. But in the ensuing five-week Senate trial, Clinton was acquitted on both counts.
Despite a very public and embarrassing scandal, and being only the second president in history to be impeached, Clinton’s job approval
rating peaked at 73 percent in 1999.
Despite being complicit in one of the greatest political scandals in U.S. presidential history, Richard Nixon was never impeached. He
resigned before the House of Representatives had a chance to impeach him. If he hadn’t quit, Nixon would likely have been the first
president ever impeached and removed from office, given the crimes he committed to cover up his involvement in the Watergate break-ins.
https://www.history.com/news/how-many-presidents-impeached
-
For some act to be deemed a crime requires that a LAW defining the act as a crime exist. Are you that ignorant of basic English? Try Googling "crime" and see if it says "...or whatever Congress decides is a crime after the fact."
Yes, it really does matter.
Even Adam "The Evidence is Ironclad!" Schiff said he's not sure if he'll vote for impeachment. Really?? That tells you how much of a sham this whole mock investigation has been.
There's a reason only 2 presidents have been impeached in 231 years. There's a reason ZERO presidents have ever been removed from office through impeachment.
For you to even ask that question, and then say Congress can remove the President for anything they feel like, demonstrates you really don't have a firm grasp on the facts.
No, they can't remove the president for "no crime." They can't remove him for wearing the wrong color anything.
Is this really the state of our education system? READ THE CONSTITUTION!!
https://www.history.com/news/how-many-presidents-impeached
Wow, that went right over your head. Let me spell it out for you:
Congress has the sole power to remove the president and no other individual or agency can overrule that decision. So you can make any argument you want about whether there was a violation or not but if congress votes to have the president removed it happens because they have the final say. Therefore the decision to remove the president stands but because it is the right one but because it is the final one.
In Nixon V. United states the supreme court ruled that impeachment was a political matter not a criminal one and that it could not review the impeachment.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nixon_v._United_States
So yes, congress can impeach a president for whatever they want.
Maybe you should look up the facts before acting like a douche to others so you don't look so foolish.
-
Wow, that went right over your head. Let me spell it out for you:
Congress has the sole power to remove the president
AS LONG AS THEY ARE IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE CONSTITUTION
and no other individual or agency can overrule that decision.
You left out the most important part, as usual.
Having the authority to impeach doesn't grant them the authority to ignore the Constitution.
Article I, Section 2: The House of Representatives shall chuse their Speaker and other Officers; and shall have the sole Power of Impeachment.
Article I, Section 3: The Senate shall have the sole Power to try all Impeachments. When sitting for that Purpose, they shall be on Oath or Affirmation. When the President of the United States is tried, the Chief Justice shall preside: And no Person shall be convicted without the Concurrence of two thirds of the Members present.
Judgment in Cases of Impeachment shall not extend further than to removal from Office, and disqualification to hold and enjoy any Office of honor, Trust or Profit under the United States: but the Party convicted shall nevertheless be liable and subject to Indictment, Trial, Judgment and Punishment, according to Law.
Article II, Section 4: The President, Vice President and all Civil Officers of the United States, shall be removed from Office on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors.
No crime means no impeachment and no trial. It's plain English. "...on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors." Without actual criminal charges, there can be no impeachment. Subsequently, the Senate can't convict a president of a non-crime, i.e. "wearing the wrong color tie."
You really need to read the Constitution instead of pretending you already know what it says.
-
I know some of you are going to scream about what I am going to say here. :rofl: I don’t give a fuck! :rofl:
I really do understand the Dems points and side in the impeachment of Trump. I don’t agree with it, but I understand it. He terrifies them. All of them. They have been so lawless for so long, if he stays in office for another term, some of them are going down. And the rest of them might somehow be implicated. Because, let’s face it, by ignoring all the crimes committed by their peers and not doing their constitutional duties and investigate these charges, they are just as guilty. IMHO
But besides the crime aspect, he terrifies them because Thrump doesn’t care about his political career. So they have no sway over him. They cannot destroy his career nor his reputation. The only choice they have is to do whatever they can to keep him from being reelected. The lies flying around are so perverse that even the average joe on the street can’t answer this basic question. "What Has Trump Done That Is Impeachable?"
-
I know some of you are going to scream about what I am going to say here. :rofl: I don’t give a fuck! :rofl:
I really do understand the Dems points and side in the impeachment of Trump. I don’t agree with it, but I understand it. He terrifies them. All of them. They have been so lawless for so long, if he stays in office for another term, some of them are going down. And the rest of them might somehow be implicated. Because, let’s face it, by ignoring all the crimes committed by their peers and not doing their constitutional duties and investigate these charges, they are just as guilty. IMHO
But besides the crime aspect, he terrifies them because Thrump doesn’t care about his political career. So they have no sway over him. They cannot destroy his career nor his reputation. The only choice they have is to do whatever they can to keep him from being reelected. The lies flying around are so perverse that even the average joe on the street can’t answer this basic question. "What Has Trump Done That Is Impeachable?"
True. The rats that infest the swamp did what they did: spying on Trump and his team, protecting Hillary, etc.; precisely because they knew once she was in office, they would not only be safe from accountability but richly rewarded.
Election night 2016 was their "Oh, shit!!" moment. Everything since has been an attempt to cover their own asses.
Biden is corrupt. His son is a corrupt loser, too. Just heard that Hunter was reportedly smoking crack in a strip club, one which he visited one a month for a couple of evenings at a time. He used a credit card with NO NAME on it. I have it feeling he was concealing his identity because he was conducting himself in ways that could be used against him and his father.
Sleazy Hunter and Creepy Joe. Two peas from the same pod.
-
A lot of truth here. Trump is really upsetting their gravy train. Most elected already knew and were part of it.
Trump is a true outsider and is exposing the sweet deal the bastards had going.
This scares hell out of them because at the least, the peasants are becoming aware of them.
I know some of you are going to scream about what I am going to say here. :rofl: I don’t give a fuck! :rofl:
I really do understand the Dems points and side in the impeachment of Trump. I don’t agree with it, but I understand it. He terrifies them. All of them. They have been so lawless for so long, if he stays in office for another term, some of them are going down. And the rest of them might somehow be implicated. Because, let’s face it, by ignoring all the crimes committed by their peers and not doing their constitutional duties and investigate these charges, they are just as guilty. IMHO
But besides the crime aspect, he terrifies them because Thrump doesn’t care about his political career. So they have no sway over him. They cannot destroy his career nor his reputation. The only choice they have is to do whatever they can to keep him from being reelected. The lies flying around are so perverse that even the average joe on the street can’t answer this basic question. "What Has Trump Done That Is Impeachable?"
-
A lot of truth here. Trump is really upsetting their gravy train. Most elected already knew and were part of it.
Trump is a true outsider and is exposing the sweet deal the bastards had going.
This scares hell out of them because at the least, the peasants are becoming aware of them.
Robt,
You have brought up the most important point "the sweet deal the bastards had going".
The federal government was never designed to be a Government run by professional
politicians and lifetime union bureaucrats, it was meant to be run by farmers, merchants,
tradesmen, builders, and such.
Short of complete obliteration of most Large American cities, I see no way to go back
to the good "Ole days", but maybe, just maybe we'll see less of these Professional
politicians and more of the rude, crude, peasant class, walking the halls of power.
-
I know some of you are going to scream about what I am going to say here. :rofl: I don’t give a fuck! :rofl:
I really do understand the Dems points and side in the impeachment of Trump. I don’t agree with it, but I understand it. He terrifies them. All of them. They have been so lawless for so long, if he stays in office for another term, some of them are going down. And the rest of them might somehow be implicated. Because, let’s face it, by ignoring all the crimes committed by their peers and not doing their constitutional duties and investigate these charges, they are just as guilty. IMHO
But besides the crime aspect, he terrifies them because Thrump doesn’t care about his political career. So they have no sway over him. They cannot destroy his career nor his reputation. The only choice they have is to do whatever they can to keep him from being reelected. The lies flying around are so perverse that even the average joe on the street can’t answer this basic question. "What Has Trump Done That Is Impeachable?"
I agree with a lot of what you said. It’s not that that infuriated me. It’s the masses that eat up anything anti-Trump as truth and not try to get facts and decide for themselves. Purely emotionally based reactions to Mr. Meenie Wrong Tie Color Bad Orange Man.
-
I like the title of this thread as it exposes the liberal and his/her/them FEELINGs about President Trump.
Trump is playing 4D chess and libtard is playing checkers.
MAGA! :thumbsup: winning
-
I agree with a lot of what you said. It’s not that that infuriated me. It’s the masses that eat up anything anti-Trump as truth and not try to get facts and decide for themselves. Purely emotionally based reactions to Mr. Meenie Wrong Tie Color Bad Orange Man.
Sorry, my first comment was more sarcasm than anything else.
It is interesting to actually listen to Dems like Pelosi, Schiff and Nadler and understand where they are coming from. They actually have a point in how they feel. They firmly believe that Trump asking Russia during the debates is treason. And Trumps use of executive privilege amounts to obstruction of congress. Then there is the quid pro quo of Trump holding back funds in exchange for an investigation into his political opponent. Not to mention bribery and abuse of power. They honestly believe what they are saying. And they intend to use the proof they have to impeach the president. Everything they say, is true and there is no proof to the contrary. As a matter of fact they have had all this evidence for years now and they are going to use it against the president. Everything they say is the truth. We all know it is, including you.
Because no one is that stupid, right? They must know something we don’t. They have to be right in their feelings, otherwise they would be the biggest morons in the world to use something that is not true to be successful at impeaching the president. And they will be successful. That’s proof that they are right, a self fulfilling prophecy. And those of us that support Trump know nothing. Make sense, right? Logical, right? How can you be wrong when Trump is impeached by the House? They don’t want to impeach Trump. But they have the constitutional obligation to do it. They are taking the moral high ground. It’s tough to try and convince those who don’t care otherwise. ANd they don’t care.
Rush calls the “Masses” as you call them, low information voters. It’s true. They only take in one side because that side is also telling them what the other side is saying. They have been brainwashed. But how do you tell anyone who has been brainwashed that they have been brainwashed? They don’t go out to find the truth or even just an opposing view because they don’t want to. They are afraid to. They already think they know the truth. And if it turns out that everything they know as the truth for the last 3 years has been a complete and total lie, I think you will see suicides increase significantly. The irony here is that if they do commit suicide they will probably use a gun. And of course the Dems will blame Trump.....
This is all sarcasm, obviously. It is true the Dems are that stupid. Because they think we are really that stupid. Those of us that have educated ourselves on this subject know better.
-
You left out the most important part, as usual.
Having the authority to impeach doesn't grant them the authority to ignore the Constitution.
No crime means no impeachment and no trial. It's plain English. "...on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors." Without actual criminal charges, there can be no impeachment. Subsequently, the Senate can't convict a president of a non-crime, i.e. "wearing the wrong color tie."
You really need to read the Constitution instead of pretending you already know what it says.
And when the SCOTUS refuses to weigh in then who is going to overturn congress' decision? If congress just skipped a proscribed step then they might step in but the SCOTUS has already said they aren't going to get into the political question. Interpreting what constitutes a "high crime"could be determined to be one of those political questions.
But lets say they would take up the issue. The next question is "What is high crimes and misdemeanors?". Well as it turns out, it isn't as simple as a plain reading as you would like to ignorantly believe.
Impeachment dates back to the 1300s in Britain and the term high crimes and misdemeanors was used in 1386. In that time often impeachment occurred for things that weren't criminal in nature. This continued for hundreds of years.
In 1774 a chief justice was impeached for something that was not criminal yet the language high crimes and misdemeanors was used. Among those who voted to impeach? Multiple founding fathers.
Alexander Hamilton in the Federalist papers argued for impeachment for abuse or violation of public trust. Multiple other founding fathers described non-criminal reasons that could justify impeachment.
This first American impeachment was of senator William Blount in 1797. Of the 5 things he was impeached for, only 1 was criminal.
Multiple judges have been impeached for non criminal things including insanity and drunkenness.
The history goes on but long story short, your claim that high crimes and misdemeanors only refers to violations of criminal statutes is not supported by the facts.
I suggest you read more about the constitution instead of just reading and hearing what you want to find. Here is some light reading to start you off.
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/10/what-does-high-crimes-and-misdemeanors-actually-mean/600343/
-
And when the SCOTUS refuses to weigh in then who is going to overturn congress' decision? If congress just skipped a proscribed step then they might step in but the SCOTUS has already said they aren't going to get into the political question. Interpreting what constitutes a "high crime"could be determined to be one of those political questions.
But lets say they would take up the issue. The next question is "What is high crimes and misdemeanors?". Well as it turns out, it isn't as simple as a plain reading as you would like to ignorantly believe.
Impeachment dates back to the 1300s in Britain and the term high crimes and misdemeanors was used in 1386. In that time often impeachment occurred for things that weren't criminal in nature. This continued for hundreds of years.
In 1774 a chief justice was impeached for something that was not criminal yet the language high crimes and misdemeanors was used. Among those who voted to impeach? Multiple founding fathers.
Alexander Hamilton in the Federalist papers argued for impeachment for abuse or violation of public trust. Multiple other founding fathers described non-criminal reasons that could justify impeachment.
This first American impeachment was of senator William Blount in 1797. Of the 5 things he was impeached for, only 1 was criminal.
Multiple judges have been impeached for non criminal things including insanity and drunkenness.
The history goes on but long story short, your claim that high crimes and misdemeanors only refers to violations of criminal statutes is not supported by the facts.
I suggest you read more about the constitution instead of just reading and hearing what you want to find. Here is some light reading to start you off.
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/10/what-does-high-crimes-and-misdemeanors-actually-mean/600343/
Did you even try to read what I posted? The Senate holds a trial. The Chief Justice of the Supreme Court presides over the trial. It takes 2/3 of the Senate to convict and remove a President.
You're getting way ahead of the situation asking about SCOTUS getting involved.
"High crime." The operative word is "CRIME." Geesh. How obtuse can one person be?
-
Dems want him out so bad because hes not part of the club. They know he will bring them down for decades of abuse of power.
December should be interesting.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
Dems want him out so bad because hes not part of the club. They know he will bring them down for decades of abuse of power.
December should be interesting.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
Even though 2 (almost 3) presidents have been impeached, exactly ZERO have been convicted by the Senate and removed from office.
Trump's not moving until 2024. Everyone should just accept it.
-
Guess he needs to make sure 2/3rds of the Senate doesn’t disapprove of his tie color...
-
Guess he needs to make sure 2/3rds of the Senate doesn’t disapprove of his tie color...
The media is always quick to report in their impeachment coverage that "the Senate is controlled by a Republican majority." FAKE NEWS! While technically accurate, it has no bearing on the issue.
There are 50 senators (+ the VP who presides as Senate President who votes when a tie-breaker is needed).
100 * 2/3 = 67 -- called a "Super Majority". Thus, 33 votes for acquittal is all that's needed to prevent an impeachment trial from convicting Trump.
Current party representation in the Senate:
GOP: 53;
DNC: 45;
Independent: 2.
Normally Independents caucus with the Dems, so the split is more like 53-47.
If the Dems held 53 seats, and if the Independents voted with them, they'd still need 12 members of the GOP's 45 to flip. With the flimsy evidence they currently demonstrated in the hearings, that would be 99% unlikely.
In reality, the Dems need 20 Republican Senators to flip -- out of 53.
Math is hard.
-
Did you even try to read what I posted? The Senate holds a trial. The Chief Justice of the Supreme Court presides over the trial. It takes 2/3 of the Senate to convict and remove a President.
You're getting way ahead of the situation asking about SCOTUS getting involved.
"High crime." The operative word is "CRIME." Geesh. How obtuse can one person be?
Posted a whole bunch of history for you on the meaning and application of high crimes and you just ignore it. You can lead a horse to water but you can't make it drink. If only you would look at the facts for the truth instead of seeing everything through your confirmation bias. High crimes does not mean crimes.
I mentioned SCOTUS because no other group or agency would even have a chance at overruling Congress. If congress voted to impeach and convicted in a trial to remove the president for wearing the wrong color tie, who do you think people would try to turn to to fight it? SCOTUS!
-
Posted a whole bunch of history for you on the meaning and application of high crimes and you just ignore it. You can lead a horse to water but you can't make it drink. If only you would look at the facts for the truth instead of seeing everything through your confirmation bias. High crimes does not mean crimes.
I mentioned SCOTUS because no other group or agency would even have a chance at overruling Congress. If congress voted to impeach and convicted in a trial to remove the president for wearing the wrong color tie, who do you think people would try to turn to to fight it? SCOTUS!
No. I don't ignore relevant facts. I just ignore YOU.
SCOTUS can't overturn a conviction for impeachment unless there's a Constitutional reason the conviction was invalid. I don't think the Senate will get 2/3rds of their body without making damn sure it'll hold up to that scrutiny.
Just because the House can play fast and loose with the articles of impeachment and get Trump on "stuff they don't like", the voting public isn't going to let them get away with it.
Whatever they do to Trump, they better be willing to have it done to the next Dem in the Oval Office. Precedence is a bitch. Just ask Harry Reid how that nuclear option worked now that McConnell uses it to push Trump's nominees through for a vote in spite of Dems trying to obstruct the process.
-
No. I don't ignore relevant facts. I just ignore YOU.
SCOTUS can't overturn a conviction for impeachment unless there's a Constitutional reason the conviction was invalid. I don't think the Senate will get 2/3rds of their body without making damn sure it'll hold up to that scrutiny.
Just because the House can play fast and loose with the articles of impeachment and get Trump on "stuff they don't like", the voting public isn't going to let them get away with it.
Whatever they do to Trump, they better be willing to have it done to the next Dem in the Oval Office. Precedence is a bitch. Just ask Harry Reid how that nuclear option worked now that McConnell uses it to push Trump's nominees through for a vote in spite of Dems trying to obstruct the process.
No, they probably won't get 2/3rds of the senate but that is irrelevant to whether they can impeach Trump for whatever they want. I never claimed they will successfully removed the president, I only stated it doesn't matter whether they prove an actual criminal action.
You did ignore the facts I posted when you simply claimed your common sense definition was more accurate than 400 years of history and precedent. And you clearly didn't ignore me either.
But who cares, if they remove Trump we will get Pence anyway and he seems quite capable of the job.
-
But who cares, if they remove Trump we will get Pence anyway and he seems quite capable of the job.
That right there. IMO you’re completely missing the point of the push for impeachment proceedings against Trump. Consider the timing of this all...
-
That right there. IMO you’re completely missing the point of the push for impeachment proceedings against Trump. Consider the timing of this all...
"The best defense is a good offense."
The Dems have been very offensive the last 3 years. :rofl:
-
That right there. IMO you’re completely missing the point of the push for impeachment proceedings against Trump. Consider the timing of this all...
When it comes to the timing it is a lose lose situation. If they do it quickly then republicans will claim it is rushed and not proper. If they do it slowly it will get closer and closer to the election time then the republicans will claim democrats are drawing it out to affect the election.
-
Trump will be the only pres ivestigated daily and never charged. Then attempted impeached for nothing and win reelection.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
Trump will be the only pres ivestigated daily and never charged. Then attempted impeached for nothing and win reelection.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
On the other hand if he loses re-election then would you have wished for the impeachment so that Pence could have run and maybe won?
Considering nearly half the country supports impeachment I am not confident Trump will win. Polls have Americans supporting impeachment at 47-50 percent.
On a side note, the same poll showed that most Americans think they won't change their minds regardless of what the hearings find. So much for keeping an open mind and changing one's position to account for new information...
https://www.npr.org/2019/11/19/780540637/poll-americans-overwhelmingly-say-impeachment-hearings-wont-change-their-minds
-
On the other hand if he loses re-election then would you have wished for the impeachment so that Pence could have run and maybe won?
Considering nearly half the country supports impeachment I am not confident Trump will win. Polls have Americans supporting impeachment at 47-50 percent.
On a side note, the same poll showed that most Americans think they won't change their minds regardless of what the hearings find. So much for keeping an open mind and changing one's position to account for new information...
https://www.npr.org/2019/11/19/780540637/poll-americans-overwhelmingly-say-impeachment-hearings-wont-change-their-minds
WRONG!
Majority of voters now oppose impeachment: Quinnipiac poll
Majority of voters now OPPOSE IMPEACHMENT. So, if Republicans have no reason to change their minds (which was can assume they have not done), and Independents who were once in favor of impeachment have already flipped (based on recent polls compared to 3 months ago), and now even MORE voters oppose impeachment, who are these voters who changed their minds?
The answer is DEMOCRATS. Even Dem voters are tired of the lies and exclusive "Orange Man Bad" agenda of the House.
Quinnipiac found 51% of registered voters surveyed said they don’t want to see the president ousted through impeachment.
That’s the first time the number has been above 50% since before Speaker Nancy Pelosi announced an impeachment inquiry
in late September.
Another 45% do want to see the president impeached and forced out.
https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2019/dec/10/majority-voters-now-oppose-impeachment-quinnipiac-/
-
I had a conversation that was a shape shifter. That's when you discuss 1 topic and it merges to another. So she asked about guns, guess her building is not as safe either. Then moved on to who made the gun laws, then finally on to Trump, who owns the fed, etc...
She had no idea why Trump should be impeached, but that she hates him. She is a dem, but becoming pro 2a due to all the crime increasing.
I showed her a little of the red bill. Discussed who owns the fed reserve, the media, you know tinfoil stuff.
-
WRONG!
Majority of voters now oppose impeachment: Quinnipiac poll
Majority of voters now OPPOSE IMPEACHMENT. So, if Republicans have no reason to change their minds (which was can assume they have not done), and Independents who were once in favor of impeachment have already flipped (based on recent polls compared to 3 months ago), and now even MORE voters oppose impeachment, who are these voters who changed their minds?
The answer is DEMOCRATS. Even Dem voters are tired of the lies and exclusive "Orange Man Bad" agenda of the House.
https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2019/dec/10/majority-voters-now-oppose-impeachment-quinnipiac-/
So what, a sway of a couple percent on impeachment is hardly a sign of whether he can win re-election.
-
So what, a sway of a couple percent on impeachment is hardly a sign of whether he can win re-election.
LOL! You can't stand to be proven wrong.
One would think you'd be used to it by now.
MORE PEOPLE THINK DONALD TRUMP WILL WIN
2020 ELECTION OVER DEMOCRATIC NOMINEE,
POLL SHOWS
Despite the ongoing impeachment inquiry against President Donald Trump, more voters think
he would win the 2020 general election over an unnamed Democratic nominee.
https://www.newsweek.com/poll-trump-will-win-2020-election-over-democratic-nominee-1468952
-
LOL! You can't stand to be proven wrong.
One would think you'd be used to it by now.
MORE PEOPLE THINK DONALD TRUMP WILL WIN
2020 ELECTION OVER DEMOCRATIC NOMINEE,
POLL SHOWS
https://www.newsweek.com/poll-trump-will-win-2020-election-over-democratic-nominee-1468952
You didn't prove me wrong, what a joke. I quoted poll numbers that were real, all you did is show new poll numbers have moved a little.
Meanwhile you insisted a president couldn't be impeached for something that wasn't a crime and when I decimated you with facts you changed the subject and try to find empty victories wherever you can.
You also failed to support any argument that a small change in poll numbers on impeachment would have a significant impact on the election so still waiting...
-
You didn't prove me wrong, what a joke. I quoted poll numbers that were real, all you did is show new poll numbers have moved a little.
Meanwhile you insisted a president couldn't be impeached for something that wasn't a crime and when I decimated you with facts you changed the subject and try to find empty victories wherever you can.
You also failed to support any argument that a small change in poll numbers on impeachment would have a significant impact on the election so still waiting...
Trump has NOT been impeached yet.
Please try to keep up.
Until Pelosi transmits the articles of impeachment to the Senate via her selected House Managers, the process has stalled.
Logically, if Trump were actually impeached, the Senate, according to the Constitution, has 30 days in which to take up the matter and hold a trial.
Right now, that clock hasn't started. Ergo, Trump is not impeached -- yet.
If a grand jury votes to indict a suspect, but the prosecutor never files charges with the court, was the suspect ever charged? If so, there would be a trail -- and a speedy one at that -- required to hear the case.
Same thing here. Pelosi is abusing her power, substituting her prerogative over that of the entire House that voted on the articles.
This might all be mute when she returns from holiday break and transmits the articles to the Senate amid the fallout from holding onto them.
I think she's damned if she does and damned if she doesn't. :rofl:
-
Trump has NOT been impeached yet.
Please try to keep up.
Straw Man. I never said he had been impeached though many agree he already has been.
Until Pelosi transmits the articles of impeachment to the Senate via her selected House Managers, the process has stalled.
Logically, if Trump were actually impeached, the Senate, according to the Constitution, has 30 days in which to take up the matter and hold a trial.
Right now, that clock hasn't started. Ergo, Trump is not impeached -- yet.
If a grand jury votes to indict a suspect, but the prosecutor never files charges with the court, was the suspect ever charged? If so, there would be a trail -- and a speedy one at that -- required to hear the case.
Same thing here. Pelosi is abusing her power, substituting her prerogative over that of the entire House that voted on the articles.
This might all be mute when she returns from holiday break and transmits the articles to the Senate amid the fallout from holding onto them.
I think she's damned if she does and damned if she doesn't. :rofl:
Certainly debatable. Many experts seem to disagree on the matter.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2019/12/20/yes-donald-trump-has-been-impeached/
-
Certainly debatable. Many experts seem to disagree on the matter.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2019/12/20/yes-donald-trump-has-been-impeached/
I see two experts cited in that article you posted
I fail to see how that constitutes "many"
-
Straw Man. I never said he had been impeached though many agree he already has been.
Certainly debatable. Many experts seem to disagree on the matter.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2019/12/20/yes-donald-trump-has-been-impeached/
The experts you cite are giving opinions, not fact.
The fact is, the HOUSE has impeached Trump, not "CONGRESS". The Senate has to have their say. Until the Senate is offered a chance to hold a trial, the impeachment is just a do-nothing resolution.
According to your experts' opinion, any bill the House passes is a law ready to be signed by the President, yet the Senate still must vote before it's a law.
-
Saw a discussion today that brings up a very good point:
1. House passed the articles of impeachment
2. Pelosi is holding onto the articles until the Senate agrees to the Dem's demands on how the trial will be run
So,
A. if the President is actually impeached right now, the Senate could not be held hostage over the trial rules. The Senate has the SOLE POWER to try impeachment. cases Therefore, if Trump were actually impeached, the Senate would have a DUTY to schedule the trial within 30 days according to the Constitution. They could do that today without the House transmitting the articles. But, since we know they can't do that yet, it means Trump has not been impeached.
B. Pelosi is supposed to select house managers, or basically prosecutors, to deliver the impeachment articles to the Senate and to present the House's case at trial. There can be no trial without the managers, just like there can be no criminal trial if the prosecution fails to show up.
Bottom line: Trump has not been formally impeached right mow,
-
Saw a discussion today that brings up a very good point:
1. House passed the articles of impeachment
2. Pelosi is holding onto the articles until the Senate agrees to the Dem's demands on how the trial will be run
So,
A. if the President is actually impeached right now, the Senate could not be held hostage over the trial rules. The Senate has the SOLE POWER to try impeachment. cases Therefore, if Trump were actually impeached, the Senate would have a DUTY to schedule the trial within 30 days according to the Constitution. They could do that today without the House transmitting the articles. But, since we know they can't do that yet, it means Trump has not been impeached.
B. Pelosi is supposed to select house managers, or basically prosecutors, to deliver the impeachment articles to the Senate and to present the House's case at trial. There can be no trial without the managers, just like there can be no criminal trial if the prosecution fails to show up.
Bottom line: Trump has not been formally impeached right mow,
All of the constitutional scholars/experts that I follow agree with what you wrote here. This includes one of the Dems main impeachment witnesses.
Pelosi is just trying to pull a power grab by trying to control the rules for the senate trial. She has nothing to do with how the senate does their job. It is none of her fucking business. It’s all a political ploy because they know the senate will acquit. All of the impeachment theatrics was really a huge waste of time.
-
All of the constitutional scholars/experts that I follow agree with what you wrote here. This includes one of the Dems main impeachment witnesses.
Pelosi is just trying to pull a power grab by trying to control the rules for the senate trial. She has nothing to do with how the senate does their job. It is none of her fucking business. It’s all a political ploy because they know the senate will acquit. All of the impeachment theatrics was really a huge waste of time.
1: "Why should I apply for CCW in Hawaii? It's a 100% waste of time, because I know it'll never be approved by the Police Chief."
2: "I applied for CCW, because the police can't make any decision on my application if I never submit it. At least now I can say, "I did my part of the process.""
I'm seeing Pelosi taking the same stance in #2. If the House never impeached Trump, the voters would say a Dem majority-controlled House did nothing the get rid of Trump. Even though she knew the impeachment was destined to fail in the Senate trial, she thinks the Dem Party can use impeachment in the election, saying "We did our part, but the Senate is preventing us from succeeding. We need a Dem majority in the Senate, too, to finish the job."
The Dems have one objective: seize power. Everything else, including doing the job they are being paid for, is unimportant.
-
I see two experts cited in that article you posted
I fail to see how that constitutes "many"
So what? How many experts are saying he hasn't been impeached? Is it going to be settled by which side has more experts? I just posted this because it disputed Flapp's claims of certainty. I am not saying which way it is but pointing out that it something not real clear.
-
The experts you cite are giving opinions, not fact.
The fact is, the HOUSE has impeached Trump, not "CONGRESS". The Senate has to have their say. Until the Senate is offered a chance to hold a trial, the impeachment is just a do-nothing resolution.
According to your experts' opinion, any bill the House passes is a law ready to be signed by the President, yet the Senate still must vote before it's a law.
You just said Trump has not been impeached but then said the house has impeached Trump, so which is it? You made the statement, I posted an article of people explaining why he has been impeached, and now you are saying he has been impeached. I guess I should give you credit for admitting when you were wrong.
-
So what? How many experts are saying he hasn't been impeached? Is it going to be settled by which side has more experts? I just posted this because it disputed Flapp's claims of certainty. I am not saying which way it is but pointing out that it something not real clear.
so what?
you said many, and the source you listed had two
for someone who is so careful how you communicate, you are being so cavalier here
your history as a masterdebator in high school should have taught you that this is not kool
focus
-
so what?
you said many, and the source you listed had two
for someone who is so careful how you communicate, you are being so cavalier here
your history as a masterdebator in high school should have taught you that this is not kool
focus
I was not on a debate team in high school.
I said many because when I looked into it I found many. I also follow it on news I get from the radio as well as through the internet. I know, I only posted one link. Would it change your mind if I posted 5 links citing 10 sources? Is there some amount of sources that would have satisfied your definition of many and you would be convinced that Trump had been impeached or are you just nitpicking to nitpick?
Try reading the article and digest the explanation of the people mentioned in the article. Maybe you will find it a well supported argument, maybe you won't, but either way then we can discuss the merits or their arguments instead of how many many is.
-
You just said Trump has not been impeached but then said the house has impeached Trump, so which is it? You made the statement, I posted an article of people explaining why he has been impeached, and now you are saying he has been impeached. I guess I should give you credit for admitting when you were wrong.
You're arguing semantics -- the last resort of someone who has lost the argument on the facts.
"The House of Representatives shall choose their Speaker and other Officers; and shall have the sole Power of Impeachment."
The House passed 2 articles of impeachment. From the perspective of the Constitution, the President was impeached by the House majority, and down partisan political lines. As I said, the HOUSE impeached him, but NOT THE CONGRESS.
"The Senate shall have the sole Power to try all Impeachments."
Unless the articles are presented to the Senate, AS THE ARTICLES OF IMPEACHMENT STATE THEY MUST BE, then the House's vote has been overridden. Trump is not impeached, because Pelosi by executive fiat halted the impeachment process in opposition to the vote by the full House. it's no different than a Presidential VETO that ends a bill's process toward becoming a law.
Impeachment is a process, not a "state". Trump is not "impeached". Articles TO impeach him were passed.
I know this is an abstract concept and requires higher levels of intelligence than the average cow to comprehend, but do try to keep up if you're going to argue.
-
You're arguing semantics -- the last resort of someone who has lost the argument on the facts.
"The House of Representatives shall choose their Speaker and other Officers; and shall have the sole Power of Impeachment."
The House passed 2 articles of impeachment. From the perspective of the Constitution, the President was impeached by the House majority, and down partisan political lines. As I said, the HOUSE impeached him, but NOT THE CONGRESS.
"The Senate shall have the sole Power to try all Impeachments."
Unless the articles are presented to the Senate, AS THE ARTICLES OF IMPEACHMENT STATE THEY MUST BE, then the House's vote has been overridden. Trump is not impeached, because Pelosi by executive fiat halted the impeachment process in opposition to the vote by the full House. it's no different than a Presidential VETO that ends a bill's process toward becoming a law.
Impeachment is a process, not a "state". Trump is not "impeached". Articles TO impeach him were passed.
I know this is an abstract concept and requires higher levels of intelligence than the average cow to comprehend, but do try to keep up if you're going to argue.
The House impeaches and the Senate holds the trial. Whether the Senate holds a trial or not is irrelevant to whether he has been impeached. There is nothing in the constitution that says if the articles aren't given to the Senate that it became overridden. Pelosi is not doing what she is supposed to be doing with the articles of impeachment and that halts the removal process but that doesn't make it null and void. Trump has been impeached.
You are trying so desperately to find some technicality to claim he hasn't been impeached its obvious. The question is why... The House impeached him and the Senate will most likely not choose to remove him so why try so hard? Can't let any facts tarnish the record of your dear leader?
-
The House impeaches and the Senate holds the trial. Whether the Senate holds a trial or not is irrelevant to whether he has been impeached. There is nothing in the constitution that says if the articles aren't given to the Senate that it became overridden. Pelosi is not doing what she is supposed to be doing with the articles of impeachment and that halts the removal process but that doesn't make it null and void. Trump has been impeached.
You are trying so desperately to find some technicality to claim he hasn't been impeached its obvious. The question is why... The House impeached him and the Senate will most likely not choose to remove him so why try so hard? Can't let any facts tarnish the record of your dear leader?
Seems to me you are the one who's desperate.
ONE
MORE
TIME ...
Impeachment is a PROCESS, not a RESULT OF THE HOUSE'S VOTE. The House submits articles of impeachment TO THE SENATE to impeach. Just holding a vote is not impeachment. They have failed to perform the last step in the PROCESS as required. Therefore, TRUMP HAS NOT BEEN IMPEACHED YET.
Keep trying. You're as ridiculous as Pelosi and Schiff.
Simple deductive reasoning answers this question: if Trump is impeached, the Senate would be scheduling a hearing to vote on the trial's rules.
No impeachment = no trial.
-
Impeachment is a PROCESS, not a RESULT OF THE HOUSE'S VOTE. The House submits articles of impeachment TO THE SENATE to impeach. Just holding a vote is not impeachment. They have failed to perform the last step in the PROCESS as required. Therefore, TRUMP HAS NOT BEEN IMPEACHED YET.
Your reasoning is flawed. Nowhere does it clearly state that if the articles are not sent to the Senate that the impeachment process has not been fulfilled. It is just a made up argument people are trying to reason into the process. But feel free to prove me wrong, show me where in the constitution it states that if the articles aren't transferred to the Senate then it doesn't count as an impeachment.
-
Your reasoning is flawed. Nowhere does it clearly state that if the articles are not sent to the Senate that the impeachment process has not been fulfilled. It is just a made up argument people are trying to reason into the process. But feel free to prove me wrong, show me where in the constitution it states that if the articles aren't transferred to the Senate then it doesn't count as an impeachment.
The Constitution does not clearly state a million things that have been deemed unconstitutional. Is abortion in the Constitution? No? Must not be a constitutional issue, then.
-
The Constitution does not clearly state a million things that have been deemed unconstitutional. Is abortion in the Constitution? No? Must not be a constitutional issue, then.
You are trying to draw an arbitrary line in the process so it can be claimed that Trump wasn't impeached. They voted to impeach, he was impeached. A hold on the paperwork doesn't change that.
-
You are trying to draw an arbitrary line in the process so it can be claimed that Trump wasn't impeached. They voted to impeach, he was impeached. A hold on the paperwork doesn't change that.
Watch this video, then tell me I'm the one drawing an arbitrary line.
Even the Democrat Impeachment hearing witness says Trump hasn't been formally impeached.
I'll rest my case when you PROVE I'm wrong.
https://youtu.be/N2CL_gPixQs
-
Watch this video, then tell me I'm the one drawing an arbitrary line.
Even the Democrat Impeachment hearing witness says Trump hasn't been formally impeached.
I'll rest my case when you PROVE I'm wrong.
https://youtu.be/N2CL_gPixQs
Watched the video. While he makes some detailed arguments and makes some valid points I don't think he makes a solid argument that Trump hasn't been impeached.
When I heard the argument that Trump hadn't been impeached I thought to myself, maybe there is a valid argument there. So I looked at both sides and concluded there is a better argument that he has been officially impeached.
You obviously disagree so we will have to agree to disagree.
-
Watched the video. While he makes some detailed arguments and makes some valid points I don't think he makes a solid argument that Trump hasn't been impeached.
When I heard the argument that Trump hadn't been impeached I thought to myself, maybe there is a valid argument there. So I looked at both sides and concluded there is a better argument that he has been officially impeached.
You obviously disagree so we will have to agree to disagree.
Post sources. Otherwise, you opinion is baseless.
-
There is a process to Impeach a president and that has not been completed yet. 95% of the loading bar is complete.
Think of it like a law. Say a bill was approved, until it hits Ige's desk, it's not law or vetoed. Ige has 3 options once on his desk, 1) Sign the bill into law 2) Veto said bill 3) Do nothing and it automatically becomes law by X date.
So this vote of impeachment hasn't been delivered to "Ige's desk" yet. Which would mean nothing unless it does.
-
There is a process to Impeach a president and that has not been completed yet. 95% of the loading bar is complete.
Think of it like a law. Say a bill was approved, until it hits Ige's desk, it's not law or vetoed. Ige has 3 options once on his desk, 1) Sign the bill into law 2) Veto said bill 3) Do nothing and it automatically becomes law by X date.
So this vote of impeachment hasn't been delivered to "Ige's desk" yet. Which would mean nothing unless it does.
Passing articles of impeachment is analogous to a grand jury returning a bill to charge (indict) a person with a crime/crimes.
If the prosecutor's office doesn't take action to file the grand jury's charges with the court, then the accused is not officially indicted.
An indictment initiates a trial, just like impeachment does. The Senate has 30 days from impeachment to take up the matter. That 30-day clock hasn't started. You can't say Trump is impeached while admitting the Senate has no duty to schedule the trial.
No trial = no impeachment.
-
Post sources. Otherwise, you opinion is baseless.
You are asking me to post a source that the youtube guy didn't make a strong argument?
BTW I did post a source 2 pages ago addressing the question of whether Trump has been impeached.
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=35435.msg315056#msg315056
At this point though I don't see any more time on this particular question. Technically impeached or not really doesn't change anything.
-
You are asking me to post a source that the youtube guy didn't make a strong argument?
BTW I did post a source 2 pages ago addressing the question of whether Trump has been impeached.
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=35435.msg315056#msg315056
At this point though I don't see any more time on this particular question. Technically impeached or not really doesn't change anything.
You gave up, so I must be right.
:rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
Yes, it does change things. Either the House has the evidence that Trump committed impeachable offenses, or they do not. By sitting on the articles PASSED BY THE HOUSE (well, almost all of the House Dems alone), they are demonstrating that the impeachment process was a farce -- a political stunt intended to trash Trump in the 2020 election and pander to the far Left base.
Unless and until the articles are delivered to the Senate, impeachment has been stalled. Trump can't be in "impeachment limbo". If he is impeached, the trial begins. If he's not, then no trial.
The House led by Schiff and Pelosi are playing political games with their Constitutional duties. They should be removed from office for abuse of power, failure to abide by the Constitution (they have a solemn and mighty responsibility to impeach when WARRANTED, not play political football with it), and for violating the separation of powers defined in the Constitution by trying to usurp the Senate's role being the sole power to try impeachment. Holding the articles hostage to coerce the Senate majority in ANY WAY for ANY REASON is beyond their authority in the impeachment process.
it all matters. We can't as a nation afford for people like these Dems to run amok and obstruct both the President and Senate in the performance of their duties simply for "not being Hillary Clinton".
-
You gave up, so I must be right.
:rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
Yes, it does change things. Either the House has the evidence that Trump committed impeachable offenses, or they do not. By sitting on the articles PASSED BY THE HOUSE (well, almost all of the House Dems alone), they are demonstrating that the impeachment process was a farce -- a political stunt intended to trash Trump in the 2020 election and pander to the far Left base.
Unless and until the articles are delivered to the Senate, impeachment has been stalled. Trump can't be in "impeachment limbo". If he is impeached, the trial begins. If he's not, then no trial.
The House led by Schiff and Pelosi are playing political games with their Constitutional duties. They should be removed from office for abuse of power, failure to abide by the Constitution (they have a solemn and mighty responsibility to impeach when WARRANTED, not play political football with it), and for violating the separation of powers defined in the Constitution by trying to usurp the Senate's role being the sole power to try impeachment. Holding the articles hostage to coerce the Senate majority in ANY WAY for ANY REASON is beyond their authority in the impeachment process.
it all matters. We can't as a nation afford for people like these Dems to run amok and obstruct both the President and Senate in the performance of their duties simply for "not being Hillary Clinton".
I tend to agree with your premise. And I might add the fact that Pelosi is using the articles for political purposes should null and void the articles IMHO. I posted an interesting article by Trey Gowdy in the other thread and I agree with his premise. And that this is not about trying to get the senate to call witnesses. That is all BS. According to Gowdy this is all about trying to gain an advantage before and after the 2020 election. The fact she is holding on to them is acceptance that she realizes Trump is going to win in 2020. This game she is playing with the articles is all about holding on to the house, and trying to gain control of the senate. For that reason alone it is obvious the articles are a sham and should be dismissed in the senate immediately making them null and void. JMHO