2aHawaii
General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: drck1000 on December 30, 2019, 04:46:08 PM
-
Tune into HNN at 6 pm tonight. There will be a segment by Lynn Kawano on the red flag law. She was supposed to meet with Cliff Goo today at Koko Head so share concerns about the new law from a pro 2a perspective.
-
I wonder how long her and Cliff spoke vs. the snippet they produced. Of course mentioning that there are already laws in place to remove guns from a dangerous individual would be too much to ask of HNN and the Brady campaign :(
-
Pretty obvious that both sides did not get equal air time.
-
I wonder how long her and Cliff spoke vs. the snippet the produced. Of course mentioning that there are already laws in place to remove guns from a dangerous individual would be too much to ask of HNN and the Brady campaign :(
Just saw the segment on the 10 pm news. The news seemed to focus on “medical professionals” and suicide. Not the vague verbiage of the bill. They did get a couple of key points in Cliff’s portion. Not sure what else he shared that didn’t make it through, but I bet a lot.
-
Just saw the segment on the 10 pm news. The news seemed to focus on “medical professionals” and suicide. Not the vague verbiage of the bill. They did get a couple of key points in Cliff’s portion. Not sure what else he shared that didn’t make it through, but I bet a lot.
I have now seen the story (yet), it I wonder if it came about from my post about the same thing on the HIFICO Facebook page.
-
Ok found the story on their website, and it directly mentions our research.
https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2019/12/31/hawaii-joins-growing-number-states-enacting-red-flag-gun-law/
-
I have now seen the story (yet), it I wonder if it came about from my post about the same thing on the HIFICO Facebook page.
She mentioned HIFICO that research shows “the vast majority of gun owners” would avoid seeking mental healthcare for fear of losing their guns.
-
At least we got some airtime. I am thinking if the HIFICO is opposing the bill in a legal challenge the judge might ask what idea we might have in its place. So my question to people here is this: What kind of red flag law would you propose to address the issue at hand while also protecting rights better?
-
At least we got some airtime. I am thinking if the HIFICO is opposing the bill in a legal challenge the judge might ask what idea we might have in its place. So my question to people here is this: What kind of red flag law would you propose to address the issue at hand while also protecting rights better?
that's not how it works...
-
that's not how it works...
I think it is. I have heard supreme court justices pose questions like this to people making arguments.
Regardless though, even if judges will never ask such a question I think it is still something we should address. We are saying it is a bad idea so what is our idea to do it better? I have stated my ideas on this before, do you have any?
-
Replace red flag with shall issue oc and ccw.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
I think it is. I have heard supreme court justices pose questions like this to people making arguments.
Regardless though, even if judges will never ask such a question I think it is still something we should address. We are saying it is a bad idea so what is our idea to do it better? I have stated my ideas on this before, do you have any?
You're using a logical fallacy -- again. You do this all the time.
Politician's syllogism
The politician's syllogism, also known as the politician's logic or the politician's fallacy, is a logical fallacy of the form:
1. We must do something
2. This is something
3. Therefore, we must do this.
The politician's fallacy was identified in a 1988 episode of the BBC television political sitcom Yes, Prime Minister titled
"Power to the People", and has taken added life on the Internet.[1] The syllogism, invented by fictional British civil servants,
has been quoted in the real British Parliament.[2][3] The syllogism has also been quoted in American political discussion.[4]
In Yes, Prime Minister, the term is discussed between two high-ranking civil servants who are concerned that the prime
minister wants to implement a scheme to reform local government due to political opposition there. In this issue, as with
many other issues humorously explored by the show, the civil servants believe that doing anything is worse than doing
nothing because actions tend to undermine the dominance of the civil service. They identify the politician's logic as a fallacious
categorical syllogism:
1. All cats have four legs
2. My dog has four legs
3. Therefore, my dog is a cat.
This invalid form of argument, labeled AAA-2 among syllogisms, commits the fallacy of the undistributed middle: it says nothing
about all things having four legs (the middle term) and thus the conclusion does not logically follow from the premises, even if
the premises are true. The politician's syllogism similarly says nothing about all known "somethings" that could be done. As is
common with fallacious undistributed middle arguments, it can also be seen as the fallacy of affirming the consequent when
restated as an equivalent hypothetical syllogism:[5]
1. To improve things, things must change
2. We are changing things
3. Therefore, we are improving things.
You believe that passing a bad law is helping solve the problem, while you simultaneously ignore the negatives of the law on people who haven't done anything wrong.
There doesn't have to ba an alternate proposal for an adopted bad solution to be deemed to cause more harm than good.
-
Replace red flag with shall issue oc and ccw.
That’s what I’m talking about.
Red flag is not terrible in theory (application different story. no due process, Willy nilly application, discourages mental health treatment, etc.)
Don’t tell anyone you own a firearm ! Especially your not like minded neighbors, pissed off wife/girlfriend who’s soon to be your ex or your shrink.
Snowflapp,
You gonna be at the rally on January 30th ?
Talk to some legislators about passing some bad laws?
-
That’s what I’m talking about.
Red flag is not terrible in theory (application different story. no due process, Willy nilly application, discourages mental health treatment, etc.)
Don’t tell anyone you own a firearm ! Especially your not like minded neighbors, pissed off wife/girlfriend who’s soon to be your ex or your shrink.
Snowflapp,
You gonna be at the rally on January 30th ?
Talk to some legislators about passing some bad laws?
You don't give two shits about what I'll do. Don't even try to pretend.
-
At least we got some airtime. I am thinking if the HIFICO is opposing the bill in a legal challenge the judge might ask what idea we might have in its place. So my question to people here is this: What kind of red flag law would you propose to address the issue at hand while also protecting rights better?
Allow constitutional carry in Hawaii, so future victims can defend themselves.
The duration of a shooting is always dependent on the arrival of a good guy with a gun
-
I think it is. I have heard supreme court justices pose questions like this to people making arguments.
Regardless though, even if judges will never ask such a question I think it is still something we should address. We are saying it is a bad idea so what is our idea to do it better? I have stated my ideas on this before, do you have any?
Gun owners are trying to fight against laws that would infringe on due process and our individual rights. IMHO thats the extent of what gun owners should be worried about.
Its asinine to think its somehow incumbent on US to propose how to fix what government selectively dictates as "public safety concerns".
If Government is imposing laws that would drastically effect your rights, why should we put in work to propose something in place of it so that they "back off" infringing on basic rights?
So what's better than the current Red Flag Law signed in to "law"? Easy. Having it NOT exist at all. Pau.
-
You're using a logical fallacy -- again. You do this all the time.
Politician's syllogism
You believe that passing a bad law is helping solve the problem, while you simultaneously ignore the negatives of the law on people who haven't done anything wrong.
There doesn't have to ba an alternate proposal for an adopted bad solution to be deemed to cause more harm than good.
Not at all. You believe it is a politician's syllogism because you fail to understand my point.
I am saying that politicians are going to do something (are doing something) with or without us. We can pout and complain that we don't like their solution or we can come up with an alternative solution for them to pursue thereby protecting our rights and preventing them from claiming we didn't do anything to try and address the problem.
-
Allow constitutional carry in Hawaii, so future victims can defend themselves.
The duration of a shooting is always dependent on the arrival of a good guy with a gun
That is a reactionary way to address the problem, one I am all for. The thing is what they are trying to address is a preventative measure before it happens. I think it is good to both try to prevent a problem as well as have an answer for if it happens anyway. So CCW is great but it only addresses half of the equation.
-
If Government is imposing laws that would drastically effect your rights, why should we put in work to propose something in place of it so that they "back off" infringing on basic rights?
Because if we do nothing they will point to us and say we didn't have any better ideas or that we didn't contribute. They will paint us as resisting laws that try to stop mass shooters. Consider that a big part of the battle is not just legal but also the optics.
-
Because if we do nothing they will point to us and say we didn't have any better ideas or that we didn't contribute. They will paint us as resisting laws that try to stop mass shooters. Consider that a big part of the battle is not just legal but also the optics.
So, you're saying we need to come up with laws that infringe on our rights that we find tolerable to prevent the other side from passing laws that we would find intolerable?
That's like telling someone to give up a slice of their cake or have the whole thing taken. That solution only lasts until you've voluntarily given up the whole thing piece by piece.
-
So, you're saying we need to come up with laws that infringe on our rights that we find tolerable to prevent the other side from passing laws that we would find intolerable?
Strawman. I am saying we come up with a different approach that doesn't involve unconstitutional infringement on our rights.
-
Strawman. I am saying we come up with a different approach that doesn't involve unconstitutional infringement on our rights.
That solution does not exist. If it did, someone would have proposed it already.
Maybe you know more than the rest of the country? What's your plan that doesn't involve unconstitutional infringement? I know you've posted proposals, but they all had unconstitutional aspects. That tells me you have no clue WHAT solution can impact the problem without diminishing rights.
-
That solution does not exist. If it did, someone would have proposed it already.
People used to say we couldn't fly faster than the speed of sound either. Good thing some people didn't give up so easily.
Maybe you know more than the rest of the country? What's your plan that doesn't involve unconstitutional infringement? I know you've posted proposals, but they all had unconstitutional aspects. That tells me you have no clue WHAT solution can impact the problem without diminishing rights.
The ideas I came up with were in line with other constitutionally accepted revocation of people's rights. Regardless, brainstorming would seem to be the first step. You may not like my idea but at least I am coming up with something to consider. All other ideas can be brought to the table and discussed for pros and cons.
-
People used to say we couldn't fly faster than the speed of sound either. Good thing some people didn't give up so easily.
The ideas I came up with were in line with other constitutionally accepted revocation of people's rights. Regardless, brainstorming would seem to be the first step. You may not like my idea but at least I am coming up with something to consider. All other ideas can be brought to the table and discussed for pros and cons.
Totally unrelated. Laws of physics and current technology do not correlate with Constitutional law.
Talk about deflecting.
-
Totally unrelated. Laws of physics and current technology do not correlate with Constitutional law.
Talk about deflecting.
Irrelevant, I wasn't making a direct comparisons. Substitute any analogy you wish, the point is you are just giving up instead of coming up with any sort of idea.
Yes, deflecting... stop doing it please.
-
Strawman. I am saying we come up with a different approach that doesn't involve unconstitutional infringement on our rights.
This is the million dollar question that doesnt exist yet. Every law infringes on the 2a.
We should try less laws and see what happens. But thats not the long term plan now is it?.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
This is the million dollar question that doesnt exist yet.
So lets brainstorm.
Every law infringes on the 2a.
I disagree.
We should try less laws and see what happens. But thats not the long term plan now is it?.
It certainly isn't the trend.
-
That is a reactionary way to address the problem, one I am all for. The thing is what they are trying to address is a preventative measure before it happens. I think it is good to both try to prevent a problem as well as have an answer for if it happens anyway. So CCW is great but it only addresses half of the equation.
What's wrong with the laws we currently have in place that red flag law will help with?
Any Hawaii examples of a past incident that had occurred where a red flag law could have made a difference?
-
So lets brainstorm.
I disagree.
It certainly isn't the trend.
I misspoke. Majority of laws on the books infringe on the 2a.
I would like to see CCW/OC legal and see what happens over a 10 year period. WHen Florida turned "shall issue" to CCW, they planned on doing a 10 year study on it's effects. Prior to becoming law, crime was rising every year. Not 1% or a few %, but a good amount. Over a 6 year period, crime went down exponentially every year. So much that they stopped the study after 6 years or so. And remember, prior to CCW, it was always rising for years.
-
This is in response to deep concerns that law abiding gun owners have with red flag laws, particularly the one that recently went into effect in Hawaii (was in the "and here we go" thread).
Admittedly need more details and facts, but upon first impression this article is an example of damage that can be done by the "system" if there aren't checks and balances, as well as consequences for those that either made accusations/claims or those that perhaps didn't go through the proper processes. My assumptions of course, but that's my opinion. . .
EDIT: https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2020/01/05/answers-sought-after-state-authorities-take-child-without-court-order/ (https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2020/01/05/answers-sought-after-state-authorities-take-child-without-court-order/)
-
On the radio they mention how this happens all the time in the mainland.
-
This is in response to deep concerns that law abiding gun owners have with red flag laws, particularly the one that recently went into effect in Hawaii (was in the "and here we go" thread).
Admittedly need more details and facts, but upon first impression this article is an example of damage that can be done by the "system" if there aren't checks and balances, as well as consequences for those that either made accusations/claims or those that perhaps didn't go through the proper processes. My assumptions of course, but that's my opinion. . .
EDIT: https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2020/01/05/answers-sought-after-state-authorities-take-child-without-court-order/ (https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2020/01/05/answers-sought-after-state-authorities-take-child-without-court-order/)
The headline is misleading. "Answers sought after state authorities take a child without a court order" is putting it mildly. The mother has 100% legal custody of the child. The father SIGNED HIS RIGHTS AWAY, and he was court-ordered to not have contact with the family.
Basically, the "state authorities" that abducted the child from school with no notice to the legal custodial parent is guilty of facilitating kidnapping and violating an existing court order. it's much more egregious than failing to get a judge to approve removing the child from one parent reported to be unstable. The state broke the law.
-
The headline is misleading. "Answers sought after state authorities take a child without a court order" is putting it mildly. The mother has 100% legal custody of the child. The father SIGNED HIS RIGHTS AWAY, and he was court-ordered to not have contact with the family.
Basically, the "state authorities" that abducted the child from school with no notice to the legal custodial parent is guilty of facilitating kidnapping and violating an existing court order. it's much more egregious than failing to get a judge to approve removing the child from one parent reported to be unstable. The state broke the law.
But they did something. Must be good, right?
[sarcasm\]
-
The headline is misleading. "Answers sought after state authorities take a child without a court order" is putting it mildly. The mother has 100% legal custody of the child. The father SIGNED HIS RIGHTS AWAY, and he was court-ordered to not have contact with the family.
Basically, the "state authorities" that abducted the child from school with no notice to the legal custodial parent is guilty of facilitating kidnapping and violating an existing court order. it's much more egregious than failing to get a judge to approve removing the child from one parent reported to be unstable. The state broke the law.
The radio said this morning that the court order wasn't signed by the judge. A clerical error maybe? I could be mistaken what I heard while driving to work.
So in this case, it's incomplete like the impeachment of Trump, well depending what process you read on how impeachment works.
-
The radio said this morning that the court order wasn't signed by the judge. A clerical error maybe? I could be mistaken what I heard while driving to work.
So in this case, it's incomplete like the impeachment of Trump, well depending what process you read on how impeachment works.
You said the "court order" wasn't signed by a judge.
By definition, that makes it NOT A COURT ORDER. if it was typed up in the format of a court order but never signed, it's possible someone ASSUMED it was signed when they were told to execute it.
Someone AT A MINIMUM needs to lose their job/s over this. No excuse for "ripping a child from their mother's arms" without proper authorization.
-
What's wrong with the laws we currently have in place that red flag law will help with?
Any Hawaii examples of a past incident that had occurred where a red flag law could have made a difference?
Prior to the red flag law was there anyway that you could address the issue of someone you see who is mentally unstable and armed? Lets say your relative was diagnosed with brain cancer, spoke to invisible people, and started to become aggressive but refused to go see the doctor anymore. Prior to red flag laws would there have been any avenue by which you could have gotten the government to step in and do something?
I would have to dig a bit to see if there were any Hawaii shooters who exhibited serious red flags. I think in the Xerox shooting there were some but cannot recall the details. There were some instances in the mainland where there were numerous warning signs ahead of time but no one reported it. Near impossible to say whether the red flag would have prevented it however I do think there were times when it could have prevented it. Depends on the issue with the individual as well, someone suffering a temporary illness is a different case with a different way to address the problem than say someone wanting to go on a shooting spree, etc.
-
Prior to the red flag law was there anyway that you could address the issue of someone you see who is mentally unstable and armed? Lets say your relative was diagnosed with brain cancer, spoke to invisible people, and started to become aggressive but refused to go see the doctor anymore. Prior to red flag laws would there have been any avenue by which you could have gotten the government to step in and do something?
I would have to dig a bit to see if there were any Hawaii shooters who exhibited serious red flags. I think in the Xerox shooting there were some but cannot recall the details. There were some instances in the mainland where there were numerous warning signs ahead of time but no one reported it. Near impossible to say whether the red flag would have prevented it however I do think there were times when it could have prevented it. Depends on the issue with the individual as well, someone suffering a temporary illness is a different case with a different way to address the problem than say someone wanting to go on a shooting spree, etc.
So is it worth it to remove thousands peoples rights to protect a few? The answer is no. Because if that were the case, tobacco would be 100% illegal, so would alcohol and many other items that cause way more death and injuries than firearms. And smokes/booze isn't in the bill of rights.
The 2a is always specifically attacked by the left. And so does having this new form of a law. There is no way to tell the future with 100% accuracy what someone might do. See above examples again as proof. Someone buys alcohol and owns a car or has a drivers license. Red flag them and take their car away and booze because they might drink and drive and injure someone. Going to a restaurant tonight and having wine with dinner. Looks like you will have to uber or get a ride there and back. Because you might drink enough to be impaired.
-
So is it worth it to remove thousands peoples rights to protect a few? The answer is no. Because if that were the case, tobacco would be 100% illegal, so would alcohol and many other items that cause way more death and injuries than firearms. And smokes/booze isn't in the bill of rights.
No, you don't remove rights en mass. Instead you narrowly target specific individuals who for various reasons can/should/must lose their rights. Each instance of revocation of rights must be justified on its own.
The 2a is always specifically attacked by the left. And so does having this new form of a law. There is no way to tell the future with 100% accuracy what someone might do. See above examples again as proof. Someone buys alcohol and owns a car or has a drivers license. Red flag them and take their car away and booze because they might drink and drive and injure someone. Going to a restaurant tonight and having wine with dinner. Looks like you will have to uber or get a ride there and back. Because you might drink enough to be impaired.
Are you against the sex offender registry because there is no way to prove they will reoffend. Now I know that isn't the best analogy because you have to be convicted of a crime before you can be required to register but there is still an element of punitive action based on prediction.
Don't get me wrong, you are hitting the nail on the head here in terms of the difficulty in justifying the revocation of rights. Thats why I think in order to take someone's guns away a court should have to find proof that the accused is too dangerous to own firearms. I think preponderance of the evidence is too low a standard and it should be raised to clear and convincing evidence in accordance with case precedent on locking people up for mental health reasons.
-
No, you don't remove rights en mass. Instead you narrowly target specific individuals who for various reasons can/should/must lose their rights. Each instance of revocation of rights must be justified on its own.
Are you against the sex offender registry because there is no way to prove they will reoffend. Now I know that isn't the best analogy because you have to be convicted of a crime before you can be required to register but there is still an element of punitive action based on prediction.
Don't get me wrong, you are hitting the nail on the head here in terms of the difficulty in justifying the revocation of rights. Thats why I think in order to take someone's guns away a court should have to find proof that the accused is too dangerous to own firearms. I think preponderance of the evidence is too low a standard and it should be raised to clear and convincing evidence in accordance with case precedent on locking people up for mental health reasons.
Wrong.
The Sex Offender registry is not a punitive device. It is also not a preventative device. It's a public service.
We as law abiding citizens deserve to know who among us in our neighborhoods has been convicted of sexual offenses and whether the charges involved minors.
The rate of recidivism among sexual predators is very high. One study says 56.6%. Given that, it's reasonable for parents, teachers and children to be informed if there are people with risky behaviors in their past nearby.
Many say sexual predators are unable to help themselves and need intensive mental health treatment. Some are so untreatable they opt for chemical castration.
So, stop defending the criminals' rights. The law abiding have rights, too, which includes access to publicly available law enforcement & court data.
-
No, you don't remove rights en mass. Instead you narrowly target specific individuals who for various reasons can/should/must lose their rights. Each instance of revocation of rights must be justified on its own.
Are you against the sex offender registry because there is no way to prove they will reoffend. Now I know that isn't the best analogy because you have to be convicted of a crime before you can be required to register but there is still an element of punitive action based on prediction.
Don't get me wrong, you are hitting the nail on the head here in terms of the difficulty in justifying the revocation of rights. Thats why I think in order to take someone's guns away a court should have to find proof that the accused is too dangerous to own firearms. I think preponderance of the evidence is too low a standard and it should be raised to clear and convincing evidence in accordance with case precedent on locking people up for mental health reasons.
How about instead of taking the guns away without any notice, move the initial court date to 1 week from the complaint. Give the (up to this point) life time law abiding citizen a chance to address the allegations and have a mental examiner there to so do an onsite exam to see if the person is crazy.
We have seen in every state how this law is abused. See my previous post about true examples.
So red flag is not the answer and is not better than "doing something".
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
Criminals’ rights? 🤦🏻♂️
Hammurabi had it right in that regard...
-
How about instead of taking the guns away without any notice, move the initial court date to 1 week from the complaint. Give the (up to this point) life time law abiding citizen a chance to address the allegations and have a mental examiner there to so do an onsite exam to see if the person is crazy.
We have seen in every state how this law is abused. See my previous post about true examples.
So red flag is not the answer and is not better than "doing something".
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
You're proposing something similar to my proposal. You know -- that suggestion that EEF keeps saying nobody is offering on "our side"? :wacko:
How about we arrest the individual and require a mental health evaluation WITHOUT CONFISCATING ANYTHING?
If the person is a violent risk, HE is the threat, not his guns. Taking the guns and leaving him free (and probably pissed after his guns were taken) is not a solution.
If the individual is not prohibited, and the guns are legal to own, then confiscation without a chance to hear from doctors who examined the person, or without offering the individual a chance to offer a defense, is a non-starter for me.
My guess is the system is not capable of arresting him for NO CRIMES COMMITTED. So, the Red Flag law is a work-around. Nothing more, nothing less.
Work-arounds are not solutions. They are ways to avoid the need for a solution.
-
Just saw this today...
So Red Flag laws could never go bad right...?
https://www.9news.com/mobile/article/news/local/next/colorados-red-flag-law-used-to-target-officer-involved-in-fatal-shooting/73-f52ddaca-893d-493b-983c-db9ecf250ad3
Sent from my SM-T580 using Tapatalk
-
Just saw this today...
So Red Flag laws could never go bad right...?
https://www.9news.com/mobile/article/news/local/next/colorados-red-flag-law-used-to-target-officer-involved-in-fatal-shooting/73-f52ddaca-893d-493b-983c-db9ecf250ad3
Sent from my SM-T580 using Tapatalk
LEO get special treatment.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
So how do we fight this then?
How do we get this law removed/repealed (not that there is much chance of that happening...)
https://www.policeone.com/officer-safety/articles/opinion-the-dangers-posed-by-red-flag-laws-ITmhrV5x36djh5Jk/
-
So how do we fight this then?
How do we get this law removed/repealed (not that there is much chance of that happening...)
https://www.policeone.com/officer-safety/articles/opinion-the-dangers-posed-by-red-flag-laws-ITmhrV5x36djh5Jk/
Write to your law maker is the first step. Lawsuit will be the 2nd step.
-
I'll be there on the 30th. Don't know how much help I'll be other than a face with a HiFICO shirt on. But we need numbers in our favor.
-
I'll be there on the 30th. Don't know how much help I'll be other than a face with a HiFICO shirt on. But we need numbers in our favor.
Good enough
-
Wrong.
The Sex Offender registry is not a punitive device. It is also not a preventative device. It's a public service.
We as law abiding citizens deserve to know who among us in our neighborhoods has been convicted of sexual offenses and whether the charges involved minors.
The rate of recidivism among sexual predators is very high. One study says 56.6%. Given that, it's reasonable for parents, teachers and children to be informed if there are people with risky behaviors in their past nearby.
Many say sexual predators are unable to help themselves and need intensive mental health treatment. Some are so untreatable they opt for chemical castration.
So, stop defending the criminals' rights. The law abiding have rights, too, which includes access to publicly available law enforcement & court data.
Like I said, it was never meant to be a perfect analogy, just something else to think about it since it is affecting a right (though arguably one lost upon conviction)
The recidivism rates of all types of crime are actually lower for sex offenders than drug, property, and violent crime (except murder). They recommit sexual offenses at a higher rate but are less likely to commit crimes overall. Among that group of sexual offenders child molesters have a significantly higher rate of recidivism than your basic rapist so a good part of that recidivism risk seems to lie in those who are pedophilic sex offenders.
This is not a study of the sex offender registry idea, just something to consider because the individual is having a right taken away after having served their sentence based on a probability of re-offending. Thats what the link is in the comparison, the system is restricting a person's freedom based of a probability of future crime.
-
How about instead of taking the guns away without any notice, move the initial court date to 1 week from the complaint. Give the (up to this point) life time law abiding citizen a chance to address the allegations and have a mental examiner there to so do an onsite exam to see if the person is crazy.
We have seen in every state how this law is abused. See my previous post about true examples.
So red flag is not the answer and is not better than "doing something".
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
There is one huge weakness there, if you notify the person first and hold the court date later then you run the risk of not preventing anything. If I am thinking about going on a shooting rampage or killing myself then I get a notice to go to court to have my guns taken away in 1 week then this could either push me over the edge or it could cause me to move up my timeline, either way failing to prevent the harm. If a school shooter knew his guns were going to be taken away he would just act before the date. If a violent spouse knew his guns were going to be taken away he would likely act before the court date.
There is already legal precedent that someone can be arrested (rights taken away) based on probable cause but they have to be charged within 48 hours. That is the model I would use for red flag laws, if a judge finds probable cause then he grants the temporary one. What I would do different is require a hearing within 48 hours instead of the 14 days under our current law. That way if probable cause is found then the guns can be confiscated (rights taken away) temporarily before the harm can happen but the state has to justify itself expeditiously or else they have to give the guns right back for failing to show enough evidence in due time.
Maybe there can be two types of orders a judge could issue, like an immediate one for some impending harm or one like you suggest for someone who has no immediate warning signs but whose general safety is in question.
Another idea I had was instead of focusing on the firearms themselves, maybe the concerned person could petition the judge to order a psychological evaluation, following which firearms could be retained or taken away.
-
The biggest problem is the confiscation of property. It doesn't matter that it's firearms. The court decided without all the facts in hand that it will confiscate your property. What's to say that it won't confiscate your car when someone says it's parked illegally and you're parked in your assigned spot in a garage? They have it towed and you pay to get it back. What if you don't have the $1000 to get it out of the impound yard and they charge by the day. But fine, you get your car back. What recourse do you have against an unknown person? What about the state for not doing due diligence? What happened to Due Process?
If the Red Flag laws are the way they want to go, then fine, but it should be a mental health check of the person, followed by a 3 day Psych Hold if warranted for further evaluation. But done by at least 3 professionals with no conferencing between that way it remains impartial and they make their own conclusion on the mental state of the individual. Gotta have 2 to commit. Then if further action is warranted after the 3 day eval, then a court date on the 4th day. There is at least some semblance of due process. But that make too much sense so would never happen.
I know it works in reality because it was done to my neighbor in Vegas this way. METRO was called, he was given the 3 day, I was called by METRO (via neighbor) to go in and secure his firearms before he was released. METRO called me after a week to say he could have them back. The system worked.
-
If your 2nd amendment rights can be removed, then there should be enough evidence for ALL your rights to be removed. Anything less is an INFRINGEMENT, and illegal in the freaking United States of America. PERIOD
There is no argument or debate on this, and the very reason our liberty is at stake.
Why is this so hard to grasp for some people?
-
If your 2nd amendment rights can be removed, then there should be enough evidence for ALL your rights to be removed. Anything less is an INFRINGEMENT, and illegal in the freaking United States of America. PERIOD
There is no argument or debate on this, and the very reason our liberty is at stake.
Why is this so hard to grasp for some people?
Because they see guns as the problem. If they focused on the real problems (mental illness, psychotropic drugs, pure evil, etc.) they inevitably come to the same conclusion over and over -- you can't identify the violent people BEFORE they commit violence, therefore any treatment or incarceration is not preventative. They believe we as mere mortals have the ability to control every aspect of society, one way or another.
Therein lies their solution: control. Whether it's birth control, rent control or gun control, it's all the same: an attempt to place controls on human behavior that historically has been unable to be controlled. The best they have been able to do is Communist Russia and Communist China, where millions died rather than conform to the "big brother" collective society.
You can stop a baby from hurting itself with scissors by taking the scissors away. Or, you can teach the child when it's old enough to respect sharp objects and handle them safely. But, it just takes one kid behaving badly with scissors to make the whole class use safety scissors that can't cut warm butter.
Control is an illusion that is the stepping stone to tyranny. The people who don't grasp that as a real risk are the ones voting for ineffective laws that punish the gun owners who do nothing bad every single day.
-
The biggest problem is the confiscation of property. It doesn't matter that it's firearms. The court decided without all the facts in hand that it will confiscate your property. What's to say that it won't confiscate your car when someone says it's parked illegally and you're parked in your assigned spot in a garage? They have it towed and you pay to get it back. What if you don't have the $1000 to get it out of the impound yard and they charge by the day. But fine, you get your car back. What recourse do you have against an unknown person? What about the state for not doing due diligence? What happened to Due Process?
If the Red Flag laws are the way they want to go, then fine, but it should be a mental health check of the person, followed by a 3 day Psych Hold if warranted for further evaluation. But done by at least 3 professionals with no conferencing between that way it remains impartial and they make their own conclusion on the mental state of the individual. Gotta have 2 to commit. Then if further action is warranted after the 3 day eval, then a court date on the 4th day. There is at least some semblance of due process. But that make too much sense so would never happen.
I know it works in reality because it was done to my neighbor in Vegas this way. METRO was called, he was given the 3 day, I was called by METRO (via neighbor) to go in and secure his firearms before he was released. METRO called me after a week to say he could have them back. The system worked.
That certainly sounds like another viable alternative.
And it is about confiscation of property but in this case that property is a right so just like the government arresting you, they are taking away a constitutional right. Granted taking your whole person would seem a greater infringement of your rights. Regardless of whether they take just your firearms or instead take you, the process you mention could be a good alternative suggestion.
-
If your 2nd amendment rights can be removed, then there should be enough evidence for ALL your rights to be removed. Anything less is an INFRINGEMENT, and illegal in the freaking United States of America. PERIOD
There is no argument or debate on this, and the very reason our liberty is at stake.
Why is this so hard to grasp for some people?
Just to be clear, the law currently in place does require evidence. Requires probable cause to take them away in the beginning and preponderance of evidence to keep them for a year. Of course it is debatable on whether that is sufficient or not but the court is supposed to require evidence.
-
Just to be clear, the law currently in place does require evidence. Requires probable cause to take them away in the beginning and preponderance of evidence to keep them for a year. Of course it is debatable on whether that is sufficient or not but the court is supposed to require evidence.
So what stops the person from stabbing people with a three prong garden hoe, stealing guns, and burning down a neighborhood?
If the evidence says no 2A rights, then the evidence should says arrest and incarcerate.
-
Just to be clear, the law currently in place does require evidence. Requires probable cause to take them away in the beginning and preponderance of evidence to keep them for a year. Of course it is debatable on whether that is sufficient or not but the court is supposed to require evidence.
Like i stated b4, every state that has red flag laws, have required very little to confiscate.
Guns were even returned on many occassions. Which means i guess that person wasnt a danger after all, or the guns would not have been returned.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
So what stops the person from stabbing people with a three prong garden hoe, stealing guns, and burning down a neighborhood?
If the evidence says no 2A rights, then the evidence should says arrest and incarcerate.
I would tend to agree with you there.
-
Guns were even returned on many occassions. Which means i guess that person wasnt a danger after all, or the guns would not have been returned.
This could to do with the levels of proof required. Sometimes a court or prosecutor might say that there was probable cause to justify the arrest but not to take to trial or convict. So it doesn't necessarily mean the person wasn't a danger, just insufficient evidence for an extended denial of rights.
-
This could to do with the levels of proof required. Sometimes a court or prosecutor might say that there was probable cause to justify the arrest but not to take to trial or convict. So it doesn't necessarily mean the person wasn't a danger, just insufficient evidence for an extended denial of rights.
A person is a danger or isn't
If they don't have guns that doesn't make them any less dangerous
-
This could to do with the levels of proof required. Sometimes a court or prosecutor might say that there was probable cause to justify the arrest but not to take to trial or convict. So it doesn't necessarily mean the person wasn't a danger, just insufficient evidence for an extended denial of rights.
That;s the magic word right?? "probable cause". So they can do what ever they want.
-
That;s the magic word right?? "probable cause". So they can do what ever they want.
No. Probable Cause is the standard for making an arrest.
To establish probable cause, police officers must be able to point to objective circumstances leading them to believe
that a suspect committed a crime. A police officer can’t establish probable cause by saying only something like,
“I just had a hunch that the defendant was a burglar.”
Judges, not police officers, have the last word on whether probable cause exists. A police officer may be sincere in
believing that the facts establish probable cause. But if a judge examines that same information and disagrees, then
probable cause does not exist (or did not exist, if the question is being decided after an arrest).
Note that probable cause may have existed at the time of an arrest even if the defendant didn't actually do anything
wrong. Put differently, an arrest is valid as long as it is based on probable cause, even if the arrested person is innocent.
Key phrase: "police officers must be able to point to objective circumstances leading them to believe that a suspect committed a crime."
Red flag laws, by definition and intent, do not wait until a crime has been committed.
You can't have probable cause if a crime has not been, nor is not about to be, committed. Even if you want to argue the crime is related to firearms laws (mentally ill owner in possession of firearms), that's called bootstrapping. There needs to be articulable evidence of mental illness. "Acting crazy" is not evidence. If it was, half of Congress would be committed.
-
A person is a danger or isn't
If they don't have guns that doesn't make them any less dangerous
Well maybe a little less dangerous but certainly not harmless.
-
That;s the magic word right?? "probable cause". So they can do what ever they want.
Probable cause is a legal term for a certain level of proof and has been standard in court for a long time.
So you report to the police that someone assaulted you and you identify the person who did it to the officer the officer has probable cause to make an arrest. This is a very simplified scenario just to illustrate it.
Probable cause is a concept that can be difficult to nail down with a single universal definition so there is a certain flexibility for a judge to weigh in on. One of the standards is what a reasonable person would think. Now if you are hinting that it can be abused, yes sure, but that is not unique to firearms and red flag laws. But it cannot be just whatever they want it to be.
https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/probable_cause
Probable cause is not limited to criminal cases though, it is also used to determine whether there is enough evidence or information to justify a civil lawsuit. So there does not have to be evidence of a crime for probable cause to have been found.
https://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Probable+Cause