2aHawaii
General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: Kuleana on March 23, 2020, 07:56:24 PM
-
With all the talk of the US government borrowing trillions of dollars to just maintain the status quo on Wall Street, now is the time for Americans to rethink its current spending priorities on the military.
What good are these known and unknown garrisons around the globe with all their logistical costs, if the US does not have the money to properly address Covid-19 and its victims as well as financial assistance for the businesses and workers that will/are being wiped out in its wake?
There is no point of having the greatest military on Earth, if your country is headed to an economic depression.
-
IMO, that would invite our enemies to strike.
-
IMO, that would invite our enemies to strike.
Well, the US have the best weapon right now, COVID-19.
If anyone wants to come, let them in.
-
With all the talk of the US government borrowing trillions of dollars to just maintain the status quo on Wall Street, now is the time for Americans to rethink its current spending priorities on the military.
What good are these known and unknown garrisons around the globe with all their logistical costs, if the US does not have the money to properly address Covid-19 and its victims as well as financial assistance for the businesses and workers that will/are being wiped out in its wake?
There is no point of having the greatest military on Earth, if your country is headed to an economic depression.
So your idea to help the PRIVATE SECTOR economy is to force thousands of service members out of their government-funded jobs and into the private sector? How many of those will simply roll-over onto the welfare/unemployment roles, still costing tax payers but WITHOUT providing the services they were trained for -- and trained at great expense to the tax payer.
For every veteran who enters the job market in a down economy, there are civilians applying for the same job. Veterans often are given preference over non-vets. Is that what you want to see: your neighbor on food stamps and Medicare, possibly having to sell his home, while the ex-Marine gets the job your neighbor wanted?
The funds spent for a well-trained and well-equipped military also makes its way into the economy. Service members, support staff, civilian companies and all their family members spend that income, which then benefits the economy as a whole.
You have a very simplistic understanding of how finances and the economy work. If you think the government saving money somehow equates to a benefit for the private economy, there's not much hope for you.
Politicians saw a huge "peace dividend" when we won the Cold War and the military had a massive RIF. All that "savings" was spent on other programs -- and our taxes went UP. Additionally, we entered a recession at that time, because it takes time for a society to retool and retrain a drawn-down military. In the meantime, it hurts everyone short turn. More labor in the market suppresses salaries. Supply and demand.
Stack THAT draw-down recession ON TOP of the economic disaster we're facing now, and I think you'll agree that now is NOT the time.
-
So you want to cut spending on “garrisons” that you “know of” as well as don’t know of? It’s like saying I dunno what “x part” of my car does, but hell I think I don’t need it so I’ll tell the car manufacturer to cut it out.
-
double post
-
The military is effectively a socialist jobs program as well as a way for politicians to buy influence in their districts with heaping helpings of porkbarrel spending. As Smedley Butler pointed out, war is a racket.
We would have to replace the military with another socialist jobs program, which could actually save a lot of money over time because paying for bombs that simply cease to exist when they are used is a lot more wasteful than public works projects that last generations. Our quality of life would decline in some ways because we would not be able to force other countries to use the petrodollar, but the decline and rejection of our fiat currency is already happening anyway so not much to loose in the medium to long term.
What we really need to do is regrow domestic manufacturing, which is actually possible now that the trade war is over and people realize how dangerous it is to let foreigners control our supplies of medical equipment. Do not get me wrong. It will be a bumpy road no matter what direction we take, but some point we have to come to terms with the fact that our worst enemies are internal, which makes our bloated global conquest-obsessed socialist jobs program a huge liability that can and will be used against us unless we manage to scale it back to a reasonably sized institution.
-
"So your idea to help the PRIVATE SECTOR economy is to force thousands of service members out of their government-funded jobs and into the private sector? How many of those will simply roll-over onto the welfare/unemployment roles, still costing tax payers but WITHOUT providing the services they were trained for -- and trained at great expense to the tax payer."
You bet, any day of the week. I will always unapologetically put the interests of the nation's citizenry before its soldiers.
"For every veteran who enters the job market in a down economy, there are civilians applying for the same job. Veterans often are given preference over non-vets. Is that what you want to see: your neighbor on food stamps and Medicare, possibly having to sell his home, while the ex-Marine gets the job your neighbor wanted?"
Yes, veterans may have preferences for government jobs, but I doubt that will and should not hold true in the private sector during a recession or depression.
"The funds spent for a well-trained and well-equipped military also makes its way into the economy. Service members, support staff, civilian companies and all their family members spend that income, which then benefits the economy as a whole."
This maybe true as long as they are NOT SPENDING their money on businesses operating on military bases.
"You have a very simplistic understanding of how finances and the economy work. If you think the government saving money somehow equates to a benefit for the private economy, there's not much hope for you."
So you believe.
Borrowing money is never in the interest of the tax payers. Anytime a government can save money, that allows for a surplus that can greatly benefit society, especially during a pandemic crises like what the World is going through now.
"Politicians saw a huge "peace dividend" when we won the Cold War and the military had a massive RIF. All that "savings" was spent on other programs -- and our taxes went UP. Additionally, we entered a recession at that time, because it takes time for a society to retool and retrain a drawn-down military. In the meantime, it hurts everyone short turn. More labor in the market suppresses salaries. Supply and demand."
What's your point? The founding fathers were against war and standing armies. A nation should spend its time making money, not war or garrisoning the planet.
"Stack THAT draw-down recession ON TOP of the economic disaster we're facing now, and I think you;ll agree that now is NOT the time."
I humbly disagree.
The whole World is already facing a global recession that can potentially lead to a global depression by the end of this calendar year. Should that happen, every nation will need every dollar to ensure the RULE OF LAW and continuity of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness of its people within its borders.
The nations of the World will not have the time to act tough and make dirty faces at each other.
-
So you want to cut spending on “garrisons” that you “know of” as well as don’t know of? It’s like saying I dunno what “x part” of my car does, but hell I think I don’t need it so I’ll tell the car manufacturer to cut it out.
Please don't insult the intelligence of many on this forum.
It does not take Flapp's high level top secret security clearance to be aware of the existence of military outposts that are not generally known by the American public.
-
"So your idea to help the PRIVATE SECTOR economy is to force thousands of service members out of their government-funded jobs and into the private sector? How many of those will simply roll-over onto the welfare/unemployment roles, still costing tax payers but WITHOUT providing the services they were trained for -- and trained at great expense to the tax payer."
You bet, any day of the week. I will always unapologetically put the interests of the nation's citizenry before its soldiers.
"You bet, any day of the week. I will always unapologetically put the interests of the nation's citizenry before its soldiers."
Maybe you missed that day in school, but the people you refer to as merely "soldiers" are also citizens, with the same rights and interests as the rest of the "citizenry".
We know you hate the military, but now you have gone and admitted you have a personal grudge against the individual members of the military, not just the management.
You believe the "man on the street" is more deserving of -- anything -- than anyone willing to join the military. That's sad and repulsive at the same time.
-
The military is effectively a socialist jobs program as well as a way for politicians to buy influence in their districts with heaping helpings of porkbarrel spending. As Smedley Butler pointed out, war is a racket.
We would have to replace the military with another socialist jobs program, which could actually save a lot of money over time because paying for bombs that simply cease to exist when they are used is a lot more wasteful than public works projects that last generations. Our quality of life would decline in some ways because we would not be able to force other countries to use the petrodollar, but the decline and rejection of our fiat currency is already happening anyway so not much to loose in the medium to long term.
What we really need to do is regrow domestic manufacturing, which is actually possible now that the trade war is over and people realize how dangerous it is to let foreigners control our supplies of medical equipment. Do not get me wrong. It will be a bumpy road no matter what direction we take, but some point we have to come to terms with the fact that our worst enemies are internal, which makes our bloated global conquest-obsessed socialist jobs program a huge liability that can and will be used against us unless we manage to scale it back to a reasonably sized institution.
Well spoken. :worship:
That's the tragedy of many Americans who mindlessly support the military and accept all the manipulated patriotic propaganda. They are just being used to get their support to perpetually fund the military industrial complex that saps the wealth of the nation rather than add to it.
-
you should organize another convoy up to all the military "garrisons" and "outposts" you can identify and tell them go home like you guys did in Waikiki
https://www.kitv.com/story/41923536/ku-kiai-hawaii-convoy-draws-hundreds (https://www.kitv.com/story/41923536/ku-kiai-hawaii-convoy-draws-hundreds)
-
"For every veteran who enters the job market in a down economy, there are civilians applying for the same job. Veterans often are given preference over non-vets. Is that what you want to see: your neighbor on food stamps and Medicare, possibly having to sell his home, while the ex-Marine gets the job your neighbor wanted?"
Yes, veterans may have preferences for government jobs, but I doubt that will and should not hold true in the private sector during a recession or depression.
Wrong. The preferences kick in even more when the military has a RIF. Economic factors don't play into hiring policies. The gov't offers incentives, not to mention the public image boost of hiring vets -- at least for those who don;t hate the military members like you do.
"The funds spent for a well-trained and well-equipped military also makes its way into the economy. Service members, support staff, civilian companies and all their family members spend that income, which then benefits the economy as a whole."
This maybe true as long as they are NOT SPENDING their money on businesses operating on military bases.
Ever been on a base? Most concessions are run by local owners and national chains with local franchises. They hire lots of off-base employees to work the jobs, as well as many dependents.
Where do you think that money goes? Bases operate like any other gov't run place. They use civilian vendors. That vendor is not a gov't entity.
"You have a very simplistic understanding of how finances and the economy work. If you think the government saving money somehow equates to a benefit for the private economy, there's not much hope for you."
So you believe.
Not much of an argument, huh? You can't tell me why I'm incorrect in that belief?
Borrowing money is never in the interest of the tax payers. Anytime a government can save money, that allows for a surplus that can greatly benefit society, especially during a pandemic crises like what the World is going through now.
"Politicians saw a huge "peace dividend" when we won the Cold War and the military had a massive RIF. All that "savings" was spent on other programs -- and our taxes went UP. Additionally, we entered a recession at that time, because it takes time for a society to retool and retrain a drawn-down military. In the meantime, it hurts everyone short turn. More labor in the market suppresses salaries. Supply and demand."
What's your point? The founding fathers were against war and standing armies. A nation should spend its time making money, not war or garrisoning the planet.
The founding fathers? LOL! The founders never envisioned a trillion-dollar budget, nor all the welfare/charity programs we have that are quite literally nothing but using taxes to buy votes.
"Stack THAT draw-down recession ON TOP of the economic disaster we're facing now, and I think you;ll agree that now is NOT the time."
I humbly disagree.
The whole World is already facing a global recession that can potentially lead to a global depression by the end of this calendar year. Should that happen, every nation will need every dollar to ensure the RULE OF LAW and continuity of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness of its people within its borders.
The nations of the World will not have the time to act tough and make dirty faces at each other.
With a GLOBAL pandemic hitting some very strong nations (China) very hard, do you really think now is the time to drop our guard? Not only that, but our military performs some of the most effective humanitarian missions on the planet (go read about the Tsunami relief our hospital ships provided).
So short-sighted, it's not even worth considering.
-
"You bet, any day of the week. I will always unapologetically put the interests of the nation's citizenry before its soldiers."
Maybe you missed that day in school, but the people you refer to as merely "soldiers" are also citizens, with the same rights and interests as the rest of the "citizenry".
We know you hate the military, but now you have gone and admitted you have a personal grudge against the individual members of the military, not just the management.
You believe the "man on the street" is more deserving of -- anything -- than anyone willing to join the military. That's sad and repulsive at the same time.
Please don't reframe my statements for your personal agenda.
People of the military ARE CITIZENS of their nation, but don't insult everyone here that they and civilians are the same. Where do civilians or other government employees for that matter have the privilege of shopping at the HEAVILY SUBSIDIZED Navy Exchange or the Commissary for the needs of daily life or frequent a military base's bowling alley or theaters for their entertainment?
After all that special treatment, you really believe the civilian population should kowtow to military servicemen.
What you are championing is a return of the military as social class of its own above civilians. In the modern World, only fascist governments did that.
-
Please don't reframe my statements for your personal agenda.
People of the military ARE CITIZENS of their nation, but don't insult everyone here that they and civilians are the same. Where do civilians or other government employees for that matter have the privilege of shopping at the HEAVILY SUBSIDIZED Navy Exchange or the Commissary for the needs of daily life or frequent a military base's bowling alley or theaters for their entertainment?
After all that special treatment, you really believe the civilian population should kowtow to military servicemen.
What you are championing is a return of the military as social class of its own above civilians. In the modern World, only fascist governments did that.
So, now who's framing statements to create a false narrative?
It's called MWR. If you don't understand it, I can't teach it to you on a forum. Got educate yourself.
-
"Wrong. The preferences kick in even more when the military has a RIF. Economic factors don't play into hiring policies. The gov't offers incentives, not to mention the public image boost of hiring vets -- at least for those who don;t hate the military members like you do."
That's a bad policy. You must be a SOCIALIST because true capitalism dictates no special privilege to ANYONE.
"Ever been on a base? Most concessions are run by local owners and national chains with local franchises. They hire lots of off-base employees to work the jobs, as well as many dependents.
Where do you think that money goes? Bases operate like any other gov't run place. They use civilian vendors. That vendor is not a gov't entity."
Got news for you. Those businesses do not charge nor pay state taxes.
"The founding fathers? LOL! The founders never envisioned a trillion-dollar budget, nor all the welfare/charity programs we have that are quite literally nothing but using taxes to buy votes."
How do those realities of today offset the founding fathers view AGAINST war and having a standing military?
"With a GLOBAL pandemic hitting some very strong nations (China) very hard, do you really think now is the time to drop our guard? Not only that, but our military performs some of the most effective humanitarian missions on the planet (go read about the Tsunami relief our hospital ships provided)."
Any nation's military can be used to assist humanitarian disasters. You make it sound only America's military conducts such activities.
-
"Wrong. The preferences kick in even more when the military has a RIF. Economic factors don't play into hiring policies. The gov't offers incentives, not to mention the public image boost of hiring vets -- at least for those who don;t hate the military members like you do."
That's a bad policy. You must be a SOCIALIST because true capitalism dictates no special privilege to ANYONE.
Yeah. The Socialist Party Leaders NEVER EVER got anything resembling special treatment, huh? :rofl: :rofl:
I'm a Socialist like you're a Veteran.
"Ever been on a base? Most concessions are run by local owners and national chains with local franchises. They hire lots of off-base employees to work the jobs, as well as many dependents.
Where do you think that money goes? Bases operate like any other gov't run place. They use civilian vendors. That vendor is not a gov't entity."
Got news for you. Those businesses do not charge nor pay state taxes.
Wrong. Businesses operating in Hawaii owe state EXCISE taxes on their income, unless they fall into specialized sectors like research and development. Go look it up. ALL BUSINESSES that operate in Hawaii -- local or not -- even on bases -- owe excise taxes with a few exceptions..
"The founding fathers? LOL! The founders never envisioned a trillion-dollar budget, nor all the welfare/charity programs we have that are quite literally nothing but using taxes to buy votes."
How do those realities of today offset the founding fathers view AGAINST war and having a standing military.
You beat that dead horse already. Go review past comments in other threads.
"With a GLOBAL pandemic hitting some very strong nations (China) very hard, do you really think now is the time to drop our guard? Not only that, but our military performs some of the most effective humanitarian missions on the planet (go read about the Tsunami relief our hospital ships provided)."
Any nation's military can be used to assist humanitarian disasters. You make it sound only America conducts such activities.
You really spun that!! How many ships can you name from other countries that essentially provide a full service hospital off the coast of a territory that's been demolished by a natural disaster? I'll let you use Google if you can't come up with any.
-
Word on the street is that the fun guys in the middle east are already drumming that the US is responsible for the virus outbreak, due to the propaganda being spun out of communist China. Keep in mind their subjects do not have free access to information like most of us do.
I fully expect a terrorist incident occurring shortly, either in the United States or in Israel.
-
Word on the street is that the fun guys in the middle east are already drumming that the US is responsible for the virus outbreak, due to the propaganda being spun out of communist China. Keep in mind their subjects do not have free access to information like most of us do.
I fully expect a terrorist incident occurring shortly, either in the United States or in Israel.
That's a very plausible conclusion. Iran was hit by the pandemic very hard, including some of their highest leaders. Would not be a stretch for them to blame the Big Satan for their lack of ability to handle an outbreak.
It would not be surprising for someone to think attacking now is wise - while we are busy juggling so many other balls in the air.
But, hey! We can use our tax money to prop up GM and Bank of America instead of funding the military. That plan worked so well under Obama. :thumbsup:
-
But, hey! We can use our tax money to prop up GM and Bank of America instead of funding the military. :thumbsup:
Spoken like a true war junkie.
Instead of bailing out the ULTRA-RICH on Wall Street and feeding the military industrial complex, how about providing financial assistance to SMALL BUSINESSES and the WORKING CLASS of US Main Street, instead?
Nah, what was I thinking?
We should all believe like you in funding our soldiers wherever they are, which is MUCH BETTER than preventing COVID-19 deaths and helping the starving and soon homeless working class here in America.
-
Word on the street is that the fun guys in the middle east are already drumming that the US is responsible for the virus outbreak, due to the propaganda being spun out of communist China. Keep in mind their subjects do not have free access to information like most of us do.
I fully expect a terrorist incident occurring shortly, either in the United States or in Israel.
They already have enough reason to carry out such campaigns without the virus conspiracy, but it does throw another log on the fire. With our trade agreements in tatters the American vs Chinese mad scramble for influence over oil producing countries will continue with much less diplomacy than before. We could be looking at a hot war with China in the not too distant future. A lot depends on how badly this virus ravages Africa.
-
Spoken like a true war junkie.
Instead of bailing out the ULTRA-RICH on Wall Street and feeding the military industrial complex, how about providing financial assistance to SMALL BUSINESSES and the WORKING CLASS of US Main Street, instead?
Nah, what was I thinking?
We should all believe like you in funding our soldiers wherever they are, which is MUCH BETTER than preventing COVID-19 deaths and helping the starving and soon homeless working class here in America.
That is EXACTLY what Trump and Senate Republicans did this week -- well, at least tried to do before the Democrats stopped the bill -- TWICE.
You need to reevaluate which groups you are accusing of being for or against the working class and small business.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C_CxhOwdnU0&t=183s
-
That is EXACTLY what Trump and Senate Republicans did this week -- well, at least tried to do before the Democrats stopped the bill -- TWICE.
You need to reevaluate which groups you are accusing of being for or against the working class and small business.
Don't be coy and throw me into the bucket of Democratic Party slime.
Your sneaky support of anything military over the needs of the citizens of this country will be the reason why the current crisis won't end quickly.
-
They already have enough reason to carry out such campaigns without the virus conspiracy, but it does throw another log on the fire. With our trade agreements in tatters the American vs Chinese mad scramble for influence over oil producing countries will continue with much less diplomacy than before. We could be looking at a hot war with China in the not too distant future. A lot depends on how badly this virus ravages Africa.
Very possible HB, but with a global economic depression very much a possibility, no country will be able to conduct a war with each other.
Nuclear weapons notwithstanding, the resulting economic hardships due to such a war will result in the end of all of life's simplicities and bring forth widespread chaos in the streets through which the Rule of Law would cease to exist. There is no way any country could persecute such a war under those conditions for any long period of time.
-
I missed this Thread yesterday.
Interesting comments.
I'll say this I defended your butt once,
don't expect me to do it again.
BTW
NEX, BX, and PX are self supporting
and I shop there just to cheat you Hawaiian Democrats
out of your GET.
-
I missed this Thread yesterday.
Interesting comments.
I'll say this I defended your butt once,
don't expect me to do it again.
BTW
NEX, BX, and PX are self supporting
and I shop there just to cheat you Hawaiian Democrats
out of your GET.
It would be nice if businesses below a certain size were exempt too. The small business atmosphere here is very hostile.
-
(https://imagesvh1-a.akamaihd.net/uri/mgid:file:http:shared:vh1.com/news/uploads/sites/2/2018/02/michael-popcorn-1518029708.gif)
-
I missed this Thread yesterday.
Interesting comments.
I'll say this I defended your butt once,
don't expect me to do it again.
BTW
NEX, BX, and PX are self supporting
and I shop there just to cheat you Hawaiian Democrats
out of your GET.
To be accurate, the commissary/exchange system is a mixed bag re: self support.
In the US, that's almost true. With economies of scale, the system buys in massive quantities at equally massive discounts. Some of the costs of operations are paid in the form of "surcharges" added to the purchases -- basically a "tax" substitute.
Where we start losing money is where costs exceed revenue (duh :crazy:). in cities where family housing is inadequate on-base, military families/individuals live out on the local economy. Local civilian stores are often more convenient or offer better variety. Sometimes price is not the deciding factor when the on-base selections can't compete with online or local businesses.
The biggest issue is the overseas situation. Cost of stocking those shelves are much higher. Even though the military/families living there are more likely to shop on-base rather than the local stores, the prices are often higher then in the US exchanges. It's cheaper to order from Amazon nowadays. The exchanges are now offering online ordering, but that doesn't offer cheaper prices if Amazon isn't collecting tax at most destination locations.
As far as WHY the military has these facilities, those reasons have changed -- at least as far as US facilities. In the past, almost every military member and family lived on-base for security and job purposes. Off-base access was restricted to avoid potential problems between locals and the military. The attitudes of many civilians toward the military were much like Kukeana's -- total hatred and disdain. I'm talking decades ago -- post-Vietnam era. In order to avoid confrontations, the bases pretty much issued passes one a month on a weekend to let the troops decompress. The rest of the time, they were confined to base.
Now, there is an increasing tendency for military personnel to live off-base in private housing. Much of the Oahu military housing is built "off-base", and members have to drive to the bases they work at. Basically, military housing in integrated with the local civilian population. That includes shopping, schools, restaurants, auto repair, and every other business you can name.
Anyway, there have been studies by the DoD on making the BX/PX/Commissary systems self-supporting, and the conclusion was that the system would have to be 100% scrapped if that happens. From a purely pragmatic perspective in today's Amazon-driven consumer market, maybe it's time?
-
They already have enough reason to carry out such campaigns without the virus conspiracy, but it does throw another log on the fire. With our trade agreements in tatters the American vs Chinese mad scramble for influence over oil producing countries will continue with much less diplomacy than before. We could be looking at a hot war with China in the not too distant future. A lot depends on how badly this virus ravages Africa.
But as previously mentioned the military needs to be scaled back etc etc while China’s military is getting larger by the day! Can’t have it both ways, rite? Wait everything will be fine according to “Professor Kuleana” maybe aka Brandon...... :worship:
-
But as previously mentioned the military needs to be scaled back etc etc while China’s military is getting larger by the day! Can’t have it both ways, rite? Wait everything will be fine according to “Professor Kuleana” maybe aka Brandon...... :worship:
Why are you fear mongering at a time of Pandemic crisis?
The US military outspends both Russia and China combined by a HUGE MARGIN. Are you a mindless follower of the military industrial complex Eisenhower warned everybody about?
If anything, the runaway spending of the military really EXPOSED how domestically vulnerable the US really is. Not enough masks and hospitable beds, insufficient emergency medical funds to combat COVID-19 directly, etc.
Furthermore, this pandemic has just shown poorer countries the strategy to overcome America's military superiority. No need for Ebola, just ENGINEER and deliver a super-flu on the financial centers of this country, BLAME China for it, and SIT-BACK and laugh at the chaos and rule without law that will destroy the US from within.
-
To be accurate, the commissary/exchange system is a mixed bag re: self support.
In the US, that's almost true. With economies of scale, the system buys in massive quantities at equally massive discounts. Some of the costs of operations are paid in the form of "surcharges" added to the purchases -- basically a "tax" substitute.
Where we start losing money is where costs exceed revenue (duh :crazy:). in cities where family housing is inadequate on-base, military families/individuals live out on the local economy. Local civilian stores are often more convenient or offer better variety. Sometimes price is not the deciding factor when the on-base selections can't compete with online or local businesses.
The biggest issue is the overseas situation. Cost of stocking those shelves are much higher. Even though the military/families living there are more likely to shop on-base rather than the local stores, the prices are often higher then in the US exchanges. It's cheaper to order from Amazon nowadays. The exchanges are now offering online ordering, but that doesn't offer cheaper prices if Amazon isn't collecting tax at most destination locations.
As far as WHY the military has these facilities, those reasons have changed -- at least as far as US facilities. In the past, almost every military member and family lived on-base for security and job purposes. Off-base access was restricted to avoid potential problems between locals and the military. The attitudes of many civilians toward the military were much like Kukeana's -- total hatred and disdain. I'm talking decades ago -- post-Vietnam era. In order to avoid confrontations, the bases pretty much issued passes one a month on a weekend to let the troops decompress. The rest of the time, they were confined to base.
Now, there is an increasing tendency for military personnel to live off-base in private housing. Much of the Oahu military housing is built "off-base", and members have to drive to the bases they work at. Basically, military housing in integrated with the local civilian population. That includes shopping, schools, restaurants, auto repair, and every other business you can name.
Anyway, there have been studies by the DoD on making the BX/PX/Commissary systems self-supporting, and the conclusion was that the system would have to be 100% scrapped if that happens. From a purely pragmatic perspective in today's Amazon-driven consumer market, maybe it's time?
Thanks for your insights.
In my last duty location there was insufficent base housing so I lived off base.
We were encouraged to appy for welfare, as housing allowance did not cover
full cost of rents in that area.
The Commissary was far cheaper than the local Safeway.
That was in 1978 I held the rank of E-5 more than 4 years in service.
Today I compare costs as I did then.
Exchange costs are comparable with other on-line services.
For the hell of it I went on Amazon to re-order
some of my previous "Prepper" stuff most every item was
not available.
I suspect Amazon will replenish soon.
My point is Amazon has it's limits as does Walmart, Ebay et al.
but I trust the military supply chain.
I remember servicing C-5 aircraft on Guam that were full of tons of disposable
diapers. Military Exchanges got the first pallets, then the civilian stores.
FedEx and UPS weren't flying there for a few weeks, place was a mess.
Super Typhoon Pamela 1976.
-
Why are you fear mongering at a time of Pandemic crisis?
The US military outspends both Russia and China combined by a HUGE MARGIN. Are you a mindless follower of the military industrial complex Eisenhower warned everybody about?
If anything, the runaway spending of the military really EXPOSED how domestically vulnerable the US really is. Not enough masks and hospitable beds, insufficient emergency medical funds to combat COVID-19 directly, etc.
Furthermore, this pandemic has just shown poorer countries the strategy to overcome America's military superiority. No need for Ebola, just ENGINEER and deliver a super-flu on the financial centers of this country, BLAME China for it, and SIT-BACK and laugh at the chaos and rule without law that will destroy the US from within.
I tend to look at things on a per capita basis when it comes to money
go here
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_expenditure_per_capita.
Russia and China aren't even on that list.
You may have a point.
One point you also made and really miss is fear and perception
is far more powerful than facts and data.
The Governor has just virtually destroyed the largest industry in this state.
All for political reasons.
This whole thing is being Driven by Democrats that want to rule America.
I'm not going to submit to that, nor will I submit to a race based government
as you frequently advocate.
Have a good one!
-
Why are you fear mongering at a time of Pandemic crisis?
The US military outspends both Russia and China combined by a HUGE MARGIN. Are you a mindless follower of the military industrial complex Eisenhower warned everybody about?
If anything, the runaway spending of the military really EXPOSED how domestically vulnerable the US really is. Not enough masks and hospitable beds, insufficient emergency medical funds to combat COVID-19 directly, etc.
Furthermore, this pandemic has just shown poorer countries the strategy to overcome America's military superiority. No need for Ebola, just ENGINEER and deliver a super-flu on the financial centers of this country, BLAME China for it, and SIT-BACK and laugh at the chaos and rule without law that will destroy the US from within.
:rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: I should know better than saying anything to you! You accuse others of twisting your words around when you are quite adept at the same game. Responding to anything you say is a waste of my time. My bad. Fix some water pipes and spew your b.s. have a good day, Brandon...
-
:rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: I should know better than saying anything to you! You accuse others of twisting your words around when you are quite adept at the same game. Responding to anything you say is a waste of my time. My bad. Fix some water pipes and spew your b.s. have a good day, Brandon...
Dealing with individuals who thrive on personal attacks on those who do not go along with support the military first and citizens last herd mentality thinking does that to a free-thinking person. :shake:
Be healthy; you would not want to task the system now if you get sick, since the money that should have been going to a slush fund to properly address what's currently happening got allocated to the over bloated military budget. ;)
Brandon? Who's Brandon? ???
-
Dealing with individuals who thrive on personal attacks on those who do not go along with support the military first and citizens last herd mentality thinking does that to a free-thinking person. :shake:
Be healthy; you would not want to task the system now if you get sick, since the money that should have been going to a slush fund to properly address what's currently happening got allocated to the over bloated military budget. ;)
Brandon? Who's Brandon? ???
:sleeping: :sleeping: :sleeping: :wave:
-
You can catch more flies with honey than vinegar. Just sayinʻ
-
You can catch more flies with honey than vinegar. Just sayinʻ
That assumes you have some weird desire to catch flies.
I prefer to kill them. They're called "pests' for a reason. :geekdanc: :rofl:
-
I always assumed the purpose of arguments is to be persuasive, not a public catharsis.
-
I always assumed the purpose of arguments is to be persuasive, not a public catharsis.
That of course assumes the argument is actually an argument.
It only takes one provable, opposing example to stand a stated conclusion on its
#HEAD. :geekdanc:
-
I always assumed the purpose of arguments is to be persuasive, not a public catharsis.
There seems to be a personality type that craves argument.
Have run into quite a few online. One huge tip is always trying for the last word or at least beating things to death.
Not to be sexist, but the female persuasion is often seen doing this.
-
There seems to be a personality type that craves argument.
Have run into quite a few online. One huge tip is always trying for the last word or at least beating things to death.
Not to be sexist, but the female persuasion is often seen doing this.
MISOGYNIST ! :-*
-
What is sorely needed is to make the military efficient and to cut waste, fraud, and abuse. We could cut a good percentage off the military budget without reducing our capabilities or cutting troop numbers. Not just in the military, but also with military contractors and pork barrel spending by politicians. I handled some small budgets and logistics in the military and was a servicemember and I was part of the problem. It was a culture and attitude problem in the military. I didn't see or understand that this is other people's money that was being wasted till later in my career.
It's very difficult to get any changes made because it's seen as affecting national security or hurting the troops.
-
What is sorely needed is to make the military efficient and to cut waste, fraud, and abuse. We could cut a good percentage off the military budget without reducing our capabilities or cutting troop numbers. Not just in the military, but also with military contractors and pork barrel spending by politicians. I handled some small budgets and logistics in the military and was a servicemember and I was part of the problem. It was a culture and attitude problem in the military. I didn't see or understand that this is other people's money that was being wasted till later in my career.
It's very difficult to get any changes made because it's seen as affecting national security or hurting the troops.
Well said!
The war junkies, neocons, and military industrial complex all love to pray on the fears that any $1 drop in military spending means the end of the American way of life.
The age of mass invasions among military peers ended in the 20th century with the advent of nuclear weapons. Hence, the only reason for any country to maintain a military budget such as the US is to bleed the tax payers and maintain a global empire.
Why else would you maintain such an obscene military budget when it is clear funding is needed elsewhere, as revealed by the current global pandemic catastrophe.
-
What is sorely needed is to make the military efficient and to cut waste, fraud, and abuse. We could cut a good percentage off the military budget without reducing our capabilities or cutting troop numbers. Not just in the military, but also with military contractors and pork barrel spending by politicians. I handled some small budgets and logistics in the military and was a servicemember and I was part of the problem. It was a culture and attitude problem in the military. I didn't see or understand that this is other people's money that was being wasted till later in my career.
It's very difficult to get any changes made because it's seen as affecting national security or hurting the troops.
Not to blame the military/Pentagon for it, but the baseline budgeting used by the Congress and WH causes a huge percentage of wasteful spending.
The end-of-fiscal-year gymnastics we went through to spend the remainder of our budgets resulted in purchases that were usually not mission critical, and often just purely wasteful.
For 10 months we are told "we can't afford that additional person to do real mission-related work," or "our budget is too tight to fly you out the day before a 3 week exercise to rest up after a long flight." Then in August, there is total panic that if we don't replace 2 year old computers, buy an iPad for everyone in the office and get $1500 licenses for MS Office for everyone (even though nobody knows how to use it), we'll have our budget cut the next FY.
Stop that goat rope, and we'll save tens of millions or more every single year.
-
Not to blame the military/Pentagon for it, but the baseline budgeting used by the Congress and WH causes a huge percentage of wasteful spending.
The military and pentagon is just as guilty as the WH or Congress. Who do you think both entities consult when drafting the budget? The homeless on the streets? :wtf:
To say there is no corruption in the ranks of the military is disingenuous.
The military budget needs to be drastically reduced and Trump has to tell them they need to do more with less. In that way, it will force more cost-effective decisions and better uncover the corrupt within the rank and file.
This will definitely free up millions of dollars that should be used elsewhere, as revealed during the current COVID-19 crisis.
-
The military and pentagon is just as guilty as the WH or Congress. Who do you think both entities consult when drafting the budget? The homeless on the streets? :wtf:
To say there is no corruption in the ranks of the military is disingenuous.
The military budget needs to be drastically reduced and Trump has to tell them they need to do more with less. In that way, it will force more cost-effective decisions and better uncover the corrupt within the rank and file.
This will definitely free up millions of dollars that should be used elsewhere, as revealed during the current COVID-19 crisis.
What's your point? The baseline budgeting includes every single federal government agency, not just the military.
You were never in the military, but PLEASE enlighten us on how the budgets are produced. I'd like to see if what's done in practice matches what you think is done in theory.
-
You were never in the military, but PLEASE enlighten us on how the budgets are produced. I'd like to see if what's done in practice matches what you think is done in theory.
The science and art of budgeting itself is a standard practice in management.
I have and maintain budgets in my line of work and, as an economist, consult others on their own short and long-term budgets.
Depending on what the organization's goal(s) is/are, budgeting is nothing more than allocating what monies you have to the materials and services you need to meet organizational objectives.
In practice, corruption in the budgeting process usually takes place when those in charge of the budget get sneaky and over-complicate the process to hide their shenanigans.
Any budget should be easy to understand for the common person; if not, the budget is likely misallocating resources unintentionally or intentionally.
-
The science and art of budgeting itself is a standard practice in management.
I have and maintain budgets in my line of work and, as an economist, consult others on their own short and long-term budgets.
Depending on what the organization's goal(s) is/are, budgeting is nothing more than allocating what monies you have to the materials and services you need to meet organizational objectives.
In practice, corruption in the budgeting process usually takes place when those in charge of the budget get sneaky and over-complicate the process to hide their shenanigans.
Any budget should be easy to understand for the common person; if not, the budget is likely misallocating resources unintentionally or intentionally.
That statement alone proves beyond any doubt you have no idea how the government does budgeting.
Just stop.
-
Gaslighting by way of force fitting “facts” into a narrow view without any direct knowledge of many of the “W’s”.
-
Baseline budgeting is an accounting method the United States Federal Government uses to
develop a budget for future years. Baseline budgeting uses current spending levels as the
"baseline" for establishing future funding requirements and assumes future budgets will equal
the current budget times the inflation rate times the population growth rate.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baseline_(budgeting)
Name a private corporation that automatically INCREASES a group's budget if they spent 100% of last year's funding with little to no consideration for justification, and which CUTS funding the following year if the group ends the year with a budget a surplus.
The baseline budgeting process rewards maximum, often wasteful, spending, and it punishes anyone who saves the gov't money.
You have much to learn.
-
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baseline_(budgeting)
Name a private corporation that automatically INCREASES a group's budget if they spent 100% of last year's funding with little to no consideration for justification, and which CUTS funding the following year if the group ends the year with a budget a surplus.
The baseline budgeting process rewards maximum, often wasteful, spending, and it punishes anyone who saves the gov't money.
You have much to learn.
Nice diversion taking away the original premise of this thread.
Your tangent discussion of "baseline budgeting" was very educational, but plays no bearing that the US military budget still needs to be scaled back in favor of other more pressing concerns.
-
Nice diversion taking away the original premise of this thread.
Your tangent discussion of "baseline budgeting" was very educational, but plays no bearing that the US military budget still needs to be scaled back in favor of other more pressing concerns.
:rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
HOW the gov't/military creates the budget you object to is entirely on point (SUBJECT: Time to Scale Back US Military Spending).
You were more than happy to engage in the baseline budgeting discussion until I showed how little you know about it.
:geekdanc:
-
You were more than happy to engage in the baseline budgeting discussion until I showed how little you know about it.
Why should that be any surprise to you?
Unlike you, who purports to know more than anyone else on this forum; I have very strong views, but am a very open-minded eternal scholar humble to learn things I know very little.
-
Why should that be any surprise to you?
Unlike you, who purports to know more than anyone else on this forum; I have very strong views, but am a very open-minded eternal scholar humble to learn things I know very little.
In your DREAMS! :sleeping:
-
Trump delivers remarks as USNS Comfort embarks for NY
https://youtu.be/tbtLrjxRGuQ
-
Trump delivers remarks as USNS Comfort embarks for NY
https://youtu.be/tbtLrjxRGuQ
:sleeping:
Two ships?
Too little too late....
:sleeping:
-
With fears of an impending global depression spoken now by both academic and so-called mainstream economists, it is imperative that the US begin scaling back not only in military spending, but also in its military presence around the globe.
America will need all what remains of its financial resources in not only maintaining the public order and trying to restart economic activity, but EVERY SOLDIER available to PREVENT a domestic communistic revolution as well as PROTECT its southern borders from the hoards of migrants and organized crime syndicates that will rush in-mass to establish a new home in the US.
The domestic situation in the US is headed to what looks like a combination of Russia in 1917 and Germany in the 1920s.
-
:sleeping:
Two ships?
Too little too late....
:sleeping:
Based on your vast experience? :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
I've been aboard the USNS Mercy on it's way to assist the Malaysia tsunami recovery. The platform is massive -- formerly built as an oil tanker.
If you BOTHERED to watch the video, the ships are being deployed to take the overflow of non-CV patients, allowing the ashore hospitals to treat CV patients. That adds the benefit of keeping uninfected patients apart from the possibly/verified infected.
You hate the military. You have only negatives to say no matter what they do. You appear to have a "military variant" of TDS (MDS?).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USNS_Mercy_(T-AH-19)
-
Veterans are uniquely qualified to help during COVID-19 crisis: Goldberg
https://youtu.be/Q5C2OPwAiSc
-
"If you BOTHERED to watch the video, the ships are being deployed to take the overflow of non-CV patients, allowing the ashore hospitals to treat CV patients. That adds the benefit of keeping uninfected patients apart from the possibly/verified infected."
I am not saying it will not help; I am saying such deployment is TOO LITTLE TOO LATE.
Why did it take so long for this decision? The US already leads the way in infections and headed to lead the way in deaths.
Once more, why only two ships?
Why not TAKE every available ship in the Seventh Fleet currently making stink-face to the Chinese in the South China Sea and REPURPOSE them similarly to aid infected Americans on the West Coast?
"You hate the military. You have only negatives to say no matter what they do. You appear to have a "military variant" of TDS (MDS?)."
I do not hate the military per se; I hate what the US military has become... An overbudgeted global police force to govern the declining American Empire and intimidate its enemies.
So useless to an American's daily life, except for the war hawks and the military industrial complex, it has accumulated so much tax payer monies for decades, which left no emergency funds to combat the worst medical and economic disasters in recent US history.
-
With fears of an impending global depression spoken now by both academic and so-called mainstream economists, it is imperative that the US begin scaling back not only in military spending, but also in its military presence around the globe.
America will need all what remains of its financial resources in not only maintaining the public order and trying to restart economic activity, but EVERY SOLDIER available to PREVENT a domestic communistic revolution as well as PROTECT its southern borders from the hoards of migrants and organized crime syndicates that will rush in-mass to establish a new home in the US.
The domestic situation in the US is headed to what looks like a combination of Russia in 1917 and Germany in the 1920s.
Military cannot be used Domestically. "Posse Comitatus"
If military were available for Domestic use I doubt
the Democrat Party would exist today.
Lincoln made a mistake by not wiping that party out permanently.
Most military guys aren't Commies or Socialists.
We were trained to accomplish a mission. Given the skills to do it,
but not always all the tools to get a job done.
The MIC isn't the problem. Democrats that infest and run the Government are.
That is what Eisenhower warned about but was too good a politician
to say Democrat IC. I guess that would be DICs to use military
acronyms.
-
"If you BOTHERED to watch the video, the ships are being deployed to take the overflow of non-CV patients, allowing the ashore hospitals to treat CV patients. That adds the benefit of keeping uninfected patients apart from the possibly/verified infected."
I am not saying it will not help; I am saying such deployment is TOO LITTLE TOO LATE.
Why did it take so long for this decision? The US already leads the way in infections and headed to lead the way in deaths.
Once more, why only two ships?
Why not TAKE every available ship in the Seventh Fleet currently making stink-face to the Chinese in the South China Sea and REPURPOSE them similarly to aid infected Americans on the West Coast?
"You hate the military. You have only negatives to say no matter what they do. You appear to have a "military variant" of TDS (MDS?)."
I do not hate the military per se; I hate what the US military has become... An overbudgeted global police force to govern the declining American Empire and intimidate its enemies.
So useless to an American's daily life, except for the war hawks and the military industrial complex, it has accumulated so much tax payer monies for decades, which left no emergency funds to combat the worst medical and economic disasters in recent US history.
"So useless to an American's daily life, except for the war hawks and the military industrial complex, it has accumulated so much tax payer monies for decades, which left no emergency funds to combat the worst medical and economic disasters in recent US history."
How many years did Democrats run this show? How are we paying now?
Don't blame the military, blame the guys you voted for, for your entire life.
-
"So useless to an American's daily life, except for the war hawks and the military industrial complex, it has accumulated so much tax payer monies for decades, which left no emergency funds to combat the worst medical and economic disasters in recent US history."
How many years did Democrats run this show? How are we paying now?
Don't blame the military, blame the guys you voted for, for your entire life.
I am NO FAN of any Democrat, but would have a Republican led government not allocate insane amounts of tax dollars to the military as well?
-
I am NO FAN of any Democrat, but would have a Republican led government not allocate insane amounts of tax dollars to the military as well?
Point taken. I can't speak for what may have been, but most Federal Military dollars flow to states with Democrat Senators.
Very curious.
-
Why did it take so long for this decision? The US already leads the way in infections and headed to lead the way in deaths.
Perhaps because the STATE GOVERNORS have to ask for help? Remember Katrina, when the STATE refused FEMA assistance until things deteriorated and the press wanted someone to blame? They blamed Bush, even though he had trucks of supplies at the border for days waiting on permission to cross into Louisiana,
The Feds can't force a state to accept assistance. Nor can any of them peer into a crystal ball and predict the extent of the infection rates.
In case you are wondering WHY NEW YORK is such a hot zone, they are (1) the most densely populated city in the nation, and (2) In Feb and Mar, the local leaders were telling everyone not to worry, to ride the subways and buses, and to attend the upcoming parade.
But, "Orange man bad"? :sleeping:
Once more, why only two ships?
Because we only have 2 hospital ships. Each ship provides 1,000 additional beds as well as medicines, supplies, healthcare workers and the INFRASTRUCTURE to sustain all of that. Ships require resources to dock and provide power for lighting and equipment. The workers have to have places to eat, sleep, and shower.
These two ships are floating cities, capable of sustaining the mission they support. They are the only two we have in our fleet.
Now, maybe if people would tell their elected officials to INCREASE MILITARY SPENDING, we could have more of these? :thumbsup: :rofl:
I do not hate the military per se; I hate what the US military has become...
A distinction without a difference.
-
"Why did it take so long for this decision? The US already leads the way in infections and headed to lead the way in deaths"
I'm amazed you believe that fake news. China still leads the world in cases.
They've been reported to have buried the dead with NO TESTING DONE to identify if they had the virus, many of whom were suspect cases.
They changed their criteria for reporting cases -- only those who show symptoms, even though they tested positive, are included.
When a Socialist country reports on ANYTHING that has the potential to make them look bad, you can bet the books have been cooked.
As for the US having such a high number of cases, look to the high-density populations in NY and CA, where they already have a huge problem with dysentery, typhoid and hepatitis due to the abysmal conditions on their streets caused by their homeless population and lack of government action to take care of the problem.
If a city is breeding diseases already, what makes you think they won't be ground zero in the nation for a pandemic?
Once again, it's a state issue, not a federal one. Not Trump's job to do the governors' jobs for them.
-
"I'm amazed you believe that fake news. China still leads the world in cases. They've been reported to have buried the dead with NO TESTING DONE to identify if they had the virus, many of whom were suspect cases.
They changed their criteria for reporting cases -- only those who show symptoms, even though they tested positive, are included. When a Socialist country reports on ANYTHING that has the potential to make them look bad, you can bet the books have been cooked."
I did not know you have high level top secret clearance in China as well to be able to make such accusations and conclusions. :worship:
What you shared is nothing but pure speculation underscored by your evident biased hatred of China.
"As for the US having such a high number of cases, look to the high-density populations in NY and CA, where they already have a huge problem with dysentery, typhoid and hepatitis due to the abysmal conditions on their streets caused by their homeless population and lack of government action to take care of the problem.
Once again, it's a state issue, not a federal one. Not Trump's job to do the governors' jobs for them."
Though technically one could argue that it is a state issue, it does not hide the fact that the US at the federal level was/is still not prepared to handle this pandemic crisis that can be attributed to the lack of funds that military budget gobbled up. :grrr:
-
I am not saying it will not help; I am saying such deployment is TOO LITTLE TOO LATE.
Why did it take so long for this decision? The US already leads the way in infections and headed to lead the way in deaths.
Once more, why only two ships?
hey genius, check the date on the story...
https://www.mcclatchydc.com/news/coronavirus/article241303776.html
and there are only 2 hospital ships to send...
-
"Nor can any of them peer into a crystal ball and predict the extent of the infection rates."
They can't tell the future, but the federal government CAN ensure emergency funds be hoarded to combat future viral outbreaks by scaling back its outrageously bloated military spending. ;)
"Now, maybe if people would tell their elected officials to INCREASE MILITARY SPENDING, we could have more of these?"
Or people can tell their elected officials to SPEND LESS on warships and MORE hospital/medical ships for the US Navy and Coast Guard. :D
-
"I'm amazed you believe that fake news. China still leads the world in cases. They've been reported to have buried the dead with NO TESTING DONE to identify if they had the virus, many of whom were suspect cases.
They changed their criteria for reporting cases -- only those who show symptoms, even though they tested positive, are included. When a Socialist country reports on ANYTHING that has the potential to make them look bad, you can bet the books have been cooked."
I did not know you have high level top secret clearance in China as well to be able to make such accusations and conclusions. :worship:
What you shared is nothing but pure speculation underscored by your evident biased hatred of China.
"As for the US having such a high number of cases, look to the high-density populations in NY and CA, where they already have a huge problem with dysentery, typhoid and hepatitis due to the abysmal conditions on their streets caused by their homeless population and lack of government action to take care of the problem.
Once again, it's a state issue, not a federal one. Not Trump's job to do the governors' jobs for them."
Though technically one could argue that it is a state issue, it does not hide the fact that the US at the federal level was/is still not prepared to handle this pandemic crisis that can be attributed to the lack of funds that military budget gobbled up. :grrr:
Obama cut the military's funding by 1/3 through sequestration.
Obama also cut the CDC and NHS budgets.
So, the premise that cutting the military budget will guarantee more health care spending for emergencies is false.
BTW, Trump increased BOTH military FEMA and CDC spending. Do some research.
-
"Nor can any of them peer into a crystal ball and predict the extent of the infection rates."
They can't tell the future, but the federal government CAN ensure emergency funds be hoarded to combat future viral outbreaks by scaling back its outrageously bloated military spending. ;)
"Now, maybe if people would tell their elected officials to INCREASE MILITARY SPENDING, we could have more of these?"
Or people can tell their elected officials to SPEND LESS on warships and MORE hospital/medical ships for the US Navy and Coast Guard. :D
The military's primary mission is to make war, not perform humanitarian aid.
If you want more equipment for the latter, then the budget needs to be increased for that, not reduced for the primary mission.
-
hey genius, check the date on the story...
https://www.mcclatchydc.com/news/coronavirus/article241303776.html
and there are only 2 hospital ships to send...
Hey Dr. Open Mouth, I already knew that when Trump did his speech.
If you read my responses to the resident intelligence informant, I asked that question as a springboard to point out that there are many other ships in the US Navy that could be retrofitted and serve similar functions to help those infected on the West Coast.
-
"Obama cut the military's funding by 1/3 through sequestration. Obama also cut the CDC and NHS budgets. So, the premise that cutting the military budget will guarantee more health care spending for emergencies is false."
No, that does not prove anything. America's military spending under Obongo still shadowed the military spending by Russia and China combined. Hence, America was still spending too much on the military.
"BTW, Trump increased BOTH military FEMA and CDC spending. Do some research."
Well, obviously, Trump did not give enough to the CDC. Trump should have DECREASED the military spending and GAVE a better Christmas gift to FEMA and the CDC.
-
Hey Dr. Open Mouth, I already knew that when Trump did his speech.
If you read my responses to the resident intelligence informant, I asked that question as a springboard to point out that there are many other ships in the US Navy that could be retrofitted and serve similar functions to help those infected on the West Coast.
"Retrofitter" is not a minor task when the design is for weapons and electronics, not a sterile operating room, 1,000 patient beds, bunks for support and medical personnel, etc.
The Mercy and Comfort were former oil tankers, because they didn't have lots of internal compartments and systems already running throughout.
Naval resources are tight, mainly because the ships and aircraft require massive amounts of time and money to maintain and upgrade them.
These are not cars you buy and take care of for 10 years, then go out and buy a new one. The Mercy was launched in 1975, Most of the staff on her are younger than the ship.
-
Hey Dr. Open Mouth, I already knew that when Trump did his speech.
If you read my responses to the resident intelligence informant, I asked that question as a springboard to point out that there are many other ships in the US Navy that could be retrofitted and serve similar functions to help those infected on the West Coast.
that's not what you said, you said "too little, too late" and "why did it take so long"
it took so long because they had to go from where they were to NY and LA
he made the decision long ago and they got there as quickly as they could
so neither of your statements are true
nor did you ever indicate until after the fact that you knew all along that he made the decision 10 days ago
sounds like your statement that you knew all along is "too little, too late"
-
The military's primary mission is to make war, not perform humanitarian aid.
If you want more equipment for the latter, then the budget needs to be increased for that, not reduced for the primary mission.
That's the point!
With the level the US has been spending on the military, you would think it was at war with a military peer. However, it has not been at war with a military peer since the 20th century. Hence, it is FLAT OUT spending money it does not have, while siphoning off financial resources away domestically where it would do much more good, as evident with the current pandemic and economic crises.
-
"Retrofitter" is not a minor task when the design is for weapons and electronics, not a sterile operating room, 1,000 patient beds, bunks for support and medical personnel, etc.
The Mercy and Comfort were former oil tankers, because they didn't have lots of internal compartments and systems already running throughout.
Naval resources are tight, mainly because the ships and aircraft require massive amounts of time and money to maintain and upgrade them.
These are not cars you buy and take care of for 10 years, then go out and buy a new one. The Mercy was launched in 1975, Most of the staff on her are younger than the ship.
When a nation is in distress, the leader must make do with what he has. If he has other ships of war that is not currently making war, those resources should be utilized for the GREATER GOOD. :thumbsup:
If Trump transformed the Seventh Fleet into a medical fleet of mercy for infected Americans on the West Coast, he would GUARANTEE HIS REELECTION for the next two terms! :geekdanc:
-
That's the point!
With the level the US has been spending on the military, you would think it was at war with a military peer. However, it has not been at war with a military peer since the 20th century. Hence, it is FLAT OUT spending money it does not have, while siphoning off financial resources away domestically where it would do much more good, as evident with the current pandemic and economic crises.
When you take funds from the military, the number of personnel, the quality of the equipment, and the ability of the private sector that helps train and equip the military are all diminished.
When the flag goes up, if you aren't ready to deploy because we cut back on maintenance, training and other vital mission tasks, it takes TIME and EVEN MORE MONEY to restart that "machine."
Imagine a boxer being in retirement for 10 years, only to be invited to a championship fight in a month against an opponent who's been winning fights the past 4 years.. Good luck getting back into shape and having any chance of winning.
-
"When you take funds from the military, the number of personnel, the quality of the equipment, and the ability of the private sector that helps train and equip the military are all diminished."
Wait a minute. Isn't what the military says to lure recruits is that they can learn a skill that they can market to employers once they get out and into the private sector? :wtf:
"When the flag goes up, if you aren't ready to deploy because we cut back on maintenance, training and other vital mission tasks, it takes TIME and EVEN MORE MONEY to restart that "machine."
This is true if you are planning to fight a 20th century style war in the 21st century. :crazy:
War in the 21st century is headed towards smart missiles, cyber attacks, and un-maned war machines, if you have not noticed. :wacko:
The age of massed invasions and the flight of bomber in mass formations like what was done up till the Gulf War is history against a military peer today.
-
Yup. Just go ahead and “transform the 7th fleet”... Go and make that demand of the 7th Fleet Commander and the Pacific Fleet Commander. I’ll give you the PACFLT Commander’s email and work phone. Hell, even his cell phone... :rofl:
:facepalm:
From someone who knows nothing about military budgeting or appropriations. Wants installations that he “knows” are there shut down, without even knowing what function they serve. Whose irrational fear of military capability in Hawaii and Pacific and that they need to be cut, without knowing what they are.
-
Yup. Just go ahead and “transform the 7th fleet”... Go and make that demand of the 7th Fleet Commander and the Pacific Fleet Commander. I’ll give you the PACFLT Commander’s email and work phone. Hell, even his cell phone... :rofl:
:facepalm:
From someone who knows nothing about military budgeting or appropriations. Wants installations that he “knows” are there shut down, without even knowing what function they serve. Whose irrational fear of military capability in Hawaii and Pacific and that they need to be cut, without knowing what they are.
Yes; I am NOT an expert with the obviously over bloated and over complicated military budgeting.
What I do know is that many Americans are currently SUFFERING AND DYING with that number to get even worse.
Under those conditions, I challenge anyone to LOOK INTO THE FACES of those families whose loved ones already are or are about to physically or economically suffer and TELL THEM that maintaining US bases and navies in the Asian-Pacific region to police the World has first priority over Americans' lives back home.
-
lack of any arguments only emotional response. Look at victims families, people suffering and dying. UNDERLINE and BOLD..etc if anyone not Hawaiian mentions anything Hawaiian and you throw down the race card
You said it yourself...you don't know anything about govt spending...so why keep digging that hole? trying to go to Wuhan?
We got it already.
You hate the United States. You hate the U.S. military and anything associated with it. The vinyl is worn out. You need new tech...stream it. SoundCloud or something...
-
lack of any arguments only emotional response. Look at victims families...etc..you said it yourself...you don't know anything about govt spending...so why keep digging that hole? trying to go to Wuhan?
We got it already.
You hate the United States. You hate the U.S. military and anything associated with it.
Yup. Wants to make decisions based on emotion as opposed to rational and logical thought/planning.
No mention of execs of the healthcare industry nor administrators of the hospitals and medical centers.
But I’ll stop. Don’t want to cause further distress...
-
You hate the United States. You hate the U.S. military and anything associated with it. The vinyl is worn out. You need new tech...stream it. SoundCloud or something...
Why don't you go buy some fried chicken at Popeyes. :stopjack:
-
"Yup. Wants to make decisions based on emotion as opposed to rational and logical thought/planning."
That's the best rebuttal you can make?
Why not share your views on how the current crisis Americans are facing will get better by not scaling back military spending? That would be more productive and I would love to hear it.
Knowing America is spending too much on the military and not enough domestically is clearly visible right now. No one denies how huge the military budget is compared to other types of domestic items. I fail to see the emotion on my basic premise.
Could it be your distaste of my position be an emotional response of your own?
"No mention of execs of the healthcare industry nor administrators of the hospitals and medical centers."
What about those people you mentioned above?
-
This topic is played out. Thanks for discussing