2aHawaii

General Topics => Off Topic => Topic started by: Rocky on April 16, 2020, 03:35:42 PM

Title: The hard choice
Post by: Rocky on April 16, 2020, 03:35:42 PM
I see 3 options here.

1)    We all stay hunkered down for months till the economy goes totally to hell in which case we have a recession/depression and either resort to communism where the "Government takes care of us" or we go all go "what would you do to feed your family"  apocolyptic . In this scenario, folks will still go out but not for shopping or work as there is neither of either so they are looting and shooting and the virus will still be spread and people will become sick and get better/immune or die as the virus runs it's course. Hospitals and essential services including police, fire would be overwhelmed. Poverty also kills.           
Think Martial law

2)   Most of  us stay hunkered down while those who are immune, resistant, asymptomatic or only slightly ill go back to work in which case the economy will crawl, but it will still function though somewhat depressed. Folks will still go out and the virus will still be spread and people will become sick and get better/immune or die as the virus runs it's course but could/will be at a manageable pace.         
This is the option their (we're) looking at now, see China and others.

3)   Everybody continues with life as it was, going to work and play and the virus will be spread massively and many people will become sick and get better/immune or sick and die as the virus runs it's course. In this scenario, hospitals are overwhelmed, death is rampant but the economy is better off and nobody is starving or looting. See Sweden  and think chicken pox (if your old enough to remember "sharing  :rofl:")
   
     In all three scenarios, people will become sick and get better/immune or die as the virus runs it's course until you are dead or immune.                                    
PERIOD.                                           
Even if you could lock yourself in house for a year and stay fed and sane, when you left home, the virus would still be out there and you would become, yes, sick and get better/immune or die as the virus runs it's course.
It's either slowly bleed to death or rip off the bandage.
    And of course, it is the elderly who are at the bottom of the totem pole. 65+ with an underlying condition

But here's some interesting facts (from CDC and Census),

There are 52,346,789  people 65 and over in the U.S. on July 1, 2018. This age group accounts for 16 percent of the total U.S. population.

65%  of registered voters ages 65 to 74 voted in the 2002 Congressional election.
Seventy-two percent of people ages 65 to 74 voted in the 2000 presidential election. This age group had the highest rate of voter participation in both the 2000 and 2002 elections.
When over 50, 42 % vote left, 57% vote right

Total aged 65 and older on Social Security  49,958,000

4.6 million people age 65 and over  are still employed. This amounts to 13 percent of all people in this age group.

Medicare provides health coverage to more than 49 million Americans.
Fifteen percent of the nation’s population relies on Medicare for health security.
As baby boomers turn 65, enrollment will reach 64 million in 2020 and 80 million in 2030.
With increasing longevity, in 2011, one in four people receiving Medicare benefits were 80 years old or older

OVER 65 WITH CHRONIC CONDITION
1 CONDITION 85.6%   
2 CONDITION 56%   
3 CONDITION 23.1%

     If just the over 85. 6% of those 52,346,789 over 65 with 1 chronic condition died due to Corona, that would be 52,346,789 deaths

Social Security for 65+ would be cut from almost 50 million to just over 7 million
Take 54 million off of Medicare
Open up 4 million jobs
It would also balance the dem/rep split

 Consider these outcomes in your decision.
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: drck1000 on April 16, 2020, 04:05:23 PM
TLDR

Nah, nah.  I'll read closer later.

I saw reports of how in Hokkaido, they relaxed things and started trying to go back to normal.  Now they have a second outbreak and back to state of emergency.  From what I read, I see a lot more of that happening. 
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 16, 2020, 04:48:48 PM
We stay hunkered down, and Trump wins by a landslide.

With an economy on life support, who would the people trust to get it back on track?  The President who already proved he can do it, or a former VP who has a record of being on the wrong side of every issue his decades long career as a politician?

Obama waited to endorse Sleepy Joe after there were NO OTHER OPTIONS.  That's not an endorsement.  Just the opposite, in fact.   :rofl:

Staying a home might not prevent infection forever, but it makes the people needing care a manageable number -- as opposed to a mass infection overwhelming all the hospitals (as in LA and NYC).

Once the weather returns to Summer temps, this thing will hopefully become all but dormant, giving us a chance to find a cure/vaccine, and get our economic problems to start healing.
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Heavies on April 16, 2020, 06:17:28 PM
IMO, it's not a one two three option decision, and I think Trump is doing it right to have each state tailor a solution that fits that state's needs.


As for THIS state, I don't see why we cannot control incoming people and get everything else back to somewhat normal and release this lockdown, with emphasis on social distancing and personal hygiene.

There is already a better than 50% recovery rate, ruining everyone financially at this point is ridiculous to even contemplate.  It's the typical gun control narrative they are pushing here, scare tactics, and diminutive percentages to justify keeping the majority in lockdown. 

Test, monitor, and quarantine all incoming people for 14 days or whatever it's supposed to be, at their own expense.   Of course tourism and related industries will suffer the most, but the rest of us can resume life, AND it is the perfect opportunity to get off of tourism as a major source of state income. 
We live on islands, they should have done this from the very start!

We need new politicans that will accomplish this.  Reduce regulations and taxes to encourage other businesses, such as manufacturing, tech, and agriculture, to set up shop in this state.  Tourism needs to be just a side bang, not the only thing keeping us afloat.  That will make Hawaii a better place for all who  are citizens here. 




I voted option 2 since that is what most closely resembles my opinion, however, reality is, there is only option 3, because without a vaccine we will never be able to come out of lockdown.
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: ren on April 16, 2020, 07:15:48 PM
What next lockdown for influenza? mono?
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 17, 2020, 10:26:48 AM
I look at it this way, lets compare something that happens like clockwork every year.

Flu
2019 stats USA
35 mill infected
14 mill went to the hospital
400K in ICU
35K deaths
6 month period

So going based on that, why is CV shutting down the US?  And the above happens every year.  CV is new, but still why not see what happens this 1st year and then adjust later.  The economy is just as fragile as people getting sick.
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 17, 2020, 10:35:07 AM
I look at it this way, lets compare something that happens like clockwork every year.

Flu
2019 stats USA
35 mill infected
14 mill went to the hospital
400K in ICU
35K deaths
6 month period

So going based on that, why is CV shutting down the US?  And the above happens every year.  CV is new, but still why not see what happens this 1st year and then adjust later.  The economy is just as fragile as people getting sick.

#1 reason why CV is being handled differently than the flu:  it's NEW.

We had no idea what the infection rate would be, how easily it could be transmitted human to human (apparently very easily compared to the flu), what the death rate would be (10% +/- was the conservative guess based on models that weren't factoring in social distancing and isolation), and long term after effects once recovered (heart/lung problems, etc.).

Basically, they were dealing with an unknown disease.  In January 1918 – December 1920, the Spanish Flu infected about 25% of the world's population, or 500 million.  Approximately 50 million died from it.  That's a 10% death rate.

Nobody had any real information as to whether COVID-19 was as bad as, or worse than, Spanish Flu.
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: macsak on April 17, 2020, 10:39:43 AM
I look at it this way, lets compare something that happens like clockwork every year.

Flu
2019 stats USA
35 mill infected
14 mill went to the hospital
400K in ICU
35K deaths
6 month period

So going based on that, why is CV shutting down the US?  And the above happens every year.  CV is new, but still why not see what happens this 1st year and then adjust later.  The economy is just as fragile as people getting sick.

that's not how it works...
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: drck1000 on April 17, 2020, 10:45:27 AM
that's not how it works...
In his defense, that's sort of how evolution works. . . but I digress. . .  ;D
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: aieahound on April 17, 2020, 10:47:17 AM
CV-19 is latest effort of Nature/the Earth to thin the herd and control the locusts (read humans).

Economics is the Locusts trying to fight back.
We’re the only species who needs it and if it collapses this gets much worse (for us as humans, including my own family)

Nature will always try to find equilibrium.

And can’t go to Communism/Socialism with no production or taxes.

Am I willing to lose a kid to this....that’s where I pause.
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Rocky on April 17, 2020, 12:31:31 PM
IMO, it's not a one two three option decision,
I voted option 2 since that is what most closely resembles my opinion, however, reality is, there is only option 3, because without a vaccine we will never be able to come out of lockdown.
So you voted your feelings vs truth/reality ?  ::)


Quote from: macsak on Today at 10:39:43 AM

    that's not how it works...

It works the way whichever option is utilized.


Am I willing to lose a kid to this....that’s where I pause.
All valid points, but as children are less susceptible to CV, wouldn't option 3 be better for your child with less population, stabilize his SS and ease the health care burden ?
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Rocky on April 17, 2020, 12:34:35 PM
I'm not seeing a lot of comment regarding the "interesting facts" .
I probably also should have put in an option for age as I believe that may have a lot of influence on voters choice.  ::)
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 17, 2020, 12:37:45 PM
that's not how it works...

Make it work.  If it doesn't fit, put spit.
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Bota-CS1 on April 17, 2020, 01:08:50 PM
Make it work.  If it doesn't fit, put spit.

Keep your 💧💦 to yourself bruh 🤦🏻‍♂️ 😷
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: macsak on April 17, 2020, 01:47:05 PM
Keep your 💧💦 to yourself bruh 🤦🏻‍♂️ 😷

heads
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: mrgaf on April 17, 2020, 06:06:18 PM
Round up everyone 65+ and euthanize them.... soylent green is people..  ::)
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 17, 2020, 10:29:44 PM
Round up everyone 65+ and euthanize them.... soylent green is people..  ::)

You don't have to round them up.  Create euthanasia centers, make life unbearable and they will come willingly.
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Rocky on April 18, 2020, 07:43:56 AM
You don't have to round them up.  Create euthanasia centers, make life unbearable and they will come willingly.
Or just use option 3.
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: mrgaf on April 18, 2020, 08:27:50 AM
You don't have to round them up.  Create euthanasia centers, make life unbearable and they will come willingly.

Lemme know when they open up.... Since I’m 70, I’ll go willingly...... gotta be better than this on the other side... :D
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 18, 2020, 02:03:53 PM
Lemme know when they open up.... Since I’m 70, I’ll go willingly...... gotta be better than this on the other side... :D

https://youtu.be/yOV8mBjHHYg

I think he made that decision primarily because he couldn't live in a world where people ate other people.

Or maybe he just wanted to add himself to the food chain -- for the good of humanity?   :shake:
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Rocky on April 18, 2020, 02:27:35 PM
 :stopjack:
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Rocky on April 21, 2020, 11:16:04 AM
Vote count so far
 OP 1)  1
OP 2)   4 
OP 3) 10
With 15 votes and from what I think I know of the 9 posters, majority of posters in the +55 age bracket and therefore majority of option 3 votes.
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Kuleana on April 21, 2020, 12:03:56 PM
The global economy is in a recession and is currently headed to a path of global depression.  The lone exogenous independent factor that caused this situation is Covid-19; a disease that the human species has never seen nor have any natural immunity.  The hope of returning the global economy to more or less what it was prior to the pandemic primarily depends how fast the planet can develop and implement a safe and reliable vaccine.  From current indications, we can not expect that to happen until sometime next year at the earliest and if we are lucky.

Given these realities, keeping the economy shut down, except for so-called "essential services" is controlled economic suicide, making a global depression inevitable.  An uncontrolled opening of the economy would yield the quickest results in averting an economic depression, at least for some parts of the US, but will run the risk of additional infections, potentially overburdening an ill-supplied American medical response system, and widespread fatalities amongst those most vulnerable to Covid-19.

Given the two opposing lines of thought in the spectrum, the only realistic choice is some version of Option 2.  We have to remember that the US economy is plugged in to the global economy and whatever decision made by the US MUST be more or less in line with what plan and at what stage the rest of the economies of the World are in and have decided to do.  With additional catastrophic human and economic consequences potentially resulting from a misalignment of the decision by every nation to reopen the global economy, some version of Option 2 is the only choice that will allow the US and any other country the flexibility to make their own short-term decisions to what's in the best interest for their people.
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: groveler on April 21, 2020, 12:04:14 PM
Vote count so far
 OP 1)  1
OP 2)   4 
OP 3) 10
With 15 votes and from what I think I know of the 9 posters, majority of posters in the +55 age bracket and therefore majority of option 3 votes.
I just added my vote.
I turn 65 this year.
#3.
I'm not afraid of this virus nor do I like the Tyranny
being imposed on me by Democrats.
The only silver lining is they are committing economic suicide,
and I can just stand by and watch.
This probably won't change Hawaii politics, much,
but if it cuts the government, their cops, and taxes, I'm all for it.






Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: groveler on April 21, 2020, 12:13:41 PM
The global economy is in a recession and is currently headed to a path of global depression.  The lone exogenous independent factor that caused this situation is Covid-19; a disease that the human species has never seen nor have any natural immunity.  The hope of returning the global economy to more or less what it was prior to the pandemic primarily depends how fast the planet can develop and implement a safe and reliable vaccine.  From current indications, we can not expect that to happen until sometime next year at the earliest and if we are lucky.

Given these realities, keeping the economy shut down, except for so-called "essential services" is controlled economic suicide, making a global depression inevitable.  An uncontrolled opening of the economy would yield the quickest results in averting an economic depression, at least for some parts of the US, but will run the risk of additional infections, potentially overburdening an ill-supplied American medical response system, and widespread fatalities amongst those most vulnerable to Covid-19.

Given the two opposing lines of thought in the spectrum, the only realistic choice is some version of Option 2.  We have to remember that the US economy is plugged in to the global economy and whatever decision made by the US MUST be more or less in line with what plan and at what stage the rest of the economies of the World are in and have decided to do.  With additional catastrophic human and economic consequences potentially resulting from a misalignment of the decision by every nation to reopen the global economy, some version of Option 2 is the only choice that will allow the US and any other country the flexibility to make their own short-term decisions to what's in the best interest for their people.
I no longer have to work with Liberals, so I
can take a strong stand for my beliefs.
I'd rather be free and dead, than a slave
and alive.
It is one of the advantages of being an old man.
We aren't as afraid of death as much as we
were when we were 18 year old soldiers.
That is why you "never pick a fight with an old man
he'll just kill you".

Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Kuleana on April 21, 2020, 12:15:45 PM
I no longer have to work with Liberals, so I
can take a strong stand for my beliefs.
I'd rather be free and dead, than a slave
and alive.
It is one of the advantages of being an old man.
We aren't as afraid of death as much as we
were when we were 18 year old soldiers.
That is why you "never pick a fight with an old man
he'll just kill you".

My dad and uncles would all agree with you.
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Rocky on April 22, 2020, 11:01:48 AM
    Option 2 is NOT the only "Realistic" choice and the US is NOT necessarily susceptible to the economic choices of the rest of the world.
As posted, wouldn't  Option 3 not only reduce Social Security by 70%, reduce Medicare beneficiaries by 80%, open up some 4 million primarily non-physically labor intensive jobs and open up not only housing but the housing market ?
   
    Without these burdens and newly created opportunities, wouldn't the US become stronger and with opening the economy by getting back to work ahead of all others, would we not have a gigantic head start on all other nations who are still in options 1 or 2 ?

    I can only guess at some of the age of posters voting, but can definitely see the majority voting for option 3 are in the 55+ age bracket.
Realist's, Fathers, Patriots or Suicidal Senile ?

(http://i.imgur.com/TDUG78n.jpg?1) (https://imgur.com/TDUG78n)
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Wchiro on April 22, 2020, 11:09:01 AM
I look at it this way, lets compare something that happens like clockwork every year.

Flu
2019 stats USA
35 mill infected
14 mill went to the hospital
400K in ICU
35K deaths
6 month period

So going based on that, why is CV shutting down the US?  And the above happens every year.  CV is new, but still why not see what happens this 1st year and then adjust later.  The economy is just as fragile as people getting sick.


The Dems and the Fake News keep pushing how bad the CV is.  They doctor the numbers (if death was due to say a car accident but they have virus they count it as death by CV) so they can push fear and reinforce their push for"Mail in Voting" because it's easy to manipulate.  Think voter fraud so they can steal the election.  Hawaii is Dem controlled and what do we have "Mail in Voting", no ID to verify who is voting or mailed in ballots are mysteriously delayed or missing.


Watch this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lsRay1wInBg
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Kuleana on April 22, 2020, 11:48:40 AM
    Option 2 is NOT the only "Realistic" choice and the US is NOT necessarily susceptible to the economic choices of the rest of the world.
As posted, wouldn't  Option 3 not only reduce Social Security by 70%, reduce Medicare beneficiaries by 80%, open up some 4 million primarily non-physically labor intensive jobs and open up not only housing but the housing market ?
   
    Without these burdens and newly created opportunities, wouldn't the US become stronger and with opening the economy by getting back to work ahead of all others, would we not have a gigantic head start on all other nations who are still in options 1 or 2 ?

    I can only guess at some of the age of posters voting, but can definitely see the majority voting for option 3 are in the 55+ age bracket.
Realist's, Fathers, Patriots or Suicidal Senile ?

(http://i.imgur.com/TDUG78n.jpg?1) (https://imgur.com/TDUG78n)

That's all potentially true.

The only problem is the fact that the majority of the US has undertaken shut downs, mask use, and socials distancing, whose effects have yet to be comprehensively analyzed and determined what part it played, if any, with the reduced infection and death numbers that most computer models predicted from a county/city, state, region, and nationwide level.

Until a reliable and valid investigation is conducted, an option 3 approach or returning to business as usual with no restrictions might lead to unwarranted consequences that no one really knows.
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Rocky on April 23, 2020, 07:10:59 AM
That's all potentially true.
The only problem is the fact that the majority of the US has undertaken shut downs, mask use, and socials distancing, whose effects have yet to be comprehensively analyzed and determined what part it played, if any, with the reduced infection and death numbers that most computer models predicted from a county/city, state, region, and nationwide level.
These "models" have already been  "analyzed" and "determined" to be 80%  incorrect from the original "models" which  predicted deaths of millions WITH preventative measures

Until a reliable and valid investigation is conducted, an option 3 2 approach or returning to business as usual with no restrictions might also lead to unwarranted consequences that no one really knows,

Option 3 lays out VERY probable results based on facts which show definite benefits, aside from a quicker, yet ultimately predicted death count in option  2.
Option 1 has way too many variables but would definitely be a worse outcome than options 2 or 3.

  Again, look at Sweden
And of course and as usual in your Beto-esque style, you did not answer  questions.
  :rofl:
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Kuleana on April 23, 2020, 08:20:04 AM
These "models" have already been  "analyzed" and "determined" to be 80%  incorrect from the original "models" which  predicted deaths of millions WITH preventative measures

Any model that is introduced is just a theoretical model that needs to be measured against empirical evidence.  Thus far, I agree that those original models has proven largely inaccurate.  However, just because those models failed to accurately predict an outcome, that does not summarily conclude that an Option 3 approach is the way to go.



Option 3 lays out VERY probable results based on facts which show definite benefits, aside from a quicker, yet ultimately predicted death count in option  2.
Option 1 has way too many variables but would definitely be a worse outcome than options 2 or 3.


What are these facts you reference?  Are these facts based on the empirical findings of the Covid-19 situation in a state in the US, nationwide, some other countries, or the entire World.   The reason I ask is because Covid-19 is a virus the human species has never encountered before; hence, it would be premature and dangerous to think that those wanting for a rapid Option 3 type reopening of the economy can make any DEFINITIVE conclusions about the causes, symptoms, short/long term effects, treatments, and preventive measures at this time.



Again, look at Sweden

Yes, I agree.  Their situation is a unique one, whose empirical results must be studied and analyzed.  We need to see whether their geographic location, weather patterns, homogeneity of their population, social interaction norms, overall health and wellness, rates of poverty, and etc. had anything to do with the current results in that nation before using their situation as proof for an Option 3 type decision for anywhere else. 



And of course and as usual in your Beto-esque style, you did not answer  questions.

Your opinion.

Are you a medical researcher by the way?

Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: groveler on April 23, 2020, 09:43:13 AM

"These "models" have already been  "analyzed" and "determined" to be 80%  incorrect from the original "models" which  predicted deaths of millions WITH preventative measures"
I have written models.  They are always wrong!
Any professional in the software business will tell you that.
Do you know why they have three computers on most modern fly by wire aircraft?
Reliability is one reason, they give you to make you trust computer control of an aircraft,
the other is they often come up with different answers
for the same inputs, so they "vote".  An agreement of two wins and the third
computer result is ignored. Public isn't told that very often.
That is on an aircraft with calibrated instrumentation.

What happens when some grad student or Post Doc PhD
starts to write an algorithm based on imperfect data?
Their model will be wrong!
Go with #3.
Let the world work as it always has.
Millennia of experience should not
be co-opted by politics of 21st century
Democrats.





Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Rocky on April 23, 2020, 10:02:52 AM

These "models" have already been  "analyzed" and "determined" to be 80%  less than the original "models" which  predicted deaths of millions WITH preventative measures           
Those models do not "summarily conclude that" the Option 2 "approach is the way to go" either.
I never stated Option 3 was the way to go but was rebutting your statement that "  the only realistic choice is some version of Option 2." and "some version of Option 2 is the only choice".         
Option 3 lays out VERY probable results based on facts which show definite benefits, aside from a quicker, yet ultimately predicted death count in option  2.
Option 1 has way too many variables but would definitely be a worse outcome than options 2 or 3.
[/b]

Facts are are not empirical and are based upon current and historical CDC, SS, and Medicare research as well as current Covid-19  actual  EXISTING US infection, hospitalization and deaths records.

Covid -19 is only the latest of Covid viruses and your above opinion of reopening of the economy would be the same for option 2

Again, look at Sweden

Their situation is not unique, Brazil is doing the same and has similar results. Both countries appear to have "peaked" in infections and deaths. Sweden's population of about 10.2 million — has seen 15,322 cases and 1,765 deaths from the virus so far, making the death rate per capita at 17.3 deaths per 100,000.  As for geographic location,  Sweden recorded more than 4,000 cases and 146 deaths with it's "open" system  compared to Denmark's 2,555 cases and 77 deaths, and Norway's 4,300 cases and 31 deaths, both who lockdown. Denmark and Norway have similar populations of around 5 million; Sweden's is twice that.
These numbers back up my "facts" regarding death count
And of course and as usual in your Beto-esque style, you did not answer  questions.

Previously schooled, trained and employed as Biomedical Engineer in hemotologic environments

Again (and as usual  :rofl:)  you did not answer my questions.
I've answered yours, give me the courtesy to  answer mine.

Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Heavies on April 23, 2020, 10:07:56 AM
Any model that is introduced is just a theoretical model that needs to be measured against empirical evidence.  Thus far, I agree that those original models has proven largely inaccurate.  However, just because those models failed to accurately predict an outcome, that does not summarily conclude that an Option 3 approach is the way to go.
These "models" have already been  "analyzed" and "determined" to be 80%  less than the original "models" which  predicted deaths of millions WITH preventative measures           
Those models do not "summarily conclude that" the Option 2 "approach is the way to go" either.
I never stated Option 3 was the way to go but was rebutting your statement that "  the only realistic choice is some version of Option 2." and "some version of Option 2 is the only choice".         
Option 3 lays out VERY probable results based on facts which show definite benefits, aside from a quicker, yet ultimately predicted death count in option  2.
Option 1 has way too many variables but would definitely be a worse outcome than options 2 or 3.
[/b]

What are these facts you reference?  Are these facts based on the empirical findings of the Covid-19 situation in a state in the US, nationwide, some other countries, or the entire World. 
Facts are are not empirical and are based upon current and historical CDC, SS, and Medicare research as well as current Covid-19  actual  EXISTINGUS infection, hospitalization and deaths records.

The reason I ask is because Covid-19 is a virus the human species has never encountered before; hence, it would be premature and dangerous to think that those wanting for a rapid Option 3 type reopening of the economy can make any DEFINITIVE conclusions about the causes, symptoms, short/long term effects, treatments, and preventive measures at this time.
Covid -19 is only the latest of Covid viruses and your above opinion of reopening of the economy would be the same for option 2

Again, look at Sweden

Yes, I agree.  Their situation is a unique one, whose empirical results must be studied and analyzed.  We need to see whether their geographic location, weather patterns, homogeneity of their population, social interaction norms, overall health and wellness, rates of poverty, and etc. had anything to do with the current results in that nation before using their situation as proof for an Option 3 type decision for anywhere else. 
Their situation is not unique, Brazil is doing the same and has similar results. Both countries appear to have "peaked" in infections and deaths. Sweden's population of about 10.2 million — has seen 15,322 cases and 1,765 deaths from the virus so far, making the death rate per capita at 17.3 deaths per 100,000.  As for geographic location,  Sweden recorded more than 4,000 cases and 146 deaths with it's "open" system  compared to Denmark's 2,555 cases and 77 deaths, and Norway's 4,300 cases and 31 deaths, both who lockdown. Denmark and Norway have similar populations of around 5 million; Sweden's is twice that.
These numbers back up my "facts" regarding death count


And of course and as usual in your Beto-esque style, you did not answer  questions
.
Your opinion.

Are you a medical researcher by the way?
Yes, was previously schooled, trained and employed as Biomedical Engineer in hemotologic environments

Again (and as usual  :rofl:)  you did not answer my questions.
I've answered yours, give me the courtesy to  answer mine.



Only thing we know for certain is the the "experts" are not really experts and know nothing.  Everyone pays for their decisions and recommendations.  Only thing to do is stick with what we know works, which is life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Kuleana on April 23, 2020, 10:58:53 AM
"Facts are are not empirical and are based upon current and historical CDC, SS, and Medicare research as well as current Covid-19  actual  EXISTINGUS infection, hospitalization and deaths records."

That is the point I am trying to make; all those numbers you cite is still being accumulated.  I understand there may never be perfect information to base a decision, but the World is not at the end of Covid-19 pandemic; therefore, whatever decision in this matter should not be made too hasty.  That is all I am saying.



"Their situation is not unique, Brazil is doing the same and has similar results. Both countries appear to have "peaked" in infections and deaths. Sweden's population of about 10.2 million — has seen 15,322 cases and 1,765 deaths from the virus so far, making the death rate per capita at 17.3 deaths per 100,000.  As for geographic location,  Sweden recorded more than 4,000 cases and 146 deaths with it's "open" system  compared to Denmark's 2,555 cases and 77 deaths, and Norway's 4,300 cases and 31 deaths, both who lockdown. Denmark and Norway have similar populations of around 5 million; Sweden's is twice that.
These numbers back up my "facts" regarding death count"

That's great information to know.  However, I did mention other variables that should be considered.  Is there any existing information to this effect?

You also mention death count.  What other metrics are you using to base your decision in this matter?



"Yes, was previously schooled, trained and employed as Biomedical Engineer in hemotologic environments"

That's great.  I am a trained and practicing economist specializing in econometric modeling and applied statistics.

From one researcher to another then, what were the theoretical underpinnings and/or assumptions you saw in the failed Covid-19 projection models and what factors should have the models incorporated to perform more accurately?



"Again (and as usual  )  you did not answer my questions.
I've answered yours, give me the courtesy to  answer mine."

Forgive me.  What was your question again?
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Rocky on April 23, 2020, 03:36:07 PM
I based my post on currently known facts, not what future numbers may assumed to be.  :geekdanc:    Information available on internet, research
Variables for Sweden's comparison were its neighboring country's as well as other side of the world.   :wacko:  Information available on internet, research
I've given "existing information" (aka  "applied statistics")    :closed:    Information available on internet, research
Death in "death count"  means  frick'n  DEAD.   :shake:     Information available on internet, research
As a researcher you couldn't even go back 6 posts to find the questions for you to answer.  :sleeping: Information available on internet, research  (see this post)
No more time for trolling 02Tango, Buh-bye. :wave:   Information also available on internet, research
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Rocky on April 23, 2020, 03:37:04 PM
Option 3 wins by twice the number of Options 1 & 2 combined.  :worship:
Unfortunately, based on the info provided and its effect on option #3  only 2 out of 12 of us "Old Guys" will survive the option we chose. :shake:
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Kuleana on April 23, 2020, 04:33:08 PM
No more time for trolling 02Tango, Buh-bye. :wave:   Information also available on internet, research

I happen to miss your question and now I am trolling?..

I thought we were having an honest discussion?

Let me go back and review a few posts and I promise to answer your question.    :shaka:

Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Kuleana on April 23, 2020, 05:21:49 PM
As posted, wouldn't  Option 3 not only reduce Social Security by 70%, reduce Medicare beneficiaries by 80%, open up some 4 million primarily non-physically labor intensive jobs and open up not only housing but the housing market?
   
If some version of Option 3 was implemented and assuming the die-off in your scenario takes place, the discretionary income of most consumers have already been negatively affected on a global scale.  Consumer confidence is very low and will remain low until a safe and reliable vaccine is found.  Even if everyone is open for business right now, it would be a miracle if the entire population ignores all what has happened and go on consuming and investing as usual.  Don't get me wrong, there would be consumer spending and investment, but no way near the rates to achieve recovery in the near term. 

As for the housing market, Inspector, is the senior expert in this area.  However, for the same reason mentioned above, in my view, everyone except the ultra-wealthy will be weary of engaging because of the financial and employment uncertainty caused by Covid-19.  Hence, I can see a housing market bubble crash that will require another trillion dollar bailout, similar to what Obama done in 2008.



Without these burdens and newly created opportunities, wouldn't the US become stronger and with opening the economy by getting back to work ahead of all others, would we not have a gigantic head start on all other nations who are still in options 1 or 2 ?

Of course, the earlier a nation takes actions to recover from Covid-19, the faster to normalcy it can reach.  However, this might not necessarily be the case for the US, as I see two main reasons for this.  First, the entire US economy, the World's #1 economy, has been affected with unemployment at all time highs in many places.  Hence, the recovery time for the US will take much longer than smaller economies.  Second, should a second wave or third wave of Covid-19 hit the US, the worse the US economy will suffer, compared to a much slower restarting of the economy that could better absorb those exogenous shocks.



I can only guess at some of the age of posters voting, but can definitely see the majority voting for option 3 are in the 55+ age bracket.
Realist's, Fathers, Patriots or Suicidal Senile?


For those favoring Option 3, I understand and sympathize with their rationale and motivation; but I stand with some version of Option 2, since I would never want to see any of our seniors suffer and die-off, if there was another, albeit, painful way available to choose.
Title: Re: The hard choice
Post by: Rocky on October 12, 2020, 01:10:07 PM
Any unregistered voters or revisions ?
 :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: