2aHawaii

General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: msp3 on May 21, 2020, 12:57:58 PM

Title: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: msp3 on May 21, 2020, 12:57:58 PM
GOVERNMENT & REGULATIONS
PUPU PLATTER 212

By A. Kam Napier
Editor-in-Chief, Pacific Business News
6 hours ago
Unlawful lockdowns?

I get calls from business leaders asking what we can do, or what they can do, to stop the government overreach into Hawaii’s economy and get us all opening faster.

Trying to find an answer had me doing some homework in Hawaii Revised Statutes, looking into recall elections (doesn’t seem a governor can be recalled, though mayors can be) and the emergency powers themselves.

That’s when I noticed something very interesting. Technically, the proclamations from Gov. David Ige and Mayor Kirk Caldwell declaring an emergency and invoking their ability to make rules with the force of law, have expired. They were issued March 4, and automatically expired 60 days later, on May 3.

Here’s the portion of the law I’m referring to: “§127A-14 State of emergency. … (d) A state of emergency and a local state of emergency shall terminate automatically sixty days after the issuance of a proclamation of a state of emergency or local state of emergency, respectively, or by a separate proclamation of the governor or mayor, whichever occurs first. [L 2014, c 111, pt of §2; am L 2019, c 214, §5]”

https://www.bizjournals.com/pacific/news/2020/05/21/are-hawaiis-covid-emergency-proclamations-legal.html
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: changemyoil66 on May 21, 2020, 01:46:28 PM
HRS mentions a 60 day limit without going through the house/senate.  It's been about 63 days since Ige's 1st proc.  But IDK if every new proc resets this clock.  He just had one a few days ago (proc 8).
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: groveler on May 21, 2020, 02:53:16 PM
HRS mentions a 60 day limit without going through the house/senate.  It's been about 63 days since Ige's 1st proc.  But IDK if every new proc resets this clock.  He just had one a few days ago (proc 8).
Yes there is a limit.  They have exceeded it.
Don't like it?  Go to court.
Kind of like gun rights in this state,
you'll be dead and broke before it gets resolved
and your Constitutional  rights are recognized.
It is the Democrat party way.

Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: Rocky on May 21, 2020, 04:38:51 PM
GOVERNMENT & REGULATIONS
PUPU PLATTER 212

By A. Kam Napier
Editor-in-Chief, Pacific Business News
6 hours ago
Unlawful lockdowns?
I get calls from business leaders asking what we can do, or what they can do, to stop the government overreach into Hawaii’s economy and get us all opening faster.

https://www.facebook.com/inthenow/videos/539715860297387/?d=n
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: zippz on May 21, 2020, 08:15:21 PM
It's one of those things the Government will say just follow it and the courts will figure it out later.  The current proclamation is probably expired and null.  The intent of it is to give the Governor the power to handle a sudden emergency then the legislature has time to call a special session to pass laws for the longer term.  It wouldn't make sense where the Governor has a 60 day limit but can keep extending it himself (through additional proclamations).  It'd be like a genie  giving you 3 wishes and you wish for more wishes.
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: zippz on May 21, 2020, 08:16:48 PM
Another tidbit I found...

But I called ACLU Hawaii and spoke to Legal Director Matteo Caballero to ask, am I right about this? He spent some time doing his homework before getting back to me, which I appreciate.  “You’re not wrong,” he said, “though the matter is more complicated than that.”  Cabellero notes ACLU Hawaii isn’t taking a position on this question. “We’re concerned with government overreach and, while we understand it’s an emergency, we ask the government to act in ways informed by science, responsive to the situation, and taking civil liberties into account.”

In other words...we're too busy right now freeing inmates from prison.
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on May 21, 2020, 08:54:20 PM
HRS mentions a 60 day limit without going through the house/senate.  It's been about 63 days since Ige's 1st proc.  But IDK if every new proc resets this clock.  He just had one a few days ago (proc 8).

I was thinking the same thing. I was reading through the chapter and I didn't see anything that explicitly covered how it worked past the 60 days. Maybe the governor just has to declare an emergency again which restarts the clock?
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on May 21, 2020, 10:23:17 PM
I was thinking the same thing. I was reading through the chapter and I didn't see anything that explicitly covered how it worked past the 60 days. Maybe the governor just has to declare an emergency again which restarts the clock?

Just declaring a new emergency with the same predicate (Covid-19) would be illegal.  You can't make new a new proclamation without a new emergency, especially now that there is more known about the virus and we are entering the time of year when heat and humidity should stop new cases nearly completely. 

Do you really think Ige is stupid enough to try such a transparent end-run around the law?
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: zippz on May 21, 2020, 10:47:43 PM
Odds are this would lose in court and the Legislature is fine with it.  So the two checks on the Governor's power wouldn't do anything.

1.  the law isn't explicit on the issue
2.  the law gives the Governor and Mayors a lot of power
3.  the legislature passed the law and don't seem to have a problem with the multiple proclamations.
4.  Legislature could change the law right now if they really wanted to.
5.  No way the Hawaii Supreme Court would oppose it.  After all they're too busy releasing prisoners.
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on May 21, 2020, 10:56:24 PM
Wisconsin Supreme Court Says the State's COVID-19 Lockdown
Violated the Rule of Law and the Separation of Powers


A seemingly arcane dispute about administrative law has profound
implications for the limits of public health authority.


Quote
Emergency Order 28 extended Wisconsin's original March 24 lockdown, which would have expired on April 24, until May 26. The sorts of
restrictions this entailed are by now familiar but are worth emphasizing, lest we forget the unprecedented extent to which COVID-19 control
measures have interfered with the liberties and livelihoods of people throughout the country.

Palm's order banned "all forms of travel" except those she deemed essential; required "all for-profit and non-profit businesses" she did not
consider "essential" to "cease all activities" except for "minimum basic operations" and work done at home; prohibited "all public and private
gatherings of any number" involving people who were "not part of a single household"; closed all places of "public amusement and activity,"
whether "indoors or outdoors," except for golf courses; continued the closure of bars and restaurants (except for takeout and delivery) as well
as salons, spas, K–12 schools, and libraries; imposed a 10-person limit on religious gatherings, including weddings and funerals; and required
all residents of the state, except for members of the same household, to maintain a distance of at least six feet from each other. Palm said
violations were punishable by a $250 fine, up to 30 days in jail, or both.

The question before the Wisconsin Supreme Court was not whether these sweeping restrictions were sensible, proportionate, or necessary. It
was whether Palm had the legal authority to impose them.

https://reason.com/2020/05/14/wisconsin-supreme-court-says-the-states-covid-19-lockdown-violated-the-rule-of-law-and-the-separation-of-powers/
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: changemyoil66 on May 22, 2020, 09:06:38 AM
OR also won against their mayor's orders because it exceeded 30 days (I think its only 30).
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: bass monkey on May 22, 2020, 09:23:04 AM
OR also won against their mayor's orders because it exceeded 30 days (I think its only 30).


You should post this topic on SSH
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: changemyoil66 on May 22, 2020, 10:02:49 AM

You should post this topic on SSH

I had some issues with my FB page a few weeks ago and have to use my real name.  So I won't be posting.  Someone else can though.
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on May 22, 2020, 10:27:55 PM
Just declaring a new emergency with the same predicate (Covid-19) would be illegal.  You can't make new a new proclamation without a new emergency, especially now that there is more known about the virus and we are entering the time of year when heat and humidity should stop new cases nearly completely. 

Do you really think Ige is stupid enough to try such a transparent end-run around the law?

I don't think he is stupid enough to go past the 60 day limit crossing his fingers that no one knows.

What section states that it has to be a separate emergency? I checked the section about declaring an emergency and found nothing to support your claim. Maybe it is in a different section?

"§127A-14  State of emergency.  (a)  The governor may declare the existence of a state of emergency in the State by proclamation if the governor finds that an emergency or disaster has occurred or that there is imminent danger or threat of an emergency or disaster in any portion of the State."

https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0127A/HRS_0127A-0014.htm
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on May 22, 2020, 10:30:00 PM
Odds are this would lose in court and the Legislature is fine with it.  So the two checks on the Governor's power wouldn't do anything.

1.  the law isn't explicit on the issue
2.  the law gives the Governor and Mayors a lot of power
3.  the legislature passed the law and don't seem to have a problem with the multiple proclamations.
4.  Legislature could change the law right now if they really wanted to.
5.  No way the Hawaii Supreme Court would oppose it.  After all they're too busy releasing prisoners.

Plus we have had wars that have lasted for years without congress ever declaring war so if courts let that slide, I can't imagine local courts are going to get hung up on the 60 day limit.
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on May 22, 2020, 10:46:00 PM
I don't think he is stupid enough to go past the 60 day limit crossing his fingers that no one knows.

What section states that it has to be a separate emergency? I checked the section about declaring an emergency and found nothing to support your claim. Maybe it is in a different section?

"§127A-14  State of emergency.  (a)  The governor may declare the existence of a state of emergency in the State by proclamation if the governor finds that an emergency or disaster has occurred or that there is imminent danger or threat of an emergency or disaster in any portion of the State."

https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0127A/HRS_0127A-0014.htm

It's simple logic.  There's a time limit for a reason.  If he tries to reset the clock, he's violating the law.

Do you honestly think Trump can deploy troops for 60 days without Congressional approval, then deploy more under the premise that it's a different deployment, just to bypass the law?

I see no difference.  An immediate extension of the expired emergency declaration requires legislative consent. 

You can fill volumes with what the laws do not say is illegal.  I think the law is clearly enforcing a time limit for emergencies unless the leg gets a chance to weigh in.  Trying to sidestep that with a "renewed" declaration would be transparently illegal based on the intent of the law.
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on May 22, 2020, 10:57:48 PM
It's simple logic.  There's a time limit for a reason.  If he tries to reset the clock, he's violating the law.

Do you honestly think Trump can deploy troops for 60 days without Congressional approval, then deploy more under the premise that it's a different deployment, just to bypass the law?

I see no difference.  An immediate extension of the expired emergency declaration requires legislative consent. 

You can fill volumes with what the laws do not say is illegal.  I think the law is clearly enforcing a time limit for emergencies unless the leg gets a chance to weigh in.  Trying to sidestep that with a "renewed" declaration would be transparently illegal based on the intent of the law.

I get the crux of your argument and I agree that it would be abuse if someone could perpetually declare an emergency, however nothing clearly spells this out. This is a shortcoming in the language of the law. I think the legislature should rewrite it to include a way to extend it but also a more clear limitation on how long it can be extended.

Along this same lines, the power to quarantine seems to be outside the bounds of what a governor can do in a quarantine. According to the law, the governor can quarantine someone if he believes the person has the disease in question. Yet we are quarantining people who have no signs and no direct reason to believe have the virus. To me that is the bigger legal question than whether we can go past 60 days.
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on May 23, 2020, 12:00:05 AM
I get the crux of your argument and I agree that it would be abuse if someone could perpetually declare an emergency, however nothing clearly spells this out. This is a shortcoming in the language of the law. I think the legislature should rewrite it to include a way to extend it but also a more clear limitation on how long it can be extended.

Along this same lines, the power to quarantine seems to be outside the bounds of what a governor can do in a quarantine. According to the law, the governor can quarantine someone if he believes the person has the disease in question. Yet we are quarantining people who have no signs and no direct reason to believe have the virus. To me that is the bigger legal question than whether we can go past 60 days.

It is clearly spelled out.  Declaring the same emergency twice back-to-back is an extension of the first one no matter what you try to call it.  Arguing otherwise requires suspension of logic and reasonable understanding of plain English language.

A lockdown is not the same as a quarantine.  Now who's trying to play word games?

Quarantined people do not get to go shopping for food or to visit other essential businesses and services.

Not a difficult concept at all.
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: Rocky on May 23, 2020, 07:16:41 AM
https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/committeefiles/special/COV/Document/05-18-20%20Making%20Hawaii%20Safe%20For%20Travel.pdf
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: ren on May 23, 2020, 09:34:45 AM
People are still scared and turn to govt. for guidance...no matter how inept govt is we always turn to them  for guidance :crazy: :shaka: :geekdanc: :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on May 23, 2020, 10:58:56 AM
People are still scared and turn to govt. for guidance...no matter how inept govt is we always turn to them  for guidance :crazy: :shaka: :geekdanc: :thumbsup:

Not just guidance, but also for the resources they often have exclusive control over, and for the legal authority they alone may have to implement needed solutions.

They've made us dependent for a wide variety of things.  Putting measures in place to stop the spread of disease is outside the expertise of most of us, but gov't is supposed to have access to the people who do know these things.  God knows we pay enough every year for salaries of these health experts.

https://health.hawaii.gov/about/office-of-the-director/
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: changemyoil66 on May 23, 2020, 03:41:17 PM
Oregon court just ruled their gov is violating law.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: 6716J on May 23, 2020, 10:20:24 PM
Well the new state travel form does a good job of violating the 4th Amendment really well.

Story from BI
https://www.bigislandvideonews.com/2020/05/22/hawaii-has-new-mandatory-travel-declaration-form/

Sent from my SM-G970U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on May 23, 2020, 10:42:45 PM
Well the new state travel form does a good job of violating the 4th Amendment really well.

Story from BI
https://www.bigislandvideonews.com/2020/05/22/hawaii-has-new-mandatory-travel-declaration-form/

Sent from my SM-G970U using Tapatalk

If I recall correctly, only the agriculture department related questions are mandatory on the current arrival forms -- to declare any fruits, vegetables, plants, soil, animals, etc.  The other side for the tourism department was totally voluntary.

Unless the laws are changed, I can't see how there'a any valid foundation for collecting information on a new form related to things outside the scope of agricultural and animal importation,

https://law.justia.com/codes/hawaii/2016/title-11/chapter-150a/section-150a-5/

Having said that, I'm sure this will be the #1 piece of business when the legislature reconvenes.
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on May 23, 2020, 11:31:52 PM
It is clearly spelled out.  Declaring the same emergency twice back-to-back is an extension of the first one no matter what you try to call it.  Arguing otherwise requires suspension of logic and reasonable understanding of plain English language.

Nope, it isn't clearly spelled out. That is the problem. You don't seem to understand how legal language works.


Quote
A lockdown is not the same as a quarantine.  Now who's trying to play word games?

The law doesn't specifically define what quarantine is. Fail #2


Quote
Quarantined people do not get to go shopping for food or to visit other essential businesses and services.

You mean like the tourists who come in and are being arrested because they went outside?
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on May 24, 2020, 12:20:21 AM
Nope, it isn't clearly spelled out. That is the problem. You don't seem to understand how legal language works.


The law doesn't specifically define what quarantine is. Fail #2


You mean like the tourists who come in and are being arrested because they went outside?

Remind us -- where did you receive your law degree?

Exactly.  They were quarantined.  Anyone showing symptoms, who were possibly exposed or who arrived in Hawaii after the lockdown started were quarantined.  Everyone else was not.

Not a difficult concept at all.
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: Rocky on May 24, 2020, 08:06:50 AM
If I recall correctly, only the agriculture department related questions are mandatory on the current arrival forms -- to declare any fruits, vegetables, plants, soil, animals, etc.  The other side for the tourism department was totally voluntary.
Unless the laws are changed, I can't see how there'a any valid foundation for collecting information on a new form related to things outside the scope of agricultural and animal importation,
https://law.justia.com/codes/hawaii/2016/title-11/chapter-150a/section-150a-5/
Having said that, I'm sure this will be the #1 piece of business when the legislature reconvenes.
Looks like a definite 4a violation and lets throw HIPA violation in there too !
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on May 24, 2020, 09:18:51 PM
Remind us -- where did you receive your law degree?

Exactly.  They were quarantined.  Anyone showing symptoms, who were possibly exposed or who arrived in Hawaii after the lockdown started were quarantined.  Everyone else was not.

Not a difficult concept at all.

You are the one making incorrect claims. It's your job to prove your own statements. Don't get mad at me when I show you don't have a basis for your argument.
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on May 24, 2020, 09:22:08 PM
You are the one making incorrect claims. It's your job to prove your own statements. Don't get mad at me when I show you don't have a basis for your argument.

There you go again, pretending you get to tell us all what the rules are.

The rule is, if you don't have anything to support your own position, don't pretend it's the other person's job to do what you can't.
Title: Re: Have Hawaii's Covid emergency proclamations expired?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on June 03, 2020, 09:13:21 PM
There you go again, pretending you get to tell us all what the rules are.

The rule is, if you don't have anything to support your own position, don't pretend it's the other person's job to do what you can't.

You said it was spelled out in plain english even though it clearly wasn't then you demand to see my law degree. You just invalidated your first argument.

You are the one who failed to prove your assertion. If you don't like it then don't make it. You could have stopped at saying why you think it is wrong to continue the emergency declaration but no, you made a claim of certainty that wasn't supported and now you are upset someone pointed it out.