2aHawaii
General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: omnigun on October 26, 2020, 11:02:59 AM
-
Japan the 3rd largest economy pledged to combat climate change and be carbon neutral by 2050.
https://www.npr.org/2020/10/26/927846739/a-decarbonized-society-japan-pledges-to-be-carbon-neutral-by-2050
This means the worlds 3 out of the top 4 economy's minus the USA have pledge to be carbon neutral.
Hope the USA is next!
-
I too will pledge this by year 2050. Hit me up in 30 years. TBH, I'm gonna slack until 2049 and in 1 year then make a 100% change.
-
I too will pledge this by year 2050. Hit me up in 30 years. TBH, I'm gonna slack until 2049 and in 1 year then make a 100% change.
But you’re gonna tax everyone else during those 29 years to make up for your slack.
-
Ironically we are carbon based life and we exhale about 2 pounds of CO2 a day.
-
But you’re gonna tax everyone else during those 29 years to make up for your slack.
Nope, just 1 huge tax in the last year of 10000000000%.
No worries, you prob not even going be around, old futt.
-
Nope, just 1 huge tax in the last year of 10000000000%.
No worries, you prob not even going be around, old futt.
First, it's YUGE! Get it straight young feller. . .
29 more years would be a good run. . . ;D
-
What? 2050? I will absolutely be dead and buried long before that date.
More importantly, 2050 will be much too late to save our planet.
According to some of the most prominent climate change experts we only have 11 years left before its too late.
Greta T., Beto, and AOC said so.
-
Ironically we are carbon based life and we exhale about 2 pounds of CO2 a day.
I thought it was cow farts. . .
-
What? 2050? I will absolutely be dead and buried long before that date.
More importantly, 2050 will be much too late to save our planet.
According to some of the most prominent climate change experts we only have 11 years left before its too late.
Greta T., Beto, and AOC said so.
Better than nothing.
-
The Paris CC Accord was structured so the wealthiest countries paid in the most money, and the least wealthy countries were given that money to help them improve their economies so they can afford to adopt low carbon emission technologies.
There was no requirement for the countries taking out of the "fund" to meet any CO2 production goals. The incentives, subsidies, tax credits, whatever you call them were to improve the ECONOMIES of these countries.
It's international welfare. And if you think the money being paid in is going to do anything other than make the leaders of the countries taking the money richer while nothing improves in their national economies, you haven't been alive for longer than, say,, 20+ years?
How is ANY country going to pay into the fund now that the pandemic has all but destroyed the economic growth each hoped to achieve for at least 2-3 years? We're going to be working hard just to get back even. When you lose 50% of your GDP growth, you then have to double what's left to break even in addition to maintaining the growth you would have had anyway. Very difficult to do.
-
Better than nothing.
At what cost?
-
According to some of the most prominent climate change experts we only have 11 years left before its too late.
Greta T., Beto, and AOC said so.
Yeah, algore promised Florida would be underwater some time ago now.
Easy to note the most frenetic globull warming clowns are also the most weird.
No wonder no one will listen to them.
-
At what cost?
Can you put a price on survival? If we never do anything ever oceans will rise, millions will die and if there is ever change to the air and ocean currents it will be a disaster. But hey everyone will have a little more in their pockets for a nice funeral.
-
Can you put a price on survival? If we never do anything ever oceans will rise, millions will die and if there is ever change to the air and ocean currents it will be a disaster. But hey everyone will have a little more in their pockets for a nice funeral.
Yes, I can. If I have to spend my wealth, my children's wealth and their children's wealth so another country can reduce their carbon emissions by 10%, I consider that to be too high a cost.
Climate Change Scammers have yet to scientifically show that manmade carbon contributes X percentage of the total. If we only contribute 10-15%, then nothing we do will stop the process.
Also, the Climate Change, Global Warming, Global Cooling models have been wrong for 50 years. It hasn't gotten any better in the past 10 years. If all of their models are wrong, is it really "Science" you are believing in? Or is it, "Better safe that sorry" marketing hype?
-
BTW, there are already other Climate Change threads on here. Nothing has changed, including your doom and gloom "The sky is falling" fear mongering.
Go read them before going down this worn out rabbit hole.
No sense in regurgitating it all for just another lap around the track.
-
Can you put a price on survival? If we never do anything ever oceans will rise, millions will die and if there is ever change to the air and ocean currents it will be a disaster. But hey everyone will have a little more in their pockets for a nice funeral.
how DARE you?
-
No sense in regurgitating it all for just another lap around the track.
Religious fanatics can be like that......... :wacko:
-
I read that those wind turbines take up a huge amount of oil to stay lubricated. So oil still needed.
-
I read that those wind turbines take up a huge amount of oil to stay lubricated. So oil still needed.
Doubt they use as much as exploding oil for power :shake:
-
(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20201028/a4e0b2be642f964ab8f127368644be80.jpg)
-
(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20201028/a4e0b2be642f964ab8f127368644be80.jpg)
That's why we have to get rid of coal and gas/oil plants. Replace with nuclear or solar/wind/renewable. Replace everything so we fully greeen.
-
Hmmmmm ok let’s make a world wide law that all humans must shove a cork up their ass to prevent passing gas. That should help! :wacko:
-
When a bunch of billionaires get together the plan is always the same, which is to figure out how to get more free money from taxpayers. Climate change is real and the consequences are increasingly catastrophic, but forcing us to pay more taxes to support people who are too rich to pay taxes is not going to accomplish anything but a socialist revolution. The solutions for this have to come from the bottom up, not the top down, but top down feels more acceptable for people who rant and rave about climate change but refuse to address the energy overconsumption in their own lives.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c4NvDaMQs6g
-
That's why we have to get rid of coal and gas/oil plants. Replace with nuclear or solar/wind/renewable. Replace everything so we fully greeen.
What if get nuclear leak? Gotta do away with electricity 100%.
-
That's why we have to get rid of coal and gas/oil plants. Replace with nuclear or solar/wind/renewable. Replace everything so we fully greeen.
All those technologies require fossil fuels. Green tech ends up using more fossil fuels because of all the energy conversions. It is better just to burn the fossil fuels and figure out ways to reduce our dependence on them. But that means the end of Hawaii megatourism.
-
All those technologies require fossil fuels. Green tech ends up using more fossil fuels because of all the energy conversions. It is better just to burn the fossil fuels and figure out ways to reduce our dependence on them. But that means the end of Hawaii megatourism.
We mentioned this to him. The response was something about technology needing to get better so it doesn't use fossil fuels as much. And only way to get it better is to have a starting point of green tech that does use lots of fossil fuels and we work from there.
Conversation now went full circle.
-
We mentioned this to him. The response was something about technology needing to get better so it doesn't use fossil fuels as much. And only way to get it better is to have a starting point of green tech that does use lots of fossil fuels and we work from there.
Conversation now went full circle.
Personal responsibility is not fashionable I guess
-
We mentioned this to him. The response was something about technology needing to get better so it doesn't use fossil fuels as much. And only way to get it better is to have a starting point of green tech that does use lots of fossil fuels and we work from there.
Conversation now went full circle.
Shocking
And he’s also mixing up green, sustainable, renewable, and other terms.
-
There's not a single electric engine in existence that can do the work of big, heavy, industrial machines needed for mining, building, and transporting the things needed for "alternative" forms of energy.
Until Tesla starts producing all-electric versions of these, we're locked into needing fossil fuels.
Cargo ships
Road construction and maintenance
Building high rises
Landscaping for more housing
hauling infrastructure components like massive sections of water and sewer pipes, Rail Supports, etc.
The work needed everyday to build and maintain our infrastructure can't just be replaced with "new technology" because we wish it so. Therefore, pretending we have total control over all factors in our lives that impact carbon emissions is naive or dishonest.
Even IF we could cut emissions in the US by 25%, that's ONE country. Now, if we assume MAN contributes 10-15% of the total carbon emissions affecting Climate Change, cutting just our emissions by 25% is not even a drop in the bucket global. The COST of that reduction could easily destroy our economy, as the energy sector would have to absorb the cost of retrofitting for new sources, and that cost would drive up the amount consumers pay for things like home heating and cooling, transporting goods and foods to the stores, and air transportation. Any energy-related product or service would create a ripple effect in all prices, driving inflation like it did in the 1970s.
-
There's not a single electric engine in existence that can do the work of big, heavy, industrial machines needed for mining, building, and transporting the things needed for "alternative" forms of energy.
Until Tesla starts producing all-electric versions of these, we're locked into needing fossil fuels.
Cargo ships
Road construction and maintenance
Building high rises
Landscaping for more housing
hauling infrastructure components like massive sections of water and sewer pipes, Rail Supports, etc.
The work needed everyday to build and maintain our infrastructure can't just be replaced with "new technology" because we wish it so. Therefore, pretending we have total control over all factors in our lives that impact carbon emissions is naive or dishonest.
Even IF we could cut emissions in the US by 25%, that's ONE country. Now, if we assume MAN contributes 10-15% of the total carbon emissions affecting Climate Change, cutting just our emissions by 25% is not even a drop in the bucket global. The COST of that reduction could easily destroy our economy, as the energy sector would have to absorb the cost of retrofitting for new sources, and that cost would drive up the amount consumers pay for things like home heating and cooling, transporting goods and foods to the stores, and air transportation. Any energy-related product or service would create a ripple effect in all prices, driving inflation like it did in the 1970s.
but but but science
we can invent new things!
we have to TRY!
otherwise we are DOOMED!
how DARE you!
-
There's not a single electric engine in existence that can do the work of big, heavy, industrial machines needed for mining, building, and transporting the things needed for "alternative" forms of energy.
Until Tesla starts producing all-electric versions of these, we're locked into needing fossil fuels.
Cargo ships
Road construction and maintenance
Building high rises
Landscaping for more housing
hauling infrastructure components like massive sections of water and sewer pipes, Rail Supports, etc.
The work needed everyday to build and maintain our infrastructure can't just be replaced with "new technology" because we wish it so. Therefore, pretending we have total control over all factors in our lives that impact carbon emissions is naive or dishonest.
Even IF we could cut emissions in the US by 25%, that's ONE country. Now, if we assume MAN contributes 10-15% of the total carbon emissions affecting Climate Change, cutting just our emissions by 25% is not even a drop in the bucket global. The COST of that reduction could easily destroy our economy, as the energy sector would have to absorb the cost of retrofitting for new sources, and that cost would drive up the amount consumers pay for things like home heating and cooling, transporting goods and foods to the stores, and air transportation. Any energy-related product or service would create a ripple effect in all prices, driving inflation like it did in the 1970s.
This isn't some all or nothing. Convert the ones you can and don't convert the ones you can't until technology catches up. You can convert slowly. I am not saying wake up tomorrow and all be electric. One thing at a time.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/climate-change-intervention-cost/2020/09/17/c6715db6-f784-11ea-89e3-4b9efa36dc64_story.html
-
This isn't some all or nothing. Convert the ones you can and don't convert the ones you can't until technology catches up. You can convert slowly. I am not saying wake up tomorrow and all be electric. One thing at a time.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/climate-change-intervention-cost/2020/09/17/c6715db6-f784-11ea-89e3-4b9efa36dc64_story.html
At what cost? Some of the things you want to convert can cost millions of dollars for one company to retrofit -- and to a technology that's not been time-tested.
Think, McFly! Imagine if every company that could change had to invest millions at once. How long to PRODUCE said tech products at the volume needed? How much MORE do businesses pay in the beginning until economies of scale make the products more affordable? How much in taxes THAT WE HAVE TO BORROW in subsidies are needed to help incentivize early adopters?
We aren't talking about mandating seatbelts or airbags over 5-10 years. We're talking about reducing emissions. How much of those emissions will be needed to produce the low emission products, making the total Climate Change problem WORSE?
"Big picture" isn't really your thing.
-
I spent ten years working in the Hawaiian astronomy world.
I learned a lot and from the best in the world.
It never ceases to amaze me, the ignorance of mankind, as to his
negligible importance or the small effect he can have on something
as dynamic and immense as our planet, much less our solar system.
This planet is 5 billion years old. We have only been here fucking it up for
a few thousand years. What arrogance, that we in the recent 4 thousand
years or so have dramatically made a dent in the Earth's capability to
"survive".
Our climate is driven by our star AKA the sun. at various times in the
past the amount of CO2 far exceeded anything we can do, but we are here.
The destruction of life on earth by naturally occurring events
far exceeds what we think we can do with our bombs and our pollution's.
Once you make this arrogance political as many have done, you detract from
what we could do to improve life for humanity using what technology and resources
we have and will develop for however long we are here..
There is no such thing as "renewable energy"
The laws of Thermodynamics are pretty explicit.
So I repudiate those that demand the destruction of my culture,
my country, and my families future, for some imagined powers that
some experts are "gifted" with, that will save us all.
Good news! Pretty much in less than 5 billion years this Earth will
no longer exist regardless of what you Eco nuts do.
-
Once you make this arrogance political as many have done, you detract from
what we could do to improve life for humanity using what technology and resources
we have .
Observed this and advised leftists of their great strategic mistake in allowing the globull warming cult to turn into a liberal religion.
That pretty much relegated it to something to ignore and reject for independents and conservatives. No one wants anything to do with liberal cult issues.
-
I spent ten years working in the Hawaiian astronomy world.
I learned a lot and from the best in the world.
It never ceases to amaze me, the ignorance of mankind, as to his
negligible importance or the small effect he can have on something
as dynamic and immense as our planet, much less our solar system.
This planet is 5 billion years old. We have only been here fucking it up for
a few thousand years. What arrogance, that we in the recent 4 thousand
years or so have dramatically made a dent in the Earth's capability to
"survive".
Our climate is driven by our star AKA the sun. at various times in the
past the amount of CO2 far exceeded anything we can do, but we are here.
The destruction of life on earth by naturally occurring events
far exceeds what we think we can do with our bombs and our pollution's.
Once you make this arrogance political as many have done, you detract from
what we could do to improve life for humanity using what technology and resources
we have and will develop for however long we are here..
There is no such thing as "renewable energy"
The laws of Thermodynamics are pretty explicit.
So I repudiate those that demand the destruction of my culture,
my country, and my families future, for some imagined powers that
some experts are "gifted" with, that will save us all.
Good news! Pretty much in less than 5 billion years this Earth will
no longer exist regardless of what you Eco nuts do.
But, if we have to start NOW! Because in 12 years ..... TOAST!!
So those new technologies OMIGOD posts about better be coming before Christmas, or we might as well blow it all on strippers and coke (The Hunter Biden Plan).
12 years? It takes longer to get Congress to agree on drapery designs and carpet colors for their offices.
As I said on ALL THE PREVIOUS CLIMATE CHANGE topics,
"When the people telling us there's a climate crisis start acting like there's a crisis by making changes in their own lives,
MAYBE I'll start to believe there's a real crisis that requires me to make changes MY life."
-
"When the people telling us there's a climate crisis start acting like there's a crisis by making changes in their own lives,
MAYBE I'll start to believe there's a real crisis that requires me to make changes MY life."
There you go, casting aspersions on the sainted algore. His exalted status entitled him to all those $$$ mansions, he is a patron saint of the globull warming hoax.
He deserves to live as wastefully as he wishes.............and have masseuses release his chakra............
-
I agree that it is important to point out that green energy sources are not really totally green. They still rely traditional fuel sources and material harvesting which are dirty.
However we also shouldn't let those facts make us believe that green technologies are no better than their oil and coal based counterparts either. Both an EV and a traditional gas vehicle are going to be dirty to produce however consuming the energy in a gas car is dirty while consuming the energy in an EV is basically clean.
We need to balance the reality of the costs of trying to go green with the ideal of a cleaner earth. The left wants to pretend green energy solves all our problems and the right wants to pretend that the technology and changes is so unrealistic and expensive we should resist any efforts.
One technology that interested me was supposed methods that could pull carbon out of the air at a better rate than the carbon put in the air to make it. If this did turn out to be doable we could theoretically set carbon levels exactly where we want them.
-
I have seen the reality of the “100% renewable by 2045” for Hawaii. Hint, it’s not quite what advocates make it out to be. Also those leading initiatives to get there are finding it’s not quite that easy. Not my project, but it severely impacts my current efforts.
Good ideas? Sure. Reality of getting there? Remains to be seen, but my opinion is folks who signed off on things were sold a lot of BS.
When people lose quality of power service, let’s see how they feel about 100% renewable HECO service. At least without “cheating”.
-
I have seen the reality of the “100% renewable by 2045” for Hawaii. Hint, it’s not quite what advocates make it out to be. Also those leading initiatives to get there are finding it’s not quite that easy. Not my project, but it severely impacts my current efforts.
Good ideas? Sure. Reality of getting there? Remains to be seen, but my opinion is folks who signed off on things were sold a lot of BS.
When people lose quality of power service, let’s see how they feel about 100% renewable HECO service. At least without “cheating”.
I agree that 100% renewable is not a realistic goal, especially if they mean that completely. Current technologies just aren't there yet. If someone makes some major advances in green technology we could get pretty close I think.
-
I agree that 100% renewable is not a realistic goal, especially if they mean that completely. Current technologies just aren't there yet. If someone makes some major advances in green technology we could get pretty close I think.
Much of the recent tech I saw was pretty darn good. Resistance to damage for hurricane prone regions and batteries though aren’t quite that great. It’s been a while since I was neck deep in research for this stuff, but when the PV industry advocated for replacing when panels got damaged instead of designing for better durability, that was telling.
-
Much of the recent tech I saw was pretty darn good. Resistance to damage for hurricane prone regions and batteries though aren’t quite that great. It’s been a while since I was neck deep in research for this stuff, but when the PV industry advocated for replacing when panels got damaged instead of designing for better durability, that was telling.
I used to pay more attention to battery technology when I was into flashlights but I am not as up to date now. I do know there were some very promising advances in battery technology on the horizon. Another almost primitive one I was surprised we don't see more of is using gravity combined with potential energy as the fuel source. They have some places where a dam holds water and provides electricity during the night and peak times but when there is excess energy from other green sources, water is pumped back up into the lake. Simplest battery around.
I would be curious to know why they advocated replacement if damaged instead of just building them more durable however there may be some technological aspect that explains it.
-
I used to pay more attention to battery technology when I was into flashlights but I am not as up to date now. I do know there were some very promising advances in battery technology on the horizon. Another almost primitive one I was surprised we don't see more of is using gravity combined with potential energy as the fuel source. They have some places where a dam holds water and provides electricity during the night and peak times but when there is excess energy from other green sources, water is pumped back up into the lake. Simplest battery around.
I would be curious to know why they advocated replacement if damaged instead of just building them more durable however there may be some technological aspect that explains it.
dams and all that concrete
-
SNIP
I would be curious to know why they advocated replacement if damaged instead of just building them more durable however there may be some technological aspect that explains it.
Bottom line.
The industry “found” a way to improve to meet Miami-Dade county criteria once the ordinance mandated standards. Beyond that, there was not much incentive to improve, at least for a given company.
The industry excuse that I often got from reps was that the panel tech was improving a such a fast rate that facility owners are better off replacing in day 5 years when it gets damaged and by then newer, better, etc panels are available. Ask for the testing that showed the improvement, get another pitch. Basically their way of justifying selling more panels. Even worse, where do those damaged panels go after? Is that a truly sustainable or green model?
-
I agree that it is important to point out that green energy sources are not really totally green. They still rely traditional fuel sources and material harvesting which are dirty.
However we also shouldn't let those facts make us believe that green technologies are no better than their oil and coal based counterparts either. Both an EV and a traditional gas vehicle are going to be dirty to produce however consuming the energy in a gas car is dirty while consuming the energy in an EV is basically clean.
We need to balance the reality of the costs of trying to go green with the ideal of a cleaner earth. The left wants to pretend green energy solves all our problems and the right wants to pretend that the technology and changes is so unrealistic and expensive we should resist any efforts.
One technology that interested me was supposed methods that could pull carbon out of the air at a better rate than the carbon put in the air to make it. If this did turn out to be doable we could theoretically set carbon levels exactly where we want them.
You left out the other end of the equation: disposal.
Much of the high tech materials being churned out to SAVE THE PLANET are not recyclable and cause a much higher rate of landfill use than traditional energy producing machines and products. Solar Panels and Lithium Batteries are at the top of the list, along with the plastics and light weight materials used in vehicles to reduce weight and therefore increase efficiency.
When you add that to the "dirty" production methods and raw materials processing, you might be trading a minor reduction in carbon emissions for products that can't be safely disposed of once these "new" green-ish things reach the end of their useful lives.
-
You left out the other end of the equation: disposal.
Much of the high tech materials being churned out to SAVE THE PLANET are not recyclable and cause a much higher rate of landfill use than traditional energy producing machines and products. Solar Panels and Lithium Batteries are at the top of the list, along with the plastics and light weight materials used in vehicles to reduce weight and therefore increase efficiency.
When you add that to the "dirty" production methods and raw materials processing, you might be trading a minor reduction in carbon emissions for products that can't be safely disposed of once these "new" green-ish things reach the end of their useful lives.
That’s was getting at in my question about if that’s a truly sustainable or green model. Asked that to the all knowing a while back, but no rational response. PV and solar panel disposal are horrible.
-
That’s was getting at in my question about if that’s a truly sustainable or green model. Asked that to the all knowing a while back, but no rational response. PV and solar panel disposal are horrible.
Here's a useful bit of trivia. Remember those incandescent bulbs the gov't banned in favor of more efficient and "green" "Compact Fluorescent" Soft Serve Ice Cream looking bulbs? Ever wonder why they have been replaced with LED bulbs now? Not only is the technology for LEDs providing much better efficiency for lighting at home than CF Bulbs, but DISPOSAL turned out to not be all the green energy people promised. There is a small amount of MERCURY in Compact Fluorescent bulbs. Over time, as more and more bulbs find their way to the landfill, that mercury begins to poison the land and potentially water. Mercury is also HAZMAT, and requires specific disposal processing. When a contractor removes Fluorescent bulbs from, say, a warehouse being retrofit with new LED bulbs, the old ones can't be dumped in the landfill before being properly packaged to contain the HAZMAT. Then, it's only allowed in certain landfills for HAZMAT disposal.
That kind of shortsightedness not only creates health hazards, but it also adds COST to the eventual replacement with better, more expensive technologies. In the beginning all new tech is EXPENSIVE. Early adopters must pay the price, wait for prices to drop, or hope for subsidies.
Anyway, the moral of the story is: nothing new is as as simple, or as perfect, as the brochure says it is.
-
Yeah, algore promised Florida would be underwater some time ago now.
Easy to note the most frenetic globull warming clowns are also the most weird.
No wonder no one will listen to them.
The only Scientific Fact that Al Gore can point to about Climate Change is that it's making him rich! :rofl:
-
The only Scientific Fact that Al Gore can point to about Climate Change is that it's making him rich! :rofl:
That, and his mass has increased relative to his bank account, causing a proportional increase in his gravitational pull on smaller objects. :rofl:
-
That, and his mass has increased relative to his bank account, causing a proportional increase in his gravitational pull on smaller objects. :rofl:
I thought when you mentioned his mass increase I thought that you were going to say that he was contributing to global warming by emitting more gas giving the cows a run for their money. Well he is full of hot air!
-
I thought when you mentioned his mass increase I thought that you were going to say that he was contributing to global warming by emitting more gas giving the cows a run for their money. Well he is full of hot air!
Any man who thinks "Carbon Credits" is a valid way to reduce Carbon emissions is no better than a snake oil salesman.
-
https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-energy-and-levelized-cost-of-storage-2020/
-
https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-energy-and-levelized-cost-of-storage-2020/
Did YOU form any conclusions on all those graphs, or are we supposed to contact the author if we want to discuss the "bottom line" analysis?
-
Did YOU form any conclusions on all those graphs, or are we supposed to contact the author if we want to discuss the "bottom line" analysis?
Solar and wind is now getting cheaper to produce energy than the equivalent oil or coal plant.
-
Solar and wind is now getting cheaper to produce energy than the equivalent oil or coal plant.
Solar and wind are not suitable for all points in the nation. Also, the only reason the production cost of solar and wind production is cheaper now is because we are energy independent under Trump.
The cost of FOSSIL FUELS used to generate the energy needed to make solar and wind products is lower, so the total cost of ALL production and supply chain systems are less.
What they fail to do is compare the cost of fossil fuel created energy at today's lower cost to that energy created with wind and solar long term. Solar doesn't work at night. Wind doesn't work when the wind slows or stops. Any idea what we'll do when the batteries are depleted after production stops for several days of bad weather (no sun -- too many clouds) and no wind? We just go home and break out the generators?
These energy sources can augment fossil fuel, nuclear and hydroelectric energy production, but they are by no means able to replace them. When the sun goes down, and demand increases in hot or cold weather (ACs and Heaters are needed), the batteries can't supply the needs. We'll still need running generators to swap to when demand exceed production capacity, and that means the SAME number of generators burning the same amount of fuel for as long as the demand exceeds alternative energy production.
You can't just crank up generators at will. They take time, up to a day or longer, to bring up to production speed and bring online on the grid. Not a simple task, as we learned when HECO shut down generators during that big Earthquake. Some people were in the dark for more than 2 days.
-
https://getpocket.com/explore/item/eight-go-mad-in-arizona-how-a-lockdown-experiment-went-horribly-wrong?utm_source=pocket-newtab (https://getpocket.com/explore/item/eight-go-mad-in-arizona-how-a-lockdown-experiment-went-horribly-wrong?utm_source=pocket-newtab)
-
You left out the other end of the equation: disposal.
Much of the high tech materials being churned out to SAVE THE PLANET are not recyclable and cause a much higher rate of landfill use than traditional energy producing machines and products. Solar Panels and Lithium Batteries are at the top of the list, along with the plastics and light weight materials used in vehicles to reduce weight and therefore increase efficiency.
When you add that to the "dirty" production methods and raw materials processing, you might be trading a minor reduction in carbon emissions for products that can't be safely disposed of once these "new" green-ish things reach the end of their useful lives.
You are right, I didn't cover it but I think it is a bit of a wash there. Recycling on solar panels and windmills is not very good, but then again there is also quite a bit of waste from petrolium power sources as well. One might have a slight advantage over the other though.
-
Bottom line.
The industry “found” a way to improve to meet Miami-Dade county criteria once the ordinance mandated standards. Beyond that, there was not much incentive to improve, at least for a given company.
The industry excuse that I often got from reps was that the panel tech was improving a such a fast rate that facility owners are better off replacing in day 5 years when it gets damaged and by then newer, better, etc panels are available. Ask for the testing that showed the improvement, get another pitch. Basically their way of justifying selling more panels. Even worse, where do those damaged panels go after? Is that a truly sustainable or green model?
If it were a monopoly then I can totally understand your suspicions however there are a number of sources for solar panels if I understand correctly so if one company could make a little more or edge out a rival by offering a better panel then I think they would, at least according to the free market.
-
If it were a monopoly then I can totally understand your suspicions however there are a number of sources for solar panels if I understand correctly so if one company could make a little more or edge out a rival by offering a better panel then I think they would, at least according to the free market.
You left out crony capitalism. We know from Obama and Solyndra that SOME green and renewable energy companies and manufacturers were being given bailouts and massive subsidies to help them compete with standard forms of energy. it's not about monopolies. It's about enabling some industries in the sector to the detriment of others in order to facilitate growth in them. The market won't support the new energy models without capital. Few people adopt those models due to cost.
in Hawaii, there was a huge demand for home solar systems because (1) the gov't gave huge tax incentives, and (2) HECO was offering the NEM (Net Energy Meter) tariff that purchased excess power from homes, offsetting the HECO power solar customers used at night or on cloudy days. Most of those customers who installed adequately sized systems are only paying $18/month for the administrative cost to have a HECO account. The energy they use from HECO is effectively free. They just had to be able to afford the solar system installation.
Those incentives are not going to happen for everyone. That program stopped in HI after 20% of the customers were added. NEM is not available for HECO customers now.
Part of the issue is, who pays for the power grid? Who pays for power production at night? They have to maintain the generator capacity online and ready to meet all demand, even when the sun is shining and thousands of customers are creating their own power. There are fixed costs associated with having that capacity online.
If you can be 100% off the grid, that's one thing. If you can't, then you need HECO for a portion of your power at least. We have no nuclear power plants here. No hydroelectric. The wind farms have been unsuccessful. Not many options left.