2aHawaii

General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: changemyoil66 on March 04, 2021, 05:34:57 PM

Title: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 04, 2021, 05:34:57 PM
Up for senate floor vote. Email and call your senator (not representative) BEFORE 3/9 and tell them to vote no

Let them know for SB301, there were 1100 oppose testimony and only 19 support.

I called my rep and the gal who picked up the phone was surprised it even made it past committee with those numbers.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: Mdotweber on March 07, 2021, 09:32:58 AM
Try to be nice to them please, think honey vs vinegar. Explain your position with personal experiences link video of people being taken down by LEO's emptying 17 rnd magazines while the perp still charges them. Invite them out to shoot, I'm sure many fellow firearms owners and instructors would gladly make a fun day of it with anybody interested.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: punaperson on March 07, 2021, 05:24:56 PM
Try to be nice to them please, think honey vs vinegar. Explain your position with personal experiences link video of people being taken down by LEO's emptying 17 rnd magazines while the perp still charges them. Invite them out to shoot, I'm sure many fellow firearms owners and instructors would gladly make a fun day of it with anybody interested.
Isn't that the strategy employed by the Jews with Nationalsozialismus? And by Russians under Stalin? And by Japanese Americans as they were rounded up for concentration "internment" camps? And by the Armenians to the Turks? And by the Cambodians to Pol Pot? And by the Uyghurs to the CCP? There are at least 20 more in the past 100 years, but I'll stop there...

Please let me know when you get an outcome that actually results in Hawaii residents increasing their ability to exercise their rights as protected by the Constitution.

PS I'm likely only going to be alive for a few more years... will I see anything?
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: Mdotweber on March 07, 2021, 07:40:21 PM
Isn't that the strategy employed by the Jews with Nationalsozialismus? And by Russians under Stalin? And by Japanese Americans as they were rounded up for concentration "internment" camps? And by the Armenians to the Turks? And by the Cambodians to Pol Pot? And by the Uyghurs to the CCP? There are at least 20 more in the past 100 years, but I'll stop there...

Please let me know when you get an outcome that actually results in Hawaii residents increasing their ability to exercise their rights as protected by the Constitution.

PS I'm likely only going to be alive for a few more years... will I see anything?

I hear ya but we can still win some of these people over. Thirteen or so nay votes can go a long way to stop this crap (at least for now).
(https://i.pinimg.com/736x/44/5d/3a/445d3afe006105d6cd8a939d6b50b7c9.jpg)
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: punaperson on March 08, 2021, 08:06:58 AM
I hear ya but we can still win some of these people over. Thirteen or so nay votes can go a long way to stop this crap (at least for now).
Oh, when you gave the example of 17-round mags used by cops I thought you were referring to legislation that would restore some of our fundamental natural individual rights to legal status (revoke/repeal unconstitutional handgun mag limit), not just the attempt to stop legislation outlawing more of our rights.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 08, 2021, 08:59:03 AM
Acasio is a new senator. So for her to listen to her people that she represents is huge.  But maybe because she hasn't been tainted like the other super anti 2a's on the committee (Rhodes, Lee, K). So it's a step to keep them reminded that they are supposed to serve the people and not push their own agenda.

It all needs to start some where.  And the attitude of "it wont help" or "no sense cause we still don't have the #s" is the mentality that got us where we are today.  But it is much easier to voice your opinions due to the internet. When the pistol mag ban came around in the 90's the internet wasn't what it was today.  So maybe much of the older guys weren't aware and didn't make that call to their senator/rep.  IDK cause I wasn't in the culture at the time so I'm just guessing. Same goes with registration.

If someone could post estimates of what was done to stop the pistol mag ban and registration that would been nice.  Like how when the SB301 came up, we got 1100 oppose testimonies.  Where the #s like that back in the 90s?
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: punaperson on March 08, 2021, 10:04:27 AM
Acasio is a new senator. So for her to listen to her people that she represents is huge.  But maybe because she hasn't been tainted like the other super anti 2a's on the committee (Rhodes, Lee, K). So it's a step to keep them reminded that they are supposed to serve the people and not push their own agenda.

Acasio was appointed, not elected. So she does not truly represent any constituency that chose her over others. Even if she did, the constituency of almost all Hawaii districts is overwhelmingly Democrat registration, so they'd want her to pass any and all "gun safety regulations". How are you going to educate and inform those who have no interest or motivation to be educated or informed? They are the ones that elect the government.

It all needs to start some where.  And the attitude of "it wont help" or "no sense cause we still don't have the #s" is the mentality that got us where we are today. 

You really think that calling a commie fascist authoritarian (aka "Democrat") and politely ("honey, not vinegar") asking them to vote against the orders of their bosses is a "mentality" that will change the unconstitutional laws? Why would you think that?

But it is much easier to voice your opinions due to the internet. When the pistol mag ban came around in the 90's the internet wasn't what it was today.  So maybe much of the older guys weren't aware and didn't make that call to their senator/rep.  IDK cause I wasn't in the culture at the time so I'm just guessing. Same goes with registration.

How long has the internet been around? How many unconstitutional laws re the right to keep and bear arms have been passed in Hawaii during that time? I believe your hypothesis fails, bigly.

If someone could post estimates of what was done to stop the pistol mag ban and registration that would been nice.  Like how when the SB301 came up, we got 1100 oppose testimonies.  Where the #s like that back in the 90s?

SB301, with "1100 opposed testimonies" (at least 10, and maybe 20 times those testimonies in favor) passed committee 5 to 3.

Just called. Senator San Buenaventura's office says they don't know how she's going to vote (haha), but will get back to me. Rep. Onishi's office says he's not on judiciary committee, which is where it will go in the House if it passes the Senate floor vote, so it's a bit in the future... call the house judiciary chair's office if it passes the senate floor vote.

Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: 6716J on March 08, 2021, 11:04:47 AM
Response from Sen Kidani..

Aloha XXXX,

 

Mahalo for taking the time to reach out with your thoughtful opposition to SB307 SD1. You make many valid points on the bill. I would like to note that in reviewing the testimony, multiple testifiers noted that they, or someone they knew, currently possessed and used firearms that fire .50 caliber ammunition. One testifier noted that a hunter used a .500 S&W revolver to hunt in addition to rifles.

 

I also appreciate the Judiciary Chair’s effort to exempt black-powder rifles and shotguns, as noted in the testimony was an unintended consequence of the bill.

 

In this instance, we will have to agree to disagree on further gun restrictions as I will likely vote for the bill when it comes to the floor for third reading. But I will note that it does have a defective date, meaning it must go to conference for discussion, and will see what the House plans on doing with the bill. I hope that I can continue to serve and assist you in other ways as your Senator.

 

 

Senator Michelle Kidani
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 08, 2021, 11:40:19 AM
1) I don't think the honey vs. vinegar is useful at all. To me, it all depends who you're talking to.  My senator who had an aide answer the phone was super nice and surprised when I spoke to her in a honey tone. Now had I used vinegar, I think she would be more defensive and not willing to give the info I gave.  But if I had to talk direct to my senator, then she's a moron and more a mix of honey and vinegar would be needed.  But not 100% vinegar.

2) The net being around and being used by majority of the people is a huge thing IMO.  Yes back in 94, the net may have been available, but there probably weren't as many users or pages as there are today. Even for myself, I didn't start to use it on a regular basis until after 2002 when I grad high school.  The social media at the time was mainly Asian Avenue, and Myspace was just starting to take off.  So to expect the NRA or like org to have a page and coordinate like how HIFICO would be low.  We only got into the 2a in 2016, so when it comes to bills and stuff, I only have XP from 16 to now, but really 2017 because I missed the RAPBACK bills.  When I went to my first hearing, there were only about 6 of us there and about 12 Moms, this was in 2017.

3) Buenaventura (Joy?) did vote against the bill last year that would reduce the time to lend a rifle/shotty from 15 days to 24 hours or something.  She was asking HPD  good questions and bringing up hunting trips that last a week or longer. After all the discussion, it circled back to 15 days and the bill died.  So when speaking to her, I would use mix vinegar and honey.  Because she is more anti2a than pro 2a.  But guess the hunters called her and were concerned.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 08, 2021, 11:41:25 AM
Response from Sen Kidani..

Aloha XXXX,

 

Mahalo for taking the time to reach out with your thoughtful opposition to SB307 SD1. You make many valid points on the bill. I would like to note that in reviewing the testimony, multiple testifiers noted that they, or someone they knew, currently possessed and used firearms that fire .50 caliber ammunition. One testifier noted that a hunter used a .500 S&W revolver to hunt in addition to rifles.

 

I also appreciate the Judiciary Chair’s effort to exempt black-powder rifles and shotguns, as noted in the testimony was an unintended consequence of the bill.

 

In this instance, we will have to agree to disagree on further gun restrictions as I will likely vote for the bill when it comes to the floor for third reading. But I will note that it does have a defective date, meaning it must go to conference for discussion, and will see what the House plans on doing with the bill. I hope that I can continue to serve and assist you in other ways as your Senator.

 

 

Senator Michelle Kidani

At least you didn't get a cookie cutter response.  And a "I support the 2a, but...".
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: Bota-CS1 on March 08, 2021, 12:38:36 PM
At least you didn't get a cookie cutter response.  And a "I support the 2a, but...".

Dear Ms Kidanj,

The fact that the chair had no clue his bill would prohibit black powder rifles and shotguns should have been your first clue Mr. Rhoads has no idea what he’s doing.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: omnigun on March 08, 2021, 03:19:20 PM

Bunch of angery snip


Its about accomplishing your goal. If you want someone to listen and take your side calling them awful things isn't the best way...That's not how politics work.  Democrats are people too...
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: robtmc on March 08, 2021, 03:26:04 PM
.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 08, 2021, 03:30:19 PM
..

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: punaperson on March 08, 2021, 04:47:37 PM

Bunch of angery snip
That's not a quote from me asshole. I know how to spell.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: punaperson on March 09, 2021, 10:05:18 AM
Anyone know the approximate time to expect vote results today on these bills?
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 09, 2021, 11:42:26 AM
Both passed.

SB301-19Aye's, 2 with reservatons, and 6 nays

SB307-21 Aye's-1 with reservations and 4 nays
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: hvybarrels on March 09, 2021, 11:55:15 AM
On the positive side if they tried to pass this during good economic times with low crime then the backlash they are now facing would be much less severe. On the negative side they just convinced tens of thousands of citizens that it is better to be a criminal than to trust the government with their information.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: punaperson on March 09, 2021, 12:21:41 PM
Both passed.

SB301-19Aye's, 2 with reservatons, and 6 nays

SB307-21 Aye's-1 with reservations and 4 nays
Thanks. That overwhelming amount of public testimony in opposition, and all the honey-coated phone calls really did the trick! Oh, wait... never mind. They only got 76% and 84% for passage... think how much worse it would have been without all that testimony and honey-baked calling!

I submitted my honey-coated call to San Buenaventura's office the other day... he said he didn't know how she'd be voting and they would get back to me. Haven't heard a word. Maybe they'll call sometime next month? I'll be sure to make another really nice honeyed phone call to them again in the near future.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: punaperson on March 09, 2021, 12:25:11 PM
On the positive side if they tried to pass this during good economic times with low crime then the backlash they are now facing would be much less severe. On the negative side they just convinced tens of thousands of citizens that it is better to be a criminal than to trust the government with their information.
Backlash? What kind of backlash? From whom? To what degree? Are you implying enough backlash that they won't be re-elected, forever? I see them getting back pats, not lashes.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: zippz on March 09, 2021, 12:51:44 PM
Thanks. That overwhelming amount of public testimony in opposition, and all the honey-coated phone calls really did the trick! Oh, wait... never mind. They only got 76% and 84% for passage... think how much worse it would have been without all that testimony and honey-baked calling!

I submitted my honey-coated call to San Buenaventura's office the other day... he said he didn't know how she'd be voting and they would get back to me. Haven't heard a word. Maybe they'll call sometime next month? I'll be sure to make another really nice honeyed phone call to them again in the near future.

The effort did make a difference.  Last year the mag ban vote was 23 aye, 2 noes.  I was expecting 21 ayes and 4 noes today.  So 2 reservations and 6 noes from a strong anti-2A Senate is good progress.  If we can get more done in the nest of the year, more people talking and seeing their Senators, maybe we can shoot for 3 reservations and 9 noes next year.  This would get us ready for the majority in 2023 for major bills like this, though we'd still lose on other lesser 2A bills and we still wouldn't be able to push for CCW or other pro2A stuff yet.

How fast it goes depends on how much effort everyone(hundreds or thousands of people) will put into it.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: hvybarrels on March 09, 2021, 01:37:29 PM
Good point. There are appreciable gains, and with populist anger on the rise among the voters they will not be able to continue to ignore us for much longer.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 09, 2021, 03:57:33 PM
My senator votes with res on 301. Maybe was my call or others. Idk. But when i spoke to her in person last year, she is very anti 2a. Like chris lee anti 2a.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 09, 2021, 04:09:13 PM
I remember a PBS "debate" with pro-2A HRA members and supporters arguing against increased gun control laws, and Peter Carlisle along with other anti-gun politicians arguing for increasing gun control laws.

Carlisle tried making the point that 50 caliber sniper rifles were designed to put a hole in the engine block of a vehicle.  Nobody in Hawaii "NEEDS" a gun designed to do that.  He mentioned the "possibility" of someone taking out a departing aircraft with one of these weapons.  As if that's ever happened in the history of our country.   :wtf:

It's no surprise that his wish is now coming true.  After all, isn't it government's role to decide how to provide what everybody in the state needs while banning the things we do not need -- all based on their decision which category things fall under?

It's not about guns or violence.  It's all about control.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: drck1000 on March 09, 2021, 04:31:28 PM
SNIP

It's not about guns or violence.  It's all about control.
But, but, but to what end. . .

[sarcasm]
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: zippz on March 09, 2021, 05:40:45 PM
My senator votes with res on 301. Maybe was my call or others. Idk. But when i spoke to her in person last year, she is very anti 2a. Like chris lee anti 2a.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

I talked to Morikawa at her breakfast meetings with the community.  She seemed strong anti, but I got the feeling she didn't know anything about guns.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: 6716J on March 09, 2021, 06:51:36 PM
SB307 - ?????
 :wtf:  SECTION 4.  This Act shall take effect on May 6, 2137.

Not that I support this and tried to get my Sen opposing it but why wait for 2137 to enact it?
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 09, 2021, 07:01:45 PM
Well at least they made an exemption for shotguns and muzzle loaders so I guess our input did temper the bill some. Not a win so much as making it not as bad a loss.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: macsak on March 09, 2021, 07:09:59 PM
SB307 - ?????
 :wtf:  SECTION 4.  This Act shall take effect on May 6, 2137.

Not that I support this and tried to get my Sen opposing it but why wait for 2137 to enact it?

it's a placeholder date
it will be amended later
just ignore it...
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: Ashiya on March 09, 2021, 07:15:59 PM
Senate floor session on YouTube:

SB307
https://youtu.be/IarzjoosuNc?t=2460

SB301
https://youtu.be/IarzjoosuNc?t=3962
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: 6716J on March 10, 2021, 01:01:05 PM
Senate floor session on YouTube:

SB307
https://youtu.be/IarzjoosuNc?t=2460

SB301
https://youtu.be/IarzjoosuNc?t=3962

At least Fevella stood up and read the part of the State Constitution the rest are violating
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 10, 2021, 01:54:18 PM
Favella is awesome for the 2a right. 
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: robtmc on March 10, 2021, 04:42:00 PM
Good point. There are appreciable gains, and with populist anger on the rise among the voters they will not be able to continue to ignore us for much longer.

Meanwhile, thousands of Hawaii residents with politically incorrect magazines are screwed and criminals the moment Igeee signs this thing..

Anyone remember the last time an anti-2A law was repealed here?

Did not think so.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: hvybarrels on March 10, 2021, 07:56:54 PM
Meanwhile, thousands of Hawaii residents with politically incorrect magazines are screwed and criminals the moment Igeee signs this thing..

Anyone remember the last time an anti-2A law was repealed here?

Did not think so.

One would hope that in a year of unimaginable changes that we would be able to see the possibilities that did not exist before. A lot of it comes down to attitude as well. Quitters get what quitters deserve.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: punaperson on March 11, 2021, 09:18:48 AM
One would hope that in a year of unimaginable changes that we would be able to see the possibilities that did not exist before.

Haha. Good one. Yeah, we see "the possibilities that did not exist before" clear as day: whimpering bent over cowering sheeple obediently doing whatever they are told without question, no matter how irrational or scientifically baseless... AND then violently attacking those who refuse to comply... Stockholm syndrome. What does that portend?

A lot of it comes down to attitude as well. Quitters get what quitters deserve.

Yeah, and delusionals get what delusionals deserve.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 11, 2021, 11:17:48 AM
Article in the Civil Beat. The House chair says most likely he will not give SB301 a hearing.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: drck1000 on March 11, 2021, 11:21:43 AM
Article in the Civil Beat. The House chair says most likely he will not give SB301 a hearing.
Yup, saw that.  Mark Nakashima documented as his stance.  Hopefully he'll follow through on that statement.

I liked his perspective on the issue.  It was good to see some "common sense" being applied at that level. 
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: zippz on March 11, 2021, 12:45:59 PM
Article in the Civil Beat. The House chair says most likely he will not give SB301 a hearing.

Can you provide a link for that, I can't find it.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 11, 2021, 12:46:59 PM
Can you provide a link for that, I can't find it.

https://www.civilbeat.org/2021/02/ban-on-large-capacity-rifle-magazines-clears-committee/?fbclid=IwAR3ZBT26EJ8IXz5kTCl-1aEAvPecWD82vh5ApJdgkEi2MTe9rrA4xXPhUu8
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: zippz on March 11, 2021, 01:00:14 PM
Yup, saw that.  Mark Nakashima documented as his stance.  Hopefully he'll follow through on that statement.

I liked his perspective on the issue.  It was good to see some "common sense" being applied at that level.

Interesting, Nakashima voted FOR the mag ban last year.  Wonder what changed his mind since then.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: drck1000 on March 11, 2021, 01:07:32 PM
Interesting, Nakashima voted FOR the mag ban last year.  Wonder what changed his mind since then.
Yeah.  He was shockingly "neutral" on this.  Hopefully a sign that feedback is being received and noted.  Not holding my breath, but hopeful. 
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: macsak on March 11, 2021, 01:21:52 PM
Can you provide a link for that, I can't find it.

focus
i emailed you the link this morning...
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: robtmc on March 11, 2021, 05:21:33 PM
Article in the Civil Beat. The House chair says most likely he will not give SB301 a hearing.
What does that imply, done deal and shove it for all those that supplied opposition?
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: drck1000 on March 11, 2021, 05:29:49 PM
What does that imply, done deal and shove it for all those that supplied opposition?
Opposite.  He stated that he's doesn't intend to hear the bill.  So if he follows through, it's DeD. 
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: 6716J on March 11, 2021, 06:26:33 PM
Bad and good from Nakashima

"When asked if Hawaii has gone too far in its firearms restrictions, Nakashima replied that “I don’t know that you can ever go too far, but for the time being I’d like to take a more moderate look at things rather than just outlawing everything in front of us.”"
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: drck1000 on March 11, 2021, 11:32:52 PM
Bad and good from Nakashima

"When asked if Hawaii has gone too far in its firearms restrictions, Nakashima replied that “I don’t know that you can ever go too far, but for the time being I’d like to take a more moderate look at things rather than just outlawing everything in front of us.”"
Yeah, I noticed that too.  I was hoping it was a planned response to sort of play to "think of the children" types.  I hope he's not just talking out of both sides of his ass and follows through with the green. 
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: punaperson on March 12, 2021, 07:40:58 AM
Bad and good from Nakashima

"When asked if Hawaii has gone too far in its firearms restrictions, Nakashima replied that “I don’t know that you can ever go too far, but for the time being I’d like to take a more moderate look at things rather than just outlawing everything in front of us.”"
Qualifier: "for the time being"... i.e. tomorrow "go too far"... no problem.

Qualifier: can never "go too far"... that's exactly what the Nazis (and every other dictator who first disarmed the civilian population before the serious mass killing begins) said. For the public good (health, crime, whatever...) firearm possession needs to be a capital crime. Nakashima is a Nazi at heart, he just (uncharacteristically honestly for a politician) said so. We've seen what the sheeple will accept in terms of total violations of their rights and liberties... does anyone really believe the masses will "draw the line" at anything? They're too fucking stupid/ignorant/apathetic to care, as long as they get their handout.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 12, 2021, 08:23:40 PM
Yeah.  He was shockingly "neutral" on this.  Hopefully a sign that feedback is being received and noted.  Not holding my breath, but hopeful.

Maybe he became a firearm owner?
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: obm on March 15, 2021, 08:56:26 AM
Can't we file an injunction to prevent the magazine ban to go forward due to pending federal cases re: the issue?  Does not make sense if the state mag ban passes, magazines are destroyed, then if the federal courts rule mags are legal gun owners needlessly forfeited their magazines.

Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: zippz on March 15, 2021, 09:01:53 AM
Can't we file an injunction to prevent the magazine ban to go forward due to pending federal cases re: the issue?  Does not make sense if the state mag ban passes, magazines are destroyed, then if the federal courts rule mags are legal gun owners needlessly forfeited their magazines.

Gonna cost at least $10k to file an injunction.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: robtmc on March 15, 2021, 09:22:47 AM
then if the federal courts rule mags are legal gun owners needlessly forfeited their magazines.
Of course HPD would immediately return them, of course they would.......    :shake:
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 15, 2021, 01:40:55 PM
Gonna cost at least $10k to file an injunction.

Need $100 from 100 people.  Or $50 from 200.  And so on. Or Since we had 1100 oppose testimony, about $10 from each person.  That would be the hailmary pass if needed.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: Brystont1 on March 15, 2021, 03:29:12 PM
Can't we file an injunction to prevent the magazine ban to go forward due to pending federal cases re: the issue?  Does not make sense if the state mag ban passes, magazines are destroyed, then if the federal courts rule mags are legal gun owners needlessly forfeited their magazines.

Just don’t forfeit your mags. They are unenforceable anyway.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: punaperson on March 15, 2021, 04:31:54 PM
Just don’t forfeit your mags. They are unenforceable anyway.
I hope you're not suggesting mass criminality via intentional non-compliance (with an unconstitutional law), because... that's illegal.

That's what took place at Lexington and Concord, and look what happened there... oh... wait...
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 15, 2021, 06:28:59 PM
I hope you're not suggesting mass criminality via intentional non-compliance (with an unconstitutional law), because... that's illegal.

That's what took place at Lexington and Concord, and look what happened there... oh... wait...

If I interpreted his comment correctly, he's stating that disassembled magazines are no longer capable of holding and feeding any rounds of ammo at all -- zero is well within the 10 rd limit.

Magazine parts kits are not magazines/ammunition feeding devices.

That's what I thought he was saying, anyway.   :geekdanc: :thumbsup:
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: punaperson on March 16, 2021, 08:06:23 AM
If I interpreted his comment correctly, he's stating that disassembled magazines are no longer capable of holding and feeding any rounds of ammo at all -- zero is well within the 10 rd limit.

Magazine parts kits are not magazines/ammunition feeding devices.

That's what I thought he was saying, anyway.   :geekdanc: :thumbsup:
Yeah, that's what he said! Of course. Now look for an amendment to the current bill. I'm just sayin'...

By the way... the dodderheads writing these bills are dumb-as-shit morons.

Here is how they introduce the ban on magazines:

"SECTION 1.  The purpose of this Act is to expand the ban on pistols with a detachable magazine with over ten round capacity to any firearm with a detachable magazine with over ten round capacity."

In Sectioin 2, which has the actual language change to the law, only magazines are referenced, not firearms.

The bill, as written above, passed three readings in the Senate, including a committee, and passed it's first reading in the House. smh.

Fucking idiots.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 16, 2021, 10:04:51 AM
If I interpreted his comment correctly, he's stating that disassembled magazines are no longer capable of holding and feeding any rounds of ammo at all -- zero is well within the 10 rd limit.

Magazine parts kits are not magazines/ammunition feeding devices.

That's what I thought he was saying, anyway.   :geekdanc: :thumbsup:

No one here does anything illegal.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 16, 2021, 11:12:48 AM
No one here does anything illegal.

Who said anything about breaking the law?  A disassembled parts kit holds 0 rounds. 
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: 6716J on March 16, 2021, 12:16:45 PM
If I interpreted his comment correctly, he's stating that disassembled magazines are no longer capable of holding and feeding any rounds of ammo at all -- zero is well within the 10 rd limit.

Magazine parts kits are not magazines/ammunition feeding devices.

That's what I thought he was saying, anyway.   :geekdanc: :thumbsup:

Yeah and "80%" parts aren't firearms either. Look how that turned out.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 16, 2021, 12:49:43 PM
Yeah and "80%" parts aren't firearms either. Look how that turned out.

Ghost guns were already illegal in Hawaii before the Ghost Gun bill.  Now, the law basically forces everyone to buy 100% lowers/frames.

Why buy a serialized 80% to mill then register when you can just buy a completed receiver and do the same registration BS?

Of course, nothing prevents anyone from traveling to the mainland, buying an 80% receiver, and bringing it back. 

Gun laws which ban products never prevent the behavior they purport to prevent.  They mostly tend to turn law abiding gun owners into felons overnight. 

So, if 30rd AR15 mags suddenly become illegal to own, and they overlooked the obvious, it'll take time -- and probably a few cases demonstrating the flaw in the bill -- before they can pass any changes.  Their biggest issue is they don't understand the problem they are pretending to solve.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: robtmc on March 16, 2021, 01:03:05 PM
Why buy a serialized 80% to mill then register when you can just buy a completed receiver and do the same registration BS?

Just posted that thought on another thread, makes no sense to go through all that crapl
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 16, 2021, 02:07:31 PM

So, if 30rd AR15 mags suddenly become illegal to own, and they overlooked the obvious, it'll take time -- and probably a few cases demonstrating the flaw in the bill -- before they can pass any changes.  Their biggest issue is they don't understand the problem they are pretending to solve.

They can always amend the bills later once it's law to read "any combination of parts".   Something similar is happening now with the ghost guns bill.  They are changing the retro active date from Sept 2020 to none.

NOw they want to ban 50 cal guns.  How much longer until 338 or other calibers?  Their entire goal is to take little by little until it's the entire pie.
Title: Re: SB307 50 cal & SB301 10rd rifle mags
Post by: ren on March 16, 2021, 02:09:10 PM
they still need 60 votes....oh...wrong...