2aHawaii

General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: Brystont1 on April 22, 2021, 08:09:04 PM

Title: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: Brystont1 on April 22, 2021, 08:09:04 PM
 I have not seen anyone here successfully refute Omnigun on the issue of these passports. Perhaps he is right about them. I’m starting a new thread here because the COVID cult thread is so hard to follow so I figured a thread dedicated specifically to this issue would be ok (mods feel free to lock/delete if I’m wrong).

Now I am not for these passports personally. We haven’t needed something like this for any other type of pathogen/disease. I’ve never had to show a negative TB card and they’re talking about annual vaccinations on COVID now. Technically they won’t be mandatory but you won’t be able to do shit like fly or go on vacation so basically if you want to have a life you’ll need to get the vaccine and show proof. Omnigun does make a good point that we do require proof of safety in other areas of our lives like for driving. I don’t believe that these comparisons to “nazis” and “fascist” are accurate. Why shouldn’t we have a vaccine passport to prove that we’ve been vaccinated? What rights do they actually violate?
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 22, 2021, 08:26:42 PM
1 right is to freely travel between states. The government knows this and is working on backdoor type of restrictions.

Does someone with HIV need to show any type of paperwork when traveling, engaging in a relationship, work, eat at a restaurant?

Once a passport starts, where will it end? Like gun control, ban 1 part at a time (mags, foregrips, etc...).

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: Glasser on April 22, 2021, 08:32:54 PM


Does someone with HIV need to show any type of paperwork when traveling, engaging in a relationship, work, eat at a restaurant?



The people screaming for you to get vaccinated are the same ones who decriminalized knowingly infecting someone with HIV / AIDS. None of this is about health and safety.

https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/new-california-law-reduces-penalty-knowingly-exposing-someone-hiv-n809416



 
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: drck1000 on April 22, 2021, 08:33:20 PM
Meh. Already have fake vaxx cards...

[sarcasm\]
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 22, 2021, 08:33:49 PM
I have not seen anyone here successfully refute Omnigun on the issue of these passports. Perhaps he is right about them. I’m starting a new thread here because the COVID cult thread is so hard to follow so I figured a thread dedicated specifically to this issue would be ok (mods feel free to lock/delete if I’m wrong).

Now I am not for these passports personally. We haven’t needed something like this for any other type of pathogen/disease. I’ve never had to show a negative TB card and they’re talking about annual vaccinations on COVID now. Technically they won’t be mandatory but you won’t be able to do shit like fly or go on vacation so basically if you want to have a life you’ll need to get the vaccine and show proof. Omnigun does make a good point that we do require proof of safety in other areas of our lives like for driving. I don’t believe that these comparisons to “nazis” and “fascist” are accurate. Why shouldn’t we have a vaccine passport to prove that we’ve been vaccinated? What rights do they actually violate?

Name another disease we make people prove they have been vaccinated against to travel or attend ball games.

Name a disease that we require they inform us they DO have so they can be barred against similar activities.

When HIV/AIDS was first identified, and a test was developed to detect its presence, a person's HIV status was being used to terminate employment, ban from school sports and professional sports, from entering the military, etc.  We now take precautions (gloves, respirators, proper needle disposal, etc) to prevent infections rather than limiting what people with the infection can or can't do.

If the passports identified people ACTUALLY INFECTED AT THE TIME with COVID-19, like using a finger stick and blood sample, then I'd be all for it.  But the vaccine in no way means you are safe from infecting others.  It only means you are vaccinated.  The length of time since your last vaccination, how many shots you've had, and whether you've been exposed to anyone with the virus in the last couple of days factors in more than some vaccination passport.  People with both vaccination shots are still being tested positive.  Yet, they have a passport.  The uninfected guy with 2 teenage kids and a wife trying to visit a hospitalized relative will, however, be banned from flying if they don't all have passports.

The overall effectiveness of the passport system is in question.  What will it accomplish?  To me, it's a solution that doesn't fix anything.  It'll force people who don't trust the vaccine's longterm side effects to get the shot while guaranteeing nothing related to stopping the spread of the virus.

Then there's the high probability that there will be counterfeit passports or legit passports being sold/given out without the accompanying vaccinations.  That absolutely won't stop infections in any way.

Flying is already a massive invasion of our privacy and takes too much time and effort to clear the security hurdles.  Passports will be one more snafu to delay travel on top of the normal stack of snafus.
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: Glasser on April 22, 2021, 08:35:20 PM
Meh. Already have fake vaxx cards...

[sarcasm\]

FBI thinks it might be a good idea to put you in prison for that.

https://www.wect.com/2021/04/16/fbi-warns-against-making-or-buying-fake-covid-vaccination-cards/

Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: drck1000 on April 22, 2021, 08:38:41 PM
FBI thinks it might be a good idea to put you in prison for that.

https://www.wect.com/2021/04/16/fbi-warns-against-making-or-buying-fake-covid-vaccination-cards/
Interesting. But my point was the vaxx card is about as verifiable as your SSN card.
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: omnigun on April 22, 2021, 09:22:18 PM
Name another disease we make people prove they have been vaccinated against to travel or attend ball games.

Name a disease that we require they inform us they DO have so they can be barred against similar activities.

When HIV/AIDS was first identified, and a test was developed to detect its presence, a person's HIV status was being used to terminate employment, ban from school sports and professional sports, from entering the military, etc.  We now take precautions (gloves, respirators, proper needle disposal, etc) to prevent infections rather than limiting what people with the infection can or can't do.

If the passports identified people ACTUALLY INFECTED AT THE TIME with COVID-19, like using a finger stick and blood sample, then I'd be all for it.  But the vaccine in no way means you are safe from infecting others.  It only means you are vaccinated.  The length of time since your last vaccination, how many shots you've had, and whether you've been exposed to anyone with the virus in the last couple of days factors in more than some vaccination passport.  People with both vaccination shots are still being tested positive.  Yet, they have a passport.  The uninfected guy with 2 teenage kids and a wife trying to visit a hospitalized relative will, however, be banned from flying if they don't all have passports.

The overall effectiveness of the passport system is in question.  What will it accomplish?  To me, it's a solution that doesn't fix anything.  It'll force people who don't trust the vaccine's longterm side effects to get the shot while guaranteeing nothing related to stopping the spread of the virus.

Then there's the high probability that there will be counterfeit passports or legit passports being sold/given out without the accompanying vaccinations.  That absolutely won't stop infections in any way.

Flying is already a massive invasion of our privacy and takes too much time and effort to clear the security hurdles.  Passports will be one more snafu to delay travel on top of the normal stack of snafus.

Many major pandemics.  The Spanish flu saw many of the same restrictions as our current pandemic and American survived without freedom lost. 

We already require privacy invasive passports to fly to other countries and ID cards for interstate airline travel.  So a passport for covid is nothing extreme.  Unless you are open borders passports are a necessity to prove citizenship and safety.

We require proof of vaccination for school and some jobs already for other viruses.

A business can already turn you away for not wearing shoes,  they can turn you away for not being vaccinated.

Israel has shown passports get more people vaccinated. Which brings everyone closer to herd immunity. Which is a good thing.  It also allows those vaccinated which have the least risk to get and pass covid the ability to resume social lives.  And contribute to the economy.

If a club can give permission to enter purely based off age, which is based off an ID.  And refuse you to enter for any reason including you being drunk, etc.  Then they can do the same with vaccinations.

And like the covid thread that need I remind you Israel the least nazi country in the world uses passports and other measures.

Other related items I can think of.  You need license/identification to purchase a certain drink with certain effects.  You need license/identification to smoke.  You need license/identification to go into certain venues like clubs.  You need license/identification to look at humans with no clothes.  You need license/identification to dispense medicine.  You need license/identification to prescribe medicine.  You need license/identification to clean teeth.  You need license/identification to travel.  You need license/identification to drive/fly.  You need license/identification to purchase guns. You need license/identification for hundreds of jobs and reasons. 
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: omnigun on April 22, 2021, 09:23:30 PM
FBI thinks it might be a good idea to put you in prison for that.

https://www.wect.com/2021/04/16/fbi-warns-against-making-or-buying-fake-covid-vaccination-cards/

Good send them to jail. That's like fake ID and passports.
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: omnigun on April 22, 2021, 09:31:42 PM
1 right is to freely travel between states. The government knows this and is working on backdoor type of restrictions.

Does someone with HIV need to show any type of paperwork when traveling, engaging in a relationship, work, eat at a restaurant?

Once a passport starts, where will it end? Like gun control, ban 1 part at a time (mags, foregrips, etc...).

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Like previously argued HIV is not as lethal, is not easily spread.  And yes 100% you should need to show that you have HIV before engaging in behaviors like donating blood or sex that put others at risk.   Just like someone with covid should remain quarantined till they don't pose a threat anymore.

Passports have nothing to do with gun control.  With that arguments, background checks will lead to gun control, drivers licenses, voting records, medical charts. 
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: omnigun on April 22, 2021, 09:32:33 PM
The people screaming for you to get vaccinated are the same ones who decriminalized knowingly infecting someone with HIV / AIDS. None of this is about health and safety.

https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/new-california-law-reduces-penalty-knowingly-exposing-someone-hiv-n809416


Yeah those people are stupid and should be voted out.  I am strongly against that law.
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: Glasser on April 22, 2021, 09:37:59 PM
Interesting. But my point was the vaxx card is about as verifiable as your SSN card.

I concur, I personally found the FBI making empty threats of 'you MIGHT be breaking the law' pretty pathetic. 
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: QUIETShooter on April 23, 2021, 06:31:14 AM
The government is getting too big.  It's sticking it's nose and hands into every aspect of life.

Communism.
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 23, 2021, 09:05:05 AM
The government is getting too big.  It's sticking it's nose and hands into every aspect of life.

Communism.

Funny how 1 person is supposedly against more government control, but yet is 100% fine with vaxx passports. #facepalm
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: Kuleana on April 23, 2021, 10:06:00 AM
The government is getting too big.  It's sticking it's nose and hands into every aspect of life.

Communism.
Keep in mind, having a large central government that works to control every aspect of life, is akin to an empire as well.

Until the power okole nationalizes every business and confiscates private property, the predominant economic system in America is still neo-feudalism.  The banks, large landowners, and corporations on the top, an ever-decreasing merchant class, and everybody else on the bottom, with an insufficient bureaucratized welfare system, to placate the poor and have nots, so they don't get any ideas to overthrow the body politic.
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: hvybarrels on April 23, 2021, 02:19:56 PM
Why do you people hate freedom so much? Would you not feel more comfortable on Reddit with the rest of the bootlickers?
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: 6716J on April 23, 2021, 04:18:10 PM
Commiefornia to mandate vaccinations for all students and faculty. Wonder how that's gonna work out for them financially.

(https://i.imgflip.com/56xlqc.jpg)
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: omnigun on April 23, 2021, 04:27:27 PM
Commiefornia to mandate vaccinations for all students and faculty. Wonder how that's gonna work out for them financially.

(https://i.imgflip.com/56xlqc.jpg)

Great.  Most schools require vaccinations to attend.  This is nothing out of norm.
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 23, 2021, 04:38:28 PM
Great.  Most schools require vaccinations to attend.  This is nothing out of norm.

I've never known a single school that required a flu shot for attendance.

Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: hvybarrels on April 23, 2021, 04:45:22 PM
I've never known a single school that required a flu shot for attendance.

Some of them do, but not usually for questionable experimental drugs that specifically target diseases that young healthy people do not have to worry about
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: drck1000 on April 23, 2021, 04:49:30 PM
I concur, I personally found the FBI making empty threats of 'you MIGHT be breaking the law' pretty pathetic.
Ahh, gotcha. . .

Yeah, those intent on breaking laws are gonna be shakin. . . just like how criminals are affected by laws and threats of when they MIGHT be breaking laws. . .
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 23, 2021, 04:52:23 PM
Some of them do, but not usually for questionable experimental drugs that specifically target diseases that young healthy people do not have to worry about

Since the COVID vaccines are NOT being made available for minors, schools requiring shots is a catch-22 situation.

Who sets the arbitrary age cut-off for requiring the shots?  Do all minors mature at the same rate?  Will all 13 year olds be identical in their reaction to the vaccine?
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: Glasser on April 23, 2021, 08:06:57 PM
Since the COVID vaccines are NOT being made available for minors, schools requiring shots is a catch-22 situation.

Who sets the arbitrary age cut-off for requiring the shots?  Do all minors mature at the same rate?  Will all 13 year olds be identical in their reaction to the vaccine?

Kaiser sent me an email yesterday saying 16 yrs and older is  on the table to get vaccinated now. I dont know why any parent would let their kid get that stuff shot in them.

Does no one remember Thalidomide?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thalidomide

https://usthalidomide.org/our-story-thalidomide-babies-us/
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: hvybarrels on April 23, 2021, 08:18:18 PM
My theory is if they want to cut me out of the economy then I will beat them to the punch. There are way too many fun projects fixing old stuff to ever get bored, so why do I need to work my butt off for shiny new crap that falls apart faster anyway? Books are cheaper than concerts and movies, and there are plenty of waves to surf on this island so I really do not have to travel by plane. Even cooking at home is way healthier and you save a ton of money. If the beast wants to tell me how to live then the beast can get on without my support.
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: Jl808 on April 24, 2021, 06:35:34 AM
Here is a good article that doesn't just parrot what the leftists / statists are pushing but actually discussing the ethics of mandatory vaccinations

https://www.newstatesman.com/science-tech/coronavirus/2020/12/would-mandatory-covid-19-vaccine-be-ethically-justified

Quote
If we believe that widespread lockdowns are acceptable in the face of Covid-19, then we should also believe that mandatory vaccination is acceptable. Likewise, if we accept the Mental Health Act 1983, which permits compulsory medical treatment of detained persons in certain circumstances, then we should accept that there is basis for mandatory Covid-19 in the law. These are the – rather contentious – arguments that a group of ethicists made to the UK government when it solicited evidence on the human rights implications of the pandemic."

"This has led ethicists to ask whether mandatory Covid-19 vaccination could be ethically justified. The answer involves a complex trade-off between personal autonomy, bodily integrity and the public good."

(snip)

"The ethical arguments for mandatory vaccination are typically based on ensuring the best outcome for the greatest number of people. There remain many uncertainties about what would be required to build herd immunity to Covid-19 taking into account the current crop of vaccines, but for other diseases herd immunity has been achieved with a mixture of natural and vaccine-induced immunity. Once the herd immunity threshold is reached within a population, vulnerable people who are unable to be vaccinated are protected regardless. For Covid-19, estimates of the herd immunity threshold typically hover between 60 and 70 per cent."

"The director of the Uehiro Centre, Julian Savulescu, writes that from an ethics perspective, a number of conditions should be met in order to justify a mandatory vaccination programme, including that: “there is a grave threat to public health", "the vaccine is safe and effective", "mandatory vaccination has a superior cost/benefit profile compared with other alternatives" and "the level of coercion is proportionate”.

Douglas has examined the third of these conditions in the context of Covid-19, looking at the trade-off between a mandatory vaccine and lockdown restrictions. In ethical terms, what do we consider more acceptable, a mandatory lockdown or a mandatory vaccine? Do we hold freedom of movement or freedom from nonconsensual bodily interference (what is known in ethics literature as the “right to bodily integrity”) in greater regard?"

(snip)

Many of us would judge the latter to be a greater violation of the convict’s rights, even if it would allow him to live a free life outside prison. “It is taken as an assumption by a lot of lawyers and ethicists that the right to bodily integrity is somehow more fundamental and stronger than the right to free movement and association,” said Douglas. This belief stems partly from the horrific historical precedents for medical experimentation on prisoners.

(snip)

Many have challenged the ethical basis for lockdowns on the grounds that there is not sufficient evidence that they work, that the interventions aren’t proportionate to the threat, and/or that the infringement on civil liberties is too egregious or the consequences too grave. Legal action has been taken against lockdowns in the UK, the US and elsewhere.

“Bodily integrity really goes back to questions of personal autonomy, so ‘I should only be jammed in the arm with a needle if I’ve agreed to do that with full information and consent’,” said Hugh Whittall, the director of the Nuffield Council on Bioethics. “To interfere with that autonomy to make decisions that concern my body, or my choices, has to be justified by some overarching public health requirement.”

The Nuffield Council has issued guidance advising that mandatory vaccines are only acceptable when the disease in question is extremely deadly or if a country is very close to entirely eradicating a disease. “It’s difficult to see that the current situation is one that would meet that threshold to justify an overall mandatory vaccination,” said Whittall.

(snip)

When coronavirus first started spreading through China and Italy, scientists estimated that the CFR could be as high as 15 per cent. Since then, this figure has been dramatically revised downwards; for example, in England in August it was 1.5 per cent. Data from Iceland, where the most testing per capita has been carried out, suggests that the IFR could be as low as 0.03 to 0.28 per cent. A review by John Ioannidis, published in October in the Bulletin of the World Health Organization, finds a median IFR of 0.2 across 51 locations. The UK government downgraded Covid-19 from a high-consequence infectious disease in March.

(snip)

Another dimension in the ethical debate over mandatory vaccination is whether the vaccine is safe and effective. All medical interventions come with some element of risk, and that includes vaccines. Rigorous safety trials keep the risk very low, but if a drug is administered to millions, or even billions of people (as is the plan with the Covid-19 vaccines), the likelihood of some people suffering an adverse reaction is high. A common metaphor to illustrate this is seatbelts: in the vast majority of cases, seatbelts save lives; however, in a tiny minority they can injure or even kill their wearer.

“[A] reason why I think it would be hard to justify mandatory vaccination for Covid is that we have less information about the risks than we would to justify, say, mandatory flu vaccination,” said Douglas. Although all the Covid-19 vaccines are going through safety trials, there is no long-term data available on side effects. The majority would conclude that contracting Covid-19 is riskier than taking the vaccine for it, but depriving people of making this judgement for themselves based on the available data would be ethically questionable.
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: eyeeatingfish on April 26, 2021, 08:48:33 PM
I support vaccines, including the covid ones. I think the available evidence shows they are safe (much safer than getting covid) and effective.

That being said when you start trying to make vaccinations mandatory now I have a problem. If you want people to get shots use the carrot, not the stick. The minute you do something at the barrel of a gun you make things worse in my opinion.

Legally speaking, as I understand it, the supreme court has upheld mandatory vaccines so I am not sure much can be done in the way of legal challenges.
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: hvybarrels on April 26, 2021, 09:41:30 PM
8 week trial means nobody knows if they are dangerous or not, but plenty of people continue to pretend like they do know. We call those kinds of people liars.
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: omnigun on April 26, 2021, 10:10:28 PM
8 week trial means nobody knows if they are dangerous or not, but plenty of people continue to pretend like they do know. We call those kinds of people liars.

8 weeks?

Vaccine has been tested for atleast 6 months.
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: hvybarrels on April 26, 2021, 10:11:48 PM
We are the test
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: hvybarrels on April 26, 2021, 10:13:47 PM
It's all about power

https://www.zerohedge.com/covid-19/bill-gates-doubles-down-opposition-open-vaccine-movement
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: Q on April 27, 2021, 01:28:54 AM
Great.  Most schools require vaccinations to attend.  This is nothing out of norm.

Schools can only enforce mandatory vaccines if there is a federal mandate. Federally mandated vaccines can only be implemented if it is FDA approved, which every covid vaccine isn't. FDA Emergency Use Authorization cannot circumvent FDA approval, which is when the agency has determined that the benefits of the product outweigh the known risks for the intended use.
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: eyeeatingfish on April 27, 2021, 10:04:39 PM
8 week trial means nobody knows if they are dangerous or not, but plenty of people continue to pretend like they do know. We call those kinds of people liars.

This is a bit of a misnomer, that it is such a new vaccine that was never tested for long periods of time. The mRNA form of vaccine has been in research and testing for decades already. Not specifically for covid of course but they have been working with this technology for quite a while.

I did read an article yesterday about side effects of vaccines and it said that historically when vaccines have had serious side effects that they have nearly always shown up relatively quickly, 2 months IIRC. So if you wait for at least two months on these new vaccines and they haven't found serious side effects then the risk of later side effects would seem to be quite low.

The whole argument of "unknown side effects" skeptical of vaccines always bring up but they are really a double edged sword. While they don't know the side effects of the vaccine 5-10 years from now, they also don't know the side effects 5-10 years after having covid either.
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 27, 2021, 10:20:22 PM
This is a bit of a misnomer, that it is such a new vaccine that was never tested for long periods of time. The mRNA form of vaccine has been in research and testing for decades already. Not specifically for covid of course but they have been working with this technology for quite a while.

I did read an article yesterday about side effects of vaccines and it said that historically when vaccines have had serious side effects that they have nearly always shown up relatively quickly, 2 months IIRC. So if you wait for at least two months on these new vaccines and they haven't found serious side effects then the risk of later side effects would seem to be quite low.

The whole argument of "unknown side effects" skeptical of vaccines always bring up but they are really a double edged sword. While they don't know the side effects of the vaccine 5-10 years from now, they also don't know the side effects 5-10 years after having covid either.

The problem with THIS vaccine family is that you CAN'T draw similarities regarding side effects to vaccines of the past.  "that it is such a new vaccine" negates your historical reference -- that serious side effects have nearly always shown up relatively quickly, (2 months).  Since those vaccines were derived most often from organic sources, such as the living or dead viruses themselves, and this new family of vaccines changes the body's DNA to generate the required antibodies is enough to say we are sailing in uncharted waters.

If the technology and research have been around for years, and there have been no previous vaccines used for other diseases, why would we think this is something we should embrace 100%?  I think it was great that Operation Warp Speed produced a CANDIDATE vaccine so quickly, but that vaccine should also be tested and studied just as much as any other vaccine -- probably more so -- precisely because it IS a technologically new vaccine for a new virus.

I can't believe drugs we have known to be safe for many decades -- like anti-malarial drugs -- were scoffed at as irresponsible and "not scientific," yet a mostly untested vaccine based on new technology for a perviously unknown disease should be shot into 100% of peoples' arms without delay.
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: omnigun on April 28, 2021, 06:21:52 AM
The problem with THIS vaccine family is that you CAN'T draw similarities regarding side effects to vaccines of the past.  "that it is such a new vaccine" negates your historical reference -- that serious side effects have nearly always shown up relatively quickly, (2 months).  Since those vaccines were derived most often from organic sources, such as the living or dead viruses themselves, and this new family of vaccines changes the body's DNA to generate the required antibodies is enough to say we are sailing in uncharted waters.

If the technology and research have been around for years, and there have been no previous vaccines used for other diseases, why would we think this is something we should embrace 100%?  I think it was great that Operation Warp Speed produced a CANDIDATE vaccine so quickly, but that vaccine should also be tested and studied just as much as any other vaccine -- probably more so -- precisely because it IS a technologically new vaccine for a new virus.

I can't believe drugs we have known to be safe for many decades -- like anti-malarial drugs -- were scoffed at as irresponsible and "not scientific," yet a mostly untested vaccine based on new technology for a perviously unknown disease should be shot into 100% of peoples' arms without delay.

#fakenews
This vaccine doesn't CHANGE your DNA. 
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 28, 2021, 12:16:02 PM
#fakenews
This vaccine doesn't CHANGE your DNA.

I misquoted.

mRNA uses the DNA of the virus to INSTRUCT THE BODY to produce the proteins contained in the virus,  The body then SHOULD produce the antibodies needed to fight off the proteins it was taught to produce.

If you learn a new skill, does that not "change" you?  Changes do not have to be physical.

mRNA teaches the body to produce antibodies by causing the body to produce part of the virus using the virus' DNA.  If that's not changing the body, then I'm sure you will argue some more.
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: macsak on April 28, 2021, 12:21:34 PM
I misquoted.

mRNA uses the DNA of the virus to INSTRUCT THE BODY to produce the proteins contained in the virus,  The body then SHOULD produce the antibodies needed to fight off the proteins it was taught to produce.

If you learn a new skill, does that not "change" you?  Changes do not have to be physical.

mRNA teaches the body to produce antibodies by causing the body to produce part of the virus using the virus' DNA.  If that's not changing the body, then I'm sure you will argue some more.

virii do not have DNA...
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 28, 2021, 12:25:28 PM
virii do not have DNA...

mRNA

I had very little sleep this morning.   :sleeping:
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 28, 2021, 01:33:38 PM
Schools can only enforce mandatory vaccines if there is a federal mandate. Federally mandated vaccines can only be implemented if it is FDA approved, which every covid vaccine isn't. FDA Emergency Use Authorization cannot circumvent FDA approval, which is when the agency has determined that the benefits of the product outweigh the known risks for the intended use.

And why the military hasn't required them either.  I mean is the COVID vaxx any worst than the peanut butter shot?
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: Q on April 28, 2021, 07:27:51 PM
And why the military hasn't required them either.  I mean is the COVID vaxx any worst than the peanut butter shot?

Probably not. We were injected with so much stuff during in processing and pre deployment, it was hard to keep track.

I will say that my hesitation with vaccines did come from my experiences in the military. After getting all the in-processing vaccinations, I became extremely susceptible to and contracted numerous staph infections (something that wasn't an issue previously), to include what was believed to be a weird form of MRSA in Afghanistan.
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 29, 2021, 09:57:01 AM
Probably not. We were injected with so much stuff during in processing and pre deployment, it was hard to keep track.

I will say that my hesitation with vaccines did come from my experiences in the military. After getting all the in-processing vaccinations, I became extremely susceptible to and contracted numerous staph infections (something that wasn't an issue previously), to include what was believed to be a weird form of MRSA in Afghanistan.

Don't forget the "gulf war syndrome" that had a hearing in DC.  I was too young to remember the outcome, but what I do remember was a Marine in uniform was all jacked up trying to speak to the committee.
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: eyeeatingfish on April 29, 2021, 08:43:36 PM
The problem with THIS vaccine family is that you CAN'T draw similarities regarding side effects to vaccines of the past.  "that it is such a new vaccine" negates your historical reference -- that serious side effects have nearly always shown up relatively quickly, (2 months).  Since those vaccines were derived most often from organic sources, such as the living or dead viruses themselves, and this new family of vaccines changes the body's DNA to generate the required antibodies is enough to say we are sailing in uncharted waters.

If the technology and research have been around for years, and there have been no previous vaccines used for other diseases, why would we think this is something we should embrace 100%?  I think it was great that Operation Warp Speed produced a CANDIDATE vaccine so quickly, but that vaccine should also be tested and studied just as much as any other vaccine -- probably more so -- precisely because it IS a technologically new vaccine for a new virus.

I can't believe drugs we have known to be safe for many decades -- like anti-malarial drugs -- were scoffed at as irresponsible and "not scientific," yet a mostly untested vaccine based on new technology for a perviously unknown disease should be shot into 100% of peoples' arms without delay.

You may be right, that  you can't compare side effects of old styles of vaccines to side effects of this newer style of vaccine. I haven't come across whether there is reason to believe this new form of vaccine will behave differently in terms of side effects than more traditional methods. However i do think that since they have been researching this new technology for about 30 years they they probably have at least some idea of what to expect in terms of side effects. It had been tested on people as well as dogs IIRC well before the covid one was developed. That being said I can definitely understand people's uneasiness of trying this new technology.

I watched a good video today where a doctor was explaining the expedited process of vaccines and it isn't as bad as it sounds. There is a lot of red tape in the FDA and things often take time due to the bureaucracy. not just because of how long trials take. Additionally the government's promise to pay for the vaccines enabled companies to dive in much quicker since they didn't have to bear the financial risk of making a drug that might not end up panning out. I don't know that any of the actual trials were rushed in terms of how long test subjects were observed or whether they were done faster than usual but I know clearing the red tape was part of the quicker than usual approval.
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 30, 2021, 09:20:45 AM
You may be right, that  you can't compare side effects of old styles of vaccines to side effects of this newer style of vaccine. I haven't come across whether there is reason to believe this new form of vaccine will behave differently in terms of side effects than more traditional methods. However i do think that since they have been researching this new technology for about 30 years they they probably have at least some idea of what to expect in terms of side effects. It had been tested on people as well as dogs IIRC well before the covid one was developed. That being said I can definitely understand people's uneasiness of trying this new technology.

I watched a good video today where a doctor was explaining the expedited process of vaccines and it isn't as bad as it sounds. There is a lot of red tape in the FDA and things often take time due to the bureaucracy. not just because of how long trials take. Additionally the government's promise to pay for the vaccines enabled companies to dive in much quicker since they didn't have to bear the financial risk of making a drug that might not end up panning out. I don't know that any of the actual trials were rushed in terms of how long test subjects were observed or whether they were done faster than usual but I know clearing the red tape was part of the quicker than usual approval.

That is why I'm not getting vaxxed yet.  There is zero long term studies on it's effects since it's a "new" vaccine.  Even though it has been around for a while, that doesn't mean it won't have any bad interactions with today's humans.  Things that we take, that were not consumed decades ago.
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: omnigun on April 30, 2021, 09:24:42 AM
That is why I'm not getting vaxxed yet.  There is zero long term studies on it's effects since it's a "new" vaccine.  Even though it has been around for a while, that doesn't mean it won't have any bad interactions with today's humans.  Things that we take, that were not consumed decades ago.

On the other end there are no long term studies of the effects of covid.  So you can't just be on one side of this...
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: hvybarrels on April 30, 2021, 11:45:31 AM
I choose not to get covid, but then again would I even notice if I got it? The vast majority of people do not.
Title: Re: Ethics of mandatory vaccinations
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 30, 2021, 11:51:28 AM
I choose not to get covid, but then again would I even notice if I got it? The vast majority of people do not.

I too choose not to get covid.  :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: