2aHawaii
General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: bushmasta55 on August 24, 2012, 11:27:33 AM
-
Thinking about trying out the indoor range at the former magnum shop, has anyone tried it before?
-
Someone on fb posted you can shoot for free on sundays, or they don't charge the entrance fees or whatever i guess.
-
I shoot there once and a while.
There's only 4 lanes so sometimes you have to wait a long time to shoot
It's a nice little range though.
Because they're open on Sunday's, it provides another weekend option to kokohead
-
Get ready to spend lots of money to shoot. They still charge outrageous prices for ammunition. That is the *only* problem i see with it. Want to shoot 100 rounds of .40? It's like 45+ dollars. Instead of like 30.
-
:sleeping:
-
Get ready to spend lots of money to shoot. They still charge outrageous prices for ammunition. That is the *only* problem i see with it. Want to shoot 100 rounds of .40? It's like 45+ dollars. Instead of like 30.
That was my only gripe. You can't use your own ammo and the price they charge for ammo is borderline ridiculous. I guess it depends on how badly you gotta scratch that itch.
On the plus side, they do have a selection of handguns to shoot (advertised at over 50 pistols and rifles) if you don't mind paying the $20-$30. If you're interested in a particular firearm and they have it available in their arsenal, its a great way to try it before you buy it.
Also, if my memory serves me correct, I think the max distance for target shooting is 25 yards. IF it is, the range is a perfect for sighting in your AR15.
-
I've shot there a few times. Almost after every time I finish registering a new gun at HPD I stop by for some fun. It's really expensive and I wish I could bring my own ammo. I was told that it was a liability when people bring in their own loads. Which is understandable.
If you get a range membership you can shoot for free and get 20% off of ammo and targets, which is awesome. BUT...range membership is $400, which sucks
I'm still trying to figure out if it would be worth it to buy a membership, or even to buy my guns from there to get credit towards a membership
I do wish they had longer hours so I could shoot after work.
-
That was my only gripe. You can't use your own ammo and the price they charge for ammo is borderline ridiculous. I guess it depends on how badly you gotta scratch that itch.
On the plus side, they do have a selection of handguns to shoot (advertised at over 50 pistols and rifles) if you don't mind paying the $20-$30. If you're interested in a particular firearm and they have it available in their arsenal, its a great way to try it before you buy it.
Also, if my memory serves me correct, I think the max distance for target shooting is 25 yards. IF it is, the range is a perfect for sighting in your AR15.
Max distance is 15 yards and they only allow frangible ammo in the AR and it costs $1.00 a round.
-
Why can't they just make you sign a waiver? Blow your self up with your ammo = your problem...
I think it is more to do with profit margin and lead disposal fees and clean up. Just my theory.
-
Those prices are outrageous>:(. So shooting .22lr is the same price? I'd rather just go to the public range on open days.
-
If you get a range membership you can shoot for free and get 20% off of ammo and targets, which is awesome. BUT...range membership is $400, which sucks
I'm still trying to figure out if it would be worth it to buy a membership, or even to buy my guns from there to get credit towards a membership
You'd have to buy $2000 worth of gun to get the full membership ($100 off every $500 spent on a gun)...my friend got there by buying a pretty plain AR, that X-Ring would sell for about $1,200
Max distance is 15 yards and they only allow frangible ammo in the AR and it costs $1.00 a round.
Hm...I thought it was 25 yards..
Why can't they just make you sign a waiver? Blow your self up with your ammo = your problem...
I think it is more to do with profit margin and lead disposal fees and clean up. Just my theory.
The problem is if you blow someone else up, that's still the range's problem..
Those prices are outrageous>:(. So shooting .22lr is the same price? I'd rather just go to the public range on open days.
Last time i shot .22lr there, it was $10 for a box of 100 CCI MiniMags. That was over two years ago..
-
Max distance is 15 yards and they only allow frangible ammo in the AR and it costs $1.00 a round.
if the ar costs $1.00, how much does ak 7.62 ammo cost? man that is nuts. was thinking of trying the range and taking my glock 9mm and ak. if the ak is that much too, then i will just bring the glock.
oh, taking advantage of the topic... i was going to go with some friends. one guy doesn't have any guns. he has never taken the pistol class, never got a permit to acquire a rifle. he has fired a few times in the past....
would he be able to shoot there? thanks.
-
if the ar costs $1.00, how much does ak 7.62 ammo cost? man that is nuts. was thinking of trying the range and taking my glock 9mm and ak. if the ak is that much too, then i will just bring the glock.
oh, taking advantage of the topic... i was going to go with some friends. one guy doesn't have any guns. he has never taken the pistol class, never got a permit to acquire a rifle. he has fired a few times in the past....
would he be able to shoot there? thanks.
Not sure how much 7.62x39 cost, but if your friend is capable of handling a handgun safely, he can borrow your handguns while you're present...best if you're next to him for safety in case he happens to bring his muzzle around.
-
Those prices are outrageous>:(. So shooting .22lr is the same price? I'd rather just go to the public range on open days.
That's the thing. The public range is not so public. It opens only on Wed through Sun, with limited hours and access to the shooting bays on Wed, Thurs. and Fri.. The drive is long for most townies (like me ;D ) and more so for folks on the Leeward side. If you decide to make the trip, you either have to go super early or go later when the shift changes. That's why I said it depends how badly you gotta scratch that itch. I think having access to an indoor range in town is a great thing. The ability to simply hop in your car and be at a range in 10 minutes is a real blessing. I'm willing to pay the $15 for the use of the range. I'm just not willing to pay their ammo prices.
-
If this helps.. I emailed them asking about the fees and ammo. I expressed my feelings that the cost of driving there(from all the way Westside), range fees, and ammo cost would make it prohibitively expensive from me to shoot there. The new ownership was very cordial and expressed a willingness to giveme a percentage discount on the ammunition. I forget how much it was, but I declined.
Try asking them. Maybe they'll give the same offer.
-
Why can't they just make you sign a waiver? Blow your self up with your ammo = your problem...
I think it is more to do with profit margin and lead disposal fees and clean up. Just my theory.
In Hawaii you cannot simply sign away your rights just by signing a piece of paper. So although you sign a waiver that doesn't necessarily mean that a judge will throw out a case. You could still be sued and the suit proceed depending on the situation.
-
In Hawaii you cannot simply sign away your rights just by signing a piece of paper. So although you sign a waiver that doesn't necessarily mean that a judge will throw out a case. You could still be sued and the suit proceed depending on the situation.
Sure you can... I did....
I'm married....
Hahaha. JK JK ;)
-
I just asked, it costs $12/100 .22. No range fees on Sundays for now. Staff is super cool but prices still high.
-
I may stop by Sunday afternoon.
-
went there today for the first time and shot my 9mm glock and ak. i think the 9mm was something like $23/50 rounds. the 7.62x39 was $27/20 rounds!!!! They ring it up after you are done shooting. My fault for not asking ahead of time what they cost.
me and my friends had a great time, but i am not bringing the ak anymore. i thought the ak would be cheaper than the ar, but i guess not. gotta start thinking again about getting a .22 upper or a dedicated .22 rifle.
the staff was super friendly though. what a change from when it was the other owner.
-
went there today for the first time and shot my 9mm glock and ak. i think the 9mm was something like $23/50 rounds. the 7.62x39 was $27/20 rounds!!!! They ring it up after you are done shooting. My fault for not asking ahead of time what they cost.
me and my friends had a great time, but i am not bringing the ak anymore. i thought the ak would be cheaper than the ar, but i guess not. gotta start thinking again about getting a .22 upper or a dedicated .22 rifle.
the staff was super friendly though. what a change from when it was the other owner.
God those prices make me ill.
-
God those prices make me ill.
Are you "licensed to ill"?
-
007-11 agent?
-
They also have one of the best NRA firearms instructor on he island. A bit pricey, but the information he provides is well worth it.
Not sure who you're talking about, but I just got a request from a lady that recently took their course...she said she wanted training on how to operate and clean her gun 'cause the person she took the course from (at Honolulu Firearms) didn't give her that info....
-
Russell is the man.....
-
Russell is the man.....
+1. Took my handgun safety course from him. Excellent information and instruction!
-
:sleeping:
-
:D
-
:sleeping:
-
I didn't think how to clean a firearm was part of the firearms safety course. I wasn't taught any of that. But isn't that the first thing you do when you take home a firearm?
-
:sleeping:
-
Not sure who you're talking about, but I just got a request from a lady that recently took their course...she said she wanted training on how to operate and clean her gun 'cause the person she took the course from (at Honolulu Firearms) didn't give her that info....
That sounds about right. But I don't interpret that as a put down of the the instructor or the course curriculum. The course isn't designed to teach you how to use your own handgun as there are as many different types of handguns as there are opinions about them. Same thing can be said about cleaning them. It's about the basics of gun safety and the laws regarding gun ownership, registration, etc.
-
I learned to clean my firearm from YouTube, lol!
-
I didn't think how to clean a firearm was part of the firearms safety course. I wasn't taught any of that. But isn't that the first thing you do when you take home a firearm?
It is part of an NRA course, both Basic and FIrst Steps. However, Hawaii state law does not require an NRA course, merely that the course be taught by an NRA instructor.
-
^^^ good to know. I now know what I should recommend to future 2a members.
-
Bill - I can not speak for HF, but the person I was referring to is Russ Tanji. I do not know if HF has other NRA Pistol instructors...................
For sure at least one more NRA Basic Pistol Instructor.
-
I learned to clean my firearm from YouTube, lol!
This is honestly the best method imo. Teaching how to clean is such a waste of time: chemicals, components, your gun isn't the gun I am using, bore snake over, rod etc. Buy a kit for your caliber, and hit the 2nd largest search engine in the world to watch a video of someone going step by step through cleaning your gun.
-
This is honestly the best method imo. Teaching how to clean is such a waste of time: chemicals, components, your gun isn't the gun I am using, bore snake over, rod etc. Buy a kit for your caliber, and hit the 2nd largest search engine in the world to watch a video of someone going step by step through cleaning your gun.
I'm a little embarrassed to admit that, when the time comes to disassemble a firearm i've not handled in a while, my default now is to search YouTube rather than pull out the manual, I imagine this would even be true if I were shooting at an indoor range (gotta stay on topic!)
-
Yep I learned how to do all my mods to my rifle from YouTube and other forums. Even how-to work on my cars and ecu mapping for my turbo
-
Bill - I can not speak for HF, but the person I was referring to is Russ Tanji. I do not know if HF has other NRA Pistol instructors. I believe Russ is not only an outstanding NRA instructor, but he has the credentials and experience when it comes to educating season / new gun owners on local laws and firearms in general. I would definitely take his course again by spending the money to gleam any wisdom I can get. It's very rare to see someone who has his background on the island. He stands out as one of the best firearms instructors I have seen on Oahu by far. He actually gets paid to teach which makes a big difference in the quality of the class. No pun intended, so please do not read between the lines.
Lets keep this civil since it is just my opinion. In addition, I am not as active in the local gun community as you are so please so not start a LIFE vs HF NRA Instructor War.
Everyone is a winner so lets keep it in perspective!
If the woman needed help continue mission and assist her to be a safe / responsible steward of bullet launchers. Maybe she had a bad experience, so at least you guys are able to help her to be safe by showing her the ABCs of bullet launcher ownership.
I have no intention of starting an "LIFE vs HF NRA Instructor war" nor did I believe I was being anything but civil. I was simply providing a counterpoint to the assertion that HF has exceptional firearms instructors. I believe that with my recent experiences and those of Chris, it might be a reasonable assumption that their training MAY not be as consistent or as good as stated.
As for the 'he's a better instructor because he gets paid to teach" comment, I am afraid I have to strongly disagree. In fact, the profit motive and the very narrow profit margins associated with high quality firearms training could be argued to be a predictor of reduced quality. Whereas those that volunteer to teach have no profit motive and tend to teach purely for the love of teaching and satisfaction of bringing more new firearms enthusiasts into the fold.
We know that there are folks out there doing a fine job of providing instruction, conversely we know that there are those that are slapping in a video and then going to the range for less than the 2 hour requirement and providing an affidavit. All so they can churn out more students with less time (read as cost) to maximize their profit. It is those individuals that are going to be the problem and bring increased scrutiny to those of us that do abide by the rules.
-
:sleeping:
-
Yeah the ammo prices kill me. I bought a 500 rd brick of cheapo Blazer 22LR, that cost me $37 bucks! A brick of brass cased AE 22LR elsewhere is between $18-25. I want to get my AK zeroed in but at the $27/20 mentioned earlier I can't justify the cost considering you can buy a box of Tula or similar for 7 bucks elsewhere on island....
-
I learned to clean my firearm from YouTube, lol!
It's always there when you need it.
-
I learned to clean my firearm from YouTube, lol!
Same here and from a really knowledgable guy named Steve on another forum.
During my handgun safety class I asked why we weren't going over the cleaning and in depth maintenance stuff and he said it's kinda like drivers ed. They don't teach out how to change out your light bulbs, change your wipers or even fill up your gas, much less clean your car, BUT if we wanted to learn then ask for help after acquiring and they'd be happy to help at no cost.
-
Same here and from a really knowledgable guy named Steve on another forum.
During my handgun safety class I asked why we weren't going over the cleaning and in depth maintenance stuff and he said it's kinda like drivers ed. They don't teach out how to change out your light bulbs, change your wipers or even fill up your gas, much less clean your car, BUT if we wanted to learn then ask for help after acquiring and they'd be happy to help at no cost.
I offer the same thing. Because, the guy is pretty much right. I can show you how to clean and break down the glock, but when you buy your sig or 1911..... wtf good did that do?
-
I offer the same thing. Because, the guy is pretty much right. I can show you how to clean and break down the glock, but when you buy your sig or 1911..... wtf good did that do?
Yea, he said they're all pretty much the same minus the bells and whistles but break down and reassembly is a different story :thumbsup:
-
Here we go....maybe I need to be censored from the post! LOL
It's okay to disagree and it's nice to see you get fired up everyonce in a while!
It's really too bad there are not many other places to shoot besides using private land and military instalations.
We used to teach our NRA classes on private land in the mainland. It was a good experience from the cusomer and instructors point of view. We were not scrutinized by anyone but ourselves. We even manged to invite our local LEOs to particpate in our three gun and IPSC mathces and held a BBQ to build upon that relationship.
I took your statements personally becasue most people love to bash HF or gun stores for that matter. I am not a buissness owner, but it is sad to see folks complaning about a gun shop, which is trying to move foward from the last owner.
If thier indoor range was to go away then what do you have? One less option. Can we all just get along.
LIFE does a great job of nurturing neophites. Tell you the truth, I was at Magnum's acouple of years ago, when an older gentlmen who was using the indoor range told me that he hated volunteering at LIFE becasue they sat around and waited for the customers to use thier weapons, which is why he teaches the NRA Course on the side in order to make a little bit of cash. Saddly, he asked if I was intrested in taking the class instead of going to Kokohead. I politely turned him down.
Despite, what he said, I still belive you guys are great! Anybody who takes the the time to educate new shooter on the safe operations of firearms is an outstanding American.
Relax and enjoy the weather.
Life is too dam short to be angry.
Dude, I don't really know how to respond to you...if you took offense to my statements that recent students had contacted me to gain additional training in what should be a component of a basic firearms class, so sorry, or you took my statements "... personally becasue [sic] most people love to bash HF or gun stores for that matter..." well that's all you, but buck up and be a man for christ sake and quite making false accusations based on your hurt feelings....and because I disagreed with your statement that "paid" instructors are better just because they are paid I'm "fired up" and "angry?" WTF???
It was not a bash on HF, it was in the first instance a fact (the student wasn't happy with the training she received) and in the second instance, my opinion. I have no reason to bash HF, as a matter of fact I have in the past used their facilities, and will likely do so in the future. I also just received a call from an old colleague who now works there and wants to become an NRA instructor. I told him I'd make sure he was on the waiting list for our next instructor's class. Would I do that if I had something against HF?
Was I a fan of the prior owner? NO. Do I hope that the new owner and management team do a better job and stay open for everyone's enjoyment? Absolutely!
We clear now?
-
:wave:
-
HF range is 50 feet(16.7 yds). A couple other pluses about the range is that you can rapid fire, shoot from a holster and shoot from 3ft to 50ft from the target. If you opt for getting a locker(extra charge) you can keep your ammo/targets/firearms in your locker. This is very convenient if you want to shoot at HF at any time w/o worrying about gun transport laws. As a member you are also entitled to shoot their steel targets(dueling tree) and 20% off ammo/targets.
Russ Tanji is also an adjunct instructor for Sig Academy: http://www.sigsaueracademy.com/SiteMap/ShowInstructorInfo.aspx?staffid=34 (http://www.sigsaueracademy.com/SiteMap/ShowInstructorInfo.aspx?staffid=34)
While Art ran the shop, Russ said he can provide Sig Academy courses at the range. If there's enough interest I assume he can still do this w/permission from the new owner. For those wanting to take advanced training courses on the mainland, the bigger training outfits will accept introductory courses from recognized training organizations to fulfill entry level training requirements to take advanced training courses.
-osamu
-
I think I'm going tomorrow to HF range and play with some toys.
:geekdanc:
-
What are you bringing this time?
-
Hk p7 & Glock 30sf
-
Tempting to come down and play, got too much going on. :-\
-
Hk p7 & Glock 30sf
P7...........gots them strong forearms eh?
-
took a carbine class from Russ at HF the other week. I still have some frangible rounds left over. Anybody wanna buy it? :)
-
took a carbine class from Russ at HF the other week. I still have some frangible rounds left over. Anybody wanna buy it? :)
Brah, is illegal to have frangible ammo!
-
took a carbine class from Russ at HF the other week. I still have some frangible rounds left over. Anybody wanna buy it? :)
HRS 134-8:
The manufacture, possession, sale, barter, trade, gift, transfer, or acquisition of any of the following is prohibited:
...
or any type of ammunition or any projectile component thereof coated with teflon or any other similar coating designed primarily to enhance its capability to penetrate metal or pierce protective armor; and any type of ammunition or any projectile component thereof designed or intended to explode or segment upon impact with its target.
-
HRS 134-8:
The manufacture, possession, sale, barter, trade, gift, transfer, or acquisition of any of the following is prohibited:
...
or any type of ammunition or any projectile component thereof coated with teflon or any other similar coating designed primarily to enhance its capability to penetrate metal or pierce protective armor; and any type of ammunition or any projectile component thereof designed or intended to explode or segment upon impact with its target.
Mostly all hollowpoints are designed to segment. Heck if you look at the manufacturers' websites you'll see that when they talk about weight retention on their bullets.
-
Mostly all hollowpoints are designed to segment. Heck if you look at the manufacturers' websites you'll see that when they talk about weight retention on their bullets.
I disagree. A hollowpoint manufacturer's assertions about weight retention is a statement that their bullets do not segment. I got curious about this a while back, the definition of segment is "to cut or divide (a whole object) into segments". If a bullet manufacturer is claiming that their ammunition provides 95%, 98%, whatever% weight retention, they're saying, "Hey, our bullets don't break up [segment]. They stay in one piece!"
Hnl.flyboy is right, I'd keep it tightly under my hat if I had frangible ammunition, and dispose of it pronto. (Of course, I'd probably dispose it into the backstop at Koko Head, but that's another matter... :D)
-
what about tracers? legal?
-
Mostly all hollowpoints are designed to segment. Heck if you look at the manufacturers' websites you'll see that when they talk about weight retention on their bullets.
Taken from Merriam-Webster:
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/segment
(as a verb) segment:
to separate into segments : give off as segments
(as a noun) segment:
2
a : a separate piece of something : bit, fragment <chop the stalks into short segments>
It's clear that it means "into separate parts."
-
Taken from Merriam-Webster:
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/segment (http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/segment)
(as a verb) segment:
to separate into segments : give off as segments
(as a noun) segment:
2
a : a separate piece of something : bit, fragment <chop the stalks into short segments>
It's clear that it means "into separate parts."
Yup and many hollow points are designed with the understanding that the petals will break off or be broken off in the animals.
-
Yup and many hollow points are designed with the understanding that the petals will break off or be broken off in the animals.
While it is true that many hollopoints (or even 5.56 rounds with the cannelure, at least according to folklore) will break into separate pieces on impact, they are designed not to. Two 115-grain pieces will not penetrate as deeply as one 230-grain piece, so the ammo makers want the bullet to expand, but stay together in one piece for maximum penetration depth.
This discussion about what hollowpoints are or are not designed to do is irrelevant, however. All we're discussing is whether or not hollowpoints are legal in Hawaii, because regardless of whether or not hollowpoints break up, frangible ammunition absolutely does. By design. Ammunition which segments is illegal. Frangible=segments=illegal.
-
How about rifle bullets? Our gun club once did a bunch of penetration tests to see what would and would not go through drywall or plywood; even ball bullets from .223s came apart. When one member fired his preferred ('cause of it's low penetration) home defense ammo (a 45gr varmint load) into a 5 gallon jug of water...the biggest piece we recovered was the base of the jacket.
-
How about rifle bullets? Our gun club once did a bunch of penetration tests to see what would and would not go through drywall or plywood; even ball bullets from .223s came apart. When one member fired his preferred ('cause of it's low penetration) home defense ammo (a 45gr varmint load) into a 5 gallon jug of water...the biggest piece we recovered was the base of the jacket.
Not if they're not intended to break up. If your ammunition is designed or advertised to fragment, explode, come apart, break into pieces, detonate, *puff* into powder, or otherwise not stay in one piece, it is illegal. If it is not intended to do that, it's legal. The applicable portion of the statute is: "...and any type of ammunition or any projectile component thereof designed or intended to explode or segment upon impact with its target [is prohibited]." That's in HRS 134-8.
-
How about rifle bullets? Our gun club once did a bunch of penetration tests to see what would and would not go through drywall or plywood; even ball bullets from .223s came apart. When one member fired his preferred ('cause of it's low penetration) home defense ammo (a 45gr varmint load) into a 5 gallon jug of water...the biggest piece we recovered was the base of the jacket.
you mean the powder right?
-
you mean the powder right?
I assumed she meant full metal jacket, which I've heard referred to as "ball ammo".
-
My understanding is that 45gr varmint bullets are designed to blow up prairie dogs, so they fragment on impact. But they're available for sale in local stores. I've also seen Glaser Safety Slugs for sale at a gun shop in Hilo, although that was a bunch of years ago.
Ball ammo=FMJ.
-
Frangible ammo is not designed to separate.
It is designed to stay whole when it hits a soft target like a person.
When it hits a hard target like a brick wall, it disintegrates, not fragments or separates.
If you shoot a lead bullet at a wall, it breaks into a hundred pieces.
I'll buy the ammo, if the price is right.
PM me.
-
Not if they're not intended to break up. If your ammunition is designed or advertised to fragment, explode, come apart, break into pieces, detonate, *puff* into powder, or otherwise not stay in one piece, it is illegal. If it is not intended to do that, it's legal. The applicable portion of the statute is: "...and any type of ammunition or any projectile component thereof designed or intended to explode or segment upon impact with its target [is prohibited]." That's in HRS 134-8.
You bring up and interesting point about being advertised. Point taken as well from Couger about the varmint loads as they usually have pretty thin shells............but that could be due to the varmints being rather small when compared to other animals.
-
Interesting debate regarding frangibles.
Ironically, I was at Honolulu firearms a few weeks ago and this guy was questioning the range rules, stating how dumb the policies are, and they didn't do away with all of Arts stupidity, the range being the biggest problem for the business. The range guy says they sell frangibles and the guy proceeds to tell him they are illegal in HI and surprised they weren't shut down yet. The lecture about frangibles went on for a few minutes and also stated he was a firearms instructor and actually certified Art years ago.
I couldn't agree or disagree with the guy because I didn't know HI law, so just observed.
One thing I can say is this guy was very passionate and seemed 1000% sure in his stance.
Now I'm reading all of this, hmmm.... like I said interesting
-
Interesting debate regarding frangibles.
Ironically, I was at Honolulu firearms a few weeks ago and this guy was questioning the range rules, stating how dumb the policies are, and they didn't do away with all of Arts stupidity, the range being the biggest problem for the business. The range guy says they sell frangibles and the guy proceeds to tell him they are illegal in HI and surprised they weren't shut down yet. The lecture about frangibles went on for a few minutes and also stated he was a firearms instructor and actually certified Art years ago.
I couldn't agree or disagree with the guy because I didn't know HI law, so just observed.
One thing I can say is this guy was very passionate and seemed 1000% sure in his stance.
Now I'm reading all of this, hmmm.... like I said interesting
Here's the big catch with all this: what the letter of the law says is one thing, what actually flies is another. It may well be that you'd never ever get in trouble for frangible ammo because of the way the bigwigs *think* the law should read. As another example, it is 100%, indisputably illegal to take your guns off-island with you, because the airport is not on the very short list of approved places you can transport a firearm to or from. I feel fairly confident that I'll never be prosecuted for flying in and out of the state with my guns, so I'll continue to do it; but the fact remains that it's technically illegal and I (and everyone else) could get in serious trouble for it.
Perhaps the folks at Honolulu Firearms feel the same way about frangibles as I do about taking my guns home with me. ???
-
I can tell you that my two good friends, who represent HDF in our cases, have told me that they would have a hard time defending me with frangible ammo.
Take it for what it's worth.
And KK:
Disintegrate: Break up into parts
Parts: Synonyms
1. component, ingredient, division, sector. Part, piece, portion, segment, section, fraction, fragment refer to something that is less than the whole.
Fragmenting: Break or cause to break into fragments (which can be read, break or cause to break into [parts])
So these two are the same thing, but maybe different varying levels of the breaking.
-
By that broad description, every single round of ammunition, by design, is illegal.
-
I only know of a few items like some of the Hydrashock, or the ammo where the jacket is designed to completely come off of the lead that would really be considered "segmenting." But, Frangible, by it's own name means breaking into parts (or segmenting).
More importantly, do you have a better source than Attorneys who are authorized by law to give a legal opinion on the topic? I have asked, and they have said no bueno.
And, really, I was just showing you that your term is the same as the other one :love:
-
Frangible ammo is not designed to come apart, it's already apart.
It's compressed powder.
I'm buying cases of it and shooting it every time I go shooting. :crazy:
-
Frangible ammo is not designed to come apart, it's already apart.
It's compressed powder.
I'm buying cases of it and shooting it every time I go shooting. :crazy:
I'm staying away from you :P. :shake: :shake: :shake: :shake: I'm pretty sure one wrong turn signal and someone will be on me lol.
Our laws are not here to make sense, I mean take a look and see where you are allowed to target shoot with a pistol!
-
I only know of a few items like some of the Hydrashock, or the ammo where the jacket is designed to completely come off of the lead that would really be considered "segmenting." But, Frangible, by it's own name means breaking into parts (or segmenting).
More importantly, do you have a better source than Attorneys who are authorized by law to give a legal opinion on the topic? I have asked, and they have said no bueno.
And, really, I was just showing you that your term is the same as the other one :love:
I guess the only way to know for sure is if the Public Prosecutors charge someone and how the jury decides.................and if it then goes up higher to State Supreme Court or other..................
-
Frangible ammo is not designed to separate.
It is designed to stay whole when it hits a soft target like a person.
When it hits a hard target like a brick wall, it disintegrates, not fragments or separates.
If you shoot a lead bullet at a wall, it breaks into a hundred pieces.
I'll buy the ammo, if the price is right.
PM me.
I agree with King Keoni's basic premise that it might be acceptable to purchase/use frangible ammunition, though I disagree with his first and third sentences, above.
FRANGIBLE AMMUNITION
Frangible ammunition is generally broken (pardon the pun) into three levels; 1) training; 2) reduced ricochet, limited penetration ("RRLP"); and 3) general purpose frangible. Frangible ammunition is frequently used for training purposes, or aboard ships and airplanes, or within other confined areas that require heightened sensitivity to overpenetration issues.
PURPOSES OF FRANGIBLE AMMUNITION
A frangible round is designed and intended to "explode or segment" or "separate" or break apart, upon impact, with a hard surface, such as a wall or interior of an airplane fuselage. The purpose is to prevent ricochets in close quarter combat, and reduce the possibility of overpenetration.
DEFINITION OF "DISINTEGRATION"
The definition of the word, "disintegrate," is, "[t]o become reduced to components, fragments, or particles." In essence, when an object (such as a frangible round) disintegrates, it fragments, separates, or breaks into smaller parts.
HAWAII REVISED STATUTE 134-8
Haw. Rev. Stat. 134-8 states, in pertinent part, "The manufacture, possession, sale, barter, trade, gift, transfer, or acquisition of any of the following is prohibited: ... and any type of ammunition or any projectile component thereof designed or intended to explode or segment upon impact with its target" (emphasis added). Please pay particular attention to the verbiage in the last portion of the parsed sentence, above. The language reads, "... with its target." As King Keoni pointed out, frangible ammunition is designed and intended to remain intact when it impacts the frangible round's true "target." It is only when the frangible round misses its true "target" and impacts an adjacent hard surface (such as a wall) that the frangible round disintegrates, or "explodes or segments" or breaks apart.
FRANGIBLE V. FRAGMENTING
It is my understanding that a frangible round is not the same thing as a fragmenting round.
dubya
***CAVEAT***
This post is not intended to serve as, nor should this post be construed as, legal advice.
-
Why is frangible ammo illegal anyways?
-
Why is frangible ammo illegal anyways?
It's from lawmakers who don't know squat about firearms and are misled.
-
It's from lawmakers who don't know squat about firearms and are misled.
Key up barrel shroud video, she also doesn't like large capacity clips :rofl:
What is a barrel shroud? (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9rGpykAX1fo#)
And the Iraqi bullet lady
(http://www.psychophil.com/weblog/wp-content/uploads/2007/08/afplie01.jpg)
Ignorance
-
Buahahahahahaha. Should have seen that answer coming.
Its a bullet, sounds like it does what its suppose to do
-
I'm not sure where you get that frangible is supposed to stay intact... that is just well - improper. It's designed to break part anytime it hits *anything* harder than the bullet itself. So your little extraction from the end of the HRS, doesn't seem to hold much weight when talking about "its target."
Frangibles reduce over penetration issues because they break apart into nothingness when they impact their target or a backstop. If we were using steel plates, they would hit the plate. If you hit a person with it, it's going to break off into that person. If you hit paper, well that is not harder than the bullet, and it's going to pass through until it hits something of more substance.
There is a pretty substantial flaw in your argument dubya. What if my target is a steel wall? Is my frangible round not going to segment because it was my intended target? And, it will only break into fragments when it hits a wood wall, that is behind my steel one? More importantly, what thought process is my bullet going to use to determine if the substance it came in contact with was indeed my target?
Also, fragment and segment are synonyms.
The only real way to solve this is to go pull the legislative history of when it was enacted to see what they were talking about.
-
I'm not sure where you get that frangible is supposed to stay intact... that is just well - improper. It's designed to break part anytime it hits *anything* harder than the bullet itself. So your little extraction from the end of the HRS, doesn't seem to hold much weight when talking about "its target."
Thank you, Funtimes... I misstated a portion of my previous post and failed to state a basic assumption that, when talking about true "targets," I assumed the term, "targets" to mean targets made out of paper.
In my previous post I stated, "As King Keoni pointed out, frangible ammunition is designed and intended to remain intact when it impacts the frangible round's true 'target.'"
What I should have said is that, "frangible ammunition will REMAIN intact when it impacts the frangible round's true 'target,' assuming that the shooter's true 'target' is a target made out of paper."
Thank you for catching that.
Frangibles reduce over penetration issues because they break apart into nothingness when they impact their target or a backstop. If we were using steel plates, they would hit the plate. If you hit a person with it, it's going to break off into that person.
I respectfully disagree with your statement that, "If you hit a person with it (I assume you mean a frangible round), it's going to break off into that person." But then again, I understand that there are different levels of frangible ammunition, so this might actually occur...
If you hit paper, well that is not harder than the bullet, and it's going to pass through until it hits something of more substance.
I agree with this statement.
There is a pretty substantial flaw in your argument dubya. What if my target is a steel wall?Is my frangible round not going to segment? And, it will only break into fragments when it hits a wood wall, that is behind my steel one?
Good point. I should have again stated that I assumed that most shooters will be shooting at a true "target," which consists of a target made out of paper.
If your target is a steel wall, or a steel target, I concede that when your frangible round impacts the steel wall, or steel target, it will most certainly segment, fragment, break apart, etc., as it was designed and intended to do, and you may find yourself in violation of Haw. Rev. Stat. 134-8.
Also, fragment and segment are synonyms.
Depending upon the context, and in certain circumstances, I agree that the words "fragment" and "segment" can be synonyms. However, in other circumstances, the words, "fragment" and "segment" may serve as imperfect synonyms, or may not be suitable synonyms, at all. Again, I would argue that it depends on the context and circumstances.
The only real way to solve this is to go pull the legislative history of when it was enacted to see what they were talking about.
Yes, this would be helpful, though I cannot guarantee that even pulling the legislative history will provide full clarification of this matter.
Thank you, I enjoyed this conversation!
Best regards,
dubya
*** Caveat ***
This post is not intended to serve as, nor should this post be construed as, legal advice.
-
I'm just distracting myself from the paper on prisoner rights! :shake:
But, if nothing else, the above illustrates that gray area that attorney's love, and citizens hate. Why can't we just know if our shit is legal or not? ???
Thank you for the discussion! :shaka:
-
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terminal_ballistics (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terminal_ballistics)
I think this has some interesting stuff in the fragmenting / frangible, but one quote would make nervous is fragmenting bullets are "causing an effect similar to that of a frangible projectile."
I tried going back into my Forensic Science book and looking for frangibles, but I don't think we covered that type of bullet construction in the course.
This company uses a 99% compressed metal core for their frangible round.
Here is a shot from .223 - and a vest with their frangible.
DRT Ammo vs. Level IIIa armor and ballistics gel with .223 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DbgWi_NhMNg#ws)
I was thinking about some of the Seal Team 6 training etc., and I'm pretty sure they use frangible rounds in their shoot houses (most do); those agencies commonly have training accidents resulting in death.