2aHawaii

General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: ren on August 18, 2021, 08:30:36 PM

Title: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: ren on August 18, 2021, 08:30:36 PM
Never owned a shotgun but I am looking at a Benelli M4. Any cons? Any other recommendations? For HD
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: macsak on August 18, 2021, 08:50:48 PM
Never owned a shotgun but I am looking at a Benelli M4. Any cons? Any other recommendations? For HD

awesome shotgun
expensive, complex, more difficult to maintain

i have a remington 870
allegedly...
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: drck1000 on August 18, 2021, 08:59:13 PM
For semi-auto, I’ve shot the M2 and M3 a lot. I like the dual action nature of the M3, but I’d rather hand a plain semi-auto. For defensive use, I’d go for the M2. Don’t know much that about the M4 other than it’s damn pricey and hard to find.

I own a Benelli Nova. It was my dad’s.

All of the Benelli M series are pricey. I’ve also shot Remington and Mossberg pumps a lot. I recall the newer production Remingtons had feeding/pump issues.
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 18, 2021, 09:56:59 PM
I went with the Mossberg 590 Mariner. 

Simple enough for the military to operate and maintain,   :geekdanc:
reliable,
can hold up to 9 shells (8+1),
20" barrel,
lots of accessories available for it,
finish is an anti-rust coat that's proprietary - intended for boats and other wet environments (like an island), and
very affordable.

Also came with the pistol grip, if you're not happy with the stock.

I added a heat shield, picatinny rail, miniature red dot, sling swivels, sling, and replaced the factory fore end with one that has a weapons light rail.

https://www.mossberg.com/product/590-mariner-9-shot-50299/


(https://i.imgur.com/mBGLSgt.jpg?2)
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: Direjackalope on August 18, 2021, 10:41:18 PM
I’ve had a Mossberg 930 SPX for a few years. It’s the last gun I’d ever sell.
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: drck1000 on August 18, 2021, 10:51:34 PM
I’ve had a Mossberg 930 SPX for a few years. It’s the last gun I’d ever sell.
A buddy has the 930 JM Pro series. It’s a competition shotgun, but it’s a damn sweet shooter.
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: Direjackalope on August 18, 2021, 11:07:15 PM
A buddy has the 930 JM Pro series. It’s a competition shotgun, but it’s a damn sweet shooter.

When I'm back to Wisconsin on vacation I use it to shoot cans of shaving cream with 3" slugs to impress the neighbor kids.  Not only a good show but a pleasing odor!  The only down side is it's a gas driven piston gun and you have to clean the piston every so often.  The gas system seems to help out with low brass shell reliability though.  I'd short shuck a pump way more often than the 930 malfunctions with cheapo bird shot.
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: hvybarrels on August 18, 2021, 11:31:56 PM
Grandpa gun with wood furniture.The jury might cut you some slack for legit hd.
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: aaronc5362 on August 19, 2021, 12:51:12 AM
I own/ have an 870 for years now and love it. (Only shot it with my 18.5 inch barrel, havent tested out the 26 inch barrel i just acquired.)

I recently bought a moss 500, but havent shot it yet. Feels bout the same as my 870 while handling it. The only downside to the 500 is that i had to spend bout an extra 100 bucks on getting a tube action assym and hogie forend (870 comes standard with the slide action tube assym.) cause my forend has the pinned type of action bars. Read some people broke there forends with this style so i have a solid backup if mines ever break.

As for the 870, i dished out a few hundred bucks for a recent cerakote job. The finish attracts rust. Sort of speak lol. I wouldnt call it high maintenance but you do have to keep it nicely oiled/ greased for it to outlast you and your children's lifetime if you keep the parkerized finish. I keep the inside of the barrel nicely greased for both 870 and 500.

My 870 so far has a volquartsen extractor, magpul forend, streamlight protac 2/ aluminum mlok pic mount , magpul buttstock, magpul sling loop, troy 1 pt sling, and some carlsons aftermarket chokes.

My 500 has egw top pic rail, holoson 515t, cdm light mount, surefire light and thats bout it. Debating whether to cerakote the barrel professionally or try alumahyde 2 on it. Since the receiver is aluminum i might just rattle can the receiver as im not worried bout rust like the 870. But always good to have an extra "barrier" protecting the metal. Plus i like rattlecan jobs. Lol

I handled a benelli m4, m3, and m2. I like the m2 the most out of those 3. The m4 to me is heavy as fuck. It had the adjustable stock, idk if thats why it weighed alot?? Never looked up specs. M2 is cheaper by ~$500-700 when compared to m4s and it has the inertia gas system, so cleaner than the 1100 (which ive also shot.) And since the m2 is highly regarded as a competition shotgun theres a plethora of aftermarket items for it.
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: Platinum808 on August 19, 2021, 05:40:48 AM
awesome shotgun
expensive, complex, more difficult to maintain

its not difficult to maintain they give it to marines And it’s supposedly self cleaning! If the military Issues it on a Massive scale any retard must be able to use it!
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: Platinum808 on August 19, 2021, 05:44:04 AM
awesome shotgun
expensive, complex, more difficult to maintain

its not difficult to maintain they give it to marines And it’s supposedly self cleaning! If the military Issues it on a Massive scale any retard must be able to use it! I wish i owned one :D
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: mrgaf on August 19, 2021, 06:58:31 AM

its not difficult to maintain they give it to marines


 :rofl: yup, but a squid would have trouble! :D
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: changemyoil66 on August 19, 2021, 07:34:15 AM
I would say the biggest decision is semi auto or pump.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: drck1000 on August 19, 2021, 08:36:12 AM
I would say the biggest decision is semi auto or pump.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
Both. . .  Get one of each

Oh, and O/U (I still want one one day)

And Uncle Joe's double barrel of deterrence. . .
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: powerlessbump on August 19, 2021, 08:51:06 AM
Both. . .  Get one of each

Oh, and O/U (I still want one one day)

And Uncle Joe's double barrel of deterrence. . .

Slam fire... Lever...

As for me, I would run a pump to keep it cheap and use the rest to help keep a lawyer on retainer.
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: raudi on August 19, 2021, 09:28:46 AM
I bought a stoeger M3000 last year. So far I've been really happy with it and it was only $600 from SEC.
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: RSN172 on August 19, 2021, 10:00:58 AM
Since I too poor to afford a factory made shotgun,  I had to make one with stuff from Home Depot for about $30. As a suggestion if you are going to make one, get the 3/4 black pipe for the barrel /chamber, but don't buy the 1 inch black pipe for the firing pin section. That has a weld bead on the inside which you will need to grind off.  The silver color pipe does not have a weld bead on the inside and if you are lucky, you might find one that slips over the 3/4 pipe without any work.  Most times you will have to sand off  a few thousandths on the outside of the pipe to make it slide in and out easily. I got chamber inserts so it can fire 12 and 20 gauge, 9MM and 22LR. The 9MM and 22LR inserts have a very short rifled barrel.  Still not very accurate but I wouldn't want someone shooting at me from 50 ft or less.
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: QUIETShooter on August 19, 2021, 10:06:12 AM
Where do you guys train with your shotguns?  KHSC rifle side restrict to only slugs.  Can you use HD type shotguns at the skeet and trap bays?

Sorry if dumb question.  I don't own a shotgun (as you can tell).

Another dumb question:  Why only slugs at the rifle side?  Shotguns are relatively short distance weapons.  What could possibly be more of a safety hazard with shot vs. say, a rifle round like 30-06, 308, 7mm, etc.?

Unless there is an entirely other reason besides the shot loads themselves?
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: changemyoil66 on August 19, 2021, 10:13:10 AM
Where do you guys train with your shotguns?  KHSC rifle side restrict to only slugs.  Can you use HD type shotguns at the skeet and trap bays?

Sorry if dumb question.  I don't own a shotgun (as you can tell).

Another dumb question:  Why only slugs at the rifle side?  Shotguns are relatively short distance weapons.  What could possibly be more of a safety hazard with shot vs. say, a rifle round like 30-06, 308, 7mm, etc.?

Unless there is an entirely other reason besides the shot loads themselves?

HDF open shoot allows various shots.  At 30 yards, bird shot spread is like from foot to head size.  At 5 yards it's like an avocado. 
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: changemyoil66 on August 19, 2021, 10:13:23 AM
Both. . .  Get one of each

Oh, and O/U (I still want one one day)

And Uncle Joe's double barrel of deterrence. . .

Mrs. CMO wants an Elmer Fudd one.
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: aaronc5362 on August 19, 2021, 10:16:12 AM
Where do you guys train with your shotguns?  KHSC rifle side restrict to only slugs.  Can you use HD type shotguns at the skeet and trap bays?

Sorry if dumb question.  I don't own a shotgun (as you can tell).

Another dumb question:  Why only slugs at the rifle side?  Shotguns are relatively short distance weapons.  What could possibly be more of a safety hazard with shot vs. say, a rifle round like 30-06, 308, 7mm, etc.?

Unless there is an entirely other reason besides the shot loads themselves?

I never went hardcore like john wick. But i got some "training" on my friend's private land a couple times with the 870. And at home with about 15 dummy rounds (mixture of a zoom, carlsons, ebay ones) i practice reloads. Havent done it in a while tho, but its muscle memory.

Kokohead lets you shoot buck at the 100 yard burm. Id recommend taking your target off the range. Lol

Kokohead has the skeet or trap shooting section in the back.
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: drck1000 on August 19, 2021, 10:30:41 AM
Mrs. CMO wants an Elmer Fudd one.
Do it. . . Doooooo. . . itttttttttt!

I have long wanted a nice O/U.  Was looking at Brownings for a while.  I easily get sidetracked by other gun expenses.  AK project, AR optic, and now bolt gun(s). 
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: drck1000 on August 19, 2021, 10:45:18 AM
I never went hardcore like john wick. But i got some "training" on my friend's private land a couple times with the 870. And at home with about 15 dummy rounds (mixture of a zoom, carlsons, ebay ones) i practice reloads. Havent done it in a while tho, but its muscle memory.

Kokohead lets you shoot buck at the 100 yard burm. Id recommend taking your target off the range. Lol

Kokohead has the skeet or trap shooting section in the back.
It's been a while since I've done training with shottys as well.  One local training/class group has been planning on having shotgun classes, but then COVID. 

When I did reloads with shotgun, I do recall certain shotguns have sharp flap/lever (dunno what the technical term for that part is). 
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: aletheuo137 on August 19, 2021, 11:38:47 AM
Mrs. CMO wants an Elmer Fudd one.
Wabbit season!(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20210819/5eea26724d301374201bfb37548bda41.jpg)

Sent from my SM-A102U using Tapatalk
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 19, 2021, 12:50:13 PM
Where do you guys train with your shotguns?  KHSC rifle side restrict to only slugs.  Can you use HD type shotguns at the skeet and trap bays?

Sorry if dumb question.  I don't own a shotgun (as you can tell).

Another dumb question:  Why only slugs at the rifle side?  Shotguns are relatively short distance weapons.  What could possibly be more of a safety hazard with shot vs. say, a rifle round like 30-06, 308, 7mm, etc.?

Unless there is an entirely other reason besides the shot loads themselves?

Front Sight has Tactical Shotgun classes.  Friend of mine went, but I have not yet.  He said it was great!

Shooting slugs for practice is actually better.  If you miss, you learn and correct.  Using a shot shell at 50 yds or more might not teach you as well how to be accurate. 

Also, if you're not practicing at 25 yds or closer, you're practicing to go to prison.  If you're over 75 feet from someone, you aren't likely in immediate danger.  "I saw him across the street in my neighbor's back yard, and it looked like he was aiming his pistol toward me ... so I shot him with 3 rounds of #00 Buckshot."  Yeah ... right!

KHSC has a few 25yd target frame holes for shotgun use.

 :stopjack: :stopjack: :stopjack:
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: changemyoil66 on August 19, 2021, 01:24:47 PM


Also, if you're not practicing at 25 yds or closer, you're practicing to go to prison.  If you're over 75 feet from someone, you aren't likely in immediate danger.  "I saw him across the street in my neighbor's back yard, and it looked like he was aiming his pistol toward me ... so I shot him with 3 rounds of #00 Buckshot."  Yeah ... right!



This is the train of thought why I don't have a LVPO and instead have a RDS on my AR. CQB.
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: jaynick on August 19, 2021, 01:35:02 PM
I have a benelli m1 and rem870. Also owned mossberg 500.
Id go benelli m4, or the beretta 1301 is 400 cheaper and very similar. Benelli m2 is nice but beretta 1301 is priced similarly and more modern. if i were spending 1300 id go beretta.

I got my benelli used. I wouldnt even recommend an m2 now that the patent expired and cheap stoegers that are identical. My friend got one in 20gauge for his wife and im pretty certain the bolt n barrel has same forge n proof marks as mine.

Quality semi autos that are well broken in have less malfunctions than a pump gun. Theres too much human error in short stroking pump guns when under pressure. And some of the malfunctions that i get in my benelli would happen in the 870 anyway, like when the tip of the hull is bent outwards.

Also there are other benefits from italian guns like chrome lined bores and better steel(and so much nicer looking). My remington receiver and barrel are rust buckets. Barrel is so bad with the cancer i bought another one as a backup. I figure i can only bore hone it so many times. The remington rust pits and gets rough feeling, but the rust from my sweaty left hand on the benelli is just surface cosmetic rust that cleans off easily. I cleaned the remington so many times the black oxide crappy finish wore thru so i painted it. The benelli still has original exterior finish and the bore is a mirror.
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: drck1000 on August 19, 2021, 01:43:47 PM
SNIP

Quality semi autos that are well broken in have less malfunctions than a pump gun. Theres too much human error in short stroking pump guns when under pressure. And some of the malfunctions that i get in my benelli would happen in the 870 anyway, like when the tip of the hull is bent outwards.

That is something that I've noticed as well, mostly in other folks' guns.  I noticed that in the later production 870s (say post 2017ish). 

On the Benelli M2 and M3, I've seen the previous HK iterations here and there.  Sometimes for prices much better than Benelli new.  Yeah, they're used, but many of the folks that had those HK versions seemed to be more "hobbist" folks.  At least from what I've seen.  There are a couple of HK models of the M3 that I had passed on a few times and still kicking myself. 
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: macsak on August 19, 2021, 02:06:15 PM
That is something that I've noticed as well, mostly in other folks' guns.  I noticed that in the later production 870s (say post 2017ish). 

On the Benelli M2 and M3, I've seen the previous HK iterations here and there.  Sometimes for prices much better than Benelli new.  Yeah, they're used, but many of the folks that had those HK versions seemed to be more "hobbist" folks.  At least from what I've seen.  There are a couple of HK models of the M3 that I had passed on a few times and still kicking myself.

HK owners are posers...
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 19, 2021, 02:06:32 PM
Piggy-backing on the comments re: pump action.

I think if one goes with an expensive dual-action shotgun -- both semi and pump in one firearm -- you can have the best of both worlds.

If, however, money is an issue, that's not going to be the best option. 

For pump action, I like the Mossberg 590 I posted.  Mossberg's actions have been engineered to provide a uniquely reliable method of chambering a round.  It also offers an excellent way to load directly into the chamber if the tube is empty. 

I also have a KELTEC KSG that holds 14+1 and is a bullpup design.  If you're looking for home defense shotguns, don't overlook the bullpups.

The KSG is excellent for close quarters.  No long barrel sticking out, and a pistol grip for the trigger hand.  The biggest disadvantage is the need to practice more until you get the pump action  mastered.  People regularly complain they short-stroke it.  That's because the length of pull is so much shorter than a full size shotgun.  Instead of having the support hand extended to the fore grip, allowing a long, smooth pull to rack a shell, your support arm starts on the KSG with it bent at the elbow and pointing more in a downward direction.  You have to seriously manhandle the gun when racking another round since you don't have the same leverage. 

The KSG design requires the carriage  to move past the end of the magazine tubes inside the butt stock before it can grab the next shell.  If you only pull back far enough to eject the expended shell, it's not going to pick up the next one, requiring yet another pump to load a round. 

There are all kinds of reviews of the KSG.  If interested, I'd watch them first and commit to practicing if you decide to get one.  Even if you use dummy shells to just practice cycling the action, you'll be doing yourself a huge favor.

For first timers, I think a "standard" size pump action is better if for home defense.  Having the Mossberg and the KSG gives me options.

Don't get me wrong.  I love the KSG, and I won't hesitate to grab it from the safe if needed.  I'm just saying you should know what you're getting before making a choice.
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: aieahound on August 19, 2021, 06:18:53 PM
Mrs. CMO wants an Elmer Fudd one.

Nothing like Crazy Joe Biden’s Double Barrel O’ Justice.
“Just fire two blasts….”

https://youtu.be/CrzyRXSxuAg

https://youtu.be/F-mztxHgYQo

Q. You still out there ?
(It’s not a general question. His user name is Q)

Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: drck1000 on August 20, 2021, 12:43:50 PM
HK  owners that shoot poofpoof are posers...
:rofl:
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: aaronc5362 on August 20, 2021, 01:11:26 PM

When I did reloads with shotgun, I do recall certain shotguns have sharp flap/lever (dunno what the technical term for that part is).


I think your referring to the... lift gate aka elevator. ??  This is where mossberg design shines in my opinion. 870 tends to pinch my fatty finger if done wrong.  Can always take some 1k grit sandpaper and smooth it out. I seen people dremel it so its nice and shiny and rounded edges or find a used mariner. Mine is 20ga, so im SOL on a mariner hahahha.

Yeah, i agree with above post about not pumping hard enough. But thats just user error. Just rack it hard. Kinda like how people ride the charging handle on ar15s. Its designed to be worked hard. Let that charging handle go.. or rack that pump like your throwing a left jab with all your 80%  of your strength. Lol.

I would love a semi auto shotty... preferably m2. Nothing wrong with m4 or m3.. just what i would want.

If you order online.. eurooptic.com has this "pay your tax rebate" often. I mustve gotten it 3 times in my email in the past couple months. Its always benellis. Lol. But they just charge for shipping..
But you gotta pay your local ffl fee too. Might be cheaper than in store.
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: aaronc5362 on August 20, 2021, 01:13:35 PM
Btw smiddy and wession ..
 just came out with their mp 12 gauge. So similar to the ksg or dp12.

I just seen it on youtube...
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: drck1000 on August 20, 2021, 01:49:52 PM

I think your referring to the... lift gate aka elevator. ??  This is where mossberg design shines in my opinion. 870 tends to pinch my fatty finger if done wrong.  Can always take some 1k grit sandpaper and smooth it out. I seen people dremel it so its nice and shiny and rounded edges or find a used mariner. Mine is 20ga, so im SOL on a mariner hahahha.


Yeah, that.   ;D  Flapper thingy.

Those were on other folks guns. I recall the flapper on the HK (M2 and M3 predecessor) shottys were particularly sharp.  Don't think my buddies would have appreciated me taking some sandpaper to their flappers. . .  ;D

I've shot that Mossberg marine one as well.  I like that shotty as well.  I've seen them run, and run, and run.  To the point where the barrel is hot even with gloves and keeps on going.  I wouldn't mind owning one if I was in the market for a pump.
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: aaronc5362 on August 20, 2021, 02:04:28 PM
Those were on other folks guns. I recall the flapper on the HK (M2 and M3 predecessor) shottys were particularly sharp.  Don't think my buddies would have appreciated me taking some sandpaper to their flappers. . . 

 :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:


Yeah, that.     Flapper thingy ..... waiting for sir jackson to chime in on this comment  :D
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: jc2721 on August 20, 2021, 02:33:16 PM
Check out some of Paul Harrell's youtube videos and you can decide for yourself on a shotgun. 

He has a distinguished rifleman's badge, if that means anything to you, and he doesn't seem full of himself.  :shaka:
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: omnigun on August 20, 2021, 02:49:25 PM
Check out some of Paul Harrell's youtube videos and you can decide for yourself on a shotgun. 

He has a distinguished rifleman's badge, if that means anything to you, and he doesn't seem full of himself.  :shaka:

Excellent source of info that wasn't bought and sold by a manufacturer.
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 20, 2021, 03:02:16 PM
Those were on other folks guns. I recall the flapper on the HK (M2 and M3 predecessor) shottys were particularly sharp.  Don't think my buddies would have appreciated me taking some sandpaper to their flappers. . . 

 :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:


Yeah, that.     Flapper thingy ..... waiting for sir jackson to chime in on this comment  :D

If you're flappy and you know it,  clap your hands!   :geekdanc: :geekdanc: :geekdanc:
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 20, 2021, 03:03:50 PM
Excellent source of info that wasn't bought and sold by a manufacture.

"Manufacture" is a verb.

You're one judgmental SOB.
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: omnigun on August 20, 2021, 03:13:23 PM
"Manufacture" is a verb.

You're one judgmental SOB.

Fixed, I actually don't point out spelling or grammar.  I don't care about those two.  People make mistakes, computers too.  Try focus on the content next time  :shaka:
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 20, 2021, 03:16:14 PM
Fixed, I actually don't point out spelling or grammar.  I don't care about those two.  People make mistakes, computers too.  Try focus on the content next time  :shaka:

You want me to focus on the content, but can't be bothered to learn the language so your "content" is intelligible.

#EveryoneElseIsIgnorant
#ReadMyMindNotMyWords
#NotSarcasm
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: Bota-CS1 on August 20, 2021, 03:28:37 PM
Never owned a shotgun but I am looking at a Benelli M4. Any cons? Any other recommendations? For HD

Benelli was the name recognition in the industry, which means other options get overlooked.  FN series of shotguns comes to mind as well as the Berettas and Remingtons.  I'd make some more recommendations based on what you're looking for the shotgun to do for you. 
Title: Re: Shotgun recommendation?
Post by: tim808 on August 20, 2021, 08:08:00 PM
I like the mossbergs for the tang safety.  For me, I like semi shotguns cause I don’t “train” and under stress I don’t have to worry about whether I cycled the action.  With a pump -sometimes a click, sometimes eject a live round

Used to do similar with a pump pball gun

Semi is just easier under stress

I have a Moss 930 that I bought to go hunting.  Only used it for trap a few times.  Seems ok but haven’t used it much.

I had a tristar pump and a semi.  Talk about bang for the buck.  Chrome lined barrel and chamber.  Durable exterior coating.  I regret selling them but we’re moving eventually and have to thin the herd.