2aHawaii
General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: QUIETShooter on August 28, 2021, 06:48:44 AM
-
To me anyway. And probably to the majority of Americans following the story.
It doesn't matter where one stands on the Jan. 6th riot at the capitol. I think the issue here is the conduct and actions of a police officer using deadly force and the decision of the DOJ to dismiss any criminal charges against him.
Officer Byrd claims he was doing his job. That he saved lives and countless jobs. What the hell is he talking about? There were police officers on both sides of that barricaded door. Some of them were directly behind Ashlii Babbet. He could have easily killed a fellow officer or a rioter by his reckless action.
No other police officer used their weapons in trying to subdue and control the rioters. They used courage and restraint as is expected. Drawing their weapons was the last resort.
The DOJ and Officer Byrd maintain that the shooting was justified. If we apply this same logic and assume every officer feels that way, there would have been dozens of rioters shot that day on Jan.6th or hundreds of fanatical looters and violent protestors during the summer riots that happened in Portland and other cities in 2020. But no. The police used extraordinary restraint and courage.
There were other officers with him on that side of the door. They could have restrained Ashlii. It's not like he was on his own defending against the hordes. The fact that this same officer showed lack of responsibility by leaving his service weapon in the restroom on one occasion and showed arrogance that nothing will happen because of it due to his rank and position shows a part of his character that should have drew a red flag.
And the DOJ exonerating him only fuels more distrust in everything associated with government.
I'd like to know how others on this forum feel about this subject. Please share what you think about Officer Byrd's actions and the DOJ's decision to pardon and condone his shooting of an unarmed rioter.
-
Officer Byrd claims he was doing his job. That he saved lives and countless jobs.
I am sure Derek Chauvin probably felt the same way ....
-
The cop was doing his job. Just like the recent incident in Hawaii. The race of the person shot or the political beliefs don't matter. That women shot was warned. There were government officials behind that barricade. That officer was 100% justified.
-
To me anyway. And probably to the majority of Americans following the story.
It doesn't matter where one stands on the Jan. 6th riot at the capitol. I think the issue here is the conduct and actions of a police officer using deadly force and the decision of the DOJ to dismiss any criminal charges against him.
Officer Byrd claims he was doing his job. That he saved lives and countless jobs. What the hell is he talking about? There were police officers on both sides of that barricaded door. Some of them were directly behind Ashlii Babbet. He could have easily killed a fellow officer or a rioter by his reckless action.
No other police officer used their weapons in trying to subdue and control the rioters. They used courage and restraint as is expected. Drawing their weapons was the last resort.
The DOJ and Officer Byrd maintain that the shooting was justified. If we apply this same logic and assume every officer feels that way, there would have been dozens of rioters shot that day on Jan.6th or hundreds of fanatical looters and violent protestors during the summer riots that happened in Portland and other cities in 2020. But no. The police used extraordinary restraint and courage.
There were other officers with him on that side of the door. They could have restrained Ashlii. It's not like he was on his own defending against the hordes. The fact that this same officer showed lack of responsibility by leaving his service weapon in the restroom on one occasion and showed arrogance that nothing will happen because of it due to his rank and position shows a part of his character that should have drew a red flag.
And the DOJ exonerating him only fuels more distrust in everything associated with government.
I'd like to know how others on this forum feel about this subject. Please share what you think about Officer Byrd's actions and the DOJ's decision to pardon and condone his shooting of an unarmed rioter.
"And the DOJ exonerating him only fuels more distrust in everything associated with government."
No shit. The biggest threat to our health, safety, and welfare is the Democrat infested Federal government. It practices no oversight of Democrats
or RINOs operating in the Democrat Party's interests. But won't hesitate to destroy Americans.
I maintain that modern "progressive" Democrats are not Americans.
As much as I despise police, I resist "Monday morning quarter backing" them. That being said, I don't know if
Democrats are capable of impartial investigations of their members, especially when one of those members is of their
"protected class".
When I concealed carry in WA state. I took that responsibility seriously. I doubt that I would have pulled
my weapon out in the conditions those cops were in. But then again citizens carrying guns are held to
a higher standard than highly trained professional cops are. We are not allowed to make mistakes.
:grrr:
-
The guy that took a dump and left his gun in the toilet :thumbsup:
-
This is an interesting edit of some of the videos.
Watch it and as many others of it as you can find. They were plentiful when all the video was up right after.
And draw your own conclusions.
Just a suggestion.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/investigations/2021/01/08/ashli-babbitt-shooting-video-capitol/
-
This is the perfect demonstration of how a liberal bubble breeds stupidity and eats their own. He has the "support" of everyone around him so he thinks it is safe to go on TV and tell his moronic story.
The Deep State is literally offering him up on the altar of sacrifice so that they have an excuse to start kicking our doors once someone executes him.
-
The cop was doing his job. Just like the recent incident in Hawaii. The race of the person shot or the political beliefs don't matter. That women shot was warned. There were government officials behind that barricade. That officer was 100% justified.
as always, you left out, "in my opinion"...
-
Nah. It was 100%. 8)
-
The guy that took a dump and left his gun in the toilet :thumbsup:
To be fair Capitol Police leaving Glocks around is hardly unusual.
https://www.rollcall.com/2019/02/27/capitol-police-weapon-left-unattended-in-capitol-bathroom-again/
CPD is outside of the other branches, has no oversight and cannot be FOIA'd.
So, how often do officers leave their guns unattended around the Capitol complex? The answer is unknown because Capitol Police are not required to disclose such incidents.
-
as always, you left out, "in my opinion"...
No. It's a fact. If you have a problem with it, deal with the courts/justice system.
-
In my opinion . . . there was repeated yelling "there's a gun", "he's got a gun". If a person is doing something they should not be doing, and law enforcement is pointing a gun in their direction, they need to stop and back away, comply, or surrender. Respect the guy with the gun and hopefully you won't get shot.
-
The more I watch that video the more I believe a lot of it was staged in order to provoke an overreaction. The guards walked away from their posts, swat team standing by doing nothing, perfect camera angles, FBI plants in the crowd screaming for blood.
They so desperately want the "American Taliban" to engage in a terrorist act of retribution in order to justify the horrible things that they want to do to us.
-
This is a twitter post by General Michael Hayden, former director of the CIA and NSA. If they really believe this about us then it's more than reasonable to expect the kind of dirty tricks they have specialized in over the past 80 years.
https://www.sofmag.com/meet-the-general-former-director-of-cia-nsa-that-compares-convoys-of-americans-waving-u-s-flags-to-taliban/
(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/E9M_D2GWYAYei06?format=jpg&name=large)
-
This is a twitter post by General Michael Hayden, former director of the CIA and NSA. If they really believe this about us then it's more than reasonable to expect the kind of dirty tricks they have specialized in over the past 80 years.
https://www.sofmag.com/meet-the-general-former-director-of-cia-nsa-that-compares-convoys-of-americans-waving-u-s-flags-to-taliban/
(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/E9M_D2GWYAYei06?format=jpg&name=large)
He was always human garbage. I remember watching his speech when he went to DefCon the hacker/ tech convention many many years ago. He got a lot of boos, but he was there trying to recruit people and it obviously worked. Techlords went from 'All Information Must Be Free' to 'You Aren't Allowed to Say or See That!'
He is scum.
-
The more I watch that video the more I believe a lot of it was staged in order to provoke an overreaction. The guards walked away from their posts, swat team standing by doing nothing, perfect camera angles, FBI plants in the crowd screaming for blood.
They so desperately want the "American Taliban" to engage in a terrorist act of retribution in order to justify the horrible things that they want to do to us.
I thought it a little strange that the 3 officers moved away when the swat team arrived. They were relieved from duty I guess?
Also the swat team didn't immediately replace the officers but kinda hung off the side. This allowed time for the rioters to break the windows enough for the woman to try to get through.
This is an interesting edit of some of the videos.
Watch it and as many others of it as you can find. They were plentiful when all the video was up right after.
And draw your own conclusions.
Just a suggestion.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/investigations/2021/01/08/ashli-babbitt-shooting-video-capitol/
Thanks for sharing this. I didn't see this version and showed a lot of other things not shown in earlier videos.
-
I thought it a little strange that the 3 officers moved away when the swat team arrived. They were relieved from duty I guess?
Also the swat team didn't immediately replace the officers but kinda hung off the side. This allowed time for the rioters to break the windows enough for the woman to try to get through.
Thanks for sharing this. I didn't see this version and showed a lot of other things not shown in earlier videos.
Find out where they live. set their cribs on fire , shoot everything that leaves the structure, and then fade into the night.
:wave:
-
Trying to be objective as possible:
I don't know all the details of the case but I could see how under the right set of circumstances the shooting may have been justified. I have seen the video and I would say that the video in and of itself doesn't justify the shooting. However depending on:
-the building layout,
-what Officer Byrd could see and hear,
-what other officers/officials may have been telling him,
-what/who he was protecting
-what other weapons he may have had access to,
The shooting may have been justifiable in my opinion.
I don't know whether I would have shot were I in his position though.
-
Did Officer Byrd shout out a warning to Ashlee Babbett as she climbed through the barricade? You know, the usual “stop or I’ll shoot” phrase?
-
Did Officer Byrd shout out a warning to Ashlee Babbett as she climbed through the barricade? You know, the usual “stop or I’ll shoot” phrase?
I don't recall hearing him say one in the video but so much background noise I might not be able to hear it if he did.
-
I don't recall hearing him say one in the video but so much background noise I might not be able to hear it if he did.
He did mention he shouted in the manner of : Stop. Please. Get Back.
But in my opinion it doesn't hold as much water as : Stop. Or I'll Shoot.
And yes, I know I am on the outside looking in. Easy to play armchair quarterback when one wasn't in that situation.
Trying to understand just exactly what kind of threat Ashlee was posing in that scenario where she had to be shot and also trying to understand how DOJ and other agencies investigating came to their conclusion.
-
Context matters.
Someone primed the situation to create hysteria and panic for the security forces inside the Capitol that day.
Trump asked to have the National Guard activated to provide additional crowd control / security a few days before, Gen Milley denied the request. (threat level increase)
FBI released a last second middle of the night vague warning of organized violence by unknown groups being imminent. (threat level increase)
Then early in the morning reports that bombs were set around DC. ( massive threat level increase)
Ninjas were sent to multiple locations to cut the temporary fencing and the crowds start moving closer to the building. (threat level increase)
Someone orders Flashbangs and CS to get fired into the unmoving crowd. Which makes them start moving (threat level increase)
Someone orders guards to stand down at doors on one end of the building and let people in, (perimeter breach) (threat level increase)
While on the opposite side of the building Anti-fa folks are breaking windows and forcing doors (threat level increase)
I am sure radio chatter was a mess, spamming reports of breaches and locations of crowds all over the building. I am sure the mentality was now that they were under siege.
Look at all the pics where they stacked chairs up against doors to make panicked barricades like tropes from a bad movie. A lot of those door didnt even have locks.
the IG report about that day after the fact severely criticized the CPD for not having done ANY planing, training or developed any strategic protocols for scenarios where crowds came into the building.
All this certainly made for a situation where I am sure more than some of the security in the building were sh*tting their pants and certain they were go down Benghazi style and their corpses were going to be dragged to the street and hung from light poles
To me it doesnt look at all like some random snowballing of events, more like someone was making sure a lot of boxes got checked to create a situation where deadly force would be used, legitimately or not.
-
No. It's a fact. If you have a problem with it, deal with the courts/justice system.
how is it a fact if it wasn't proven in a court of law?
or consensus?
or wherever you moved the goalposts to today?
-
He did mention he shouted in the manner of : Stop. Please. Get Back.
But in my opinion it doesn't hold as much water as : Stop. Or I'll Shoot.
And yes, I know I am on the outside looking in. Easy to play armchair quarterback when one wasn't in that situation.
Trying to understand just exactly what kind of threat Ashlee was posing in that scenario where she had to be shot and also trying to understand how DOJ and other agencies investigating came to their conclusion.
In my opinion if a guy with a gun is pointing at you and says Stop. Please. Get Back. I think most people would get the point.
I think the threat was if she gets past and others follow there are VIP members behind that door/area.
-
how is it a fact if it wasn't proven in a court of law?
or consensus?
or wherever you moved the goalposts to today?
It was proven in the court of law. Charges dismissed or not issued.
-
Context matters.
Someone primed the situation to create hysteria and panic for the security forces inside the Capitol that day.
Trump asked to have the National Guard activated to provide additional crowd control / security a few days before, Gen Milley denied the request. (threat level increase)
FBI released a last second middle of the night vague warning of organized violence by unknown groups being imminent. (threat level increase)
Then early in the morning reports that bombs were set around DC. ( massive threat level increase)
Ninjas were sent to multiple locations to cut the temporary fencing and the crowds start moving closer to the building. (threat level increase)
Someone orders Flashbangs and CS to get fired into the unmoving crowd. Which makes them start moving (threat level increase)
Someone orders guards to stand down at doors on one end of the building and let people in, (perimeter breach) (threat level increase)
While on the opposite side of the building Anti-fa folks are breaking windows and forcing doors (threat level increase)
I am sure radio chatter was a mess, spamming reports of breaches and locations of crowds all over the building. I am sure the mentality was now that they were under siege.
Look at all the pics where they stacked chairs up against doors to make panicked barricades like tropes from a bad movie. A lot of those door didnt even have locks.
the IG report about that day after the fact severely criticized the CPD for not having done ANY planing, training or developed any strategic protocols for scenarios where crowds came into the building.
All this certainly made for a situation where I am sure more than some of the security in the building were sh*tting their pants and certain they were go down Benghazi style and their corpses were going to be dragged to the street and hung from light poles
To me it doesnt look at all like some random snowballing of events, more like someone was making sure a lot of boxes got checked to create a situation where deadly force would be used, legitimately or not.
(https://media1.giphy.com/media/VM01S5yIaKCgqg1bSF/giphy.gif)
-
He did mention he shouted in the manner of : Stop. Please. Get Back.
But in my opinion it doesn't hold as much water as : Stop. Or I'll Shoot.
And yes, I know I am on the outside looking in. Easy to play armchair quarterback when one wasn't in that situation.
Trying to understand just exactly what kind of threat Ashlee was posing in that scenario where she had to be shot and also trying to understand how DOJ and other agencies investigating came to their conclusion.
As I see it, unlike many officer's use of force situations where it is usually 1v1 or 2v1 type settings this was a large crowd which I think forces the officer to look at not only her as a possible threat but the group as a whole. If one person breaks the line of defense then there is a decent probability that more will follow since once he tackles the first one the others can enter unchallenged. So knowing that a failure to stop the first one may mean they all could enter. So the officer might try to evaluate the threat that the crowd poses as a whole. Can the officer tell if the crowd means harm to one of the people being protected? Imagine (hypothetically) if the officer heard someone in the crowd yell out "Kill the senator!" The officer would have to weigh the threat of the whole crowd. It would really be a tough call and I don't know whether they get dignitary protection training like the Secret Service or not.
-
What would HPD and the City Prosecutors do to an officer who fired into and unarmed crowd?