2aHawaii
General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: tat1029 on October 04, 2021, 12:29:14 PM
-
Howdy gang,
I'm new here, this is my first post, thanks for having me.
I've been inquiring and researching for regulations (zoning, permitting, rounds allowed per minute/hr... etc) for target practice on private AG lot on BI, but am getting nowhere. Nobody seems to know it 100%. These AG lots are on the East side, 125ft wide by 1040ft long. I understand about reckless endangering, berms/baffles to prevent noise, and some of the basic safety guidelines. I'd like to practice on my property, and when the neighbors call the cops and they end up on my gate, I want to be sure of my rights and speak from knowledge and confidence. I can't afford to have a misdemeanor on my record either as I'm still an income generator. Also, I have constant wild pigs that I need to manage, so I need to practice, no other way around. And since there are no public target places on this side, how can we acquire safe gun handling if we do not have outlets for practice?
FYIs that may help:
- my closest neighbor is about 500ft away from my target, and I have made sure that the lot behind me is inhabited, so no neighbors on the direction of ammo for at least 1,300ft
- i'd be wanting to shoot .345 riffle, .22 rifle (mostly) and occasional pistol
Lastly, if anyone has leads on private target areas on the East side, please share, you can shoot me an email via the forum.
Thanks! :geekdanc:
-
I read that the individual counties/islands regulate use of private property. Check the local ordinances for your city and county.
Here are some earlier discussions on the matter of public ranges on Hawaii Island and what's allowed on private property.
There are also posts on here showing the NRA specs for building a shooting range, but that's outside whatever the local ordinances and laws might allow.
The biggest problem as discussed here is noise complaints. If neighbors complain, whether or not your gunfire rises to the level of noise nuisance, a Cop might not want to listen to your explanation of why the noise doesn't violate any ordinances. Think dog barking. If it goes on incessantly for 5 minutes, it's a nuisance. If it starts and stops with a few minutes between noises that only last a few minutes, it's not against the ordinance. That doesn't mean the Cop isn't going to issue a summons. You'll need to show evidence you aren't breaking the ordinances. Best way to do that is install surveillance cameras at your shooting spot or put a video camera in place while shooting, capturing the shooting AND pauses.
No matter what, have your lawyer on speed dial, and give his card to responding officers to any noise complaints. The Cops may not want to judge whether or not your evidence proves you were within the permitted noise durations. They may just cite you and let you defend yourself in front of a ... well ... judge. Having a lawyer already familiar with your shooting situation would expedite clearing up any misunderstandings.
Maybe you should talk to your neighbors. If they have times they'd be more inclined to tolerate noise, and other times when they need quiet, maybe accommodating them would prevent a 911 call? Never hurts to ask.
https://www.hawaiitribune-herald.com/2017/08/18/hawaii-news/county-council-approves-gun-ranges-for-the-big-island/
https://www.bigislandvideonews.com/2017/01/18/video-shooting-range-talk-packs-hilo-gmac-meeting/
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=26209.msg230756#msg230756
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=1864.msg15101;topicseen#msg15101
-
Howdy gang,
I'm new here, this is my first post, thanks for having me.
I've been inquiring and researching for regulations (zoning, permitting, rounds allowed per minute/hr... etc) for target practice on private AG lot on BI, but am getting nowhere. Nobody seems to know it 100%. These AG lots are on the East side, 125ft wide by 1040ft long. I understand about reckless endangering, berms/baffles to prevent noise, and some of the basic safety guidelines. I'd like to practice on my property, and when the neighbors call the cops and they end up on my gate, I want to be sure of my rights and speak from knowledge and confidence. I can't afford to have a misdemeanor on my record either as I'm still an income generator. Also, I have constant wild pigs that I need to manage, so I need to practice, no other way around. And since there are no public target places on this side, how can we acquire safe gun handling if we do not have outlets for practice?
FYIs that may help:
- my closest neighbor is about 500ft away from my target, and I have made sure that the lot behind me is inhabited, so no neighbors on the direction of ammo for at least 1,300ft
- i'd be wanting to shoot .345 riffle, .22 rifle (mostly) and occasional pistol
Lastly, if anyone has leads on private target areas on the East side, please share, you can shoot me an email via the forum.
Thanks! :geekdanc:
Puna?
-
I suppose you guys expected me to chime in.
I'm East side BI.
Very simply it all has to do with your neighbors.
Have a talk with them, and invite them to leave
if they have a problem.
Because they are the only ones that do.
Across a gulch from me I have heard
automatic weapons fire.
Very illegal in Hawaii.
Why would I call the cops?
Hawaii gun laws suck and I'd never turn
anyone over to the cops
for someone just "Plinking".
BI, know your neighbors.
don't fuck with them
and that is pretty much it.
Never call the cops.
Aloha
:shaka:
-
I suppose you guys expected me to chime in.
I'm East side BI.
Very simply it all has to do with your neighbors.
Have a talk with them, and invite them to leave
if they have a problem.
Because they are the only ones that do.
Across a gulch from me I have heard
automatic weapons fire.
Very illegal in Hawaii.
Why would I call the cops?
Hawaii gun laws suck and I'd never turn
anyone over to the cops
for someone just "Plinking".
BI, know your neighbors.
don't fuck with them
and that is pretty much it.
Never call the cops.
Aloha
:shaka:
The world needs more gun friendly people like that in this world
-
I suppose you guys expected me to chime in.
I'm East side BI.
Very simply it all has to do with your neighbors.
Have a talk with them, and invite them to leave
if they have a problem.
Because they are the only ones that do.
Across a gulch from me I have heard
automatic weapons fire.
Very illegal in Hawaii.
Why would I call the cops?
Hawaii gun laws suck and I'd never turn
anyone over to the cops
for someone just "Plinking".
BI, know your neighbors.
don't fuck with them
and that is pretty much it.
Never call the cops.
Aloha
:shaka:
Fireworks are illegal.
Guns are legal.
Both make loud noises.
Just an observation.
-
Fireworks are illegal.
Guns are legal.
Both make loud noises.
Just an observation.
Just for you,
We don't do a lot of fireworks.
It scares the shit out of very strong animals
that go through fences like a hot knife through butter.
We can get them back in, but
it is a pain to do do.
and then we have to fix fences.
:popcorn:
-
Just for you,
We don't do a lot of fireworks.
It scares the shit out of very strong animals
that go through fences like a hot knife through butter.
We can get them back in, but
it is a pain to do do.
and then we have to fix fences.
:popcorn:
I abstain from burning up my income in the form of fireworks.
There are people around my neighborhood who routinely set off those window-rattling explosions. I really wish I could catch them in the act. Cops can't/won't do anything without an eye witness who can identify the individual.
And, yes, the noise freaks out my pets. Not to mention, I really don't like the noise, either. More than inconsiderate. More like cruel and sadistic.
I'm amazed people have that much disposable income in this high cost of living "paradise."
-
Puna?
YES
-
I suppose you guys expected me to chime in.
I'm East side BI.
Very simply it all has to do with your neighbors.
Have a talk with them, and invite them to leave
if they have a problem.
Because they are the only ones that do.
Across a gulch from me I have heard
automatic weapons fire.
Very illegal in Hawaii.
Why would I call the cops?
Hawaii gun laws suck and I'd never turn
anyone over to the cops
for someone just "Plinking".
BI, know your neighbors.
don't fuck with them
and that is pretty much it.
Never call the cops.
Aloha
:shaka:
I'm all about alerting my closest neighbors, I think it's basic courtesy. Sound carries super far out here so it's impossible to alert everyone. Most closer neighbors are gun-friendly and shoot occasionally, either for pig management or just because. And no one sends out alerts. The problem always is the one or two who are super sensitive and no matter how nice we go about and communicate in advance, they are always in disapproval. It only takes that one neighbor to ruin it. And giving courtesy alert to the types only gives them the opportunity to call the cops in advance for them to show up in the act. It's a toughy ::).
-
I abstain from burning up my income in the form of fireworks.
There are people around my neighborhood who routinely set off those window-rattling explosions. I really wish I could catch them in the act. Cops can't/won't do anything without an eye witness who can identify the individual.
And, yes, the noise freaks out my pets. Not to mention, I really don't like the noise, either. More than inconsiderate. More like cruel and sadistic.
I'm amazed people have that much disposable income in this high cost of living "paradise."
I hear you. Same happens in my hood, from time to time the explosives go off when it's not even a holiday to justify. Cops can do nothing in these cases, not that I ever called but have heard the reports.
-
Fireworks are illegal.
Guns are legal.
Both make loud noises.
Just an observation.
Right?? Great observation, thanks
-
I read that the individual counties/islands regulate use of private property. Check the local ordinances for your city and county.
Here are some earlier discussions on the matter of public ranges on Hawaii Island and what's allowed on private property.
There are also posts on here showing the NRA specs for building a shooting range, but that's outside whatever the local ordinances and laws might allow.
The biggest problem as discussed here is noise complaints. If neighbors complain, whether or not your gunfire rises to the level of noise nuisance, a Cop might not want to listen to your explanation of why the noise doesn't violate any ordinances. Think dog barking. If it goes on incessantly for 5 minutes, it's a nuisance. If it starts and stops with a few minutes between noises that only last a few minutes, it's not against the ordinance. That doesn't mean the Cop isn't going to issue a summons. You'll need to show evidence you aren't breaking the ordinances. Best way to do that is install surveillance cameras at your shooting spot or put a video camera in place while shooting, capturing the shooting AND pauses.
No matter what, have your lawyer on speed dial, and give his card to responding officers to any noise complaints. The Cops may not want to judge whether or not your evidence proves you were within the permitted noise durations. They may just cite you and let you defend yourself in front of a ... well ... judge. Having a lawyer already familiar with your shooting situation would expedite clearing up any misunderstandings.
Maybe you should talk to your neighbors. If they have times they'd be more inclined to tolerate noise, and other times when they need quiet, maybe accommodating them would prevent a 911 call? Never hurts to ask.
https://www.hawaiitribune-herald.com/2017/08/18/hawaii-news/county-council-approves-gun-ranges-for-the-big-island/
https://www.bigislandvideonews.com/2017/01/18/video-shooting-range-talk-packs-hilo-gmac-meeting/
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=26209.msg230756#msg230756
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=1864.msg15101;topicseen#msg15101
Excellent reply, thank you @Flapp_Jackson!
I will check the ordinances and go from there. You provided two very valuable takeaways: 1) having a lawyer on speed dial and a biz card to hand out, and 2) video evidence of following ordinances. Like I answered on another post, most neighbors seem ok and also shoot occasionally, often just a few rounds so they don't bother to communicate about it. Also it's frequently pig-related, so impossible to alert everyone or you chance losing the target. In my case I'm looking to ALSO practice so it will be longer rounds. I'm ok with working with the neighbors but the problem in asking for ideal times is that each one will have their own and may be impossible to find a slot that works for everyone, it may just open up a can of worms. Then there are the one or two who are super touchy and never in agreement. I'm thinking the best course it to state the time I'm planning to shoot and send out a quick group message to closest ones. I'll have to figure what the sweet spot is.
I'll go now read the articles you linked here, thank you again!
Aloha
-
Excellent reply, thank you @Flapp_Jackson!
I will check the ordinances and go from there. You provided two very valuable takeaways: 1) having a lawyer on speed dial and a biz card to hand out, and 2) video evidence of following ordinances. Like I answered on another post, most neighbors seem ok and also shoot occasionally, often just a few rounds so they don't bother to communicate about it. Also it's frequently pig-related, so impossible to alert everyone or you chance losing the target. In my case I'm looking to ALSO practice so it will be longer rounds. I'm ok with working with the neighbors but the problem in asking for ideal times is that each one will have their own and may be impossible to find a slot that works for everyone, it may just open up a can of worms. Then there are the one or two who are super touchy and never in agreement. I'm thinking the best course it to state the time I'm planning to shoot and send out a quick group message to closest ones. I'll have to figure what the sweet spot is.
I'll go now read the articles you linked here, thank you again!
Aloha
I'm glad you found some value in my post.
Rather than imagine what problems will prevent neighbors from agreeing to a time for you to shoot, I was thinking of asking about times they don't want the noise.
One issue that may come up might be someone with a child who naps in the afternoon. Another might be someone who works nights and sleeps in the morning.
Just asking is enough to give them notice of who's making the noise so they don't wonder what's going on. Then, if they prefer the noise occur at a different time, they know who to talk to.
Knowledge reduces stress -- usually.
I'm not suggesting that you let the neighbors dictate your shooting schedule. More like, if you have a choice when you practice, choose a time that irritates the fewest possible people within earshot. The only way to know when that is would be to ask.
It's easier to invite the neighbors to a party than it is to deal with the Cops at 1AM because the neighbors didn't appreciate the noise. Hopefully they would feel comfortable enough to ask you to tone it down rather than call the Cops. Heck, the neighbors might decide to have a beer since they're up anyway! :geekdanc: :thumbsup:
Good luck. :shaka:
-
It might be a little far, but the Morita Camp Shooting Range 16 Mile Marker is located on Saddle Road
-
There's ways to mitigate just about any problem, just depends how much you want to spend.
You can mitigate noise issues, depending on the landscape, by building tall dirt berms or hescos to absorb and redirect sound. Though things like nearby trees and hills would reflect sound back. And be nice to the neighbors.
Usually biggest problems are surface danger zones, neighbors sound issues, and lead runoff in streams.
-
SNIP
FYIs that may help:
- my closest neighbor is about 500ft away from my target, and I have made sure that the lot behind me is inhabited, so no neighbors on the direction of ammo for at least 1,300ft
- i'd be wanting to shoot .345 riffle, .22 rifle (mostly) and occasional pistol
Lastly, if anyone has leads on private target areas on the East side, please share, you can shoot me an email via the forum.
Thanks! :geekdanc:
It's been a LONG time since I was in the range planner/designer role. 1,300 ft isn't a lot without mitigation/barriers. Even for .22 lr. Dunno what particular rifle calibers you were envisioning, but you're talking potentially mile(s). I've had projects to design baffles (side and ceiling), backstops, bullet catches, etc. Those stuff aren't cheap. That said, depends on your site's topography. If you need to dig/excavate an area, to form say a berm, be very careful on the site drainage. I've seen some epic failures on that aspect.
-
I dunno what .345 is, but a 22lr and 9mm pistol range is easier to accommodate than rifles. Main thing is the downrange area is cleared for the maximum range of whatever your firing and you have an adequate backstop. There's things that can mitigate the range issues like overhead baffles or shooting rifles through a culvert pipe etc.
NRA has a range guide for purchase.
-
I'm glad you found some value in my post.
Rather than imagine what problems will prevent neighbors from agreeing to a time for you to shoot, I was thinking of asking about times they don't want the noise.
One issue that may come up might be someone with a child who naps in the afternoon. Another might be someone who works nights and sleeps in the morning.
Just asking is enough to give them notice of who's making the noise so they don't wonder what's going on. Then, if they prefer the noise occur at a different time, they know who to talk to.
Knowledge reduces stress -- usually.
I'm not suggesting that you let the neighbors dictate your shooting schedule. More like, if you have a choice when you practice, choose a time that irritates the fewest possible people within earshot. The only way to know when that is would be to ask.
It's easier to invite the neighbors to a party than it is to deal with the Cops at 1AM because the neighbors didn't appreciate the noise. Hopefully they would feel comfortable enough to ask you to tone it down rather than call the Cops. Heck, the neighbors might decide to have a beer since they're up anyway! :geekdanc: :thumbsup:
Good luck. :shaka:
Gotcha! Yes, I've already reached out to the few who are most affected and asked. So far so good :shaka:.
"Heck, the neighbors might decide to have a beer since they're up anyway!" ;D Right?
-
It might be a little far, but the Morita Camp Shooting Range 16 Mile Marker is located on Saddle Road
Way far, no feasible. It would be a full day commitment and a lot of driving. We need more ranges spread out the East side, period.
-
I dunno what .345 is, but a 22lr and 9mm pistol range is easier to accommodate than rifles. Main thing is the downrange area is cleared for the maximum range of whatever your firing and you have an adequate backstop. There's things that can mitigate the range issues like overhead baffles or shooting rifles through a culvert pipe etc.
NRA has a range guide for purchase.
Rifle needed for pigs + distance. By .345 I meant ammo. For target practice, have backstop, will look into baffle and culvert pipe, not familiar with latter. Thank you.
-
It's been a LONG time since I was in the range planner/designer role. 1,300 ft isn't a lot without mitigation/barriers. Even for .22 lr. Dunno what particular rifle calibers you were envisioning, but you're talking potentially mile(s). I've had projects to design baffles (side and ceiling), backstops, bullet catches, etc. Those stuff aren't cheap. That said, depends on your site's topography. If you need to dig/excavate an area, to form say a berm, be very careful on the site drainage. I've seen some epic failures on that aspect.
Always mitigation barrier, have a backstop in place with at least 1,000ft of uninhabited land behind it. Super safe.
"I've seen some epic failures on that aspect" I bet! I've seen some myself, not related to shooting ranges, but just thoughtless excavation without taking topography into consideration. Because you know, mankind wants what it wants. Then nature teaches hard lessons :worship:
-
I APPRECIATE EVERYONE'S INPUT - MAHALO!!! :shaka: :shaka: :shaka:
-
Good general information ....
Building A Backyard Range
Before you begin construction on your range, you will need to visit with your county planning department.
While there, thoroughly review your state and local laws and zoning ordinances as well as any potential
neighborhood covenants, codes, and restrictions that may be in place regarding the recreational use of
firearms on your property. You will also want to identify, if any, Environmental Protection Agency restrictions
on lead ammunition or regulatory requirements for reclamation of spent lead ammunition.
This is also a great time to discuss your construction plans with the planning department in the event that
you need to apply for permits or update your property site plan.
Additionally, you may consider having a conversation with the local code enforcement personnel to inform
them of your plans to construct a range on your property and that you have verified that it is legal and in
accordance with local zoning ordinances. This will help them manage neighbor complaints that they may
receive once your range is established and you start shooting.
The National Rifle Association has an online Range Development and Operations course that is designed
to educate people that are looking to build a public range or private range. The comprehensive course that
gives helpful information regarding environmental concerns along with indoor and outdoor range construction.
For a much lower price point, the NRA Range Source Book retails for $59.95 and has over 30 chapters that
will help you get started on your indoor or outdoor range.
https://www.gunsamerica.com/digest/building-a-backyard-range/
Find out what the Hawaii Island dispatchers' procedures are when they receive a 911 call reporting gunfire. If they check their database, and your address is listed as having a range, the dispatcher may be able to let the caller know, and no officers will be dispatched.
If you've followed the news about ranges on the mainland, many anti-gunners have moved into areas with ranges only to do everything they can to have them shut down. Noise is the #1 complaint used to cause gun ranges problems.
-
From Flapp’s quote:
You will also want to identify, if any, Environmental Protection Agency restrictions
on lead ammunition or regulatory requirements for reclamation of spent lead ammunition.
It was on my mind that if ever to re-sell the property would you have to do lead reclamation or disclose it to the buyer regarding lead.
I would think you would have to at least disclose it. Especially on AG land.
Loved shooting on my friends old ag land though. :D
-
Gotcha! Yes, I've already reached out to the few who are most affected and asked. So far so good :shaka:.
"Heck, the neighbors might decide to have a beer since they're up anyway!" ;D Right?
If you have that sort of neighbors, all the better. They can bring ammo and beer. ;D
-
Dang. I wanna be your neighbor. ;D
That’s cool that the neighbors are good with it so far.
-
Always mitigation barrier, have a backstop in place with at least 1,000ft of uninhabited land behind it. Super safe.
1,000ft and a berm aren't enough alone if there are buildings downrange. 9mm can go something like 4,000ft.
-
I'm all about alerting my closest neighbors, I think it's basic courtesy. Sound carries super far out here so it's impossible to alert everyone. Most closer neighbors are gun-friendly and shoot occasionally, either for pig management or just because. And no one sends out alerts. The problem always is the one or two who are super sensitive and no matter how nice we go about and communicate in advance, they are always in disapproval. It only takes that one neighbor to ruin it. And giving courtesy alert to the types only gives them the opportunity to call the cops in advance for them to show up in the act. It's a toughy ::).
I'm at the very end of this thread.
You are BI so you know that bad neighbors will be invited to leave
and they eventually will leave.
Be they busy-bodies or Meth factories.
Lots of guys on this site are City centric. Consider this
BI is the size of Connecticut and only two hundred thousand people.
Most the cops can't even physically drive to our houses, much less find them
outside towns.
Discreetly check things out and go from there.
Fuk the law. for shooting, But only here.
Oahu has too many pussies to get away with
that.
:wacko:
-
From Flapp’s quote:
You will also want to identify, if any, Environmental Protection Agency restrictions
on lead ammunition or regulatory requirements for reclamation of spent lead ammunition.
It was on my mind that if ever to re-sell the property would you have to do lead reclamation or disclose it to the buyer regarding lead.
I would think you would have to at least disclose it. Especially on AG land.
:D
This is a good question for real estate agents, since selling a property in HI requires full disclosure, usually. In other states, the seller pays the buyer a fee/consideration (around $500) to waive that requirement. We wouldn't want to disclose dead bodies on the land, would we? :crazy:
In the Hunter Ed course and the state web site, it is mentioned that certain hunting areas border private property, and hunters need to get permission from the owner to enter that land. Wouldn't this pose a lead remediation problem, and why would an owner risk having to deal with such an issue?
-
Hunting is not a practice range. Hopefully your not putting thousands of rounds down range while hunting.
Unless it’s doves and birdshot.
And it’s just something to consider.
Been to couple of ranges set up on ag land on Oahu.
They are good fun.
One was the only place two of my kids would go shooting because informal and we could blow up all the apples, melons and strawberries we wanted. (Strawberries mounted on meat sticks.)
Reactive targets are awesome.
But then the pigs would come in later to grab the leftover debris.
-
This is a good question for real estate agents, since selling a property in HI requires full disclosure, usually. In other states, the seller pays the buyer a fee/consideration (around $500) to waive that requirement. We wouldn't want to disclose dead bodies on the land, would we? :crazy:
In the Hunter Ed course and the state web site, it is mentioned that certain hunting areas border private property, and hunters need to get permission from the owner to enter that land. Wouldn't this pose a lead remediation problem, and why would an owner risk having to deal with such an issue?
More of a volume issue. A hunter might shoot a few rounds spread out over one trip, not a big deal. A shooter practicing at the range could put hundreds of rounds in a small area in one session. Private property owners are more concerned with injuries.
-
By the lot size you gave, it sounds like the lot sizes of most lots in FFVE where I live, except that my lot is about 266x490. I used to shoot all the time before COVID. No one ever complained and cops take 45 minutes minimum to get out here. I would keep my shooting sessions to no more than 50 shots and no longer than 30 minutes. If I wanted to shoot more I would take a break for at least an hour. Easy to do when you are just shooting in your backyard or in my case sometimes from my 2nd story deck. I used to hear one guy shooting sometimes 200 rounds for an hour. Don’t hear that anymore, probably because ammo is too expensive. Nowadays if I shoot centerfire, it has to be to try and kill something, like a pig or mongoose. I may on occasion shoot my 22LR at targets but only 10-20 rounds. The only thing I like to keep in practice with is defensive handgun shooting. Since I have a Glock G19, I bought a Umarex BB clone and use that to practice drawing from concealment and shooting at the man targets I bought at Front Sight from 3 to 7 yards. Cheap practice at about a penny a shot and quiet.
-
1,000ft and a berm aren't enough alone if there are buildings downrange. 9mm can go something like 4,000ft.
Only if you are shooting above a horizontal plane. My backstop is a 8 ft high by 12 ft wide by 10 ft thick pile of brush and logs from clearing the trees on my property. Behind it is 150 ft of densely forested ohia and guava trees 20 to 30 ft high. After that is more of the same uninhabited densely forested land for 3/4 mile with no homes and then the highway. I love where I live, where nobody cares what hell you are doing and minds there own business. Can’t say the same for most of Crylua where I used to live, except for the really good neighbors I had and knew well for 6 houses on both sides as well as the same amount across the street. What really surprised me when I was living and working on Oahu is the amount of people who didn’t even know their next door neighbor. On the BI my next door neighbor might be 200 yards away because of the lot size and vacant lots between us but I know them.