2aHawaii

Tools and Uses => Firearms and Accessories => Topic started by: Inspector on November 13, 2021, 05:40:24 AM

Title: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on November 13, 2021, 05:40:24 AM
I promised Heavies that I would write a little bit about my holster experiences. My experience is extremely limited and in some cases not making smart choices. So hopefully my experience will help you along the way in making good choices in holsters.

Understand that I am not making any recommendations here. I made choices based on desire, inexperience and recommendations. Choosing a holster is even more personal a choice than the pistol you choose to carry.

My carry experience starts back in the early 90’s living in CA when high capacity semi auto pistols were really coming into their own. The first Glock 17’s had only been out for a few years. And most service pistols were full size and full weight. I bought my first pistol I intended to carry and that was the Glock 17 Gen 2. I carried it inside my waistband and and fully loaded it would fall down my pants leg occasionally. I decided at that time I needed a real holster. I chose an all plastic OWB Serpa style holster. Serpa holsters were quite popular at that time. Little did I know that at a later time they would get a bad reputation. For those who don’t know, the Serpa holster has a retention button that needs to be pressed before you can draw your pistol. And considering the position of the button, some accidents apparently occurred where the finger that is pressing the retention button slips onto the trigger while drawing and accidental discharge can happen. I carried that Glock in that holster all around my home and out plinking in the LA National Forest. I applied for a CCW permit but was turned down of course. So no carry for me.

Just about that time Sig came out with the “Compact” P228 which is the granddaddy to the P229. It was smaller in the frame and slide than my Glock. So I bought it thinking if I were to ever carry I would carry my Sig. From the 90’s until 2020 when I moved to AZ I only used that Serpa holster and only carried my Glock around my house. Now I live in a state where I can carry concealed or not concealed every where. Of course I broke out the Serpa holster with my Glock and went right to my local range that promptly told me Serpa holsters are not allowed there due to the aforementioned accidental discharge issue.

After a lot of research and talking to Stang, I decided my first real EDC holster would be leather and come from a company that makes custom leather holsters called Simply Rugged. They are located out here in Prescott, AZ. I purchased a leather holster made for my Sig that is designed to be used both IWB and OWB. First I set up the holster for OWB. Put in my Sig and realized this this is a big heavy gun. Size is one factor in carrying in a holster. But weight is a real drag when it comes to carrying. It is tiring and can be obnoxious as times. And over a 4-8 hour period it is extremely tiring and annoying. After this I configured the holster for IWB and put it on. Once again the holster is quite minimal and quite comfortable. But put in the gun and the whole dynamic changes. The weight and size of the P228 is just not conducive for me to carry. But I continued to carry the gun both IWB and OWB and found that the gun is actually much more comfortable carrying OWB. And now I carry it around the house and when I go shopping at the local stores OWB. I will wear a unbuttoned flannel shirt over it. I carry it on my trips to the range as well. Always OWB. I practice drawing and double taps with it. I also do the same with my Glock 17 and the Serpa holster.

Location of the holster is also critical for concealment and comfort. I’m fat so appendix carry is comfortable when standing but uncomfortable while sitting. I find the best location for me is at the 4 o’clock position. Not directly on my hip but slightly behind my hip but not at the 5 o’clock position or small of my back. Also, while carrying OWB I have tried the 3 o’clock position and it is not bad either. The leather holster conforms better to my body while kydex/plastic does not.

One thing I need to also mention is that belt choice is even more important than gun and holster choices. If you buy leather, it needs to be thick and stiff and be able to hold up to the constant weight and drawing and pulling you put on it. It needs to be a minimum of 1.5” and a maximum of 1.75” wide. I recommend 1.5” as that is what I have and it can be difficult to feed through the slots of my holsters. A wider belt would be even more difficult. I suggest you buy one from a holster manufacturer. A non holster specific commercial belt will not do. There are numerous other choices for belts on the market. Especially tactical belt choices. Just make sure you get one designed to be used with a holster.

Here are my takeaways so far. Plastic/Kydex holsters are excellent because they maintain their shape and are easier to draw from and easier to reholster. Retention can be adjustable. Which I find to be an excellent feature. Leather feels better to me against my skin compared to hard plastic/kydex. So they are more comfortable as an IWB holster. Plastic/Kydex holsters also make noise when drawing and reholstering. A lot of people consider this a detriment as if you want to get the draw on someone it can give you away. Otherwise Kydex is probably the best choice for a holster. Leather needs to be broken in before it demonstrates similar properties to Kydex/Plastic. But in my opinion leather holsters also have a coolness factor that kydex/plastic can never have. Again, it is a very personal choice.

Future installments will include revolver carry IWB/OWB in leather holsters. Also I will be buying and trying a hybrid holster made of leather and kydex. And another kydex/plastic holster for my Glock. And I have a couple of accessory carriers for mags and speed loaders. Also, there are going to be gun purchases and more holster choices.

That is it for my first installment of my experience into the holster world. I have a lot more to write as I have bought 3 more holsters since this experience so I will write more as I get more time.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: 6716J on November 13, 2021, 06:09:34 PM


Sent from my SM-G970U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on November 14, 2021, 02:52:29 AM
This is my next experience into buying and using a holster.

During my time here in AZ I have been taking some training courses from my local indoor range. The owners of the range have excellent classes taught for real world use. One of the classes required having a holster. Anything except a Serpa holster. And they recommended NOT to bring a leather holster. I wanted to bring my leather holster but it turns out leather requires a break in period. In other words when I got my first leather holster it was custom made for my Sig. It was tight and required some effort to push the pistol all the way in. In other words it was a tight fit. So since this experience I decided to leave the gun in the holster for a few days at a time. And slowly but surely it has become just tight enough to retain the pistol but not so tight it requires strength to push it in all the way.

So now I am in a dilemma. I have a nice leather holster for my class. But it has not been broken in yet. So I decided to by a cheap plastic/kydex holster for my Sig. Now I live in the country. Holsters are everywhere. Every LGS here carries multiple lines of holsters. But it was also the day before my class. So after a few hours of visiting every single store that sells holsters I found that no one carried a holster to fit my Sig. And why should they? My Sig is from the 90’s. And it was replaced by the P229 which has a slightly different profile on the slide. So I decided to break a cardinal rule. I decided to buy a cheap plastic/kydex holster that was a generic holster designed to fit numerous different models. I brought it home and noticed right off that it felt cheap and the quality seemed pretty bad. It was designed as an IWB/OWB type model. First thing I tried to do was to run my belt through it. Now I decided to buy my belt from Simply Rugged as they build their belts for holsters. They are thick, very stiff and are designed specifically for the task at hand. It took almost all the pressure and strength I could muster to run my belt through the belt clip. And I was honestly about to break something on the holster. After further observation it appears the holster was designed to be used with a tactical type belt which are very stiff but are made out of some type of fabric which is much thinner than my belt. I finally figured out a way to get my belt into the clip but it literally took me several minutes of going one inch at a time.

After I got the belt through it and positioned where I wanted it I put it on and decided to try holstering my Sig. It was too tight. But, it had adjustable retention. So I loosened it a bit and continued to adjust it until it seemed right. I tried to draw and reholster several times. It seemed like it was working rather well at this point. That is until I bumped the butt stock with my arm. The gun moved forward. More directly it tilted forward. It seems that the holster was adjustable for cant. I could adjust the cant or tilt of the gun to make it easier to grab to draw and reholster. Only problem was I had tightened the cant adjustment screws down pretty tight. So once again I had to remove the holster from the belt and try and figure out what happened. As it turns out this holster is so cheap that even with the cant adjustment screws cranked way down, they still did not hold the cant when bumped. But okay I could live with that. But wait, there’s more. The belt clip that was giving me so much of an issue to thread my belt through was also designed for a much wider belt than my standard 1.5” wide belt. And so it also allowed the holster to tilt slightly back and forth if pressure was applied in either direction or if bumped. Okay, I just bought this thing for the 2 day class. I can live with this.

But now I decided to look closer at how my gun fit into this holster. And I found something I really didn’t like. And that was even with the retention fairly tight, my gun was still a little loose in the holster. In other words there was some slop. That was the straw that broke the camel’s back. I promptly repackaged the holster and took it back to the store and got my money back. But now I have a problem. Out of all the stores and holsters I looked at for several hours, that was the only holster that said it would fit my Sig.

Now what do I do? So I went back into my safe and decided to use my Glock. Now I have used this Glock as a test bed for a lot of different aftermarket pieces and parts to customize it to work well for me. I have it to that point where it is as good as it gets. One thing I have on it is an extended mag release. Which has never caused me a problem in 20+ years. More on that later. So back out shopping. it seems that the Glock 17 is so popular that most of the LGS around me have empty pegs where the Glock 17 holsters are kept. Oooops. I cannot find a holster for my Glock 17. But I kept looking. I finally found a cheap plastic holster, OWB that was designed for my Glock and seemed like it had all the features I wanted. And it was cheap. Just over $30. Fine, I bought it and took it home. But I learned something from the previous holster. I decided to set up the holster first before I put my belt through it. I set the retention on it. And it held my Glock snugly with no slop. I set the cant and it seemed to hold it better than the previous holster but still not perfect. Okay I can live with that. I tried to thread my belt through it and it fit well. It seems that this holster is going to work. After trying it on and adjusting the location to where I wanted it, I decided to place it at the 3 o’clock position. It worked really really well. So now I am set for my class.

The first day of class we did not use our holsters. We were learning how to shoot tiny little holes in our targets and to shoot a business card with the edge facing us (Yes I split a business card with one shot). And yes I have pictures if someone wants to see them. The second day we were taught practical (not tactical) holster work. Of course a lot of working with a holster requires practice and repetition. So after practicing for a while with unloaded weapons it was time to try live fire after drawing from our holsters. I loaded my Glock, placed it in the holster and stood on the line ready to draw and eventually fire my first shot.. I was ordered to draw and present and then extend and then fire. Which I did. And something really bad happened at that point. My magazine fell out of my pistol. Oh shit! What happened? So I grabbed it quickly and reinserted the magazine. The pistol did pick up the next round before the mag fell out. Weird. Never ever done that before. When came my turn again I went up to the line, did all my holster draw stuff and fired a shot. Guess what happened? The magazine dropped out again! Damn! Something was wrong and I didn’t know what it was. My instructor diagnosed the problem as my hitting the extended mag release while I was firing. Really? In 20+ years of having this extended mag release I pick now to accidentally hit it? Twice in a row?

Break time and I decided to unload my pistol and holster it before I walk around the parking lot. So I looked at my pistol as I was holstering and low and behold I saw the problem. Every holster is designed differently. And every one of my holsters covers the trigger and trigger guard like they are supposed to. But none of them cover the magazine release. Except this dumb plastic cheap holster I got at the last minute. It covered the mag release and actually pushed on it ever so slightly as I holstered my weapon. It was just enough so that when I pull out my weapon the mag does not fall out. But the jolt from firing a round was enough to jar the magazine loose and it would fall out. I tried it a few times and I could reproduce this issue every time. So I casually walked out to my car and flipped open the trunk. Took off my holster, got out my knife and cut a notch out the holster. It was just enough to not cover the mag release when I holstered the weapon.

I have to say the rest of the day went smoothly as the holster and my Glock worked flawlessly. So what did I learn from this? First thing I realized is this. When you buy new equipment, don’t wait until the last second to buy something. Take your time, shop around, think it over, and buy what you think is going to work best for you. Also, don’t go on the cheap. I really don’t buy on the cheap normally. But this holster was only going to be used for this class. In other words, one time use. It made sense at the time. In hind sight it doesn’t make sense and it never made sense to do this. In the meantime I have used this holster a lot since my Serpa holster has the retention button that gets in the way of fast drawing. So it turns out it is not a one time use. But the big thing I learned from this is to always use and test out any new piece of equipment before you set out into the real world thinking everything is good. What if I had bought the holster and tried drawing and holstering without a problem and then needed to use my Glock to defend myself and the magazine drops out after the first shot? I would have never known that problem existed until I actually practiced live fire drills. Good thing it happened in a controlled environment. And that is why we practice and test and practice more.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: stangzilla on November 14, 2021, 04:33:58 AM
Nice write ups, Inspector  :thumbsup:
Can't wait for the revolver installments. Will that be with your SP101?
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on November 14, 2021, 04:57:41 AM
Nice write ups, Inspector  :thumbsup:
Can't wait for the revolver installments. Will that be with your SP101?
As a matter of fact, yes! It includes my experiences with the SP-101 and my 2 K frame S&W. I also have some experience with my N Frame revolvers Model 627 and Model 25-1 as well. I’ll try and get around to writing this up soon. I will be traveling for a while so don’t look for it until after the first of next month.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Heavies on November 14, 2021, 05:12:02 AM
Thank you Inspector. Real world experience is invaluable. I am hoping we will all, especially in Hawaii,  be able to benefit from your experience very soon!
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on November 14, 2021, 05:17:36 AM
Thank you Inspector. Real world experience is invaluable. I am hoping we will all, especially in Hawaii,  be able to benefit from your experience very soon!
It is the only reason I am spending so much time writing this. I hope even one person will learn something that is valuable to them.

But mostly I hope the SCOTUS decision will be in our favor and Hawaii will benefit from it.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: stangzilla on November 14, 2021, 11:45:21 AM
I also have a leather Simply Rugged holster for my 3" GP100, and a leather belt slide for my 1911 w/o rail.
They make great leather holsters. I have used it a couple times on my friends farm. I love the way it looks and its functional. My experience is very limited, but easy to see Simply rugged makes great leather holsters  :thumbsup:
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on November 17, 2021, 03:30:45 AM
Okay, I have a little time this morning so I am going to write about my next experiences about my journey into holsters.

My next and last holster purchase also came from Simply Rugged Holsters. Just know that I purchase only no nonsense holsters meaning I am not paying for extras such as scrollwork, engraving nor exotic materials. Simply Rugged offers all these extras. I want only a holster. I will buy something fancy one day but for now I have purchased only plain black holsters.

I now have enough holsters to warrant having to put them in a box because they don’t  stack well and they have a tendency to slide off a shelf. And being all black they sort of start looking similar. I pull out a semi auto holster but it turns out to be a revolver holster. Fortunately, Simply Rugged stamps their holsters with marks so you can see what firearm the holster is for. For instance on my holster for my S&W Model 10 with 3” barrel they marked it K/3. The K stands for K frame and the 3 for 3” barrel.

First holster I ordered was for my S&W Model 10 K Frame with 3” barrel. I ordered an IWB/OWB holster. I already have the belt loops from my Sig holster so I didn’t have to order any extras if I didn’t want them. It is again in plain black and marked K/3. This holster is very comfortable. Both IWB and OWB. After putting it on I put my revolver into it and found I needed to move it from the 4 o’clock position to the 2:30-3:00 o’clock position. But what I found is that it is so much lighter than my fully loaded Sig P228. It is wider but lighter and that goes a long way with me. So now carrying a revolver is all of the sudden a much more pleasurable and easier choice.

Now, while I was at it, I decided to also try carrying my other K Frame which has a 4” barrel. Of course since it is a K Frame it fits the holster perfectly. And considering the longer barrel it does stick out beyond the bottom of the holster but only by 1/4”-3/8”. Not enough to notice anything different. I know this sounds kinda dumb, but I realized that even though this is a custom made holster it can be used for other pistols. Which brings me to my next experience. I decided to try holstering my Ruger SP-101 with 3” barrel. And guess what? It fits pretty darn good! Not perfect. But good enough that it is retained well and draws well so I am using my SP-101 in my EDC rotation. I like it because it is a tad smaller than my K Frames and a tad lighter. Remember, smaller size goes a long way. Especially in the butt. But weight is much more tiring. So lighter is definitely much better for me. So I have one holster now that does triple duty. I won’t keep my K Frame with the 4” barrel in my EDC rotation for personal reasons. But it is wonderful that I can carry my SP-101 without having to buy another holster.

So, let’s review what I have for EDC whether IWB or OWB. I have my Glock 17 which right now is OWB only. I have a Sig P228 which is both IWB and OWB. And I have 2 revolvers which can be both as well. While I was on the Simply Rugged website they had some pre made holsters at a special price. I suppose these are holsters that are either commonly sold but probably custom made for someone that didn’t want it or maybe made mistakenly. Either way, I ran across a plain black holster for an N Frame S&W with a 5” barrel. Which miraculously fits my S&W Model 627 357 Mag. For those that don’t know this is a full size revolver that is heavy. The holster is OWB carry only and it was a good price. I can’t pass up a bargain so in my cart it went. Now I can carry my N Frame as part of my EDC if I want. I can carry any way I want here. So having another option, albeit not a practical option is nice. But then I remember I have another N Frame. I have a Model 25 which is a very nice older model in 45 ACP. It has a 4” barrel so it fits well in this holster. When I am out in the desert I can now carry my N Frame revolvers safely and securely. A very nice addition to my newly expanding holster collection.

To sum up, I am really enjoying having a decent rotation of firearms to carry. While I do prefer to carry OWB, I do so with a loose shirt over it. It does print and can be seen. But let’s face it if you are walking towards me you cannot see it. If you are on my left side you cannot see it. If you are on my right side it prints only a little and may be detected and from behind is where it prints the most and is most detectible. But if one is not looking for a gun, I guarantee you will walk right by anyone and not notice. Even if they are printing. I walk around every where looking for people who carry. And I rarely see someone who is carrying and printing. I see more people carrying OWB and IWB and not trying to cover it up. A lot of people don’t care. And even when they don’t cover it up looking for someone who is carrying is not always easy. My preference at this point is to carry a revolver. For what I own the K Frame and SP-101 are lighter and less tiring. They get the bulk of my EDC right now. As does my Glock. I carry around the house and every time I leave the house.

Next installments will be as follows (maybe not in this order);

* Mouse or pocket gun carry with holster for deep concealment and backup (Ruger LCP Max in 380 ACP) already getting experience with this
* Magazine holders and Speed Loader holders
* My take/feelings about leather vs kydex vs plastic
* A new gun purchase (Sig P365 XL) and a IWB/OWB hybrid holster (leather & kydex). And I will try this as a pocket carry as well. This gun will replace my Glock 17 and Sig P228 in my EDC rotation. I have not purchased this gun yet. And a little farther down the line a J Frame revolver.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on November 17, 2021, 03:46:41 AM
I also have a leather Simply Rugged holster for my 3" GP100, and a leather belt slide for my 1911 w/o rail.
They make great leather holsters. I have used it a couple times on my friends farm. I love the way it looks and its functional. My experience is very limited, but easy to see Simply rugged makes great leather holsters  :thumbsup:
I also go to the range twice a week to practice my holster draw with live fire. My favorite 2 guns to live fire practice drawing with are my Glock and my S&W Model 10. And between those 2 the revolver gets the nod. I just feel a little more comfy with the revolver. I guess it is just a personal choice. I also use the 22 conversion on my Glock to save some money.

This is my S&W Model 547 with 4” barrel so you will see it stick out of the bottom of the holster.
Title: koRe: My Holster Experiences
Post by: oldfart on November 17, 2021, 06:47:56 AM
I used to rep Ted Blocker Custom Holsters around 30 years ago.
They sold the company and I stopped selling stuff.
Still have quite a bit of new old stock in storage.
Sold a custom holster to Tom Selleck once.
I used to have something like Tupperware parties at my house with new HPD recruits.
I would teach basic concealed carry methods and drawing techniques.

I got a lot of stuff to get rid of. Just ask.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: macsak on November 17, 2021, 07:08:16 AM
Okay, I have a little time this morning so I am going to write about my next experiences about my journey into holsters.

My next and last holster purchase also came from Simply Rugged Holsters. Just know that I purchase only no nonsense holsters meaning I am not paying for extras such as scrollwork, engraving nor exotic materials. Simply Rugged offers all these extras. I want only a holster. I will buy something fancy one day but for now I have purchased only plain black holsters.

I now have enough holsters to warrant having to put them in a box because they don’t  stack well and they have a tendency to slide off a shelf. And being all black they sort of start looking similar. I pull out a semi auto holster but it turns out to be a revolver holster. Fortunately, Simply Rugged stamps their holsters with marks so you can see what firearm the holster is for. For instance on my holster for my S&W Model 10 with 3” barrel they marked it K/3. The K stands for K frame and the 3 for 3” barrel.

First holster I ordered was for my S&W Model 10 K Frame with 3” barrel. I ordered an IWB/OWB holster. I already have the belt loops from my Sig holster so I didn’t have to order any extras if I didn’t want them. It is again in plain black and marked K/3. This holster is very comfortable. Both IWB and OWB. After putting it on I put my revolver into it and found I needed to move it from the 4 o’clock position to the 2:30-3:00 o’clock position. But what I found is that it is so much lighter than my fully loaded Sig P228. It is wider but lighter and that goes a long way with me. So now carrying a revolver is all of the sudden a much more pleasurable and easier choice.

Now, while I was at it, I decided to also try carrying my other K Frame which has a 4” barrel. Of course since it is a K Frame it fits the holster perfectly. And considering the longer barrel it does stick out beyond the bottom of the holster but only by 1/4”-3/8”. Not enough to notice anything different. I know this sounds kinda dumb, but I realized that even though this is a custom made holster it can be used for other pistols. Which brings me to my next experience. I decided to try holstering my Ruger SP-101 with 3” barrel. And guess what? It fits pretty darn good! Not perfect. But good enough that it is retained well and draws well so I am using my SP-101 in my EDC rotation. I like it because it is a tad smaller than my K Frames and a tad lighter. Remember, smaller size goes a long way. Especially in the butt. But weight is much more tiring. So lighter is definitely much better for me. So I have one holster now that does triple duty. I won’t keep my K Frame with the 4” barrel in my EDC rotation for personal reasons. But it is wonderful that I can carry my SP-101 without having to buy another holster.

So, let’s review what I have for EDC whether IWB or OWB. I have my Glock 17 which right now is OWB only. I have a Sig P228 which is both IWB and OWB. And I have 2 revolvers which can be both as well. While I was on the Simply Rugged website they had some pre made holsters at a special price. I suppose these are holsters that are either commonly sold but probably custom made for someone that didn’t want it or maybe made mistakenly. Either way, I ran across a plain black holster for an N Frame S&W with a 5” barrel. Which miraculously fits my S&W Model 627 357 Mag. For those that don’t know this is a full size revolver that is heavy. The holster is OWB carry only and it was a good price. I can’t pass up a bargain so in my cart it went. Now I can carry my N Frame as part of my EDC if I want. I can carry any way I want here. So having another option, albeit not a practical option is nice. But then I remember I have another N Frame. I have a Model 25 which is a very nice older model in 45 ACP. It has a 4” barrel so it fits well in this holster. When I am out in the desert I can now carry my N Frame revolvers safely and securely. A very nice addition to my newly expanding holster collection.

To sum up, I am really enjoying having a decent rotation of firearms to carry. While I do prefer to carry OWB, I do so with a loose shirt over it. It does print and can be seen. But let’s face it if you are walking towards me you cannot see it. If you are on my left side you cannot see it. If you are on my right side it prints only a little and may be detected and from behind is where it prints the most and is most detectible. But if one is not looking for a gun, I guarantee you will walk right by anyone and not notice. Even if they are printing. I walk around every where looking for people who carry. And I rarely see someone who is carrying and printing. I see more people carrying OWB and IWB and not trying to cover it up. A lot of people don’t care. And even when they don’t cover it up looking for someone who is carrying is not always easy. My preference at this point is to carry a revolver. For what I own the K Frame and SP-101 are lighter and less tiring. They get the bulk of my EDC right now. As does my Glock. I carry around the house and every time I leave the house.

Next installments will be as follows (maybe not in this order);

* Mouse or pocket gun carry with holster for deep concealment and backup (Ruger LCP Max in 380 ACP) already getting experience with this
* Magazine holders and Speed Loader holders
* My take/feelings about leather vs kydex vs plastic
* A new gun purchase (Sig P365 XL) and a IWB/OWB hybrid holster (leather & kydex). And I will try this as a pocket carry as well. This gun will replace my Glock 17 and Sig P228 in my EDC rotation. I have not purchased this gun yet. And a little farther down the line a J Frame revolver.

too easy...
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on November 17, 2021, 07:12:07 AM
Member quotes….
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: oldfart on November 17, 2021, 08:58:05 AM
too easy...
...
I'm dense.... please provide graphic illustration of what you're talking about.
 :rofl:
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: macsak on November 17, 2021, 09:48:39 AM
...
I'm dense.... please provide graphic illustration of what you're talking about.
 :rofl:

heads
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on November 20, 2021, 09:01:48 AM
Here is a nice article that stresses comfort over everything else.

COMFORTABLE CARRY

THINKING ABOUT THE DECISION
OF WHAT TO CARRY AND HOW

https://gunsmagazine.com/our-experts/montana-musings/comfortable-carry/
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on November 20, 2021, 09:12:05 AM
EDC MICRO-CARRY

AN NAA .22 MAG. ANCHORS MIKE’S DEEP-COVER CARRY RIG!

https://americanhandgunner.com/discover/concealed-carry/edc-micro-carry/
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on November 20, 2021, 09:12:54 AM
HOW MUCH AMMO IS ENOUGH?

https://americanhandgunner.com/discover/how-much-ammo-do-you-need-to-carry/
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: DocMercy on November 23, 2021, 04:01:14 PM
Next installments will be as follows (maybe not in this order);

* A new gun purchase (Sig P365 XL) and a IWB/OWB hybrid holster (leather & kydex).

Buying a holster is more difficult than buying a bra. I make this statement based on hours of shopping with my wife at the Ala Moana mall. When you buy the wrong holster, you normally cannot return it. When I ordered two Safariland holsters for the Glock 19, I thought they were different enough to warrant getting one with waist attachments and one without. Both could be configured for OWB carry, so they were identical functionally. This meant that I bought two holsters when one would have been satisfactory. Then I realized that either I am a poor shot or I need a flashlight and laser beam to improve my aim. This requires a brand new holster, rendering the first two, useless. Trying not to make the same mistake with the Sig P365 XL. This was ordered with a Sig Romeo red dot sight, which comes with an outer protector. I will bet you that when I finally order a holster for that small gun, the fit will be off. Obviously, if the Young vs. Hawaii case turns out in our favor, this will create another wrinkle (CCW) in the process of selecting a holster.

I have a bunch of other handguns in the ordering pipeline. They have top, bottom, or both types of rails. The ones with the long rails have at least two mounting locations for the optics. This forces me to wait until I determine the spot that is most balanced. This further delays the process of getting a holster.

We need a list of vendors whose choices are not limited to one or two types of optics, or one barrel length. Not all guns are sized like Jayne Mansfield or Audrey Hepburn. I need a holster maker who uses real handguns, not blueprints based on rough estimates, when they craft their holsters.

Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on December 03, 2021, 03:25:22 AM
In this part of my holster experience I will dive into what I have learned from pocket carry.

Pocket carry for me has been an eye opening experience. While I enjoy carrying my firearms IWB and OWB I have issues with both of these types of carry. Mostly my issues stem from my being overweight and also not being used to carrying 3-4 pounds of dead weight in a single spot on my body. This doesn’t sound like much but ask anyone who carries a firearm for a living what it was like in the beginning.

Trying to carry a heavy fully loaded firearm on my hip or behind my hip causes muscle fatigue to set in after 4-6 hours. After 8 hours I am ready to take the holster off and relax. Also, being older I also occasionally suffer from sciatica which is a pinched nerve that runs up and down my leg. That alone can be quite painful. Carrying on my hip or behind occasionally causes my sciatica to flare up.

My next purchase is going to be the smallest and lightest 9mm pistol I feel fits my hand the best and that I can shoot competently. I have decided on the Sig Sauer P365 XL. I have chosen the XL because I have a larger hand and it seems to fit better in my hand than the slightly smaller P365. I will write about my carry experiences with this pistol after I buy one and a holster to fit. Hopefully, it will solve some of my physical issues with carrying IWB and OWB.

In the meantime a good friend of mine met me at the range one day. He had this little mouse gun that he had just bought. I am not big fan of mouse guns. That is until now. The gun he has is a Ruger LCP Max in .380ACP. I also was not enamored with this round as it is quite low in power. As a review this new LCP comes with one 10 round magazine. But 12 round magazines can be purchased for it. That can give you 12+1 rounds that can be dumped quickly into someone attacking you. That is not insignificant and was not lost on me.

My friend offered to let me shoot the little gun. Now I have shot LCP’s before. Both the original LCP and the LCP II. While the LCP II is much better than the original I was not very impressed. But after his letting me fire his LCP Max, I have to say I was hooked. I immediately went out and bought one for myself. This little gun is soft shooting but has a lot of muzzle flip which is very controllable. The gun comes with a tritium front sight and I can see it and place it on target extremely fast. I can recover from my previous shot very quickly and get the next shot off very quickly. I can literally dump all 13 rounds off almost as fast as I can pull the trigger and maintain acceptable control of the gun.

Now let’s look at the .380ACP round. I don’t want to get into a comparison between the 9mm Luger and .380ACP rounds. The 9mm takes the prize in almost every category. Except size/compactness. The .380ACP uses a 9mm projectile in the 90gr-100gr range at approximately 1,000 fps. And in terms of foot/pounds you are looking at about 175-200 or so. My feeling is if I have at least 13 rounds plus a possible extra 12 round or 15 round magazine, I can put the hurt on someone attacking me. The first 13 are going in very quickly. If you consider shot placement I do not feel under gunned with this little piece at all. Consider this, more people are killed in the US every year by a .22 than any other caliber. And considering this gun should be used at bad breath distances, a head shot is not out of the question.

So what about a holster and carry options? The LCP Max comes with a Ruger nylon pocket carry holster which is just a cheap holster designed for pocket carry for any gun of that size. Actually, Ruger says any LCP or LCP II holster will work with the LCP Max. This holster is padded. And when the gun is inserted it is very flat and pretty much the same size as a phone or wallet length and width wise. When you place this rig in your front pocket, it fits beautifully. It does not print to say “I have a gun” at all. It says I am carrying my phone or wallet.

What is really amazing about carrying this rig in the pocket is comfort! I can carry this rig all day and night and forget it is there ready if needed. It is the most comfortable way I have found to carry a firearm. I can sit and stand and walk without any discomfort at all. The padded nylon holster along with the diminutive size and weight of the gun is the key IMHO. I keep thinking I want to get a specialized kydex or leather holster for this gun. But my thoughts are this. The padded nylon is so comfortable that I think a hard leather or kydex holster will be uncomfortable while sitting and walking. If the nylon holster gets funky from sweat, it can be cleaned or even replaced quite cheaply. When I go out now with my wife to a place where I feel having a firearm would be a no no I carry this rig every time. When I am just going around town running errands and shopping I carry IWB/OWB and I conceal it the best I can. I can honestly say if concealment is your number one priority then pocket carry is the way to go. The IWB/OWB carry methods can and do print under certain circumstances. Maybe not much and maybe not often, but pocket carry done right does not print and say “I have a firearm”.

What about draw and draw speed you might ask? Well, that would be an excellent question. Pocket carry has its downsides and that is slower draw and getting to the firearm in order to draw can be a problem. When I carry in the pocket I make sure I have a loose fitting shirt when it is cold, and a tucked in t-shirt when it is warm. I have practiced drawing from the pocket and just getting to the gun is slowed down due to the location. But also, the draw is different with a pocket carry. When carrying in the front pocket of pants the gun is facing down towards the ground. I have to draw up first to get the gun near the top of the pocket. Then I have to turn the gun approximately 90 degrees so it is pointing forward and then pull the gun out towards the rear. At this point the gun can be fired while still in the pocket if it is deemed necessary to do so. I turn the gun 90 degrees so the tab on the pocket holster grabs at the pocket and is left in the pocket during the draw. Some pocket holsters have sticky material and some have tabs and some have both. So far the sticky material on my holster does not keep it in my pocket. You want the holster to stay in the pocket during the draw so you can get your finger into the trigger guard. The tab that is built in to the holster will stop the holster at the top of the pocket so the firearm can be withdrawn from the holster when you turn the firearm 90 degrees as I described.

When I start wearing my cold winter coat/jacket (I have two different coats/jackets) the LCP Max goes in the pocket of my coat/jacket. Once again, it is quite comfortable to carry this way and you can forget it is there ready for you. In this case the firearm is facing forward so having to draw from this position can be a little faster and less complicated. However, make sure the pocket holster tab catches at the pocket entrance or you will be drawing a gun with the holster still on and the trigger guard covered. Some feel it is better to pocket carry in this way without a holster. It can be fairly quick because there is always the possibility you can fire while it is still in your pocket. Again, this is not always recommended but sometimes an attacker needs to feel that first shot before you feel his attack.

Remember, the more clothes you have to wear to stay warm, the harder it will be to draw from an IWB/OWB holster since heavy coats/jackets will cover your firearm and slow down your draw even to the point of preventing you from getting to your firearm when under duress. This is why a good pocket carry option should always be available to you.

If you pocket carry without a holster you must constantly maintain your firearm from lint and dirt. This is why so many prefer revolvers. They just work. Lint or dirt or crud does not usually stop them. With this said, I am planning more pocket pistol purchases. There will be a revolver or two as well.

So there we are with my experience with carrying in the pocket. I hope this helps you to decide whether this method is right for you or not.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 03, 2021, 10:19:28 AM
Buying a holster is more difficult than buying a bra. I make this statement based on hours of shopping with my wife at the Ala Moana mall. When you buy the wrong holster, you normally cannot return it. When I ordered two Safariland holsters for the Glock 19, I thought they were different enough to warrant getting one with waist attachments and one without. Both could be configured for OWB carry, so they were identical functionally. This meant that I bought two holsters when one would have been satisfactory. Then I realized that either I am a poor shot or I need a flashlight and laser beam to improve my aim. This requires a brand new holster, rendering the first two, useless. Trying not to make the same mistake with the Sig P365 XL. This was ordered with a Sig Romeo red dot sight, which comes with an outer protector. I will bet you that when I finally order a holster for that small gun, the fit will be off. Obviously, if the Young vs. Hawaii case turns out in our favor, this will create another wrinkle (CCW) in the process of selecting a holster.

I have a bunch of other handguns in the ordering pipeline. They have top, bottom, or both types of rails. The ones with the long rails have at least two mounting locations for the optics. This forces me to wait until I determine the spot that is most balanced. This further delays the process of getting a holster.

We need a list of vendors whose choices are not limited to one or two types of optics, or one barrel length. Not all guns are sized like Jayne Mansfield or Audrey Hepburn. I need a holster maker who uses real handguns, not blueprints based on rough estimates, when they craft their holsters.

Sorry Inspector, don't mean to highjack the thread.

Doc,
Everyone has this issue. I only have 1 handgun and like 5 holsters.

1) 1st holster was a Serpa, got it at the gun store when I picked up the gun. Was a total noob at this time.
2) Learned many places don't allow them to be used. So I bought a drop leg G-code with hood
3) Got a CCW Kydex holster
4) Added a light to the VP9, so got another OWB holster from FalTac Unlimited. G-code doesn't make a hood holster with a WML.  I use the RTI clip so I don't need an entire new drop leg system.
5) Got a new CCW Kydex due to the WML being added
6) Tried the FalTac and didn't like it. Went with Safariland.  And again, used the G-Code RTI system, so another entire drop leg wasn't needed, just the holster.

THis is why I also refuse to add a RDS on my VP9. Because I will need 2 new holsters (OWB/IWB). So when I do decide to RDS, I'm just gonna buy another gun.

I prefer drop leg because my plate carrier which has side plates get in the way for a hip holster.  This and my body type make it difficult. It's not impossible,just awkward to get to.  So a drop leg is much easier for me.

I didn't learn this either at home dry firing or from YT.  It took getting reps in at the range and taking a skill builder to figure out what I prefer.  And as a noob, I had nothing to compare to.   But I have more reps and XP. So when I ordered my 1911, I know which holster to get.  So 1 and done for the 1911.

Example is my FalTac holster with hood. When seated or prone, I cannot disengage the hood.  Which is a major problem.  I didn't realize this because when standing up, there is no issue.  My G-code also had no issue doing this, so I was unaware it was a problem, until I tried with the FalTac.. IIRC it was DRCK that mentioned to try it, so in reality, he saved me.  Because if I had to draw my pistol prone or seated, I would be unable to with that FalTac holster.   So I had to buy a Safariland one instead, which does work when seated or prone.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on December 03, 2021, 10:38:08 AM
Sorry Inspector, don't mean to highjack the thread.

Doc,
Everyone has this issue. I only have 1 handgun and like 5 holsters.

1) 1st holster was a Serpa, got it at the gun store when I picked up the gun. Was a total noob at this time.
2) Learned many places don't allow them to be used. So I bought a drop leg G-code with hood
3) Got a CCW Kydex holster
4) Added a light to the VP9, so got another OWB holster from FalTac Unlimited. G-code doesn't make a hood holster with a WML.  I use the RTI clip so I don't need an entire new drop leg system.
5) Got a new CCW Kydex due to the WML being added
6) Tried the FalTac and didn't like it. Went with Safariland.  And again, used the G-Code RTI system, so another entire drop leg wasn't needed, just the holster.

THis is why I also refuse to add a RDS on my VP9. Because I will need 2 new holsters (OWB/IWB). So when I do decide to RDS, I'm just gonna buy another gun.

I prefer drop leg because my plate carrier which has side plates get in the way for a hip holster.  This and my body type make it difficult. It's not impossible,just awkward to get to.  So a drop leg is much easier for me.

I didn't learn this either at home dry firing or from YT.  It took getting reps in at the range and taking a skill builder to figure out what I prefer.  And as a noob, I had nothing to compare to.   But I have more reps and XP. So when I ordered my 1911, I know which holster to get.  So 1 and done for the 1911.

Example is my FalTac holster with hood. When seated or prone, I cannot disengage the hood.  Which is a major problem.  I didn't realize this because when standing up, there is no issue.  My G-code also had no issue doing this, so I was unaware it was a problem, until I tried with the FalTac.. IIRC it was DRCK that mentioned to try it, so in reality, he saved me.  Because if I had to draw my pistol prone or seated, I would be unable to with that FalTac holster.   So I had to buy a Safariland one instead, which does work when seated or prone.
By all means, keep the conversation going. Just because I have a minute amount of experience doesn’t mean you can’t impart your experience. I learned something from your post today.  :thumbsup:
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 03, 2021, 11:38:26 AM
I learned something from your post today. 

You learned that CMO has no focus, thus 5 holsters.

I have nothing really to add to my XP cause when I do carry, it's only for a week (vacation).  So carrying for that little amount of time, you can even ccw a full size 1911 and just deal with it.

But here's my little XP:

Carry strictly in Vegas

1) I carry IWB Kydex because when gambling, I lean forward on the table. So if I carried at 4-5oclock, I would be printing.  Plus when walking shoulder to shoulder on the strip in a crowd, I want control of the pistol in front of me.

2) When I go off strip, I switch to 4-5 oclock.

3) I wear a Hanes tank top (tucked in) under my t-shirt. Because when drawing from IWB with 1 hand, this allows the shirt to stick to the Hanes tank and stay up (clear the guns grip), which allows me to clear the shirt from the gun.  Without a tank on, the t-shirt drops very quickly and sometimes gets wrapped on the grip of the pistol if I'm not fast enough.  So transfer this issue to drawing from a different position or under stress. The tank also helps with sweat build up (kydex holster) and rubbing rash. But it is a pain in the a$$ when I have to take a dump, which is about 3x a day (high protein diet).  Gotta tuck the tank back in after each session. IDK if a leather holster would cause sweat, but if it does, now it absorbs the sweat and can probably smell if not cleaned. Kydex doesn't absorb sweat.

4) I carry my VP9, it's a bigger gun, but see above about just dealing with it for 1 week.  If I carried daily, I would get something smaller.  Good thing kydex can make any holster now.

5) WML when carrying IWB rubs against the boto.  So this can be either good or bad, depends on how sukebe you are. It's actually the holster that's rubbing the boto, not the light. The WML causes a protrusion.

6) When taking a dump, I don't leave the gun on the TP holder, Its in my underwear. Don't want to leave the pistol behind by mistake. If I leave the holster on the belt, due to the weight, it will fall over (top heavy) and hit the dirty bathroom floor. So I find it easier to unholster. See below pic.  I can imagine a leather or cloth holster absorbing any liquids on the restroom floor too. Kydex is easy to clean.

7) See pic below, how the screws are in lower.  This causes the grip to be higher on my appendix.  At this height, the end of the holster is just above where the boto begins.  With it lower, it's covering the base of the boto and rubbing.  See also above separate WML issue, but nothing to solve this since I hang to the right naturally.  So like Inspector mentioned, Kydex is more modular than leather. Not only height stuff, but cant as well, or if you want to add a claw, etc...


(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20211203/b93866154d199ccc32e0762be0ca55a0.jpg)(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20211203/b409f5cd85e0eea893c73a080d93d924.jpg)
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 03, 2021, 11:50:49 AM
Forgot to add, I only have 1 pistol.  And now that I'm looking to get a 2nd one (1911), holster options was also a factor.  Since it would be strictly OWB, I like to have the hood (foreskin).  So certain 1911 models, Safariland didn't make hoods.  I do not want to buy 5 holsters again.  Buy once, cry one.  I now understand this saying.  Which Inspector mentioned in his first post or so. Spend the money and don't go cheap.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on December 03, 2021, 12:05:35 PM
You learned that CMO has no focus, thus 5 holsters.

I have nothing really to add to my XP cause when I do carry, it's only for a week (vacation).  So carrying for that little amount of time, you can even ccw a full size 1911 and just deal with it.

But here's my little XP:

Carry strictly in Vegas

1) I carry IWB Kydex because when gambling, I lean forward on the table. So if I carried at 4-5oclock, I would be printing.  Plus when walking shoulder to shoulder on the strip in a crowd, I want control of the pistol in front of me.

2) When I go off strip, I switch to 4-5 oclock.

3) I wear a Hanes tank top (tucked in) under my t-shirt. Because when drawing from IWB with 1 hand, this allows the shirt to stick to the Hanes tank and stay up (clear the guns grip), which allows me to clear the shirt from the gun.  Without a tank on, the t-shirt drops very quickly and sometimes gets wrapped on the grip of the pistol if I'm not fast enough.  So transfer this issue to drawing from a different position or under stress. The tank also helps with sweat build up (kydex holster) and rubbing rash. But it is a pain in the a$$ when I have to take a dump, which is about 3x a day (high protein diet).  Gotta tuck the tank back in after each session. IDK if a leather holster would cause sweat, but if it does, now it absorbs the sweat and can probably smell if not cleaned. Kydex doesn't absorb sweat.

4) I carry my VP9, it's a bigger gun, but see above about just dealing with it for 1 week.  If I carried daily, I would get something smaller.  Good thing kydex can make any holster now.

5) WML when carrying IWB rubs against the boto.  So this can be either good or bad, depends on how sukebe you are. It's actually the holster that's rubbing the boto, not the light. The WML causes a protrusion.

6) When taking a dump, I don't leave the gun on the TP holder, Its in my underwear. Don't want to leave the pistol behind by mistake. If I leave the holster on the belt, due to the weight, it will fall over (top heavy) and hit the dirty bathroom floor. So I find it easier to unholster. See below pic.  I can imagine a leather or cloth holster absorbing any liquids on the restroom floor too. Kydex is easy to clean.

7) See pic below, how the screws are in lower.  This causes the grip to be higher on my appendix.  At this height, the end of the holster is just above where the boto begins.  With it lower, it's covering the base of the boto and rubbing.  See also above separate WML issue, but nothing to solve this since I hang to the right naturally.  So like Inspector mentioned, Kydex is more modular than leather. Not only height stuff, but cant as well, or if you want to add a claw, etc...


[SNIP THE BOTO PIC]
That was a little too much TMI  :rofl:

But seriously I don’t do IWB without a t-shirt tucked in between the holster and my skin. I make sure there is a breathable layer between my holster and skin. I use strictly leather for my IWB holsters. So far the sweat has been wicked away from the leather by the t-shirt and not infiltrated it that I can tell. It still smells like good leather.

However, with my new Sig Sauer P365 XL I just bought today I ordered a hybrid holster that also has a suede backing to the leather. It has a kydex shell. I am looking forward to how this new little light pistol carries as I figured out it could probably be used as a pocket carry as well. It seems a little big and heavy for pocket carry. But I did a little experiment and I will be buying a pocket holster for it.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 03, 2021, 12:09:53 PM

. So far the sweat has been wicked away from the leather by the t-shirt and not infiltrated it that I can tell. It still smells like good leather.



Ever smell a stink baseball glove?  Everyone else can smell it, except the user of the glove.

Why the 365XL and not just a 365?  Figure for pocket carry, the smaller the better.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on December 03, 2021, 12:21:18 PM
Ever smell a stink baseball glove?  Everyone else can smell it, except the user of the glove.

Why the 365XL and not just a 365?  Figure for pocket carry, the smaller the better.
My nephew has a 365. The X in the XL denotes a slightly longer grip with no mag extensions I can get my pinky around it. It feels slightly more stable than his 365 with the 12 round mags with finger extensions. The length of the grip of the 365 with 12 round mags with extension is the same as the XL with 12 round flush fit mags. Mostly I like it just for feel and grip. The L in XL stands for a slightly longer barrel. The gun itself is a little softer shooting with the longer barrel and the sight picture that is added by the longer barrel is noticeable. But the biggest difference for me between the two guns are that the XL has much better sights. Since the length of the grip is the same for both with 12 round mags the only other dimension difference is in the barrel length. Barrel length is not as critical as grip length/size when concealed, even for pocket carry.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on December 04, 2021, 04:59:36 AM
This part is about magazine holders, speedloader holders and clip/speed strip holders. There is not a lot I can say about this subject so it will be brief.

When I ordered my holsters from Simply Rugged I also ordered a two magazine holder mostly for experimentation and because one of the classes I intend to take has a mandatory one magazine holder minimum requirement. Of course since I ordered the holder from this outfit it is made out of leather and matches all my leather holsters from them.

My first impression of the 2 magazine holder is that it is larger than I thought it would be. And also the magazines stick up above my belt line farther than I wanted. I was hoping they would be lower on my belt line. However, even with 2 fully loaded magazines it is comfortable and it was worth the investment.

Having the magazines ride higher above my belt line than I wanted made me realize that they will stick into my big stomach when I sit down. And they do. It is not bad but it is noticeable. So I tried an experiment. I turned it upside down. I reinserted my two magazines and sat down again. This time I realized why they ride so high above my belt line. The jab I feel with them riding below the belt line is much worse than the slight dig when they are above the belt line. So now I understand why. I think some day I may just try one of the magazine holders that hold them at an angle that is more horizontal.

The magazine holder I have also needs some breaking in. In the same way my leather holsters need breaking in. When inserting the mags I need to push them down with more force than I feel is necessary. They are a tight fit. I know they need to be tight but they don’t need to be that tight. I left some magazines in the holder for a few days and now it is much better. I also spent an hour or so just inserting and removing the mags and now they are much better. They now slide right in and only require a minimal amount of effort to insert them all the way in. And they pull out of the holder just as smoothly.

The way the holder is designed and made you can also adjust the tension on the magazines. The two magazine wells are separated by a metal insert which I will describe as a washer that is about 1/4”-3/8” thick. It is held in by the standard leather screw setup so it is possible to use standard washers to expand the length of the metal insert thus making the magazine wells slightly larger.

While shopping for some other items on Cabela’s with my Cabela’s points I found an HKS non leather 2 speedloader holder. It uses snaps to hold the speedloaders in place. It looks like tooled leather but I assume it is made of plastic of some sort. When it came I looked it over for quality and it is made very nicely. And it holds my speedloaders very securely. The snaps are just right in that they are easy enough to snap into place and unsnap when needed. It works very well during my reload practices. I looked all over for a leather holder but they are hard to find and very expensive when you do find them. So I think this is one time when I can be pake and get away with it.

I have a couple of very old military clip holders for some old military rifles I own. They are designed to hold one or two fully charged clips of rifle ammunition. They are an ugly brown leather with snaps that are too tight for practical use. But I will try and incorporate them during my revolver EDC. I can see already that a more modern and practical carry pouch will replace these quickly. I will eventually purchase a couple of speed strips that will be used to charge my revolvers in lieu of the speedloaders. I will write about it at a later date. But for now, speedloaders work very well for me with practice.

My thoughts on all of this might not agree with some of you. I do not feel under gunned when I carry a six shot revolver and no additional ammo. Same goes for when I carry a 12-17 round semi auto. I do not feel the need to carry additional magazines nor speedloaders all the time. This may be a mistake on my part but it is how I feel. It doesn’t mean I won’t carry extra ammo. I do somewhat irregularly carry extra. I have changed all my pants over from regular blue jeans to cargo pants/shorts. So if I do feel the need to carry extra ammo, the magazines go in one of my pockets. If I decide to carry extra for my revolvers I do carry the speedloaders in my holder. Most conflicts are settled without firing a shot. And with that even less are settled with only one or two shots. While the chance of my ever having to pull a weapon on someone are rather slim, I feel I have enough confidence in my abilities to put down one or two perps if necessary with what I am carrying. I do feel naked without a pistol on my person every day. One of them (at a minimum) goes with me every single day when I leave my house. And one is with me almost all the time when I am working outside my house. Recently during my trip to CA I felt totally naked without a gun on my person. I do not want to break any laws. I just tried to stay out of any known bad areas during my trip. Feeling naked without a gun on your person is a feeling you will experience if you ever get to carry concealed or open for a length of time.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on December 04, 2021, 05:40:08 AM
You learned that CMO has no focus, thus 5 holsters.
😂 I would say 5 holsters is probably less than most. 😂

Some go for the one for OWB and one for IWB. So at a minimum they have 2 per gun. I like the idea of having one holster that does both. Some love kydex and I love leather. I have a hybrid (leather/kydex) on order right now. I think there is value in both materials. I think kydex is really the value proposition of all of the materials. I have only OWB kydex holsters but I will eventually get try an IWB kydex for my new pistol. And I will probably get an all leather holster for it as well. You don’t know what you are going to prefer until you try them.

BTW, I have a couple of friends that have several holsters per gun and have a lot of guns. Therefore their box of holsters is the size of a Dell Computer box. And it takes them a bit to find the one they want o use when it comes time to dig. One of them has two boxes. A large one to hold most of them and a small one to hold the few they use the most.

I can see that the bulk of my monthly fun money is going to go to various holsters for the next year or so. But I am saving up for a very expensive revolver currently. So I need to trade off my priorities.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Heavies on December 04, 2021, 05:15:53 PM
Best and most comfortable holsters I’ve tried are made by bladetech.  IWB and OWB. For some reason they are hard to find when I went looking. They are standard type holster though, so no lights or dots.

They are not Made from kydex, but some other kind of plastic. It kind of gives, whereas kydex is really stiff, and doesn’t feel uncomfortable, even against skin.  I have a IWB for my Kahr CM9, the tiny lightweight 9mm (little over 1lb loaded) disappears appendix carry. Very comfortable. The holster has one belt clip, which means easy on and easy off, with the pistol in the holster, which IMO is a good safety feature. Pistol has limited capacity though, but nice to have the power of 9mm, and more slim than a revolver.


Ps. I have way more than 5 holsters. Lol :rofl:
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 04, 2021, 07:55:41 PM
I use this for ccw now. Elastic band. Helps when  sitting, mag isnt standing straight up and in the way. Plus 1 less thing to be IWB.

For OWB range, no really matter to me. Bladetech, estaac,etc...plate carrier has 1 gcode scorpion pistol mag.(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20211205/e857900afa3ed737afeebc97aa53796e.jpg)

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Bushido on December 05, 2021, 09:29:33 AM
Most people will go through a bunch of holster in the beginning, I did. IMO most people are looking for an "inexpensive" holster to do something it won't. I wasted a lot of money believing the sales pitch, the hype and trying all kinds of hybrid IWBs, OWBs, etc.... My suggestion spend the money and buy a quality "piggy back" AIWB and be done with it. Maybe the only reason I wouldn't carry AIWB is if I had an previous injury that prevented it or carrying a revolver. I think most people that say it's uncomfortable either have a cheap one (yes I did that too), are inexperienced with CCW, are wearing it wrong, or don't know the tips to make it comfortable ie.when sitting, bending, in a car, etc.... I had a inexpensive piggy back one and it was horrible i never wore it in public. It was well made, sturdy, looked good but clearly not as much thought went into it as the better ones. I stayed with my separate holster and mag carrier for years because I didn't want to spend the money. Once i finally gave in and bought the TRex Arms Sidecar 1.0 and the LLOD Associate I realized I was doing it all wrong, the difference is night and day. I haven't tried the Tier I Concealment ones but maybe the only other one I would consider. The Tier ! wedges may help custom fit your holster to you if you need to. I use a surfboard deck pad material (feels like a wetsuit material) from Xcel on one of mines. I've seen some use those shoe soul inserts. ---- Once you have it set up how you want it, you almost forget you have it on. If it's not like that, there's tips you can do to get there. Bottom line if it's uncomfortable, you won't be wearing unless you think you might need it. That's the wrong mindset to have IMO.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: drck1000 on December 06, 2021, 12:20:42 PM
Have been meaning to read closely and chime in, but have been busy and Inspector, you're one verbose retiree. . .  ;D

Experiences in trying various holsters, for different applications and for different guns is definitely something I have a lot of experience with.  Mostly because I am one who like to try for myself and find out, as well as interest in a variety of applications where need a holster.

I've certainly experienced the cheap(er) holster that was ok and ended up getting rid of them.  Even some higher quality or known builders/manufacturers ended up being just ok, or not for me.  Holsters, like mentioned above, is very much user preference. 

Some lessons along the way, both personal experience and have seen:
1. My gun buying considers availability of holster options.  At least if that gun is intended for training, competition, etc.  If just for plinking, whatever goes.  I've also not gotten a new handgun because of having to get more holsters and mags, but that's another story.  Most of the handguns commonly used for military or LEO typically have a lot of holster options. 

2. Be wary of custom holster options. Having friends or knowing how to work kydex is a good opportunity to fill the voids for holsters on unique or less than common handguns.  I have a couple of friends who are pretty good at making holsters for unique firearms.  That said, caution that a typically a lot of trial and error can be involved.  many of the popular holster makers/mfrs have gone through that.  An example that I see often is things like the fit around say the mag release may seen fine while fit testing, but while in use can cause the mag release to get pressed upon the draw.  Or other fit issues that typically arise only when used in say competition or training. 

3. Having stuff like lights or RDS makes for limited holster options, as well as likely needing multiple holsters for the various iterations.  Also, variations in location of the light, slight variations in aftermarket slides, etc often require some "customization".  A dremel is a great tool for that.  I've had to dremel a number of my Safariland holsters where the RDS needed a little more clearance.

4. As mentioned already, belts are an essential consideration for holsters.  That applies to all applications that I typically encounter, but especially for CCW.  I have a number of CCW holsters and luckly they have belt clip options for various belts that I have.

5. Trying is key, as CMO mentioned and found out.  What may seem to work ok while trying out at home may not work that well once you get out and shooting, moving, competing, etc.

Finally, having 5 holsters?  That's cute. . .  ;D
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on December 06, 2021, 12:37:13 PM
Have been meaning to read closely and chime in, but have been busy and Inspector, you're one verbose retiree. . .  ;D
You callin’ me fat? Cuz I not know what verbose means!  :P

“Don't use a five-dollar word when a fifty-cent word will do.”


― Mark Twain
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 06, 2021, 12:49:26 PM


4. As mentioned already, belts are an essential consideration for holsters.  That applies to all applications that I typically encounter, but especially for CCW.  I have a number of CCW holsters and luckly they have belt clip options for various belts that I have.


With tasers becoming legal soon, this may affect many here daily.  Some don't wear belts, so I use a ULTI clip. It's designed for no belt usage and keeps the holster attached to your pants. 

I got this for my taser holster that I will be using for when I go to the gym wearing basketball shorts (no belt).  I go to the gym about 5x a week, so it will be used often.

https://www.ulticlip.com/product/ultituck/?v=7516fd43adaa

I will probably end up getting 2 IWB holsters, 1 with the ULTI clip and another with a regular belt clip.  The belt clip 1 will be used for work and going out.  I don't want to have to keep unscrewing the clips daily if I only had 1 holster.

I will however use the ULTI clip with my work slacks and just clip it to my pants and not the leather belt.  For now until I make sure this is the right holster for my needs. Don't want to have 5 taser holsters.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: drck1000 on December 06, 2021, 01:00:55 PM
You callin’ me fat? Cuz I not know what verbose means!  :P

“Don't use a five-dollar word when a fifty-cent word will do.”


― Mark Twain

You make posts with lots of words. . . there, I said it. . .  :rofl:
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: drck1000 on December 06, 2021, 01:02:10 PM
With tasers becoming legal soon, this may affect many here daily.  Some don't wear belts, so I use a ULTI clip. It's designed for no belt usage and keeps the holster attached to your pants. 

I got this for my taser holster that I will be using for when I go to the gym wearing basketball shorts (no belt).  I go to the gym about 5x a week, so it will be used often.

https://www.ulticlip.com/product/ultituck/?v=7516fd43adaa

I will probably end up getting 2 IWB holsters, 1 with the ULTI clip and another with a regular belt clip.  The belt clip 1 will be used for work and going out.  I don't want to have to keep unscrewing the clips daily if I only had 1 holster.

I will however use the ULTI clip with my work slacks and just clip it to my pants and not the leather belt.  For now until I make sure this is the right holster for my needs. Don't want to have 5 taser holsters.
Don't taze yourself in the junk. . .  :o  :shake:

 :rofl:
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on December 06, 2021, 01:04:52 PM
You make posts with lots of words. . . there, I said it. . .  :rofl:
:grrr:
 :grrr: :grrr: :grrr:
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 06, 2021, 01:17:21 PM
Don't taze yourself in the junk. . .  :o  :shake:

 :rofl:

Some people may enjoy the feeling.  Just sayin.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on December 06, 2021, 01:18:49 PM
Don't taze yourself in the junk. . .  :o  :shake:

 :rofl:
I’ll give you $50 if you video it and put it up here.  :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 06, 2021, 01:36:39 PM
I’ll give you $50 if you video it and put it up here.  :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:

He'd need assistance trying to hit such a teeny-weeny target.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 06, 2021, 02:05:49 PM
I’ll give you $50 if you video it and put it up here.  :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:

That would pay for the holster and clips.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: drck1000 on December 06, 2021, 02:26:02 PM
Some people may enjoy the feeling.  Just sayin.
Some people may not having any feeling there. . . jus sayin'

I’ll give you $50 if you video it and put it up here.  :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
"I'd (pay for that) for a dollar!"

I'd actually pay a lot more if he committed to it on here. 
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on December 06, 2021, 02:36:18 PM
That would pay for the holster and clips.
Well, tell me what you want? I could do a GoFundMe page…
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: QUIETShooter on December 07, 2021, 09:02:40 AM
I'd like to contribute to this thread if I may.  But first off will state: I have no experience with holsters, lol!

Because I recently retired, I decided to get a SD pistol just in case one day a miracle happens and Hawaii will have carry laws.  I already own revolvers but as SD weapons they are too large and bulky.  They are perfect for home defense though.

So I went out recently and bought a Sig Sauer P365.  I got the tac-pac which came with the pistol, three 12 round mags (altered to accept only ten) and a holster that can be configured IWB or OWB.  And I also ordered a 10 round mag on-line that will help hide the pistol print even further.  (F**kn 78 bucks with the shipping, dammmmnnnnn!!!! :rofl:)

The holster is not the greatest, according to the experts on YT.  Being inexperienced, I honestly wouldn't know.  But before I got the pistol I ordered a battle belt from Tactical Armament.  It looks and feels great but one problem:  the belt is too thick and wide and won't fit the belt loop of the holster.

So for the time being I'm using just a regular pants belt.  I tried the IWB configuration and I didn't like it.  Seems like I couldn't wear it for long periods and it printed.  I tried the OWB configuration and found the 3 o'clock position is most comfortable and I like it the most when I practice drawing from it.

In fact, I'm wearing it right now as I'm writing this.  I was practicing in the living room then decided to take a break to write this.  ;D  Only problem is it also prints, even with the 10 rd. magazine.  Very little and subtle but the print is there.  This is with a T-shirt.  If I had a jacket on it can't be seen.

But I love practicing with this holster and this little gun.  The gun feels great in my hands and even though I'm medium build I have large hands.  Very happy with this gun.  Now if I can only hit something with it, lol!

The best way I found so far to CC this little gun is to just stick it in my pocket.  I wear relaxed fitting jeans ( Levi's 559) and the gun disappears in the pocket.  You can tell there's something in the pocket but it can be construed as a wallet.  And with the shirt worn outside you can't tell.

I plan to buy a Vanguard type pocket holster which is essentially just a trigger guard type device to protect the trigger.  There is a clip that you can use for IWB carry and it will retain the holster while you draw the gun out.  Or you can take that clip off and attach the lanyard that comes with it, attached it to your belt and it will pull the holster off the gun when you draw it out of your pocket.

Pocket draw is a little slower according to reviews but for me if I want maximum concealment, I want to try this option.  I haven't practiced this route yet but I plan to after I order the product.

Please feel free to critique or offer tips, insults, or praise, lol!  Thanks for letting me share what little I know. :shaka:

Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 07, 2021, 09:21:21 AM
I'd like to contribute to this thread if I may.  But first off will state: I have no experience with holsters, lol!

Because I recently retired, I decided to get a SD pistol just in case one day a miracle happens and Hawaii will have carry laws.  I already own revolvers but as SD weapons they are too large and bulky.  They are perfect for home defense though.

So I went out recently and bought a Sig Sauer P365.  I got the tac-pac which came with the pistol, three 12 round mags (altered to accept only ten) and a holster that can be configured IWB or OWB.  And I also ordered a 10 round mag on-line that will help hide the pistol print even further.  (F**kn 78 bucks with the shipping, dammmmnnnnn!!!! :rofl:)

The holster is not the greatest, according to the experts on YT.  Being inexperienced, I honestly wouldn't know.  But before I got the pistol I ordered a battle belt from Tactical Armament.  It looks and feels great but one problem:  the belt is too thick and wide and won't fit the belt loop of the holster.

So for the time being I'm using just a regular pants belt.  I tried the IWB configuration and I didn't like it.  Seems like I couldn't wear it for long periods and it printed.  I tried the OWB configuration and found the 3 o'clock position is most comfortable and I like it the most when I practice drawing from it.

In fact, I'm wearing it right now as I'm writing this.  I was practicing in the living room then decided to take a break to write this.  ;D  Only problem is it also prints, even with the 10 rd. magazine.  Very little and subtle but the print is there.  This is with a T-shirt.  If I had a jacket on it can't be seen.

But I love practicing with this holster and this little gun.  The gun feels great in my hands and even though I'm medium build I have large hands.  Very happy with this gun.  Now if I can only hit something with it, lol!

The best way I found so far to CC this little gun is to just stick it in my pocket.  I wear relaxed fitting jeans ( Levi's 559) and the gun disappears in the pocket.  You can tell there's something in the pocket but it can be construed as a wallet.  And with the shirt worn outside you can't tell.

I plan to buy a Vanguard type pocket holster which is essentially just a trigger guard type device to protect the trigger.  There is a clip that you can use for IWB carry and it will retain the holster while you draw the gun out.  Or you can take that clip off and attach the lanyard that comes with it, attached it to your belt and it will pull the holster off the gun when you draw it out of your pocket.

Pocket draw is a little slower according to reviews but for me if I want maximum concealment, I want to try this option.  I haven't practiced this route yet but I plan to after I order the product.

Please feel free to critique or offer tips, insults, or praise, lol!  Thanks for letting me share what little I know. :shaka:

B4 I first carried in Vegas, I wore just my holster IWB out when doing errands or getting lunch.  Just to get a partial feel of what it's like. When I did this, I noticed the sweat build up due to it being Kydex and the rubbing.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on December 07, 2021, 09:24:06 AM
I'd like to contribute to this thread if I may.  But first off will state: I have no experience with holsters, lol!

Because I recently retired, I decided to get a SD pistol just in case one day a miracle happens and Hawaii will have carry laws.  I already own revolvers but as SD weapons they are too large and bulky.  They are perfect for home defense though.

So I went out recently and bought a Sig Sauer P365.  I got the tac-pac which came with the pistol, three 12 round mags (altered to accept only ten) and a holster that can be configured IWB or OWB.  And I also ordered a 10 round mag on-line that will help hide the pistol print even further.  (F**kn 78 bucks with the shipping, dammmmnnnnn!!!! :rofl:)

The holster is not the greatest, according to the experts on YT.  Being inexperienced, I honestly wouldn't know.  But before I got the pistol I ordered a battle belt from Tactical Armament.  It looks and feels great but one problem:  the belt is too thick and wide and won't fit the belt loop of the holster.

So for the time being I'm using just a regular pants belt.  I tried the IWB configuration and I didn't like it.  Seems like I couldn't wear it for long periods and it printed.  I tried the OWB configuration and found the 3 o'clock position is most comfortable and I like it the most when I practice drawing from it.

In fact, I'm wearing it right now as I'm writing this.  I was practicing in the living room then decided to take a break to write this.  ;D  Only problem is it also prints, even with the 10 rd. magazine.  Very little and subtle but the print is there.  This is with a T-shirt.  If I had a jacket on it can't be seen.

But I love practicing with this holster and this little gun.  The gun feels great in my hands and even though I'm medium build I have large hands.  Very happy with this gun.  Now if I can only hit something with it, lol!

The best way I found so far to CC this little gun is to just stick it in my pocket.  I wear relaxed fitting jeans ( Levi's 559) and the gun disappears in the pocket.  You can tell there's something in the pocket but it can be construed as a wallet.  And with the shirt worn outside you can't tell.

I plan to buy a Vanguard type pocket holster which is essentially just a trigger guard type device to protect the trigger.  There is a clip that you can use for IWB carry and it will retain the holster while you draw the gun out.  Or you can take that clip off and attach the lanyard that comes with it, attached it to your belt and it will pull the holster off the gun when you draw it out of your pocket.

Pocket draw is a little slower according to reviews but for me if I want maximum concealment, I want to try this option.  I haven't practiced this route yet but I plan to after I order the product.

Please feel free to critique or offer tips, insults, or praise, lol!  Thanks for letting me share what little I know. :shaka:
Hey QS thanks for contributing to this thread and making it better!  :shaka:

So I just bought a P365 XL for myself. I have not had it long enough to even fire it yet. Probably this Thursday. I love the way it feels in my hands as I have large hands as well. I also just added a Hogue sleeve to it. Gives me a better grip by giving it a palm swell and accentuating the finger groove. I actually tried to put it in a too small for it pocket holster and put it in my pocket and it seems like it may be doable. So I will be ordering a pocket holster for it soon to try it out. I have already ordered a hybrid kydex/leather IWB/OWB holster to try. I’ll do a write up once I get some experience with it.

Have you fired your pistol yet? I have fired my nephew’s pistol several times and besides the grip being a little short for me I like it.

Please come back and write up your experience with the pocket holster and let us know how it goes.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: drck1000 on December 07, 2021, 09:57:19 AM
I use this for ccw now. Elastic band. Helps when  sitting, mag isnt standing straight up and in the way. Plus 1 less thing to be IWB.

For OWB range, no really matter to me. Bladetech, estaac,etc...plate carrier has 1 gcode scorpion pistol mag.

SNIP

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
Is that mag at your 3 o'clock and bottom of the mag facing rearward? 
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 07, 2021, 10:12:07 AM
Is that mag at your 3 o'clock and bottom of the mag facing rearward?

Pic in inverted. It's on my 11 o'clock. Heads pointed down.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: drck1000 on December 07, 2021, 10:21:59 AM
SNIP

1) The holster is not the greatest, according to the experts on YT.  Being inexperienced, I honestly wouldn't know.  But before I got the pistol I ordered a battle belt from Tactical Armament.  It looks and feels great but one problem:  the belt is too thick and wide and won't fit the belt loop of the holster.

2) So for the time being I'm using just a regular pants belt.  I tried the IWB configuration and I didn't like it.  Seems like I couldn't wear it for long periods and it printed.  I tried the OWB configuration and found the 3 o'clock position is most comfortable and I like it the most when I practice drawing from it.

In fact, I'm wearing it right now as I'm writing this.  I was practicing in the living room then decided to take a break to write this.  ;D  Only problem is it also prints, even with the 10 rd. magazine.  Very little and subtle but the print is there.  This is with a T-shirt.  If I had a jacket on it can't be seen.

3) Please feel free to critique or offer tips, insults, or praise, lol!  Thanks for letting me share what little I know. :shaka:
1) Does your holster have belt clips that can be adjusted or swapped out.  I (and prob others here) have spare belt clips for belt with and thicknesses. 

2) 3 o'clock is where I started carrying back when I had a CCW in another state.  I was a bid thinner then.  Now, carrying at 3 o'clock has some "natural retention".  Seriously though, I don't carry there often, but in the times that I do, the gun does dig into my side a little.  But after a couple of days, I don't notice it.  I rarely carry a 3 o'clock, even in the rare times that I do carry.

3) Tips?  Always.  Praise?  Maybe.  Insults?  Friendly banter. . .  ;D
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: drck1000 on December 07, 2021, 10:23:46 AM
Pic in inverted. It's on my 11 o'clock. Heads pointed down.
"We were inverted"

You would have to pull the mag with your left hand and to the rear? 
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 07, 2021, 10:39:13 AM
"We were inverted"

You would have to pull the mag with your left hand and to the rear?

Pull mag with left hand toward the rear.  Thumb is  on the top which would mimic the index finger on the front of the mag.  Like how 1 normally indexs a mag when OWB drawing from a mag holder.

I have a magnetic mag clip for the pocket, but I don't like to show clips in pockets.  Even for EDC knives. So I bought it and stopped using it. So add to the box of extra holsters.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on December 22, 2021, 05:01:17 AM
My New EDC Rig   

I finally have my new EDC rig together. It consists of a new Sig Sauer P365 XL, two 12 round flush fit magazines, one 15 round extended magazine, a Hogue Handall rubber sleeve, and a hybrid IWB/OWB holster from a company called Hidden hybrid Holsters.

For those of you not familiar with the Sig P365 it comes in a few different models. For this article I will only describe 3 of them. The P365 basic is a very small 9mm which comes with a 10 round magazine that is flush and a 12 round extended magazine which adds a place for your pinky. Then there is the P365 X model which has the same barrel and slide as the basic model but adds a longer grip which is the exact same length as the basic model with the extended 12 round magazine. And then there is the XL model which has the same grip as the X model and adds a longer slide and barrel to the basic and X models. I decided on the XL model specifically for a couple of reasons. The first is the the grip on the XL just feels a little better to me than the basic model with the extended 12 round mag. Next is the slightly longer barrel and slide gives me a better sight picture to pick up the front sight easier and quicker and it is a little softer shooting for me. Which allows me to get back on target a little quicker. The XL also comes with a straight trigger which is all the rage these days but to be honest, I am not a fan of the straight trigger. The reset is also very short on the XL plus the overall width is slightly wider. It took me a while to figure out where the extra width is on the XL. Turns out it is at the very bottom of the grip where the mag well is slightly flared which makes mag changes easier, quicker and less prone to errors.

The biggest advantages to this pistol as an EDC is that it is VERY thin. Especially compared to the Glock models. It is small and light. And as I stated in my earlier articles, weight is very tiring. Size is a huge advantage, but weight can be a real problem over several hours. Another big advantage is capacity. While 12 round flush fit mags are optimum, having an additional 15 round mag to keep in a pocket or mag holder is another huge advantage. If I carry an extra 2 mags (One 12 and one 15 round) I can carry up to 39 rounds or 42 if I carry two 15 round mags in addition to the 12 round mag in the pistol.

If I have included photos you will also notice I added a Hogue Handall to my pistol. It adds a palm swell and well as finger grooves which help me get a better grip. Plus, even though this pistol is softer shooting than the basic and X models, it is still snappy and can cause me a little pain due to my arthritis. The rubber sleeve actually comforts my hand and helps reduce felt recoil.

Now, for the jewel of this complete EDC rig. I bought a hybrid IWB/OWB holster from Hidden Hybrid Holsters. This company is known for their quality holsters and soft leather along with a suede backing which makes this holster VERY comfortable. There are a couple of other things which make this rig very comfortable. The kydex shell is very thin. Thinner than some of the holsters I have looked at and that I own. Combine this with a very thin pistol and you can hardly feel this holster while wearing it IWB. All I can say is WOW! What a difference between my much larger and heavier pistols and holster rigs. Also, this holster easily and quickly converts to OWB and the retention is adjustable. I have tried this holster so far at the 3 o’clock position and the 4 o’clock position. I feel it best at the 3 o’clock position. I will also try appendix carry as this rig should work well. But my fat stomach will probably not allow this to conceal all that well. While I have not had much time carrying this rig yet, I can tell just from my initial assessments that I made all the right choices for my EDC.

I now have my main EDC pistols and holsters set. The Sig will be my EDC IWB and my Ruger LCP Max is my deep concealed carry in my pocket pistol. Either as a backup or as my main EDC when wearing a lot of heavy cold weather coats/jackets. Carrying IWB or even OWB with heavy coats and jackets can slow your draw and interfere with your draw depending on your circumstances. If wearing an unbuttoned or unzipped coat or jacket, then IWB/OWB carry is optimal. So there may be times that a deep pocket carry pistol carried in the jacket pocket is optimal. This Sig P365 XL might even do as a pocket carry either in a pinch or possibly as an EDC but after a little experimenting I feel it is just a tad too large and heavy for me to be practical. Maybe buying a P365 basic model which is smaller and lighter would be better. I can also buy a basic model shell and move my FCU from my XL to the basic shell.

Here are some observations which are purely my opinions and are right/best for me. They may not be right for you. Hybrid holsters are the way to go for IWB carry. They offer a kydex shell to hold your pistol snug with adjustable retention. Plus they hold their shape when you draw your pistol allowing you to easily reholster. And have a leather backing for comfort. My particular holster has soft leather plus suede as a backing. It holds my pistol close and tight against my body and fat stomach which aids tremendously in keeping the pistol from printing. For what it is, it is far above and beyond what I was expecting and hoping it would be. As an OWB holster it is also comfortable but once you put the holster OWB then size and weight/heft become bigger factors. And the Sig being small and light really makes this combination a sweet complete rig for me. Kydex and plastic only holsters are only okay as IWB carry IMHO. They are hard and can have sharp edges which can be uncomfortable. They perform well as a OWB holster but only if how the holster attaches to your belt is well designed. I have one OWB plastic holster which holds my Glock very well but is sloppy when it comes to hanging off my belt. I have a kydex Serpa holster which holds my Glock very well and keeps the pistol nice and tight up against my body where it should be. With no slop. And then we have my favorite all leather holsters. I think all leather holsters are fine for IWB if they have reinforced mouths to keep them from collapsing when you draw your pistol. If they collapse when you draw then you will have problems reholstering. They are comfortable and can be customized with engraving, stitching and exotic materials and colors to make them your own and look spectacular. But I think leather makes OWB holsters the best. Combine comfort, good looks and customization and you have something that will last a lifetime nod garner lots of comments.

There are choke holster manufacturers out there. Due your research and buy only quality holsters from reputable sources. One note about Alien Gear. This is not a bash on them. They offer a solution that is a jack of all trades and a master of none. For some people this is a great solution. Take a look at them as they offer a complete holster system that does a lot. I looked at them and felt they were too thick/wide and overly complicated for what I wanted. I decided I wanted a IWB/OWB as there are times I want to carry and not have to conceal. Like when I work around my house or going out to the desert. No need conceal. So I wanted the option of carrying OWB as this is more comfortable than IWB any day of the week. I could have purchased 2 holsters, one an IWB and another OWB and probably have maybe even a little more comfort. But I felt that this was one area I could save a little money by buying a single  holster that fit all my needs.

There you have it. This is the extent of my EDC and holster experiences. I have others planned for the future but are far off into the future so this will be the last article for a while. My future projects include a true IWB/OWB holster for my Ruger LCP Max. I don’t intend to carry it like this a lot but I want the option in case something happens to my Sig. Also, I want to buy a S&W J Frame Revolver which is their small frame. Along with a good holster I want to make this a backup to the Sig. Either in the pocket or carry in an ankle holster. There are a lot of options to try.

If you do a lot of research and are willing to experiment as I am you will find you will have more holsters than you need. But you won’t really know what works best for you without trying. All I will suggest is that you shouldn’t cheap out. A good holster is going to be a bit pricey but is worth every penny because it will work well for you and last a lifetime. Cheap holsters will end up at the bottom of your holster box and will probably never see the light of day again. But as important as holster choice is your choice of pistols. So make your choices wisely.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: QUIETShooter on December 22, 2021, 08:06:20 AM
Hey QS thanks for contributing to this thread and making it better!  :shaka:

So I just bought a P365 XL for myself. I have not had it long enough to even fire it yet. Probably this Thursday. I love the way it feels in my hands as I have large hands as well. I also just added a Hogue sleeve to it. Gives me a better grip by giving it a palm swell and accentuating the finger groove. I actually tried to put it in a too small for it pocket holster and put it in my pocket and it seems like it may be doable. So I will be ordering a pocket holster for it soon to try it out. I have already ordered a hybrid kydex/leather IWB/OWB holster to try. I’ll do a write up once I get some experience with it.

Have you fired your pistol yet? I have fired my nephew’s pistol several times and besides the grip being a little short for me I like it.

Please come back and write up your experience with the pocket holster and let us know how it goes.

Hi Inspector!

Sorry so late in replying.  For some reason I have been bypassing this thread.  Can’t believe I missed so much activity, lol!

I’m glad you like your new P365XL!  I’m sure this gun will work out well for you.

Yes I’ve shot my pistol recently.  For a little pistol I like the feel and the expected snappiness is tolerable for me.  I just need to put in the required time at the range to improve my marksmanship.

The gun is so fun to shoot I’m now thinking of getting another Sig, this time a full sized model, maybe a 320. 

Wishing you lots of great times with your new EDC gun.  Take care and be safe!
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: QUIETShooter on December 22, 2021, 09:34:14 AM
1) Does your holster have belt clips that can be adjusted or swapped out.  I (and prob others here) have spare belt clips for belt with and thicknesses. 

2) 3 o'clock is where I started carrying back when I had a CCW in another state.  I was a bid thinner then.  Now, carrying at 3 o'clock has some "natural retention".  Seriously though, I don't carry there often, but in the times that I do, the gun does dig into my side a little.  But after a couple of days, I don't notice it.  I rarely carry a 3 o'clock, even in the rare times that I do carry.

3) Tips?  Always.  Praise?  Maybe.  Insults?  Friendly banter. . .  ;D

The P365 TACPAC holster that Sig provided doesn't have provisions for swap out or adjustment.  Comments on YT say it's a cheapie holster but it's ok for me.  I don't know any better though. :rofl:

I also have "love handles" and it competes with the 3 o'clock position, lol!   I'm working on the love handles although at times it looks hopeless. ;D

Thanks on the offer of spare belt clips and loops.  You guys are great! :shaka:  But no need.  I think I'd like to dive in that rabbit hole of looking for the "right" holster.  First thing is to look for a box big enough to dump all of them in........ :D

Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: aaronc5362 on December 22, 2021, 11:16:33 AM
The P365 TACPAC holster that Sig provided doesn't have provisions for swap out or adjustment.  Comments on YT say it's a cheapie holster but it's ok for me.  I don't know any better though. :rofl:

I also have "love handles" and it competes with the 3 o'clock position, lol!   I'm working on the love handles although at times it looks hopeless. ;D

Thanks on the offer of spare belt clips and loops.  You guys are great! :shaka:  But no need.  I think I'd like to dive in that rabbit hole of looking for the "right" holster.  First thing is to look for a box big enough to dump all of them in........ :D

Try looking into a belly band setup. There's cheap ones on Amazon. Never tried though. Unity tactical prob is best but its an expensive experiment.

Blue force gear and sticky holsters sell pocket holsters if your into that.

My 3rd suggestion is a SOB holster. It rides upside down sort of speak at your 6 oclock position. But you will need long type of tshirts.

4th suggestion is appendix carry like a trex sidecar. Or whatever its called.

Also are you gonna run a tlr7 sub or any weaponlight on it? Ya should debate on that first before spending money on a holster. I had like 3 or 4 holsters wasnt light bearing so I gave a few away to friends and still have a couple. Somewhere.

The only time I ever carried was on a hike in kailua. All my friends told me to bring my 357 mag. It wasnt a public trail. Luckily never ran into any boars. 2 of the other people in the group were/ still are LEOs but we all carried owb . although I do buy a holster for each pistol just incase whether it be at my friends AG land or shtf.

Whats also neat is that umarex/ elite force (airsoft companies) make 1:1 replicas of real firearms. For example, they bought the mold from glock to make gen 3 g19, gen 4 g17, and g45s. Not sure how much they paid but I'm sure glock gets royalties per airsoft pistol sold.  So I used my shtf g19 belt for airsoft a few times. After that, I rearranged a few things. So it kinda gave me a real life scenario if I was in a urban environment. I waa running, cutting corners, lying on the ground, switching from primary to pistol and doing fast reloads. It was pretty fun. And before any of you get mad or put me down, the g19 setup I used in airsoft, I used on the AG land with my real firearm. Minus the lying down and running.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: zippz on December 22, 2021, 11:19:38 AM
I shot a 357 686 revolver in a steel challenge match this past weekend, first time drawing it from a Speed Beez kydex holster.   It felt very weird, like my draw was sluggish or lagging.  I realized it was the weight and front heaviness of the revolver that made it feel that way.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on December 22, 2021, 11:51:09 AM
I shot a 357 686 revolver in a steel challenge match this past weekend, first time drawing it from a Speed Beez kydex holster.   It felt very weird, like my draw was sluggish or lagging.  I realized it was the weight and front heaviness of the revolver that made it feel that way.
Don’t feel bad. I have been practicing holster draw for a while now and I found it is very hard to draw fast and do it correctly at the same time. So I practice on the fundamentals first. Get it right most of the time and then I practice on speed. So for me I get the same feeling you do. Like I am drawing in slow motion even though I am trying to draw quickly.
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 22, 2021, 02:45:05 PM
When u carry a few times a year, size no matter.

Plus its cold so jackets hide everything.(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20211223/1c37d541c52e0380b92d6debf295c58e.jpg)

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on December 22, 2021, 02:47:47 PM
When u carry a few times a year, size no matter.

Plus its cold so jackets hide everything.(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20211223/1c37d541c52e0380b92d6debf295c58e.jpg)

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
Are you not worried about accidental discharge? 😂 😝
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: macsak on December 22, 2021, 04:54:05 PM
When u carry a few times a year, size no matter.

Plus its cold so jackets hide everything.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

cute your purple belt
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on December 22, 2021, 04:57:55 PM
Are you not worried about accidental discharge? 😂 😝

Nothing there to worry about, I'm guessing.   :rofl:
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 22, 2021, 08:40:38 PM
Are you not worried about accidental discharge?
3/16, target too small. Small boto club for the win.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: Inspector on December 23, 2021, 01:24:31 AM
3/16, target too small. Small boto club for the win.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
Small boto club or not, it is nice to see you and your wife sharing your common interests. Exercising your 2A rights together. I understand you two shoot together and go to classes together. I think that is actually pretty cool!!! ❤️
Title: Re: My Holster Experiences
Post by: changemyoil66 on December 24, 2021, 07:17:44 AM
Small boto club or not, it is nice to see you and your wife sharing your common interests. Exercising your 2A rights together. I understand you two shoot together and go to classes together. I think that is actually pretty cool!!!
Yup, we take skill builders together when shes not working. She gets to shoot ammo for free, doesnt need to load mags. In return, she provides purple ammo can, purple gun bag, purple water jug.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk