2aHawaii
General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: buckjay on September 28, 2012, 06:23:57 PM
-
My woes with the MWS platform continue... after buying a $450 LMT barrel from someone only to have it fall out during transit (and the seller won't take responsibility) I ended up buying a brand new LMT SS barrel to have ADCO cut down to 16".
Well I finally got my $750 barrel ($1200 if you count my earlier loss!!!) from ADCO today and I try to thread on my brand new Surefire MB762K-211C brake and it only threads on about 10%. I read around and people say to just crank it down and thread it on with the wrench. I manage to get it all the way to measure how many shims I'll need and then I removed it. I put on the shims and started putting it back on.. got about halfway and the fucking thing is stuck. I can't move backwards or forwards. It feels like the threads the barrel got deformed and now it won't back up or move forward. The barrel is spinning in my vice now.. must be giving it 60-70lbs of torque before the barrel starts to spin.
Anyone know of anyone on island with the tools to fix this? Assuming a big fat vice and a 5/8-24 tap.
-
Sounds like a job for X-Ring
-
Sounds like a job for X-Ring
Yes it does.
-
I've seen these guys on TV.
(http://www.redjacketfirearms.com/templates/jsn_epic_pro/images/logo.png)
-
Well, looks like I'm sending it back to ADCO.
-
Did you try heat? a propane torch?
-
Don't really want to make it worse. I was told its most likely stainless steel galling (stainless on stainless without lube... ouch).
-
It needs to be done on a lathe. That is the best way. to make sure its true to the bore.
Wayne at Pacific Custom Rifles can fix it also. if youre near Kalihi.
-
Might be galling, but it sounds more like someone got metric and SAE or some other threading mixed up.
There's a deliberate effort to make SAE and metric threads more-or-less compatible wherever possible, but the slight errors between pitches and diameters "add up" if long threads are involved, which ultimately leads to jamming. After all, most threads are designed so that maximum pull-strength is achieved within approximately five or six threads, and this works out fairly well for metric versus SAE nuts and bolts, but on longer threaded pieces you are dancing with disaster. On the other hand, it may be just plain shitty machining.
I strongly object to the advice about "keep on turning" the two workpieces together. Sufficient forces on the threads may well result in a cold-welding of the two pieces. It sort of goes along with the classically foolish advice: "Don't force it, use a bigger hammer." Some threading is designed to be a wringing fit, such as the barrel-to-receiver matings on many firearms, but the torque involved in screwing these kinds of parts together does not increase very much as the parts are joined --usually within only 10 or so threads:
(http://www.24hourcampfire.com/ubbthreads/ubbthreads.php/ubb/download/Number/17368/filename/BarrelShanks2.jpg)
I'd also be really concerned that with the torques involved with that very bad kind of brute-force advice, that permanent damage has been done to both the barrel and the attached part by now, and possibly even the receiver.
You may well have a piece of junk now, due to that bad advice.
Terry, 230RN
NOTE: I am avoiding discussion of the myriad British threading systems.
(Pic credit in properties)