2aHawaii
General Topics => Strategies and Tactics => Topic started by: dubya on October 18, 2012, 10:44:50 AM
-
Travis Haley - Adaptive Carbine: Zero at Distance (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8iCNIRuQuBg#ws)
Thoughts?
What distance do you choose to zero your rifle in at?
dubya
-
Thoughts?
dubya
Yeah, I wonder what shirt Travis is wearing.
-
Yeah, I wonder what shirt Travis is wearing.
personally, i was wondering what type of ammo he was using, but it's great to see that there are those among the forum-dwellers who are fashion-conscious, as well!
joo rook mahvaleous, dahling! :thumbsup:
-
First thought: Damn, that bugger can SHOOT! Second thought: I never thought about different zero ranges, but I'm now a firm believer in the 300 yard zero. I don't know why anyone would use anything different, honestly. The exact same hold from touching distance out to three hundred, and all of the POIs are within a four inch circle? Too good to be true! Too bad here on Oahu we don't have a long enough range to do it, so I guess I'll have to settle for zeroing at 100 yards and then adding in whatever the old iPhone ballistic calculator app says I need for 300. :(
-
joo rook mahvaleous, dahling! :thumbsup:
That's...Incredible!
-
I'm now a firm believer in the 300 yard zero. I don't know why anyone would use anything different, honestly. The exact same hold from touching distance out to three hundred, and all of the POIs are within a four inch circle? Too good to be true! Too bad here on Oahu we don't have a long enough range to do it, so I guess I'll have to settle for zeroing at 100 yards and then adding in whatever the old iPhone ballistic calculator app says I need for 300. :(
We shoot the 200, 300 and 600 yardlines at least once a month at Puuloa.
-
Travis Haley - Adaptive Carbine: Zero at Distance (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8iCNIRuQuBg#ws)
Thoughts?
What distance do you choose to zero your rifle in at?
My thoughts are that this just doesn't make sense. The physics governing the flight of a projectile don't change because of where you point the barrel!
I mean, I get that it has to do with an expanding cone; more to the point, a cone that converges at the muzzle. But if a bullet drops 4" as it travels from 300 to 400 yards, then it drops 4" every time it makes that trip! The fact that I point the barrel 1 degree higher shouldn't change that.
It makes my head hurt.
That being said, I zero my high-powered rifles at 100 yards. Why? Because Kokohead is where I can shoot regularly, and 100 yards is the farthest place I can easily place a target frame. When I took Chuck Taylor's sniper class, he was a proponent of the 200 yards zero, and the rifle I used for that class I did zero at 200.
My carbines and .22 rifles are a different story. Those I tend to zero at 50 yards, for nearly the same reason.
-
Travis Haley - Adaptive Carbine: Zero at Distance (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8iCNIRuQuBg#ws)
Thoughts?
What distance do you choose to zero your rifle in at?
dubya
100 yards but like I learned from the All Guard team, zeroes are just a baseline; it will change given conditions.
With that in mind I know how much clicks I am up from my mechanical zero. I guess the best analogy is driving a stick shift. At about xx mph you shift into the next gear but it all depends on whether you are climbing a hill etc. Knowing where you are (range estimation) in relation to your mech zero is important. For example my AR service rifle zeros are 1 MOA from mech zero for 100 yards, 3 MOA up for 200, 4.5 MOA for 300 and 18.75 MOA up for 600. given that I am shooting 77s at about 2700 fps from 100-300 yards and 80s at 2700 fps at 600. If I shoot 77s all the way to 600 my zero is about 4-5 MOA less than shooting with 80s.
-
My thoughts are that this just doesn't make sense. The physics governing the flight of a projectile don't change because of where you point the barrel!
I mean, I get that it has to do with an expanding cone; more to the point, a cone that converges at the muzzle. But if a bullet drops 4" as it travels from 300 to 400 yards, then it drops 4" every time it makes that trip! The fact that I point the barrel 1 degree higher shouldn't change that.
It makes my head hurt.
That being said, I zero my high-powered rifles at 100 yards. Why? Because Kokohead is where I can shoot regularly, and 100 yards is the farthest place I can easily place a target frame. When I took Chuck Taylor's sniper class, he was a proponent of the 200 yards zero, and the rifle I used for that class I did zero at 200.
My carbines and .22 rifles are a different story. Those I tend to zero at 50 yards, for nearly the same reason.
The physics don't change but where your bullet impacts will if you change the direction of your barrel. A one degree offset will affect the bullet's final resting place.
The sights are what we use to perceive where the barrel and ultimately where the bullet will land. We use line of sight which in relation to how a bullet travels is somewhat misleading because gravity will affect the bullet the moment it leaves the barrel and it will drop at a constant rate no matter what velocity. Our line of sight in a straight line versus an arc of the bullet. IMHO, knowing your rifle, ammo and how to adjust your sights in relation to a particular range is important. Travis conducted a very good experiment and it I think ultimately it bestows on your experience with your rifle, equipment and ammunition. In addition, shooting in different environments and ranges will help you determine what zero you should set your rifle at. Of course, if you are in the mil or other similar orgs, I'm not saying you should "Do wateva u like" ;D
-
A one degree offset will affect the bullet's final resting place.
Right, and obvious. Let's do a "what if"
You put your rifle in a vise, and align it parallel to the ground. Then, using a delicate digital level, you incline it 5 degrees. you fire a round. A sophisticated tracking system records the flight of the projectile. it notes, amongst all the other data it records, that between the distances of 400 and 500 yards, the bulled drops exactly 4", from a height of 6' to 5'8".
Now you increase the tilt by 1 degree, to 6 degrees above horizontal. You fire again. Obviously the point of impact changes at virtually every point along the flight path. But between 400 and 500 yards, the bullet will still fall by about 4". Not exactly, but pretty close. Admittedly that drop is now happening at a different height, let's say from 7' to 6"8(ish)".
Right?
So why doesn't that matter?
-
My thoughts are that this just doesn't make sense. The physics governing the flight of a projectile don't change because of where you point the barrel!
I mean, I get that it has to do with an expanding cone; more to the point, a cone that converges at the muzzle. But if a bullet drops 4" as it travels from 300 to 400 yards, then it drops 4" every time it makes that trip! The fact that I point the barrel 1 degree higher shouldn't change that.
It makes my head hurt.
That being said, I zero my high-powered rifles at 100 yards. Why? Because Kokohead is where I can shoot regularly, and 100 yards is the farthest place I can easily place a target frame. When I took Chuck Taylor's sniper class, he was a proponent of the 200 yards zero, and the rifle I used for that class I did zero at 200.
My carbines and .22 rifles are a different story. Those I tend to zero at 50 yards, for nearly the same reason.
You are not correct, the bullet flight does change depending on where the barrel is pointed. What Travis is talking about is where you set your crosshairs or dot. Depending on where you set your dot along that flight path of the bullet will give you different results.
For instance a lot of hunters will set their crosshairs at 200 yards. This means that given a relatively flat shooting bullet if they hold on the vitals of the animal they will hit it..............it may be a bit high or low, but you will hit it. It makes distance estimation a lot less important. Same reason (flat shooting round) is why a lot of deer hunters like a 0.270 instead of a 0.308.
Now what you need to realize is that not all bullets will drop at the same rate vertically versus how far they have traveled horizontally. There is a term called a BC or ballistic coefficient. This is a measured factor that indicates how "efficient" a bullet is..............in other words how well does the bullet keep velocity. The longer it takes for a bullet to travel a certain distance (in general) the further it drops vertically.
Now back to the drop. The problem is when you start to get into extreme angles your bullet point of impact is changed because gravity is acting in a direction that is far from perpendicular to the path of the bullet and more parallel to it.
-
Right, and obvious. Let's do a "what if"
You put your rifle in a vise, and align it parallel to the ground. Then, using a delicate digital level, you incline it 5 degrees. you fire a round. A sophisticated tracking system records the flight of the projectile. it notes, amongst all the other data it records, that between the distances of 400 and 500 yards, the bulled drops exactly 4", from a height of 6' to 5'8".
Now you increase the tilt by 1 degree, to 6 degrees above horizontal. You fire again. Obviously the point of impact changes at virtually every point along the flight path. But between 400 and 500 yards, the bullet will still fall by about 4". Not exactly, but pretty close. Admittedly that drop is now happening at a different height, let's say from 7' to 6"8(ish)".
Right?
So why doesn't that matter?
Yes, physics will dictate that the bullet will drop the same distance no matter how you point your barrel; what I stated is that POI will change given the different elevation of the barrel. Not arguing with you or physics.
-
Right, and obvious. Let's do a "what if"
You put your rifle in a vise, and align it parallel to the ground. Then, using a delicate digital level, you incline it 5 degrees. you fire a round. A sophisticated tracking system records the flight of the projectile. it notes, amongst all the other data it records, that between the distances of 400 and 500 yards, the bulled drops exactly 4", from a height of 6' to 5'8".
Now you increase the tilt by 1 degree, to 6 degrees above horizontal. You fire again. Obviously the point of impact changes at virtually every point along the flight path. But between 400 and 500 yards, the bullet will still fall by about 4". Not exactly, but pretty close. Admittedly that drop is now happening at a different height, let's say from 7' to 6"8(ish)".
Right?
So why doesn't that matter?
It does matter, and you're hitting the nail on the head without realizing it. The problem is that your target is, say, 6'0" tall. The first bullet dropped the four inches down to 5'8" and hit him in the forehead. The second bullet goes 8" over his head. The flight path of the bullet relative to the line of the bore was relatively similar, but there was a big difference in the point of impact for the two rounds. I do think the initial bore angle would make a difference on the arc of the bullet, which is why you have to account for the angle of the shot in long range shooting, right?
Anyway, the big takeaway is that, like you said, changing the initial angle of your barrel will change the point of impact of your bullet. The trick is to find the right zero range (initial angle of the bore) for your rifle and round in order to maximize your chances of scoring a hit.
-
Paul Howe, who is also pretty beastly, says 100 yard zero. In his demonstration, you drop the muzzle on target at mid chest /throat... and then at 300 yards you had a 6" drop... hitting still center mass
My point? I think the guns and ammo used here matter - and your mileage may vary.
-
My point? I think the guns and ammo used here matter - and your mileage may vary.
Of course the gun/ammo are the key. Just recall when the military went to the 5.56 varmint round with the flat trajectory. Early M-16s did not even have a freaking elevation adjustment other than the coarse front sight post. Just flip the back sight for close or far (I have to wonder how often that got used), and let the minimal drop over usual engagement range take care of the rest.
Thank the Marines and emphasis on real marksmanship for forcing the return of true adjustable rear sights, not that many know how to use them in these days of optics. With the new popularity of heavier cartridges, shooters are becoming familiar with trajectories again. Great fun looking at graphs of bullet drop when zeroed at various ranges to see effective hit zones. I found some great freeware called "Ballistics Tables" some time back that lets you plug in all sorts of details to figure this out, like sight height over the bore and all. Wish I had a chrono for accurate velocity inputs. Good stuff.
Addendum: One huge benefit of the software I mentioned with the sight height input is the ability to see the first bullet crossing distance. Depending on cartridge, like 30 yds before dropping to the zero range at 300. I have a laser reflective piece of tape 26 yds out for setting sights.
Piece of cake to sight in with a laser boresighter and be on the paper at the desired range when first shooting. I have found some small variances, but so far, inches, due to recoil and whatnot. Still, superior to shooting all over the place trying to get on the paper. Works for iron and optic sights, just adjust where the dot hits by an inch or two per what the software trajectory predicts.
-
On a sort-of related note, I read an interesting article about using your mildots for ranging. It emphasized the importance of knowing your bullet drops, because you can use mildots to get an accurate shot off at an unknown range without measuring and doing math if you do. For example, you look at a target and guess it's somewhere between 250-400 yards. (Because you suck at guessing range, that's why. This is a hypothetical, dammit! :thumbsup:) You know that your POI will be one mil low at 200, and four mils low at 400. The target measures a shade over three mils on the reticle, so you put the first dot at the top of the target and let 'er rip. You know you're going to be on for range because the target covers all POIs from 200-400 yards.
Just thought was a neat point; I've never used a mildot scope, but I'm planning to buy one for my AR once I get my pennies scraped together, so I've been doing some reading on how best to employ them.
-
Ok, I went camping this weekend, and was discussing this post with another forum member and personal friend who was there. And I think I am not doing a good job of expressing my confusion. So let me try again...
First, I get the forces involved. I understand gravity, ballistic coefficient, air density, and flavor of chewing gum all have impact on the flight path. I also get that small changes at the beginning make large changes at the end.
I may get the details slightly off because I'm not willing to invest another 8 minutes rewatching the video just now, but this fellow Travis has a series of targets (let's say 6). He shoots each of these targets multiple times, one time each at 25, 50, 100, 200, 300 and 400 yards. That's a total of 36 shots. For each and every one of those 36 shots, he uses the same sight picture.
Now, between targets, he changes the sighting of the rifle. The first target is shot at all distances with a zero of 25 yards. The second, shot at all distances with a zero of 50 yards. Etc, etc.
It's obvious that the holes in each target are going to differ.
The part that I just refuse to believe is that, on one target, the best grouping is 3 shots in one hand span, while on another target, the best grouping is 5 shots in one hand span, and that difference is attributed to differing zeros.
In my mind, the vertical string shouldn't change all that much. It should appear higher or lower on the target, yes. But the bullet should fall about the same distance as it traverses the distance between distance X and distance Y. Not exactly the same, because the trajectory is slightly different, but the end result should not be (in my brain) that any variation in zero should change group sizes at any distance.
I'm not denying that it seems to work. Some fairly respectable organizations seem to believe in it.
I'm just saying that it CAN'T work.
-
Ok, I went camping this weekend, and was discussing this post with another forum member and personal friend who was there. And I think I am not doing a good job of expressing my confusion. So let me try again...
First, I get the forces involved. I understand gravity, ballistic coefficient, air density, and flavor of chewing gum all have impact on the flight path. I also get that small changes at the beginning make large changes at the end.
I may get the details slightly off because I'm not willing to invest another 8 minutes rewatching the video just now, but this fellow Travis has a series of targets (let's say 6). He shoots each of these targets multiple times, one time each at 25, 50, 100, 200, 300 and 400 yards. That's a total of 36 shots. For each and every one of those 36 shots, he uses the same sight picture.
Now, between targets, he changes the sighting of the rifle. The first target is shot at all distances with a zero of 25 yards. The second, shot at all distances with a zero of 50 yards. Etc, etc.
It's obvious that the holes in each target are going to differ.
The part that I just refuse to believe is that, on one target, the best grouping is 3 shots in one hand span, while on another target, the best grouping is 5 shots in one hand span, and that difference is attributed to differing zeros.
In my mind, the vertical string shouldn't change all that much. It should appear higher or lower on the target, yes. But the bullet should fall about the same distance as it traverses the distance between distance X and distance Y. Not exactly the same, because the trajectory is slightly different, but the end result should not be (in my brain) that any variation in zero should change group sizes at any distance.
I'm not denying that it seems to work. Some fairly respectable organizations seem to believe in it.
I'm just saying that it CAN'T work.
The best thing to do to understand zeroes for different distances is to get out there and shoot at varying distances. The bullet does not travel in a straight line. It travels in an arc. In relation to the sights on the gun, the barrel will be pointed up/down or parallel to the ground. The bullet will fall at a constant rate, that's a given, due to gravity. Remember that while we look through the sights to acquire a target and point the barrel to it, the bullet does not travel as our line of sight does; that's why at certain distances the bullet will cross the sights line at two points which may give the impression that the bullet "flies & rises" through the air. That's what drill sergeants said to us in basic. Of course we never argued. :'(
So in summary, we have a straight line (sights) and an arc (bullet path) that intersects to give us a reference point as to where our bullet will impact.
-
The part that I just refuse to believe is that, on one target, the best grouping is 3 shots in one hand span, while on another target, the best grouping is 5 shots in one hand span, and that difference is attributed to differing zeros.
I'm just saying that it CAN'T work.
If I can get my arse in gear, will post a few trajectory screenshots showing bullet flight path for a few of the zeros used in the video. If any of them are of particular interest, let me know and will make sure I use those for comparison. I'll use M855 at 2900 fps as the model cartridge.
-
The best thing to do to understand zeroes for different distances is to get out there and shoot at varying distances. The bullet does not travel in a straight line. It travels in an arc. In relation to the sights on the gun, the barrel will be pointed up/down or parallel to the ground. The bullet will fall at a constant rate, that's a given, due to gravity. Remember that while we look through the sights to acquire a target and point the barrel to it, the bullet does not travel as our line of sight does; that's why at certain distances the bullet will cross the sights line at two points which may give the impression that the bullet "flies & rises" through the air. That's what drill sergeants said to us in basic. Of course we never argued. :'(
So in summary, we have a straight line (sights) and an arc (bullet path) that intersects to give us a reference point as to where our bullet will impact.
All of which I understand, and none of which indicates why one zero gives superior grouping to another.
-
If I can get my arse in gear, will post a few trajectory screenshots showing bullet flight path for a few of the zeros used in the video. If any of them are of particular interest, let me know and will make sure I use those for comparison. I'll use M855 at 2900 fps as the model cartridge.
If it's all the same, use M2 ball, please!
-
All of which I understand, and none of which indicates why one zero gives superior grouping to another.
It is more a matter of distance. The farther you are from the target, the bigger your group will be. 1MOA at 100yards = 1 inch. 1MOA at 300 yards = 3 inches. That is under ideal conditions.
Zeroing at distance increases hit probability. A rifle zeroed for 100 yards will have less of a hit probability of hitting a target at 300 yards than a the same rifle zeroed at 300 yards. It is kinda built into the Rear sight of M16A2s/M4s. Ever wonder about the 8/3 (M16A2) or 6/3 (M4) settings on the elevation drum?
-
All of which I understand, and none of which indicates why one zero gives superior grouping to another.
From experience and from teachings of others, light can affect what we perceive as the target.
"Lights up, sights up; lights down, sights down" especially if I am shooting at bullseye targets which is all I ever shoot.
In the case with lighting conditions, groups will tend to string vertically because the target will appear bigger or smaller. An AllGuard shooter used my databook to demonstrate what he was seeing. The problem was very pronounced at the 600 yard line. I was vertically stringing all the way out to the 7 ring from a COM hold. THe light conditions varied greatly from shadey gray to full sunlight coming from 6 oclock as we were shooting mid day at about noon.
-
Zero's are definitely a choice of what you purpose is with the rifle, distances and acceptable hit zone sizes. I prefer the IBZ 50y/200m for my purposes because it has the flatest trajectory and remains within +/- 2.5" all the way out to around ~240yds. My next preference edged by a hair is the 100. I will also note that the 100y zero used by Paul Howe is really a modified 100y zero where he purposely offests his 100 yard zero by 3 inches. So it truly is not a 100y zero unless if you use his hold off technique.
Without trying to explain it some of the ballistic confusion, here is a video that may help.
AR15 Zero: Introduction (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Klvve0ZG_jo#ws)
This is another explanation on the topic by another top trainer especially in the AR/M4/M16 community and former Navy SEAL.
Point Blank Range (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VExUc6D6Re8#ws)
-
This thread is interesting. I shoot with irons cause can't afford a scope just yet but good to know this info.
I'm curious, does this apply for iron sights as well or only scopes?
-
This thread is interesting. I shoot with irons cause can't afford a scope just yet but good to know this info.
I'm curious, does this apply for iron sights as well or only scopes?
yes, same
-
If it's all the same, use M2 ball, please!
A .30 cal round? Will need BC and velocity of course.
For illumination of why the video had the results he got, standard milspec M855 or M193 are more appropriate as the trajectories will follow the hits he got.
-
Ok, here are approximations just to show the variation in bullet strike as a function of zero range. I used 2.5" sight height above the bore, which I believe is close to AR standard.
Point to observe is the variation in bullet strike above and below line of sight out to max range. That corresponds to the spread of hits you saw on the video. Not an exact match, but who knows what he was shooting, as well as differences in his sight height above the bore. Sorry about the pic size, but it does make it a bit easier to see detail. The difference the flatter trajectory of the light M193 is interesting if you did switch between rounds without option to re-zero.
Did not post the 200yd zero, as that is essentially the same as a 50yd zero.
25yd:
(http://i894.photobucket.com/albums/ac148/robtmc/25yd.jpg)
50yd:
(http://i894.photobucket.com/albums/ac148/robtmc/50yd.jpg)
100yd:
(http://i894.photobucket.com/albums/ac148/robtmc/100yd.jpg)
300yd:
(http://i894.photobucket.com/albums/ac148/robtmc/300yd.jpg)
-
Point to observe is the variation in bullet strike above and below line of sight out to max range. That corresponds to the spread of hits you saw on the video.
EUREKA!! It's using different portions of the curve!
Ok, guys, was it REALLY that hard for someone just to say "For Pete's sake, Tom, by changing the sighting range, you're rotating the graph of the function?"
Thanks, robtmc! Now, I will get you the data for the M2 ball, because I would really love to see how these graphs apply to my collection of WWII battle rifles.
-
Like I said with the 100 yard zero... pretty much getting like a 6-10" drop at 300 yards. One point of aim... just below the throat across the chest and you will hit center mass.
-
M2 ball:
150 gr bullet
.308" diameter
2805 fps at muzzle, 2740 fps @ 78 feet
BC is G8 type, .21
SD is .23
All data courtesy of the internet, and not guaranteed valid!
-
Can you measure the sight height above bore and say what zero ranges to look at, or the same as before? Don't want to spam the board with too much stuff. I am interested in how it compares to 7.62 NATO that I shoot.
-
Can you measure the sight height above bore and say what zero ranges to look at, or the same as before? Don't want to spam the board with too much stuff. I am interested in how it compares to 7.62 NATO that I shoot.
I'll try measure it tonight or tomorrow night, but it's just a blade attached to the barrel. Certainly less than 1". And the same zeroes as before would be lovely: 25, 50, 100, 200, 300.
Mahalo!!
-
Works for me. Rear aperture over bolt face is good for height too. It matters for accurate first crossing of sight line. AR types are more severe with the large over bore height they have, and optics can make it even more exaggerated.
I'll swag it at about an inch for iron sights, per what I found for the M1A at around .96 to 1.1". I can also do listed numbers if you want, maybe email them to you or whatever to avoid clutter.
-
Paul Howe, who is also pretty beastly, says 100 yard zero. In his demonstration, you drop the muzzle on target at mid chest /throat... and then at 300 yards you had a 6" drop... hitting still center mass
My point? I think the guns and ammo used here matter - and your mileage may vary.
I have a man-crush on Paul Howe. One old-school bad ass mofo.
-
Paul Howe is former ODD who was involved in Mogadishu right?
-
Paul Howe was 1st SFOD-D and was an instructor. He was also in Somalia and the Battle of Mogadishu in which "Blackhawk Down" was taken from. He is definitely an old school bad ass and a great guy to train under and just to shoot the shit with over a beer. He will also tell you that his preferred zero is a loli-pop and not a true zero and comes with some of its own twists that the user should be aware of.
-
I have no clue on his history. Just saw him in a few training videos. Loved his no bullshit demeanor.
Louis Awerbuck is another dude that's super badass. Sounds irritated and angry doing the videos.
-
I have no clue on his history. Just saw him in a few training videos. Loved his no bullshit demeanor.
Louis Awerbuck is another dude that's super badass. Sounds irritated and angry doing the videos.
Louis sounds like a zombie. Can't tell if he's got a pulse.
-
Paul Howe was 1st SFOD-D and was an instructor. He was also in Somalia and the Battle of Mogadishu in which "Blackhawk Down" was taken from. He is definitely an old school bad ass and a great guy to train under and just to shoot the shit with over a beer. He will also tell you that his preferred zero is a loli-pop and not a true zero and comes with some of its own twists that the user should be aware of.
Eric Bana's character in the movie Blackhawk Down was based off of Paul Howe.
As far as zero distance goes, I only have 200m to build my range without stepping into the livestock area, which could get me 300m but Id be shooting from the ditch next to the public highway. 200m zero gets my vote.
-
Louis sounds like a zombie. Can't tell if he's got a pulse.
Sounds like a distinct advantage in precision shooting! :thumbsup:
-
For those of you interested in zeroing at 200 yards/meters or even 300 yards/meters, are you using a magnified optic? Just wondering how you are getting decent/consistent enough groups to be certain that you are adjusting your groups properly? Are you just moving the "center of mass"?
I have all my ARs are zeroed at 50 yards for the 50/200ish zero. All of my ARs have red dots or just irons. I can get decent groupings at 50 yards enough to adjust with confidence. I will shoot groups at 100 yards, but I don't expect much from my 2 MOA dot and 3-4 MOA ammo. I've shot at 200 yards on rare occasion with my AR, but without a magnified scope, I wouldn't expect much more than groupings that would fit in say a 16" square (torso sized) box. Maybe a 12" square if I practiced a lot. At 300 yards, my 2 MOA dot would be 6" and I would expect my groups to be much larger than that!
I could see zeroing my bolt gun with a 4-16x50 scope beyond 100 yards, but I really don't see any practical reason to zero beyond 100 yards for an AR. Maybe for those of you shooting rifle marksmanship matches with your ARs with match grade or handloaded ammo.
-
For those of you interested in zeroing at 200 yards/meters or even 300 yards/meters, are you using a magnified optic? Just wondering how you are getting decent/consistent enough groups to be certain that you are adjusting your groups properly? Are you just moving the "center of mass"?
I have all my ARs are zeroed at 50 yards for the 50/200ish zero. All of my ARs have red dots or just irons. I can get decent groupings at 50 yards enough to adjust with confidence. I will shoot groups at 100 yards, but I don't expect much from my 2 MOA dot and 3-4 MOA ammo. I've shot at 200 yards on rare occasion with my AR, but without a magnified scope, I wouldn't expect much more than groupings that would fit in say a 16" square (torso sized) box. Maybe a 12" square if I practiced a lot. At 300 yards, my 2 MOA dot would be 6" and I would expect my groups to be much larger than that!
I could see zeroing my bolt gun with a 4-16x50 scope beyond 100 yards, but I really don't see any practical reason to zero beyond 100 yards for an AR. Maybe for those of you shooting rifle marksmanship matches with your ARs with match grade or handloaded ammo.
If you know where you are at 100 or 50 you should be able to get a zero at 200.
FWIW, I have experienced shooters that are within MOA at 200 and 300 with irons
-
I've held a MOA at 600 using irons a while back...it'll take a lot of practice to get there again, though......
-
Eric Bana's character in the movie Blackhawk Down was based off of Paul Howe.
As far as zero distance goes, I only have 200m to build my range without stepping into the livestock area, which could get me 300m but Id be shooting from the ditch next to the public highway. 200m zero gets my vote.
200m is a rock solid zero as it is pretty much the Improved Battlesight Zero 50y/200m.
For those of you interested in zeroing at 200 yards/meters or even 300 yards/meters, are you using a magnified optic? Just wondering how you are getting decent/consistent enough groups to be certain that you are adjusting your groups properly? Are you just moving the "center of mass"?
I have all my ARs are zeroed at 50 yards for the 50/200ish zero. All of my ARs have red dots or just irons. I can get decent groupings at 50 yards enough to adjust with confidence. I will shoot groups at 100 yards, but I don't expect much from my 2 MOA dot and 3-4 MOA ammo. I've shot at 200 yards on rare occasion with my AR, but without a magnified scope, I wouldn't expect much more than groupings that would fit in say a 16" square (torso sized) box. Maybe a 12" square if I practiced a lot. At 300 yards, my 2 MOA dot would be 6" and I would expect my groups to be much larger than that!
I could see zeroing my bolt gun with a 4-16x50 scope beyond 100 yards, but I really don't see any practical reason to zero beyond 100 yards for an AR. Maybe for those of you shooting rifle marksmanship matches with your ARs with match grade or handloaded ammo.
As mentioned above the 200m zero is where you get picky on point of impact but it is also easily verified at 50 yards for groups. The same goes for the 25/300. The only differences is where you are getting the most picky on your group, either the first crossing of line of sight or the outer crossing. If you zero at 25 or 50 there is a bit of a variance at the outer crossing of line of sight. So in reality when you zero for groups at the outer crossing of the LOS your first crossing will show a lesser identifiable variation due to the closer distance.
-
I've held a MOA at 600 using irons a while back...it'll take a lot of practice to get there again, though......
When you say MOA at 600 yards, I assume that you mean keeping to a maximum grouping of 6 inches. Not surprised and like you said, it takes a lot of practice and discipline. I'd honestly be happy with a 6 inch group at 200 yards.
If you know where you are at 100 or 50 you should be able to get a zero at 200.
FWIW, I have experienced shooters that are within MOA at 200 and 300 with irons
Yes. With my chosen zero of 50 yards, I know I will be about an inch low at 25 yards, POA/POI at 50 yards, about 2 inches high at 100 yards and back to about POA/POI at about 200 meters or so. My typical procedure to zero is to shoot 3 round groups at 50 yards from a rest or Lead Sled and adjust accordingly. I will shoot a couple of 5 round groups at 50 yards to confirm the zero and hoping to keep my groups to less than an inch for some level of confidence. After that, I will shoot the metal targets at about 240 yards to "confirm". I am basically confirming zero at 200 yards (or really should be 200 meters), but I still consider that a 50 yard zero.
On the rare occasion that I've had access to a 200 yard range, I've shot groups at 200 yards to confirm zero. But at that range, I am just verifying that I am in the general vicinity and am generally happy with a 8" group or even ok with out to 12" groups. I just can't see the target with enough definition to say that I am putting the red dot back on the same spot to begin with without magnification. I could use the method of putting the POA on top of the dot, but I generally don't since I am not expecting to be that precise anyways.
As mentioned above the 200m zero is where you get picky on point of impact but it is also easily verified at 50 yards for groups. The same goes for the 25/300. The only differences is where you are getting the most picky on your group, either the first crossing of line of sight or the outer crossing. If you zero at 25 or 50 there is a bit of a variance at the outer crossing of line of sight. So in reality when you zero for groups at the outer crossing of the LOS your first crossing will show a lesser identifiable variation due to the closer distance.
I understand the 50yard/200meter and 25yard/300yard zeros (or there abouts depending on your chosen load, projectile weight, etc). As mentioned above, I personally zero to 50 yards and the groups shot at 200 yards (or 200 meters) are to confirm. I can see how refining the zero at 200 yards (or the second crossing) would help further refine the first crossing. However, I just don't feel that I am consistent enough at 200 yards to have much confidence that adjusting the zero at that that distance based on the larger group sizing that I get at those ranges. I think a magnified optic would help in that regard. And yes, I do very much need to practice.
The reason why I asked is that I've heard of precision shooters zeroing their guns anywhere from 200 yards out to 600 yards and even further. However, they are typically doing so with magnified optics to zero their guns. I guess my point is that I didn't think anyone would be really zeroing their 16" barrelled ARs (5.56/.223) at 200 yards, let alone 300 yards, which is what the video in the OP was about. I can see if you're talking larger calibers with magnified optics, but not 5.56/.223 with unmagnified red dots. Again, I am not saying that it's not possible, but just didn't think it was practical.
-
Not sure of what you are asking but it depends on why you are shooting. I have zeroes at 100, 200, 300 and 600 for the game I shoot in. To add, zeroes are just a baseline and from what very experienced shooters told me, it changes. Ammo, weather, how the moon aligns with the planet etc.
-
Not sure of what you are asking but it depends on why you are shooting. I have zeroes at 100, 200, 300 and 600 for the game I shoot in. To add, zeroes are just a baseline and from what very experienced shooters told me, it changes. Ammo, weather, how the moon aligns with the planet etc.
The OP is "Zero at Distance" with a link to a portion of Travis Haley's Adaptive Carbine: Zero at Distance. So I assumed the OP was referring to what distance you zero your AR15/M4 type gun. Then there were some who mentioned wanting to zero their gun at 200 yards or even 300 yards and I am wondering 1) are people really zeroing their AR15/M4 at 200 or 300, or are they doing the 50/200 or 25/300 zero, and 2) if they are zeroing their guns at 200 or 300 yards are they using a magnified optic to do so because the margin for error of doing so with unmagnified red dot or irons is pretty significant such that how could you adjust your zero with confidence at 200 or 300 yards.
On the rare occasion that I can shoot on paper at 200 yards, I will readily admit that I am not that consistent, particularly when shooting from prone with a mag-monopod. Even from a bench, I am not sure I could put my red dot or irons back on the target consistently enough at 200 or 300 to expect a group that I could say with some level of confidence that my adjustments to windage or elevation are helping anything.
However, If the discussion is intended for all rifles, like precision or hunting bolt guns, then yes, I can see zeroing at anywhere from 50 yards out to 600 yards or as far as the range you have access to can go depending on your intended application (like you said).
-
The OP is "Zero at Distance" with a link to a portion of Travis Haley's Adaptive Carbine: Zero at Distance. So I assumed the OP was referring to what distance you zero your AR15/M4 type gun. Then there were some who mentioned wanting to zero their gun at 200 yards or even 300 yards and I am wondering 1) are people really zeroing their AR15/M4 at 200 or 300, or are they doing the 50/200 or 25/300 zero, and 2) if they are zeroing their guns at 200 or 300 yards are they using a magnified optic to do so because the margin for error of doing so with unmagnified red dot or irons is pretty significant such that how could you adjust your zero with confidence at 200 or 300 yards.
On the rare occasion that I can shoot on paper at 200 yards, I will readily admit that I am not that consistent, particularly when shooting from prone with a mag-monopod. Even from a bench, I am not sure I could put my red dot or irons back on the target consistently enough at 200 or 300 to expect a group that I could say with some level of confidence that my adjustments to windage or elevation are helping anything.
However, If the discussion is intended for all rifles, like precision or hunting bolt guns, then yes, I can see zeroing at anywhere from 50 yards out to 600 yards or as far as the range you have access to can go depending on your intended application (like you said).
You could always go with the trick my dad preferred for hunting rifles back before he cleared out a 400-yard range and we were limited to 100: zero x.xx" high at 100. We used an inch at 100, but there's no reason you can't look up the values in a ballistic calculator and just mathematically zero for 300 yards on a 100 yard target. For example: you put in the data for a 300 yard zero using the load data of your choice. You see that according to the maths, you'll be 2" high at 100 yards. Then you head over to Koko Head and zero your rifle 2" high at 100 yards, and presto! -300 yard zero (give or take the accuracy of the computations and data input to the ballistic program). As long as you're on the paper/steel at 300 often enough to make you happy, your zero is good to go. (Plus, this'll save you 400 yards of walking every time you have to check the target!)
The advantage to this method is that at 100 yards, your groups should be small enough that you can move them around the paper by adjusting your sights. All that's left to do is take some shots at 300 yards to verify, and at that point you can say, "Yes, my zero is valid" or "Nope, back to the drawing board for a different drop chart." That way you don't have worry about the group size at three hundred.
-
You could always go with the trick my dad preferred for hunting rifles back before he cleared out a 400-yard range and we were limited to 100: zero x.xx" high at 100. We used an inch at 100, but there's no reason you can't look up the values in a ballistic calculator and just mathematically zero for 300 yards on a 100 yard target. For example: you put in the data for a 300 yard zero using the load data of your choice. You see that according to the maths, you'll be 2" high at 100 yards. Then you head over to Koko Head and zero your rifle 2" high at 100 yards, and presto! -300 yard zero (give or take the accuracy of the computations and data input to the ballistic program). As long as you're on the paper/steel at 300 often enough to make you happy, your zero is good to go. (Plus, this'll save you 400 yards of walking every time you have to check the target!)
The advantage to this method is that at 100 yards, your groups should be small enough that you can move them around the paper by adjusting your sights. All that's left to do is take some shots at 300 yards to verify, and at that point you can say, "Yes, my zero is valid" or "Nope, back to the drawing board for a different drop chart." That way you don't have worry about the group size at three hundred.
That's what I was getting at. At 50 yard or 100 yards, my groups are small enough that I can adjust and be confident that I am adjusting the gun and not making up for my tendencies. Beyond that, I am not sure if it's the sights that are being adjusted or if I am just throwing the rounds off myself. Probably a little bit of both.
Regarding the X.XX" offset based on calculated ballistics, I understand that concept. In a recent class, the preferred zero was a 50yard/200meter zero. But we started at the 25 yard mark and set our POA about an inch over the POI and did a rough zero from there before moving back to 50 yards. I believe that is done often where someone may be limited to a max range of say 25 yards. They also have targets with the offsets specifically for those applications, even the military has those as well. That said, you are really zeroing at say 50 yards with an approximation at 200 meters. As opposed to truly zeroing at 200 meters (or 200 yards, or whatever chosen distance).
I was just thinking about those who said that they wished that they had 200 or even 300 yard ranges to zero at. When like you said, you can get it close enough with a 50 or 100 yard range to know, wish some level of confidence, that you will be POA/POI at a distance beyond the range's maximum for target stands.
-
We shoot at 200,300 and 600 yards monthly at Puuloa. I just shot the full course this past weekend. I've cleaned the 200 and 300 targets a few times. I'm an average shooter. I scored for an All Guard shooter who shot a perfect 10x at 200 yards, rapid fire sitting. The X ring measures 3 " and we were shooting irons. Before optics thats how they did it and at greater distances. Optics don't make a bad shooter better. Practice makes a bad shooter better. The key to getting tight groups is focusing on that front sight - no matter how big or small.
Just like waking up in the morning, making coffee, putting on your clothes and driving to work; when you do it so many times you will get good groups that you can read eventually.
I on the other hand am a slow learner :-\
Come out and shoot www.puuloa.com (http://www.puuloa.com)
I admit it is a lot of work, it is hot, there is no shade and then you take your shot.
-
We shoot at 200,300 and 600 yards monthly at Puuloa. I just shot the full course this past weekend. I've cleaned the 200 and 300 targets a few times. I'm an average shooter. I scored for an All Guard shooter who shot a perfect 10x at 200 yards, rapid fire sitting. The X ring measures 3 " and we were shooting irons. Before optics thats how they did it and at greater distances. Optics don't make a bad shooter better. Practice makes a bad shooter better. The key to getting tight groups is focusing on that front sight - no matter how big or small.
Just like waking up in the morning, making coffee, putting on your clothes and driving to work; when you do it so many times you will get good groups that you can read eventually.
I on the other hand am a slow learner :-\
Come out and shoot www.puuloa.com (http://www.puuloa.com)
I admit it is a lot of work, it is hot, there is no shade and then you take your shot.
I've actually been meaning to go out there for a shoot for a while. I just have so much going on with shooting (USPSA, Koko Head, Schofield) and other stuff. I emailed a guy a while back and was planning on taking my .308 out there for a test run. At one point, I was even thinking of putting together an AR for the service rifle class. Something like the BCM's AR rifle.
I have no doubt that there are many excellent shooters who can do really well with irons. Practice and discipline are a must for sure.
I'll eventually get my arse out there to Puuloa. :thumbsup:
-
I've actually been meaning to go out there for a shoot for a while. I just have so much going on with shooting (USPSA, Koko Head, Schofield) and other stuff. I emailed a guy a while back and was planning on taking my .308 out there for a test run. At one point, I was even thinking of putting together an AR for the service rifle class. Something like the BCM's AR rifle.
I have no doubt that there are many excellent shooters who can do really well with irons. Practice and discipline are a must for sure.
I'll eventually get my arse out there to Puuloa. :thumbsup:
I just joined Schofield as well, the drive and crowd at Kokohead is getting insane :shake:
-
I just joined Schofield as well, the drive and crowd at Kokohead is getting insane :shake:
Awesome! I'm an RSO out there. Only one range day for this month though. :(
But, it's on KR3, which is the long range one. I am not sure if I can make it out there this weekend though. Hopefully I'll run into you sometime out there.
-
Awesome! I'm an RSO out there. Only one range day for this month though. :(
But, it's on KR3, which is the long range one. I am not sure if I can make it out there this weekend though. Hopefully I'll run into you sometime out there.
I got drill this weekend - we are doing unit quals at 25m :(
-
thanks for the link
I wish I could do more than just zero at 50 or 100
-
I understand the 50yard/200meter and 25yard/300yard zeros (or there abouts depending on your chosen load, projectile weight, etc). As mentioned above, I personally zero to 50 yards and the groups shot at 200 yards (or 200 meters) are to confirm. I can see how refining the zero at 200 yards (or the second crossing) would help further refine the first crossing. However, I just don't feel that I am consistent enough at 200 yards to have much confidence that adjusting the zero at that that distance based on the larger group sizing that I get at those ranges. I think a magnified optic would help in that regard. And yes, I do very much need to practice.
The reason why I asked is that I've heard of precision shooters zeroing their guns anywhere from 200 yards out to 600 yards and even further. However, they are typically doing so with magnified optics to zero their guns. I guess my point is that I didn't think anyone would be really zeroing their 16" barrelled ARs (5.56/.223) at 200 yards, let alone 300 yards, which is what the video in the OP was about. I can see if you're talking larger calibers with magnified optics, but not 5.56/.223 with unmagnified red dots. Again, I am not saying that it's not possible, but just didn't think it was practical.
I think your onto it and I agree with what you are saying. In reality for your average shooter with iron sights, or a non-magnified optic, it is really hard to tell any appreciable differences at 200 or beyond. In other words the 50y/200m or 25/300 are good workable numbers. And you are correct in that a rifle capable of holding MOA or less and a good shooter, then getting more picky about your zero comes into play. A different powder load, bullet type, bullet weight, etc, etc can change a bullets trajectory, so as an example to assume that any .223 / 5.56 is going to be a 50y/200m projectile is not technically correct and this will show in a precision set up. Now if you are only aiming for perhaps an 8" sized hit zone, that you deem to be acceptable accuracy then again the generic 50y/200m or 25/300 is going to be workable. I will however add that with the 25 / 300 a shooter really needs to confirm the outer 300 and not just rely on the 25 hits. There is too narrow of a margin to just rely on the 25 zero to be accurate at 300.
-
I think your onto it and I agree with what you are saying. In reality for your average shooter with iron sights, or a non-magnified optic, it is really hard to tell any appreciable differences at 200 or beyond. In other words the 50y/200m or 25/300 are good workable numbers. And you are correct in that a rifle capable of holding MOA or less and a good shooter, then getting more picky about your zero comes into play. A different powder load, bullet type, bullet weight, etc, etc can change a bullets trajectory, so as an example to assume that any .223 / 5.56 is going to be a 50y/200m projectile is not technically correct and this will show in a precision set up. Now if you are only aiming for perhaps an 8" sized hit zone, that you deem to be acceptable accuracy then again the generic 50y/200m or 25/300 is going to be workable. I will however add that with the 25 / 300 a shooter really needs to confirm the outer 300 and not just rely on the 25 hits. There is too narrow of a margin to just rely on the 25 zero to be accurate at 300.
Yeah, that's pretty much what I was getting at. I am positive my two primary guns are capable of holding MOA, but my ammo isn't. That's my story and I'm sticking to it. Haha.
This came up since I took a basic carbine course with Redback One last month and I have to admit that I was humbled when we shot prone at 200 yards. It's not something that I get to do very often at all, but I thought I would be just fine. Yes, you're adding some level of stress and some fatigue (it was near the end of TD1), but I still thought I would shoot better than I did.
Excellent point on the 25/300 and margin for error on zeroing at 25. I should probably do more confirming at 200 with my 50y/200m zero, but we just don't have that many options for that here unfortunately.
-
Awesome! I'm an RSO out there. Only one range day for this month though. :(
But, it's on KR3, which is the long range one. I am not sure if I can make it out there this weekend though. Hopefully I'll run into you sometime out there.
Someone still has to step up to RSO this one. Gus has OIC, but no RSO. Same old people have been volunteering so I've been cutting back on my volunteering to force others to step up. That and it's been crazy busy at work.
-
I just joined Schofield as well, the drive and crowd at Kokohead is getting insane :shake:
Nice. I'll need to get out and let you shoot my stuff when we get KR-3 next (not this week, I'm actually playing golf for the first time in like 6 months). You'll dig KR-3, but it's funky. For some reason my range finder has a hard time pulling distances past 200 yards out there. Other places I shoot 700 yards and the distance comes up OK. I don't know what it is about that range.
-
Someone still has to step up to RSO this one. Gus has OIC, but no RSO. Same old people have been volunteering so I've been cutting back on my volunteering to force others to step up. That and it's been crazy busy at work.
I hear you. I just joined earlier this year and I've already RSO'ed twice for CR2.
I spoke to Gus yesterday that if he was an RSO short and could have to cancel the range that I would be available, but something else came up for Sunday.
I want to shoot as well, but I've told Phil many times that if I am free to shoot and he's an RSO short, that I would RSO so that the range could open. I would then hope that others would offer the same just to keep things going.
-
Right, and obvious. Let's do a "what if"
You put your rifle in a vise, and align it parallel to the ground. Then, using a delicate digital level, you incline it 5 degrees. you fire a round. A sophisticated tracking system records the flight of the projectile. it notes, amongst all the other data it records, that between the distances of 400 and 500 yards, the bulled drops exactly 4", from a height of 6' to 5'8".
Now you increase the tilt by 1 degree, to 6 degrees above horizontal. You fire again. Obviously the point of impact changes at virtually every point along the flight path. But between 400 and 500 yards, the bullet will still fall by about 4". Not exactly, but pretty close. Admittedly that drop is now happening at a different height, let's say from 7' to 6"8(ish)".
Right?
So why doesn't that matter?
no. if you tilt your rifle more up, you introduce more vertical velocity. so the bullet will travel up slightly, before it starts its fall. so not only is it shooting higher, but it's dropping later as it has to wait for gravity to overcome the initial velocity.