2aHawaii
Tools and Uses => Firearms and Accessories => Topic started by: dirsh on October 21, 2012, 05:43:22 PM
-
I was told that's what I should use for home defense
-
Not to be a jerk, but who gave you that advice
-
What HPD uses is not optimal. Come by and talk to Brian about what is good.
-
Zmax? Lol
I was told that if you ever have to explain it in court, it would be best to use the same rounds that have been tested and deemed appropriate for pd stopping power
-
Btw dex I got the hornady tap from you guys for my 45
I hear that's some good stuff
-
TAP is good. Thats what a lot of our off duty customers buy.
-
Not to be a jerk, but who gave you that advice
IIRC, Mass Ayoob has mentioned that as being a good idea. The line of reasoning is that it takes away the prosecutor's ability to paint you as a bloodthirsty killer.
Overzealous Assistant DA: "Mr. Cougar, why in the world would anyone need ammunition that is 'designed to reliably expand on impact with soft tissue, causing rapid incapacitation; even through light barricades and heavy clothing'? YOU BOUGHT THAT AMMUNITION FOR ONE REASON: TO KILL PEOPLE, DID YOU NOT?"
Me: "Well, sir, the local police department has determined that particular ammunition to be suitable for protecting the lives of their officers and citizens, so I figured if it was good enough for them, it'd be good enough for me."
It's debatable whether or not you'd find yourself in a situation like that, but this is a state that thinks teflon-coated ammunition is so evil it should be banned. In my humble opinion, you're giving the DA a lot more rope to hang you with if you're using handloads in your defensive guns.
-
Not to be a jerk, but who gave you that advice
It is solid advice from a legal perspective. It's right in line with it is better to not use hand loads, or severely modified pistols ("Hair trigger arguments" etc.). The problem here, is our Officers don't use really good ammo :).
-
I think they use Speer Gold Dots
-
Not to be a jerk, but who gave you that advice
I hate to post the person's name who I heard it from. Instead I will just say that when my other half and I did a handgun safety class to obtain our affidavit at a certain indoor gun range when it came do home defense or self-defense ammunition he made the exact same statement and the exact same argument posted above. That instructor was IMHO a good instructor in that he emphasized the importance of being able to shoot one handed and weak hand in home defense situations. So I too always wondered what brand and type of rounds HPD used but just never asked.
-
My uncles aunties co workers boyfriends 2nd cousin? Got it.
Many interesting posts to take note of. Guess they can't say you got cop killer hollow points if you shooting the same thing as the cops.
On another note I heard the sane thing about not doing any modifications to your self defense gun cause that would be more to use against you in the court of law should you ever find yourself there.
-
It is solid advice from a legal perspective. It's right in line with it is better to not use hand loads, or severely modified pistols ("Hair trigger arguments" etc.). The problem here, is our Officers don't use really good ammo :).
Huh. I was under the impression that Speer Gold Dots were pretty decent ammo..
-
I hate to post the person's name who I heard it from. Instead I will just say that when my other half and I did a handgun safety class to obtain our affidavit at a certain indoor gun range when it came do home defense or self-defense ammunition he made the exact same statement and the exact same argument posted above. That instructor was IMHO a good instructor in that he emphasized the importance of being able to shoot one handed and weak hand in home defense situations. So I too always wondered what brand and type of rounds HPD used but just never asked.
got the info from the same guy when taking my carbine class. I just can't find my notes. I think i'm just going to ask him again.
btw found this while searching for legal issues of using zombie ammo. thought it was cool
(http://i699.photobucket.com/albums/vv360/wolfganggross/cutaway17-5-22-12/cutaway17-5-22-12068.jpg)
Just wanted to show the differences between the 7.62x39mm Hornaday Zombie Max 123gr next to the Hornaday V Max 123gr, Both are noncorrosive, berdan primed, polymer coated steel case.
One has ball powder, while the other has stick, and the jacket on the Zombie is twice as thick. wolfgang
-
Can the average gun handle repeated use of zombie ammo looks like the powder is more powerful. Does the jacket also increase the bullet weight?
-
Can the average gun handle repeated use of zombie ammo looks like the powder is more powerful. Does the jacket also increase the bullet weight?
So long as the ammo is loaded to standard specs, then yes to repeated usage. Don't be fooled by what the powder looks like....the looks don't necessarily correspond with pressure. Other things contribute such as how fast the powder burns, if the load is compressed or not, if the bullet is sitting on the lands when loaded, etc.
-
Who has the zombie ammo for the lowest price? Might grab a box of .30-.30 incase the zombies invade
-
Can the average gun handle repeated use of zombie ammo looks like the powder is more powerful. Does the jacket also increase the bullet weight?
Looks like the powder in the zombie ammo will burn slower, because the particles are much bigger. The V-Max, being small little ball powder, looks like it'll burn quicker and hotter. If one had a little bit of the stick powder, and one had a bunch of the ball powder, I'd be concerned.
-
Handgun. Speer Gold Dot. Some of the best defensive ammo on the market today.
.223 Federal TRU 55gr Hi-Shok SP.
-
https://pnn.s3.amazonaws.com/media_files/docs/12980-f6100edfdec9c2c2713d0254d8eb8470905b62b3868d2c36930440d3.pdf
This has all the equipment HPD bought for APEC and stuff.
American Eagle AE9AP for training;
Speer Gold Dot 9mm 124gr LE 53618 for service.
-
Looks like the powder in the zombie ammo will burn slower, because the particles are much bigger. The V-Max, being small little ball powder, looks like it'll burn quicker and hotter. If one had a little bit of the stick powder, and one had a bunch of the ball powder, I'd be concerned.
This. Also, I'd wager that the Z-Max bullet is actually lighter, due to the thicker jacket. Copper being lighter than lead, the zombie bullet with a higher ratio of copper:lead would seem to be lighter. That's a SWAG (scientific wild-ass guess), of course.
-
That's a SWAG (scientific wild-ass guess), of course.
Right. The new kids' definition of "swag" is wrong and stupid :grrr:
-
Right. The new kids' definition of "swag" is wrong and stupid :grrr:
Agreed!
(http://almostdumb.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/place-fist-here-bro.jpg)
-
Agreed!
(http://almostdumb.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/place-fist-here-bro.jpg)
*fistbump*
-
I just had a co-workers wife buy a pistol at a LGS and they made a big deal to them about the Gold Dots being what HPD used. I agreed it was decent ammo but not necessarily the best, especially paying about $10 more than OGC for a 20 box.
The couple was sold on the "HPD bullet" like it was some kind of super bullet. Im also still disappointed this LGS sold them a subcompact XD for a home defense weapon AND charged a good $125 more than other shops :crazy:
Fools and their money.....
-
I could really care less what peoples opinion is on HPD and what rounds they use. Having said that, Speer Gold Dot is not just "average" or "decent" ammo, it is some of THE best and often arguably the top 2 or 3 in defensive ammo on the market today. I have no ties with Speer but with the numerous ballistics courses that I have attended and conducted on my own, even courses held by different companies and direct competitors, time and time again shows who the top contenders are and Gold Dots are in the top of the top. It really is so close that the top 3 or 4 in pistol selection show no major differences. So flip a coin, it is that close with the top contenders.
-
I could really care less what peoples opinion is on HPD and what rounds they use. Having said that, Speer Gold Dot is not just "average" or "decent" ammo, it is some of THE best and often arguably the top 2 or 3 in defensive ammo on the market today. I have no ties with Speer but with the numerous ballistics courses that I have attended and conducted on my own, even courses held by different companies and direct competitors, time and time again shows who the top contenders are and Gold Dots are in the top of the top. It really is so close that the top 3 or 4 in pistol selection show no major differences. So flip a coin, it is that close with the top contenders.
Just to clarify, in case some of that was re: me, I actually just questioned the city spending lots of money on good ammo. I have no questions about the quality of the ammo at all (in terms of speer). I just wouldn't put it past the city to not give all of our officers great ammunition is all.
-
Just to clarify, in case some of that was re: me, I actually just questioned the city spending lots of money on good ammo. I have no questions about the quality of the ammo at all (in terms of speer). I just wouldn't put it past the city to not give all of our officers great ammunition is all.
It was more to clarify that Speer Gold Dot is great ammunition which some seemed to elude to it not being good ammo or that the HPD does not use great ammo and Speer Gold Dots are top notch. I will however concede that their current .223 choice is not optimal IMO, even though it has worked in the documented incidents as of this time. The .308 and .50BMG are top notch choices. As for the City, they do not really have much input on the ammo types, but budgets all come from the City that the HPD obviously has to manage or work with in house. I will however say that one certain gun shop owner FORCED the City into purchasing some absolute CRAP duty ammunition for a particular unit. I really shouldn't say forced, maybe swindled or deceived the City into accepting a certain CRAP ammo. Fortunately there will be no more dealings with that individual and that shop is no longer open, at least under previous ownership. This mistake occurred once and decisions were made by people who had no expertise or no business making those decisions. Fortunately I believe that mistake has been remedied and hopefully it will not happen again in the future.
Not that there is necessarily any confusion, but the Federal AEP is practice ammunition only.
-
revival.
why doesn't hpd use lawman 124 instead of the fed?