2aHawaii

General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: eyeeatingfish on April 21, 2023, 10:25:31 PM

Title: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on April 21, 2023, 10:25:31 PM
I have been loosely following this story and I have generally supported him in past when he was accused of doing something wrong. However this new developing story that he has received large gifts for years without disclosing them is one I am having a hard time justifying. I have no problem with Thomas having a rich friend who treats him to nice things, as long as the friend does not directly or indirectly become party or beneficiary of a case that goes before the court. What does bother me is the failure to declare these gifts. It is not clear whether his failure to disclose constitutes a legal violation or just an ethical violation.

I really don't want to lose a conservative seat on the supreme court but this is not looking good for him.
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 21, 2023, 11:06:08 PM
I have been loosely following this story and I have generally supported him in past when he was accused of doing something wrong. However this new developing story that he has received large gifts for years without disclosing them is one I am having a hard time justifying. I have no problem with Thomas having a rich friend who treats him to nice things, as long as the friend does not directly or indirectly become party or beneficiary of a case that goes before the court. What does bother me is the failure to declare these gifts. It is not clear whether his failure to disclose constitutes a legal violation or just an ethical violation.

I really don't want to lose a conservative seat on the supreme court but this is not looking good for him.

It's not a legal violation.  Gifts in the form of "personal hospitality" were not listed in the disclosure rules until last month.  Whether or not the trips should have been disclosed is now in question.  Adding the specific case for "personal hospitality" demonstrates there was no such requirement before last month.  The confusion, ambiguity or question as to that type of gift needing to be disclosed should be enough to shield Thomas (and all the Justices) from impeachment on these grounds.

There's no real means of enforcing these rules for the SCOTUS.  Unlike every other government branch or judicial court, SCOTUS has no stated code of ethics.  That leaves the analysis of what's unethical up to Congress who has the power to codify this practice.

Only one Justice has ever been impeached:  Samuel Chase, in 1804-05, but he was acquitted in the Senate.

Democrats need to stop the Scorched Earth tactics they've been employing since Trump was elected.  It's not enough to smear their opponents in hopes they lose an election.  now they want them impeached, kicked out of office, banned from all government service, and/or thrown in prison.

This is what you call "extreme," even though they like to pretend it's Republicans who are the extremists.
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: hvybarrels on April 22, 2023, 06:44:41 AM
After the witch hunts come the Stalinist purges
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: QUIETShooter on April 22, 2023, 07:28:04 AM
After the witch hunts come the Stalinist purges

Yeah, this looks like a typical demorat witch hunt in my opinion.
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 22, 2023, 08:09:31 AM
The fact that ur questioning this shows their tactic is working.

Wait till another "violation" is created that targets only certain appointed judges.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 22, 2023, 08:10:35 AM
It's not a legal violation.  Gifts in the form of "personal hospitality" were not listed in the disclosure rules until last month.  Whether or not the trips should have been disclosed is now in question.  Adding the specific case for "personal hospitality" demonstrates there was no such requirement before last month.  The confusion, ambiguity or question as to that type of gift needing to be disclosed should be enough to shield Thomas (and all the Justices) from impeachment on these grounds.

There's no real means of enforcing these rules for the SCOTUS.  Unlike every other government branch or judicial court, SCOTUS has no stated code of ethics.  That leaves the analysis of what's unethical up to Congress who has the power to codify this practice.

Only one Justice has ever been impeached:  Samuel Chase, in 1804-05, but he was acquitted in the Senate.

Democrats need to stop the Scorched Earth tactics they've been employing since Trump was elected.  It's not enough to smear their opponents in hopes they lose an election.  now they want them impeached, kicked out of office, banned from all government service, and/or thrown in prison.

This is what you call "extreme," even though they like to pretend it's Republicans who are the extremists.
They wont stop until they get what they want. This is why the GOP is on the losing end.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: QUIETShooter on April 22, 2023, 09:46:37 AM
Eliminate all opposition.

By whatever means possible.

This is their agenda.  No objectivity involved.  Over everything else. 

Even legality.
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: mrgaf on April 22, 2023, 11:09:45 AM
Eliminate all opposition.

By whatever means possible.

This is their agenda.  No objectivity involved.  Over everything else. 

Even legality.

We need to eliminate “them” by whatever means possible. Time for a purge! :D
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on April 22, 2023, 11:39:29 PM
It's not a legal violation.  Gifts in the form of "personal hospitality" were not listed in the disclosure rules until last month.  Whether or not the trips should have been disclosed is now in question.  Adding the specific case for "personal hospitality" demonstrates there was no such requirement before last month.  The confusion, ambiguity or question as to that type of gift needing to be disclosed should be enough to shield Thomas (and all the Justices) from impeachment on these grounds.

There's no real means of enforcing these rules for the SCOTUS.  Unlike every other government branch or judicial court, SCOTUS has no stated code of ethics.  That leaves the analysis of what's unethical up to Congress who has the power to codify this practice.

Only one Justice has ever been impeached:  Samuel Chase, in 1804-05, but he was acquitted in the Senate.

Democrats need to stop the Scorched Earth tactics they've been employing since Trump was elected.  It's not enough to smear their opponents in hopes they lose an election.  now they want them impeached, kicked out of office, banned from all government service, and/or thrown in prison.

This is what you call "extreme," even though they like to pretend it's Republicans who are the extremists.

I would really need to sit down and look at the specific laws and ethical regulations to say for certain whether this constitutes any actual violation. However, even if he skated around any actual rule violations, this still makes me uncomfortable when being done by someone on the highest court in the land. I think judges should try to live above reproach and this just seems like it would be something he should have declared without having to be told to declare it by some law. The appearance of impropriety is bad even if there is no actual impropriety.

Remember when the former Honolulu police chief bought a motorcycle from the store that was awarded the contract to sell multiple ATVs to the police department? There may have been no quid pro quo and she may have paid standard market price for the motorcycle but it still looks bad and shouldn't have been done in my opinion.
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on April 22, 2023, 11:42:20 PM
The fact that ur questioning this shows their tactic is working.

Wait till another "violation" is created that targets only certain appointed judges.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

They are grasping at smoke in the air most of the time but every once in a while they grab onto something tangible. When they do I think we should concede otherwise we lack integrity.
Just as how they never want to give Trump credit for anything good, if we don't give Trump any criticism for anything bad then we are no different than them. (Not making it about Turmp, just using that as an example)
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 22, 2023, 11:52:02 PM
I would really need to sit down and look at the specific laws and ethical regulations to say for certain whether this constitutes any actual violation. However, even if he skated around any actual rule violations, this still makes me uncomfortable when being done by someone on the highest court in the land. I think judges should try to live above reproach and this just seems like it would be something he should have declared without having to be told to declare it by some law. The appearance of impropriety is bad even if there is no actual impropriety.

Remember when the former Honolulu police chief bought a motorcycle from the store that was awarded the contract to sell multiple ATVs to the police department? There may have been no quid pro quo and she may have paid standard market price for the motorcycle but it still looks bad and shouldn't have been done in my opinion.

It's not that complicated.

The impeachment process for a justice is the same as a president.  The House votes on whether to impeach based on the allegations.  They send the articles of impeachment to the Senate, and the Senate holds a trial.

Given that Thomas is the most conservative member of the court and the House is under Republican control, it's more likely than not that any calls for his impeachment will be voted down.

The same people were screaming for Kavanaugh to be impeached as well.  Even with control of the House, they couldn't impeach.

Quote
Several Democratic presidential hopefuls are calling for the impeachment of Supreme
Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh after a new book provided unreported details of an incident
of alleged sexual misconduct while he was a student at Yale.

Because justices receive lifetime appointments, removing one is harder than just calling up
someone and firing them. In order to remove one, you have to impeach them.

The process is the same as impeaching the president of the United States. The House of
Representatives would vote on whether to impeach the justice in question. If the justice is
impeached, there would be a Senate trial.

The House needs only a simple majority to impeach a Supreme Court justice or any federal
judge. To convict and then remove the justice or judge, the Senate requires a two-thirds majority.
https://www.cnn.com/2019/09/16/politics/scotus-impeach/index.html

The Democrats spend more time trying to solidify their party's power through disruption rather than doing their actual jobs.
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: Heavies on April 23, 2023, 04:39:41 AM
Did these “grifts” have any relation to any pending SCOTUS cases?
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 23, 2023, 10:30:25 AM
Did these “grifts” have any relation to any pending SCOTUS cases?

You know if they did, that fact would be front and center in the headline.

The people who bring up "just the appearance of impropriety" as the standard also argued that Biden's son's business ventures with foreign adversaries don't prove anything.

 :crazy:
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 23, 2023, 02:52:12 PM
Even the Chief Justice is disinclined to participate in this witch hunt.

Chief SCOTUS Justice Roberts denies request to testify on ethics amid Thomas reports

https://youtu.be/jEJkpOYy3ZE
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on April 23, 2023, 09:18:20 PM
Did these “grifts” have any relation to any pending SCOTUS cases?

There have not been any cases mentioned where Thomas' friend is a party. If he were then I think there would be recusal and potential bribery issues for sure. It could just be that the rich guy likes a sympathetic ear to conservative issues. Of course it could be that they are really just good friends as well.
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on April 23, 2023, 09:20:26 PM
It's not that complicated.

The impeachment process for a justice is the same as a president.  The House votes on whether to impeach based on the allegations.  They send the articles of impeachment to the Senate, and the Senate holds a trial.


My last comment wasn't focusing on removal though, it was focusing on integrity.
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 24, 2023, 11:27:33 AM
There have not been any cases mentioned where Thomas' friend is a party. If he were then I think there would be recusal and potential bribery issues for sure. It could just be that the rich guy likes a sympathetic ear to conservative issues. Of course it could be that they are really just good friends as well.

Other articles stated that there are no cases linked to his friend.  Not yet anyways until they create 1.

"youre a GOP and theres a 2A case pending, thus u bribed the judge."
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 24, 2023, 11:35:23 AM
My last comment wasn't focusing on removal though, it was focusing on integrity.

The topic is about impeachment, which if followed through to a verdict, ought to include expulsion as a punishment.

If not, then the impeachment was not serious.  it was an unwarranted waste of tax payer money and resources -- nothing more than a political attack.
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 24, 2023, 11:38:28 AM


If not, then the impeachment was not serious.  it was an unwarranted waste of tax payer money and resources -- nothing more than a political attack.

We have seen what they've done to Trump and anyone who helps him.  So the next logical step is to do the same to any justice who doesn't fall in line and violate the constitution for them.  Right now, they're probing.

At what point does Brown Shirts come into mind for the rest of the people?
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 24, 2023, 07:56:23 PM
If the shoe was on the other side and George Soros was giving free trips and perks to a liberal judge would the right say anything?  Regardless of politics, ethics should be followed. There's no room for corruption.  We are not communists.

Chief justice Roberts is staying quiet on the issue.  That tells me it's common practice for the justices to be wined and dined by people with and without an agenda.

If Roberts entertains this BS, they will all be caught up in the flood.

Just a guess, but I'd be willing to bet a dollar.
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on April 24, 2023, 10:27:50 PM
Other articles stated that there are no cases linked to his friend.  Not yet anyways until they create 1.

"youre a GOP and theres a 2A case pending, thus u bribed the judge."

New updates are now indicating that Thomas did hear a case where Harlan Crow, Thomas' generous friend, was a party to the case. Thomas did not recuse himself in that case. According to the article, it is not certain whether Thomas knew Crow was a party to the case or not. That is a bit troublesome.

EDIT: Adding Link
https://news.bloomberglaw.com/us-law-week/thomass-billionaire-friend-had-business-before-supreme-court
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 24, 2023, 10:29:42 PM
New updates are now indicating that Thomas did hear a case where Harlan Crow, Thomas' generous friend, was a party to the case. Thomas did not recuse himself in that case. According to the article, it is not certain whether Thomas knew Crow was a party to the case or not. That is a bit troublesome.

But not impeachment level troublesome...?
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on April 24, 2023, 10:32:51 PM
The topic is about impeachment, which if followed through to a verdict, ought to include expulsion as a punishment.

If not, then the impeachment was not serious.  it was an unwarranted waste of tax payer money and resources -- nothing more than a political attack.

Fair enough
I don't want to offer any opinion on whether he should be impeached or not because I don't know enough to say whether I think there is a good cause to remove him from his position.

My comments about integrity should be viewed as a separate but parallel aspect of this case because not all instances of lack of integrity in government leaders amount to a crime but should still be condemned
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on April 24, 2023, 10:34:13 PM
But not impeachment level troublesome...?

Potentially. If there was any evidence Thomas knew Crow was party to the case then I would lean that way.
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 24, 2023, 10:41:08 PM
Potentially. If there was any evidence Thomas knew Crow was party to the case then I would lean that way.

From the LA Times, that bastion of Conservative values:

Quote
Since 1978, the Ethics in Government Act has required judges and justices to
report travel costs and other expenses that are provided to them by groups,
universities and other such entities. However, it includes an exception for the
“personal hospitality of any individual,” so long as the travel does not involve
official business.

“Justice Thomas and Ginni never asked for any of this hospitality,” Crow said
in a statement to ProPublica. He added that we “never asked about a pending
or lower court case, and Justice Thomas has never discussed one.”
https://www.latimes.com/politics/story/2023-04-06/the-times-reported-about-justice-thomas-gifts-20-years-ago-after-he-just-stopped-disclosing-them

I'm sure they only discussed golf and grandkids.   :rofl:

#TarmacConspiracy
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 24, 2023, 11:05:12 PM
Isn't it obvious that nobody here gives a damn about ethical behavior?

Projecting.
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 25, 2023, 08:49:32 AM
Isn't it obvious that nobody here gives a damn about ethical behavior?

So you agree and state that you "don't give a damn about ethical behavior".
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 25, 2023, 08:50:12 AM
New updates are now indicating that Thomas did hear a case where Harlan Crow, Thomas' generous friend, was a party to the case. Thomas did not recuse himself in that case. According to the article, it is not certain whether Thomas knew Crow was a party to the case or not. That is a bit troublesome.

Not gonna google. Can you post the details?
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 25, 2023, 02:08:47 PM
Parroting you

Show me where I even once said anything close to not giving "a damn about ethical behavior."
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 25, 2023, 02:12:42 PM
Not gonna google. Can you post the details?

It irks me when someone purports to quote a source but doesn't offer readers the smallest courtesy of posting the link for that source.

I imagine it's because they are quoting from memory.  If they can't remember where they found the article and can't bother to Google it, how are we supposed to trust that they remembered the facts of that article accurately?
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 25, 2023, 02:13:10 PM
Show me where I even once said anything close to not giving "a damn about ethical behavior."

We all know your question is rhetorical as xhe doesn't reply when asked for proof.
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 25, 2023, 02:27:36 PM
We all know your question is rhetorical as xhe doesn't reply when asked for proof.

Posting an opinion is one thing.  Insults and personal attacks are not opinions.

It's obvious RHAYDER has nothing intelligent to say, nor can xhe come up with effective counter arguments.

So, xhe resorts to bullying and false accusations.

Typical troll behavior -- although extremely low quality trolling.  My cat trolls better.
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on April 26, 2023, 08:18:56 PM
Isn't it obvious that nobody here gives a damn about ethical behavior?

So you are saying everyone here is a liberal? News to me.
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on April 26, 2023, 08:21:03 PM
Not gonna google. Can you post the details?

I thought I posted the link but apparently I forgot. Here it is
https://news.bloomberglaw.com/us-law-week/thomass-billionaire-friend-had-business-before-supreme-court
Title: Re: Should Justice Clarence Thomas be impeached?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 26, 2023, 08:44:24 PM
I thought I posted the link but apparently I forgot. Here it is
https://news.bloomberglaw.com/us-law-week/thomass-billionaire-friend-had-business-before-supreme-court

Subtracting 'irk points."

 :thumbsup: :geekdanc: