2aHawaii

General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: changemyoil66 on May 31, 2023, 09:23:29 AM

Title: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: changemyoil66 on May 31, 2023, 09:23:29 AM
Green has yet to sign this, but it's so much to read. So figure start a new thread as things are being notice.

PTA process will change.  EVERYONES handgun affidavit will be void and a new class needs to be taken.  And retaken every 4 years.  This would take effect 1/1/24

ALL private property is a sensitive place, so CCW is banned unless permission granted.  Where as the C&C ordinance only applies to commercial establishments and not private residences.


More will be posted. Too bad only on average 100 people submitted testimony.  We should have gotten 5,000 easily.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: Brystont1 on May 31, 2023, 09:32:00 AM
Regarding testimonies I know a few people that I got into firearms who told me that the PTA requirements don’t affect them because they don’t plan to buy more guns. So essentially they didn’t care. We have a weak 2A culture here.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: changemyoil66 on May 31, 2023, 10:06:26 AM
Regarding testimonies I know a few people that I got into firearms who told me that the PTA requirements don’t affect them because they don’t plan to buy more guns. So essentially they didn’t care. We have a weak 2A culture here.

It's unfortunate that this is the mentality here. Concepts are hard.  I learned this when HI was banning bump stocks. "I don't own one, so doesn't affect me". Then the bill came that had "anything that increases the rate of fire". Luckily, this part got deleted.  But is shows how the state will take anything that they can grab at. Look at sensitive places, SCOTUS said you can have some, but HI took that as EVERYWHERE.

The other issue is that since this bill changes HRS134 a lot and isn't just a 1 section type of bill, it may affect your friends and they just don't know it yet.  I doubt that they all fully read the bill so the statement "it doesn't affect me" is a 100% true statement that can be made.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: hvybarrels on May 31, 2023, 10:38:39 AM
Are you saying that someone who bought a handgun 20 years ago will have to take a class and re register it?
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: changemyoil66 on May 31, 2023, 10:41:39 AM
Are you saying that someone who bought a handgun 20 years ago will have to take a class and re register it?

No. But if they want to buy another one, their affidavit from 20 years ago is no longer valid.  So they have to take the new class.  Or if they want to get a CCW, they need the new class.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: zippz on May 31, 2023, 11:06:42 AM
I don't see anything that would prohibit open carry at a range or your own property for CCW licensees.

If it's related to 134-g, you're not carrying the firearm pursuant to a CCW license, your carrying because there is no law prohibiting carry on your own property.  It would also be difficult to show that open carry made you look threatening at a gun range.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: changemyoil66 on May 31, 2023, 11:18:12 AM
I don't see anything that would prohibit open carry at a range or your own property for CCW licensees.

If it's related to 134-g, you're not carrying the firearm pursuant to a CCW license, your carrying because there is no law prohibiting carry on your own property.  It would also be difficult to show that open carry made you look threatening at a gun range.

Good to know.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: zippz on May 31, 2023, 11:44:41 AM
There's going to be a huge demand for firearm safety courses come Jan 1st to buy a gun because of this.  If you plan on buying guns next year, you should buy it this year for this and other reasons.  I'm working on things to try and make it better.  Though it's difficult to plan for until the police departments put out their new requirements and policies.


1.  Getting instructors to include the extra lessons in their current courses.

2.  Combine CCW & Permit to acquire into a single class

3.  Keep their classes open so mental health and other new topics can be taught later.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: stangzilla on May 31, 2023, 01:22:12 PM
There's going to be a huge demand for firearm safety courses come Jan 1st to buy a gun because of this.  If you plan on buying guns next year, you should buy it this year for this and other reasons.  I'm working on things to try and make it better.  Though it's difficult to plan for until the police departments put out their new requirements and policies.


1.  Getting instructors to include the extra lessons in their current courses.

2.  Combine CCW & Permit to acquire into a single class

3.  Keep their classes open so mental health and other new topics can be taught later.

I'm going to buy my firearms now!!!
always looking for an excuse to buy more. although I wish it wasn't this way
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: changemyoil66 on May 31, 2023, 01:22:47 PM
I'm going to buy my firearms now!!!
always looking for an excuse to buy more. although I wish it wasn't this way

TBH man, you gonna buy more stuff later too. So no matter you buy now or later.  :rofl:
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: stangzilla on May 31, 2023, 01:30:39 PM
TBH man, you gonna buy more stuff later too. So no matter you buy now or later.  :rofl:

you know me already.  haha!
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: stangzilla on May 31, 2023, 11:56:45 PM
What about the hunters ed class. I also have that
Will that be no good too?
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: dogman on June 01, 2023, 05:08:30 AM
What about the hunters ed class. I also have that
Will that be no good too?
YES
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: stangzilla on June 01, 2023, 07:13:53 AM
YES

Thanks
Well. That sucks
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: QUIETShooter on June 01, 2023, 08:36:52 AM
The list of where CCW carry is prohibited is miles long.

Where CAN someone with a CCW license carry legally?  Seems like at home, on your property, and on the sidewalk.  Maybe sidewalk.  Depends which and where on sidewalk?

Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: changemyoil66 on June 01, 2023, 08:53:06 AM
What about the hunters ed class. I also have that
Will that be no good too?

To buy a rifle/shotty, yes. To buy a handgun, no.  The bill adds an additional requirement to teach about suicide prevention in the class needed to buy a handgun.  And the instructors must be approved by HPD.  Right now, no one is needed to be approved by HPD to meet the handgun class requirement.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: changemyoil66 on June 01, 2023, 08:53:58 AM
The list of where CCW carry is prohibited is miles long.

Where CAN someone with a CCW license carry legally?  Seems like at home, on your property, and on the sidewalk.  Maybe sidewalk.  Depends which and where on sidewalk?

Correct, the sidewalk and your property.  ALL PRIVATE PROPERTY is automatically banned unless given approval. So even your friends home or a retail store.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: BRU on June 01, 2023, 09:17:37 AM
The list of where CCW carry is prohibited is miles long.

Where CAN someone with a CCW license carry legally?  Seems like at home, on your property, and on the sidewalk.  Maybe sidewalk.  Depends which and where on sidewalk?

Maybe not all sidewalks. There are private or HOA owned streets/sidewalks. I’m not sure how the bill would apply to private sidewalks. The streets in my subdivision are HOA owned so I guess people that don’t live in the subdivision aren’t allowed to enter and carry by default.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: changemyoil66 on June 01, 2023, 09:57:11 AM
Maybe not all sidewalks. There are private or HOA owned streets/sidewalks. I’m not sure how the bill would apply to private sidewalks. The streets in my subdivision are HOA owned so I guess people that don’t live in the subdivision aren’t allowed to enter and carry by default.

Yes, public sidewalks only. HIFICO has a video of a property line in Waikiki, but not all have this line to show the difference between public and private.  Whether an owner who's part of the AOAO can give permission for a common area, I haven't read  that section yet.   There is something about AOAO common areas, but the part I read applied to owners. Owners are allowed to CCW in the common areas.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: RSN172 on June 01, 2023, 10:03:07 AM
Until a court rules these stupid regulations as unconstitutional,  a CCW permit is virtually useless.  I already don't need a permit to carry on my property.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: zippz on June 01, 2023, 10:05:12 AM
Until a court rules these stupid regulations as unconstitutional,  a CCW permit is virtually useless.  I already don't need a permit to carry on my property.

One.of the reasons for having the 4 year CCW license is so people can continue to get it and show demand for it, and be confident a lot of these restrictions will be lifted in a year or so.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: changemyoil66 on June 01, 2023, 10:15:29 AM
One.of the reasons for having the 4 year CCW license is so people can continue to get it and show demand for it, and be confident a lot of these restrictions will be lifted in a year or so.


^^^This, cause lower numbers issued give lawmakers more reason to pass more anti 2a laws. "not many have a CCW anyways, so this law will only affect a few".
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: changemyoil66 on June 02, 2023, 12:16:36 PM
For CCW app's if you aren't approved by 120 days, it's an automatic denial and your $150 is not refunded. Page 54 (j)

For PTA, you must give all prior medical carrier information as well, not just your current one and "no current doctor".

You cannot lend someone your rifle/shotgun anymore  unless they have taken hunters ed or like handgun course within 4 years. per page 32 (h). I cannot find the strikethru of the 15 day or 75 day lending. But (h) says:
"No person shall sell, give, lend, or deliver into the possession of another any firearm expect in accordance with this chapter"

Armored car would have to figure out what "on duty" means. Is a lunch break "on duty"?  Cause you cannot openly carry unless on duty and an armored car. So paid lunch break I guess.

LEOSA has no exceptions. Page 9 (10).   IDK if they mean all "buildings" or just state/county buildings.  As the verbiage says "state or county property, installations, buildings, bases, parks, and other private property if the owner prohibits it".  IMO, "buildings" means all buildings, not just state/county buildings.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: changemyoil66 on June 02, 2023, 12:55:56 PM
My question is: Is there a preemption?  Like would this law override C&C ordinance 23-006 (bill 57)?  I don't think it does, so there are 2 sets of laws for CCWing.

Example: 23-006 has a duty to inform. SB1230 only requires to inform upon request or if in a vehicle.  So in the end, there's a duty to inform.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: zippz on June 02, 2023, 01:08:04 PM

You cannot lend someone your rifle/shotgun anymore 

LEOSA has no exceptions.

The lending of rifles and shotguns is allowed and hasn't changed as it goes off of hrs 134-4.

What the leosa thing essentially says is LEOSA cannot carry at government places, or private places that prohibit carry.  Or other federally prohibited place.  Otherwise they can carry in the sensitive places listed in sb1230.

Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: changemyoil66 on June 02, 2023, 01:14:43 PM
The lending of rifles and shotguns is allowed and hasn't changed as it goes off of hrs 134-4.

What the leosa thing essentially says is LEOSA cannot carry at government places, or private places that prohibit carry.  Or other federally prohibited place.  Otherwise they can carry in the sensitive places listed in sb1230.

So why would that section (h) have the word "lend" if it applies solely to sales/transfers of guns?  It sounds like 2 areas conflict with each other. 

For the LEOSA prohibit carry, this is a tricky one as it doesn't say a sign is needed.  So like Costco doesn't have a sign at the front, but their corporate policy is no carrying. LEOSA cannot carry in Costco and wouldn't know unless they contacted Costco.  Same goes if a Hospital doesn't have a no weapons sign, but it's against their policy.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: zippz on June 02, 2023, 01:50:11 PM
So why would that section (h) have the word "lend" if it applies solely to sales/transfers of guns?  It sounds like 2 areas conflict with each other. 
That phrase isn't underlined so the current law was not changed in that regard.  Although there appears to be a conflict, 134-4 is very specific that no permit is needed


For the LEOSA prohibit carry, this is a tricky one as it doesn't say a sign is needed.  So like Costco doesn't have a sign at the front, but their corporate policy is no carrying. LEOSA cannot carry in Costco and wouldn't know unless they contacted Costco.  Same goes if a Hospital doesn't have a no weapons sign, but it's against their policy.

In SB1230 they drafted the law very carefully to not say private property is automatically defaulted to owners banning carry as it would be a 1A violation.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: QUIETShooter on June 02, 2023, 02:19:14 PM
I'm waiting  :popcorn: for a situation to arise where there is conflict or open to interpretation situations.  It's gonna happen.  Should be interesting.  This is what happens when the City and State like play god with firearm control.

Gotta buy more popcorn.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: changemyoil66 on June 02, 2023, 04:04:18 PM
So Rep Tarnas thanked hifico for helping make a fair bill.

THIS IS A LIE.

 Only thing hifico did was insisit on a 4 year ccw and effective date of 1/1/24 for new permit to acquire law to take effect. Hifico said the entire bill sucks and see u in court if it passes.

AG lied when they said they looked at history and tradition (bruen) to craft the bill. For every hearing when asked about bruen, their story kept changing.



Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: zippz on June 02, 2023, 04:18:23 PM
So Rep Tarnas thanked hifico for helping make a fair bill.

It's like getting murdered and thanking the murderer for making it a quick death.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: changemyoil66 on June 02, 2023, 07:43:03 PM
All guns need to be transported in a locked container. No box that the gun came in. So new purchases need to be put into a lockable case.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on June 02, 2023, 09:16:39 PM
All guns need to be transported in a locked container. No box that the gun came in. So new purchases need to be put into a lockable case.

Hmmm.  Are you sure?

I read it as IF you are a licensed carrier and IF you are transporting a firearm inside a sensitive area, into/out of a parking area or at a sensitive place's parking area, or storing or retrieving a concealed firearm from the vehicle's trunk (meaning you aren't going to get in trouble for being outside the vehicle with a cased firearm in a sensitive place if you're just putting it away), then locked case applies.

The locked container rule keeps specifying they apply when transporting "a concealed firearm."  I think we already put to bed that not all cased firearms are considered concealed especially if they are not listed on your license application.  So the locked container rule should only cover concealed firearms, not those you are not carrying concealed to/from a sensitive place.  A long gun is a firearm, but it's not a "concealed firearm," so the locked container rule isn't applicable.

That's my interpretation.  I think they used "concealed firearm" on purpose, to differentiate a handgun you can/will carry from all other firearms.

Quote
(c)  Notwithstanding subsection (a), a person carrying a firearm pursuant to a license issued under section 134-9, or in accordance with title 18 United States Code section 926B or 926C, may:

     (1)  Transport a concealed firearm within the person's vehicle or in a location specified in paragraphs (14) or (15) of the definition of "sensitive location" in subsection (i); provided that the firearm is unloaded and in a locked container;

     (2)  Transport a concealed firearm within a vehicle into or out of a parking area in a location covered under subsection (a); provided that the firearm is secured in a locked container; and {?}

     (3)  Transport a concealed firearm in the immediate area surrounding their vehicle within a prohibited parking lot area only for the purpose of storing or retrieving a firearm within a locked container in the vehicle's trunk or other place inside the vehicle that is out of plain view.  {?}

I notice they only specified unloaded in the first situation, but not the 2nd and 3rd {?}
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: dogman on June 02, 2023, 10:42:04 PM
What about the hunters ed class. I also have that
Will that be no good too?

To buy a rifle/shotty, yes. To buy a handgun, no. 
"yes" . . . "no" . . . not correct I believe. I could be wrong but I believe begining in 2024, current (or new?) Hunters Ed card cannot be used to acquire a handgun. You will, however, need the new and improved Hunters Ed class card to get a long gun permit . . . I believe.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: changemyoil66 on June 03, 2023, 08:28:51 AM
Hmmm.  Are you sure?

I read it as IF you are a licensed carrier and IF you are transporting a firearm inside a sensitive area, into/out of a parking area or at a sensitive place's parking area, or storing or retrieving a concealed firearm from the vehicle's trunk (meaning you aren't going to get in trouble for being outside the vehicle with a cased firearm in a sensitive place if you're just putting it away), then locked case applies.

The locked container rule keeps specifying they apply when transporting "a concealed firearm."  I think we already put to bed that not all cased firearms are considered concealed especially if they are not listed on your license application.  So the locked container rule should only cover concealed firearms, not those you are not carrying concealed to/from a sensitive place.  A long gun is a firearm, but it's not a "concealed firearm," so the locked container rule isn't applicable.

That's my interpretation.  I think they used "concealed firearm" on purpose, to differentiate a handgun you can/will carry from all other firearms.

I notice they only specified unloaded in the first situation, but not the 2nd and 3rd {?}
Theres a separate section for transporting in general. I tabed the 77 pages and will post the section later as the papers are at work.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: zippz on June 03, 2023, 12:35:24 PM
"yes" . . . "no" . . . not correct I believe. I could be wrong but I believe begining in 2024, current (or new?) Hunters Ed card cannot be used to acquire a handgun. You will, however, need the new and improved Hunters Ed class card to get a long gun permit . . . I believe.

For long guns acquisition, you must have taken hunters Ed within the past 4 years.  Or take the new firearms safety course.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: dogman on June 03, 2023, 08:31:35 PM
For long guns acquisition, you must have taken hunters Ed within the past 4 years.  Or take the new firearms safety course.
If you took the Hunters Ed course in the last two and a half years, the card can still be used in 2024 to apply for a long gun permit?
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: QUIETShooter on June 04, 2023, 06:14:24 AM
SB1230 is as clear as mud.

Or doo-doo.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: changemyoil66 on June 05, 2023, 09:16:10 AM
Hmmm.  Are you sure?

I read it as IF you are a licensed carrier and IF you are transporting a firearm inside a sensitive area, into/out of a parking area or at a sensitive place's parking area, or storing or retrieving a concealed firearm from the vehicle's trunk (meaning you aren't going to get in trouble for being outside the vehicle with a cased firearm in a sensitive place if you're just putting it away), then locked case applies.

The locked container rule keeps specifying they apply when transporting "a concealed firearm."  I think we already put to bed that not all cased firearms are considered concealed especially if they are not listed on your license application.  So the locked container rule should only cover concealed firearms, not those you are not carrying concealed to/from a sensitive place.  A long gun is a firearm, but it's not a "concealed firearm," so the locked container rule isn't applicable.

That's my interpretation.  I think they used "concealed firearm" on purpose, to differentiate a handgun you can/will carry from all other firearms.

I notice they only specified unloaded in the first situation, but not the 2nd and 3rd {?}

My mistake. I looked thru the 77 pages again and was wrong.
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: changemyoil66 on June 05, 2023, 09:16:31 AM
If you took the Hunters Ed course in the last two and a half years, the card can still be used in 2024 to apply for a long gun permit?

Yes
Title: Re: Going Thru SB1230
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on June 05, 2023, 11:26:08 AM
My mistake. I looked thru the 77 pages again and was wrong.

 :thumbsup: