2aHawaii
General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: xxRENDOGxx on December 07, 2012, 10:33:46 PM
-
If you catch somebody breaking into your house at 2:45 in the morning?
It's dark, so you cannot see if the intruder is armed.
Also, you don't know if he's alone.
WHAT DO YOU DO?
posting in LEGAL because of legal issues involved
-
Better to be judged by 12 than carried by 6. I'd shoot him.
-
Always see where your are shooting.
You might win the battle by shooting the intruder but your start a war thats ends up in the court.
Scenario 1#: Actual situation where you shot him where his back is turn but he is not fleeing.
In court the prosecutor will say you shot him in the back while fleeing. I think there is a retreat clause
Scenario #2 You shoot and miss and goes into neighbors house or whatever collateral damage.
Scenario # Person just drunk as hell and just entered your house thinking it was his and he is not armed.
Use a high intensity flashlight it'll blind the intruder and help you assess the situation better. Take a class.
-
your responsible for every bullet you shoot. if its dark enough that you cant see what you are specifically shooting at, im not sure if you shoot.
especially given what RSwarrior said. you shoot someone in the back without realizing it, good luck in court. you miss and cause collateral damage, good luck with your conscience AND with court.
my thoughts? you have a gun. make sure know whether he's armed or not. and if he isnt aware of your presence, i'd try to defuse the situation. you can always shoot him if he makes a sudden move. you cant take back a bullet that leaves your barrel.
-
Okay. So I confront the intruder.
I turn on my lights and see that he's a BIG motherfucker. Like 6'4" and yoked, but I see that he's UNARMED.
I am armed with my Mossy 500, but I am 5'5" and slim.
He charges towards me.
May I shoot him now?
-
Okay. So I confront the intruder.
I turn on my lights and see that he's a BIG motherfucker. Like 6'4" and yoked, but I see that he's UNARMED.
I am armed with my Mossy 500, but I am 5'5" and slim.
He charges towards me.
May I shoot him now?
that's an aggressive move. honestly, even if he's your size, if someone charges you, i think you're obligated to shoot him.. of course you shoot him. what you dont want is to shoot the guy who sees you and tries to run, and then you end up in court cause the guy has a load of buckshot in his back.
these are just my thoughts though.
-
All these textbook classroom examples are useless in a crime ridden large metropolitan city where drugs and crime go hand in hand and any Dr. Phil tactic may very well cost you or your family their lives. Almost equivent to comparing military basic training to combat. He broke into my home illegally and my life or family is threatened. If he's high on drugs and crazy (PCP for all we know), he is coming to potentially harm or kill you or your family while you reach for your flashlight to access the situation. He is the criminal unlawfully entering your home.
-
Okay. So I confront the intruder.
I turn on my lights and see that he's a BIG motherfucker. Like 6'4" and yoked, but I see that he's UNARMED.
I am armed with my Mossy 500, but I am 5'5" and slim.
He charges towards me.
May I shoot him now?
Why do you have to use me as your example of an intruder?
-
Why do you have to use me as your example of an intruder?
Couldn't be you....you would have been armed.
-
All these textbook classroom examples are useless in a crime ridden large metropolitan city where drugs and crime go hand in hand and any Dr. Phil tactic may very well cost you or your family their lives. Almost equivent to comparing military basic training to combat. He broke into my home illegally and my life or family is threatened. If he's high on drugs and crazy (PCP for all we know), he is coming to potentially harm or kill you or your family while you reach for your flashlight to access the situation. He is the criminal unlawfully entering your home.
and then you shoot an unarmed guy who turns out not to be on drugs, and whether or not you do a whole lot of time in prison is completely in the hands of a random jury.
if you want to take that gamble, fine by me. but im going to at least know what im shooting at before i pull any triggers.
there's a reason you can mount a flashlight on a gun, by the way. so you dont waste time looking for a flashlight.
when you enter a situation with the expectation that someone's gonna die, you're setting yourself up to make a huge mistake, imo.
-
Like I said I'd rather be judged by 12, than carried by 6. Just my opinion and sound advice from a 42 year veterian Detroit homocide sergeant detective...my father.
-
that's an aggressive move. honestly, even if he's your size, if someone charges you, i think you're obligated to shoot him.. of course you shoot him. what you dont want is to shoot the guy who sees you and tries to run, and then you end up in court cause the guy has a load of buckshot in his back.
these are just my thoughts though.
You blast your buckshot to his chest to neutralize the threat, but he survives. The assailant now testifies to the jury that YOU posed a threat to HIM and that he was just trying to defend himself against YOU.
I guess don't forget rule number 2.
(http://lh3.ggpht.com/_BzoJp6lHmHg/S3zMs87PtWI/AAAAAAAAADU/-lJw1Za7EpA/Rule%202-Double%20Tap_thumb%5B1%5D.png?imgmax=800)
-
If you catch somebody breaking into your house at 2:45 in the morning?
It's dark, so you cannot see if the intruder is armed.
Also, you don't know if he's alone.
WHAT DO YOU DO?
posting in LEGAL because of legal issues involved
Defend yourself, but cover your ass...
You call 911 while getting your gun. (If possible) tell them the situation, that you are "afraid for your life", armed and prepared to defend yourself. Whatever you do, just keep the line open.
You blast your buckshot to his chest to neutralize the threat, but he survives. The assailant now testifies to the jury that YOU posed a threat to HIM and that he was just trying to defend himself against YOU.
I guess don't forget rule number 2.
(http://lh3.ggpht.com/_BzoJp6lHmHg/S3zMs87PtWI/AAAAAAAAADU/-lJw1Za7EpA/Rule%202-Double%20Tap_thumb%5B1%5D.png?imgmax=800)
I seriously hope you're trying to be funny, because (if you're serious) that's just idiotic. Try to remember that shooting someone in self defense, means shooting to stop. You're not 007 with a license to kill. As evident with current events, there's a fine line between self defense and murder...decide which side do you want to be on.
-
Defend yourself, but cover your ass...
You call 911 while getting your gun. (If possible) tell them the situation, that you are "afraid for your life", armed and prepared to defend yourself. Whatever you do, just keep the line open.
+1 - hopefully there is the luxury of time beforehand to call 911 but if not call directly after the incident with same rational. I believe in most break-ins people are surprised and caught off guard with minimal time to react (seconds), and unfortunately become victims. There are a lot of women that get raped and/or killed in their own homes who didn't have the means or the time to stop the assault.
-
Be sure of your target before you start shooting.
My adult son who lives out of state decided to "surprise" me by sneaking into my house at 2:00am one morning.
I have a "realtor" lock box on the front door. (The ones with the combination)
Only three people in the world have the combination, and two of them are laying in bed next to each other when I hear the door open.
I immediately get up and grab my home defense handgun.
With my finger off of the trigger, I peek out around the corner to the living room, gun pointing where I look.(with a TLR-1S attached)
I see the silhouette of a 6'1", 250# man.
I immediately hit the strobe button.
No sooner did I hit the strobe, do I hear, "Don't shoot Dad, it's me"
I point my gun down, finger still off the trigger. I then go back in the room and put the gun back to sleep.
I come back out and give my son a big hug. He says "Surprise!!"
Moral of the story. Coming out guns blazing isn't always the answer.
-
.
-
Just throwing this out there but if can, maybe invest in an alarm system. Can be kinda expensive, I guess but may be worth it. Or can go with a cheaper alarm system (dog), too. What was that about an ounce of prevention?
+1 on alarm and dog, but if they guy is persistence and able to bypass all of that and to a point lethal force must be use make sure have a surveillance camera system recording the whole thing.
*Keeps you in check that you know you are being recorded
*Easier to explain in court by by showing video evidence(Been in court enough that lawyers will use what you wrote down and what you say against you.)
Always remember to see what you are shooting at, point shooting is only good in a war zone where law and order does not necessarily apply. In the civilian world you are accountable for every shot.
-
Be sure of your target before you start shooting.
My adult son who lives out of state decided to "surprise" me by sneaking into my house at 2:00am one morning......................
I took you for being a young dude.
-
I took you for being a young dude.
How many young guys have that much $$ for guns? Or a wife well trained to accept them? ;)
-
I took you for being a young dude.
Don't let my rugged youthful looks fool you. :rofl:
-
I think his scenario is hypothetical, in that speaking in terms of the general population who probably doesn't have strobes and all the bells and whistles on their firearm (probably their one and only firearm). He said intruder, so assumption as I took it is the invader is someone not known to the homeowner. I think of this in terms of an elderly or single woman living alone, with minimal firearm training at some point in their life.
-
+1 on alarm and dog, but if they guy is persistence and able to bypass all of that and to a point lethal force must be use make sure have a surveillance camera system recording the whole thing.
*Keeps you in check that you know you are being recorded
*Easier to explain in court by by showing video evidence(Been in court enough that lawyers will use what you wrote down and what you say against you.)
Always remember to see what you are shooting at, point shooting is only good in a war zone where law and order does not necessarily apply. In the civilian world you are accountable for every shot.
i think the point on the dog/alarm is more for two things.
an alarm/dog can notify you the instant someone breaks in. that may give you more time to react.
an alarm system can immediately call the cops, saving you the trouble.
as KK's story illustrates, being trigger happy is a good way to end things with a tragedy.
-
Just throwing this out there but if can, maybe invest in an alarm system. Can be kinda expensive, I guess but may be worth it. Or can go with a cheaper alarm system (dog), too. What was that about an ounce of prevention?
Actually, I do have an alarm system. A few days ago, my alarm was triggered at 3:00 in the morning. In a panic, I rushed out unarmed to see WTF was going on. I disabled the alarm, picked up my bat, then proceeded to clear the premises. Everything checked out. The alarm was triggered due to a faulty sensor.
I see that I failed horribly in my tactics and strategy dealing with an intruder. My wife said I need to re-evaluate my strategy. :( She said "For nothing you get gun."
Which brought me to post this topic. I was curious to see how other, more experienced folks would react in a similar situation.
-
Be sure of your target before you start shooting.
My adult son who lives out of state decided to "surprise" me by sneaking into my house at 2:00am one morning.
I have a "realtor" lock box on the front door. (The ones with the combination)
Only three people in the world have the combination, and two of them are laying in bed next to each other when I hear the door open.
I immediately get up and grab my home defense handgun.
With my finger off of the trigger, I peek out around the corner to the living room, gun pointing where I look.(with a TLR-1S attached)
I see the silhouette of a 6'1", 250# man.
I immediately hit the strobe button.
No sooner did I hit the strobe, do I hear, "Don't shoot Dad, it's me"
I point my gun down, finger still off the trigger. I then go back in the room and put the gun back to sleep.
I come back out and give my son a big hug. He says "Surprise!!"
Moral of the story. Coming out guns blazing isn't always the answer.
Those who own guns long enough and have the training will eventually have something similar happen. For me it was a new neighbor, drunk and fiddling around the backdoor at 3am. I "greeted" him with a 12ga and kept him on the ground until HPD arrived to sort things out. His wife and kids came by to ID his drunk ass, so I let it go. I remember the officer asking if there was anything I want to say? All I could think of was: "Uhhh...Welcome to the neighborhood?" They moved away a few months later. Funny, but true.
(KK) You and I (plus a few others) have the training and control to remember the rule: "Be sure of your target before you start shooting." Those who don't need to either get training of have the proper mindset. Because the whole shoot first ask questions later mentality is the exact crap anti-gun folks love to attribute to all gun owners.
I think his scenario is hypothetical, in that speaking in terms of the general population who probably doesn't have strobes and all the bells and whistles on their firearm (probably their one and only firearm). He said intruder, so assumption as I took it is the invader is someone not known to the homeowner. I think of this in terms of an elderly or single woman living alone, with minimal firearm training at some point in their life.
No amount of bells and whistles can replace having a good head on ones shoulders. Because if someone is so afraid that they're trigger happy, shooting at every spooky shadow or sound, then they really shouldn't be considering a gun for defense.
-
i think the point on the dog/alarm is more for two things.
an alarm/dog can notify you the instant someone breaks in. that may give you more time to react.
an alarm system can immediately call the cops, saving you the trouble.
as KK's story illustrates, being trigger happy is a good way to end things with a tragedy.
Criminals want to be in and out without alerting others. Alarms are expensive and fail often, so a yappy dog is one of the best deterrents for an intruder. :thumbsup:
The "attack" Papillon.
Smaller than my shoe and would probably surrender because she's French, but noisy as hell when someone comes steps onto the driveway. (And yeah she hates Angry Birds)
(http://i612.photobucket.com/albums/tt203/Colt808/Picture007-1.jpg)
-
I do get your points...not disputing them, and experienced gun owners do all the things you accurately point out, are well trained, and have alarms and security/safety precautions in place but speaking in a broader sense, living in Detroit my entire childhood and visiting frequently, I 've been to more funerals and hospitals than I care to remember of people who were seriously injured or killed from home intrusion incidents who were at the hands of the invader, where they could care less if you live or die. In Detroit if somebody isn't killed daily, it's a good day. In Detroit, criminals getting shot by homeowners is no big news and unless the homeowner took it to the extreme (once threat removed, go for kill), these cases usually don't even make it to court. Hawaii is a completely different story and environment and one, no matter who, must use extreme caution and judgement before expending a round at someone. I've been through several courses and understand and agree the concepts. Just saying not everyone is as educated and trained in firearms and I don't necessarily agree that segment of the population, just because there not experts should opt not to have a firearm to protect themselves. I only wish some of the people I know who died would have at least had a fighting chance. Just my opinion from a different prospective, not disagreeing with proven firearm courses or tactics.
-
I asked the same question on another forum and just wanted to share some of the responses I got...
Assuming I heard someone breaking in down the hall? Lock door to my bedroom.
Call 911.
If the guy attempts to kick in my door, he will be face to face with my Mossberg 500.
As much as you guys have fantasies about going Rambo on people, I'd prefer to let the police deal with it if possible. Even if you don't end up getting charged, you'll probably be arrested, have all your stuff confiscated and have all kinds of issues that will follow you for the rest of your life. Say good bye to any clearance or any sort of government job ever. Also, any time you're pulled over for the rest of your life "you ever been arrested?" I don't want that hassle if I can avoid it.
Still, if the police fail to get there in time, you have an option to keep yourself safe. It's like I tell the ban people. It's the same reason I know first aid and have a kit, I'd ideally like to call 911 and let the paramedics handle it, but if they fail to arrive, I have options.
I'll probably be called a pussy by a bunch of 14 year old kids. Deal with it. I will keep myself safe, but I'm not going to fuck up my life unless it absolutely cannot be avoided.
This does not apply to people with kids or other family in other rooms, where you may not be able to stay put and may be forced to move to the living room or main hallway to ensure the intruder isn't going after someone else in a different room. In that case, I understand needing to leave the safety of your room to protect others in the house. This is only for a living situation where you live alone or with someone else in the same room.
-
Another one...
I grab my machete. Story time.
>live on the edge of a canyon, kind of bad neighborhood
>3am, playing stalker cop. wander away from pc to grab a drink
>here somebody fucking with my back door
>its a sliding glass door, leads right into my living room, the person is pulling at it pretty hard
>flimsy lock is holding, but not well
>all lights are out in living room and kitchen, sneak back to my room
>grab my machete
>sneak back in
>flip up the lock and stand to the side of the door
>nigger shambles in through blinds
>walks straight to my entertainment system
>flip on light and scream "ON YOUR KNEES, NOW!"
>he flips his shit, turns and swings at me
>I dodge, he falls
>I swing as hard as I can, slash the SHIT out of him down his back, stopped when I hit his scapula
>he lets out a scream I will never forget and manages to knock me down as he get out the door
>blood everywhere, I mean, fucktons
>I chase him out, and before he can hop the fence (the guy had so much adrenaline he almost floated up the thing) I hit him in the calf
>bad hit, mostly stopped by his jeans
>he flips and faceplants from a 6 foot drop, into the canyon
>I scream, "YOU COME BACK AND I WILL FUCKING KILL YOU"
Nobody ever came back. Neighbors asked what happened, I kept it kinda hush hush and said I "chased off" a burglar. I'm glad nothing came of it. Here in Commie-fornia I could probably get jail time for that.
Terrible pic is the legitimus collins & Co. machete I used.
-
And another...
point gun at him, demand he identify himself
somebody I don't know, or sudden movement, shoot.
no response or movement, or tripping all over his drunk ass self, I turn on the lights to see who it is.
somebody I don't know, and sudden movement, shoot.
somebody I do know, tell them to get the fuck out.
somebody I don't know stoned out of their mind, buttstroke them unconscious, drag their ass to the front yard, call the cops, keep the shotgun trained on them till the po leese arrive
-
i was told by a couple of police patients that shooting someone, even if you are in the right, costs you tens of thousands of dollars, you lose your guns for a while, you have to deal with the stress and the guilt from hurting/killing someone, even if it was a legit shoot
not to mention the time lost from work
they told me to do the 911 and barricade yourself in a room thing and only blast if someone forcibly tries to enter
oh, and they told me to make sure the intruder knows you are armed and try and keep the phone line open to 911 like the others have said
they also stressed the importance of letting the officers know who you are and where you are so there are no friendly fire incidents
aloha
steve
I asked the same question on another forum and just wanted to share some of the responses I got...
Assuming I heard someone breaking in down the hall? Lock door to my bedroom.
Call 911.
If the guy attempts to kick in my door, he will be face to face with my Mossberg 500.
As much as you guys have fantasies about going Rambo on people, I'd prefer to let the police deal with it if possible. Even if you don't end up getting charged, you'll probably be arrested, have all your stuff confiscated and have all kinds of issues that will follow you for the rest of your life. Say good bye to any clearance or any sort of government job ever. Also, any time you're pulled over for the rest of your life "you ever been arrested?" I don't want that hassle if I can avoid it.
Still, if the police fail to get there in time, you have an option to keep yourself safe. It's like I tell the ban people. It's the same reason I know first aid and have a kit, I'd ideally like to call 911 and let the paramedics handle it, but if they fail to arrive, I have options.
I'll probably be called a pussy by a bunch of 14 year old kids. Deal with it. I will keep myself safe, but I'm not going to fuck up my life unless it absolutely cannot be avoided.
This does not apply to people with kids or other family in other rooms, where you may not be able to stay put and may be forced to move to the living room or main hallway to ensure the intruder isn't going after someone else in a different room. In that case, I understand needing to leave the safety of your room to protect others in the house. This is only for a living situation where you live alone or with someone else in the same room.
-
I really think its where you live and people seeing their communities overrun by gangs and punks. Most people answering your question are generally not the ones who become victims. Sadly it's our elderly people that are the main victims, in a broader sense. Interesting responses you rounded up.
-
i was told by a couple of police patients that shooting someone, even if you are in the right, costs you tens of thousands of dollars, you lose your guns for a while, you have to deal with the stress and the guilt from hurting/killing someone, even if it was a legit shoot
not to mention the time lost from work
they told me to do the 911 and barricade yourself in a room thing and only blast if someone forcibly tries to enter
oh, and they told me to make sure the intruder knows you are armed and try and keep the phone line open to 911 like the others have said
they also stressed the importance of letting the officers know who you are and where you are so there are no friendly fire incidents
aloha
steve
All good points. I would add one thing about the guilt. Just like being a soldier or a gun owner willing to use deadly force only when necessary, that is something one has to be willing to do when it's absolutely necessary and live with the moral consequences.
-
I do get your points...not disputing them, and experienced gun owners do all the things you accurately point out, are well trained, and have alarms and security/safety precautions in place but speaking in a broader sense, living in Detroit my entire childhood and visiting frequently, I 've been to more funerals and hospitals than I care to remember of people who were seriously injured or killed from home intrusion incidents who were at the hands of the invader, where they could care less if you live or die. In Detroit if somebody isn't killed daily, it's a good day. In Detroit, criminals getting shot by homeowners is no big news and unless the homeowner took it to the extreme (once threat removed, go for kill), these cases usually don't even make it to court. Hawaii is a completely different story and environment and one, no matter who, must use extreme caution and judgement before expending a round at someone. I've been through several courses and understand and agree the concepts. Just saying not everyone is as educated and trained in firearms and I don't necessarily agree that segment of the population, just because there not experts should opt not to have a firearm to protect themselves. I only wish some of the people I know who died would have at least had a fighting chance. Just my opinion from a different prospective, not disagreeing with proven firearm courses or tactics.
no one said to not defend yourself.
people did say not to shoot at something that you cant properly identify.
and this isnt detroit. they have different laws, and differnt expectations. you shoot someone in hawaii, it really doesnt matter the situation, i guarantee you'll have to fight for a long time in court.
and and if a home invader comes in not caring if someone lives or dies, i dont think that is this situation at all. that's not an ambiguous threat, that's a clear aggressive threat. that's different. you're applying your ideas for one situation to a totally different situation, and then wondering why people aren't supporting that idea 100%. the situation you just mentioned now, vs the one in the OP, are two very different situations. the first one is such an ambiguous case, i dont think anyone could or should recommend shooting without properly identifying the threat. because, as two people just pointed out with personal stories, you could easily have innocent blood on your hands.
it doesnt matter if its hawaii, detroit, baltimore, texas, california, whatever. this isnt a warzone, you are obligated to know exactly what you're shooting at. collateral damage is not an acceptable risk to take just because home invaders kill people in detroit all the time. you want to protect your family? your family is going to have it pretty rough if you accidentally shoot one of them, or end up in jail, because you didnt properly identify your target. sounds stupid, but yeah, it does indeed happen.
-
If you catch somebody breaking into your house at 2:45 in the morning?
It's dark, so you cannot see if the intruder is armed.
Also, you don't know if he's alone.
WHAT DO YOU DO?
Ok...take all the semantics and changes in scenarios out and in Hawaii. I'm sleeping in my bed, wife next to me and no kids. I hear someone in the house and coming my way. I grab my firearm next to my bed, where it resides and I get up. Now the intruder is approaching me in my bedroom as I get up. I strobe him and see he is no one I know and continues to come at me once I say I have a firearm. Sorry, there is a high probability I would shoot him. Didn't have time for any tactics or retreating, calling 911 or anything. It's just my opinion on the matter. It was his choice to break into my house unlawfully and I'll let a juror decide the outcome. Now even if I didn't have a strobe and the intruder did the same thing, and I could only make out a figure, again I think I would stop the threat or at least attempt.
-
Ok...take all the semantics and changes in scenarios out and in Hawaii. I'm sleeping in my bed, wife next to me and no kids. I hear someone in the house and coming my way. I grab my firearm next to my bed, where it resides and I get up. Now the intruder is approaching me in my bedroom as I get up. I strobe him and see he is no one I know and continues to come at me once I say I have a firearm. Sorry, there is a high probability I would shoot him. Didn't have time for any tactics or retreating, calling 911 or anything. It's just my opinion on the matter. It was his choice to break into my house unlawfully and I'll let a juror decide the outcome. Now even if I didn't have a strobe and the intruder did the same thing, and I could only make out a figure, again I think I would stop the threat or at least attempt.
well, that's a different and much more specific situation than what has been stated in the first post. no one is asking you to not shoot someone who is moving towards in your own bedroom.
really though, it sounds like you just want people here to affirm your own opinion that you should blow someone away in a certain situation. dont take it the wrong way, but you keep changing things in the scenario to make it more and more attractive to shoot, when that doesnt seem to be the point of the thread at all.
-
It's one or the other...the intruder either keeps coming and endures the consequences or runs like hell. I think it's pretty cut and dry. Must be missing something. Seems you're more concerned about what happens afterward than making sure you don't get killed.
-
It's one or the other...the intruder either keeps coming and endures the consequences or runs like hell. I think it's pretty cut and dry. Must be missing something. Seems you're more concerned about what happens afterward than making sure you don't get killed.
yeah, you're missing the part where you're substituting a different situation than the one in the original post. its not the same situation.
its not about being concerned with what happens after, its about not doing something you're going to regret.
you're going to tell me you wouldnt regret, say, accidentally shooting a drunk who mistakenly hobbled into your house, but you shot him anyways, because you didnt recognize him? or you accidentally shooting a family member who you didnt recognize because it was dark?
cmon.
-
None of that was in your post...it said intruder. I take that as someone you don't know and you said "breaking" into your house, meaning forced entry. That means unlawfully breaking into your residence. I would hope everyone would account for family members before doing anything and lets just hypothethically say it was a drunk who decided to bust your window and enter your home simply because they were too drunk to know better. Are you willing to take the chance that he is just a drunk and not a criminal if he keeps coming at you and if you don't have lights, how could you ID him 100% before making a decision?
-
None of that was in your post...it said intruder. I take that as someone you don't know and you said "breaking" into your house, meaning forced entry. That means unlawfully breaking into your residence. I would hope everyone would account for family members before doing anything and lets just hypothethically say it was a drunk who decided to bust your window and enter your home simply because they were too drunk to know better. Are you willing to take the chance that he is just a drunk and not a criminal if he keeps coming at you and if you don't have lights, how could you ID him 100% before making a decision?
If I hear it (the crash), a very loud and distinct GET THE FUCK OUT OR I WILL SHOOT is going to make someone pipe up if they are on my side. I'm not hiding from the individual per-se, I'm more taking a good position in my room behind cover where I do have an advantage. If you came into my room, and you were drunk, well god help you.
-
I asked the same question on another forum and just wanted to share some of the responses I got...
Assuming I heard someone breaking in down the hall? Lock door to my bedroom.
Call 911.
If the guy attempts to kick in my door, he will be face to face with my Mossberg 500.
As much as you guys have fantasies about going Rambo on people, I'd prefer to let the police deal with it if possible. Even if you don't end up getting charged, you'll probably be arrested, have all your stuff confiscated and have all kinds of issues that will follow you for the rest of your life. Say good bye to any clearance or any sort of government job ever. Also, any time you're pulled over for the rest of your life "you ever been arrested?" I don't want that hassle if I can avoid it.
Still, if the police fail to get there in time, you have an option to keep yourself safe. It's like I tell the ban people. It's the same reason I know first aid and have a kit, I'd ideally like to call 911 and let the paramedics handle it, but if they fail to arrive, I have options.
I'll probably be called a pussy by a bunch of 14 year old kids. Deal with it. I will keep myself safe, but I'm not going to fuck up my life unless it absolutely cannot be avoided.
This does not apply to people with kids or other family in other rooms, where you may not be able to stay put and may be forced to move to the living room or main hallway to ensure the intruder isn't going after someone else in a different room. In that case, I understand needing to leave the safety of your room to protect others in the house. This is only for a living situation where you live alone or with someone else in the same room.
This is exactly what my plan is and always has been. But prior to locking my bedroom door and having my wife retreat to the bathroom with the phone to call 911, I will be yelling at the intruder that the police are on the way. And if I see him he will be shot on sight. In this state and this day and age if you shoot someone it better be in the best self defense light you can put yourself in. Shooting an intruder that is armed in your living room after you went after him from your bedroom will likely bring a civil lawsuit by the perps family. Retreating to the farthest back part of the house you can and waiting for the police is in my opinion the best way to do this. I have insurance that will cover stuff stolen. But I am terribly afraid of a pending lawsuit by an injured perp that I didn't kill or his family if I did. JMHO
-
Don't go trigger happy assess the situation first.
Dunno if you all know this story....
Japanese foreign exchange student was out partying all night with friends ends up entering the wrong house thinking it was his. The homeowner shot him dead because the Japanese kid can't really speak English well and was intoxicated.
Then there two recent posts on here...
*one where the homeowner shot drugged out kids execution style.
*The other one the guy shot a car full of teenagers out of fear.
Agreed above about the consequences of shooting. If the intruder is not drunk then or very erratic yes I will shot him. If he is drunk or slurring I'll just MMA his ass then again he might have aids.
-
This is exactly what my plan is and always has been. But prior to locking my bedroom door and having my wife retreat to the bathroom with the phone to call 911, I will be yelling at the intruder that the police are on the way. And if I see him he will be shot on sight. In this state and this day and age if you shoot someone it better be in the best self defense light you can put yourself in. Shooting an intruder that is armed in your living room after you went after him from your bedroom will likely bring a civil lawsuit by the perps family. Retreating to the farthest back part of the house you can and waiting for the police is in my opinion the best way to do this. I have insurance that will cover stuff stolen. But I am terribly afraid of a pending lawsuit by an injured perp that I didn't kill or his family if I did. JMHO
Well if you are found innocent on the criminal suit side you should be okay from the civil suit due to Castle Law we now have.
However, if you are found guilty from criminal side, you get sentenced after you get out of jail you deal with civil suit from the family or they have someone waiting for you once you released....
So try not to shoot anyone in the back or kill them execution style. I just shows you as the aggressor rather than someone who is on defense.
-
Dont shoot what you cant see clearly. Owning a gun is a very huge responsibility. Where much is given, much is required. Here in communist Hawaii...... be well trained not only HOW to shoot, but WHEN. Most situations DO NOT call for firing your weapon. Your decision WILL affect us all.
-
Okay. I'll just throw this out there.
Howbout non-lethal weapons in this situation. Such as a baseball bat. Or pepper spray.
Would anybody even consider this as an option for this scenario?
ITT in Hawaii, your typical 3am burglar is probably going to be a chronic high as a kite on ice. Slim chance that he will be packing a firearm. Probably a shitty knife or a shank screwdriver or something. But still, who's willing to take that chance, right?
-
Okay. I'll just throw this out there.
Howbout non-lethal weapons in this situation. Such as a baseball bat. Or pepper spray.
Would anybody even consider this as an option for this scenario?
ITT in Hawaii, your typical 3am burglar is probably going to be a chronic high as a kite on ice. Slim chance that he will be packing a firearm. Probably a shitty knife or a shank screwdriver or something. But still, who's willing to take that chance, right?
if he's jacked on ICE, that's even more reason to grab a gun. you aint gonna do much to a dude on ice with a bat unless you land crippling blows. pain doesnt mean much to a guy who's jacked up on drugs.
-
Okay. I'll just throw this out there.
Howbout non-lethal weapons in this situation. Such as a baseball bat. Or pepper spray.
Would anybody even consider this as an option for this scenario?
ITT in Hawaii, your typical 3am burglar is probably going to be a chronic high as a kite on ice. Slim chance that he will be packing a firearm. Probably a shitty knife or a shank screwdriver or something. But still, who's willing to take that chance, right?
Both reasonable options, but consider...
Using a bat: Are capable of wielding bat in a manner that it won't be taken away and used against you? Do you have the room to use it effectively? Even if there is room, do you want to get close enough to an intruder to use the bat?
Pepper spray: Do you want to deploy that withing the confines of your home? You might as well spray yourself in the face while you're at it.
Nothing wrong with being prepared, but thinking up scenarios (What if this? What if that?) is a sure way of conditioning yourself into a bad situation. Arm youself, but there really is no need to seek confrontation. Your primary concern should be keeping you and your family safe, not wondering how to beat down or confront an intruder.
-
Also be aware that any kind of blunt force weapon directed at long bones or the head constitutes deadly force. You can't bonk someone over the head with a pipe unless it would also be acceptable to shoot them. That being the case, why use a less-effective tool when the consequences of improper employment are the same as the more-lethal option?
-
Both reasonable options, but consider...
Using a bat: Are capable of wielding bat in a manner that it won't be taken away and used against you? Do you have the room to use it effectively? Even if there is room, do you want to get close enough to an intruder to use the bat?
Pepper spray: Do you want to deploy that withing the confines of your home? You might as well spray yourself in the face while you're at it.
Nothing wrong with being prepared, but thinking up scenarios (What if this? What if that?) is a sure way of conditioning yourself into a bad situation. Arm youself, but there really is no need to seek confrontation. Your primary concern should be keeping you and your family safe, not wondering how to beat down or confront an intruder.
As both non-lethal items will make you look good in court they MIGHT NOT BE EFFECTIVE at the time of incident.
Neither will be effective on multiple invaders which is now more common as groups is raiding houses.
Baseball Bat -How many hits to take down someone while the other two flank you
Pepper Spray- one time use?
I still vouch for lethal force of a firearm but you MUST SEE WHAT YOU ARE SHOOTING
-
Okay. I'll just throw this out there.
Howbout non-lethal weapons in this situation. Such as a baseball bat. Or pepper spray.
Would anybody even consider this as an option for this scenario?
ITT in Hawaii, your typical 3am burglar is probably going to be a chronic high as a kite on ice. Slim chance that he will be packing a firearm. Probably a shitty knife or a shank screwdriver or something. But still, who's willing to take that chance, right?
If you indeed shoot him dead and believed that he was high or something make sure you get your lawyer to have them do an autopsy to back your statement up.
Either way if that bullet leaves your gun make sure you talk get a lawyer right away. When you fill those police report and when you finally show up to court the prosecutor will use anything that you wrote down on the report against you.
-
Also be aware that any kind of blunt force weapon directed at long bones or the head constitutes deadly force. You can't bonk someone over the head with a pipe unless it would also be acceptable to shoot them. That being the case, why use a less-effective tool when the consequences of improper employment are the same as the more-lethal option?
The more I read, the more afraid I get. Seems like burglars nowadays can come in your house and take what they want. As long as they don't pose an immediate threat to you or your family. He breaks in your house, steals something. You lock yourself in your room, call 911 and wait for the police.
Am I alone here?
-
The more I read, the more afraid I get. Seems like burglars nowadays can come in your house and take what they want. As long as they don't pose an immediate threat to you or your family. He breaks in your house, steals something. You lock yourself in your room, call 911 and wait for the police.
Am I alone here?
You're not alone. Main reason one is that I don't wanna give up anything...but I'm afraid of losing everything when I'm in court (God knows how much you'll have to spend). I want to make it as clear-cut as possible for the jury, going above and beyond despite Castle Doctrine laws. Hawaii is super liberal, and without a very very VERY strong Castle Doctrine law and a less liberal atmosphere, I'll be retreating to my corner.
Main reason two is with the angles in my house, a populated room would be my backstop. I don't plan on missing, and practice often, but I feel extremely irresponsible positioning myself in a manner in which I couldn't shoot because of family in the background.
-
You're not alone. Main reason one is that I don't wanna give up anything...but I'm afraid of losing everything when I'm in court (God knows how much you'll have to spend). I want to make it as clear-cut as possible for the jury, going above and beyond despite Castle Doctrine laws. Hawaii is super liberal, and without a very very VERY strong Castle Doctrine law and a less liberal atmosphere, I'll be retreating to my corner.
Main reason two is with the angles in my house, a populated room would be my backstop. I don't plan on missing, and practice often, but I feel extremely irresponsible positioning myself in a manner in which I couldn't shoot because of family in the background.
Run. Hide. Fight.
-
As both non-lethal items will make you look good in court they MIGHT NOT BE EFFECTIVE at the time of incident.
Neither will be effective on multiple invaders which is now more common as groups is raiding houses.
Baseball Bat -How many hits to take down someone while the other two flank you
Pepper Spray- one time use?
I still vouch for lethal force of a firearm but you MUST SEE WHAT YOU ARE SHOOTING
True, that's why I only said they are reasonable options (after considering what was presented). Obviously anything less than lethal would be less than effective, in a kill to protect situation. But let me add that no one looks good in court...regardless of circumstances, anything that goes beyond an investigation is never good.
Again, "Arm youself, but there really is no need to seek confrontation." Grab your shotgun, handgun, or whatever else you feel competent to use for defense, then do what Chris said...
Run. Hide. Fight.
-
I just hope that our burglars aren't reading this right now.
Hypothetically speaking.
He breaks in. Steals all my kids' Christmas presents.
I cannot shoot him because my life isn't in danger & I want to avoid costly court consequences (he's just helping himself to our stuff, that's all).
I cannot hit him with a bat because my life isn't in danger & I want to avoid costly court consequences (because assault with a deadly weapon).
I CAN barricade myself in my room and call 911 and by the time the police show up, he'll be long gone.
I MIGHT be able to get into a fistfight with the perpetrator to subdue him until the police show up (seems like the only legal thing I CAN do) but he could possibly KILL ME in doing so.
Am I trying to be a hero and make the front cover of tomorrow's newspaper by stopping the bad guy? No.
Am I trying to "take the law into my own hands"? No.
Are my kids' Christmas presents worth my life or my family's safety? HELL NO.
Will I let him take them as he pleases? That's what I'm trying to figure out.
Would you?
I'm not trying to be a smartass here. I just feel so much more vulnerable now after seeing my fellow gun community's views on this topic.
-
I just hope that our burglars aren't reading this right now.
* They're too busy burglarizing
Hypothetically speaking.
He breaks in. Steals all my kids' Christmas presents.
I cannot shoot him because my life isn't in danger & I want to avoid costly court consequences (he's just helping himself to our stuff, that's all).
*Dead men tell no lies
I cannot hit him with a bat because my life isn't in danger & I want to avoid costly court consequences (because assault with a deadly weapon).
*If you own a gun, you shouldn't even be considering a bat.
I CAN barricade myself in my room and call 911 and by the time the police show up, he'll be long gone.
*Thats an option
I MIGHT be able to get into a fistfight with the perpetrator to subdue him until the police show up (seems like the only legal thing I CAN do) but he could possibly KILL ME in doing so.
*Very stupid idea. Someone breaks into your home with your children and wife home. This is no time for a dick measuring contest.
Am I trying to be a hero and make the front cover of tomorrow's newspaper by stopping the bad guy? No.
Am I trying to "take the law into my own hands"? No.
Are my kids' Christmas presents worth my life or my family's safety? HELL NO.
Will I let him take them as he pleases? That's what I'm trying to figure out.
Would you?
I'm not trying to be a smartass here. I just feel so much more vulnerable now after seeing my fellow gun community's views on this topic.
My opinion.
*Someone breaks in for any reason and my family is home.
1) I get the gun.
2) if I see he's unarmed, I yell. "Get out of here" (most burglars are cowards. They sneak into the house when they think people aren't home. Like roaches, as soon as they're seen, they scurry into their homes.
2b) If he's armed, he gets the gun pointed at him and the obligatory "Drop the weapon.
3a) If he leaves, awesome.
3b) If he doesn't immediately leave or makes any comment other than "OK", he gets the gun pointed at him. (Someone willing to stand there after the homeowner yells at them is no common thief. This type of burglar is a predator. He has assessed the situation, looked at you and defiantly thought in his mind "I can take this guy")
Any time someone is brazen enough to break into your home, your life is already in danger.
Criminals don't think like me and you.
The home burglar is a different breed altogether. Much like a mugger, this is someone in afraid to use violence to steal.
The worst mistake you can make is to underestimate their propensity for violence.
-
My opinion.
*Someone breaks in for any reason and my family is home.
1) I get the gun.
2) if I see he's unarmed, I yell. "Get out of here" (most burglars are cowards. They sneak into the house when they think people aren't home. Like roaches, as soon as they're seen, they scurry into their homes.
2b) If he's armed, he gets the gun pointed at him and the obligatory "Drop the weapon.
3a) If he leaves, awesome.
3b) If he doesn't immediately leave or makes any comment other than "OK", he gets the gun pointed at him. (Someone willing to stand there after the homeowner yells at them is no common thief. This type of burglar is a predator. He has assessed the situation, looked at you and defiantly thought in his mind "I can take this guy")
Any time someone is brazen enough to break into your home, your life is already in danger.
Criminals don't think like me and you.
The home burglar is a different breed altogether. Much like a mugger, this is someone in afraid to use violence to steal.
The worst mistake you can make is to underestimate their propensity for violence.
JMO and fully agree with KK:
Typical thieves are generally cowards and break in and steal your stuff when no one is home and if they make the terrible mistake of breaking in when someone is home and is yielding a weapon in self-defense, yelling “GET THE F%$* OUT OF MY HOUSE, I HAVE A GUN”, or something along those lines, chances are they will run like hell like the cowards they are.
I believe (correct me if I’m wrong) the intent of the “Stand Your Ground” and “Castle Law” (generally speaking) is for the rare cases involving the truly sick bastard, or someone who is out of their mind on drugs, or a crazed ex-husband or boyfriend who truly intends to do bodily harm and is hell-bent of doing so at all costs and will likely not stop the attack no matter what. Even as liberal as Hawaii is I can’t imagine the general public or prosecutor’s office not siding with the victim (homeowner) in this case, even if the use of deadly force was used to stop the threat.
No one wants to shoot anyone just for the hell of it or losing a few items, it’s not worth it and I don’t think warranted or justified. I got to believe most people can clearly tell the difference between the two situations relatively quick. However, sometimes the situation is so dire and life threatening (not your typical burglar) that deadly force is warranted and I believe the state and general public would be on your side. Again JMO.
Does anyone know of a case in Hawaii that applied the Castle Doctrine since it was enacted into Law in 2010? I don’t recall one.
-
JMO and fully agree with KK:
Typical thieves are generally cowards and break in and steal your stuff when no one is home and if they make the terrible mistake of breaking in when someone is home and is yielding a weapon in self-defense, yelling “GET THE F%$* OUT OF MY HOUSE, I HAVE A GUN”, or something along those lines, chances are they will run like hell like the cowards they are.
I believe (correct me if I’m wrong) the intent of the “Stand Your Ground” and “Castle Law” (generally speaking) is for the rare cases involving the truly sick bastard, or someone who is out of their mind on drugs, or a crazed ex-husband or boyfriend who truly intends to do bodily harm and is hell-bent of doing so at all costs and will likely not stop the attack no matter what. Even as liberal as Hawaii is I can’t imagine the general public or prosecutor’s office not siding with the victim (homeowner) in this case, even if the use of deadly force was used to stop the threat.
No one wants to shoot anyone just for the hell of it or losing a few items, it’s not worth it and I don’t think warranted or justified. I got to believe most people can clearly tell the difference between the two situations relatively quick. However, sometimes the situation is so dire and life threatening (not your typical burglar) that deadly force is warranted and I believe the state and general public would be on your side. Again JMO.
Does anyone know of a case in Hawaii that applied the Castle Doctrine since it was enacted into Law in 2010? I don’t recall one.
I think we all agree with this. Just to underscore the point, although you're not justified shooting someone who only wants to steal your laptop, you would be fully justified in pointing a gun at the person while telling them to GTFO. From HRS 703-300:
A threat to cause death or serious bodily injury, by the production of a weapon or otherwise, so long as the actor's intent is limited to creating an apprehension that the actor will use deadly force if necessary, does not constitute deadly force.
If someone has broken into your home, I don't think anyone would fault you for creating an apprehension in the perp's mind that you will use deadly force if necessary. :thumbsup:
-
My opinion.
*Someone breaks in for any reason and my family is home.
1) I get the gun.
2) if I see he's unarmed, I yell. "Get out of here" (most burglars are cowards. They sneak into the house when they think people aren't home. Like roaches, as soon as they're seen, they scurry into their homes.
2b) If he's armed, he gets the gun pointed at him and the obligatory "Drop the weapon.
3a) If he leaves, awesome.
3b) If he doesn't immediately leave or makes any comment other than "OK", he gets the gun pointed at him. (Someone willing to stand there after the homeowner yells at them is no common thief. This type of burglar is a predator. He has assessed the situation, looked at you and defiantly thought in his mind "I can take this guy")
Any time someone is brazen enough to break into your home, your life is already in danger.
Thank you KK. Very well put. THAT was the answer I was looking for.
Reassuring posts by Cougar & Bunker too. Thanks guys.
Now I feel better. :shaka:
-
I just hope that our burglars aren't reading this right now.
Hypothetically speaking.
He breaks in. Steals all my kids' Christmas presents.
I cannot shoot him because my life isn't in danger & I want to avoid costly court consequences (he's just helping himself to our stuff, that's all).
I cannot hit him with a bat because my life isn't in danger & I want to avoid costly court consequences (because assault with a deadly weapon).
I CAN barricade myself in my room and call 911 and by the time the police show up, he'll be long gone.
I MIGHT be able to get into a fistfight with the perpetrator to subdue him until the police show up (seems like the only legal thing I CAN do) but he could possibly KILL ME in doing so.
Am I trying to be a hero and make the front cover of tomorrow's newspaper by stopping the bad guy? No.
Am I trying to "take the law into my own hands"? No.
Are my kids' Christmas presents worth my life or my family's safety? HELL NO.
Will I let him take them as he pleases? That's what I'm trying to figure out.
Would you?
I'm not trying to be a smartass here. I just feel so much more vulnerable now after seeing my fellow gun community's views on this topic.
Good scenario.
How about this
You: I a responsible gun owner protecting my cache of firearms to prevent it from being stolen and be fallen into the wrong hands by which I would be held accountable for.
Lawyer: You have a safe?
You: yes but even with a safe if this intruder is not get caught by authorities there is a huge possibility he might return with friends and steal the whole safe. From that point on if my firearms if being used for crimes that can link back you me so I decided to use lethal force.
-
Good scenario.
How about this
You: I a responsible gun owner protecting my cache of firearms to prevent it from being stolen and be fallen into the wrong hands by which I would be held accountable for.
Lawyer: You have a safe?
You: yes but even with a safe if this intruder is not get caught by authorities there is a huge possibility he might return with friends and steal the whole safe. From that point on if my firearms if being used for crimes that can link back you me so I decided to use lethal force.
JMO: I don't think this would fly in a court of law for many reasons. For starters, I don't see the homeowner in a life threatening situation at the time of invasion if they had ample time to retreat to a secure locked room and call 911, at which time the intruder ran out of the household. Speculating what the criminal may do in the future is pure speculation on the homeowners part, and if the firearms are registered, it is a law enforcement problem if they are stolen. No different than a gun shop getting robbed.
I would determine how the intruder entered and reevaluate my security system if I had one, and if not buy one and possibly install other security countermeasures and deterints, such as sensor flood lights, reinforced doors, etc. Some people who just rent may opt to move. In big inter-cities, many homeowners have security systems and bars on their windows and doors, like caged rats in their own home. Thank God we don't have to live like that in Hawaii. I would also reevaluate my home defense plan and see if it is adequate and be prepared just in case.