2aHawaii
General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: clshade on December 17, 2012, 04:47:21 PM
-
This can't be a new idea but I figured I bring it up.
Has anyone suggested a Federal level CCW and certification program (that supersedes State law) as a possible solution instead of just increased Federal controls on gun ownership?
That would have something in it for everyone. Anti-gunners would be happy knowing that only certified people can (legally) carry and pro-gunners get a universal set of expectations to follow and a certain right to carry if they are followed. The NRA and other organizations like it develop and administer the trainings and provide scholarships for those who cannot afford it. Have class certificate? Pass Federal background check? Can carry - anywhere in the US. Even planes, theaters and schools. Hell, especially planes, theaters and schools.
While such a system probably would not fly in this political climate and has its own drawbacks, it IS a compromise where each side gets and gives something. And pushing it as a solution would give us the opportunity to highlight the many, many stories where violence is prevented, stopped or reduced by the presence of responsible, brave armed citizens.
A well regulated militia - focusing on bearing arms, not just which arms are legal to own. Whadda ya think?
-
Bite your tongue! :o
-
Ha! Terry, you know how many Hawaiians would bum rush such a CCW permit? :)
-
I know. Every time the subject comes up (such as the recent federally-mandated reciprocity proposal) the folks in restrictive states are all ga-ga about it, but the ones from states where "Free Air" abounds hate the notion. (Except for those who frequently travel to restrictive states.)
You don't want the federal government mucking about in concealed carry issues at all, to my mind. Sure, any law as originally written may look like it's acceptable (ha!), but two years down the road, they'll start adding on other certification requirements which are "reasonable," like hitting a ten inch bull at 1000 yards with a rusty World War I 1911 and the like. I exaggerate for the sake of illustration, but... well, maybe I'm not exaggerating.
Camel's noses under your skirts and all that. EEEK!
Terry "No I don't wear skirts, but I can imagine what a camel's nose under there might be like," 230RN
-
I know. Every time the subject comes up (such as the recent federally-mandated reciprocity proposal) the folks in restrictive states are all ga-ga about it, but the ones from states where "Free Air" abounds hate the notion. (Except for those who frequently travel to restrictive states.)
You don't want the federal government mucking about in concealed carry issues at all, to my mind. Sure, any law as originally written may look like it's acceptible (ha!), but two years down the road, they'll start adding on other certification requirements which are "reasonable," like hitting a ten inch bull at 1000 yards with a rusty World War I 1911 and the like. I exaggerate for the sake of illustration, but... well, maybe I'm not exaggerating.
Camel's noses under your skirts and all that. EEEK!
Terry "No I don't wear skirts, but I can imagine what a camel's nose under there might be like," 230RN
I'm with you 1000%, Terry!
-
Interesting idea. But doesn't a compromise here pose a slippery slope? It seems to support a haves vs have-nots scenario.
The second amendment: "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed." What is the correct interpretation here?
Interpretation #1: Does Militia = the people
The 2nd amendment could be read this way... The militia would be a trained group of "people" that would be keeping and bearing arms. A militia should always exist to the security of a free state.
Interpretation #2: militia is not necessarily = to the people.
I'm thinking that the 2nd amendment could be read this way.... "Despite the fact that a militia (military and police) is needed to keep security, regular people's rights to keep and bear arms should not be infringed".
The big difference here is that the 2nd interpretation says that keeping a militia is needed but that non-militia should be able to keep and bear arms anyway in case the militia abuses their power.
The first interpretation says that non-trained people should leave keeping and bearing arms only to those trained. The second interpretation protects the people from the militia while the first interpretation says that the people is the militia.
Pls correct me if I'm wrong... Sorry, clshade... I am probably thinking of something different and missing the point of your OP.
-
Hmmm.... well, it wasn't my intention to rehash the definition of militia just to point out that a federal CCW scheme would nicely fit the description of it.
The way I see it, we already have a federal foot up the arse of the 2nd amendment. The fact that I cannot own or carry the same hardware the military uses is proof enough of that. We all know that a new "assault weapons" ban will have zero net effect on gun related violence. It seems to me that if there is going to be a rising clamor for the fed to do ~something~ to increase public safety we ought to have a ready answer.
Making it legal to CCW everywhere is a ~good~ idea and would have an effect on gun violence. Might not be the best opening salvo in the coming discussion of "gun control" but I haven't yet heard any others.
I think a concerted effort to change the issue from one of "gun control" to "public safety" is a key tactic to making this a meaningful national discussion instead of (yet another) divisive one.
-
Interesting idea. But doesn't a compromise here pose a slippery slope? It seems to support a haves vs have-nots scenario.
The second amendment: "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed." What is the correct interpretation here?
Interpretation #1: Does Militia = the people
The 2nd amendment could be read this way... The militia would be a trained group of "people" that would be keeping and bearing arms. A militia should always exist to the security of a free state.
Interpretation #2: militia is not necessarily = to the people.
I'm thinking that the 2nd amendment could be read this way.... "Despite the fact that a militia (military and police) is needed to keep security, regular people's rights to keep and bear arms should not be infringed".
The big difference here is that the 2nd interpretation says that keeping a militia is needed but that non-militia should be able to keep and bear arms anyway in case the militia abuses their power.
The first interpretation says that non-trained people should leave keeping and bearing arms only to those trained. The second interpretation protects the people from the militia while the first interpretation says that the people is the militia.
Pls correct me if I'm wrong... Sorry, clshade... I am probably thinking of something different and missing the point of your OP.
The militia has nothing whatsoever to do with the right. The first portion is simply a statement of fact which explains the necessity of protecting the right in a constitutional amendment. Professor Eugene Volokh wrote an extensively-researched academic paper on this very subject. (http://www2.law.ucla.edu/volokh/common.htm)
-
I'm with you 1000%, Terry!
+1
-
Imma bite my tongue on this one.
-
I'd be game for Federal Constitutional Carry :)
-
You and I have gone over this before, and we have some irreconcilable viewpoints on things 2A. You seem to take the lawyerly view of it, where "case law" and "precedent" and other weaselly "interpretations" are acceptable.
To me the only "case," the only "precedent," the only "interpretation" is
shall
not
be
infringed.
The only compromise I will take on this matter is that weapons of mass destruction are outside of the purview of the second Amendment --but that depends on one's conception of what is "mass."
I repeat and say again, redundantly and repetitively, over and over. You do not want the Federal Government mucking about in concealed carry issues.
At all.
That's my opinion and I'm stickin' to it.
.
Terry, 230RN
-
Apologies for bringing it up, folks. I suppose I should have known better.
Terry, while I highly agree with you in principle politics doesn't work that way. Never has. Except in the fictitious civics class textbooks we were all fed in school.
We are either saavy to the political process and control it or it will be controlled for us. If the gun control advocacy groups are going to take this to a federal level the we MUST play at a federal level. That gun rights advocacy groups are unwilling to do this other than to block gun control legislation suggests to me that the gun controllers are going to win eventually. There are no "feel good" moments that support our case the way "feel bad" moments support theirs.
So you have concealed carry in your state. Good for you. Does you zero good if (dare I say, when) the Fed passes a law banning civilian carry.
If we are unwilling to secure our rights specifically at the federal level they will eventually be taken away. It has been shown over and over again that a hardline interpretation of the 2nd amendment is an inadequate legal defense against increasing gun control legislation.
-
You and I have gone over this before, and we have some irreconcilable viewpoints on things 2A. You seem to take the lawyerly view of it, where "case law" and "precedent" and other weaselly "interpretations" are acceptable.
To me the only "case," the only "precedent," the only "interpretation" is
shall
not
be
infringed.
The only compromise I will take on this matter is that weapons of mass destruction are outside of the purview of the second Amendment --but that depends on one's conception of what is "mass."
I repeat and say again, redundantly and repetitively, over and over. You do not want the Federal Government mucking about in concealed carry issues.
At all.
That's my opinion and I'm stickin' to it.
.
Terry, 230RN
but that's your interpretation.
the point of case laws and precedents is that it sets an accepted interpretation in writing. without those, we very could have no guns. DC would certainly have no handguns. without case laws and precedents, you leave it open for interpretation, and effectively at the mercy of whichever politicians run the state/country.
-
Apologies for bringing it up, folks. I suppose I should have known better.
Terry, while I highly agree with you in principle politics doesn't work that way. Never has. Except in the fictitious civics class textbooks we were all fed in school.
We are either saavy to the political process and control it or it will be controlled for us. If the gun control advocacy groups are going to take this to a federal level the we MUST play at a federal level. That gun rights advocacy groups are unwilling to do this other than to block gun control legislation suggests to me that the gun controllers are going to win eventually. There are no "feel good" moments that support our case the way "feel bad" moments support theirs.
So you have concealed carry in your state. Good for you. Does you zero good if (dare I say, when) the Fed passes a law banning civilian carry.
If we are unwilling to secure our rights specifically at the federal level they will eventually be taken away. It has been shown over and over again that a hardline interpretation of the 2nd amendment is an inadequate legal defense against increasing gun control legislation.
dont apologize. this brings up an important issue in an oblique way. the second amendment is federal policy. why then, are firearms laws and such generally left to state level decisions. should we allow the states to reinterpret the second amenment how they see fit, or should it go back to a national level regulation?
my opinion? go national. there is no reason why arizona and texas should have laws so different from hawaii, illinois or new jersey. and they should all be less restrictive, of course.
-
The federal government will never tell the individual states what to do concerning CCW. It would open the feds up to liability. Even if the federal government was to have a so called CCW "class" the individual state would still reserve the right to add more restrictions, which hawaii would do. So your federal loop hole " still would not work". The only way is to do it the hard way by continuing to appeal HPD's policy. Hate to pop your bubble but I highly doubt that any form of CCW will ever be approved in hawaii being that it is such a conservative state. If you want to carry concealed join HPD or the Sheriffs.
-
Sorry, but I fail to see how regulation of CCW can be considered an enumerated power of the federal government.
Or, for that matter, other things. Examples abound.
"the second amendment is federal policy"
No, it's law, and not restricted to the Federal govenment. It was really settled as soon as the Bill of Rights was approved, not in recent SCOTUS cases. I submit, for convenience' sake and for emphasis, the words of the Preamble, not to the Constitution, but to the Bill of Rights itself:
Constitution as Ratified by the States
December 15, 1791
Preamble (to the "Bill of Rights," i.e., the first ten amendments))
Congress OF THE United States
begun and held at the City of New York, on Wednesday
the Fourth of March, one thousand seven hundred and eighty nine.
THE Conventions of a number of the States having at the time of their adopting the Constitution, expressed a desire, in order to prevent misconstruction or abuse of its powers, that further declaratory and restrictive clauses should be added: And as extending the ground of public confidence in the Government, will best insure the beneficent ends of its institution
RESOLVED by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America, in Congress assembled, two thirds of both Houses concurring, that the following Articles be proposed to the Legislatures of the several States, as Amendments to the Constitution of the United States, all or any of which Articles, when ratified by three fourths of the said Legislatures, to be valid to all intents and purposes, as part of the said Constitution; viz.:
ARTICLES in addition to, and Amendment of the Constitution of the United States of America, proposed by Congress, and ratified by the Legislatures of the several States, pursuant to the fifth Article of the original Constitution.
Repeated for truth:
...expressed a desire, in order to prevent misconstruction or abuse of its powers, that further declaratory and restrictive clauses should be added...
Read 'em and weep.
And undertand that even the States' CCW provisions are unconstitutional.
Hence the term "Constitutional Carry."
And I add, after a succession of past compromises over 2A (among other things), where do the compromises end?
Terry, 230RN
-
Concealed carry has nothing to do with the 2nd amendment. Concealed carry is "allowed" and "regulated" by the individual states. Your constitutional right to keep and bear arms is fulfilled by the states by allowing you to own a gun. No where in the constitution does it say it is your constitutional right to carry a concealed firearm. Sorry, I'm all for CCW but there is a smarter way to fight for it. Anything federally regulated is bad especially anything concerning CCW.
-
Well, this is kind of my point.
We have the RIGHTto bear arms, however, nowhere is that right adequately defined. In the absence of that definition the right to bear arms has been defined by restriction over the years, both federally and by the various states and municipalities that have chosen to.
If we change the conversation from which guns we can and cannot own to what is the enforcable definition of the right to bear arms there may be fertile ground for a public process that perserves our rights and explicitly raises public safety. Federal law can and does superceed all other levels if the law is written that way.
That puts the good side of gun ownership and the right to carry at the forefront of the discussion: in most cases it is ONLY armed citizens that have a chance at stopping a mass murderer. And having a potentially armed populace in all public places might well stop the mass murders from even being attempted.
We all know this. An explicit, federally protected right to CCW is a valid answer to the question of "how do we keep these mass murders from happening. Whether it happens or not is less important than changing the conversation from how guns make us less safe to how guns make us more safe.
-
Concealed carry has nothing to do with the 2nd amendment
.
I'm sorry, say again? I don't think I heard that correctly.
Concealed carry is "allowed" and "regulated" by the individual states. Your constitutional right to keep and bear arms is fulfilled by the states by allowing you to own a gun. No where in the constitution does it say it is your constitutional right to carry a concealed firearm.
So why are there cases challenging CCW laws on Constitutional grounds?
Sorry, I'm all for CCW but there is a smarter way to fight for it. Anything federally regulated is bad especially anything concerning CCW.
Ok. But look up the word "infringed."
-
Argh. I'm not quite saying what I'm trying to say...
Let me try to put it more clearly.
Right now the only public discussion about firearms and gun violence goes like this:
"Guns are dangerous! We need to have fewer of them in order to keep our kids safe!"
"No, we don't."
The gun lobby offers no comprensive solution, no legal clarification, nothing except "no."
That is a long term failing strategy as any study of the trend in gun control legislation will show you.
I'm not argueing FOR CCW. I'm arguing for a different tack in how the gun lobby goes about defending the right to keep and bear arms. Federal CCW might not be it but if we don't cahnge something in our strategy I'm pretty sure what is left of the 2nd ammendment will continue to be erroded away.
-
Sorry, but I fail to see how regulation of CCW can be considered an enumerated power of the federal government.
Or, for that matter, other things. Examples abound.
"the second amendment is federal policy"
No, it's law, and not restricted to the Federal govenment. It was really settled as soon as the Bill of Rights was approved, not in recent SCOTUS cases. I submit, for convenience' sake and for emphasis, the words of the Preamble, not to the Constitution, but to the Bill of Rights itself:
Repeated for truth:
...expressed a desire, in order to prevent misconstruction or abuse of its powers, that further declaratory and restrictive clauses should be added...
Read 'em and weep.
And undertand that even the States' CCW provisions are unconstitutional.
Hence the term "Constitutional Carry."
And I add, after a succession of past compromises over 2A (among other things), where do the compromises end?
Terry, 230RN
a policy is a law. and by federal, i mean it was enacted at the federal, aka national, level. which it is.
what i meant is, the 2nd amendment extends to every state because it was established at the federal level. its not up to the states.
i dont need a lesson on the bill of rights.
-
.
I'm sorry, say again? I don't think I heard that correctly.
So why are there cases challenging CCW laws on Constitutional grounds?
Ok. But look up the word "infringed."
how can something be infringed upon when there is no consensus as to how far those rights extend, because they are vaguely worded and open to interpretations?
that's his point. nothing is strictly defined, so its up to people, not just YOU to interpret it. and how its interpreted changes whether or not your rights are being infringed. concealed carry nor open carry are either explicitly stated, so unless there is a consensus at the legislative or judiciary level, no, your rights arent being infringed just because you interpret it differently. the only solution, is to gain a consensus and get a SPECIFICALLY written law, so the next time, you can claim that indeed your rights are being infringed on if you arent allowed to carry in state.
-
Concealed carry has nothing to do with the 2nd amendment. Concealed carry is "allowed" and "regulated" by the individual states. Your constitutional right to keep and bear arms is fulfilled by the states by allowing you to own a gun. No where in the constitution does it say it is your constitutional right to carry a concealed firearm. Sorry, I'm all for CCW but there is a smarter way to fight for it. Anything federally regulated is bad especially anything concerning CCW.
You have to read further into the Constitution, specifically the part of Amendment Número Dos that comes after the word "keep".
-
You have to read further into the Constitution, specifically the part of Amendment Número Dos that comes after the word "keep".
Like how xer 21 said. It's the interpretation of it that matters. The only ones allowed to interpret the constitution is the US Supreme Court. Remember, we are in the 9th circuit, the most liberal and reserved of all the circuits.
-
Lordy, lordy, how can you misinterpret "shall not be infringed?"
Let me try to put it more clearly.
Right now the only public discussion about firearms and gun violence goes like this:
"Guns are dangerous! We need to have fewer of them in order to keep our kids safe!"
"No, we don't."
The gun lobby offers no comprensive solution, no legal clarification, nothing except "no."
That is a long term failing strategy as any study of the trend in gun control legislation will show you.
I'm not blind to current events, but neither am I blind to the inevitable result of compromise after compromise after compromise. You know the clearly and often stated end game on that process: no guns for private citizens except in extremely limited circumstances, like .22LRs for farmers...
History shows this unequivocally and forcefully... and in "free" countries, to boot. Viz England and Australia.
The point is, we should be arguing from the standpoint of the ultimate necessity for private firearms ownership. It doesn't take a crystal ball to see that an unarmed citizenry is vulnerable to tyranny --it only takes a the briefest review of real history. And recent history, at that.
I disagree that "No, we don't" is our only answer to today's challenges. Some folks are becoming cognizant of many possible other causes for the "snapping" of individuals --the drugs they've been prescribed, the video games, economic frustration, lack of competent parenting, etc, etc, etc. Of course MDs and video gamers (etc) will challenge those assertions, but I think things like that are being examined. Even if not by our lockbrained mass media.
And indeed, even the "gun lobby" has made compromises.
Too damned many of them.
Terry, 230RN
-
The point is, we should be arguing from the standpoint of the ultimate necessity for private firearms ownership. It doesn't take a crystal ball to see that an unarmed citizenry is vulnerable to tyranny --it only takes a the briefest review of real history. And recent history, at that.
no, we shouldnt because if you keep reacting to one extreme by going to the complete opposite extreme, when the majority outnumbers you, you're setting yourself up to lose.
It doesn't take a crystal ball to see that an unarmed citizenry is vulnerable to tyranny...FOR YOU.
stop acting like you're the majority. you're not. most people dont think like you, and you arent going to change that beating them over the head with the opinions they've already tuned out.
-
how can something be infringed upon when there is no consensus as to how far those rights extend, because they are vaguely worded and open to interpretations?
that's his point. nothing is strictly defined, so its up to people, not just YOU to interpret it. and how its interpreted changes whether or not your rights are being infringed. concealed carry nor open carry are either explicitly stated, so unless there is a consensus at the legislative or judiciary level, no, your rights arent being infringed just because you interpret it differently. the only solution, is to gain a consensus and get a SPECIFICALLY written law, so the next time, you can claim that indeed your rights are being infringed on if you arent allowed to carry in state.
Bear. Grizzly bear. Panda bear. Bear, bear, bear. Everyone knows what those words mean; it's the reason the liberals dreamed up the "collective right" crap. They knew what the words said, and what they meant, and they knew that if they admitted that the right applies to individual citizens, then keep would mean "have", bear would mean "carry", and arms would mean "weapons and tools of war". It only seems hazy and unclear because you've been assaulted with 24/7 propaganda that it's hazy and unclear. It's crystal clear, but if the grabbers can convince people that it's written in Cuneiform and that nobody really knows what it means, they can pretend it means anything they want.
-
First, Terry, I think you know and I've said before - I completely agree with you and your assessment of the 2nd amendment. I, at least, don't think that is up for too much discussion as a principle as the founding fathers were very clear why they included the 2nd amendment in the first place.
I don't think any of us would want to define the 2nd amendment more narrowly than it defines itself. That's why we're all on a 2a forum.
Hardline constitutional interpretation is popular with a segment of the population - right, left and center. It makes sense, it feels right, simpler is better, etc. And... the nations actual laws, for better or worse, blow that ideal out of the water. It simply isn't the way ANY aspect of the constitution is handled. The nation's laws, codes and policies take up volumes and all of that is based on refinements, interpretations and implementations of the what the constitution mandates and allows for. And, as we all know, does NOT allow. (NDAA's indefinite detention, the various states that flat out deny any right to bear arms except for sport, etc.)
The Constitution lays out the various branches, their powers, how they are to be elected or appointed, etc. It also lays out a number of operating principles and a few procedural bits. It says VERY little about how to implement the operating principles - by design. Implementation is left up to the legislature to figure out and adjust over time as needed. It is one of the great strengths of our constitution that it is flexible and adaptable.
The 2nd amendment has thus been legislated INTO the narrow implementation it now "enjoys." What I am suggesting is that we may need to legislate it OUT of that narrow implementation.
-
The 2nd amendment has thus been legislated INTO the narrow implementation it now "enjoys." What I am suggesting is that we may need to legislate it OUT of that narrow implementation.
This....is a good point.
-
Okay. I'm convinced. Let's re-legislate CCW on a federal level with a 1000+ page law with all kinds of hooks and barbs in it that nobody finds until it's too late.
You know what happens when legislators and lawyers get their hands on a noble idea. Camels' noses under tent flaps, and all that.
But I repeat and say again, redundantly and repetitively, over and over. You do not want the Federal Government mucking about in concealed carry issues.
Horses. Water. And all that there.
Terry, 230RN
-
The 2nd amendment has thus been legislated INTO the narrow implementation it now "enjoys." What I am suggesting is that we may need to legislate it OUT of that narrow implementation.
There is always, the better but more difficult way; delegislate it out of that narrow implementation.
More laws keep the lawyers and politicians in business and in power. Let's put that power back into the hands of the people.
-
There is always, the better but more difficult way; delegislate it out of that narrow implementation.
More laws keep the lawyers and politicians in business and in power. Let's put that power back into the hands of the people.
How would you delegislate it?
-
Delegislation is indeed to best way to do it: repealing the laws that are infringing on the 2nd amendment.
Repealing laws is incredibly difficult.
Which is part of why I'm suggesting the pro gun lobby should be considering supporting pro gun laws.
Let's drop the idea of federal CCW for the moment and consider instead the wave of states that passed "Confiscation of firearms in an emergency is forbidden" laws. This is a pro-gun law that specifically protects the right to keep arms even if a panicking law enforcement agency would rather disarm everyone.
You can also amend laws. For example, you could amend the NFA to include specific protections for ownership of firearms NOT otherwise controlled by the NFA.
-
Bear. Grizzly bear. Panda bear. Bear, bear, bear. Everyone knows what those words mean; it's the reason the liberals dreamed up the "collective right" crap. They knew what the words said, and what they meant, and they knew that if they admitted that the right applies to individual citizens, then keep would mean "have", bear would mean "carry", and arms would mean "weapons and tools of war". It only seems hazy and unclear because you've been assaulted with 24/7 propaganda that it's hazy and unclear. It's crystal clear, but if the grabbers can convince people that it's written in Cuneiform and that nobody really knows what it means, they can pretend it means anything they want.
no, it seems hazy and unclear, because its hazy and unclear. it says absolutely nothing about concealed carry, nor does it spell out whether or not bearing arms is situational, or free game, whenever, wherever. they interpret it one way, you interpret it another, but neither is a strict definition, its an interpretation based essentially on guessing and personal beliefs.
as others have said, its intentionally vague. you werent there when they wrote it, and neither were anti gun people. at best, you're all guessing, unless you've been having secret conversations with the ghosts of the founding fathers.