2aHawaii

General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: changemyoil66 on January 24, 2024, 08:50:23 AM

Title: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 24, 2024, 08:50:23 AM
Hearing is on 1/26/24 3pm. Testimony is due 24 hours prior or it will be marked late.

https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/session/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=SB&billnumber=2346&year=2024

Click on the orange button "submit testimony".

To read the bill, click on the bill number on the right.

You have to log into your account to submit testimony

This bill will allocate more money to host more gun buy backs.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: hvybarrels on January 24, 2024, 11:31:18 AM
*oppose*
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: Direjackalope on January 24, 2024, 07:46:50 PM
Done
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: rpoL98 on January 24, 2024, 08:25:32 PM
yeah, like the bad guys are gonna turn in their Glocks and suddenly go out and get jobs and become upstanding citizens.  this is wasteful use of our tax-payer dollars.  Somebody has been hitting that crack pipe again, wrong pipe dream.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: QUIETShooter on January 24, 2024, 08:36:31 PM
The day of reckoning will come.  Politicians will be running around, sh*tting their pants as the whole state is being overrun by criminals.

LE will be hiding at home, arguing they need to protect their family (they are the only ones with the scary black guns thanks to some stupid laws passed by the sh*theads called politicians).

The politicians will look at us, the law abiding citizens.  "What are you looking at us for?  You made your bed, now sleep in it."

Bye Bye, MADDAH FACKAH..... :rofl:
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on January 24, 2024, 08:44:31 PM
From the Cato institute -- at least read the last paragraph:

GBP = Gun Buy-back Program

Quote
The theoretical effect of a GBP on firearm‐​related violence is unclear. GBPs may
reduce gun crime if criminals who would otherwise commit firearm‐​related crime
sell their firearms to local governments and eschew criminal activity. Moreover, GBPs
may also reduce gun crime if law‐​abiding individuals sell their firearms, reducing the
supply of guns available for theft by potential criminals. Finally, a reduction in the
supply of firearms could reduce firearm‐​related suicides if such acts are impulsive
and influenced by the ease of firearm access at a time of high emotion.

On the other hand, GBPs may fail for a number of reasons. First, if the price that
city governments are willing to pay gun owners is generally less than the value of
the firearm, a relatively small number of firearms may be collected. Second, if criminals
believe that law‐​abiding citizens (and potential victims) are relinquishing their firearms,
they may be more willing to commit gun crimes following a GBP. Moreover, if GBPs
induce owners to turn in older firearms that are not well‐​functioning and the income
gained from the sale of the firearm is used to purchase newer, more effective guns,
firearm‐​related violence could rise. Finally, repeated GBP programs may permanently
lower the cost of owning a firearm, also leading to an increase in newer firearm purchases.

While policymakers are fiercely debating whether to implement GBPs, little is known
about their effectiveness. Our research is the first to present credible causal estimates on
 the effects of GBPs in the United States. We highlight three key findings. First, using data
from the 1991–2015 National Incident‐​Based Reporting System, we found no evidence
that GBPs are effective at deterring gun crime in either the short‐​or long‐​run. The precision
of our estimates is such that we can rule out decreases in gun crime of 1.2 percent or more
in the 12 months following a GBP and 2.3 percent or more one year after a GBP and beyond.
Second, in the two months following a GBP, we detected a small increase in gun crimes with
no corresponding change in nongun crimes. This finding is consistent with a possible criminal
response to perceptions about the likelihood of self‐​defense among law‐​abiding gun owners.
Finally, turning to data from the National Vital Statistics System, we found no evidence that
GBPs affected firearm‐​related suicides or homicides.

We conclude that GBPs are an ineffective policy strategy to reduce gun violence, a finding
consistent with descriptive evidence that firearm sales prices are set too low by cities to appreciably
reduce the local supply of firearms, most GBP participants are drawn from populations with low
crime risk, and firearms sold in GBPs tend to be older and less well‐​functioning than the average
firearm.

https://www.cato.org/research-briefs-economic-policy/have-us-gun-buyback-programs-misfired

My take: there is no statistical or otherwise objective data that supports the belief that buying guns from the public with tax-payer monies has any effect at all on crime, much less gun crime.  In fact, many post-buy-back statistics show a rise in crime, including gun crimes, which contradicts the program supporters' claims that they reduce crime. 

Until there is data showing a measurable benefit to these gun buy-back programs, it would be wasteful and a misuse of public funds for the state to financially support such programs.

Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: QUIETShooter on January 24, 2024, 09:21:37 PM
Gun Buy Backs are a Dog and Pony Show.

A Flash in the Pan maneuver that does nothing but give the impression that they are reducing gun violence.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: zippz on January 24, 2024, 09:30:58 PM
I don't have a problem with voluntary gun buybacks as they serve a purpose.  It's usually for people that inherit guns or don't want them anymore.  If a person doesn't want the gun and doesn't know how to handle or store it safely, it may be better to get rid of it especially if they have kids.  There are problems with kids getting the guns and taking them to school or committing suicide with them.  Or there's people with unregistered guns that don't know what to do with it.

A case can be made that taxpayer money shouldn't be involved.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on January 24, 2024, 10:00:40 PM
I don't have a problem with voluntary gun buybacks as they serve a purpose.  It's usually for people that inherit guns or don't want them anymore.  If a person doesn't want the gun and doesn't know how to handle or store it safely, it may be better to get rid of it especially if they have kids.  There are problems with kids getting the guns and taking them to school or committing suicide with them.  Or there's people with unregistered guns that don't know what to do with it.

A case can be made that taxpayer money shouldn't be involved.

Then they should start a recycling program.  Pretending the people turning in guns they inherited or don't want are not the people the buy-backs supposedly want to turn in their guns.

This is the rationale they put in the bill:
Quote
The legislature finds that Hawaii has seen a significant increase in incidents
of gun violence, a trend that until recently was primarily confined to the
continental United States.  Acts of gun violence are becoming a regular occurrence
in local communities.  The overwhelming success of a recent gun buyback event on
Oahu by the department of law enforcement illustrates the demand of the public to
get guns off of the State's streets, with a total of four hundred ninety-four firearms
being turned in, including sawed-off shotguns, a MAC‑10, an Uzi, pistols with silencers,
and multiple assault weapons, such as AK-47 and AR-15 type rifles.  The program
provides a service and avenue for the public to turn in unwanted firearms, limits the
number of firearms entering the black market, and reduces violent crimes, accidental
shootings, and the risk of a firearm being brought into a school.

According to all studies, there is no evidence to support the black market, reduced violent crime, accidental shootings and guns in schools claims.

What does happen is guns that can't be legally transferred and/or no longer have any resale value are surrendered.  Also, as said, anyone with a gun who acquired it via inheritance surrender them probably because they had an emotional attachment keeping them from selling them on the private market or don't know the laws well enough to comfortably sell them. 

Simply listing the numbers and types of guns turned in is not evidence of effectiveness.  The objectives listed have nothing to do with numbers or types.  I would challenge them to show proof the previous buy-backs had any measurable impact on crime, violence, guns in schools or accidents.

Dad has a gun.  Dad turns in gun for gift card.  Dad uses that $100 he would have spent on food for a better, more modern gun. 

Kid still has potential access...
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: zippz on January 24, 2024, 10:15:09 PM
Then they should start a recycling program.  Pretending the people turning in guns they inherited or don't want are not the people the buy-backs supposedly want to turn in their guns.

This is the rationale they put in the bill:
According to all studies, there is no evidence to support the black market, reduced violent crime, accidental shootings and guns in schools claims.

What does happen is guns that can't be legally transferred and/or no longer have any resale value are surrendered.  Also, as said, anyone with a gun who acquired it via inheritance surrender them probably because they had an emotional attachment keeping them from selling them on the private market or don't know the laws well enough to comfortably sell them. 

Simply listing the numbers and types of guns turned in is not evidence of effectiveness.  The objectives listed have nothing to do with numbers or types.  I would challenge them to show proof the previous buy-backs had any measurable impact on crime, violence, guns in schools or accidents.

Dad has a gun.  Dad turns in gun for gift card.  Dad uses that $100 he would have spent on food for a better, more modern gun. 

Kid still has potential access...

It's hard to quantify the effectiveness of a buy back since the amount of guns turned in is relatively minute.  But it's still a community service and people do want that service with the turnout from the last one.  I'm guessing they were grateful for the service and I'm not really concerned with what they do with their guns.  The other alternative is for people to turn them into the police, but many of them would be scared to do so and not get anything back for their gun.

If you want to help these people, put together a video, website, or flyer on how they can register and sell their guns.  It'll keep the guns from getting destroyed and have a new life while the owners get better value from them.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on January 25, 2024, 12:51:48 AM
It's hard to quantify the effectiveness of a buy back since the amount of guns turned in is relatively minute.  But it's still a community service and people do want that service with the turnout from the last one.  I'm guessing they were grateful for the service and I'm not really concerned with what they do with their guns.  The other alternative is for people to turn them into the police, but many of them would be scared to do so and not get anything back for their gun.

If you want to help these people, put together a video, website, or flyer on how they can register and sell their guns.  It'll keep the guns from getting destroyed and have a new life while the owners get better value from them.

Who said I want to help these people?  Anyone who finds themselves in possession of a firearm that they do not want have but to contact the police station to learn what options they have.  There's no need for a program to hand them a Safeway card using tax dollars when they would have opted to surrender the firearm regardless of any incentive.

If anonymity is a benefit, then host a "no questions asked" amnesty day for gun turn-in.  No gift cards needed, just the benefit of getting rid of something you might think could cause legal problems.

Instead of gift cards or events, just have an amnesty box installed at the police station where you can securely and anonymously deposit unwanted firearms -- something like a bank night deposit drop box that makes sure the guns are not accessible outside. 

Having a turn-in day once or twice a year, or even monthly, may not be days on which everyone who wants to can show up.

There are all kinds of solutions that can provide this "service" without holding a periodic one-day event where everyone waiting in line gets to see who is trying to turn in their guns anonymously.   :crazy:
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: Shoboshi on January 25, 2024, 02:23:39 AM
Submitted.

Thanks for also including if oppose or against and a generalized what to write about. Have to walk the horse right up to the water. I find my friends are more likely to submit a testimony if you make it as painless and easy as possible.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: oldfart on January 25, 2024, 02:54:53 AM
 If I were running the program, I would have some knowledgeable volunteer community members inspect the guns before destruction.
The reason for that is to try to prevent some possibly valuable piece of historical significance from being destroyed.
It would be the same thing as having an archeological survey done before bringing in bulldozers to build another Walmart.
https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/1741983/remains-at-wal-mart-site-to-be-reburied/
This a common practice here.

If a piece were found to be particularly valuable, it could be sold to benefit the family that turned it in or the proceeds from the sale could be used to finance another turn-in event.
King Kalakaua's rifle was on display at the Bishop Museum.
Some historic guns are on display at Iolani Palace. Some are on display at the US Army Museum in Waikiki.
https://www.hawaiianairlines.com/hawaii-stories/hana-hou/articles/issue-26-6/the-guns-of-yesteryear

I don't see the harm in this "turn-in" program, except for the cost.
I would not call it a "buy-back" though. The term "Buy-Back" implies that the government or police sold it first.
That's just plain incorrect and it gives the wrong impression to the public.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on January 25, 2024, 04:02:17 AM
If I were running the program, I would have some knowledgeable volunteer community members inspect the guns before destruction.
The reason for that is to try to prevent some possibly valuable piece of historical significance from being destroyed.
It would be the same thing as having an archeological survey done before bringing in bulldozers to build another Walmart.
https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/1741983/remains-at-wal-mart-site-to-be-reburied/
This a common practice here.

If a piece were found to be particularly valuable, it could be sold to benefit the family that turned it in or the proceeds from the sale could be used to finance another turn-in event.
King Kalakaua's rifle was on display at the Bishop Museum.
Some historic guns are on display at Iolani Palace. Some are on display at the US Army Museum in Waikiki.
https://www.hawaiianairlines.com/hawaii-stories/hana-hou/articles/issue-26-6/the-guns-of-yesteryear

I don't see the harm in this "turn-in" program, except for the cost.
I would not call it a "buy-back" though. The term "Buy-Back" implies that the government or police sold it first.
That's just plain incorrect and it gives the wrong impression to the public.

Then there are the obvious problems which other gun buy-back programs have experienced, because the laws and rules let it happen.

New York changes gun buyback after
seller gets $21,000 for 3D-printed parts

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/oct/11/new-york-gun-buyback-rules-3d-printed-parts

Gun buy-backs are designed to get weapons off the streets.
So why are the guns coming back?

Quote
The buy-backs, often funded by charity, give people an incentive to get rid of guns that
could result in accidents, suicides or crimes, and make sure they don’t end up back on
the streets.

But reporting by the New York Times’ Mike McIntire reveals that that’s not always what
happens. Instead, companies promising free gun destruction are using a legal loophole
to destroy only a small part of each gun and sell the other parts online, often resulting
in guns going right back into the community.
https://www.vpm.org/npr-news/2024-01-15/gun-buy-backs-are-designed-to-get-weapons-off-the-streets-so-why-are-the-guns-coming-back

My biggest concern is the resulting opportunity cost of these programs.

What other, more effective, likely more expensive programs or efforts are being sidelined while touting the reduction in "guns on the streets" from buy-backs?  Efforts that could actually be reducing violence, stopping crime, and preventing suicide could benefit from the added funds and resources, but instead, we are funding a "disposal service" for guns that will most likely never be used to harm anyone.

If you had to guess, how many people turning in old, nonfunctional or otherwise unwanted guns they can't/don't want to sell also have more guns at home?  Those people turning in a few junkers for free stuff won't stop any of the problems like black market sales, homicides, suicides, guns at school, etc.

I don't think government should offer these kinds of "services" for the public even without freebies offered.  There are plenty of anti-gun groups raising millions to get anti-gun candidates elected to office.  They can certainly afford to provide this service to the public on an on-going basis with private donations.

If the program really does help solve all these gun problems, you'd think they would already be setting up volunteer-run collection centers rather than demanding gov't use our taxes to do it.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: aletheuo137 on January 25, 2024, 07:15:42 AM
Done

Sent from my moto g power (2021) using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: stangzilla on January 25, 2024, 07:45:11 AM
Done

Sent from my moto g power (2021) using Tapatalk
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: zippz on January 25, 2024, 07:48:27 AM
I don't see the harm in this "turn-in" program, except for the cost.
I would not call it a "buy-back" though. The term "Buy-Back" implies that the government or police sold it first.
That's just plain incorrect and it gives the wrong impression to the public.

I'd suggest they inspect the guns and for the servicable and high value ones, they sell it to fund the program.  Though they'd never actually go for it.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: randay on January 25, 2024, 08:48:55 AM
For anyone in support of gun buyback events, specifically for people with legitimate reasons to turn in firearms, consider that there is no need for a huge politicized event to get this done. Those people who need to turn in firearms for legitimate reasons should be able to do so at any time at HPD.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: zippz on January 25, 2024, 09:16:18 AM
For anyone in support of gun buyback events, specifically for people with legitimate reasons to turn in firearms, consider that there is no need for a huge politicized event to get this done. Those people who need to turn in firearms for legitimate reasons should be able to do so at any time at HPD.

You have to put yourself in the minds of these people.  A lot of them know nothing about guns and/or firearms laws.  Many of them are probably afraid and don't know what to do with the gun.

A lot of people aren't going to HPD to turn them in.  Technically they could be arrested for turning in unregistered guns to HPD and they'd be afraid of that happening though we know HPD wouldn't do that.  I don't know if HPD will take a gun from an anonymous person with no questions asked.  These people need assurances that it will be anonymous with no questions asked and they will not be arrested or blamed.  Making it a big public event with a lot of people in a similar circumstance gives them assurances they will not be harmed
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: randay on January 25, 2024, 09:27:54 AM
You have to put yourself in the minds of these people.  A lot of them know nothing about guns and/or firearms laws.  Many of them are probably afraid and don't know what to do with the gun.

A lot of people aren't going to HPD to turn them in.  Technically they could be arrested for turning in unregistered guns to HPD and they'd be afraid of that happening though we know HPD wouldn't do that.  I don't know if HPD will take a gun from an anonymous person with no questions asked.  These people need assurances that it will be anonymous with no questions asked and they will not be arrested or blamed.  Making it a big public event with a lot of people in a similar circumstance gives them assurances they will not be harmed

None of that justifies a gun buyback to me. They can easily run news articles/advertisements stating the facts, same way they advertise the gun buyback. also, HPD should not take guns anonymously with no questions asked. questions need to be asked. laws need to be enforced. the whole amnesty part is the worst part of gun buybacks. thats why i say legitimate reasons, like inherited guns from dead relatives. or they have the gun legally and are old and none of thier family wants them, or they dont want to deal with it. thats what voluntary means to me. Anything else is just a get out of jail card, with a nice little $200 gift card on top. makes absolutely no sense to me. Pretty soon itll be, do a crime and get a gift card. Just robbed a persons home? Heres $500 GC for costco! rediculous if you ask me.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: QUIETShooter on January 25, 2024, 09:39:10 AM
Anonymous?  The recent "gun buy back" was a circus with media all over the place.  They even interviewed some people.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: ren on January 25, 2024, 09:39:35 AM
If a person committed a crime with a gun and turns it in, is the gun not considered evidence?
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: randay on January 25, 2024, 09:46:44 AM
If a person committed a crime with a gun and turns it in, is the gun not considered evidence?

apparently you get a free pass. just wait till they announce the next gun buyback and go make anykind, youll never be caught.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 25, 2024, 10:24:02 AM
Then they should start a recycling program.  Pretending the people turning in guns they inherited or don't want are not the people the buy-backs supposedly want to turn in their guns.



Dude, they gonna do a HI5 tax. Every gun is taxed another $50 and $10 which goes into a "buy back" fund.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 25, 2024, 10:26:06 AM
If I were running the program, I would have some knowledgeable volunteer community members inspect the guns before destruction.
The reason for that is to try to prevent some possibly valuable piece of historical significance from being destroyed.
It would be the same thing as having an archeological survey done before bringing in bulldozers to build another Walmart.
https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/1741983/remains-at-wal-mart-site-to-be-reburied/
This a common practice here.

If a piece were found to be particularly valuable, it could be sold to benefit the family that turned it in or the proceeds from the sale could be used to finance another turn-in event.
King Kalakaua's rifle was on display at the Bishop Museum.
Some historic guns are on display at Iolani Palace. Some are on display at the US Army Museum in Waikiki.
https://www.hawaiianairlines.com/hawaii-stories/hana-hou/articles/issue-26-6/the-guns-of-yesteryear

I don't see the harm in this "turn-in" program, except for the cost.
I would not call it a "buy-back" though. The term "Buy-Back" implies that the government or police sold it first.
That's just plain incorrect and it gives the wrong impression to the public.

TX had someone do this.  Brandon Herera had a vid about it. He was outside trying to buy guns with cash since he's a FFL.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 25, 2024, 10:27:00 AM
Anyone who stated they got rid of an old gun they no longer use for safety is full of shit. What they did was hold out to get compensated.  If safety really was their concern, they could easily drop it off at HPD.  Greed is what kept them from doing so.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on January 25, 2024, 10:32:54 AM
Anyone who stated they got rid of an old gun they no longer use for safety is full of shit. What they did was hold out to get compensated.  If safety really was their concern, they could easily drop it off at HPD.  Greed is what kept them from doing so.
That, or the gun laws here are so prohibitive, they were concerned they might be in trouble turning in a gun that's not properly registered to them, might not be legal to have, they aren't permitted to possess due to a pot conviction, etc.

A promise of "no questions asked" removes the fear barrier.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on January 25, 2024, 10:33:46 AM
Dude, they gonna do a HI5 tax. Every gun is taxed another $50 and $10 which goes into a "buy back" fund.

Didn't consider that.

Never mind.   :wacko:
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on January 25, 2024, 10:39:06 AM
If a person committed a crime with a gun and turns it in, is the gun not considered evidence?

Saw this on an episode of Blue Bloods.

Someone turned in a firearm at a "no questions asked" buy-back, and a Cop working the event recognized the gun.  It was used in multiple homicides, and the Cop tried to question the owner about it. 

The venue (I think a church) told the officer to stop, and eventually the police chief had to decide whether it was worth violating the promise of anonymity to potentially close several major cases and possibly arrest the perp.

They decided if they didn't honor the promise, it would create distrust in future gun owners when turning in guns.

Tough call to make, but they should understand what they potentially agreed to when they made the promise.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: oldfart on January 25, 2024, 11:19:33 AM
Who is Oscar Guzman?
...
My name is Oscar Guzman, and I am pleased to announce that I will be your new NRA ILA Information Specialist for Hawaii. I look forward to keeping you informed and updated on the latest news and developments surrounding Second Amendment policies in Hawaii.

I’m a staunch supporter of the Second Amendment and have always supported my fellow citizens’ right to keep and bear arms. I believe the skills and experience I accrued during college and in my professional endeavors will help me to positively contribute to efforts to promote the Second Amendment in Hawaii.

I’m proud to represent the NRA ILA Grassroots Division and am eager to communicate with you in the near future. You may be receiving “update emails”, calls, or alerts for further personal insights to help all of us reach a common goal- protecting The Second Amendment!

 
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: oldfart on January 25, 2024, 11:31:28 AM
Saw this on an episode of Blue Bloods.

Someone turned in a firearm at a "no questions asked" buy-back, and a Cop working the event recognized the gun.  It was used in multiple homicides, and the Cop tried to question the owner about it. 

....
Blue Bloods -with Tom Selleck. :thumbsup: :D
Tom is a friend of the 2A.
Back in the day when he was here doing Magnum P.I. I went to the Diamond Head studios, had lunch and sold Tom a holster for his 45 auto.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 25, 2024, 11:49:17 AM
Saw this on an episode of Blue Bloods.

Someone turned in a firearm at a "no questions asked" buy-back, and a Cop working the event recognized the gun.  It was used in multiple homicides, and the Cop tried to question the owner about it. 

The venue (I think a church) told the officer to stop, and eventually the police chief had to decide whether it was worth violating the promise of anonymity to potentially close several major cases and possibly arrest the perp.

They decided if they didn't honor the promise, it would create distrust in future gun owners when turning in guns.

Tough call to make, but they should understand what they potentially agreed to when they made the promise.

HPD runs the serial #s to see if they're reported stolen, as that's all they can do.  They won't spend the time or $ running ballistics on every gun that is turned in.

HPD was also running ID"s in order to enter the chiefs hearing.  And asking CCW holders if they were carrying. Because having a valid CCW does show on their system.

I'm no sure if the same speech was given, but to our group of 10 who was let in, the cop in charge of this mentioned to leave all weapons in your car and dont' bring them inside.  "This is your chance to not get stopped at the metal detectors".  1 guy asked if OC was Ok and he said yes. But then when he got to the metal detector, they told him he cannot bring it in.  I then told the cop there that the other cop said it was OK (higher in rank).  He asked who and I said the cops name and pointed. He then asked if I had OC on me, and I said no.  The other guy still couldn't bring in his OC.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 25, 2024, 11:49:48 AM
....
Blue Bloods -with Tom Selleck. :thumbsup: :D
Tom is a friend of the 2A.
Back in the day when he was here doing Magnum P.I. I went to the Diamond Head studios, had lunch and sold Tom a holster for his 45 auto.

Pic? That would be cool to have.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: oldfart on January 25, 2024, 12:04:00 PM
Pic? That would be cool to have.
...
I kept a copy of the check as a souvenir
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 25, 2024, 12:13:16 PM
...
I kept a copy of the check as a souvenir

How much did you sell it for?
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: oldfart on January 25, 2024, 12:26:21 PM
How much did you sell it for?
...
I gotta go dig it up. It was a custom job for competition shooting because we were trying to get him to come out and shoot combat competition with the club. His driver/assistant was already shooting with us.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: randay on January 26, 2024, 05:33:48 PM
The committee(s) on PSM recommend(s) that the measure be PASSED, WITH AMENDMENTS. The votes in PSM were as follows: 3 Aye(s): Senator(s) Wakai, Elefante, Rhoads; Aye(s) with reservations: none ; 1 No(es): Senator(s) Awa; and 1 Excused: Senator(s) Fukunaga.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 26, 2024, 05:36:33 PM
There was nothing special about the test or hearing. As this bill wasnt that important.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: randay on January 26, 2024, 07:09:29 PM
There was nothing special about the test or hearing. As this bill wasnt that important.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Did you just bring this bill to our attention and ask for testimony, and now youre gonna tell us this bill isnt important? The guy who is constantly whining about lack of testimony and trying to guilt trip people into participating? unbelievable.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: zippz on January 26, 2024, 07:22:40 PM
my testimony was for people to turn guns into the gun stores instead year-round.  People then have a choice to have the gun store sell the gun, or turn it in no questions asked and the police pick it up later.

Benefit of this is no taxpayer money is used, gun owner and gun store make money, guns don't go to waste, and people don't have to fear arrest or scoldings from police.

Wakai was interested in my plan and was concerned about original cost, but passed the bill essentially unchanged.  The program cost is $825,000 for a statewide program
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 26, 2024, 07:23:03 PM
Did you just bring this bill to our attention and ask for testimony, and now youre gonna tell us this bill isnt important? The guy who is constantly whining about lack of testimony and trying to guilt trip people into participating? unbelievable.
Assault weapon ban bill=super important.


Bill about gun buy backs=not as important.

Do u see the HUGE difference,

Its good to write test for all gun related bills.

If it makes u feel better only 20 people submitted testimony for this bill. So regardless of the level of importance, still no one cares.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: randay on January 27, 2024, 05:30:24 AM
Assault weapon ban bill=super important.


Bill about gun buy backs=not as important.

Do u see the HUGE difference,

Its good to write test for all gun related bills.

If it makes u feel better only 20 people submitted testimony for this bill. So regardless of the level of importance, still no one cares.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Quit complaining about testimony numbers. dont ask people to take time out of their day to learn about bills then submit testimony, and then turn around and dismiss all of their efforts. Keep it up and soon youll literally have "no one" who cares.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 27, 2024, 06:53:28 AM
Quit complaining about testimony numbers. dont ask people to take time out of their day to learn about bills then submit testimony, and then turn around and dismiss all of their efforts. Keep it up and soon youll literally have "no one" who cares.
Please show where i dismissed all their efforts.

And yes, taking 2 mins out of ones day to read a bill and submit test that isnt too important is such a strain on peoples day.

Compares to the AWB bill that takes much more time to read.

Thanks for playing.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: randay on January 27, 2024, 06:57:52 AM
Please show where i dismissed all their efforts.

And yes, taking 2 mins out of ones day to read a bill and submit test that isnt too important is such a strain on peoples day.

Compares to the AWB bill that takes much more time to read.

Thanks for playing.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

i dont play this game. good luck with that.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: zippz on January 27, 2024, 06:59:05 AM
The thing is people treat this bill as anti-2A when it's not.  It was introduced by and voted on by legislators that are against the 2A, there's questionable preparatory language that can be seen as anti 2A, and it leads to the destruction of guns.   But this bill isn't unconstitutional.  For people that are against it it's a minor fiscal issue.

Flip it over and there's around 300 gun owners who used the program and I presume liked it.  Most of them aren't strong 2a supporters but it doesn't really affect me as a gun owner except for the tax money which is why it's a fiscal issue.  But even if you're against the tax money being wasted, it's a small drop in the bucket compared to everything else.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 27, 2024, 08:21:22 AM
i dont play this game. good luck with that.
So u cannot find it. Thanks for playing.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: oldfart on January 27, 2024, 10:31:45 AM
So u cannot find it. Thanks for playing.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
....
Assume that josh green or his spy is reading this forum and laughing at you bickering at each other. Remember that basic warfare strategy is to divide and conquer.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: QUIETShooter on January 27, 2024, 10:54:06 AM
....
Assume that josh green or his spy is reading this forum and laughing at you bickering at each other. Remember that basic warfare strategy is to divide and conquer.

Oh yes, they are lurking here........
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 27, 2024, 11:04:39 AM
....
Assume that josh green or his spy is reading this forum and laughing at you bickering at each other. Remember that basic warfare strategy is to divide and conquer.
Not just green...

Theyre also laughing at sb1230.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: rpoL98 on January 27, 2024, 11:26:35 AM
Not just green...

Theyre also laughing  ROTFLMAO at SB1230.  FIFY

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
:shaka:
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY B
Post by: hvybarrels on January 27, 2024, 01:15:01 PM
Not just green...

Theyre also laughing at sb1230.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

It was more of a psychological warfare campaign than anything. It became obvious the goal was to demoralize activists by making you go to chiefs meetings and beg for your rights. He can’t take your rights away. You can accept the belief that everything is hopeless and choose surrender your rights but that’s different.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: randay on January 27, 2024, 02:37:36 PM
The thing is people treat this bill as anti-2A when it's not.  It was introduced by and voted on by legislators that are against the 2A, there's questionable preparatory language that can be seen as anti 2A, and it leads to the destruction of guns.   But this bill isn't unconstitutional.  For people that are against it it's a minor fiscal issue.

Flip it over and there's around 300 gun owners who used the program and I presume liked it.  Most of them aren't strong 2a supporters but it doesn't really affect me as a gun owner except for the tax money which is why it's a fiscal issue.  But even if you're against the tax money being wasted, it's a small drop in the bucket compared to everything else.

All they have to do is change it from voluntary to mandatory. And how do you know 300 gun owners used the program? they did not take names or ask any questions. How many were criminals disposing of illegal firearms? We know for a fact that illegal firearms were turned in.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: randay on January 27, 2024, 02:39:26 PM
....
Assume that josh green or his spy is reading this forum and laughing at you bickering at each other. Remember that basic warfare strategy is to divide and conquer.

Tell it to the "show me where" circle jerkers who turn. They do it in literally every thread.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on January 27, 2024, 02:50:59 PM
Tell it to the "show me where" circle jerkers who turn. They do it in literally every thread.

Show me where someone said "show me where" in this thread:

https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=52475.0

If not, then "literally every thread" is an exaggeration -- one I believe is much bigger than you think.  There are some threads where "some people" fall into a rut and post that over and over, but it's nowhere near "literally every thread".

My mom told me a million times, "Stop exaggerating!"
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: macsak on January 27, 2024, 03:00:55 PM
you use that word, but i don't think you know what it means...

Tell it to the "show me where" circle jerkers who turn. They do it in literally every thread.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: rpoL98 on January 27, 2024, 03:11:31 PM
Gun Buy Backs are a Dog and Pony Show.

A Flash in the Pan maneuver that does nothing but give the impression that they are reducing gun violence.
(https://i.imgur.com/dU2jDQT.jpg)
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: zippz on January 27, 2024, 03:31:22 PM
All they have to do is change it from voluntary to mandatory. And how do you know 300 gun owners used the program? they did not take names or ask any questions. How many were criminals disposing of illegal firearms? We know for a fact that illegal firearms were turned in.

I can't find numbers for people, but I'd assume majority turned in one, and the limit was 3 gift cards per person with no limit on firearms.turned in.  So my swag is 200 to 300 people.  if you can find the actual number I'd like to know it.

Technically most of the people were probably criminals turning in guns.  Since many were unregistered  :D

But for hardcore criminals turning in guns, probably very few if any.  There are lots of ways to disappear guns...just bury it.in the forest or make it corrode into dust.   lots of people seem to have boating accidents on 2ahawaii.


Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: QUIETShooter on January 27, 2024, 03:47:44 PM


Technically most of the people were probably criminals turning in guns.  Since many were unregistered  :D



Long guns in possession prior to 1994 need not be registered.  It was not required.  Correct me if I'm wrong.  But if I am correct, why are these people technically criminals for not registering their guns.  Unless you are referring to handguns.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: zippz on January 27, 2024, 03:51:45 PM
Long guns in possession prior to 1994 need not be registered.  It was not required.  Correct me if I'm wrong.  But if I am correct, why are these people technically criminals for not registering their guns.  Unless you are referring to handguns.

if a pre94 long.gun is inherited after that date, it has to be registered by the new owner.

Though I guess it could be up in the air if it just stayed in a box and the people say they didn't want it.
Title: Re: Testimony due before 1/25/24 3pm GUN BUY BACK
Post by: randay on January 27, 2024, 04:34:11 PM
I can't find numbers for people, but I'd assume majority turned in one, and the limit was 3 gift cards per person with no limit on firearms.turned in.  So my swag is 200 to 300 people.  if you can find the actual number I'd like to know it.

Technically most of the people were probably criminals turning in guns.  Since many were unregistered  :D

But for hardcore criminals turning in guns, probably very few if any.  There are lots of ways to disappear guns...just bury it.in the forest or make it corrode into dust.   lots of people seem to have boating accidents on 2ahawaii.

Thats kind of the point, there is no questions asked and so the data is incomplete. You've assumed that it was mostly gun owners who had legitimate reasons, While the anti-2a lawmakers have assumed that they are all guns that would have been used sold on the black market or used in crimes. Just two sides of the same coin with not enough details to factually say so one way or the other.

Another other way that gun buybacks are anti-2a is that they are used by anti-2a prove their point, even though theres no real data to prove it. the proof of that is in the introduction of this bill right here. "limits the number of firearms entering the black market, and reduces violent crimes, accidental shootings, and the risk of a firearm being brought into a school."

If you say this is not an Anti-2a bill, and that it isnt important, I have to strongly disagree.  :shaka: