2aHawaii

General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: Flapp_Jackson on March 07, 2024, 10:45:49 AM

Title: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 07, 2024, 10:45:49 AM
Landmark Bill: Property Owners to Bear
Liability for Injuries in Gun-Free Zones

Quote
A new Georgia bill would make property owners liable if a lawful concealed
carry permit holder is harmed while barred from being armed on their property.

House Bill 1364 allows legal gun owners who are prohibited from carrying on
private property and subsequently injured to sue the landowner.
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/landmark-bill-property-owners-to-bear-liability-for-injuries-in-gun-free-zones/ar-BB1jl8Ky

I guess if the threat of civil and financial liability is significant enough, the property owners will choose to make their properties gun-friendly zones instead.

And, the owners who refuse will either close their doors or, God forbid, be sued out of existence should a patron be killed or injured on the premises.

Giving family members the right to sue after a loved one is killed will not bring them back, but at least it's better than the illogical status quo now.  Rational people agree that if a business has a policy that causes harm, they should be held liable for that.  Gun free zones should not be an exception.


https://youtu.be/iOmcq7dacj8
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: oldfart on March 07, 2024, 12:08:11 PM
Ooh, that's interesting. Rhoads head would explode if another senator proposed that.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: ren on March 07, 2024, 12:53:43 PM
we should at least work with our legislators to draft one for 2025. We need to.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 07, 2024, 10:31:25 PM
Interesting idea, I doubt it will stand up to legal challenge but still an interesting idea.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: ren on March 07, 2024, 10:34:38 PM
(https://i.imgflip.com/1xmh1l.jpg)
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: zippz on March 08, 2024, 09:30:57 AM
I see a purpose for it, but I'm hesitant due to property owner rights and a person doesn't have to be there.  Maybe in limited circumstances.

There's a better case when it comes to government properties as sometimes you have no choice and have to be there.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 08, 2024, 09:39:58 AM
I see a purpose for it, but I'm hesitant due to property owner rights and a person doesn't have to be there.  Maybe in limited circumstances.

There's a better case when it comes to government properties as sometimes you have no choice and have to be there.

So if you go into a store and slip on a puddle of spilled liquid, you don't think you should have the right to sue because of "property owner rights?"

No matter what property you own, opening it up to the public also opens you up to civil action if someone is injured.  It's why businesses carry large liability insurance policies.

Choosing to have a gun free zone is still their right.  It just makes disarming people on par with failing to maintain a safe, clean place to walk in terms of being liable should someone be injured.  They can have all the mitigating measures they want, too:  metal detectors, armed guards, surveillance cameras monitored by security personnel, locked entrances requiring someone let you in, and so on.

If you're going to deprive someone of the right to defend themselves, then you have an even greater responsibility to ensure that someone is as safe as possible.  That's my opinon anyway.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 08, 2024, 12:38:39 PM
It's not only while in their business, but also where you go the rest of the day if disarmed because you cannot leave your gun in the car (if it's not legal to do so).  Or at most, something happens while you're walking to your car, which has your firearm in it.

I hope this passes and wins when challenged in court.

Like Flap said, they are responsible if I slip on an uncleaned wet spot. Or if they're found negligent if something falls on me.  So getting hurt in a store because one is unable to defend themselves with the best tool should be no different.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 08, 2024, 01:11:43 PM
It's not only while in their business, but also where you go the rest of the day if disarmed because you cannot leave your gun in the car (if it's not legal to do so).  Or at most, something happens while you're walking to your car, which has your firearm in it.

I hope this passes and wins when challenged in court.

Like Flap said, they are responsible if I slip on an uncleaned wet spot. Or if they're found negligent if something falls on me.  So getting hurt in a store because one is unable to defend themselves with the best tool should be no different.

Then there's the "vote with your wallet" approach.  if one restaurant is gun free and there are others who aren't, you have the option to spend your money at the places which don't violate your beliefs or rights no matter which side of the issue you're on.

Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 08, 2024, 01:13:30 PM
Then there's the "vote with your wallet" approach.  if one restaurant is gun free and there are others who aren't, you have the option to spend your money at the places which don't violate your beliefs or rights no matter which side of the issue you're on.

I try to do that as well.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: QUIETShooter on March 08, 2024, 01:23:41 PM
State and County that declare "sensitive places" and thereby prohibit carrying firearms for self defense should also be liable for the safety of whoever is on the premises.

We should be able to sue them.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: RSN172 on March 10, 2024, 08:22:29 AM
State and County that declare "sensitive places" and thereby prohibit carrying firearms for self defense should also be liable for the safety of whoever is on the premises.

We should be able to sue them.

But in Hawaii, we get da Aloha Spirit.  Az why no need carry gun.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: QUIETShooter on March 10, 2024, 09:17:13 AM
But in Hawaii, we get da Aloha Spirit.  Az why no need carry gun.

Ah, yes.  The bastardization of a genuine concept by corrupt, self-serving, bullsh*t, two-faced, greedy, bought and paid-for politicians, LE, and their bureaucratic cronies in the justice system.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 10, 2024, 09:58:39 PM
I see a purpose for it, but I'm hesitant due to property owner rights and a person doesn't have to be there.  Maybe in limited circumstances.

There's a better case when it comes to government properties as sometimes you have no choice and have to be there.

This made me think about the Christian cake bakers. A store owner could say that guns are against his religion. I think it could create a lot of unintended precedent.

If a bank bans medical masks can you sue them if you catch a cold at a bank? (for example)
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 11, 2024, 08:20:14 AM
This made me think about the Christian cake bakers. A store owner could say that guns are against his religion. I think it could create a lot of unintended precedent.

If a bank bans medical masks can you sue them if you catch a cold at a bank? (for example)

Typical bad example. You're trying to create a problem where there isn't one.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 11, 2024, 11:56:57 AM
This made me think about the Christian cake bakers. A store owner could say that guns are against his religion. I think it could create a lot of unintended precedent.

If a bank bans medical masks can you sue them if you catch a cold at a bank? (for example)

You should do all your banking online or ask for special accommodations.  If you knowingly follow policies and rules knowing you are putting yourself at risk, and there are alternatives, then you bear some of the responsibility if you're injured.

That's partly why I said to vote with your wallet.  If you disarm yourself by choosing to go to a gun free business, that's your choice -- isn't it?

Banks are no different.  Switch banks, use their online and phone services, or ask for a medical exemption for masks.  Sheeple would accept the risks because they feel they have no other choice.

The Christian cake baker is a totally irrelevant situation.  The reason for his gun free zone doesn't matter.  Whether his reason is religion, his dog was shot in a hunting accident, his wife is a better shot than he is, or loud noises make him curl up in the fetal position, it all has the same end result:  disarming his customers.  He's free to have that policy in his store, but he can't get immunity from liability simply because he claims religious beliefs.  He needs to get insurance and implement additional safety measures for his clientele, or he's risking losing his business if something bad happens.

It's no different than if he sprinkles holy water at the entrance to bless his customers when they enter, and someone slips on the water and gets hurt.  The accident was foreseeable, and religious beliefs can't shield him from the consequences.

As for baking cakes for Gay weddings, go read the decision.  He didn't prevail on the argument that he can run his business however his religious beliefs guide him.  Rather, the NATURE of his cake decorating was deemed "a creative process," and he was being forced to use his creativity and skill to make a cake that supported something he did not think was right. 

Making a store a gun free zone has zero to do with creativity or skill.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: macsak on March 11, 2024, 12:30:04 PM
HPD can carry wherever they want...

You should do all your banking online or ask for special accommodations.  If you knowingly follow policies and rules knowing you are putting yourself at risk, and there are alternatives, then you bear some of the responsibility if you're injured.

That's partly why I said to vote with your wallet.  If you disarm yourself by choosing to go to a gun free business, that's your choice -- isn't it?

Banks are no different.  Switch banks, use their online and phone services, or ask for a medical exemption for masks.  Sheeple would accept the risks because they feel they have no other choice.

The Christian cake baker is a totally irrelevant situation.  The reason for his gun free zone doesn't matter.  Whether his reason is religion, his dog was shot in a hunting accident, his wife is a better shot than he is, or loud noises make him curl up in the fetal position, it all has the same end result:  disarming his customers.  He's free to have that policy in his store, but he can't get immunity from liability simply because he claims religious beliefs.  He needs to get insurance and implement additional safety measures for his clientele, or he's risking losing his business if something bad happens.

It's no different than if he sprinkles holy water at the entrance to bless his customers when they enter, and someone slips on the water and gets hurt.  The accident was foreseeable, and religious beliefs can't shield him from the consequences.

As for baking cakes for Gay weddings, go read the decision.  He didn't prevail on the argument that he can run his business however his religious beliefs guide him.  Rather, the NATURE of his cake decorating was deemed "a creative process," and he was being forced to use his creativity and skill to make a cake that supported something he did not think was right. 

Making a store a gun free zone has zero to do with creativity or skill.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: Rocky on March 11, 2024, 12:50:56 PM
"It's no different than if he sprinkles holy water at the entrance to bless his customers when they enter,"
But if an atheist/muslim walks in and gets "sprinkled", isn't that a violation of their unreligious/religious rights and he can't get immunity from liability simply because he claims religious beliefs?  :wacko:
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 11, 2024, 03:53:34 PM
HPD can carry wherever they want...

Another excemption, besides owning certain parts.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 11, 2024, 06:03:05 PM
But if an atheist/muslim walks in and gets "sprinkled", isn't that a violation of their unreligious/religious rights and he can't get immunity from liability simply because he claims religious beliefs?  :wacko:

If someone sprinkles holy water and you take offense, you are admitting you also believe the water is blessed.  Otherwise, you wouldn't make a stink over it.

A smart atheist/Muslim would smile or laugh and ignore it -- until they slipped and fell!   :shake:
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 11, 2024, 09:44:08 PM
Typical bad example. You're trying to create a problem where there isn't one.

Typical trolling post. Lets see how long you derail this thread
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 11, 2024, 09:56:02 PM
You should do all your banking online or ask for special accommodations.  If you knowingly follow policies and rules knowing you are putting yourself at risk, and there are alternatives, then you bear some of the responsibility if you're injured.

That's partly why I said to vote with your wallet.  If you disarm yourself by choosing to go to a gun free business, that's your choice -- isn't it?

Banks are no different.  Switch banks, use their online and phone services, or ask for a medical exemption for masks.  Sheeple would accept the risks because they feel they have no other choice.

The Christian cake baker is a totally irrelevant situation.  The reason for his gun free zone doesn't matter.  Whether his reason is religion, his dog was shot in a hunting accident, his wife is a better shot than he is, or loud noises make him curl up in the fetal position, it all has the same end result:  disarming his customers.  He's free to have that policy in his store, but he can't get immunity from liability simply because he claims religious beliefs.  He needs to get insurance and implement additional safety measures for his clientele, or he's risking losing his business if something bad happens.

It's no different than if he sprinkles holy water at the entrance to bless his customers when they enter, and someone slips on the water and gets hurt.  The accident was foreseeable, and religious beliefs can't shield him from the consequences.

As for baking cakes for Gay weddings, go read the decision.  He didn't prevail on the argument that he can run his business however his religious beliefs guide him.  Rather, the NATURE of his cake decorating was deemed "a creative process," and he was being forced to use his creativity and skill to make a cake that supported something he did not think was right. 

Making a store a gun free zone has zero to do with creativity or skill.

Seems like it could be a double edged sword though. Don't allow firearms and the store is liable. Allow firearms and they could still be liable if another customer ended up causing harm with a firearm.

The other problem with this type of suggestion is that it can snowball. So imagine you park your car in a parking lot of a business and it gets broken into. Is the business responsible if it didn't have a security cameras? What if it did have cameras but no security guards? What if there were security guards but the injured party says there weren't enough? I don't think we should take steps to an even more litigious society.

You say that the accident was foreseeable but that's not a good example because the store is creating the wet floor, the store isn't creating robber.

I have no objection to voting with your wallet, if a store has a sign saying no firearms allowed I will choose another store if possible.

Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 12, 2024, 07:31:00 AM
Typical trolling post. Lets see how long you derail this thread

You mean, how long u derail the thread trying to move goal post and other tactics people use when wrong. FIFY
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 12, 2024, 07:31:33 AM
Seems like it could be a double edged sword though. Don't allow firearms and the store is liable. Allow firearms and they could still be liable if another customer ended up causing harm with a firearm.

The other problem with this type of suggestion is that it can snowball. So imagine you park your car in a parking lot of a business and it gets broken into. Is the business responsible if it didn't have a security cameras? What if it did have cameras but no security guards? What if there were security guards but the injured party says there weren't enough? I don't think we should take steps to an even more litigious society.

You say that the accident was foreseeable but that's not a good example because the store is creating the wet floor, the store isn't creating robber.

I have no objection to voting with your wallet, if a store has a sign saying no firearms allowed I will choose another store if possible.

Another bad example. Geez.

*edit

Quantity doesn't = quality.

If a business has no sign, then all G. But if they put a no guns allowed sign or guns allowed, then liability could be there. When there's the weight of the law for no guns allowed, then the gov should also share liability.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 12, 2024, 09:08:50 AM
Seems like it could be a double edged sword though. Don't allow firearms and the store is liable. Allow firearms and they could still be liable if another customer ended up causing harm with a firearm.

The other problem with this type of suggestion is that it can snowball. So imagine you park your car in a parking lot of a business and it gets broken into. Is the business responsible if it didn't have a security cameras? What if it did have cameras but no security guards? What if there were security guards but the injured party says there weren't enough? I don't think we should take steps to an even more litigious society.

You say that the accident was foreseeable but that's not a good example because the store is creating the wet floor, the store isn't creating robber.

I have no objection to voting with your wallet, if a store has a sign saying no firearms allowed I will choose another store if possible.

Wrong.

If someone walks in and starts shooting, and the people were allowed to be armed, they'd have a chance to fight back. If they choose to be unarmed, that's not the business' fault if they were allowed to carry there.

The guy who wanted to commit murder would have entered armed with a weapon regardless of the signage and policies.  There's no liability for the business in so far as what one criminal decided to do.

Unless you can prove the gun-friendly policy had something to do with the criminal act of that one individual, then the business is not liable.

Making his customers sitting ducks against their will when the criminal shows up -- that's something that can have foreseeable consequences.

It's not a difficult concept.  Maybe you'd like to further explain this double-edged sword theory of yours. 

As for your poor analogy, courts have ruled in many cases that a business was liable for car break ins and damage in spite of signage saying you're parking at your own risk, company not responsible, yada yada...   It all depends on the state's laws and the circumstances.  Disclaimers cannot counteract negligence or failure to take reasonable measures to safeguard parking lots and garages especially if break ins and car theft are common in that lot/garage.

On top of all that, there's a massive difference between property loss and injury or death when it comes to liability.  That includes amount of damages.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 19, 2024, 11:30:13 PM
Wrong.

If someone walks in and starts shooting, and the people were allowed to be armed, they'd have a chance to fight back. If they choose to be unarmed, that's not the business' fault if they were allowed to carry there.

The guy who wanted to commit murder would have entered armed with a weapon regardless of the signage and policies.  There's no liability for the business in so far as what one criminal decided to do.

Unless you can prove the gun-friendly policy had something to do with the criminal act of that one individual, then the business is not liable.

Making his customers sitting ducks against their will when the criminal shows up -- that's something that can have foreseeable consequences.

It's not a difficult concept.  Maybe you'd like to further explain this double-edged sword theory of yours. 

As for your poor analogy, courts have ruled in many cases that a business was liable for car break ins and damage in spite of signage saying you're parking at your own risk, company not responsible, yada yada...   It all depends on the state's laws and the circumstances.  Disclaimers cannot counteract negligence or failure to take reasonable measures to safeguard parking lots and garages especially if break ins and car theft are common in that lot/garage.

On top of all that, there's a massive difference between property loss and injury or death when it comes to liability.  That includes amount of damages.

Thats a weak argument.
Can you find any such example where a company has been successfully sued because someone suffered due to policy to not allow a firearm?

What usually happens in cases such as a car break in on a property is when there was a certain expectation of security that was not enforced. So for example if a business had a security gate but the gate was broken that opens the company up to more liability because the customer had an expectation of security in that they were lead to believe a security measure was in place when it actually wasn't.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 20, 2024, 12:12:47 AM
Thats a weak argument.
Can you find any such example where a company has been successfully sued because someone suffered due to policy to not allow a firearm?

What usually happens in cases such as a car break in on a property is when there was a certain expectation of security that was not enforced. So for example if a business had a security gate but the gate was broken that opens the company up to more liability because the customer had an expectation of security in that they were lead to believe a security measure was in place when it actually wasn't.

That's a weak opinion.

"Can you find any such example where a company has been successfully sued because someone suffered due to policy to not allow a firearm? "

That's not the entire issue.  The issue is whether the company also added security measures to ensure the safety of its customers and employees.

Schools have been sued after mass shootings.  Some of those are still going through the legal process.

Police departments were sued for failure to stop an active shooter.

The movie theater in Aurora, CO, was sued, but the gun free zone policy was actually the government's policy/law that disarmed the public.  That's usually been the case since so many of these crimes occurred in cities and states where concealed carry is not commonly permitted.  After Bruen, that's already changing.

Now that "shall issue" is the law of the land, many places (like here) are rushing to stop CCW by trying to get businesses to do it for them.  I predict there will be more lawsuits over gun free zones once the people responsible can't hide behind the law and qualified immunity.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 20, 2024, 09:54:41 AM
That's a weak opinion.

"Can you find any such example where a company has been successfully sued because someone suffered due to policy to not allow a firearm? "

That's not the entire issue.  The issue is whether the company also added security measures to ensure the safety of its customers and employees.

Schools have been sued after mass shootings.  Some of those are still going through the legal process.

Police departments were sued for failure to stop an active shooter.

The movie theater in Aurora, CO, was sued, but the gun free zone policy was actually the government's policy/law that disarmed the public.  That's usually been the case since so many of these crimes occurred in cities and states where concealed carry is not commonly permitted.  After Bruen, that's already changing.

Now that "shall issue" is the law of the land, many places (like here) are rushing to stop CCW by trying to get businesses to do it for them.  I predict there will be more lawsuits over gun free zones once the people responsible can't hide behind the law and qualified immunity.

I will be one to file suit if I'm ever injured due to a no guns allowed place.  I hope that I never have to though, because that means something bad happened.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 20, 2024, 11:21:42 AM
I will be one to file suit if I'm ever injured due to a no guns allowed place.  I hope that I never have to though, because that means something bad happened.

Thanks for being willing to take one for the "team!"

 :thumbsup: :geekdanc:
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 21, 2024, 11:52:54 PM
That's a weak opinion.

"Can you find any such example where a company has been successfully sued because someone suffered due to policy to not allow a firearm? "

That's not the entire issue.  The issue is whether the company also added security measures to ensure the safety of its customers and employees.

Schools have been sued after mass shootings.  Some of those are still going through the legal process.

Police departments were sued for failure to stop an active shooter.

The movie theater in Aurora, CO, was sued, but the gun free zone policy was actually the government's policy/law that disarmed the public.  That's usually been the case since so many of these crimes occurred in cities and states where concealed carry is not commonly permitted.  After Bruen, that's already changing.

Now that "shall issue" is the law of the land, many places (like here) are rushing to stop CCW by trying to get businesses to do it for them.  I predict there will be more lawsuits over gun free zones once the people responsible can't hide behind the law and qualified immunity.


I would be interested in the outcome of those cases to see what type of precedent they set.


Seems like they could be sued either way though. If a business allows you to bring in your firearm and you accidentally shoot an innocent person, then the store could still get sued
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 22, 2024, 08:09:32 AM

I would be interested in the outcome of those cases to see what type of precedent they set.


Seems like they could be sued either way though. If a business allows you to bring in your firearm and you accidentally shoot an innocent person, then the store could still get sued

Hence a no signage at all is the best option.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 22, 2024, 08:31:21 AM

I would be interested in the outcome of those cases to see what type of precedent they set.


Seems like they could be sued either way though. If a business allows you to bring in your firearm and you accidentally shoot an innocent person, then the store could still get sued

I started this answer three times, and each time I was getting sucked into your vortex of nonsense.  Let me make it simple for you.

The business has no control over what a customer who decides to hurt others does.  That also applies to accidental (negligent) discharges.  There's no liability from that perspective.  No sign, policy or law will stop a criminal or careless person who decides to carry anyway from hurting others, whether it's with a gun, knife, flame thrower or just their hands. 

The business does have control over allowing law abiding people to protect themselves.  That makes them liable for providing protection for their customers' safety against the person who might want to hurt others if the business decides to ban firearms.

Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 22, 2024, 09:22:02 AM
I started this answer three times, and each time I was getting sucked into your vortex of nonsense.  Let me make it simple for you.

The business has no control over what a customer who decides to hurt others does.  That also applies to accidental (negligent) discharges.  There's no liability from that perspective.  No sign, policy or law will stop a criminal or careless person who decides to carry anyway from hurting others, whether it's with a gun, knife, flame thrower or just their hands. 

The business does have control over allowing law abiding people to protect themselves.  That makes them liable for providing protection for their customers' safety against the person who might want to hurt others if the business decides to ban firearms.

You're simple answer doesn't work for whataboutism, which is why it was ignored.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 22, 2024, 11:40:19 AM
You're simple answer doesn't work for whataboutism, which is why it was ignored.

I posted this while the Sun shined. 

Trolls only come out late at night. 

Give him/her/it/they a little more time before assuming they read it.

 :shaka: :thumbsup: :geekdanc:

From their profile:  [Last Active:March 21, 2024, 11:59:42 PM]
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 24, 2024, 11:21:38 PM
I started this answer three times, and each time I was getting sucked into your vortex of nonsense.  Let me make it simple for you.

The business has no control over what a customer who decides to hurt others does.  That also applies to accidental (negligent) discharges.  There's no liability from that perspective.  No sign, policy or law will stop a criminal or careless person who decides to carry anyway from hurting others, whether it's with a gun, knife, flame thrower or just their hands. 

The business does have control over allowing law abiding people to protect themselves.  That makes them liable for providing protection for their customers' safety against the person who might want to hurt others if the business decides to ban firearms.

I understand your reasoning, I just am not sure it would hold up in a civil suit.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 25, 2024, 11:43:00 AM
I understand your reasoning, I just am not sure it would hold up in a civil suit.

Posted at 11:21 PM.

I rest my case.

"I'm not sure' = "I don't know"

If you posted about everything you don't know, we'd never finish reading your comments.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 25, 2024, 12:04:40 PM
Posted at 11:21 PM.

I rest my case.

"I'm not sure' = "I don't know"

If you posted about everything you don't know, we'd never finish reading your comments.

He could of also posted the "why" he doesn't think it would win.  I mean, you posted the why they should be liable in detail.

Maybe in order to go to start his day, he has to post something.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 25, 2024, 12:20:33 PM
He could of also posted the "why" he doesn't think it would win.  I mean, you posted the why they should be liable in detail.

Maybe in order to go to start his day, he has to post something.

i don't think he really wants to engage in discussion.  He posts when the fewest members possible are going to see his comments.

Then he waits days -- sometimes weeks -- before responding to any replies.

If he was really interested in engaging, he would read and answer responses more punctually.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 25, 2024, 12:46:43 PM
i don't think he really wants to engage in discussion.  He posts when the fewest members possible are going to see his comments.

Then he waits days -- sometimes weeks -- before responding to any replies.

If he was really interested in engaging, he would read and answer responses more punctually.

Maybe he post at work and works night shift.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 25, 2024, 12:49:49 PM
Maybe he post at work and works night shift.

Maybe his posts ARE his work?

#PaidTroll
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 25, 2024, 11:07:12 PM
Posted at 11:21 PM.

I rest my case.

"I'm not sure' = "I don't know"


Me not knowing something doesn't amount to you knowing it. The different between you and me is I can admit when I don't know something. You pointing out that I don't know after I said I don't know isn't exactly a revelation nor is it a rebuttal. You made an assertion, one which you have failed to make a strong case is true. You pointing out that I don't know after I said I don't know isn't proof of your claim.
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 26, 2024, 12:10:13 AM
Me not knowing something doesn't amount to you knowing it. The different between you and me is I can admit when I don't know something. You pointing out that I don't know after I said I don't know isn't exactly a revelation nor is it a rebuttal. You made an assertion, one which you have failed to make a strong case is true. You pointing out that I don't know after I said I don't know isn't proof of your claim.

Did I trigger you?

Since you missed it, the obvious point of my comment was that you don't have to tell us you don't know something.  Nobody cares.

What use is that kind of post -- other than to feed an ego?
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 26, 2024, 09:26:13 AM
Did I trigger you?

Since you missed it, the obvious point of my comment was that you don't have to tell us you don't know something.  Nobody cares.

What use is that kind of post -- other than to feed an ego?
He feels the need to post something, which shows why hes wrong majority of the time.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 28, 2024, 11:10:44 PM
Did I trigger you?

You think what you say has that much effect on me? I'd charge you rent if you lived in my head.


Quote
Since you missed it, the obvious point of my comment was that you don't have to tell us you don't know something.  Nobody cares.

Thanks for supporting my swoosh on you.

Quote
What use is that kind of post -- other than to feed an ego?

What use? To tell you that you haven't made a good case to support your assertion. I know that triggers you
Title: Re: Georgia bill makes gun-free property owners liable for disarmed visitors' safety
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 29, 2024, 02:27:29 AM
You think what you say has that much effect on me? I'd charge you rent if you lived in my head.


Thanks for supporting my swoosh on you.

What use? To tell you that you haven't made a good case to support your assertion. I know that triggers you

 :sleeping: