2aHawaii
General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: Flapp_Jackson on December 06, 2024, 04:23:15 PM
-
The original thread is old, so starting a fresh one. Original thread:
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=49828.0
Daniel Penny's fate is now in the hands of the jury - or is it? The prosecution and defense rested, and the jury has been deliberating over the 1st count of Manslaughter before considering the 2nd count of Negligent Homicide.
Today, news has it that the jury is deadlocked on the 1st charge, which is the more serious one.
Here's the nutshell summary of the courtroom shenanigans:
What should have happened in the jury room:
step 1 - deliberate on the 1st charge
step 2 - agree on a verdict on the 1st charge, either guilty or not guilty. A hung jury on the 1st count means a mistrial, so they never get to step 3.
step 3 - deliberate on the 2nd charge
step 4 - agree on a verdict on the 2nd charge
Here's where the prosecution and judge show how evil they are. In any other trial, when a jury is unable to reach a decision on the primary charge, the entire case is declared a mistrial and all charges are unresolved. The prosecutor can refile to retry the case either the same as the first time, or they can refile with only the lesser charge/s in order to make a conviction more likely.
However, when the prosecutor heard about the deadlock (before the judge was able to declare a mistrial), they made a motion to drop the 1st count of Manslaughter and to allow the jury to deliberate on the 2nd (lesser) charge of Negligent Homicide. And, since this is New York where rules and precedents don't really matter (re: Trump prosecutions, SCOTUS Bruen decision, ...), the judge granted the motion.
That's not how the system is supposed to work.
The defense of course objected to the motion to drop the 1st charge and asked to continue the trial to a verdict, as they were right to do. Even though I think he'll have a great basis to appeal the verdict if convicted, this is a sleazy move by the state to salvage a case that was about to be declared a mistrial.
What really sucks about this is the state presented a case to try and prove manslaughter. How much of that evidence would not have been presented, or presented in a different manner, or been disputed differently by the defense, had the trial started out with only the 2nd charge? Courtroom strategies often hinge on what the elements of the crime are. it's impossible to instruct the jury to now disregard any evidence that only pertains to the Manslaughter charge and not the Negligent Homicide charge.
The NY justice system needs a complete overhaul.
https://youtu.be/qBR0oNp9A7c
-
Either the prosecution is corrupt or "just following orders". NYPD should have refused to arrest him or escort to and from the courthouse. But NYPD are cucks and do as they're told as majority of cops do.
-
Soros-funded prosecutors.
Either the prosecution is corrupt or "just following orders". NYPD should have refused to arrest him or escort to and from the courthouse. But NYPD are cucks and do as they're told as majority of cops do.
there's that dental plan, again.
and their pensions.
-
I'm late to this incident, haven't paid attention to it. It's not murder or manslaughter and Penny had good intentions. However I think he just screwed up and held the VNR too long and it wasn't an incident calling for lethal force. If that was the case, then negligent homicide could be possible and it would be at the discretion of the prosecutor and jury. I would see him as being covered by the good samaritan law and let him go. Another option would be for guys to just pin him down without the VNR.
-
I'm late to this incident, haven't paid attention to it. It's not murder or manslaughter and Penny had good intentions. However I think he just screwed up and held the VNR too long and it wasn't an incident calling for lethal force. If that was the case, then negligent homicide could be possible and it would be at the discretion of the prosecutor and jury. I would see him as being covered by the good samaritan law and let him go. Another option would be for guys to just pin him down without the VNR.
Good Samaritan law? I think you have the wrong idea about what that means. In NY, Good Samaritan laws are meant to shield someone who provides aid in an emergency situation from being sued and from other legal consequences. It's also used to protect someone legally who calls 911 to assist a person overdosing, even if that person is the caller. It does not cover the use of force to defend others from a deranged lunatic threatening to kill them.
So, the forensic pathologist based the autopsy report, in part, off of the
footage itself of the fatal encounter, which Harris said she saw was clear-cut
evidence ruling out that Neely had died of a drug overdose.
"After watching it, I had no further questions as to why he was dead," Harris said.
Penny's defense attorneys questioned Harris about her initially writing
"inconclusive" for the cause of death on Neely's death certificate. One day
after Neely's death, the finding on May 2, 2023, said "pending further study."
The doctor said she eventually decided on asphyxiation, consistent with compression
of the neck, upon reviewing the video in question depicting Neely "dying."
Hence, Harris reached her conclusion before she ever received Neely's toxicology
report.
The toxicology report ultimately revealed that Neely, who had a history of abusing
the drug K2, which made him paranoid and prone to violent outbursts, had synthetic
substances in his system at the time that he died. "Two to 100 times more potent to
standard, natural occurring cannabinoids," K2 is classified as a stimulant similar to
the potency of cocaine, Harris remarked.
"We found in the blood a synthetic cannabinoid, a relatively new drug in the scheme
of drugs," she said. "They're synthetic and more potent than marijuana. In a class of
drugs, they fall under the category of stimulants. They rev the body up, fall into the
same class of drugs as, say, cocaine."
https://townhall.com/tipsheet/miacathell/2024/11/18/daniel-penny-medical-examiner-n2647890
"I based my decision on the autopsy findings coupled with the video," she said.
"I didn’t wait for toxicology, because no toxicological report would change my
opinion. He could have come back with enough fentanyl to kill an elephant and
walked onto the train and got put in a chokehold, and that’s how he died."
https://www.foxnews.com/us/medical-examiner-says-subway-madman-had-drugs-system-marine-vets-chokehold-trial
How can any doctor be so sure of the cause of death when she couldn't determine a cause before seeing the video? This is why jurors are told to avoid news reports involving the cases they are hearing. It's had to not form an opinion based on what's in the media (including viral videos). It taints the expected independence of any opinions formed.
He had a heartbeat after Penny released him. Penny had no idea Neely was dead until long after he was being questioned by police. It was a long time before he knew the situation was more serious than he believed.
-
Why is BLM still a thing? Didn’t people hear about the scams they were running?
https://nypost.com/2024/12/06/us-news/blm-head-accuses-daniel-penny-jurors-of-racism-report/
-
Why is BLM still a thing?
https://nypost.com/2024/12/06/us-news/blm-head-accuses-daniel-penny-jurors-of-racism-report/
BLM attracts lazy, self-entitled people.
-
It's a shame. They give nothing back to the black community but only use contrived prejudice as a platform to enrich themselves.
They are making the world a much more dangerous place. Thank goodness so many black men saw through the lies and voted for Trump.
-
Good Samaritan law? I think you have the wrong idea about what that means. In NY, Good Samaritan laws are meant to shield someone who provides aid in an emergency situation from being sued and from other legal consequences. It's also used to protect someone legally who calls 911 to assist a person overdosing, even if that person is the caller. It does not cover the use of force to defend others from a deranged lunatic threatening to kill them.
https://townhall.com/tipsheet/miacathell/2024/11/18/daniel-penny-medical-examiner-n2647890
https://www.foxnews.com/us/medical-examiner-says-subway-madman-had-drugs-system-marine-vets-chokehold-trial
How can any doctor be so sure of the cause of death when she couldn't determine a cause before seeing the video? This is why jurors are told to avoid news reports involving the cases they are hearing. It's had to not form an opinion based on what's in the media (including viral videos). It taints the expected independence of any opinions formed.
He had a heartbeat after Penny released him. Penny had no idea Neely was dead until long after he was being questioned by police. It was a long time before he knew the situation was more serious than he believed.
Self defense to help others shares a lot of elements of "good samaritan" law and this event appears to follow the spirit of the law even if not meeting the legal text of it. Some states have some niche exemptions from criminal liability. If an act is determined to fall under good samaritan law against civil liability, then it'd be difficult and unpopular to charge a person criminally with it.
I tried drafting and passing a law to protect self-defenders against civil liability but it's difficult, complex, and has a lot of controversy around it like "stand your ground." Adding self-defense of others civil protections may be easier if connected to good samaritan.
I can see how it may be difficult to diagnose the cause of death from a VNR as there may not be physical injuries from it since it doesn't require a lot of pressure. Perhaps injuries from the struggle but not the VNR. What seemed like the person struggling could have been spams from lack of oxygen in the brain, the death throes. It doesn't take long to get permanent brain damage and they could still have some pulse later. The drugs in his system probably played a part in it too.
Is there a video available of the entire encounter?
-
It's sad what this Marine is going through.
Makes you wonder if it's worth it trying to protect others than your friends and loved ones. Is there laws where if you do nothing you can also get in trouble? Not sure. Damn if you do and damn if you don't.
A flawed justice system is just as bad as criminal activity.
-
[snip]
Is there a video available of the entire encounter?
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12051875/Video-shows-Marine-veteran-Daniel-Penny-ignoring-warnings-restraining-Jordan-Neely.html
Remember, it's not as cut and dried as one might believe, because one knows the outcome in advance and what the videos shows from a spectator's perspective. In the moment, it's an adrenaline driven event with people talking and yelling from different directions. Focus and attention can be taken away from Neely as others assist -- which seems to be the case while 2-3 people are helping Penny subdue Neely.
Several people testified they were afraid for their safety, and some for their lives. Neely was threatening to kill them (men, women and children) and was obviously not in his right mind. How much Monday morning quarterbacking is acceptable when second-guessing the actions Penny took? This wasn't a refereed wrestling match or military training class. It's a judgement call, and what matters is what Neely was thinking at that moment.
The videos include some of the statements he made to police. He only wanted to stop the threat, not injure or kill anyone.
-
I'm late to this incident, haven't paid attention to it. It's not murder or manslaughter and Penny had good intentions. However I think he just screwed up and held the VNR too long and it wasn't an incident calling for lethal force. If that was the case, then negligent homicide could be possible and it would be at the discretion of the prosecutor and jury. I would see him as being covered by the good samaritan law and let him go. Another option would be for guys to just pin him down without the VNR.
The bad guy stated "im gonna take u all with me". This is in a city where 9/11 happened with the suicide highjackers.
A reasomable use of deadly force sounds fine. But im not a corrupt prosecutor looking to screw over a white guy.
Unless the bad guy meant hes taking everyone to Burger King.
Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk
-
Why does it seem everything is skewed against the good guys nowadays.
When you do good, it's bad.
When you do something bad, society has to understand. And administer kumbaya, kindness, and tolerance to your behavior.
Never mind that there are innocent people dead or injured.
-
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12051875/Video-shows-Marine-veteran-Daniel-Penny-ignoring-warnings-restraining-Jordan-Neely.html
Remember, it's not as cut and dried as one might believe, because one knows the outcome in advance and what the videos shows from a spectator's perspective. In the moment, it's an adrenaline driven event with people talking and yelling from different directions. Focus and attention can be taken away from Neely as others assist -- which seems to be the case while 2-3 people are helping Penny subdue Neely.
Several people testified they were afraid for their safety, and some for their lives. Neely was threatening to kill them (men, women and children) and was obviously not in his right mind. How much Monday morning quarterbacking is acceptable when second-guessing the actions Penny took? This wasn't a refereed wrestling match or military training class. It's a judgement call, and what matters is what Neely was thinking at that moment.
The videos include some of the statements he made to police. He only wanted to stop the threat, not injure or kill anyone.
I counted 50 seconds from when Neely went limp to Penny completely releasing him. Depends when he released or relaxed the hold and can't tell from the videos. Holding the VNR for 50 seconds after going limp would be going into negligence. I think a normally fit person would most likely recover without permanent injury tho.
Most likely the hold and excitement combined with the drugs and other ailments did him in.
-
Why does it seem everything is skewed against the good guys nowadays.
When you do good, it's bad.
When you do something bad, society has to understand. And administer kumbaya, kindness, and tolerance to your behavior.
Never mind that there are innocent people dead or injured.
The answer is black and white.
I'm not one to blame all government decisions on DEI/race in all cases, but the media helps fuel these attitudes. When Democrat-run states have already had riots in the streets, buildings and businesses destroyed, stores looted, city blocks taken over by protestors, cops assassinated in cold blood and so on, the people in charge become conditioned to try and prevent the next occurrence. Their actions are "skewed" not so much against the good guys, but more like skewed for the black (or other minority) person and against the Caucasian individual.
White man wins fight with deranged Black man, so it must have been racially motivated. Even if it wasn't, people can be convinced it was, because Black Lives Matter and White Privilege.
i'm not saying the powers that control NYC aren't looking to stop violence by punishing people who defend themselves and others. After all, the good guy will stay on scene while the criminal will flee, making the good guy easier to prosecute than the evasive criminal.
I'm just saying the government has the safety of the entire city at large to manage, and preventing another backlash from what can be perceived as a murdering White man walking without charges for killing an "unarmed black man" could be a higher priority than actual justice.
-
I counted 50 seconds from when Neely went limp to Penny completely releasing him. Depends when he released or relaxed the hold and can't tell from the videos. Holding the VNR for 50 seconds after going limp would be going into negligence. I think a normally fit person would most likely recover without permanent injury tho.
Most likely the hold and excitement combined with the drugs and other ailments did him in.
i'm curious if you would have come a definitive conclusion that the choke hold was unquestionably the cause of death after watching that video but before any tox reports were available? Would the fact he was positive for drugs have made you change that conclusion?
That's what the medical examiner did. She said a cause of death could not be found from the physical evidence obtained at autopsy, but the video she watched afterward was the evidence that proved Penny killed him. She said no amount of drugs in Neely's system would have changed her mind.
-
watching Quincy, House, Doogie Howser or Googling WebMD does not make anyone a doctor
-
i'm curious if you would have come a definitive conclusion that the choke hold was unquestionably the cause of death after watching that video but before any tox reports were available? Would the fact he was positive for drugs have made you change that conclusion?
That's what the medical examiner did. She said a cause of death could not be found from the physical evidence obtained at autopsy, but the video she watched afterward was the evidence that proved Penny killed him. She said no amount of drugs in Neely's system would have changed her mind.
Depends on what their policy and procedures are, or whatever the industry standard is.
-
I counted 50 seconds from when Neely went limp to Penny completely releasing him. Depends when he released or relaxed the hold and can't tell from the videos. Holding the VNR for 50 seconds after going limp would be going into negligence. I think a normally fit person would most likely recover without permanent injury tho.
Most likely the hold and excitement combined with the drugs and other ailments did him in.
I watched the video and here are my thoughts. For the sake of focusing on the "choke hold", lets accept that the circumstance justified the initial application.
The difference between having a headlock and applying a choke of some sort can be so subtle as to be nearly impossible to visually tell whether Penny was closing off the blood flow or the airway. The choke wasn't in quite as deep as a good VNR should be but looking at Penny's left bicep, it looked like it was not far down his head enough to get good pressure on the sides of neck. If your bicep is too high on the head you end up squeezing their jaw bone and wont have much effect. Maybe he was still able to get sufficient pressure though. The video does show that the guy had clearly lost consciousness at a certain point but prior to that we don't know if his stillness was exhaustion or being unconscious. If he had crushed the trachea or yanked on his head causing a spinal injury I would think the coroner would be able to tell but there is no way the coroner can look at the video and determine the hold was the cause of death because we can't tell how much pressure Penny applied or when he applied the pressure and when he released the pressure. I have done mat-work with people who can turn light purple from a choke and still be consciously fighting and do so for a good 30 seconds because the choke is not quite closed enough.
From the point that Penny realizes the guy has lost consciousness he quickly lets go and they try to get him to a recovery position. If he had held the choke knowing that the male had lost consciousness then there could be a stronger case for a manslaughter type crime but his actions don't look negligent or reckless to me.
This is just a breakdown of the choke itself. There are so many other variables which can weigh on whether the choke was justified, whether it's length was justified, etc. I haven't dove into what lead up to the application of the choke hold so I don't have an opinion on that part. For Penny though, he has to be able to justify every step from beginning to end.
-
The original thread is old, so starting a fresh one. Original thread:
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=49828.0
Daniel Penny's fate is now in the hands of the jury - or is it? The prosecution and defense rested, and the jury has been deliberating over the 1st count of Manslaughter before considering the 2nd count of Negligent Homicide.
Today, news has it that the jury is deadlocked on the 1st charge, which is the more serious one.
Here's the nutshell summary of the courtroom shenanigans:
What should have happened in the jury room:
step 1 - deliberate on the 1st charge
step 2 - agree on a verdict on the 1st charge, either guilty or not guilty. A hung jury on the 1st count means a mistrial, so they never get to step 3.
step 3 - deliberate on the 2nd charge
step 4 - agree on a verdict on the 2nd charge
Here's where the prosecution and judge show how evil they are. In any other trial, when a jury is unable to reach a decision on the primary charge, the entire case is declared a mistrial and all charges are unresolved. The prosecutor can refile to retry the case either the same as the first time, or they can refile with only the lesser charge/s in order to make a conviction more likely.
However, when the prosecutor heard about the deadlock (before the judge was able to declare a mistrial), they made a motion to drop the 1st count of Manslaughter and to allow the jury to deliberate on the 2nd (lesser) charge of Negligent Homicide. And, since this is New York where rules and precedents don't really matter (re: Trump prosecutions, SCOTUS Bruen decision, ...), the judge granted the motion.
That's not how the system is supposed to work.
The defense of course objected to the motion to drop the 1st charge and asked to continue the trial to a verdict, as they were right to do. Even though I think he'll have a great basis to appeal the verdict if convicted, this is a sleazy move by the state to salvage a case that was about to be declared a mistrial.
What really sucks about this is the state presented a case to try and prove manslaughter. How much of that evidence would not have been presented, or presented in a different manner, or been disputed differently by the defense, had the trial started out with only the 2nd charge? Courtroom strategies often hinge on what the elements of the crime are. it's impossible to instruct the jury to now disregard any evidence that only pertains to the Manslaughter charge and not the Negligent Homicide charge.
Was this in violation of some rule or standard or is it just an outside of the box strategy by the prosecutors?
-
Was this in violation of some rule or standard or is it just an outside of the box strategy by the prosecutors?
Yes. To allow this would be to allow prosecutors to pile on severe charges they know they might not win and then throw them away during jury deliberation when it appears a mistrial is about to occur.
But, i'm not a lawyer. You should listen to this lawyer:
https://youtu.be/oVqpvNBsYVo
-
Yes. To allow this would be to allow prosecutors to pile on severe charges they know they might not win and then throw them away during jury deliberation when it appears a mistrial is about to occur.
But, i'm not a lawyer. You should listen to this lawyer:
https://youtu.be/oVqpvNBsYVo
seems like NYC specializes in "mockery & sham" trials. and New Yorkers seem to be proud of it.
-
seems like NYC specializes in "mockery & sham" trials. and New Yorkers seem to be proud of it.
I think most New Yorkers have the age old attitude of "I don't want to get involved!" If Trump, Penny or anyone else is getting screwed by the system, they don't give a flip, because it doesn't involve them personally.
-
Verdict in. NOT GUILTY.
-
yasssss!!!!!
Verdict in. NOT GUILTY.
-
Da crazy guy faddah already filed a lawsuit. Maybe NY can give him $2M to make him go away. Follow HI example.
-
Good to see. Amazed it was a unanimous ruling though, figured there'd be some politically motivated people that would screw it up. People are that fed up with crime NY.
It was either self defense or there was reasonable doubt the choke was used or for how long since the autopsy report didn't state injuries, the witnesses, and Neely's mental and physical state.
-
He's also lucky that he had a sizable GFM to help pay his lawyer bills.
-
Da crazy guy faddah already filed a lawsuit. Maybe NY can give him $2M to make him go away. Follow HI example.
"NY" won't give them a penny (pun intended :geekdanc:). A lawsuit would be against Daniel Penny.
Penny's GiveSendGo campaign has raised $3,306,411.
Funds are being raised to pay Mr. Penny’s legal fees incurred the
criminal charges filed and any future civil lawsuits that may arise, as
well as expenses related to his defense.
it appears they fully anticipated civil actions after the criminal case.
Being that he's been found not guilty criminally, it helps his defense against civil action even though the standard of proof is lower for civil trials. A guilty verdict would have given Neely's family a slam dunk.
-
Curious how he was acquitted by the same jury that had at least one person believing he was guilty of manslaughter.
So, what went on in that jury room? Today they voted unanimously to acquit Penny on the lesser charge of criminally negligent homicide.
Hmmmm. Seems like more going on than a preponderance of the evidence.
It would be interesting to learn why the person/people who voted guilty on the first count changed their minds after the prosecution had the first count dismissed?
Maybe they interpreted that as the prosecution wanting to get a verdict on count 2 two avoid a mistrial -- that they believe the prosecution couldn't win on the merits if they retried the case?
Maybe they saw that as a sign the prosecution knew he was not guilty of Manslaughter?
In a normal trial, the prosecution would not drop, or be allowed by the judge to drop, the first of 2 counts without having reached a plea deal with the defendant. Once the jury is deliberating, it's rare that the prosecution makes any changes to their case unless they hammer out a plea deal to ensure a conviction.
Once the jury was deemed deadlocked and a mistrial declared, the prosecution may offer a plea deal to avoid having to retry the case. Different jury, more time has passed, defense has more time to prepare including finding more witnesses in their favor, etc. -- it can all work against a conviction. They will try to use the mistrial and possible refiling to urge the defendant to put the matter behind them rather than spend their lives and money on further litigation and possible appeals.
I also have to ask, did the jury resent the prosecution for withdrawing the top charge in an effort to game the system and ensure a conviction? Maybe that flipped the guilty votes to not guilty -- so as to not reward the state's bad behavior?
This is a strange trial. Good ending to a court battle that should have never gone to trial. :thumbsup: :geekdanc: :shaka:
https://youtu.be/p5KOJNKgbaM
-
Yes. To allow this would be to allow prosecutors to pile on severe charges they know they might not win and then throw them away during jury deliberation when it appears a mistrial is about to occur.
But, i'm not a lawyer. You should listen to this lawyer:
https://youtu.be/oVqpvNBsYVo
Thanks, i'll give it a listen. Usually I follow these types of cases closely but I am just learning about this one now.
-
Thanks, i'll give it a listen. Usually I follow these types of cases closely but I am just learning about this one now.
The altercation happened on May 1, 2023 on a NY Subway.
On May 11, 2023, Penny was charged with second-degree manslaughter
and was released on bond. He was formally indicted by a grand jury the
next month, with an additional lesser charge of criminally negligent homicide
added a few weeks later. Penny pleaded not guilty to both charges,
under which he faced up to 15 years in prison. Two men shown in
Vázquez's video helping Penny to restrain Neely were not charged.
Penny's trial began in October 2024 and concluded in December 2024.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killing_of_Jordan_Neely
Maybe you should catch up by reading this thread, lots of good info on the linked articles and videos.
Just skip past the derailment section. You'll know it when you see it.
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=49828.0
-
Thanks, i'll give it a listen. Usually I follow these types of cases closely but I am just learning about this one now.
1 factor that isn't mentioned much is that this took place where 9/11 took place. So when someones yelling "i'm going to take you all with me", a reasonable person would assume suicide bomber or highjacker, etc...
-
1 factor that isn't mentioned much is that this took place where 9/11 took place. So when someones yelling "i'm going to take you all with me", a reasonable person would assume suicide bomber or highjacker, etc...
Even a deranged-sounding man with a knife or lead pipe could kill or severely injure a lot of people in a closed space if nobody fights back out of fear of being wrung through the NY legal system.
Not many people hijack a subway train, but with the whack jobs and drug abusers in big cities, you never know.
A lot of suicidal people opt for suicide by Cop, which means they won't be timid about taking others down with them.
Many scenarios, but luckily this one ended with only the threat being taken down and without gunfire erupting on a crowded subway train and platform.
Now if the voters there can stop the threat that is the NYC prosecutor's office.
-
https://youtu.be/i39EV0ve5qM
-
Daniel Penny's defense lawyers are considering filing a Malicious Prosecution Lawsuit against NYC DA Alvin Bragg and others who decided to press charges and take Penny to trial.
One fact that is in Penny's favor: there was another man who assisted Penny in holding Neely down as they waited for police to arrive. That man was not charged at all. The man, 39 yo Eric Gonzalez, testified in the Penny trial under a non-prosecution agreement with the Manhattan District Attorney's Office.
Gonzalez lied to the police on day one, saying Neely hit him in order to justify his and Penny's actions. He claimed he arrived on scene earlier that was actual, and he admitted lying because he was afraid of having Neely's death pinned on him.
All that lying, but he gets a non-prosecution agreement to testify -- as an admitted liar -- while Penny gets railroaded.
*********
Gonzalez is the one in the black coat and ball cap. I'll leave any deductions about why he was essentially given immunity to you.
(https://i.imgur.com/1zYHH2G.png)
-
Not white. Popolo.
Das why.
-
Daniel Penny's defense lawyers are considering filing a Malicious Prosecution Lawsuit against NYC DA Alvin Bragg and others who decided to press charges and take Penny to trial.
One fact that is in Penny's favor: there was another man who assisted Penny in holding Neely down as they waited for police to arrive. That man was not charged at all. The man, 39 yo Eric Gonzalez, testified in the Penny trial under a non-prosecution agreement with the Manhattan District Attorney's Office.
Gonzalez lied to the police on day one, saying Neely hit him in order to justify his and Penny's actions. He claimed he arrived on scene earlier that was actual, and he admitted lying because he was afraid of having Neely's death pinned on him.
All that lying, but he gets a non-prosecution agreement to testify -- as an admitted liar -- while Penny gets railroaded.
*********
Gonzalez is the one in the black coat and ball cap. I'll leave any deductions about why he was essentially given immunity to you.
I think the most likely case is that Bragg thought needed Eric to testify in order to win against Penny. Either way, offering a non-prosecution agreement to one party is not enough to prove malicious prosecution, I think Penny's attorneys face an uphill battle on this one.
-
I think the most likely case is that Bragg thought needed Eric to testify in order to win against Penny. Either way, offering a non-prosecution agreement to one party is not enough to prove malicious prosecution, I think Penny's attorneys face an uphill battle on this one.
SWWOOOOOOSSSSHHHHHHHHHHH X1000ft.
-
Rumor is Pete is inviting Perry to the Army/Navy football game.
IDK if Trump will be there. But would be interesting to see a president elect and if he switches sides as the POTUS traditionally does. Either your for Army or Navy, but POTUS is for both.
-
I think the most likely case is that Bragg thought needed Eric to testify in order to win against Penny. Either way, offering a non-prosecution agreement to one party is not enough to prove malicious prosecution, I think Penny's attorneys face an uphill battle on this one.
Unequal application of the law is the best evidence of malicious prosecution.
Just ask Trump. He's been convicted of crimes no other developer has ever been charged with. They are crimes that would have been misdemeanors except for the unproven and undisclosed underlying crime needed to charge as felonies.
You totally ignored all the times Gonzalez lied to the police -- something in and of itself is a criminal act. Yet, this is the dishonest man Bragg "needed?" Gonzalez would say whatever Bragg told him to say if it meant not being charged alongside Penny.
-
(https://i.imgur.com/9xu2rxk.jpg)
-
Unequal application of the law is the best evidence of malicious prosecution.
Just ask Trump. He's been convicted of crimes no other developer has ever been charged with. They are crimes that would have been misdemeanors except for the unproven and undisclosed underlying crime needed to charge as felonies.
You totally ignored all the times Gonzalez lied to the police -- something in and of itself is a criminal act. Yet, this is the dishonest man Bragg "needed?" Gonzalez would say whatever Bragg told him to say if it meant not being charged alongside Penny.
Incorrect. Proving unequal application of the law is a difficult case to start with since it is going to be hard to find any other case to directly compare it to. In other words you would need to point to another case where a drugged up crazy person threatened a bunch of people on a subway and got chocked out, ultimately dying, by a good Samaritan and the same prosecutors chose not to charge the Samaritan. On top of that you would also need to prove that this was the case where the prosecution erred. By that I mean even if you found a good parallel case you would need to prove that this one was prosecuted wrongly as opposed the other case not being prosecuted when it should have been. The prosecutors would put forth the claim that any parallel case that wasn't prosecuted was actually the unequal application. Simply put there are so many small variables from case to case and from prosecutor to prosecutor it is very hard to say that it was malicious prosecution. We can assume bias and politics all day long but proving it in court is not an easy case to make.
Yes Trump has been prosecuted under a statute that has never been used before but when you look at the facts of the case he did technically violate the statute. The problem with the hush money case is not in whether he did violate the law rather it was because it was so technical and stretching that it wouldn't be done if it weren't Trump.
A malicious prosecution involves filing a case without grounds or probable cause. The Penny case and the hush money case are not without probable cause so even if you could make the case that the law was not applied equally, that still does not amount to malicious prosecution. Imagine cop 1 gives warnings all day long then the next day cop 2 gives tickets all day long in the same area for the same speeds. You can argue unequal application of speeding law but thats not grounds for maliciousness.
I didn't ignore that Gonzales lied to police, I only stated that I thought he needed Gonzalez' testimony to prove his case. Having lied to police is not a major disqualifier as is lying under oath (perjury), legally speaking. Criminals lie to cops all the time but if they are a key witness they are still used.
-
Incorrect. Proving unequal application of the law is a difficult case to start with since it is going to be hard to find any other case to directly compare it to. In other words you would need to point to another case where a drugged up crazy person threatened a bunch of people on a subway and got chocked out, ultimately dying, by a good Samaritan and the same prosecutors chose not to charge the Samaritan. On top of that you would also need to prove that this was the case where the prosecution erred. By that I mean even if you found a good parallel case you would need to prove that this one was prosecuted wrongly as opposed the other case not being prosecuted when it should have been. The prosecutors would put forth the claim that any parallel case that wasn't prosecuted was actually the unequal application. Simply put there are so many small variables from case to case and from prosecutor to prosecutor it is very hard to say that it was malicious prosecution. We can assume bias and politics all day long but proving it in court is not an easy case to make.
Yes Trump has been prosecuted under a statute that has never been used before but when you look at the facts of the case he did technically violate the statute. The problem with the hush money case is not in whether he did violate the law rather it was because it was so technical and stretching that it wouldn't be done if it weren't Trump.
A malicious prosecution involves filing a case without grounds or probable cause. The Penny case and the hush money case are not without probable cause so even if you could make the case that the law was not applied equally, that still does not amount to malicious prosecution. Imagine cop 1 gives warnings all day long then the next day cop 2 gives tickets all day long in the same area for the same speeds. You can argue unequal application of speeding law but thats not grounds for maliciousness.
I didn't ignore that Gonzales lied to police, I only stated that I thought he needed Gonzalez' testimony to prove his case. Having lied to police is not a major disqualifier as is lying under oath (perjury), legally speaking. Criminals lie to cops all the time but if they are a key witness they are still used.
i'm not going to pretend to defend or explain what Penny's lawyers stated. You have an opposing opinion (surprise) and feel like you have to defend it with definitions you copied from google results.
All I can tell you is the process should have resulted in nobody charged. Alvin Bragg has demonstrated political bias in exercising the powers of his office more than once. To me, this is one more example of a political prosecution -- it is even more obvious since a jury unanimously found him not guilty in spite of some believing him guilty of more serious charges.
Whereas most google lawyers post a definition of malicious prosecution to include having the charges dismissed, this is the real standard:
The Supreme Court, on April 4, 2022, held in a 6-3 opinion in Thompson v. Clark
(2022) 142 S.Ct. 1332, that a plaintiff who brings a Fourth Amendment claim under
42 U.S.C. § 1983 (“Section 1983”) for malicious prosecution need only show the
underlying criminal prosecution ended without a conviction to demonstrate the
favorable termination element of the claim.
So, that eliminates the "charges dismissed" hurdle. And it doesn't take a genius to show the video, not medical evidence, caused the ME to change the cause of death to a homicide by asphyxiation. Video evidence can be misinterpreted due to lighting, perception, angle of viewpoint, etc. In the Rittenhouse case, there was a lot of video evidence. Both the prosecution and defense used the same video evidence to argue both sides of the case. The prosecution lost, because they jury didn't buy their conclusions based on the video and witness testimony.
i hope they get NYC by the financial balls and squeeze. That place is a judicial s#!thole.
-
Prosecutor stated that they charged Perry due to the bad guys past experience of injustice and stuff like that. Nothing to see here...
Perry went to NYC for school. I hope this is a lesson to anyone who goes to NYC for school or moves for work to think twice.
-
i'm not going to pretend to defend or explain what Penny's lawyers stated. You have an opposing opinion (surprise) and feel like you have to defend it with definitions you copied from google results.
All I can tell you is the process should have resulted in nobody charged. Alvin Bragg has demonstrated political bias in exercising the powers of his office more than once.
I do agree with you here but note that I am not saying his lawyers have no case, only pointing it out as a difficult case. Then again, he doesn't even have to prove the case if he can get them to settle for a decent sum so he doesn't have to even win to win.
From the Thomas V Clark case
"And the wrongful initiation of charges without probable cause is
likewise the gravamen of the tort of malicious prosecution. "
https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/21pdf/20-659_3ea4.pdf
So the fact that the prosecution ended without conviction isn't the only or even the dominant question to look at. As I said we are in agreement that the case should not have been brought but proving it was malicious is a much higher burden than proving, for example, that Bragg had bad judgement in whether to file the case.