2aHawaii
General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: Jl808 on January 18, 2013, 09:21:13 AM
-
Ok, thinking this through... I am thinking about what ideas I would have when talking with legislators about not infringing on our rights.
Is there anything that can be done (besides adding more laws) to prevent guns from being accessed by law breakers?
Or do what we have now work and it's just a matter of better enforcement? What are our gun crime stats in Hawaii?
Other ideas?
-
Ok, thinking this through... I am thinking about what ideas I would have when talking with legislators about not infringing on our rights.
Is there anything that can be done (besides adding more laws) to prevent guns from being accessed by law breakers?
Or do what we have now work and it's just a matter of better enforcement? What are our gun crime stats in Hawaii?
Other ideas?
Yes; several other ideas. Not trying to sound all "conspiracy theorist" or anything like that, but do you all think it would be best to discuss these ideas online, in a public forum, though?
-
Ok, thinking this through... I am thinking about what ideas I would have when talking with legislators about not infringing on our rights.
Is there anything that can be done (besides adding more laws) to prevent guns from being accessed by law breakers?
Or do what we have now work and it's just a matter of better enforcement? What are our gun crime stats in Hawaii?
Other ideas?
the past three years, we've had 24 total murders with guns.
how much safer can it honestly get with more laws?
-
Yes; several other ideas. Not trying to sound all "conspiracy theorist" or anything like that, but do you all think it would be best to discuss these ideas online, in a public forum, though?
im not sure what you'd be suggesting, but he's suggesting how to stop criminals from getting guns, not the lawmakers from confiscating them.
-
you cant stop the criminals from getting guns. The only thing you can do is make sure there are more good guys with guns then bad guys. Allow CCW.
-
Well, I'll do what I can to find and post the stats I've been looking at. I recall from my legislation reading and fact checking last night that Hawaii had all of 1 firearm homicide in 2011 and it was with a rifle and that nationally we consistently rank in the top 5 safest states. Where we rank at the moment I don't know.
I'm not sure there is much liability in discussing these things publicly. Its not like we have a backroom avenue to make something sneaky happen anyway. Sure, anyone can see this but I doubt very many people other than us are looking at it. I'd be aware that this is a public space and, as always, chose your words accordingly.
I think its a great idea to discuss this. I've often thought that the gun lobby needs to do more to address the fears of those clamoring for more gun safety. In the absence of our expertise (only partly through our own fault) we have things like "assault weapons" being defined by cosmetics. Yep, that bayonet lug sure does make that rifle SOOO much more dangerous. Wait, when was the last time a mounted bayonet was used in the commission of a crime?
Meanwhile there are REAL issues that we could work together on solving like how to keep weapons out of the hands of criminals. Hawaii actually does this fairly well and has its priorities largely straight: 1 permit to acquire per year for long guns, 1 permit for each handgun. And, like it or not, all modern weapons are registered and that registration is used to confiscate weapons from people if they become ineligible to own firearms. This combination is fairly effective while largely allowing civilians to own non-NFA firearms that give us enough teeth to feel like we could put up a fight against tyranny if we had to.
That's what the crime stats say: handguns are by far the most common firearms used in crimes.
Better funding of law enforcement is a must. LEO's have an extremely tough job and that gets exponentially harder the more hostile the funding situation gets. In particular the ATF needs to be stabilized, well funded, and WELL REGULATED so they stop killing innocent people with no-knock raids based on inaccurate information. The director of the ATF should be someone who understands firearms and not a left wing, armchair theoretician. Hell, call Petraeus and see if he's looking for a job.
Those are a few ideas of the top of my head.
-
Well, I'll do what I can to find and post the stats I've been looking at. I recall from my legislation reading and fact checking last night that Hawaii had all of 1 firearm homicide in 2011 and it was with a rifle and that nationally we consistently rank in the top 5 safest states. Where we rank at the moment I don't know.
I'm not sure there is much liability in discussing these things publicly. Its not like we have a backroom avenue to make something sneaky happen anyway. Sure, anyone can see this but I doubt very many people other than us are looking at it. I'd be aware that this is a public space and, as always, chose your words accordingly.
I think its a great idea to discuss this. I've often thought that the gun lobby needs to do more to address the fears of those clamoring for more gun safety. In the absence of our expertise (only partly through our own fault) we have things like "assault weapons" being defined by cosmetics. Yep, that bayonet lug sure does make that rifle SOOO much more dangerous. Wait, when was the last time a mounted bayonet was used in the commission of a crime?
Meanwhile there are REAL issues that we could work together on solving like how to keep weapons out of the hands of criminals. Hawaii actually does this fairly well and has its priorities largely straight: 1 permit to acquire per year for long guns, 1 permit for each handgun. And, like it or not, all modern weapons are registered and that registration is used to confiscate weapons from people if they become ineligible to own firearms. This combination is fairly effective while largely allowing civilians to own non-NFA firearms that give us enough teeth to feel like we could put up a fight against tyranny if we had to.
That's what the crime stats say: handguns are by far the most common firearms used in crimes.
Better funding of law enforcement is a must. LEO's have an extremely tough job and that gets exponentially harder the more hostile the funding situation gets. In particular the ATF needs to be stabilized, well funded, and WELL REGULATED so they stop killing innocent people with no-knock raids based on inaccurate information. The director of the ATF should be someone who understands firearms and not a left wing, armchair theoretician. Hell, call Petraeus and see if he's looking for a job.
Those are a few ideas of the top of my head.
have at it.
http://www2.fbi.gov/ucr/cius2009/data/table_20.html (http://www2.fbi.gov/ucr/cius2009/data/table_20.html)
http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/crime-in-the-u.s/2010/crime-in-the-u.s.-2010/tables/10tbl20.xls (http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/crime-in-the-u.s/2010/crime-in-the-u.s.-2010/tables/10tbl20.xls)
http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/crime-in-the-u.s/2011/crime-in-the-u.s.-2011/tables/table-20 (http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/crime-in-the-u.s/2011/crime-in-the-u.s.-2011/tables/table-20)
-
im not sure what you'd be suggesting, but he's suggesting how to stop criminals from getting guns, not the lawmakers from confiscating them.
Try read original post again, bruddah xer21. See, below:
Ok, thinking this through... I am thinking about what ideas I would have when talking with legislators about not infringing on our rights.
Bruddah JI808 DOES talk about how to stop criminals from getting guns in his sentence, below:
Is there anything that can be done (besides adding more laws) to prevent guns from being accessed by law breakers?
What I was "suggesting" refers to the first sentence and the last sentence of the original post. Do you want to give your thoughts and strategies away to members of the pro-gun community who may be viewing this public, online forum?
-
bass monkey, you actually can largely stop the criminals from getting guns. Australia and England are proof of this and there are many others so your argument, while I agree with you, is easy to invalidate. The NFA itself is also proof that gun control alters the gun violence landscape. The trick in the US and the individual states is balancing than against the 2nd amendment and the weight of public opinion that England's solution is not constitutional here.
Meanwhile, examples like Vermont and New Hampshire are also worth pointing out: 2 of the most lax gun control states yet are the top two safe states in terms of gun control. Why? Is it JUST that the gun laws are lax or are there other factors. Louisiana also has incredibly lax gun laws and it is the least safe state. Why? What's the difference? Is it the heat? The state of the economy? Something in the water?
Its very worth talking about because without looking at real stats and thinking outside the box we're just going to get more bullshit "barrel shrouds are dangerous!" from our brilliant legislators.
-
North Dakota also has almost no gun related homicides.
Hmmm... I think we'll find that the most effective way to reduce ~gun~ violence (which has already been the trend for several years despite increases in gun ownership) will be reducing the conditions which encourage violent crime in general. More jobs, better social services, stabilized economy, less income inequality, effective and high integrity law enforcement, etc.
-
North Dakota also has almost no gun related homicides.
Hmmm... I think we'll find that the most effective way to reduce ~gun~ violence (which has already been the trend for several years despite increases in gun ownership) will be reducing the conditions which encourage violent crime in general. More jobs, better social services, stabilized economy, less income inequality, effective and high integrity law enforcement, etc.
How about making sure that all legal firearms owners store their firearms properly. I cannot tell you how many people I have spoken to that keep their guns under the bed, in the car etc. And they think that is OK. Many say "I am thinking about buying one of those gun cabinets." Thinking about it? You have the responsiblity as an owner to secure it in a manner that negates the chances of an accident and reduces as much as possible the chance of theft. This alone would contribute to keeping guns out of the hands of criminals. I am not accusing anyone in particular but some of the people I have come across don't seem to understand the importance of this responsibility. That would be my step #1.....
-
BUD, I'd say store it however you like but if it isn't under lock and key (of some kind) the owner may be held partially liable for what happens with the weapon if it is stolen.
Not substantially different than if I forget to park my car properly when on a steep hill and it rolls into someone's house. My property, my lack of proper control over it, my responsibility for the damage. Its not 1 to 1 responsibility with stolen firearms, though, if someone else commits a crime with it - that will be a tricky one to word properly.
I wouldn't mandate particular kinds of storage by law. Having a home defense weapon that you can't get to is considered by many people to be rather pointless. The law can encourage safe storage, though. HI law already does this, I think, with regard to children having inappropriate access to firearms.
-
bass monkey, you actually can largely stop the criminals from getting guns. Australia and England are proof of this and there are many others so your argument, while I agree with you, is easy to invalidate. The NFA itself is also proof that gun control alters the gun violence landscape. The trick in the US and the individual states is balancing than against the 2nd amendment and the weight of public opinion that England's solution is not constitutional here.
Meanwhile, examples like Vermont and New Hampshire are also worth pointing out: 2 of the most lax gun control states yet are the top two safe states in terms of gun control. Why? Is it JUST that the gun laws are lax or are there other factors. Louisiana also has incredibly lax gun laws and it is the least safe state. Why? What's the difference? Is it the heat? The state of the economy? Something in the water?
Its very worth talking about because without looking at real stats and thinking outside the box we're just going to get more bullshit "barrel shrouds are dangerous!" from our brilliant legislators.
That is true, but at the same time it also takes guns away from the law abiding citizen. I was also trying to avoid the C word
-
... implement stiffer penalties for crimes committed using firearms.
-
Ban or no ban criminals will acquire guns. Is idiotic to think that a ban will prevent the criminal underworld from acquireing guns. Take a look at drugs. It's been banned for decades yet it still runs rampant in our streets.
They need to strengthen our laws. Make the punishment so severe that the criminal element will shy away from the use of guns because the penalty is so severe. On the flip side where are we going to put the convicted when they are sent to prison. No one wants to build new prisons to hold the offenders. So went in into a "damned if we do, and damned if we don't scenario.
I believe that a gun is used in a crime it should be a automatic a felony that cannot be pled down with a mandatory minimum 8 years without the possibility of parole. If the weapon is fired it is another 3 years per round fired. If the crime involves children it is 10 years per child affected. These type of criminals need to be put away and the key lost. They do not belong in society.
They need to stop blaming the responsible gun owners and face the reality. Punish the offenders.
-
Ban or no ban criminals will acquire guns. Is idiotic to think that a ban will prevent the criminal underworld from acquireing guns. Take a look at drugs. It's been banned for decades yet it still runs rampant in our streets.
They need to strengthen our laws. Make the punishment so severe that the criminal element will shy away from the use of guns because the penalty is so severe. On the flip side where are we going to put the convicted when they are sent to prison. No one wants to build new prisons to hold the offenders. So went in into a "damned if we do, and damned if we don't scenario.
I believe that a gun is used in a crime it should be a automatic a felony that cannot be pled down with a mandatory minimum 8 years without the possibility of parole. If the weapon is fired it is another 3 years per round fired. If the crime involves children it is 10 years per child affected. These type of criminals need to be put away and the key lost. They do not belong in society.
They need to stop blaming the responsible gun owners and face the reality. Punish the offenders.
+1. Agree.
-
first this was brought on by sandy hook. why is there such misinformation and lack of evidence on what type of gun was used, but the media blew it up as the AR. whatever type of gun that was used was acquired legally so all this legislation would of done nothing to prevent the tragedy that took place. in one of obamas speechs he even said laws would not of stopped these types of tragedies. really wonder why they are really concentrating on demonizing the AR. I'm not a conspiracy type of guy but all this media that dosent add up really has me thinking
-
Reality: The US has the most firearms per capita
Reality: We have among the highest rates of gun violence among the 1st world nations and worse than several 3rd world nations.
Reality: Anti-gunners use this as their premise that reducing the availability of any guns for any reason will contribute to reducing gun violence.
Reality: Countries that have drastically reduced civilian access to firearms have a marked drop in gun related violence
Reality: We either address this effectively or it will continue being the basis of incremental gun control legislation that doesn't actually make us any safer.
-
Reality: The US has the most firearms per capita
This is a good thing.
Reality: We have among the highest rates of gun violence among the 1st world nations and worse than several 3rd world nations.
If there are no guns, violent crimes will involve less guns is obvious. dosent mean it makes people less violent and violent crimes will go down.
The media will show us what they hope to turn into general consciousness.
backround checks should be mandatory. lower capacity magazines ok. crimes committed by convicted criminals with firearms should have sever penalties. disarming the people unconstitutional.
-
Is any gun law really gonna have any affect on someone that is committed to commit such crimes. there mind is made up and no law is gonna have weight in their decisions. If new laws that don't stop criminals or tragedies from happening pass, and gun violence is still a problem. what kind of laws will they pass next?
-
2L8v, that's kind of my point. Of course criminals don't obey laws. That is why incrementalism is the ONLY valid gun control strategy and the anti-gun strategists know it. Every new law is a step in the direction of having almost no guns available - the only way it has ever been demonstrated to reduce the number of guns in the hands of criminals.
That is the key for us in the pro-gun stance: removing guns, at its most extreme, only reduces GUN violence - if that. States like NH and VT demonstrate that the presence of guns in the hands of citizens reduces ALL violence.
My point is that in order to build a common language with the idiots on the left we have to demonstrate that our way is better than theirs even for what it is they (say they) want to do. CCW works. Really damned well. And it reduces all violent crime not just "gun violence." In no cases does extreme gun control (Chicago, anyone?) actually reduce violence of any kind.
You can say "But its not about 'gun violence', it is about disarming the people so they are easier to control!" Of course it is, but we can't say that and still play in the nice illusion that is politics in D.C. We don't need to make that argument - and get called tinfoil hat wearers - when the CCW argument is so strong.
The key thing to understand about most liberals (though certainly not all) is that they really do believe that fewer guns for any reason makes us safer. They aren't thinking of it in terms of government tyranny at all and aren't knowingly trying to undermine our defense against tyranny, they really are just trying to make things safer. If we can prove that universal CCW would make things safer a significant number of them can be swayed to support it.
Nationally, at least, and in some other battleground states. I think HI has a variety of reasons that CCW is a steep uphill battle - and none of them have to do with public safety.
-
De-criminalize pakalolo. Prices would go down leaving no incentive for people to kill each other over drug money and territory.
-
Reality: The US has the most firearms per capita
Reality: We have among the highest rates of gun violence among the 1st world nations and worse than several 3rd world nations.
Reality: Anti-gunners use this as their premise that reducing the availability of any guns for any reason will contribute to reducing gun violence.
Reality: Countries that have drastically reduced civilian access to firearms have a marked drop in gun related violence
Reality: We either address this effectively or it will continue being the basis of incremental gun control legislation that doesn't actually make us any safer.
Here is some reality. The U.S. 28th in gun homicide rates. The U.S. not in the top 10 for violent crime rates...
http://newsbusters.org/blogs/noel-sheppard/2013/01/10/fox-affiliate-thoroughly-debunks-piers-morgan-s-gun-homicide-statisti (http://newsbusters.org/blogs/noel-sheppard/2013/01/10/fox-affiliate-thoroughly-debunks-piers-morgan-s-gun-homicide-statisti)
-
The article is confusing/comparing violence rates and gun homicide rates. The US in the top ten GUN homicides in the world and has the most gun violence of any developed nation.
edit- damn. My source was quite wrong. Clicked the wrong link in my search and didn't catch it. Bugger. The actual UN data I thought I was referring to isn't collated the same way. The UN .xls form data is here: http://www.unodc.org/unodc/en/data-and-analysis/homicide.html (http://www.unodc.org/unodc/en/data-and-analysis/homicide.html)
Gotta keep the numbers in their proper place - or what the numbers say is not reality. If you have a source that puts the US at 28th for gun homicides I'd love to see it.
I'm not refuting the point of the article, though. The UK is a MUCH less safe place than the US. But the libs focus on GUN violence stats because they think more guns = more violence. They are wrong.
That's my point: compared to the UK the US has MORE guns and LESS violence. Yes, we have more gun deaths and accidents but WAY less violence over all.
So the arguments that more guns = less safety is false. The argument that more guns = more gun accidents and death is true but less guns = less safety overall. If VT and NH are used as examples more guns in the hands of civilians = the most safety of all - INCLUDING safety from gun violence.
That's the bigger picture that the 2nd amendment argument from the right-wingnuts (from the point of view of the libs) are drowning out. They ~really~ need to stop it because it only wins arguments with people who already agree with you.
As to the topic - the best way to keep bad guys from ~using~ guns (since we can't really keep them from getting them) is to allow citizens to be armed if they wish to be. We all know this and the data supports it. Why we aren't hammering the hell out of that data to make the point that more guns, and guns ~carried~, IS more safety is beyond me.
-
clshade, you starting to make sense. :shaka:
I think thats what i am trying to say, just dont know how to say it. It makes sense
-
It is not about guns. It never was. It is all bout finding the real cause of the increase of these events.
Check this out.
http://www.ignatius-piazza-front-sight.com/2013/01/17/obamabiden-knowingly-avoid-right-target-to-stop-gun-violence/ (http://www.ignatius-piazza-front-sight.com/2013/01/17/obamabiden-knowingly-avoid-right-target-to-stop-gun-violence/)
Now why is it that they continue on this path to destroy rights? They even got us gun owners debating on what new regulation is 'acceptable'
"Shall not be infringed" im sticking by that...
Anything more is reliqueshing your freedom. A lawful gun owner is not a criminal!
-
It is not about guns. It never was. It is all bout finding the real cause of the increase of these events.
Check this out.
http://www.ignatius-piazza-front-sight.com/2013/01/17/obamabiden-knowingly-avoid-right-target-to-stop-gun-violence/ (http://www.ignatius-piazza-front-sight.com/2013/01/17/obamabiden-knowingly-avoid-right-target-to-stop-gun-violence/)
Now why is it that they continue on this path to destroy rights? They even got us gun owners debating on what new regulation is 'acceptable'
"Shall not be infringed" im sticking by that...
Anything more is reliqueshing your freedom. A lawful gun owner is not a criminal!
Amen!
-
It is not about guns. It never was. It is all bout finding the real cause of the increase of these events.
Check this out.
http://www.ignatius-piazza-front-sight.com/2013/01/17/obamabiden-knowingly-avoid-right-target-to-stop-gun-violence/ (http://www.ignatius-piazza-front-sight.com/2013/01/17/obamabiden-knowingly-avoid-right-target-to-stop-gun-violence/)
Now why is it that they continue on this path to destroy rights? They even got us gun owners debating on what new regulation is 'acceptable'
"Shall not be infringed" im sticking by that...
Anything more is reliqueshing your freedom. A lawful gun owner is not a criminal!
Amen. Everyone seems to be "acceptable" with a grandfather clause or something. We shouldnt have to keep compromising!!!
-
It is not about guns. It never was.
Wrong. For the political base of the left it IS actually about safety. Read that sentence again if you think I'm disagreeing with you.
What I'm doing is pointing out how to talk to those people who don't believe that and not sound like a paranoid lunatic to them.
The politicians may be all about restricting freedom but their base is ~actually~ about safety and think gun control is the way to do it.
We will never change the minds of the politicians. We MUST change the minds of their base. And the data supports our arguments about overall safety.
-
Wrong. For the political base of the left it IS actually about safety. Read that sentence again if you think I'm disagreeing with you.
What I'm doing is pointing out how to talk to those people who don't believe that and not sound like a paranoid lunatic to them.
The politicians may be all about restricting freedom but their base is ~actually~ about safety and think gun control is the way to do it.
We will never change the minds of the politicians. We MUST change the minds of their base. And the data supports our arguments about overall safety.
this is lost on FAR too many people who speak out on the issue. instead of properly framing their protests, they pretend that they're speaking to people who think like they do.
and that's why we have muppets like Ted Nugent and Alex Jones and more saying stupid ass things that make us look like psychos. i'll give wayne la pierre a bit a slack because i think he's trying to divide people on purpose. whether thats a good tactic, remains to be seen.
-
We don't need any further gun restrictions.
The laws in place work very well.
A) The problem is criminals buy illegal guns.
B) People need to secure their firearms in safes.
-
Its so hard to come up with a good reason to keep our laws the way they are other than its our constitutional rights. In the media they say assault rifles aren't used for hunting but our 2nd isn't about hunting, so frustrating. If we had to make an argument it would be best it not be specifically about guns but about our rights being degraded and we got to find a way to make it appeal to everyone to get more support.
-
Wrong. For the political base of the left it IS actually about safety. Read that sentence again if you think I'm disagreeing with you.
What I'm doing is pointing out how to talk to those people who don't believe that and not sound like a paranoid lunatic to them.
The politicians may be all about restricting freedom but their base is ~actually~ about safety and think gun control is the way to do it.
We will never change the minds of the politicians. We MUST change the minds of their base. And the data supports our arguments about overall safety.
What you write matches what I've observed talking with my liberal "friends" about guns. I once discussed the theater with my friend.
Me: "if I was in that theater with you and I had a gun, would you wish I was there or I wasn't?"
He: "of course I'd wish you were there. But it's because I trust you and know that you wouldn't shoot me. But how would I know that the next person with a firearm won't shoot me by accident?"
Ok so what I got out of this so far is the following...
1. Harsher punishment for crimes involving with firearms
2. Better funding for HPD
3. Allow CCW
What do you guys think about this...
4. Incentives for purchase of gun safes?
5. Incentives for taking firearm training
6. Incentives for passing safety, education and skill tests in proper handling and use of firearms? A requirement for CCW perhaps? (I know I'm dreaming but one can dream right?)
7. What about deputizing those with impeccable safety records and those that pass all tests and requirements? Allow CCW automatically? Call it a citizens deputy program?
A deputized citizen might be able to volunteer at schools or other places in case HPD officers are understaffed.
Hmm thinking about making this a win win for the state also... How about setting up an annual required test and fee to maintain a "deputy" status and to fund such a program?
-
Send some wall street bankers to prison and seize their assets. Those guys are criminals. And you better believe they are armed.
-
I believe a determined person will get his/her hands on a gun, whether criminally or not.
That being said, it is my personal opinion that making it easier for the lawful guys to have guns if they wish to have it would make the country safer.
-
Gonna take my senator to lunch this week. Any other suggestions?
-
My main argument now is that when laws fail (i.e. murder, burglary etc.) then laws that will ENABLE the citizen need to be passed. If govt. wants to take away or limit a law abiding citizens' means to defend themselves then it is only logical that the govt. take responsibilty for the citizen's personal safety. Then the govt. must provide the same means as a firearm or any other tool the citizen has or used to have - 24 hour instant access to protection. Asimple analogy is fire - the fire dept. can't be there the moment a fire is started thus we have fire extinguishers till they can respond; the same with firearms or any other defensive tool. Bottom line the govt. can not respond to a personal safety issue adequately. I was watching a "documentary" called Planet Rock narrated by Ice T and the main issue was laws that targeted drugs. Some laws made the illicit drug trade worse.
On another note, why do I have to fill out a form when I buy pepper spray?
-
edit - typing at the same time... excellent post, ren.
Jl808,
Some other possible talking points.
- Gun safety training is only a valid requirement if gun owners are allowed to carry their weapons in a way that might constitute a public threat. This is already handled for hunters via the hunters' safety course requirement. Handgun owners have no legal way to carry their firearms in a way that is a public threat. The safety training law is attempting to solve a problem we don't have.
- Annual reregistration will only tax the small firearms offices of the police departments more. It is already protocol to use registration records to confiscate any firearms owned by a person who commits a crime that makes them ineligible to own firearms. Since this is true and no measure of safety is to be gained from annual re-registration, it looks solely like an income generating stream.
- To date, firearms registration has been free other than the unavoidable 1 time fingerprint fees. This makes compliance with the law easy for those most likely to turn to crime: low income gun owners. Since there is no safety benefit to be gained, no demonstrated need for the regular safety trainings that the registration fees would help pay for there is no benefit to society from this law, only increased costs and increased risks that potential criminals will source guns on the black market.
- Requiring proof of registration for purchasing ammunition is unreasonable. A wife might ask her husband to pick up some ammunition for her pistol on the way home from work, a friend might buy some ammunition as a gift, and the sports supply stores that sell ammunition don't have the means to verify the registrations putting undue responsibility on them.
- Given that Hawaii already has some of the most effective gun regulations in the US as well as an exemplary low gun violence rate, further restrictions on law abiding gun owners may well be counterproductive - as evidenced by the substantially higher crime rates in cities and states with more severe gun control laws. Consider carefully before imposing further limitations and burdens on those who follow the law.
- With the exception that there is no way for the people of Hawaii to legally bear arms, other than while hunting, our firearms regulations strike a critical and difficult balance between ensuring public safety and meeting Hawaii's responsibility to protect it's people's 2nd amendment rights.
-
We don't need any further gun restrictions.
The laws in place work very well.
A) The problem is criminals buy illegal guns.
B) People need to secure their firearms in safes.
True dat! +1
-
Thanks guys. Besides constitutional rights, I think there are 2 topics to talk about here trying to understand where the legislature is coming from.
1. Public safety
2. Taxation / income for state
For safety, instead of punishing folks for no crime committed, I think we have to address the real issue is that it's the insane and not the tool that is causing the mass murders.
To really address the mass murder issue, the state needs to look into mental health issues why these insane individuals commit homicide and suicide.
For the issue of keeping guns out of the hands of criminals, I think this is an elephant. Additional laws are an easy way out for legislators because the law abiding are easy targets unless we speak up like we did on Saturday. Maybe they can start dealing with the real issue instead by eating the real elephant one bite at a time. I'm in no way an expert in this so I do not suggest anything on this except what you guys already have which is to make penalties stiffer for those who commit crime with a firearm.
How can the legislature make things safer in terms of firearm ownership? If the state is really interested in making firearm ownership safer, then how about tax incentives for firearm owners to buy a good safe for their firearms as well as tax incentives for taking firearm related safety classes? Firearm ownership and protecting ones family is expensive enough as it is. Ammo to practice the use the firearm safely by going to the range is also expensive enough; no need to make ammo even more expensive. The last thing we need are gun owners who cannot practice safety with what they have because ammo is expensive and additionally taxed.
As far as taxation, well it sounds like taxation with no representation. I don't think any of us want to be taxed for no good reason.
One thing I was thinking that may add overall safety for the community is to look at CCW more seriously. What I am suggesting is that only those that have impeccable record (no criminal, drug. alcohol or mental issues) and have demonstrated that they can be trusted with a firearm in public (training in both firearm and law) should be allowed to CCW. Yes it is a constitutional right but even I don't want just any Yahoo (mental issues or lack of training) to be able to CCW and possibly be a menace to the public.
I am suggesting that the state might be able to legislate some kind of civilian deputy program or whatever might be a more appropriate name that will be not easy to maintain (annual testing, license fee, etc) but will ultimately result in some form of OC or CCW. What do you guys think about this?
Not only will this improve overall safety (as proven by CCW stats) but also addresses police shortage issues by allowing some civilians to perform some police duties in their neighborhood without becoming cops. Sure the police union would not want this but this is a less expensive way to cover the police force shortage in Hawaii.
If applicants were somehow "taxed" to maintain such a program, I think it would be an acceptable reason for such a taxation.
I know the legislature is ultimately interested in finding additional tax revenue to cover the budget deficit but I would not want to be taxed for no good reason at all.
I'd appreciate feedback if there are any holes in this thinking.
-
More abortion clinics/planned parenthood.
The more kids born into poverty and abusive households the more they will be tempted to do something illegal and possibly violent to support themselves.
-
More abortion clinics
??? :wtf:
-
More abortion clinics/planned parenthood.
The more kids born into poverty and abusive households the more they will be tempted to do something illegal and possibly violent to support themselves.
I agree with this. I think we should club babies to death if their parents make less than $40,000 per year. Who's got a hammer I can borrow?
-
Hey that would be me. The difference is moms wanted to have a baby and wasn't forced to do it because a tax-exempt religious organization with too much political power was trying to control people's lives.
-
Hey that would be me. The difference is moms wanted to have a baby and wasn't forced to do it because a tax-exempt religious organization with too much political power was trying to control people's lives.
I hate it when people try to control me and tell me I can't kill things. Damn them and their religious persecution! I need to be free to kill stuff!
-
You just want them to grow up and have a miserable life where they learn to do terrible things so you have an excuse to kill them later.
-
You just want them to grow up and have a miserable life where they learn to do terrible things so you have an excuse to kill them later.
This is a bullshit assessment of people.
I grew up with 3 siblings in a "poor" family and my siblings and I were neither miserable or did terrible things.
That idiotic type of thinking is the same kind of stupidity that thinks that as soon as someone picks up a gun, they instantly become a mass murderer.