2aHawaii
General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: Paul96734 on January 26, 2013, 01:31:46 PM
-
About to start shopping around for my first pistol. I was looking at the Glock 17 Gen 4, but I have also heard that the SW M&P 9 is a good alternative. Opinions??
-
I just gave my sister a G17 Gen 4 and I have a M&P 9. The M&P 9 grip is more comfortable and has a natural point angle IMO. My sister has small hands and preferred the glock because it was blocky. She said it was easier to hold on to with two hands.
Only way is to hold both and see how the grip fits your one/two hand hold. Keep in mind, the M&P in the shop will have the medium backstrap in place so it can get smaller and larger. Not sure how the Glocks come from the factory.
As far as reliability, both have ate everything with no probs.
FWIW, I shoot tighter groups with my M&P. The stock M&P trigger is lighter and smoother than the stock 17G4. It's a big enough difference that I'd recommend the M&P over the glock for the trigger alone, especially if you are planning on keeping the gun bone stock.
If you go with the glock, make sure it has the most current recoil spring assembly. If not, glock will send you one for free. I never shot mine with the old RSA, so I can't comment on if the new one is better or not. But.... the new one ran like a champ!
:shaka:
-
Thank you for your thoughts Pit.I was watching some comparison videos and they both state that the M&P has the slight edge over the Glock. Yet, I am attracted to the Glock platform because of the simplicity of the design. The common thread that I have read the most is that the Glock standard sights need to be replaced. I guess both complete a niche within the 9mm field, and maybe I need to look at purchasing both.
GLOCK 17 Gen 4 vs M&P 9 Shooting Review (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tP-0jjAu-lY#ws)
-
Both are definitely great pistols.
I prefer the grip of the Glock. It just fits my hand better.
Both have excellent triggers, I'd call that one a tie.
I shoot better groups with a Glock than with a M&P.
I really believe that the new owner should shoot both guns before buying one but either way you'll be getting a great gun.
-
Both are definitely great pistols.
I prefer the grip of the Glock. It just fits my hand better.
Both have excellent triggers, I'd call that one a tie.
I shoot better groups with a Glock than with a M&P.
I really believe that the new owner should shoot both guns before buying one but either way you'll be getting a great gun.
u forgot to tell him that I shoot better than you do........haha j/k homie. We need to meet up for some trigger time and bring the new toys :thumbsup: Oh, and I finally took the steel targets for a spin........hella fun! thanks again bro.
sorry, :stopjack:
-
Your FIRST pistol should be a .22. If you start with a centerfire, you'll either spend lots of money on expensive ammo learning how to flinch, or you'll decide that ammo is too expensive and never shoot the thing.
-
A very valid point CrazyCat. I already have a Browning .22 that I inherited and have been shooting with over the years. I should have titled my topic as the first pistol that I "purchase".
-
That's good to hear. The guy who handles membership for our club (Kahuku Practical Pistol Shooters Club) has been inundated with people (almost always new members with no shooting experience) asking what handgun to start with "a .40 or .45; maybe a .357"? He tells them all to start with a .22. I can't count the number of people I see at the range who are in the habit of flinching (and missing), but still think .22s are unmanly.
-
That's good to hear. The guy who handles membership for our club (Kahuku Practical Pistol Shooters Club) has been inundated with people (almost always new members with no shooting experience) asking what handgun to start with "a .40 or .45; maybe a .357"? He tells them all to start with a .22. I can't count the number of people I see at the range who are in the habit of flinching (and missing), but still think .22s are unmanly.
I assume your club shoots at khsc..not in kahuku? I see alot of rounds up in Laie falls when I go, well used too!
-
Also....how about a CZ-75b?
-
u forgot to tell him that I shoot better than you do........haha j/k homie. We need to meet up for some trigger time and bring the new toys :thumbsup: Oh, and I finally took the steel targets for a spin........hella fun! thanks again bro.
sorry, :stopjack:
I seem to recall beating you at 250 yards with me using a pistol and you using a rifle...
:rofl:
:stopjack:
-
Just for the record u had a scoped tc contender shooting 223 or x39 with almost a rifle barrel ;D . I can't remember what I was shooting but I'm pretty sure it was a iron sighted ak of some sort.
I do like that tc........I still need to buy one for myself.
Btt
glock mags can be found cheaper than m&p mags, especially used. Something to consider.
-
Just for the record u had a scoped tc contender shooting 223 or x39 with almost a rifle barrel ;D . I can't remember what I was shooting but I'm pretty sure it was a iron sighted ak of some sort.
I do like that tc........I still need to buy one for myself.
Btt
glock mags can be found cheaper than m&p mags, especially used. Something to consider.
:rofl:
:geekdanc:
It was a 1x power scope.
:stopjack:
-
The thing I like about Glock is that there are hundreds of accessories and upgrades for the Glock.
The M&P doesn't have nearly as much.
Plus you can use the Glock mags in multiple guns (17,19,26,etc...)
-
I also like the fact that on a Glock you can change out the barrel for different calibers. One platform with multiple uses.
-
I also like the fact that on a Glock you can change out the barrel for different calibers. One platform with multiple uses.
IDK about that. I know you can get aftermarket 9mm conversion barrels if you have a G22/23 or M&P40 and get the proper magazines. The M&P40 is able to shoot with a factory M&P9 barrel. I have a Storm Lake 40-9 conversion barrel on my M&P40.
-
I found some links that offer conversion kits to make it either a.22 or .357 SIG.
-
The only polymer pistol I'd consider replacing my Glocks with is the new Walther PPQ.
-
How about a Smith SD9VE?
-
Most people generally side with one or the other. Enthusiasts get both lol. Glocks already have their name and a lot of aftermarket support. M&P's also have a big aftermarket but not as big as glock. My biggest gripe is the factory trigger reset, it's not as pronounced as a Glocks.
-
I think that for his 1st pistol, the Glock or MP would be a better choice than the CZ.
I just got my CZ SP-01 last month only cause it is one of the Super 9mm out there, but it may be too heavy for his 1st pistol if he'd want to use it in other manners.
The CZ is definitely heavier for EDC or primary pistol compared to the Glock and MP since they polymer frames, but is great for target shooting and follow up shots due to the weight. Glock got many upgrade mod parts out there as well.
I like my G19 with some mods as my primary pistol and I have a Sig 226 40 SW, Sig 1911, and the CZ Sp-01 as backups (as well as my 1 shottys and 6920 for long guns).
Also....how about a CZ-75b?
-
The only polymer pistol I'd consider replacing my Glocks with is the new Walther PPQ.
+1 my sentiments exactly. :thumbsup:
Anyone know of a LGS that actually sells one?
-
The only polymer pistol I'd consider replacing my Glocks with is the new Walther PPQ.
Not sure if I would replace but surely augment. Everything I heard or read, an excellent handgun. I'm a huge fan of Walther, so I'm likely to invest in one too.
-
M&P is a sexier looking pistol, has a nice ergo feel and a familiar angle and point for most people used to a more American grip angle. Stock M&P trigger is horrible and is THE most common, or first thing upgraded by most serious M&P shooters. I will say that I played around with the M&P CORE variant and the trigger is a bit improved over their past standard models. Accuracy has been extremely spotty in prior serial run models in 9mm and the one that I heavily Tested and Evaluated when they were first released had horrible accuracy even from a rest. Supposed to be an issue addressed in new models.
The Glock is my choice. I do like the pronounced grip angle as I get more cam in my support wrist which helps to manage recoil much more efficiently with my already aggressive thumbs forward or modern combat grip. Trigger is much better than the M&P and easily improved to be an excellent trigger for its type. Accuracy is good, reliability is high. Beware that some of the early Gen4's have had some issues. This is not voodoo, it is real. Newest versions have supposedly better addressed the issues.
Having said the above, I will say that I have never been a fan of the M&P pistols. I will say that having handled the CORE version and that I have a couple red of mini red dots sitting around, I have a 9mm longslide and a .40 S&W on order.
I will also note that I know of a test done between the M&P and Glock with 30 participants using 15 Glocks and 15 M&P's. Each were carried and fired for 2 weeks, then the group traded pistols for another 2 weeks. I was very much expecting the M&P to be more popular. To my shock, 100% chose the Glock after an in depth, post T&E, written evaluation and review from all the testers.
-
I have both and love both of them. The biggest difference to me was the triggers. Glock have that audible reset and have a bit crisper break. To me the the M&P's trigger was mushy out of the box and had an awkward break. After a few hundred rounds it smoothen out but you really have to slow your trigger presses down at first until you get the hang of the break. For a first gun either will do. Get what feels better in your hands. Before you go to the range dry fire the crap out of it while practicing sight alignment and trigger press. Trust me, it will save you on ammo and frustration. :thumbsup:
-
I'd like to see they study/review of all 15 people choosing the Glock over an M&P.
-
I have both. M&P 9 pro feels better in the hand ergonomically but weird wrist feel until I changed out the trigger to the Apex kit. Glocks are cheap with GSSF discount so I bought 2. Never had a single problem with any yet but if I had to choose 1 it would be the G34.
-
I was able to grip a G17 Gen 4 tonight, and I am very comfortable with how it felt within my hands. After doing some additional research, I am thinking the Walther PPQ would be a good compliment to the G17 rather than the M&P 9, but I would have to actually see how both models feel.
Walther PPQ: "Sniper's Pistol" by Nutnfancy (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HcV7l4AjeXk#ws)
-
The Kahuku Practical Pistol Shooters Club is on the Big Island...and the range that we shoot IPSC and IDPA at is actually in Glenwood.
-
Lol, anyone complaining about the lack of aftermarket products available for the M&P has never owned a Beretta Cougar 8045! :'(
-
+1 my sentiments exactly. :thumbsup:
Anyone know of a LGS that actually sells one?
I remember seeing one at X-Ring, but that was back in early December. Not sure if they still have it.
-
I have a glock 23 and M&P9c. While the M&P grip is great the trigger reset sucks. It's all the way out. The glock feels good and is proven. The glock is easy to take apart. The M&P takes a bit to disassemble. Other than the M&P trigger reset, they both shoot great. I also bought an advantage arms .22 conversion for my glock. Now I can shoot all day for cheap.
The glock 23 is almost the same size as the M&P9c.
-
Which glock is the best?
-
Which glock is the best?
Glock 23. You can get the 9mm conversion and the .22 conversion.
-
Which glock is the best?
i have a 17, 19, and 23... I like the 17 the best, then the 19.
-
As far ass .22 for practice/first gun. They also sell some awesome replica blow-back gas pellet guns. ( not air soft ) that you can shoot cheap and in the backyard or garage.
What about Springfield XD/XDM. I love the grip and they have conversion barrels ?
-
hey bro you got a link for barrel conversions for Springfield XD handguns?
Might have to check that out
-
In the end it becomes personal preference. When sh*t hits the fan reliability is what matters most and both are reliable, trigger reset when your reacting to a threat, negligible, you can drive both of them hard. But Walther pistols are just sexy!
-
My preference is the M&P.
-
I prefer the M&P also, in both .40 S&W and 9mm. Another thing to consider, if you end up shooting a lot, you'll probably end up reloading. No problem shooting lead out of an M&P stock barrel. With the Glock, its up in the air whether you need a aftermarket barrel or not to safely shoot lead.
The hard thing about both pistols is that it normally takes a while to get proficient with either pistol. One gun may feel more comfortable in the shop, but that doesn't necessarily carry over to the range. The stock trigger pull leaves a lot to be desired, hence the very common initial problems with "low, left". Both are extremely reliable, but for me and my wife, the M&Ps are what we started with and prefer. And lastly, I'm glad someone finally said it, the M&Ps are just a whole lot nicer looking.
-
I prefer the M&P ... And lastly, I'm glad someone finally said it, the M&Ps are just a whole lot nicer looking.
Hahaha, with a name like "M&P family" I'd expect nothing less from you.
:rofl:
-
My first pistol was a Walther P99, still have and love it! Fits my hand great, the changeable back straps was a novel feature and godsend back then. Ultra reliable. Only con is most rail lights don't fit, that has been addressed since then in later versions. The trigger and all it's various settings will take training but also pretty novel. Plus it has a decocker, visual and tactile loaded chamber indicator, etc. Yep, still love this gun!
I've had many guns since that one and really like the XDm a lot. A lot! It's a total shame to have to neuter the mags from 19 to 10 here though. Stupid illogical liberal thinking but it is what it is (so far). I also dig the manual of arms on the Springfield. Just seems to cross from 1911 to XDm seamlessly. I could not get used to the M&P mag release for example, though it's a fine shooter. Go back to the XDm and back in the comfort zone.
Anyways, so many guns to choose from. I hope you can get trigger and holster time to see which work for you. One probably won't fit into all settings so you'll end up with more guns sooner or later ;) One is none and all that.
ps.
Howzit aieahound! I still ready to buy that one whenever you ready to sell, lol!
-
Out of curiosity, have you tried an XD? If you like the ergonomics of the M&P, I'm pretty sure, you'd like how the XD feels. I've got an 9mm XD, and an M&P in .45. They both feel great, and shoot well. The trigger on the M&P isn't that great, neither is the reset on the XD, which can easily be fixed, with a drop in trigger kit. If you are dead set on your choices, all I have to say is, that you can't go wrong with either one. But if you like to accessorize, I'd go with the Glock, just due to the fact of how big the market for Glocks is.
-
The only polymer pistol I'd consider replacing my Glocks with is the new Walther PPQ.
+1
i was going to eventually buy a glock to compliment my ppq, but now that they offer the 2nd gen ppq in a 5" barrel and with button style mag release(instead of the debated ambi paddles,which to me are excellent) there isnt a reason to. now theres a ppq for everyone.
parts availability will grow significantly because of the new longer barrel models for idpa n other competitions and also because the ppq line will double or triple in sales in 2013 just because of the introduction of the longer barrel and button magazine release which americans love so much and also since walther opened a usa branch so you dont have to deal with smith and wesson anymore since they previously imported it but didnt carry parts or want to service it since they sell a competitor, the m&p9/40. i cant wait til more people jump on the walther bandwagon so aftermarket parts increases. right now parts are limited but there isnt a need for improvement really. there is a jard drop in barrel and a sprinco recoil reducing spring available. to me the only upgrades you need are dawson fiber optic metal sights or meprolight nightsights.
only thing i could think of is if i could ever get ahold of a reasonably priced keltec sub2000 in g22 mag config then id buy a glock pistol to match.
oh my second recommendation is the steyr m9a1. its like an updated 21st century glock. after i get my hands on an m&p22 or the new ppk in .22 i will be getting this steyr. you can really choke up on the grip of one of those. low bore axis and very high quality. i havent shot one but i held one and borat would agree that it was "naaaiiiiiiice" mags go for around $30 too so its not that bad. walther p99/ppq mags are $60, but there is a $30 generic magnum research version of a p99, and the ppq mags are exactly the same except for the finish. :thumbsup:
-
hey bro you got a link for barrel conversions for Springfield XD handguns?
Might have to check that out
I bought the one from Pistol Gear for my XDM 40. Converts it to 9mm. Conversion takes about 5 seconds. They have barrels for both the XD and XDM. Not for the compacts yet though.
http://www.pistolgear.com/products.php?id=59 (http://www.pistolgear.com/products.php?id=59)
I know storm lake and bar-sto also make conversion barrels.
-
I bought the one from Pistol Gear for my XDM 40. Converts it to 9mm. Conversion takes about 5 seconds. They have barrels for both the XD and XDM. Not for the compacts yet though.
http://www.pistolgear.com/products.php?id=59 (http://www.pistolgear.com/products.php?id=59)
I know storm lake and bar-sto also make conversion barrels.
thanks bro. got your pm. thanks for the link, ill go check it out