2aHawaii

General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: Bunker on May 19, 2013, 05:48:16 PM

Title: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: Bunker on May 19, 2013, 05:48:16 PM
This is very sad and so f*&ked up!

http://www.cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=50147180n (http://www.cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=50147180n)
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: ren on May 19, 2013, 07:29:06 PM
I thought I read that the suspect was the person that killed the girl?  :( That was a few days ago though
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: fstbckgt on May 19, 2013, 07:29:59 PM
I thought I read that the suspect was the person that killed the girl?  :( That was a few days ago though
Nope, cop
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: justin1098 on May 19, 2013, 08:03:19 PM
they will probably blame it on sequestration.
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: Colt808 on May 19, 2013, 08:12:25 PM
This is very sad and so f*&ked up!

http://www.cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=50147180n (http://www.cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=50147180n)
Definitely
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: michalebsdad on May 19, 2013, 08:26:00 PM
If dispatch was on the radio telling everyone that there was an armed individual with hostages...why did they enter? Why not wait for the hostage rescue team? Very sad news indeed!
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: Jl808 on May 19, 2013, 08:33:28 PM
Tragic... It's hard to second guess the police officer though until more is known about what happened during the incident.  If you were the police officer and you know an armed suspect was in there, would you investigate or wait outside?

While the cop stopped the criminal, it's tragic that it was the good guy's bullet that killed the girl too.
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: 230RN on May 19, 2013, 09:31:24 PM
The bad guy had served 9 years in prison and was wanted for parole violation, so by law, he couldn't legally even have a gun.
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: sliver on May 20, 2013, 12:18:37 AM
if only the cop had followed NY law like an average citizen would have to and only had 7 bullets in his gun...  she still would be alive! :popcorn:
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: fstbckgt on May 20, 2013, 12:23:35 AM
if only the cop had followed NY law like an average citizen would have to and only had 7 bullets in his gun...  she still would be alive! :popcorn:

8 shots does seem excessive, considering a hostage was so close. Too bad he didn't have an AR.
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: sliver on May 20, 2013, 01:41:11 AM
8 shots does seem excessive, considering a hostage was so close. Too bad he didn't have an AR.
 


its too bad that cop didn't have the ability to aim... 
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: fstbckgt on May 20, 2013, 01:49:28 AM
 


its too bad that cop didn't have the ability to aim...
Exactly, the longer sight radius of an AR may have helped.
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: sliver on May 20, 2013, 02:19:36 AM
Exactly, the longer sight radius of an AR may have helped.

eh, if I can put 10 rounds into a 4 inch hole at 25 yards (and I'm not even that good of a shooter) with a stock glock, a trained LEO should have been able to down a suspect without killing the hostage!
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: fstbckgt on May 20, 2013, 02:27:04 AM
eh, if I can put 10 rounds into a 4 inch hole at 25 yards (and I'm not even that good of a shooter) with a stock glock, a trained LEO should have been able to down a suspect without killing the hostage!
If you can empty a mag quickly and accurately into a 4 inch hole at 25 under pressure with a gun pointed at your face maybe you should join the academy.
We all know its mighty easy to pull a shot by a foot let alone several inches, and thats at the range.

I wonder what distance this incident occurred at, 5-10 yards? Anyone see it mentioned anywhere?

http://news.yahoo.com/split-second-choice-ended-ny-student-dead-062837730.html (http://news.yahoo.com/split-second-choice-ended-ny-student-dead-062837730.html)
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: Bunker on May 20, 2013, 06:57:24 AM
The debate about the cop is valid but to root cause this incident, the girl would still be alive today if the shitbag criminal never existed.
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: GZire on May 20, 2013, 07:30:41 AM
if only the cop had followed NY law like an average citizen would have to and only had 7 bullets in his gun...  she still would be alive! :popcorn:


My guess is the LEO probably put the first shot into the gal's head.  The rest that followed were probably after she dropped.
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: moosed on May 20, 2013, 08:28:11 AM
eh, if I can put 10 rounds into a 4 inch hole at 25 yards (and I'm not even that good of a shooter) with a stock glock, a trained LEO should have been able to down a suspect without killing the hostage!

Why don't you show us all how it's done ...

while you are full of adrenaline and a big guy has you in a headlock!   :wtf:
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: moosed on May 20, 2013, 08:29:04 AM

My guess is the LEO probably put the first shot into the gal's head.  The rest that followed were probably after she dropped.

"Pop quiz, Hotshot!"

"Shoot the hostage!"
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: bass monkey on May 20, 2013, 08:45:53 AM
If dispatch was on the radio telling everyone that there was an armed individual with hostages...why did they enter? Why not wait for the hostage rescue team? Very sad news indeed!

I agree. If I was a patrol officer I would secure the area and call/wait for ssd, that's what they trained for. 

However, there will be nay sayers, like in Virginia tech, or one of the school shootings, where people put the pd on blast because the police set up a perimeter and waited for re enforcement while you could hear people getting shot inside.
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: Lifer on May 20, 2013, 12:50:42 PM

My guess is the LEO probably put the first shot into the gal's head.  The rest that followed were probably after she dropped.

Good observation, didnt even think of that.

No matter what, still a very sad story (except for the criminal dying).
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: Aiea78 on May 20, 2013, 02:43:31 PM
Pretty girl :(   I think that would ruin me from continuing police work.
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: GZire on May 20, 2013, 03:14:39 PM
Good observation, didnt even think of that.

No matter what, still a very sad story (except for the criminal dying).


It's sad all the way around.  Trouble is the criminal forced everyone into this.  Can't really lay the blame on anyone except him.
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: Garuda on May 20, 2013, 04:47:38 PM
The bad guy had served 9 years in prison and was wanted for parole violation, so by law, he couldn't legally even have a gun.

THIS!!!!!!!

I really feel for the family, especially her twin. 

  Clearly prison didn't teach him anything.  Repeat offenders need to be dealt with HARSHLY and SWIFTLY. 

I don't understand how this guy above and others can be arrested multiple times.  Maybe after the 3rd arrest, you're just not getting it. 

I propose a platform a thousand yards out in the ocean equipped with a medieval catapult.  Felons with multiple arrests will be subject to medieval catapult.  This will also be televised with all commercial ads paying for the operators of catapult, tv time, and whatever is leftover goes to aloha united way. 
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: buckjay on May 20, 2013, 05:18:58 PM
I just don't understand why a lone police officer would go into a house where there's a known hostage situation and escalate the situation like he did.
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: bass monkey on May 20, 2013, 05:21:07 PM
THIS!!!!!!!

I really feel for the family, especially her twin. 

  Clearly prison didn't teach him anything.  Repeat offenders need to be dealt with HARSHLY and SWIFTLY. 

I don't understand how this guy above and others can be arrested multiple times.  Maybe after the 3rd arrest, you're just not getting it. 

I propose a platform a thousand yards out in the ocean equipped with a medieval catapult.  Felons with multiple arrests will be subject to medieval catapult.  This will also be televised with all commercial ads paying for the operators of catapult, tv time, and whatever is leftover goes to aloha united way.


Some areas down here, especially the weed and seed areas have a 3 strike rule. 
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: GZire on May 21, 2013, 07:16:47 AM
I just don't understand why a lone police officer would go into a house where there's a known hostage situation and escalate the situation like he did.


What the LEO knew and the sequence in which he knew it is still under investigation.  It's life and death/split second decision.  Without knowing all the facts it's tough for us to judge him.
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: michalebsdad on May 21, 2013, 06:03:10 PM

What the LEO knew and the sequence in which he knew it is still under investigation.  It's life and death/split second decision.  Without knowing all the facts it's tough for us to judge him.

It is difficult situation for everyone. I can tell you that when doors are being kicked in (down range) that same split second decision takes practice and lots of it. It is not how many rounds you can fire, it is how well placed those shots can be. That comes from muscle memory which is obtained from LOTS and LOTS of practice. I don't know how many LEOs practice CQB. I pray for him and the victims family, they both are going through hell.
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: 230RN on May 23, 2013, 09:57:56 AM
Quote
I propose a platform a thousand yards out in the ocean equipped with a medieval catapult.  Felons with multiple arrests will be subject to medieval catapult.  This will also be televised with all commercial ads paying for the operators of catapult, tv time, and whatever is leftover goes to aloha united way.


I've proposed an island somewhat north of the 60th parallel where repeat violent criminals get put on it with a gun, ammo, a week's supply of food, and the clothes on their backs.  Subsistence staples and medical supplies would be dropped to the island once a week. 

Think about it. 

All the other prisoners also have guns.

Well, there is that stuffy old Eighth Amendment to that stuffy old Bill Of RIghts to consider.
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: Jl808 on May 23, 2013, 10:26:21 AM
eh, if I can put 10 rounds into a 4 inch hole at 25 yards (and I'm not even that good of a shooter) with a stock glock, a trained LEO should have been able to down a suspect without killing the hostage!

Hi sliver -- I don't mean to single anyone out but read up on this thing called "Survival Stress Response".  There's a bunch of good books written on this but here a good report I found while Googling.

http://mikeleesolutions-web.sharepoint.com/Documents/Survival%20Stress%20in%20Law%20Enforcement.pdf (http://mikeleesolutions-web.sharepoint.com/Documents/Survival%20Stress%20in%20Law%20Enforcement.pdf)

Page 8, Expected Effects of Survival Stress

1. Increased heart rate
2. Auditory exclusions - not hearing things
3. Visual problems - tunnel vision, loss of near vision, loss of depth perception and loss of night vision
4. Freezing - delayed reaction can result in damage or death
5. Deterioration of motor skills - loss of fine motor skills
6. Vasoconstrictions

Page 12 has a nice chart showing what can get affected depending on heart rate.

Page 15 lists some things that can be done to prevent or reduce these effects.
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: xer 21 on May 29, 2013, 12:43:00 AM
while everyone's debating whether or not you can accurately empty 8 rounds in a stress situation, the question i have was, is, if there was a hostage, why would you just dump your whole mag at the guy?  that's kind of asking for collateral damage, no?
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: GZire on May 29, 2013, 07:31:39 AM
while everyone's debating whether or not you can accurately empty 8 rounds in a stress situation, the question i have was, is, if there was a hostage, why would you just dump your whole mag at the guy?  that's kind of asking for collateral damage, no?


This is why some of us think the first round may have been an attempt to one shot the bad guy and the rest to put him down after he (may) have shot the gal in the head. 
Title: Re: Long Island college student accidentally killed by police
Post by: Bunker on May 29, 2013, 08:33:07 AM
At Rebello's wake on Tuesday night, "some friends wondered if the shooting could have been prevented and said police should have waited for backup. Earlier, her godfather said there should have been negotiations before shots were fired."

http://abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory/mourners-hofstra-students-death-preventable-19229132#.UaZI0mT73fg (http://abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory/mourners-hofstra-students-death-preventable-19229132#.UaZI0mT73fg)

(http://i1287.photobucket.com/albums/a632/Bunker9939/image_7466_zps2b3fdce8.jpg) (http://s1287.photobucket.com/user/Bunker9939/media/image_7466_zps2b3fdce8.jpg.html)

(http://i1287.photobucket.com/albums/a632/Bunker9939/aee2cadc26d19611320f6a706700c9f1_zps2418e756.jpg)