2aHawaii
General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: Dblnaknak on June 03, 2013, 08:16:02 AM
-
So the other day I got a call from a doctor that I saw one time for gout. His office stated that I have to schedule an appt for a consultation concerning my HPD handgun permit. If I don't show up they will be sending HPD a letter of my non-compliance. By the way I have to pay for the visit. This doctor is a pediatrician not a psychologist. I have done this permit process like 20 times yet this is the first time I had to actually see a doctor for a "consultation".
I'm definitely changing doctors. This consultation screams unethical charging of patients for something that he is not even trained to diagnose.
-
Yea could be that, plus sounds like a gut-less display of CYA (cover your ass) on the part of the doc
-
Let your doctor know you will be filing a complaint with the state licensing board and the attorney generals office.
-
Let your doctor know you will be filing a complaint with the state licensing board and the attorney generals office.
But I wouldn't tell your doctor this untll after you get your permit paperwork cleared... If you're even going to go that route.
Just curious -if you're even willing to share the information- was this with Kaiser?
-
But I wouldn't tell your doctor this untll after you get your permit paperwork cleared... If you're even going to go that route.
Just curious -if you're even willing to share the information- was this with Kaiser?
It is with HMSA at queens.
-
This is off topic, but has anyone else wondered when the Affordable Care Act goes into place will all of our doctor waivers forms then be sent to the Federal level??
-
I'd ask the dr. Why and what grounds does he feel your unfit. You have the right to acess all info in your medical history.
-
I would tell the doctor there is nothing in the statute about a current mental health exam. There is only a reference to your mental health history.
[§134-3.5] Disclosure for firearm permit and registration purposes. A health care provider or public health authority shall disclose health information, including protected health care information, relating to an individual's mental health history, to the appropriate county chief of police in response to a request for the information from the chief of police; provided that:
(1) The information shall be used only for the purpose of evaluating the individual's fitness to acquire or own a firearm; and
(2) The individual has signed a waiver permitting release of the health information for that purpose. [L 2001, c 252, §1]
Furthermore, I would instruct the doctor to honestly answer the HPD request based on your history on file and the doctor's current knowledge of your mental health.
Then ... wait. If the doctor actually follows through with his notice and prevents you from getting a permit, I would be in a lawyer's office that day. I can't even count how many rights and laws this would violate. The most obvious is infringing on your second amendment right. Also, he would be filing a false statement, saying you should not be issued a permit with no evidence or diagnosis to substantiate that claim. This one denial could prevent you from ever owning another firearm in Hawaii. The injuries this could do would be quite substantial.
If I were a lawyer, I would be all over this one after you get denied!!
Some people have all the luck! :D I can see a pretty good payday coming to you because of this anti-gun doctor!
:thumbsup:
-
If I don't show up they will be sending HPD a letter of my non-compliance.
Is that your paraphrasing, or the doctor's actual words? if the doctor's, then ask him, with what law are you not complying?
Non-compliance sounds like a "scare" word, as if there really is some law or regulation you are breaking. This is one of those few occasions where I would have no fear at all standing up to the establishment. This is a completely inappropriate and unnecessary request/order from the doctor!
-
Please correct me if I'm wrong. Isn't a pediatrician a child's doctor? If so, why are you going to see a pediatrician?
This is fishy.
-
Interesting topic. I'd like to know how it turns out.
-
Is that your paraphrasing, or the doctor's actual words? if the doctor's, then ask him, with what law are you not complying?
Non-compliance sounds like a "scare" word, as if there really is some law or regulation you are breaking. This is one of those few occasions where I would have no fear at all standing up to the establishment. This is a completely inappropriate and unnecessary request/order from the doctor!
That is what the clerk said when I told her this appt is bullshit and the doctor has no right, nor no authority to make me schedule an appt. he saw me for gout and the only info he can release is related to that appt. I also told her that he is not my pcp and has no stance to threaten my standing in relation to the permit.
-
Please correct me if I'm wrong. Isn't a pediatrician a child's doctor? If so, why are you going to see a pediatrician?
This is fishy.
It's the doctor I saw because my regular doctor was out on that day.
-
Yup, this is bullshit.
Unfortunately, it is dangerous bullshit unless I am mistaken. And, not being a lawyer, I very well may be.
The physician is not required to schedule a consultation to determine your fitness. That is not the deal. The deal is that the state may contact the physicians to see if you are fit or not. If the physician does not know, for example because they have only seen you once for gout, then that is the answer: "I don't know."
What I don't have enough understanding of is the appeal process if your permit is denied because this doc is a scumbag.
Might could try scheduling an appt. AFTER the 2 week period for the permit then cancel on his @ss when it comes through.
And be sure to let us know who this idiot is. I think we just found one office to avoid at all costs. (edit: unless you want to go the route moosed suggests. In which case keep it under your hat to avoid a counter suit for slander.)
-
Naknak, which doctor's name did you put on the form at HPD -- your regular doc or the pediatrician? If you put yourr primary care physician's name on it, why is the other guy getting involved? If you put the pediatrician's name on the form because your regular guy was out, wouldn't it have been better to have put the regular doc's name on it anyway?
-
Naknak, which doctor's name did you put on the form at HPD -- your regular doc or the pediatrician? If you put yourr primary care physician's name on it, why is the other guy getting involved? If you put the pediatrician's name on the form because your regular guy was out, wouldn't it have been better to have put the regular doc's name on it anyway?
I did what I always do. I just put queens and the address. I rarely go to the doctor. It's been about 9 months since my last appt with this douch bag.
-
Operating on the theory that bureacratic inertia and dumb luck are nature's primary forces, we can conjecture that someone at HPD sent a request for information to Queen's and that someone at Queen's looked up your records and the result is that the pediatrician you saw just once wound up with that request and decided he need to know you better in order to fil out the form.
Maybe you already did this, but why couldn't you call your PCP, explain to his receptionist what has happened, and ask them to hold of the pediatrician and
take over the request for information? This is assuming your PCP is cool and has done this for you before.
The pediatrician would be more likely to turn the matter over to another doctor's office than to a civilian. (The rule of: "If you ain't one of us, you must be the enemy.")
-
no offense really, but I LOL because this made me think of this funny scene:
http://youtu.be/to3TaeqbW0E (http://youtu.be/to3TaeqbW0E)
sorry couln't help myself
Please correct me if I'm wrong. Isn't a pediatrician a child's doctor? If so, why are you going to see a pediatrician?
This is fishy.
-
At the doctors now. Read the letter from HPD. It says nothing about requiring an eval. The nurse stated its an internal policy. I informed them that how is it possible for them do require an appt for a psychological release for a doctor that has no background in psychology. She could not answer my question. She referred me to the manager. So I'm still waiting.
-
keep your cool
don't give them any excuse to cause you more grief and possibly give you a negative report to hpd
At the doctors now. Read the letter from HPD. It says nothing about requiring an eval. The nurse stated its an internal policy. I informed them that how is it possible for them do require an appt for a psychological release for a doctor that has no background in psychology. She could not answer my question. She referred me to the manager. So I'm still waiting.
-
I applied for a handgun permit (after owning several) hpd calls me n says I need to go get clearance from doc. I asked why they said my doc jus needs to clear me. I go to my doc n he asks if I have guns I said yes n he said this is like the 6th one that he was sent for no reason so he jus filled it out and sent me on my way.
-
Boy if this happen to me I'd already be talking to a lawyer. I'm wondering if there's something this doctor could do with this form which may cause you to lose your current firearms? I doubt it, but I don't know. that's why I be talking to lawyer already.
-
Sounds like a lawsuit waiting to happen if you ask me, or maybe there just picking random names. But it's funny that it's for existing gun owners and not new registrations.
-
At the doctors now. Read the letter from HPD. It says nothing about requiring an eval. The nurse stated its an internal policy. I informed them that how is it possible for them do require an appt for a psychological release for a doctor that has no background in psychology. She could not answer my question. She referred me to the manager. So I'm still waiting.
If indeed there is an "internal policy" (which I doubt...) ask them to produce it.
Remind them that physicians have immunity from issues arising out of these evaluations, and that failing to respond to one means that the process for the PTA continues.
-
Looks like queens is taking a anti-2a stance. It's a administrative policy that's requiring doctors to speak with their patients about their mental health. The doctors themselves don't know why they are doing it. What cracks me up is that these doctors don't have a background in mental health so what are they using as a diagnosis baseline. He just asked me if I had road rage issues, owned a guns safe, and felt depressed. I guess we can thank the aurora shooting and sandy hook for this.
-
Turn on the recorder
Damn too
Late
-
no offense really, but I LOL because this made me think of this funny scene:
http://youtu.be/to3TaeqbW0E (http://youtu.be/to3TaeqbW0E)
sorry couln't help myself
LOL!!! That's classic.
-
more of this will come our way cause of the affordable care act!!
-
I've done lots of permits in Hilo, and no one has ever asked who my doctor was. There's a medical records release form, but all you do is print your name and SS#, then sign it.
-
I've done lots of permits in Hilo, and no one has ever asked who my doctor was. There's a medical records release form, but all you do is print your name and SS#, then sign it.
This is the first time Ive ever had to speak with someone. This is like the third permit this year.
-
Operating on the theory that bureacratic inertia and dumb luck are nature's primary forces, we can conjecture that someone at HPD sent a request for information to Queen's and that someone at Queen's looked up your records and the result is that the pediatrician you saw just once wound up with that request and decided he need to know you better in order to fil out the form.
Maybe you already did this, but why couldn't you call your PCP, explain to his receptionist what has happened, and ask them to hold of the pediatrician and
take over the request for information? This is assuming your PCP is cool and has done this for you before.
The pediatrician would be more likely to turn the matter over to another doctor's office than to a civilian. (The rule of: "If you ain't one of us, you must be the enemy.")
+1 seeing that u renewed your permit with your pcp before you should have no problem
-
"....he saw me for gout.."
Was it in your trigger toe?
-
i just got a call from my doctors office too for a appt to come in so the doctor can approve me for my permit
i asked the nurse why because this is my second one and never had to go in on the first one
-
I wonder if this delays the process
BC my work is very difficult to take off to go to hpd
I already bought a gun but have to wait 2 months to pick it up bc of my work schedule
Now if I also have to go to doctor that's a real big inconvenience
-
i just got a call from my doctors office too for a appt to come in so the doctor can approve me for my permit
i asked the nurse why because this is my second one and never had to go in on the first one
I find it funny how when you are sick and need to see the Dr. they really don't have time for you. But apparently if they need to approve you for a permit they need to see you right away! :wtf:
-
Somethin stinks here. Is this shit even legal? So now they force you to see a doctor and they force you to state to your doc your firearm ownership? WTF?
-
HRS 134-2 does not require a physicians clearance, read it here: http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-0002.htm (http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-0002.htm)
I would sure like to know what grounds the medical facility or HPD is using to justify these requirements. Also in HRS 134-2 its states that all forms shall be uniformed and approved by the Attorney General, it appears that only Oahu is requiring you to provide doctors information.
-
This topic came to mind when I visited my doc today, so I asked about the form and how many he's received in the 12+ years as my doctor? He explained that physicians receive is a generic form that asks: "If there is a diagnosed mental health condition...Complete and return." There's no clearance involved and no psychiatric/psychological evaluation required. It's based solely on what they have on record and if there's no problem, they don't return anything. Pretty simple. As for the forms received for me? He said "I'm not your therapist, but I know you...no problems...probably shredded it."
So clearly Dblnaknak's problem is with Queen's and/or the doctor not HPD or HRS. If it is some internal hospital policy, there's little anyone can do and there's nothing to sue over. Just remember that medical facilities are like any other business. If we don't like it, we're free to shop around.
Dblnaknak: If you can change your PCP, you should do so immediately.
-
any updates?
did you have to get a note from another doctor to get your permit to acquire?
or were you good to go and its just scare tactics?
bc i just went to HPD last week to start the handgun process
i also am a kaiser member and saw the letter about firearms permits, and doesn't look good for us kaiser members as gun enthusiasts
hate to say it, but kaiser looking like 2A haters.
i'm just wondering if you really have to go to another doctor, or if HPD doesn't hear anything from your doctor you are still good to go.
bc if they just give me a "no comment", they are not denying me, so why is it my obligation to find another doctor?
and if i do, how am i supposed to schedule an appointment within the 14 day waiting period? thats pretty ridiculous.
-
stangzilla,
I am a Kaiser member. When I applied there was a printed form with the Kaiser info which I had to sign. Waited the 14 days and picked up my handgun permit.
-
stangzilla,
I am a Kaiser member. When I applied there was a printed form with the Kaiser info which I had to sign. Waited the 14 days and picked up my handgun permit.
thanks for the info.
did you go recently, bc now the form is different.
before we would fill out our Dr's name, now i notice we just fill in our Medical record number.
which leads me to belive it will not reach my doctor, but maybe just a receiving clerk.
but if you went recently, and this is how it goes, then thats fine with me.
-
thanks for the info.
did you go recently, bc now the form is different.
before we would fill out our Dr's name, now i notice we just fill in our Medical record number.
which leads me to belive it will not reach my doctor, but maybe just a receiving clerk.
but if you went recently, and this is how it goes, then thats fine with me.
Two and 1/2 weeks ago. Form was filled out. Had the Kaiser Psy. address. I don't recall putting my med record no.
-
any updates?
did you have to get a note from another doctor to get your permit to acquire?
or were you good to go and its just scare tactics?
bc i just went to HPD last week to start the handgun process
i also am a kaiser member and saw the letter about firearms permits, and doesn't look good for us kaiser members as gun enthusiasts
hate to say it, but kaiser looking like 2A haters.
i'm just wondering if you really have to go to another doctor, or if HPD doesn't hear anything from your doctor you are still good to go.
bc if they just give me a "no comment", they are not denying me, so why is it my obligation to find another doctor?
and if i do, how am i supposed to schedule an appointment within the 14 day waiting period? thats pretty ridiculous.
A friend of mine tried to renew his permit about a month and a half ago and his Kaiser pcp gave him a letter stating that they will no longer give clearances to own firearms or ammo. Stating that this is their new policy. Their excuse was that the doctor are not qualified to make that assessment. Kaiser also wrote that he can see an outside doctor for the clearance but He would have to pay out of his own pocket. I saw the letter.
I am also a Kaiser member but when I renewed my permit 3 weeks ago, I noticed that the medical info form has change. Didn't have to put medical record number and my pcp's name. I received my permit no questions asked and no letter. Maybe cause I've been renewing my permit every year for 15 years, who knows.
-
picked up my permit, no letter from kaiser.
I also work at kaiser.
so I can see the letter.
and I am worried that this may be in the future.
I hear of a few people that have received the letter.
and most do not get it.
I am just worried that this will be a few more steps to go through to get a permit in the future.
and how will it work with the 14 day waiting period if you have to wait for the letter from insurance of the denial,
then look for and schedule an appointment outside your carrier, and be in a timely manner to complete the permit process.
i smell what they're cooking, and it stinks!
-
So I hope this does not change the direction of this thread but it is on topic. What exactly does the police chief get to know about your medical history? Is it complete discloser or just looking for an opinion from your primary care doctor about whether or not you are together enough to have a firearm? I do not like the idea of having my personal medical information being reviewed all that much. I guess you gotta though if you want a firearm...hey wait isn't the second amendment my firearms permit? Another topic another thread sorry guys.
As always your shared knowledge, theories and comments are greatly appreciated. :shaka:
-
A friend of mine tried to renew his permit about a month and a half ago and his Kaiser pcp gave him a letter stating that they will no longer give clearances to own firearms or ammo. Stating that this is their new policy. Their excuse was that the doctor are not qualified to make that assessment. Kaiser also wrote that he can see an outside doctor for the clearance but He would have to pay out of his own pocket. I saw the letter.
I am also a Kaiser member but when I renewed my permit 3 weeks ago, I noticed that the medical info form has change. Didn't have to put medical record number and my pcp's name. I received my permit no questions asked and no letter. Maybe cause I've been renewing my permit every year for 15 years, who knows.
If your doctor or health plan doesn't respond to the HPD request, the processing of your PTA goes thru. My doc just ignores the requests now.....
-
If your doctor or health plan doesn't respond to the HPD request, the processing of your PTA goes thru. My doc just ignores the requests now.....
Yeah. The HPD letter is a "complete and return if there is a reason someone might be disqualified" and is very generic. Its not a big deal. If it goes to your regular physician that knows you, then the form usually goes straight into a shredder.
This was said a page back but I guess few bother to read with all the bickering going on of late.