2aHawaii

General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: ayeroff on June 18, 2013, 02:16:37 PM

Title: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: ayeroff on June 18, 2013, 02:16:37 PM
I'm in the Navy and getting ready to transfer to Pearl Harbor later this summer. I will be bringing 8 firearms with me, so I've been reading up on all of Hawaii's laws and registration requirements/procedures.  The process sounds "fun." 

One thing I'm still confused about is my AR-15 and AR-10 rifle magazines: Specifically, the law about magazine capacity for rifle magazines capable of being used in a pistol.  The AR-10 mags are 20 rounders.  The AR-15 mags are 30 rounders.  All pretty standard.  But if I'm reading the law correct, I can bring the AR-10 mags into Hawaii because they are not capable of being used in a pistol... BUT  I cannot bring the AR-15 mags into Hawaii because they are capable of being used in a AR-15 pistol variant???  Is that right? 

If I am right, then why does it seem like people/companies frequently post for sale ads on this forum for AR-15 mags.  Is this a law that deosn't really get enforced???  Do people just keep AR-15 mags in their safe in case the law gets changed and not use them at the range?  Please educate me.

Thanks!
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: macsak on June 18, 2013, 02:24:17 PM
it's been discussed a bunch on this forum
in a nutshell, technically illegal
some stores won't sell them
you can use them at the range and not get busted

I'm in the Navy and getting ready to transfer to Pearl Harbor later this summer. I will be bringing 8 firearms with me, so I've been reading up on all of Hawaii's laws and registration requirements/procedures.  The process sounds "fun." 

One thing I'm still confused about is my AR-15 and AR-10 rifle magazines: Specifically, the law about magazine capacity for rifle magazines capable of being used in a pistol.  The AR-10 mags are 20 rounders.  The AR-15 mags are 30 rounders.  All pretty standard.  But if I'm reading the law correct, I can bring the AR-10 mags into Hawaii because they are not capable of being used in a pistol... BUT  I cannot bring the AR-15 mags into Hawaii because they are capable of being used in a AR-15 pistol variant???  Is that right? 

If I am right, then why does it seem like people/companies frequently post for sale ads on this forum for AR-15 mags.  Is this a law that deosn't really get enforced???  Do people just keep AR-15 mags in their safe in case the law gets changed and not use them at the range?  Please educate me.

Thanks!
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: hnl.flyboy on June 18, 2013, 02:28:27 PM
Just as macsak said, technically illegal.  HPD has said they will not arrest over the 30 round AR mags.  On any day the public range is open, you'll find that most AR owners will have 30 round mags inserted into their AR.
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: sworbeyegib on June 18, 2013, 02:34:15 PM
The wording of the law is pretty confusing.  Its been debated, and brought up in just about every firearm circle on island.

The official and safe interpretation, is that yes they are illegal. 

But, it is heavily unenforced.  I can't think of any time someone has been reprimanded for owning or using them at the range. 

Some stores don't carry them, some stores will only sell to military and LEOs, some just have them openly on the shelves for anyone.  It seems not even the stores can all completely agree on it.

Legally I can't tell you to go ahead and bring them in... But I'd be lying if I said all of my AR mags were 10 rounders.

If you are extra concerned, you can always by limiters to keep them at 10 rounds.
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: GZire on June 18, 2013, 03:52:00 PM
.........But, it is heavily unenforced.  I can't think of any time someone has been reprimanded for owning or using them at the range.............

I've heard of guys getting scolded, but I think that's more an issue that the RSO had with the people than anything else.  No LEOs called.
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: ren on June 18, 2013, 03:54:24 PM
I've heard of guys getting scolded, but I think that's more an issue that the RSO had with the people than anything else.  No LEOs called.
Because some shooters load up to full cap, and do a mag dump.
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: michalebsdad on June 18, 2013, 04:50:07 PM
Not supposed to load more than 5 rounds at the range...

Military can purchase 30 round mags...at least I was allowed to

Ammo here can be tricky at times...my brothers here love to "hoard" it all!  :shaka:
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: GZire on June 18, 2013, 05:44:25 PM
Because some shooters load up to full cap, and do a mag dump.

Yup..........that would do it.
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: Colt808 on June 19, 2013, 04:52:51 AM
I'm in the Navy and getting ready to transfer to Pearl Harbor later this summer. I will be bringing 8 firearms with me, so I've been reading up on all of Hawaii's laws and registration requirements/procedures.  The process sounds "fun." 

One thing I'm still confused about is my AR-15 and AR-10 rifle magazines: Specifically, the law about magazine capacity for rifle magazines capable of being used in a pistol.  The AR-10 mags are 20 rounders.  The AR-15 mags are 30 rounders.  All pretty standard.  But if I'm reading the law correct, I can bring the AR-10 mags into Hawaii because they are not capable of being used in a pistol... BUT  I cannot bring the AR-15 mags into Hawaii because they are capable of being used in a AR-15 pistol variant???  Is that right? 

If I am right, then why does it seem like people/companies frequently post for sale ads on this forum for AR-15 mags.  Is this a law that deosn't really get enforced???  Do people just keep AR-15 mags in their safe in case the law gets changed and not use them at the range?  Please educate me.

Thanks!
It's basically as others have stated...Illegal, but not enforced. The only time I know of where it becomes an issue is when a firearm is used in a crime.

As far as the registration process goes, when you get here, just register the receivers and leave the mags/uppers at home. It'll save you from doing a case juggling act if theres a line.
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: jc2721 on June 19, 2013, 09:25:42 AM
Welcome to the site--good luck with your transfer(s).
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: lippy laroux on June 19, 2013, 11:57:24 AM
When I was stationed at Subase Pearl in the 1980's  I lived in the baracks and kept my guns in a gunlocker in my room;  what are the rules; can you keep firearms on the base still?
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: GZire on June 19, 2013, 01:02:13 PM
^^^I believe you can for Schofield.  What the rules are on the different posts, I don't know.

Best thing is to contact the post and ask them.
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: Colt808 on June 19, 2013, 08:44:16 PM
^^^I believe you can for Schofield.  What the rules are on the different posts, I don't know.

Best thing is to contact the post and ask them.
A lot changed after LTG Wiercinski's policy memo...Most of the housing communities and barracks now require soldiers to store personal firearms in the unit arms room. As I understand it, all installations/branches have established similar policies.
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: HiCarry on June 21, 2013, 12:32:34 PM
It's pretty much as previously stated, except I'll add that I know of a few cases where LEO have approached shooters at the range and challenged them on the capacity of their magazines. Since in the instances I know about the mags were blocked for 10 rounds it wasn't an issue, but I suspect that had that not been the case, there would have been a little bit of a legal entanglement....
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: michalebsdad on June 21, 2013, 06:20:30 PM
Damn those "legal entanglements"...
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: WCMTWS on June 23, 2013, 12:54:48 AM
Really? You have seen people questioned on their mag capacity? How long ago was that?
Maybe I should pick up some limiters?
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: GreenStomper on June 23, 2013, 11:28:32 PM


As far as the registration process goes, when you get here, just register the receivers and leave the mags/uppers at home. It'll save you from doing a case juggling act if theres a line.

If you register just the lower, that's the way HPD sees it. If you intend to ever reassemble it, then it needs to be registered as a completed (whole assembly) firearm. Thus making it a two trip affair and you have to juggle.
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: Colt808 on June 23, 2013, 11:36:38 PM
If you register just the lower, that's the way HPD sees it. If you intend to ever reassemble it, then it needs to be registered as a completed (whole assembly) firearm. Thus making it a two trip affair and you have to juggle.

Incorrect. Only the serialized part (the receiver) is required for registration. If HPD has told you otherwise, then you've been misinformed. Nowhere in HRS or HAR is "re-registration" required. 
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: Funtimes on June 24, 2013, 08:02:49 AM
If you register just the lower, that's the way HPD sees it. If you intend to ever reassemble it, then it needs to be registered as a completed (whole assembly) firearm. Thus making it a two trip affair and you have to juggle.

Might be some of their made up rules, but the firearm is registered as soon as you get a slip for the lower receiver - whether they like it or not.
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: aieahound on June 24, 2013, 09:29:07 AM
I transferred one of my ARs to a friend which only had the lower registered previously.

The officer behind the window said "it's only registered as a lower, did you build it ? " I replied yes. He didn't say anything more on the matter and the transfer was completed.
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: HiCarry on June 24, 2013, 06:54:48 PM
Really? You have seen people questioned on their mag capacity? How long ago was that?
Maybe I should pick up some limiters?
one was about 3 years ago, the other about a year ago....
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: mmmorgalis64 on July 03, 2013, 10:04:20 PM
You can use 30 rounders at the range, just 5 shots at a time. I'm military and went and bought a 9 round mag at a gun show before I transferred here. But I brought my 30's too and used them with no problem at KoKoHead.
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: Funtimes on July 05, 2013, 09:15:07 PM
one was about 3 years ago, the other about a year ago....

Better the reason to have non-window mags :P...
Title: Re: Military member transferring to Oahu - Questions about Hawaii Firearm Regulation
Post by: WCMTWS on July 05, 2013, 10:12:48 PM
Yeah, I have seen an number of people using 30rd mags, but if people are questioning me on them (capacity wise) it just seems a little sketch
Meh they sell them here so might as well use them!
You can use 30 rounders at the range, just 5 shots at a time. I'm military and went and bought a 9 round mag at a gun show before I transferred here. But I brought my 30's too and used them with no problem at KoKoHead.