2aHawaii

General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: mr. me 808 on July 08, 2013, 07:07:33 PM

Title: high capacity magazines
Post by: mr. me 808 on July 08, 2013, 07:07:33 PM
I had a question on high cap magazines, maybe somebody can help out.  Some guns don't come with a 10rd magazine option when you buy.  Is there a legal way to block high cap magazines yourself or can only an ffl can do so?
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: moosed on July 08, 2013, 07:12:48 PM
Shhhh!  We're hunting Wabbit!
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: mr. me 808 on July 08, 2013, 07:26:06 PM
Shhhh!  We're hunting Wabbit!

Roger that, modified original post
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: OldFaithful on July 08, 2013, 07:28:52 PM
Need more info.  Rifle or pistol mags?  You really mean hi caps or actual standard capacity?  Buying online? 
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: SpeedTek on July 08, 2013, 07:36:26 PM
If you have shipped to your house assembled hi-cap mags that can fit in a legal pistol you are commiting a misdermenor.

You can ship it to a FFL and they will have to have it blocked for you.

If you are transferring a pistol by FFL. The recieving FFL will have to block the mags before giving them to you.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: mr. me 808 on July 08, 2013, 07:57:46 PM
Talking about pistol mags.  Not high cap, but standard capacity in any 2a friendly state.  Some pistols you look at don't provide a 10rd mag as an option, was just curious.  Also, hypothetically speaking, if one had a "disassembled" magazine greater than 10 rounds is there a way they could legally block it themselves so they could assemble and use those mags in Hawaii?  What is the legally acceptable way to block the magazine?  Does anyone know if you can give your mags to a shop to have them block them for you if you can't legally do it yourself?
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: Dirtyc on July 08, 2013, 08:38:40 PM
what if you have a 9mm carbine would a 33rd glock mag be illegal?
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: Aiea78 on July 08, 2013, 08:39:41 PM
I've seen plastic blocks glued to the follower and riveted mag bodies. 

John Perreira is a name you will come across for limiting mags:

Jhp Arms
Licensee Name: Perreira, John H
47-440 Ahuimanu Pl
Kaneohe, HI 96744
Phone: 808-239-7449
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: nathanm14fan on July 08, 2013, 08:47:50 PM
I have purchased many a magazine block from magazineblocks.com. I simply insert the block, and epoxy the floorplate shut. Easy to do and makes for a permanent fix that follows the letter of the law.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: mr. me 808 on July 08, 2013, 09:15:23 PM
I have purchased many a magazine block from magazineblocks.com. I simply insert the block, and epoxy the floorplate shut. Easy to do and makes for a permanent fix that follows the letter of the law.
I'll check that out, thanks!
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: SpeedTek on July 08, 2013, 09:29:08 PM
what if you have a 9mm carbine would a 33rd glock mag be illegal?


YES but there is a fix....If you make the mag not fit the glock pistol anymore then you can use it in your carbine....
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: SpeedTek on July 08, 2013, 09:34:13 PM
Talking about pistol mags.  Not high cap, but standard capacity in any 2a friendly state.  Some pistols you look at don't provide a 10rd mag as an option, was just curious.  Also, hypothetically speaking, if one had a "disassembled" magazine greater than 10 rounds is there a way they could legally block it themselves so they could assemble and use those mags in Hawaii?  What is the legally acceptable way to block the magazine?  Does anyone know if you can give your mags to a shop to have them block them for you if you can't legally do it yourself?

You can do it yourself....The law is NOT Readily restorable.......
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: Paul96734 on July 08, 2013, 09:41:19 PM
The recieving FFL will have to block the mags before giving them to you.

Yep, they will do that.  ;D
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: mnpfamily on July 08, 2013, 09:42:51 PM
I have purchased many a magazine block from magazineblocks.com. I simply insert the block, and epoxy the floorplate shut. Easy to do and makes for a permanent fix that follows the letter of the law.
Are you still able to clean mags, change springs and followers, etc. after that?  Just wondering as some of the  "standard cap" mags seeme to work better than the 10 rounders.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: OldFaithful on July 08, 2013, 10:18:03 PM
They sell magazine parts/rebuild kits.  Its basically a disassembled standard capacity magazine that you can use for spare parts, spring, floor plate, follower, magazine tube.  Since its not assembled, its legal.  It would be just like disassembling a blocked magazine.  However if you assemble it without inserting a magazine block then that's illegal.  Google magazine blocks and you can find a good site to buy some to do it yourself.  If SHTF I wouldn't mind having a few disassembled ones standby
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: moosed on July 08, 2013, 10:21:04 PM
Are you still able to clean mags, change springs and followers, etc. after that?  Just wondering as some of the  "standard cap" mags seeme to work better than the 10 rounders.

It's always better to be safe than sorry, so don't act on this information without verification...

I ran across a case where the court determined that if you remove a part of the magazine (the floor plate) and replace it with a round limiting floor plate, you do not have to seal the magazine to make it "not capable of being readily restored to a capacity of more than ten rounds."

Simply keep the original floor plates at home and make sure you don't have other magazines with the same original floor plates with you.  As long as you don't have the parts with you to restore the magazine's >10 capacity, it is legal.

I will post that link if I find the case information again.  This mostly applies to AR-15 type mags.  Pistol mags may not offer the same types of capacity limiting devices. (???)
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: Funtimes on July 09, 2013, 12:24:28 AM
what if you have a 9mm carbine would a 33rd glock mag be illegal?
absolutely illegal.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: Kingkeoni on July 09, 2013, 06:36:04 AM
absolutely illegal.

Not necessarily. If the magazine is made to NOT fit in a Glock pistol. (Typically a small piece is attached to the mag and a groove is made in the rifle mag well so it becomes proprietary) then it is 100% legal to own the 33 round magazine.

The law states:      (c)  The manufacture, possession, sale, barter, trade, gift, transfer, or acquisition of detachable ammunition magazines with a capacity in excess of ten rounds which are designed for or capable of use with a pistol is prohibited.

Your proprietary magazine is designed for your rifle only and is not capable of use with any pistol.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: GZire on July 09, 2013, 07:47:10 AM
^^^KK you have my interest piqued. I gave up long ago on getting a KRISS Vector because of the Glock mag issue.  I'd be interested to see how a mag could be modified to fit only the KRISS.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: Jl808 on July 09, 2013, 10:07:49 AM
+1. I would like to know that as well. I have the exact same question as GZire.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: SpeedTek on July 09, 2013, 11:06:05 AM
Not necessarily. If the magazine is made to NOT fit in a Glock pistol. (Typically a small piece is attached to the mag and a groove is made in the rifle mag well so it becomes proprietary) then it is 100% legal to own the 33 round magazine.

The law states:      (c)  The manufacture, possession, sale, barter, trade, gift, transfer, or acquisition of detachable ammunition magazines with a capacity in excess of ten rounds which are designed for or capable of use with a pistol is prohibited.

Your proprietary magazine is designed for your rifle only and is not capable of use with any pistol.

X-Ring does it.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: aieahound on July 09, 2013, 12:50:26 PM
I have purchased many a magazine block from magazineblocks.com. I simply insert the block, and epoxy the floorplate shut. Easy to do and makes for a permanent fix that follows the letter of the law.

You can epoxy the mag block to the follower, then you can still dissamble the mag for cleaning.
I think that's how John Perreira does it.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: GZire on July 09, 2013, 01:27:57 PM
You can epoxy the mag block to the follower, then you can still dissamble the mag for cleaning.
I think that's how John Perreira does it.

Epoxy is not permanent though.  All you do is heat a part and it breaks the epoxy bond.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: moosed on July 09, 2013, 01:29:48 PM
Epoxy is not permanent though.  All you do is heat a part and it breaks the epoxy bond.

Nothing in the law says it has to be "permanent".  It merely needs to be "not capable of being readily restored to a capacity of more than ten rounds."

read·i·ly  (rd-l, rdl-)
adv.
1. In a prompt, timely manner; promptly.
2. In a cooperative manner; willingly.
3. In a manner indicating or connoting ease; easily.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: GZire on July 09, 2013, 01:52:05 PM
Nothing in the law says it has to be "permanent".  It merely needs to be "not capable of being readily restored to a capacity of more than ten rounds."

read·i·ly  (rd-l, rdl-)
adv.
1. In a prompt, timely manner; promptly.
2. In a cooperative manner; willingly.
3. In a manner indicating or connoting ease; easily.


Sorry forgot to type that in.  Restoration of the mag is easy with a microtorch/heat gun or by heating of the materials.  Epoxy bonds break down under heat it's how golf clubs are reshafted.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: aieahound on July 09, 2013, 02:13:10 PM
I don't know what kind of epoxy you're referring to but the epoxy I would use is marine grade and can be drilled and tapped.

If you heated it enough to break the bond, you'd probably melt and distort the plastic follower first rendering the mag useless ( and the mag block ).

I would use Marine-Tex or PC-11 marine grade epoxy.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: mnpfamily on July 09, 2013, 02:40:50 PM
I had some done where the blocker was attached to the follower and they didn't last very long.  Had them re-done and this time the block was screwed to the floor plate.  No problems so far with those, and the base pad isn't affected so I can still maintain the mags.
However, I also have some STI "magazine parts" that I'd like to be able to use as magazines, but I'm not sure the above mentioned would work with the STI base plates.  I have Arredondo limiters for them, but that whole "readily reversed" thing worries me so I just use the 10 round mags.  Would be nice to be able to use the longer mag tubes as they are easier to use with the mag well that's on the pistol.  Being able to disassemble the mag is important as they are often dropped in the dust and dirt, and riveting a shim inside the mag body (a widely used technique) would make removing the guts a major pain.  Just searching for low-cost but efficient options, hopefully I didn't thread drift too far.

Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: GZire on July 09, 2013, 02:50:59 PM
I don't know what kind of epoxy you're referring to but the epoxy I would use is marine grade and can be drilled and tapped.

If you heated it enough to break the bond, you'd probably melt and distort the plastic follower first rendering the mag useless ( and the mag block ).

I would use Marine-Tex or PC-11 marine grade epoxy.

Aiea, all epoxies break down under heat.  Even the stuff we use to fasten anchors into the piers to stop 900 ft long cruise ships.

I do get what you are saying about tapping into the block as a type of anchor, but I'm having difficulty picturing it.

Sorry guys I'm being a bit of a pain here, but I've seen guys show up with AR pistols (that were probably not legal in Hawaii), but I've never seen a guy show up with a 33 round Glock mag.  I don't want to be "That Guy" if I go down this path.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: GZire on July 09, 2013, 02:52:22 PM
^^^Sorry one more thing, I'm specifically talking about being able to modify a 33 round Glock mag for use in a KRISS Vector carbine so that it cannot be used in a Glock pistol.  I'm not sure we're talking about blocking a mag here because if it was about capping at 10 rounds I'd just buy a 10 round mag.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: Kingkeoni on July 09, 2013, 02:58:02 PM
^^^Sorry one more thing, I'm specifically talking about being able to modify a 33 round Glock mag for use in a KRISS Vector carbine so that it cannot be used in a Glock pistol.  I'm not sure we're talking about blocking a mag here because if it was about capping at 10 rounds I'd just buy a 10 round mag.

Bear in mind that if you go this route, you'll be creating a groove inside your mag well of your intended firearm.

It will not hinder its ability to accept standard mags but it will allow that firearm to accept the modified 33 round mag with a corresponding nub.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: GZire on July 09, 2013, 03:00:56 PM
Bear in mind that if you go this route, you'll be creating a groove inside your mag well of your intended firearm.

It will not hinder its ability to accept standard mags but it will allow that firearm to accept the modified 33 round mag with a corresponding nub.


OK I see where this is going.  Something for me to think about.

Sold my USC a long time ago and this is the only other "sub gun" type of carbine that I'd been interested in.


One more question, so I assume with the mod to the magwell the KRISS would still be able to accept the non modified mags?  So if I wanted to sell to a mainland guy who wasn't under the high cap blockade, it would be doable without further repair/mods to the magwell?
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: aieahound on July 09, 2013, 03:13:56 PM
Aiea, all epoxies break down under heat.  Even the stuff we use to fasten anchors into the piers to stop 900 ft long cruise ships.

It'll anchor a 900 ft long cruise ship.

If you heated it enough to break the bond, you'd definitely ( changed from probably ) melt and distort the plastic follower first rendering the mag useless ( and the mag block ).

I had some done where the blocker was attached to the follower and they didn't last very long. 

Stop trying to stuff the 11th round in.  :D ( Just kiddin")

 :stopjack:

KK,

The last question was for you or Speedtek.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: Kingkeoni on July 09, 2013, 03:46:41 PM
One more question, so I assume with the mod to the magwell the KRISS would still be able to accept the non modified mags?  So if I wanted to sell to a mainland guy who wasn't under the high cap blockade, it would be doable without further repair/mods to the magwell?

Yes, if done properly, it would be imperceptible to all but the most knowledgeable gun guys.

It would require no additional modifications or repairs.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: GZire on July 09, 2013, 04:40:01 PM
Yes, if done properly, it would be imperceptible to all but the most knowledgeable gun guys.

It would require no additional modifications or repairs.


You are waving a steak in front of a starving dog man.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: Aiea78 on July 09, 2013, 05:08:58 PM
Hahaha!!!  You guys are killin' me! :D

JP blocked mags - I had trouble stuffing even 9 or 10 rounds in depending on how they stacked in there.  It was pissing me off in class: loading 1-6, 7, 8... 8... 8  WTF  8... grumble swear unload start over 1-6, 7, 8...8... 9!  9... 9... @!#$$#^Y# ding low chang yow uppa kwaidai ah Q#Q^%&# 

So I want to trim the block down a skoosh see if that helps.  Damn dumass "law" to begin with.  If I expire in a gun battle because the mag malf'd somebody sue the state for me.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: nathanm14fan on July 09, 2013, 05:12:37 PM
Are you still able to clean mags, change springs and followers, etc. after that?  Just wondering as some of the  "standard cap" mags seeme to work better than the 10 rounders.

Nope, the floorplate is epoxied shut-no removal possible. I wouldn't worry too much about changing the springs out due to wear & tear if you are just using this for occasional range practice or home defense.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: Funtimes on July 09, 2013, 07:11:14 PM
Nothing in the law says it has to be "permanent".  It merely needs to be "not capable of being readily restored to a capacity of more than ten rounds."

read·i·ly  (rd-l, rdl-)
adv.
1. In a prompt, timely manner; promptly.
2. In a cooperative manner; willingly.
3. In a manner indicating or connoting ease; easily.


30 minutes with hand tool is the standard for that. No magazine - period - is not 'readily restorable" under 9th circuit doctrine.   Thank the guys trying to skirt the fully automatic firearm laws for this, stupid, standard.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: nathanm14fan on July 09, 2013, 07:27:04 PM
30 minutes with hand tool is the standard for that. No magazine - period - is not 'readily restorable" under 9th circuit doctrine.   Thank the guys trying to skirt the fully automatic firearm laws for this, stupid, standard.

Do you have a reference for the court case that shows this doctrine? I am just curious to read the 9th circuit's reasoning on this.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: Funtimes on July 09, 2013, 08:38:00 PM
Do you have a reference for the court case that shows this doctrine? I am just curious to read the 9th circuit's reasoning on this.

I don't have it off hand - it's cited some where in the 20+ threads of magazine capacities here.  It was some idiot who modified his gun, then there is constructive possession of assault weapons.   

Here is one: USA v. Brown, which states in it's relevant part that "[f]or purposes of summary judgment, we accept the process and time frame offered by Kelly in his deposition [(which was about 45 minutes) -CB], a two-hour restoration process using ordinary tools, including a
stick weld, is within the ordinary meaning of  “readily restored.” As to the temporal component, two hours, while not an insignificant amount of time, is still within a range that may properly be considered  “with fairly quick efficiency,” “without needless loss of time,” or  “reasonably fast.” As to
the means of restoration, requiring the use of ordinary tools and a stick weld, even by a skilled worker, is likewise within what may properly be considered “with a fair degree of ease,” “without much difficulty,” or “with facility.”

Source: http://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca9/04-16049/0416049-2011-02-25.html (http://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca9/04-16049/0416049-2011-02-25.html)

There's a few in the 9th as well, I just don't have time to search it out.

The reasoning was pretty much guy was an idiot and douche, and they didn't want him to get away -- so they made a stupid rule.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: nathanm14fan on July 09, 2013, 09:04:24 PM
That works for me. Thanks for the analysis! :thumbsup:
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: GZire on July 10, 2013, 09:44:28 AM
30 minutes with hand tool is the standard for that. No magazine - period - is not 'readily restorable" under 9th circuit doctrine.   Thank the guys trying to skirt the fully automatic firearm laws for this, stupid, standard.


Thanks F that's a good goal to shoot towards.
Title: Re: high capacity magazines
Post by: GZire on July 10, 2013, 09:46:14 AM
Hahaha!!!  You guys are killin' me! :D

JP blocked mags - I had trouble stuffing even 9 or 10 rounds in depending on how they stacked in there.  It was pissing me off in class: loading 1-6, 7, 8... 8... 8  WTF  8... grumble swear unload start over 1-6, 7, 8...8... 9!  9... 9... @!#$$#^Y# ding low chang yow uppa kwaidai ah Q#Q^%&# 

So I want to trim the block down a skoosh see if that helps.  Damn dumass "law" to begin with.  If I expire in a gun battle because the mag malf'd somebody sue the state for me.


Just to be clear.  I'd like to have problems shoving the 33rd round into the magazine to use in a 16" totally Hawaii legal KRISS Vector.  I wouldn't be looking to block a magazine per se as I don't even have a Glock nor do I want one.  I'd need to have the magazine capable of use only in the KRISS.