I doubt that I could ever successfully answer your questions so I've stopped bothering. Probably the only way I could possibly satisfy your questions is over a couple beers in a bar somewhere.
As with most insurance, it depends on the coverage and how much you're willing to pay. It's debatable about what the State should require. To repeat myself, I'm not supporting the insurance bill but I would be "okay" with CCW insurance only if that was ever possible in this State.
Per the NRA website:
ALL NRA CARRY GUARD MEMBERS GET THESE GREAT BENEFITS:
- 24/7/365 access to the members-only hotline for incident reporting and emergency assistance.
- Immediate access as needed to supplementary payments for bail, bonds, legal retainer fees, lawful replacement of legally possessed firearm, compensation while in court, psychological support and cleanup costs.
- Full coverage for your spouse inside and outside of the home automatically at no extra charge.
- Civil defense legal fees in addition to the insurance limit for each membership level.
- Access to legal assistance and ability to select your own counsel.
There are three levels of insurance so I imagine the Bronze level would be a good start. This is typical with most insurance. Comprehensive car insurance is required but not collision. The difference can depend on how on an object hits your car. If you're following a Christmas tree truck and one falls off and lands on your car, that's a missile and comprehensive. If the tree lands on the road and you run into it, that's collision. It's all in the fine details. Another example is that hurricane coverage for my property insurance would double the premium and I live 4 miles from the beach so I opted out. I work in the insurance industry but I'm not one of those maximum coverage kinda guys.
That's a good example of why I wanted you to do some research.
The NRA insurance covers whom? The person you shoot? The innocent bystander you injured? The person who owns the store where you shot out a 40' x 40' window?
No, it covers YOU, the customer. They do have up to $1M in liability insurance, but that only kicks in if you are sued in civil court and lose. In most cases, if your use of that carry weapon was justified, you're not going to be held liable for incidental injuries or damages. The person committing the crime would be liable if anyone.
Mandatory insurance is for the purpose of protecting the policy holder in case of a situation in which you can be held responsible for some action. The state wants to force drivers to be financially capable of taking care of other people's expenses if you cause any damages or injuries. The state does not require that you carry collision or comprehensive coverage to fix your own car if you crash it. BTW, comprehensive coverage is for loss to your car by something other than collision: fire, theft, vandalism, etc. It's not required by the state, but if you have a car loan, the bank 99.9% of the time will require you to have it.
So, the apples to oranges comparison should be clear. Car insurance is required to financially protect OTHER PEOPLE from you driving. CCW insurance, if mandatory, should also be for protecting other people from you having to use your firearm in public. THAT'S BACKWARDS. The only policy you can find for CCW covers YOU, not other people.
The ONLY thing forcing people carrying to have insurance does is create a HUGE, DEEP pocket of money (liability insurance) so lawyers can get rich suing anyone who has to defend themselves. If the insurer decides it's cheaper to settle, that's what they'll do.
Lawmakers helping lawyers make great money off gun owners exercising a right. That's all CCW insurance will be.
That's on the civil side. As for the legal side of discharging a firearm in self defense, the NRA coverage is a good idea. It'll protect the policy holder from the financial burden of defending their justified use of a gun.
To buy insurance should be a personal decision. Forcing someone to buy a policy to protect themselves from the state or to create another pool of cash for frivolous lawsuits is just wrong.
The last item: if you do something illegal with your firearm while legally carrying, like shoot someone over road rage or accidentally shoot another movie goer in a theater while fondling your pistol in the dark, the insurance is 100% useless.