I highly recommend the new winchester 1873s, I had 2 and have one original, they are great guns especially tuned up, and currently are beating uberti in terms of quality control. I have a couple of uberti rifles as well, the ubertis tuned up are a must, but nowdays they are getting sloppy. For a big slug like a 44 mag, id definitely get a marlin, for 357 id get either the marlin or winchester, they are the best fit and can be tuned quite nice. The Rossi/Puma 92s are very well made as well, and can handle loads the winchester 73 cannot. Both the marlin and rossi/puma are best for heavy loads. The henrys are nice american made guns, but there are better options, ive owned atleast one example of all of them.