Where are we headed? (Read 27973 times)

Alex Europa

Re: Where are we headed?
« Reply #20 on: October 25, 2011, 07:52:32 AM »
I used the locked in the bathroom, bad guy breaking down the door thing as an example cause according to the HRS, it says that were supposed to retreat inside our own homes, which is stupid.  I just gave my interpretation.
§703-304  Use of force in self-protection.

(5)  The use of deadly force is NOT justifiable under this section if:
(b)  The actor knows that he can avoid the necessity of using such force with complete safety by RETREATING or by surrendering possession of a thing to a person asserting a claim of right thereto or by complying with a demand that he abstain from any action which he has no  duty to take, except that:

You can't give an interpretation if you omit the most important part of a statute:

Quote
(5)  The use of deadly force is not justifiable under this section if:
     (a)  The actor, with the intent of causing death or serious bodily injury, provoked the use of force against himself in the same encounter; or
     (b)  The actor knows that he can avoid the necessity of using such force with complete safety by retreating or by surrendering possession of a thing to a person asserting a claim of right thereto or by complying with a demand that he abstain from any action which he has no duty to take, except that:
         (i)  The actor is not obliged to retreat from his dwelling or place of work, unless he was the initial aggressor or is assailed in his place of work by another person whose place of work the actor knows it to be; and

As sirkaiks stated, this is what is generally known as the Castle Doctrine.


For those of you who are new to the gun world, or to the Hawaiian (government's) gun culture, I would recommend that you do everyone a favor and hold your "opinions" until you have a better grasp on all of the moving parts. If you don't even know what a NICS check is or that we have the Castle Doctrine here in Hawaii, then when you state an opinion THAT SOME OTHER NEW SHOOTER MAY READ, you are spreading misinformation and NOT furthering the cause. It is perfectly understandable and acceptable to not know or understand something, but maybe the community as a whole would be better served by asking questions than making statements about a process or law which you know nothing about.

- Alex

Kingkeoni

Re: Where are we headed?
« Reply #21 on: October 25, 2011, 07:56:28 AM »
I used the locked in the bathroom, bad guy breaking down the door thing as an example cause according to the HRS, it says that were supposed to retreat inside our own homes, which is stupid.  I just gave my interpretation.
§703-304  Use of force in self-protection.

(5)  The use of deadly force is NOT justifiable under this section if:
(b)  The actor knows that he can avoid the necessity of using such force with complete safety by RETREATING or by surrendering possession of a thing to a person asserting a claim of right thereto or by complying with a demand that he abstain from any action which he has no  duty to take, except that:

You can't give an interpretation if you omit the most important part of a statute:

Quote
(5)  The use of deadly force is not justifiable under this section if:
     (a)  The actor, with the intent of causing death or serious bodily injury, provoked the use of force against himself in the same encounter; or
     (b)  The actor knows that he can avoid the necessity of using such force with complete safety by retreating or by surrendering possession of a thing to a person asserting a claim of right thereto or by complying with a demand that he abstain from any action which he has no duty to take, except that:
         (i)  The actor is not obliged to retreat from his dwelling or place of work, unless he was the initial aggressor or is assailed in his place of work by another person whose place of work the actor knows it to be; and

As sirkaiks stated, this is what is generally known as the Castle Doctrine.


For those of you who are new to the gun world, or to the Hawaiian (government's) gun culture, I would recommend that you do everyone a favor and hold your "opinions" until you have a better grasp on all of the moving parts. If you don't even know what a NICS check is or that we have the Castle Doctrine here in Hawaii, then when you state an opinion THAT SOME OTHER NEW SHOOTER MAY READ, you are spreading misinformation and NOT furthering the cause. It is perfectly understandable and acceptable to not know or understand something, but maybe the community as a whole would be better served by asking questions than making statements about a process or law which you know nothing about.

- Alex

Amen
Your number one Option for Personal Security is a lifelong commitment to avoidance, deterrence, and de-escalation.

Someday someone may kill you with your own gun, but they should have to beat you to death with it because it is empty.

Mr. Farknocker

Re: Where are we headed?
« Reply #22 on: October 25, 2011, 07:57:54 AM »
Then explain why, instead of just saying "wrong".  Were all here to learn

http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/Archives/measure_indiv_Archives.aspx?billtype=SB&billnumber=532&year=2010

check out this link... click on the pdf icon on the top, you can read the "Castle Doctirine" which was passed in May 2010.  A lot of guys on the forum also have the same beliefs as you.  I just think most people are unaware of this new bill that was past.  :shaka:

Sirkaiks,

Keep in mind that the Act 97 appears to relate to civil liability and not criminal liability. You may recall that Martin, the subject of this post, shot an injured one thief and killed the other. The surviving one sued Martin for "civil liability." In other words he sued Martin for money. Act 97 bars claims for civil liability made against individuals that employed the use of force and who meet its requirements.

Mr. Farknocker

Re: Where are we headed?
« Reply #23 on: October 25, 2011, 08:41:36 AM »
Apparently, this incident sparked a huge outcry by gun opponents and proponents. 

Martin, the man convicted, had been burglarized many times and had his furniture stolen three months before the incident. He slept with his clothes and boots on prepared for the next encounter and reportedly kept his gun primed and ready by his bedside.   Unfortunately, Martin also had a history of gun-related misbehaviour, including firing upon a car six years before - an incident which led to his shotgun certificate being revoked. Martin himself, claimed to be suffering from a paranoid personality disorder which diminished his responsibility.

The man who was killed was none other than a 16 year old boy. While Martin may have argued that he was being attacked and simply defended himself, the court found that the kid  was shot in the back as he was trying to flee through a window.

The court determined that Martin went beyond self defense and convicted him of murder.  Many called Martin monstrous while others decried the verdict.   Eventually Martin's verdict was reduced to manslaughter.

While I can't vouch for Britain's laws, the law's in the U.S., as a general matter, do not allow you to use deadly force to protect property.   Whether its theft of your papayas or your Van Gogh, you can't kill the thief for that.  The law furthers the public policy that a life is valued above property.

In any event, you can find more info about Martin here:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/norfolk/3009769.stm

This is ABSOLUTELY NOT TRUE.   Do some research. There are plenty of states that cover a homeowner in the event of a felony. Housebreaking is a felony in most states. I cite Utah for example. Texas is the same. Commission of a felony is enough, especially in your home. If someone breaks in, odds are they are not there to raid your fridge.

Vooduchkn,

The general rule holds true as it applies to property in general; both real and personal. You are correct, however, when it applies to places of habitation which is a subset of "property".  My error was in failing to limit the rule to a residence or place of abode which I believe  was the subject of the Martin Story you relayed. While many states have adopted the Castle and Stand Your Ground doctrines, they vary widely from State to State in their scope and application. In some States, use of deadly force is justified when a felony against property is being or about to be committed. In other States, the use of deadly force is limited to stopping an unlawful entry. Once the person has entered, the use of deadly force may not be used unless it meets other criteria. Other States, like Hawaii, limit the use of deadly force to instances where certain felonies are being committed. See, HRS Sec. 703-304(2). Compare Utah Criminal Code regarding the use of force in defense of a habitation versus property. http://le.utah.gov/~code/TITLE76/htm/76_02_040600.htm

http://le.utah.gov/~code/TITLE76/htm/76_02_040500.htm

Alex Europa

Re: Where are we headed?
« Reply #24 on: October 25, 2011, 09:04:48 AM »
Massad Ayoob on what to do after a justified shooting:

http://www.gunsandammo.com/2011/05/26/video-after-a-real-shooting/

- Alex

vooduchikn

Re: Where are we headed?
« Reply #25 on: October 25, 2011, 09:26:20 AM »
Massad Ayoob on what to do after a justified shooting:

http://www.gunsandammo.com/2011/05/26/video-after-a-real-shooting/

- Alex

Now we are getting somewhere!
Relax, I've banned myself..

bass monkey

Re: Where are we headed?
« Reply #26 on: October 25, 2011, 10:37:55 AM »
§703-304  Use of force in self-protection.

(5)  The use of deadly force is not justifiable under this section if:

     (a)  The actor, with the intent of causing death or serious bodily injury, provoked the use of force against himself in the same encounter; or

     (b)  The actor knows that he can avoid the necessity of using such force with complete safety by retreating or by surrendering possession of a thing to a person asserting a claim of right thereto or by complying with a demand that he abstain from any action which he has no duty to take, except that:

         (i)  The actor is not obliged to retreat from his dwelling or place of work, unless he was the initial aggressor or is assailed in his place of work by another person whose place of work the actor knows it to be; and



So if you feel it necessary to stop a threat from causing harm to you or your family, you are not required to retreat in your house and may handle the situation the best way you deem fit?

Sorry still new to this and trying to wrap my head around it, and rather then just spread misinformation, ill post it in a question form like suggested.  Seems like knowing about the laws is just as critical as knowing about your weapon.

Alex Europa

Re: Where are we headed?
« Reply #27 on: October 25, 2011, 10:52:22 AM »
So if you feel it necessary to stop a threat from causing harm to you or your family, you are not required to retreat in your house and may handle the situation the best way you deem fit?

Sorry still new to this and trying to wrap my head around it, and rather then just spread misinformation, ill post it in a question form like suggested.  Seems like knowing about the laws is just as critical as knowing about your weapon.

It is actually MORE important than knowing about your weapon, IMO. You can't support or defend your family from a prison cell.

To give a general answer to your question, yes.

However, I encourage you to research the following: Deadly Force, Grievous/Serious Bodily Harm, Escalation of Force, Disparity of Force, and Use of Force Continum. The biggest thing when in a self-defense situation is 1) acting accordingly to your training 2)being able to ARTICULATE why you did what you did. More often than not, #2 is FAR more important than #1.

Also, get your hands on anything and everything written by Massad Ayoob, I would recommend In the Gravest Extreme to start with.

Speaking of Massad Ayoob, would anyone be interested in seeing how much it would cost to hold a MAG 20/MAG 40 class out here? I've heard that it is BY FAR the BEST course that a gun owner can take. One MAJOR benefit to taking his class is that if you are involved in a justified self-defense shooting, Massad Ayoob will come out and testify on your behalf. That's worth the cost of the course alone, IMO!

http://massadayoobgroup.com/?page_id=7

- Alex

bass monkey

Re: Where are we headed?
« Reply #28 on: October 25, 2011, 11:19:16 AM »
Thanks alex.  I know a little about escalation of force but thanks for pointing me in the right direction.

Cougar8045

Re: Where are we headed?
« Reply #29 on: October 25, 2011, 11:35:54 AM »
So if you feel it necessary to stop a threat from causing harm to you or your family, you are not required to retreat in your house and may handle the situation the best way you deem fit?

Sorry still new to this and trying to wrap my head around it, and rather then just spread misinformation, ill post it in a question form like suggested.  Seems like knowing about the laws is just as critical as knowing about your weapon.

It is actually MORE important than knowing about your weapon, IMO. You can't support or defend your family from a prison cell.

To give a general answer to your question, yes.

However, I encourage you to research the following: Deadly Force, Grievous/Serious Bodily Harm, Escalation of Force, Disparity of Force, and Use of Force Continum. The biggest thing when in a self-defense situation is 1) acting accordingly to your training 2)being able to ARTICULATE why you did what you did. More often than not, #2 is FAR more important than #1.

Also, get your hands on anything and everything written by Massad Ayoob, I would recommend In the Gravest Extreme to start with.

Speaking of Massad Ayoob, would anyone be interested in seeing how much it would cost to hold a MAG 20/MAG 40 class out here? I've heard that it is BY FAR the BEST course that a gun owner can take. One MAJOR benefit to taking his class is that if you are involved in a justified self-defense shooting, Massad Ayoob will come out and testify on your behalf. That's worth the cost of the course alone, IMO!

http://massadayoobgroup.com/?page_id=7

- Alex
I had the Deadly Force Triangle beat into my head, and it should serve a guy well:  Deadly force is authorized when all sides of the triangle are present: Opportunity, Capability, and Intent.  Opportunity means the bad guy was located in a way that would allow him to do serious bodily harm to you, or kill you.  That might mean inside ten yards for a club or knife, or it might be somewhat farther for a gun.  Capability means he has the means to do you serious harm or death, so some sort of weapon, club, knife, gun, three huge friends, etc.  Intent means that he has done or said something that indicates he intends to use the first two.  The reason I like it is for the reason Alex stated:  you need to be able to articulate why you took the shot.  That's true, so I think that if you're thinking along the lines of the Deadly Force Triangle, you'll be able to articulate exactly why your shoot was justified, i.e.  "He had just broken down the door to the room I was in [Opportunity], and he was holding a crowbar [Capability].  When he raised the crowbar and came at me [Intent], I shot him."  Of course, in accordance with Massad Ayoob's much more expert advice, that's what you're going to say 24 hours later in the interrogation room, with your lawyer present and having already discussed it with him. 
I'm just a fluffy white bunny rabbit who lost his way. 

"If a thief be found breaking in, and be smitten that he die, there shall no blood be shed for him. ..."  -Exodus 22:2

Funtimes

Re: Where are we headed?
« Reply #30 on: October 25, 2011, 11:40:05 AM »
It comes down to this:

Shoot when you think you might die and rather not be dead. At this point jail doesn't even matter anymore.
Check out the Hawaii Defense Foundation.
HDF on Facebook
Defender of the Accused in Arkansas Courts
Posts are not legal advice & are my own, unless said so.

Funtimes

Re: Where are we headed?
« Reply #31 on: October 25, 2011, 11:41:58 AM »
So if you feel it necessary to stop a threat from causing harm to you or your family, you are not required to retreat in your house and may handle the situation the best way you deem fit?

Sorry still new to this and trying to wrap my head around it, and rather then just spread misinformation, ill post it in a question form like suggested.  Seems like knowing about the laws is just as critical as knowing about your weapon.

It is actually MORE important than knowing about your weapon, IMO. You can't support or defend your family from a prison cell.

To give a general answer to your question, yes.

However, I encourage you to research the following: Deadly Force, Grievous/Serious Bodily Harm, Escalation of Force, Disparity of Force, and Use of Force Continum. The biggest thing when in a self-defense situation is 1) acting accordingly to your training 2)being able to ARTICULATE why you did what you did. More often than not, #2 is FAR more important than #1.

Also, get your hands on anything and everything written by Massad Ayoob, I would recommend In the Gravest Extreme to start with.

Speaking of Massad Ayoob, would anyone be interested in seeing how much it would cost to hold a MAG 20/MAG 40 class out here? I've heard that it is BY FAR the BEST course that a gun owner can take. One MAJOR benefit to taking his class is that if you are involved in a justified self-defense shooting, Massad Ayoob will come out and testify on your behalf. That's worth the cost of the course alone, IMO!

http://massadayoobgroup.com/?page_id=7

- Alex

I'm pretty sure if HDF contacted these guys, and we had enough people, and a range to use... we could schedule something.  That gets kind of hard though! Especially when courses are two days long for most of them.  I now Chris Costa would likely come (at least he said so on our Radio interview).
Check out the Hawaii Defense Foundation.
HDF on Facebook
Defender of the Accused in Arkansas Courts
Posts are not legal advice & are my own, unless said so.

Cougar8045

Re: Where are we headed?
« Reply #32 on: October 25, 2011, 11:47:49 AM »
It comes down to this:

Shoot when you think you might die and rather not be dead. At this point jail doesn't even matter anymore.
That's probably a more realistic expectation.   8)  If you can't hear anything but the voice in your head going, "I'mgonnadieI'mgonnadieI'mgonnadieI'mgonnadieI'MGONNADIE!", you're probably good to go, eh?
I'm just a fluffy white bunny rabbit who lost his way. 

"If a thief be found breaking in, and be smitten that he die, there shall no blood be shed for him. ..."  -Exodus 22:2

Foxen

Re: Where are we headed?
« Reply #33 on: October 25, 2011, 12:06:13 PM »
It comes down to this:

Shoot when you think you might die and rather not be dead. At this point jail doesn't even matter anymore.

As one of my friend's puts it... "I'd rather be tried by a jury of 12 than be carried and buried by 6."

(edited for grammar and spelling)
« Last Edit: October 25, 2011, 09:32:20 PM by Foxen »

bass monkey

Re: Where are we headed?
« Reply #34 on: October 25, 2011, 02:14:03 PM »
All great advice guys.  I looked up that book and may have a few leads so hoping i can get into reading that real soon.

sirkaiks

Re: Where are we headed?
« Reply #35 on: October 25, 2011, 02:42:16 PM »

Sirkaiks,

Keep in mind that the Act 97 appears to relate to civil liability and not criminal liability. You may recall that Martin, the subject of this post, shot an injured one thief and killed the other. The surviving one sued Martin for "civil liability." In other words he sued Martin for money. Act 97 bars claims for civil liability made against individuals that employed the use of force and who meet its requirements.

I wasen't really refering to the story, just mentioning Hawaii law.  But while we're at it, that means he couldn't get sued right?

2aHawaii

  • Administrator
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3629
  • Total likes: 67
  • Sheepdog
  • Referrals: 17
    • View Profile
    • 2aHawaii
Re: Where are we headed?
« Reply #36 on: October 25, 2011, 03:04:38 PM »

Sirkaiks,

Keep in mind that the Act 97 appears to relate to civil liability and not criminal liability. You may recall that Martin, the subject of this post, shot an injured one thief and killed the other. The surviving one sued Martin for "civil liability." In other words he sued Martin for money. Act 97 bars claims for civil liability made against individuals that employed the use of force and who meet its requirements.

I wasen't really refering to the story, just mentioning Hawaii law.  But while we're at it, that means he couldn't get sued right?

I would be hesitant to ever say that you couldn't be sued (especially in Hawaii) but at that moment, your life is probably the only thing on your mind.
I am not a lawyer.

"A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed." - United States Constitution Amendment 2 & Hawaii State Constitution Article 1 Section 17

Buying from Amazon? Click through here

Mr. Farknocker

Re: Where are we headed?
« Reply #37 on: October 25, 2011, 03:21:02 PM »

Sirkaiks,

Keep in mind that the Act 97 appears to relate to civil liability and not criminal liability. You may recall that Martin, the subject of this post, shot an injured one thief and killed the other. The surviving one sued Martin for "civil liability." In other words he sued Martin for money. Act 97 bars claims for civil liability made against individuals that employed the use of force and who meet its requirements.

I wasen't really refering to the story, just mentioning Hawaii law.  But while we're at it, that means he couldn't get sued right?

Technically speaking, Act 97, now known as HRS §663-1.57, doesn’t prevent a property owner from getting sued. It means that the property owner has a statutory defense to a perpetrator’s claims for injury or death (yes, dead people can file claims too!). HRS §663-1.57 would be raised as an affirmative defense in the owner's answer to the perpetrator's civil complaint. How and when the owner prosecutes this defense to judgment depends on the situation. For example, if the perpetrator is injured and then files suit against the owner for damages, the owner may have to wait until the perpetrator is charged and convicted before prosecuting this statutory  defense to judgment either by way of a motion for summary judgment or bench/jury trial.

http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol13_Ch0601-0676/HRS0663/HRS_0663-0001_0057.htm

sirkaiks

Re: Where are we headed?
« Reply #38 on: October 25, 2011, 06:17:40 PM »


Technically speaking, Act 97, now known as HRS §663-1.57, doesn’t prevent a property owner from getting sued. It means that the property owner has a statutory defense to a perpetrator’s claims for injury or death (yes, dead people can file claims too!). HRS §663-1.57 would be raised as an affirmative defense in the owner's answer to the perpetrator's civil complaint. How and when the owner prosecutes this defense to judgment depends on the situation. For example, if the perpetrator is injured and then files suit against the owner for damages, the owner may have to wait until the perpetrator is charged and convicted before prosecuting this statutory  defense to judgment either by way of a motion for summary judgment or bench/jury trial.

http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol13_Ch0601-0676/HRS0663/HRS_0663-0001_0057.htm
not trying to be a wise ass, but are you a lawyer?  this is a good discussion btw

sirkaiks

Re: Where are we headed?
« Reply #39 on: October 27, 2011, 01:12:33 PM »
 :wave: