Handgun Red Dot Study - Sage Dynamics (Read 13409 times)

drck1000

ren

Re: Handgun Red Dot Study - Sage Dynamics
« Reply #1 on: January 01, 2018, 09:04:15 PM »
shot bullseye with a dot and my groups shrank in half compared with irons
Deeds Not Words

drck1000

Re: Handgun Red Dot Study - Sage Dynamics
« Reply #2 on: January 02, 2018, 08:56:51 AM »
shot bullseye with a dot and my groups shrank in half compared with irons
Nice. What gun?

I’ve been interested in a RDS handgun for a while. The cost of the dot has been the major hurdle. I’d likely go with a 17 or 19 MOS though.

I’ve long been a believer of red dots on long guns. Just haven’t taken the leap into handguns. I’ve shot handguns with RDS and they are nice once you get used to picking up the dot on the draw. I just have a hard time with the cost of the RDS being more than that gun. But maybe I have to think of it as overall value.

Drakiir84

Re: Handgun Red Dot Study - Sage Dynamics
« Reply #3 on: January 02, 2018, 09:26:16 AM »
Nice. What gun?

I’ve been interested in a RDS handgun for a while. The cost of the dot has been the major hurdle. I’d likely go with a 17 or 19 MOS though.

I’ve long been a believer of red dots on long guns. Just haven’t taken the leap into handguns. I’ve shot handguns with RDS and they are nice once you get used to picking up the dot on the draw. I just have a hard time with the cost of the RDS being more than that gun. But maybe I have to think of it as overall value.

Shoot my 19 with the Shield RMS on it the next time you come out.   With the mount they designed specifically for the MOS models it was under $400.   Have had it for a year, maybe 3 or 4k rounds on it.  The always on feature and co-witnessing with standard height irons were the big sellers for me.
"The rifle is a weapon. Let there be no mistake about that. It is a tool of power, and thus dependent completely upon the moral stature of its user. It is equally useful in securing meat for the table, destroying group enemies on the battlefield, and resisting tyranny. In fact, it is the only means of resisting tyranny, since a citizenry armed with rifles simply cannot be tyrannized."
-Jeff Cooper

Surf

Re: Handgun Red Dot Study - Sage Dynamics
« Reply #4 on: January 02, 2018, 09:55:16 AM »
Steep learning curve for me, mostly on first shot from the draw and sight tracking under rapid strings of fire.  Precision at distance is very nice.  I have a 19 set-up and go back and forth trying to get accustomed to it.  Still no luck, but will give it another go.

solidjohnny

Re: Handgun Red Dot Study - Sage Dynamics
« Reply #5 on: January 02, 2018, 09:58:11 AM »
The price of the Trijicon RMR Adjustible LED model has come down a lot in the last year.  Burris makes a great mini red dot as well.  I ran one on my 12ga shotgun and a friend has one on his MOS Glock.  Mine worked great even after firing boxes of 3in slugs and a bruised up shoulder!
« Last Edit: January 02, 2018, 10:04:27 AM by solidjohnny »

zippz

Re: Handgun Red Dot Study - Sage Dynamics
« Reply #6 on: January 02, 2018, 12:05:23 PM »
I'm waiting a little bit longer for it to get cheaper and sights to improve before putting one on m y handgun.  Age is creeping up on me, I still have good sight but I notice it takes me a split second longer and little more effort to get things in focus

jks

Re: Handgun Red Dot Study - Sage Dynamics
« Reply #7 on: January 02, 2018, 12:21:26 PM »
Although it's not a glock(since like 75-80% of pistol shooters I see shoot glocks), the sig RX models are a good deal.
The 320RX's can be had for about 8 bills locally. I have both the compact and full size rx's have had no issues.

Did move one of the romeo 1s to my 320x5 that I shoot for uspsa carry optics division. Over a 1k rounds and no problems with holding zero or battery life. Did learn that the oem battery sucks and your better off just replacing it from the get go.

Influence

Re: Handgun Red Dot Study - Sage Dynamics
« Reply #8 on: January 02, 2018, 01:29:39 PM »
The RMR 06/07 Type 1 is $350 on Cabela’s.  If utilizing Active Junky and Raise, I believe it can be had around $300.  Just picked up an 06 and am sending off my slide tomorrow

rpoL98

Re: Handgun Red Dot Study - Sage Dynamics
« Reply #9 on: January 02, 2018, 04:54:06 PM »
I have one of the Glock MOS's.  also have a Glock with an aftermarket slide cut specifically for the Trij RMR.  the MOS, being universal, mounts the RMR higher than the RMR-specific slide since it has to have an adapter plate.  Since I only consider the Trij RMR, I shoulda gone with the non-MOS and had the slide cut specifically for the RMR. makes for a lower combo.  in retrospect...

some of the prices on the Glock RMR-cut slides nowadays are really attractive, e.g. Brownells, Lone Wolf.

when Trijicon vendors were trying to clear out the original-style RMR-06 inventory to make way for the Type II RMR-06, there were some one-time terrific deals to be had.  combined with a BattleWerx plate, not so sure if there's any appreciable difference.  but, just MHO.

drck1000

Re: Handgun Red Dot Study - Sage Dynamics
« Reply #10 on: January 03, 2018, 09:40:28 AM »
Shoot my 19 with the Shield RMS on it the next time you come out.   With the mount they designed specifically for the MOS models it was under $400.   Have had it for a year, maybe 3 or 4k rounds on it.  The always on feature and co-witnessing with standard height irons were the big sellers for me.
Yeah, that would be cool.  Thanks! 

I've always liked the Shield to begin with. 

drck1000

Re: Handgun Red Dot Study - Sage Dynamics
« Reply #11 on: January 03, 2018, 09:47:22 AM »
Steep learning curve for me, mostly on first shot from the draw and sight tracking under rapid strings of fire.  Precision at distance is very nice.  I have a 19 set-up and go back and forth trying to get accustomed to it.  Still no luck, but will give it another go.
I haven't shot handguns with RDS from draw much, but picking up the dot from the draw was something that I noticed was a challenge for me.  I found that it did get a little better for me after a few reps, which I assume is part of natural point of aim (or similar process), but something that I would like to spend more time with. 

I did notice shooting steel at distance is also where the RDS helps since it eliminates the whole "focal plane confusion" deal.  Similar to shooting long guns with red dot in that you're focus is on the target and you just put the dot on there. 

Speaking of getting accustomed to handgun with RDS, to me it seems like a RDS on a long gun is somewhat natural transition for most.  For me, I shot my AR with RDS more than with irons when I first started and had to put time to train with irons.  But it seems like people pick up long guns with RDS very quickly.  Do you think that's due to the more consistent positioning afforded by long guns with more points of contact with the gun? 

drck1000

Re: Handgun Red Dot Study - Sage Dynamics
« Reply #12 on: January 03, 2018, 09:52:25 AM »
Although it's not a glock(since like 75-80% of pistol shooters I see shoot glocks), the sig RX models are a good deal.
The 320RX's can be had for about 8 bills locally. I have both the compact and full size rx's have had no issues.

Did move one of the romeo 1s to my 320x5 that I shoot for uspsa carry optics division. Over a 1k rounds and no problems with holding zero or battery life. Did learn that the oem battery sucks and your better off just replacing it from the get go.
My preference for a Glock with a RDS is so that I can compare between the two sighting options.  However, I'd love to have a P320 with a RDS.  Or even a PPQ 5" version with the RDS mount (I think Q or something like that). 

macsak

Re: Handgun Red Dot Study - Sage Dynamics
« Reply #13 on: January 03, 2018, 10:06:57 AM »
PPQ 5" version with the RDS mount (I think Q or something like that).

Q5

drck1000

Re: Handgun Red Dot Study - Sage Dynamics
« Reply #14 on: January 03, 2018, 10:19:35 AM »

ren

Re: Handgun Red Dot Study - Sage Dynamics
« Reply #15 on: January 03, 2018, 10:23:42 AM »
Nice. What gun?

I’ve been interested in a RDS handgun for a while. The cost of the dot has been the major hurdle. I’d likely go with a 17 or 19 MOS though.

I’ve long been a believer of red dots on long guns. Just haven’t taken the leap into handguns. I’ve shot handguns with RDS and they are nice once you get used to picking up the dot on the draw. I just have a hard time with the cost of the RDS being more than that gun. But maybe I have to think of it as overall value.

It was a 1911 with an Aimpoint T1
Deeds Not Words

zippz

Re: Handgun Red Dot Study - Sage Dynamics
« Reply #16 on: January 03, 2018, 11:05:42 AM »
Speaking of getting accustomed to handgun with RDS, to me it seems like a RDS on a long gun is somewhat natural transition for most.  For me, I shot my AR with RDS more than with irons when I first started and had to put time to train with irons.  But it seems like people pick up long guns with RDS very quickly.  Do you think that's due to the more consistent positioning afforded by long guns with more points of contact with the gun?

I'm guessing the difference is on an AR15 the RDS dot and iron sights are at about the same height so you can keep the same cheek weld, stock placement, etc.  On the handgun, the red dot is slightly higher.  Doesn't seem like much but decades of muscle memory looking at the low iron sights would make it difficult to adjust.  Also if you look at the red dot sight off angle, then the dot disappears in that small piece of glass.  Iron sights you know where the sights are and can line them up quickly.

drck1000

Re: Handgun Red Dot Study - Sage Dynamics
« Reply #17 on: January 04, 2018, 08:05:34 AM »
It was a 1911 with an Aimpoint T1
Nice!  A nice 1911 would be a good test for affect on accuracy between irons and a RDS. 

drck1000

Re: Handgun Red Dot Study - Sage Dynamics
« Reply #18 on: January 04, 2018, 08:09:16 AM »
I'm guessing the difference is on an AR15 the RDS dot and iron sights are at about the same height so you can keep the same cheek weld, stock placement, etc.  On the handgun, the red dot is slightly higher.  Doesn't seem like much but decades of muscle memory looking at the low iron sights would make it difficult to adjust.  Also if you look at the red dot sight off angle, then the dot disappears in that small piece of glass.  Iron sights you know where the sights are and can line them up quickly.
I think long guns are sort of automatic in that you have contact with you shoulder and then the cheek part is more consistent.  The dot is always sort of "just there" when I bring the rifle up.  For me, I think I get sloppy on the draw with the handgun and RDS and I think because of how it's "just there" with the long gun.  That I get sloppy and I think I don't have the gun level (or level enough) where I can't pick up the dot at first pass.  Then I have to sort of adjust and pick up the dot.  I think once I get the draw level correct, I think I could pick up the dot quicker, but I haven't been able to try. 

I see what you are saying about the dot level, but that's not much difference for me since all my RDS on long guns are lower 1/3. 
« Last Edit: January 04, 2018, 10:57:08 AM by drck1000 »

jks

Re: Handgun Red Dot Study - Sage Dynamics
« Reply #19 on: January 04, 2018, 10:50:12 AM »
That's the biggest learning curve is to learn that with the RDS youre looking over the iron sights and also not using them to cowitness. With rifles you have the reference point of your check well and shoulder to put you in the ball park of the RDS window.

That's why I prefer the sig Romeo 1 over the RMR, the window size is much larger on the Romeo 1 which gives you a larger margin of error when learning to pick up the dot.