Weaver, thumbs forward.
Weaver because I'm right handed but left eyed and it lets me line up my strong (right) hand grip with my left eye more naturally without needing an offset grip - I just pull my right arm across my body a little more to aim with my left eye. I also feel like I can move with a weaver stance. Isosceles feels too static for me - and I don't wear body armor with weak side protection. Too much martial arts training I guess.
Thumbs forward because Chris showed me that grip at an HDF class and it made sense. More positive palm contact for my weak hand and it felt right after I got over the initial odd feeling. Now my hands do that without me thinking about it.
Anyone else get the pistol grip heebeegeebee's at the range? I was at the range the other day and a guy was showing his girl how to shoot. When they got to the Beretta 9mm she... uh... let's see. Thumbs crossed around the back, left hand strong with right hand trigger finger out on the trigger guard. I reacted almost instinctively as I thought her thumbs were going to get smashed by the slide but realized just a hair too late that her thumbs were low enough.
I involuntarily reached out my hand to get her attention and started to say something like "There are easier ways to hold the gun!" but cut off the first word as my brain caught up to my horror and informed me that it was probably impolite to school a fellow in proper pistol grip when he's at the range with his lady. Too late, though. The hand motion had caught their attention and they wondered if I was trying to call their attention to something unsafe.
"No, sorry. I thought the slide was going to hit your thumbs but I see now that they are just far enough down. I noticed that your are holding the pistol with your right trigger finger up on the front of the guard. I've read that it can be hard to shoot accurately that way. Left handed, yeah?"
The "knowledgeable" fellow said "Oh, yeah, but remember she has smaller hands."
I gave him the "Oh, I see" nod and went back to my shooting... biting my tongue on the idea that stretching the offhand way out to the trigger guard wasn't going to make the gun any easier to hold with small hands... especially with the thumb wrapped around the back.
Clumsy on my part, really, and none of my business anyway. But if she tries to fire anything stiffer than that 9mm later on its not going to be a pleasant experience. Whatta ya do?
