2aHawaii
General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: passivekinetic on September 27, 2013, 01:58:58 PM
-
Comments?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TVlrSVsAdpI&feature=player_embedded (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TVlrSVsAdpI&feature=player_embedded)
Was it FMJ (of course, we won't know) and might HP have done better?
Or did he not place the shots correctly? Even at that range?
(In fact at that range, the shots might be low, if he didn't know about it).
-
I posted a similar question a few months back, and the general consensus was that a good fully bonded soft point, and shot placement was very key. People posted their mixed experiences using 5.56/.223 ammo.
As for this video, we don't know what he was shooting, or where is shots were ending up, you're right, at the range, using what looks like to be an acog, his shots may have been going low. In fact, in the video, it looks like hes hitting it in the lower jaw, rather than straight to the noggin.
This video also might just be pointing out how damn tough boars can be. Its actually a good example when remembering what takes a person out of the fight. A person can live and keep fighting for up to 30 seconds even after being shot in the heart. You have to make sure you always put enough rounds into whatever you are shooting, and put them in the right places.
-
god damn assholes. you don't just sit there watching your quarry squirm like that, that is WHY you carry a big fuckin knife with you and finish it off swiftly and give em the respect they deserve.
-
Even without a knife, they should've tried to finish it off much faster. If there was ever a time and a place to unload a full magazine into a pigs head, that was one of them.
-
.
-
Yeah that pig really suffered. Finishing shot should've come much sooner.
-
Q is right when would have to deal with pig hunters at my old job break barrel .22 air rifles were the new weapon of choice. I'd assume it has to fact its not a firearm so firing it in palolo valley, kalihi valley and other areas closer to town they wouldn't get into as much trouble.
Gone are thrle days I guess of having a ugly .30-30 lever action pig gun
-
god damn assholes. you don't just sit there watching your quarry squirm like that, that is WHY you carry a big fuckin knife with you and finish it off swiftly and give em the respect they deserve.
Yup. I agree. I was waiting for them to pull a sidearm (1911 or even a 9mm) when they were point blank, but nothing.
-
I have killed a few pigs with a .22, albeit smaller than the one in the video you posted. The last good size pig I got with a 1oz rifled slug from my 12 gauge from about 10 yards. It dropped right there. even found the wad inside the pig.
If you ever watch that life below zero show one of the guys on there is a guide in alaska and I have seen him take relatively large game with a .223 AR. Good thing is you have quick followup shots if necessary. I think the .223 round is plenty sufficient for pigs. You might want to look into the heavier bullets though depending on your twist rate.
-
I posted a similar question a few months back, and the general consensus was that a good fully bonded soft point, and shot placement was very key. People posted their mixed experiences using 5.56/.223 ammo.
As for this video, we don't know what he was shooting, or where is shots were ending up, you're right, at the range, using what looks like to be an acog, his shots may have been going low. In fact, in the video, it looks like hes hitting it in the lower jaw, rather than straight to the noggin.
This video also might just be pointing out how damn tough boars can be. Its actually a good example when remembering what takes a person out of the fight. A person can live and keep fighting for up to 30 seconds even after being shot in the heart. You have to make sure you always put enough rounds into whatever you are shooting, and put them in the right places.
Yup - I guess it is just surprising that with so many rounds, SUPPOSEDLY hitting the brain box, the animal was still alive. So either the rounds were ineffective even at point blank (hard to believe a hog is THAT tough) or he basically missed the brain box. I think it HAS to be the latter. Surely .223 is not THAT ineffective.
-
I have killed a few pigs with a .22, albeit smaller than the one in the video you posted. The last good size pig I got with a 1oz rifled slug from my 12 gauge from about 10 yards. It dropped right there. even found the wad inside the pig.
If you ever watch that life below zero show one of the guys on there is a guide in alaska and I have seen him take relatively large game with a .223 AR. Good thing is you have quick followup shots if necessary. I think the .223 round is plenty sufficient for pigs. You might want to look into the heavier bullets though depending on your twist rate.
Yes I have watched that series. It is pretty good, showing various families and individuals in AK.
I recall that guy (I think he is in his 20s) even dispatched some animals with a 22LR Ruger Mark III (a wolverine I think).
-
Had some customers take out wild boar at 220 yards with 223 55gr
With an AR. They all said the boar dropped with 1 shot
-
.
-
For game mammals:
According to the DLNR guys, air guns are not allowed for any hunting on Hawaii at all. Airguns are not humane enough to guarantee a kill.
In Hawaii, 22 magnum (not LR) pistol is only allowed if you have dogs to pin down the pig. It is usually done to dispatch the pig at point blank range. Otherwise, it has to be 357, 38 special, 44 magnum or any cartridge that is longer than 1.5" in length. Yeah, even the 45ACP is not allowed.
Otherwise 223 is the minimum caliber needed for hunting with firearms only. And shot placement is important for a clean kill.
Passivekinetic, check out the free DLNR Hunters ed class. It is WORTH IT even if you already have taken a handgun safety class.
-
If I'm not mistaken, 10mm is allowed as well. BUT the wording in the rule books call it a 10mm magnum, which does not exist. According to the DNLR guy that was present at the hunters ed course I attended, that it was just a mistake in the wording, and most know that it means 10mm auto. But there is the off chance of running into a guy that knows zilch about firearms, and may get busted for not using the right caliber.
Side note... glock 20sf with 6inch barrel and extended slide... on my wish list.
-
Passivekinetic, check out the free DLNR Hunters ed class. It is WORTH IT even if you already have taken a handgun safety class.
Been there done that.
:-)
-
Cool! I just completed my class yesterday! :thumbsup:
-
Still tons of people lining up for it?
-
It must be. When I took my class, a bunch was on stand by. The instructors mentioned the classes have always been full for the past years.
-
I got in the class by lining up for standby. The instructor said that classes are normally booked 2 months in advance but about 15 or so people are no-shows during the day of the class.
If you line up early at 2:00pm or 2:30pm on the day of the first class, there is a good chance that you will be able to get in as a standby. Bring picture ID as it is required.
-
so they do deny walkins?
they only fill the class to the limit?
i was led to believe they cram in most, if not all walkins
I got in yhe class by lining up for standby. The instructor said that classes are normally booked 2 months in advance but about 15 or so people are no-shows during the day of the class.
If you line up early at 2:00pm or 2:30pm on the day of the first class, there is a good chance that you will be able to get in as a standby. Bring picture ID as it is required.
-
I don't think they do just random walk ins. I almost positive one has to call in ahead of time and request to be on standby for a particular class. Then everyone shows up on the first day, all registered and standbys. From what I seen, standbys line up last. The instructors take in as much as possible that is on the standby list. It is best to call in and ask. The best part about the class was, it was free.
-
so they do deny walkins?
> Yes.
they only fill the class to the limit?
> Yes. As long as there are seats available, they'll accept walk-ins.
i was led to believe they cram in most, if not all walkins
> I think they do try to cram them all in but only to capacity.
-
Yes, that is the same as what I experienced.
I think early on you may have to give your name to them to be put on a list, but I think to get on THAT list (waiting list) you need to be waiting for the waiting list (haha).
I went I think 3 or 4 hours early but already there were people ahead of me.
They do literally cram as many people in as possible; some were standing room only I think. And just sitting on the floor.
Beats not getting into class at all.
When I went, I think 2 or 3 years ago, they were in the process of producing their own hunting tutorial video, showing field dressing, etc.
Not sure if that was eventually completed and if so, whether we "alumni" can get a copy of it.
-
Haha yeah we did watch the locally produced Lanai deer game care video. They showed it during class and it was very good quality.
You might want to ask them as they were reluctant in releasing it outside of the classes.
-
When I took my hunters ed class a few years, it was as a walking, and my dad and I came pretty late and were the last in the line. Its my understanding that they accept walk ins, and will try to fit as many people as they (reasonably) can into the room. Not only are they all pretty nice guys, but I'm under the impression that they get more money from the state for every person they certify. That's a nice incentive.
-
Haha yeah we did watch the locally produced Lanai deer game care video. They showed it during class and it was very good quality.
You might want to ask them as they were reluctant in releasing it outside of the classes.
ok interesting.
hey you recognize that actor that was doing the gun safety film? that old footage?
i can't put my name to him but he is old now, but always in lots of movies.
-
ok interesting.
hey you recognize that actor that was doing the gun safety film? that old footage?
i can't put my name to him but he is old now, but always in lots of movies.
Is this the video you are referring to?
http://alanmadison.com/Detailed/5.html
-
Haha yes that sure looks like it.
-
Some of the clips are here...
http://m.youtube.com/user/alanmadisonvideo
-
yeah thanks; I saw that but it doesn't show that actor. I don't think the guy in the clip is that actor (the one in the film with the young hunter).
Anyway, this was just a trivia topic. Haha