2aHawaii

General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: HiCarry on January 30, 2011, 07:02:18 PM

Title: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on January 30, 2011, 07:02:18 PM
OK fellow activists and advocates, I need to ask your help on something. I have been invited to participate in a debate/panel discussion on the local PBS. The topic (of course) is Hawaii firearms issues and the other guests will be newly (re)elected Prosecutor Keith Kaneshiro, Former Senator Ed Case, and Avi Soifer, the Dean of the UH school of law. The show is aired live on FEBRUARY 3, 2011 from 1930-2030.

Here is where I need your help: They will be accepting call-in questions so I would really like to hear a few "friendly" questions/comments thrown in with what I am sure will be mostly anti-gun, anti-self defense ones. I will see if I can get info about the call-in number, but I suspect that they don't publish it until it is announced during the show. So, you'll have to sit thru it to find out the number and call in. I intend to keep it factual and hopefully bring any emotional arguments back to fact based ones, as well as push "our" agenda as best as possible.

I am going to be boning up on relevent firearms related info so if you have any suggestions or resourses you'd like to share, I'm all ears.

Thanks! 
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: 2aHawaii on January 31, 2011, 09:40:17 AM
Is there a place to watch it online?

As for resources, http://gunfacts.info (http://gunfacts.info) is always a good one.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Antithesis on January 31, 2011, 09:42:16 AM
Sounds like a pretty heavy-hitting panel.  I marked it down in my phone's calendar.   Any particular questions or directions you want the discussion to go?
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: kaneohegrown on January 31, 2011, 10:33:42 AM
Would deffinently hit up on some of the recent local events of the new year to hi-lite why law abiding citizens shouldn't be punished for criminals breaking the law. And why we need to be able to protect ourselves at all times, not only when we're at home or our place of business.

-Kaneohe shooting, where I would suspect that the Botehlo brother had an illegally obtained rifle.

-Millilani car jacking that resulted in the victim getting shot.

-Robbery / attempted car jacking by Kualoa, caused traffic shutdown.

-Women assaulted by ex-boyfriend (with brass knuckles) who was hanging onto her car while she tried to escape (why TRO's don't stop crazy people).

-Kailua gunman who caused the school lockdowns.

Recent events off the top of my head...
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on January 31, 2011, 10:48:06 AM
Is there a place to watch it online?

As for resources, http://gunfacts.info (http://gunfacts.info) is always a good one.

Not sure if there will be an online simulcast, but past episodes seem to be available online.

Got the GunFacts....Thanks
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on January 31, 2011, 10:49:29 AM
Deleted - Dup post
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on January 31, 2011, 10:49:56 AM
Is there a place to watch it online?

As for resources, http://gunfacts.info (http://gunfacts.info) is always a good one.

Not sure if there will be an online simulcast, but past episodes seem to be available online.

Got the GunFacts....Thanks

Here's a link to the PBS info page on the episode

http://www.pbshawaii.org/ourproductions/insight.php (http://www.pbshawaii.org/ourproductions/insight.php)
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on January 31, 2011, 11:03:37 AM
Sounds like a pretty heavy-hitting panel.  I marked it down in my phone's calendar.   Any particular questions or directions you want the discussion to go?
Yeah, I will definitely be the only pro-gun, pro-self defense guy there. Would like to focus on a couple of topics, such as the cost and ineffectiveness of the registration process in Hawaii (ie no crimes solved by this cumbersom and expensive process, money that could be better spent elsewhere in these harsh economic times) and the onerouse restrictions on self-defense tools available to ordinary citizens for whom the police have no legal duty to protect. I am sure the issue of "extended or large capacity magazines" will be brought up, as will the "renewed public outcry for tougher firearms restrictions across the nation."

In general, I suspect that a lot of the viewers of PBS are, if not outright "anti" are leaning that direction. Therefore it is that "group" that would be likely to call in. So, I just wanted to have a few of "us" to balance out the anticipated anti bias. Since I don't know exactly where the topic of "conversation" will go, we'll have to be a little flexible and play it by ear....
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on January 31, 2011, 11:10:50 AM
Would deffinently hit up on some of the recent local events of the new year to hi-lite why law abiding citizens shouldn't be punished for criminals breaking the law. And why we need to be able to protect ourselves at all times, not only when we're at home or our place of business.

-Kaneohe shooting, where I would suspect that the Botehlo brother had an illegally obtained rifle.

-Millilani car jacking that resulted in the victim getting shot.

-Robbery / attempted car jacking by Kualoa, caused traffic shutdown.

-Women assaulted by ex-boyfriend (with brass knuckles) who was hanging onto her car while she tried to escape (why TRO's don't stop crazy people).

-Kailua gunman who caused the school lockdowns.

Recent events off the top of my head...

Yep, all of these instances are on my list, for the reasons you mention, if the topic arises. Thanks!
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Heavies on January 31, 2011, 01:47:09 PM
I certainly hope it goes well for you, and all of us as well. I not sure that the country, in general, is in an outcry for more gun control. Seems to me that that trend is opposite. Lots of pro laws have been moving forward in many states.  Just a thought. I may be wrong because of my pro bias.

I'll be at work when this airs, and as usual I'll be missing out on the fun.  :(
I'll be praying for you, and hope you might sway many folks in our direction!
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on January 31, 2011, 02:21:41 PM
I certainly hope it goes well for you, and all of us as well. I not sure that the country, in general, is in an outcry for more gun control. Seems to me that that trend is opposite. Lots of pro laws have been moving forward in many states.  Just a thought. I may be wrong because of my pro bias.

I'll be at work when this airs, and as usual I'll be missing out on the fun.  :(
I'll be praying for you, and hope you might sway many folks in our direction!
Yeah, I don't think there is an "outcry" either, but should anyone have some credible sources to refute that, I'd be happy to hear it. In general, most recent polls seem to indicate the public doesn't see much need for additional gun control laws.

On the same topic, did the father of the girl killed in Tucson say he didn't see a need for more gun control? I thought I read that but now cannot find the source. So agian, if anybody has link to that, I'd love to be able to pull that out of my pocket.....Thanks! 
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Funtimes on January 31, 2011, 02:35:25 PM
He did, he didn't want to see peoples rights infringed. It was one of the videos on the news.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: kaneohegrown on January 31, 2011, 03:45:10 PM
Found the video, I recall watching it after the incident. From a FOX news interview.

Megyn Kelly Interviews John Green, Father of 9-Year-Old Girl Killed in AZ Shooting (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EPCdgD4ygvI#)

@ around 8:10
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Dregs on January 31, 2011, 05:08:11 PM
Let's not forget that CDC did a study on the effectiveness of various restrictive gun laws sucn as 2 week waits, gun limits, etc. Testing the effectiveness at which it reduces crime. Results were inconclusve at best.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Funtimes on January 31, 2011, 06:31:20 PM
Let's not forget that CDC did a study on the effectiveness of various restrictive gun laws sucn as 2 week waits, gun limits, etc. Testing the effectiveness at which it reduces crime. Results were inconclusve at best.

Let me know if you can find the real results ;o
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on January 31, 2011, 06:58:27 PM
Kaneohegrown - Thanks....I was finally able to locate it as well. Not sure how the video can be presented, but I have the info on my thumb drive in case....

Dregs - I believe the CDC and the National Academy of Science each did a meta analysis of all available sudies on gun control and could not find a correlation between gun crime/gun deaths and gun control laws.

http://www.nap.edu/openbook.php?isbn=0309091241 (http://www.nap.edu/openbook.php?isbn=0309091241)

http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/rr5214a2.htm (http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/rr5214a2.htm)
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Dregs on January 31, 2011, 08:46:20 PM
Aaah yes. I am humbly corrected. It was something I read in passing. Sweet that the results were NO correlation!
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Heavies on January 31, 2011, 10:38:17 PM
Quote
Yeah, I don't think there is an "outcry" either, but should anyone have some credible sources to refute that, I'd be happy to hear it. In general, most recent polls seem to indicate the public doesn't see much need for additional gun control laws.

A very interesting article, in which the author writes how the BATF and various anti groups attempt to infringe on Rights by bypassing congress and use administrative actions and rule changes/interpretation,  also seems to confirm this.

In the latest edition of the American Rifleman in the article titled,"END RUN"   Chris Cox, executive director NRA-ILA, states, "Despite widespread and growing bipartisan support for the Second Amendment in Congress (thanks to the Second Amendment supporters turning out in droves at the ballot box) and polls showing record low support for gun control, anti-gun forces will use any means at their disposal, no matter how undemocratic, to undermine the Right to Keep and Bear Arms."

I found this, http://www.capitaltonight.com/2011/01/bloombergs-gun-control-group-polls-on-gun-control/, (http://www.capitaltonight.com/2011/01/bloombergs-gun-control-group-polls-on-gun-control/,)  Bloomberg's gun control groups poll.  It does all, but come out and say that Americans don't want more gun control.

Also from: http://www.gallup.com/poll/145556/Doubt-Political-Rhetoric-Major-Factor-Ariz-Shootings.aspx (http://www.gallup.com/poll/145556/Doubt-Political-Rhetoric-Major-Factor-Ariz-Shootings.aspx)

"Most Americans, though, do not believe tougher gun laws in Arizona would   have prevented these shootings. One in five say stricter laws would   have prevented the tragedy, while 72% disagree. Democrats, who are more   likely to support gun restrictions, are also more likely to believe the   shootings could have been prevented if tougher gun laws were in place,   but a majority of this group still says the shootings would have   occurred regardless."
These are from the 'other side' of the issue, and it is fun to see that they can't dispute the truth. ;)
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Old Guy on February 01, 2011, 07:01:26 AM
OK, if/when CCW and it's "dangers" are brought up, Here is Texas DPS stats on how much safer CCW people are vs. the rest of the population.

     http://www.txdps.state.tx.us/administration/crime_records/chl/convrates.htm (http://www.txdps.state.tx.us/administration/crime_records/chl/convrates.htm)

Personally, I'd like to "discuss" the Tupuola case with Carlisle about him sayit's OK of soneone to have shot him.
   Bet he has no concpt of history being changed and going in another direction if Tupuola was shot and the wife "saved"

Most likely that discussion will be over the heads of most involved........

This is also a good time to see where the new Attorney General stands on firearms.

Edit:  I guess Ed Case is in this because he wants another shot at running for office?  A question that Should be asked?
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Heavies on February 01, 2011, 11:31:27 PM
From an email I got, NRA/ILA
Phone numbers, email, and twitter feeds.

Quote
Insights On PBS Hawaii to Discuss Gun Control

 

This Thursday, February 3rd at 7:30 p.m., Insights on PBS Hawaii has decided they needed to discuss gun control in the United States and whether or not the recent Arizona tragedy should prompt a closer look at Hawaii's gun laws.

 

Insights host Dan Boylan and a panel representing a variety of perspectives will look at the permit process, compare Hawaii's laws to that of other states, and discuss the Second Amendment as a whole.

 

Scheduled guests for this episode include Hawaii Rifle Association (HRA) Director Bill Richter, Honolulu Prosecuting Attorney Keith Kaneshiro, anti-gun former U.S. Congressman Ed Case, and Dean of the University of Hawaii School of Law, Avi Soifer.

PBS is requesting listeners to join the discussion by calling in at (808) 973-1000 or toll-free at (800) 238-4847.

Listeners may also e-mail questions ahead of time to insights@pbshawaii.org or can follow the event on twitter and add comments on the PBS twitter page at PBS Hawaii Twitter.

 

This is a great opportunity for Hawaii's gun owners to call in to voice their opinions in support of the Second Amendment and HRA's Bill Richter as he goes toe to toe with his anti-gun opponents.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 02, 2011, 09:21:04 AM
OK, if/when CCW and it's "dangers" are brought up, Here is Texas DPS stats on how much safer CCW people are vs. the rest of the population.

     http://www.txdps.state.tx.us/administration/crime_records/chl/convrates.htm (http://www.txdps.state.tx.us/administration/crime_records/chl/convrates.htm)

Personally, I'd like to "discuss" the Tupuola case with Carlisle about him sayit's OK of soneone to have shot him.
   Bet he has no concpt of history being changed and going in another direction if Tupuola was shot and the wife "saved"

Most likely that discussion will be over the heads of most involved........

This is also a good time to see where the new Attorney General stands on firearms.

Edit:  I guess Ed Case is in this because he wants another shot at running for office?  A question that Should be asked?

Kaneshiro is supposed to be a pretty staunch anti. I would love to have the Tupuola case come up. And, Carlisle said, in reference to the incident, that "it may have been justified" to have utilized deadly force.

Thanks for the link
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 02, 2011, 09:33:15 AM
The NRA News contacted me and I am currently schedule to do a live piece at 1640 today. Not sure if they have a internet simulcast....Listen for the plug for Chris and Hawaii CCW....
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: ren on February 02, 2011, 01:23:13 PM
I had Dan Boylan as a history professor at UH West - He is VERY anti NRA!
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Heavies on February 02, 2011, 02:53:49 PM
For a show touting, "a panel representing a variety of perspectives",
seems to me like a whole bunch of antis going to bang on the one pro on the show.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 02, 2011, 03:40:18 PM
For a show touting, "a panel representing a variety of perspectives",
seems to me like a whole bunch of antis going to bang on the one pro on the show.

Now there's a call in question if I ever heard on! :-)
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Old Guy on February 03, 2011, 08:04:02 AM
I have every Confidence in your abilities to "handle" the crowd.

I sort of look at it as the Marshall facing down a bunch of bullies at High Noon in main street......

John Wayne, speaking slowly, major eye contact, small smile, oozing confidence and shooting straight ..........
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: ren on February 03, 2011, 09:10:58 AM
I have summoned the arfcom army. Let's see if they will respond.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 03, 2011, 02:17:15 PM
I am not sure if I will be able to check the forum for any more posts before the show tonight, so I just want to thank everyone for their suggestions, links to information and the general support and well wishes. Thank you!

"See" you after the show....I expect bandages and liquor to be standing by when I am done..... :shaka:
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: kaneohegrown on February 03, 2011, 08:26:51 PM
Awsome job! Seems like Ed Case just gave up after he wasn't able to bring up any real statistics or cases. I LOVED the backpedaling after the ammunition registration act question came up. Kaneshiro and Case looked absolutely BLASTED trying to answer that! :thumbsup: Great job HiCarry!
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: 2asupport on February 03, 2011, 08:32:44 PM
Awsome job! Seems like Ed Case just gave up after he wasn't able to bring up any real statistics or cases. I LOVED the backpedaling after the ammunition registration act question came up. Kaneshiro and Case looked absolutely BLASTED trying to answer that! :thumbsup: Great job HiCarry!

Kaneshiro-  "tell them to buy/bring their own ammunition"  :rofl:


Kaneshiro-  "The police have an obligation to protect you, you are being attacked,  you have a phone, call 911 and the police will come" :rofl:
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HGS on February 03, 2011, 09:17:19 PM
Thank you HiCarry for being well versed and supporting gun rights in Hawaii, you did an excellent job!   :thumbsup:
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Funtimes on February 03, 2011, 09:41:13 PM
!!! People questioned if I knew how to spell bear! :P --- that was my "bear" of a question :).
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Heavies on February 03, 2011, 10:12:06 PM
Got this dvr'ed. Can't wait to see it when I get home.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Old Guy on February 03, 2011, 10:48:39 PM
Considering the "fixed" deck, We think Hi Carry did very well.

Congratulations on a job well done.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Heavies on February 04, 2011, 12:11:42 AM
Thank you HIcarry! Awesome!
They evaded and avoided, spouted opinion and outright lied, you prevailed with truth and fact.


I guess they didn't get the emails I sent in.  :P
Maybe he did, heh, I seen him flipping through those cards looking for the one question to bolster their view. No joy.   :rofl:
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 04, 2011, 12:34:11 AM

I guess they didn't get the emails I sent in.  :P
Maybe he did, heh, I seen him flipping through those cards looking for the one question to bolster their view. No joy.   :rofl:
First, thanks to you and everyone else for the kind words and compliments. I went in thinking I was going to get eaten alive but it went better than I expected.
Awsome job! Seems like Ed Case just gave up after he wasn't able to bring up any real statistics or cases. I LOVED the backpedaling after the ammunition registration act question came up. Kaneshiro and Case looked absolutely BLASTED trying to answer that! :thumbsup: Great job HiCarry!

Thanks! Anytime you can make a politician backpedal, it's a good day.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 04, 2011, 12:38:44 AM
Awsome job! Seems like Ed Case just gave up after he wasn't able to bring up any real statistics or cases. I LOVED the backpedaling after the ammunition registration act question came up. Kaneshiro and Case looked absolutely BLASTED trying to answer that! :thumbsup: Great job HiCarry!

Kaneshiro-  "tell them to buy/bring their own ammunition"  :rofl:


Kaneshiro-  "The police have an obligation to protect you, you are being attacked,  you have a phone, call 911 and the police will come" :rofl:


Yeah, he didn't do too well, did he....."tell'em to buy their own ammo.....Isn't that kinda hard to do with out a gun registration. Well tell them to get a gun....Can't do that unless they take a class. Oh" I can hear him in the office tomorrow: (to law clerk) Get me the summaries of Warren v. DC and Castlerock V. Gonzales, would you please....I saw him a few months ago before, before the election, eating lunch. He had two big guys with baggy aloha shirts and badly printing firearms with him.....guess if you can afford armed protection or get it from the .gov, you don't have any reason to carry a firearm for personal protection.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 04, 2011, 12:39:26 AM
Thank you HiCarry for being well versed and supporting gun rights in Hawaii, you did an excellent job!   :thumbsup:
Thanks!
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 04, 2011, 12:44:52 AM
!!! People questioned if I knew how to spell bear! :P --- that was my "bear" of a question :).
Me: At least it isn't BAR....OK, how many of you caught that??

I want everyone to know that Chris helped me prep, spending his evening posing questions to me in a little mock of what we anticipated tonight. Without hesitation I can say that without his help I would not have done as well as I did. Several of the things that he brought up last night were brought up on air. Chris deserves a lot of the credit for any success we realized tonight. Thanks, Chris!
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 04, 2011, 12:47:36 AM
Got this dvr'ed. Can't wait to see it when I get home.
I think it's online....not sure if I want to watch it or not....if I can't remember saying "clip" after taking Boyland to task over it, I am sure there are other parts I don't recall....and maybe don't want to
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: birdhunter on February 04, 2011, 12:48:06 AM
Does anyone know how else to see this program without access to Oceanic cable ?  I'm out of the country at the moment and am unable to pull it up on the Hawaii PBS site either..  Listening to everyone else I will say "Great Job HiCarry" !!  ;)      Thank you for fighting for our rights, it's much appreciated !!!   :shaka:
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 04, 2011, 12:49:14 AM
Considering the "fixed" deck, We think Hi Carry did very well.

Congratulations on a job well done.

Thanks! I had your Texas CHL stats out in case they wanted to try and say CHL holders were a problem....too bad I couldn't have caught them in another backpedaling moment...
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 04, 2011, 12:53:01 AM
Thank you HIcarry! Awesome!
They evaded and avoided, spouted opinion and outright lied, you prevailed with truth and fact.


I guess they didn't get the emails I sent in.  :P
Maybe he did, heh, I seen him flipping through those cards looking for the one question to bolster their view. No joy.   :rofl:

Oh, believe me he was skipping cards looking to avoid anything for me or from anyone too "pro-gun." I could partially see the cards as he reviewed them and when I realized what he was doing, I wanted to rattle his cage a little....that's when I corrected him on his "clip" reference and feigned indignation at such sloppy research as to not be able to use the correct terminology..... >:D
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: 2aHawaii on February 04, 2011, 04:04:06 AM
Does anyone know how else to see this program without access to Oceanic cable ?  I'm out of the country at the moment and am unable to pull it up on the Hawaii PBS site either..  Listening to everyone else I will say "Great Job HiCarry" !!  ;)      Thank you for fighting for our rights, it's much appreciated !!!   :shaka:

I wasn't able to catch it either and am anxiously awaiting watching it. From what I can tell, it should be up on the Insights webpage (http://www.kmeb.org/insights02.htm) whenever they get around to it.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Dregs on February 04, 2011, 06:07:34 AM
http://www.pbshawaii.org/ourproductions/insight.php (http://www.pbshawaii.org/ourproductions/insight.php)

Absolute bottom of page:

"If you miss the Thursday program, each week's episode is rebroadcast on Fridays at 9:30pm and Sundays at 3:00pm, and you can also listen to an audio rebroadcast each Sunday morning at 6:00AM on KUMU 94.7 FM. Insights on PBS Hawaii is also available on demand to Oceanic Time Warner digital subscribers by tuning to channel 110."

Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: 2asupport on February 04, 2011, 08:15:36 AM
Got this dvr'ed. Can't wait to see it when I get home.
I think it's online....not sure if I want to watch it or not....if I can't remember saying "clip" after taking Boyland to task over it, I am sure there are other parts I don't recall....and maybe don't want to

yeah, you did slip "clip" in there on accident, or was it negligence?  ???  j/k

Im all for loosening of the firearms laws here, but, the bigger priority is no new laws.  Im somewhat glad Kaneshiro made a point that he does not see a need for any new gun laws.  Is he county or state?  When talking about mag limits he said something along the lines of "(most) guns have a mag limit of 10 rounds, pistols...."  It made me think he believes rifle/pistol capable mags do not have a limit.

I really thought Kaneshiro was going to be the Alpha anti at the discussion, turns out it was Case....

Great job on your part Hicarry,  man, you do look alot different than your avatar pic :-\
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: kaneohegrown on February 04, 2011, 08:16:38 AM
Got this dvr'ed. Can't wait to see it when I get home.
I think it's online....not sure if I want to watch it or not....if I can't remember saying "clip" after taking Boyland to task over it, I am sure there are other parts I don't recall....and maybe don't want to

Yeah I caught that too... No worries though, the point of the correction was about how people who want to restrict a gun rights should be better versed on the subject. Case in point, when they kept talking about "assault weapons / military style weapons", and you let them have it that a 30-30 is much more "powerful" ballisticlly vs an AR-15/AK-47. As I said, I thought it was a well done job.

And big Mahalo to Chris for helping prep you for the interview. It deffinently showed just how well prepared you were for the subject compared to the other panelists...  :shaka:
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: 2asupport on February 04, 2011, 08:20:28 AM
Yes, a thanks to Funtimes too...  it would have been cool if you could have been there,  less of a mob more of a fair fight  :thumbsup:
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 04, 2011, 09:50:24 AM
Yes, a thanks to Funtimes too...  it would have been cool if you could have been there,  less of a mob more of a fair fight  :thumbsup:
Man, if Chris was there we really could have kicked butt....I think PBS thought Ed Case WAS pro-gun. After all his bio said he grew up on the Big Isle hunting.... :rofl:
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: 2aHawaii on February 04, 2011, 09:54:32 AM
It's up on PBS Hawaii (http://www.pbshawaii.org/ourproductions/insights_programs/insights20110203_gunctrl.htm)
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: 2aHawaii on February 04, 2011, 11:00:46 AM
I just watched it. HiCarry, you did a pretty good job there.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Funtimes on February 04, 2011, 01:23:55 PM
Yes, a thanks to Funtimes too...  it would have been cool if you could have been there,  less of a mob more of a fair fight  :thumbsup:
Man, if Chris was there we really could have kicked butt....I think PBS thought Ed Case WAS pro-gun. After all his bio said he grew up on the Big Isle hunting.... :rofl:

I would probably never get into Richardson Law then =P for arguing with the Dean on the constitution and scrutiny questions.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: 2aHawaii on February 04, 2011, 02:24:58 PM
I would probably never get into Richardson Law then =P for arguing with the Dean on the constitution and scrutiny questions.

In some schools that might help you get in.....probably not with Richardson :P
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: kaneohegrown on February 04, 2011, 02:28:51 PM
Lol just had to go back to the whole "proof of registration for ammunition purchases"... Keith's face just drops after he realizes what he's saying.... :crazy: Made my day that much brighter  :D
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Heavies on February 04, 2011, 02:59:20 PM
Quote
Lol just had to go back to the whole "proof of registration for ammunition purchases"... Keith's face just drops after he realizes what he's saying.... Made my day that much brighter

Yeah, that part he was saying about buglaries and BG getting guns and ammo. I was like, :wtf: 
So if the BG steal our stuff, the answers are to prohibit the good guys?
Also, when he was trying to argue the part about the police are obligated to protect you. Heh, he does even know his own law!
Mr. Kanashiro, how bout punishing the bad guys! What a dingbat!  ::)
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: 001s on February 04, 2011, 03:04:34 PM
I too just watched it and agree HiCarry did an excellent job!
Thank you...
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: ren on February 04, 2011, 08:02:49 PM
great job HiCarry
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 04, 2011, 08:03:27 PM
I just watched it. HiCarry, you did a pretty good job there.
Thanks! It was a team effort.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 04, 2011, 08:09:55 PM
Yes, a thanks to Funtimes too...  it would have been cool if you could have been there,  less of a mob more of a fair fight  :thumbsup:
Man, if Chris was there we really could have kicked butt....I think PBS thought Ed Case WAS pro-gun. After all his bio said he grew up on the Big Isle hunting.... :rofl:

I would probably never get into Richardson Law then =P for arguing with the Dean on the constitution and scrutiny questions.
Damn. Bad day to want to go to law school in Hawaii (vague "Airplane!" reference...)
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 04, 2011, 08:11:38 PM
I too just watched it and agree HiCarry did an excellent job!
Thank you...
Thanks!
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 04, 2011, 08:11:57 PM
great job HiCarry
Thank you
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: bushmasta55 on February 04, 2011, 11:28:45 PM
Just got done watching.  Good job HiCarry.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Dregs on February 05, 2011, 08:13:57 AM
I watched it real quick last night and I have to say WOW. Great job. One thing, Ed Case HATES confrontation. He's talking to the table and giving eye contact only to those that share his own view. The few times he gives you the same courtesy, he's physically leaning back lol. Not to mention he's the main "Umm"er and stutterer. Loved the uncomfortable stare you were giving him every time he talked. There was one question you asked him and he was about to go into stutter mode and talk to the table when someone else made a sound, and he looked absolutely relieved as he gestured to that person to continue talking. It was hilarious lol.
 
They started to grasp at straws near the middle after they started gettig impatient. Reeling in their line way too fast. Petty deflection. It was a weak display. Not a single word regarding CDC's results. Tossing your MLKJ & Gandi FACTS towards deception because they have no counters to it. Ignoring facts you've mentioned.

 I really wish you were able to say what you wanted to after Kaneshiro lied about how people will definitely go on shooting sprees over arguments if they're allowed to always carry guns. Unfortunately you were cut off. There was another one I wish you had a chance to say something but I forgot. Had to go to sleep O_o.

I think the Dean is the most dangerous one. The rest folded quick or after a while. He faltered but he didn't fold at all and he gives off the apeparance of considering both sides the most. He was the "quietest" one and he takes the time to think the most before he speaks. Example, Case would immediately try to provide an answer to something and immediately stall to think of an answer on the fly.

All in all it was a very entertaining watch of what we're up against! Thank you very much HICarry! The touchy-feely good-feelings crumble under the facts.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Funtimes on February 05, 2011, 08:21:19 AM
What is funny is I think we covered almost all the material they asked on the show =P.

Bill fed me some Big Kahunas (yum!) while I grilled him on gun questions :D it was a good time.   We will prepare harder, research further, and find their lies... debunk them, and provide our gun owners (and non-gun owners) the truth, so help me god =).
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Anubis on February 05, 2011, 10:04:11 AM
I viewed the program on the PBS website, and I must say, HiCarry, that you were the most articulate panel member, and the only one who could make a logical point.  You did an excellent job.

I live in Colorado and  visit Hawaii to see relatives, so I see Hawaii gun laws as horribly restrictive.  I was so impressed with the lack of rationality of Mr. Kaneshiro that I had to send him some comments.  I quickly found his office's website and, of course, they have no email address to receive comments.  That did not deter me from mailing my views to him.  Probably no one here is interested in the details of my letter, but I include it here just in case...

Mr. Keith Kaneshiro
The Department of the Prosecuting Attorney
City & County of Honolulu
1060 Richards Street
Honolulu, HI 96813

Sir:

I watched the February 3 PBS discussion of gun control.  I thank you for taking the time to participate in the program.

I am a resident of Colorado, which has gun laws much different from those of Hawaii, but I have relatives in Waimea which I visit, so I am keenly aware of the differences and was interested in the PBS program.

You made two points which appear to be mutually contradictory to me.  You stated that Hawaii state law allows the legal gun owner to possess firearms in his home for the practical purpose  of defense against intruders.  Therefore, armed self defense must be legal.  When commenting on being attacked outside the home, where the law-abiding citizen cannot be legally armed, you stated that calling for police assistance on a cell phone will give adequate protection from armed attack.  Even if the police arrive within 2 or 3 minutes, that is obviously not going to afford protection from events occurring within a few seconds.  So in this case, armed self defense is illegal.  One could just as well state that firearms in the home are unnecessary also, since one can make a 911 call from home.  Armed self defense should logically be either legal or illegal in all cases, not sometimes legal and other times illegal.

You also stated that if law-abiding citizens could carry concealed weapons, people would soon be shooting each other over trivial disagreements like who gets a parking space on the street.  Of course at that point they wouldn't be law-abiding citizens, would they?  The same argument has been advanced in every state that has enacted mandatory-issue of concealed firearm licenses, and has proven groundless every time.  We have had mandatory issue here in Colorado since 2003, with thousands of licenses issued, and there has not been a single instance where a concealed pistol licensee has used a weapon to commit a crime.  Even before 2003, anyone in Colorado who could legally own a pistol could carry it in their vehicle for self-defense, or carry it openly in most places, and there were no associated wild-west shootouts then.

The futility of gun control laws is simply that they restrict law-abiding citizens and have no effect on criminals.  I know that illegal gun possession in Hawaii incurs mandatory prison time, so I will never bring a firearm when I visit my relatives there, of course—I don't want my life wrecked, so the law works on me.  But a dealer of illegal drugs in Honolulu will not hesitate to carry an illegal pistol because additional jail time for gun possession is trivial compared to the length of his sentence if he is convicted for dealing illegal drugs.

Thanks for reading my comments.

[signed my real name]
Aurora, Colorado

Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 05, 2011, 05:35:43 PM
Just got done watching.  Good job HiCarry.
Thank you.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 05, 2011, 05:42:51 PM
I watched it real quick last night and I have to say WOW. Great job. One thing, Ed Case HATES confrontation. He's talking to the table and giving eye contact only to those that share his own view. The few times he gives you the same courtesy, he's physically leaning back lol. Not to mention he's the main "Umm"er and stutterer. Loved the uncomfortable stare you were giving him every time he talked. There was one question you asked him and he was about to go into stutter mode and talk to the table when someone else made a sound, and he looked absolutely relieved as he gestured to that person to continue talking. It was hilarious lol.
 
They started to grasp at straws near the middle after they started gettig impatient. Reeling in their line way too fast. Petty deflection. It was a weak display. Not a single word regarding CDC's results. Tossing your MLKJ & Gandi FACTS towards deception because they have no counters to it. Ignoring facts you've mentioned.

 I really wish you were able to say what you wanted to after Kaneshiro lied about how people will definitely go on shooting sprees over arguments if they're allowed to always carry guns. Unfortunately you were cut off. There was another one I wish you had a chance to say something but I forgot. Had to go to sleep O_o.

I think the Dean is the most dangerous one. The rest folded quick or after a while. He faltered but he didn't fold at all and he gives off the apeparance of considering both sides the most. He was the "quietest" one and he takes the time to think the most before he speaks. Example, Case would immediately try to provide an answer to something and immediately stall to think of an answer on the fly.

All in all it was a very entertaining watch of what we're up against! Thank you very much HICarry! The touchy-feely good-feelings crumble under the facts.
Thanks for the compliments. (and those from Anubis as well...) As you noted, there were several times issues were raised and "facts" were presented by the others but I was unable to rebut them because our moderator would either quickly move on or otherwise prevent me from speaking. One of the interesting things that came out was that the show received a very unsusally large amount of comments both before and during the show. Now, as far as I know, this would have to correlate with increased viewers, which is what all television programs want. So, what if we were to try to pressure PBS into doing another show, say just on concealed carry? This time we'd try to get Chris on (not sure if they're inclined to ask me back at this point... >:D) and continue this "public" discussioin....after all if Thursday's show is any indication, it would be watched by more folks than the show normally gets....
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Funtimes on February 05, 2011, 06:07:14 PM
lol I can only imagine how that would have went if I was there and Ken said "they could buy their own ammo".

I imagine something along the lines of "Are you seriously that ignorant?" would have slipped out.

I actually think that I would have loved to speak with the Dean.  I like really smart people, and he seems to be that way.  Ed brings the "feelings", kaneshiro was bringing political agenda, and the dean was willing to evaluate the legalities of stuff.  He would be my buddy, whether or not we agreed.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 06, 2011, 12:18:53 AM
lol I can only imagine how that would have went if I was there and Ken said "they could buy their own ammo".

I imagine something along the lines of "Are you seriously that ignorant?" would have slipped out.

I actually think that I would have loved to speak with the Dean.  I like really smart people, and he seems to be that way.  Ed brings the "feelings", kaneshiro was bringing political agenda, and the dean was willing to evaluate the legalities of stuff.  He would be my buddy, whether or not we agreed.

If it hadn't been on TV (all the associated nervousness) I think he would be the most fun to debate....he got me a little with flustered with the "arbitrary" issue, but I really would have loved to be able to have replied to the analogy of the yelling person versus concealed carry on campus. We could have gone the prior restraint argument and the minor little fact that there has never been a mass shooting at a school that allows concealed carry. And, to the best of my knowledge, no incidence of a CCW holder causing a problem.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Pugs_808 on February 06, 2011, 02:08:53 AM
Hi! I'm new to this forum and yesterday I just completed the mandatoy basic handgun course. I just finished watching that video clip and all I can say is "WoW!" HiCarry, you did a teriffic job in the debate! I felt very honored to have someone like you there fighting for us. Thank you very much!
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 06, 2011, 08:27:03 PM
Hi! I'm new to this forum and yesterday I just completed the mandatoy basic handgun course. I just finished watching that video clip and all I can say is "WoW!" HiCarry, you did a teriffic job in the debate! I felt very honored to have someone like you there fighting for us. Thank you very much!
Good job on the handgun course. Where did you take it?

Thanks for the compliments, but it wasn't just me. It was everyone from Chris who helped me prep, to the folks on the forum who provided some help witih research, and everyone else, rather they called, emailed, or "tweeted" in comments. That's exactly what this "movement" needs - cooperatation and collaboration and that's exactly what I saw. So, if you're "new" to shooting, get involved. If you're an old hand, you should have already been involved. And, if you need help or information, just ask - there's lots of smart and knowledgeable folks here, and in the shooting community in general, who will be happy to assist.

Aloha,
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: 808shooter on February 06, 2011, 08:40:15 PM
Just watched it from my DVR and all I can say is WOW, great job HiCarry. 

From day 1 of hearing about this program, I thought that it would be set up to make the pro-gun side look bad.  It just seemed like they underestimated you.  By the half-way point, you were the only one who seemed to have any conviction in their argument.  Everyone started backing off, and doing what so many politicians in HI do, which is sit on their high perch with a stink eye....  and that "go back to where you came from" attitude.  Maybe i'm biased, but it just seemed like they gave up making references towards the end and started making really short points, as if they realized that their "dog" in the fight wasn't *that* big of a deal.  I'm glad that this forum was opened up because again, it really seemed like they underestimated the discussion.  Maybe they didn't know there were/are law abiding citizens who wish to CCW and responsibly own firearms?


Again, good job.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Antithesis on February 06, 2011, 10:45:18 PM
Great Job Highcarry.  You really did the shooting community proud.  I think now would be a good time to strike while the metal is hot.  We should email Ed Case and possibly even Keith Kanashiro to say how disappointed we are with their Anti-gun position.  It might make him/them rethink being so vocally anti-gun if there is a strong backlash of his constituents voicing disapproval. 
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Old Guy on February 06, 2011, 10:53:55 PM
I am going to e mail PBS Hawaii and let them know that our family did not like the gun control program
   because we could see how Biased the program was and how the moderater skewed the questions.

Because of their open bias, I Do Not Support PBS.

Here is how to contact them:  http://www.pbshawaii.org/about/about_contactus.php (http://www.pbshawaii.org/about/about_contactus.php)

Those of us who aren't happy should make our voices heard and tell them Why we do Not Support PBS.

I Strongly suggest that as many of you send in Un Happy viewer ratings equalling No Support.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: 808shooter on February 06, 2011, 11:27:34 PM
I am going to e mail PBS Hawaii and let them know that our family did not like the gun control program
   because we could see how Biased the program was and how the moderater skewed the questions.

Because of their open bias, I Do Not Support PBS.

Here is how to contact them:  http://www.pbshawaii.org/about/about_contactus.php (http://www.pbshawaii.org/about/about_contactus.php)

Those of us who aren't happy should make our voices heard and tell them Why we do Not Support PBS.

I Strongly suggest that as many of you send in Un Happy viewer ratings equalling No Support.

Sorry but I respectfully disagree.  I think these forums/shows are exactly what we pro-gun people need to get the agenda out.  I think that the more reasonable people start thinking about the fact that HPD 99% of the time will NOT be there in time to stop a 30 second homicide, the more people will accept CCW.  IMHO, getting those domestic violence victims CCW permits are the only way to start this frame of mind. 

I noticed that when the subject started with HPD response time and whether HPD would get to a homicide to "protect" you from getting killed, the subject got squashed and the conversation was changed into a new direction.  We need to get politicians and the public to keep names like Tupuola front of mind.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 07, 2011, 01:32:59 AM
I am going to e mail PBS Hawaii and let them know that our family did not like the gun control program
   because we could see how Biased the program was and how the moderater skewed the questions.

Because of their open bias, I Do Not Support PBS.

Here is how to contact them:  http://www.pbshawaii.org/about/about_contactus.php (http://www.pbshawaii.org/about/about_contactus.php)

Those of us who aren't happy should make our voices heard and tell them Why we do Not Support PBS.

I Strongly suggest that as many of you send in Un Happy viewer ratings equalling No Support.

First, thank you, 808Shooter and Antithesis. OG, I agree and disagree....let them know the bias was obvious, but that you're interested in hearing more about the issues. Suggest that as a way to make up for such a lopsided and biased show, they should do another one, more balanced, about concealed carry in Hawaii.

While we want them to know that we caught onto what was happening, we also want them to know that there are rational, intelligent (sort of the population PBS "goes" for..) and successful individuals on this side of the argument and that, like voting, we also contribute to the charities and issues we support: PBS could be a beneficiary of that financial support if they were a little more fair and balanced (purposeful Fox News reference....)
Title: support
Post by: Old Guy on February 07, 2011, 02:58:18 PM
Sorry if you misunderstood what I was trying to get across.

Hi Carry said what I meant.

Because of open bias, we did not like the program.

If it were Fair and Balanced we would be supportive ($)   of PBS. 

But, since their programs are Un fair and Biased as we see it, they  get no support from us.

Why should we support organizations/agencies that are openly "against" our beliefs?

Example is  Aloha United Way.  It or many of the organizations in it have Anti 2A platforms.
   As a result, We Do NOT contribute to Aloha United Way.

What we do is to contribute to organizations such as the Boy Scouts Directly. 
   There by cutting out The United Way from getting a small piece of the pie.

Hope this makes things clearer.
 
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: tuor on February 07, 2011, 08:59:10 PM
I just went through some of the episode.  You did a great job HiCarry!  You were calm, polished, well prepared and most of all an excellent representative of our community. 

As for Mr. Case; I saw what the others did.  A politician in the same vein as the current President; no substance.  Emotion not to be hindered by fact.  By the way, we're not an Eastern culture despite how many Asians like myself reside here.  If he thinks Japan is the way it is because of their gun laws - let's just say we don't have as many instances of someone stabbing to death their entire family because they lost a business contract or something, and we'd like to keep it that way.  Shame works there - shame isn't stopping a jealous ex or a crackhead bent on carrying out his or her paranoid delusions here.

As for Mr. Kaneshiro;  I wonder if HE has to call 911 if someone he helped put in jail were right outside his door or coming for him while he is walking to his car at night.  No? WHY IS THAT?   He couldn't even address Warren vs. D.C.  and kept going for the more guns = more guns in criminals hands fallacy.  Just say it Mr. Kaneshiro; you think us locals can't be trusted and that you know what's best for us.

Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Funtimes on February 07, 2011, 09:04:34 PM
I just went through some of the episode.  You did a great job HiCarry!  You were calm, polished, well prepared and most of all an excellent representative of our community. 

As for Mr. Case; I saw what the others did.  A politician in the same vein as the current President; no substance.  Emotion not to be hindered by fact.  By the way, we're not an Eastern culture despite how many Asians like myself reside here.  If he thinks Japan is the way it is because of their gun laws - let's just say we don't have as many instances of someone stabbing to death their entire family because they lost a business contract or something, and we'd like to keep it that way.  Shame works there - shame isn't stopping a jealous ex or a crackhead bent on carrying out his or her paranoid delusions here.

As for Mr. Kaneshiro;  I wonder if HE has to call 911 if someone he helped put in jail were right outside his door or coming for him while he is walking to his car at night.  No? WHY IS THAT?   He couldn't even address Warren vs. D.C.  and kept going for the more guns = more guns in criminals hands fallacy.  Just say it Mr. Kaneshiro; you think us locals can't be trusted and that you know what's best for us.

I can't wait till locals can't carry and tourists can, there will be a *HUGE* uproar.  Which will be good, because it bring the issue right to the frong lines of battle.  I bet a dinner out, by the end of this year most of the nation has reciprocity via the Thune Amendment.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Old Guy on February 08, 2011, 04:40:50 AM
As I understand it,  Kaneshiro and members of his staff can carry concealed with the blessings of HPD.

There are requirements.

So can Judges and members of the Hawaii AG's office.

They can carry under different rules from us regular citizens.

Of so I've been told.  There may have been a newspaper article about this.

If I knew where I saw, I'd reference it.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: tuor on February 08, 2011, 06:52:01 AM
If that is true that only certain "privileged" members of society can CCW here in Hawaii - then I blame a complicit media for the fact that most people probably don't know about it.  Although I expect a certain portion of the population here to feel like they can't trust themselves with anything more than a butter knife (and therefore no one else can be trusted),  I don't think that would fly with most people.   
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Funtimes on February 08, 2011, 02:38:12 PM
As I understand it,  Kaneshiro and members of his staff can carry concealed with the blessings of HPD.

There are requirements.

So can Judges and members of the Hawaii AG's office.

They can carry under different rules from us regular citizens.

Of so I've been told.  There may have been a newspaper article about this.

If I knew where I saw, I'd reference it.

We have yet to find anything in the statutes that would authorize this. Not saying it doesn't happen, we have a firm and strong belief that it does. We can only find this type of stuff in discovery.

If that is true that only certain "privileged" members of society can CCW here in Hawaii - then I blame a complicit media for the fact that most people probably don't know about it.  Although I expect a certain portion of the population here to feel like they can't trust themselves with anything more than a butter knife (and therefore no one else can be trusted),  I don't think that would fly with most people.

Certainly doesn't fly with me :P.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: kaneohegrown on February 08, 2011, 03:42:37 PM
If I recall, the only non "judicial / LE" concealed carry permit being issued was to Cayetano and his wife. I think that flew for like 2 days or something, the public then found out and police chief immediatly revoked the permits. Was a while back, but I remember it being big news, even though I was still in HS at the time...
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 09, 2011, 12:14:06 AM
Tuor - Thanks.

While I have no other proof other than what I saw, I believe that there are members of the Judiciary that have been granted a CCW, although I do not know if it was thru the "normal" channels and hence has a paper trail for discovery purposes. I know I saw a group of individuals at the KKSC where they (who did not look like LE and who I was told were judges) were going thru some live fire exercises. I was told they were getting concealed carry permits and this was their class for that.

Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Heavies on February 09, 2011, 01:41:23 PM
Quote
While I have no other proof other than what I saw, I believe that there are members of the Judiciary that have been granted a CCW, although I do not know if it was thru the "normal" channels and hence has a paper trail for discovery purposes. I know I saw a group of individuals at the KKSC where they (who did not look like LE and who I was told were judges) were going thru some live fire exercises. I was told they were getting concealed carry permits and this was their class for that.

That's messed up! If they are not LE or military doing duty, then they would have to have had been issued permits by the chief. If they did not go through, 'normal' channels they are carrying illegal.
Therefore, there has to be a paper trail or something. Right?
Class for CCW? Where is the requirements?
This needs investigation.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: Anubis on February 26, 2011, 01:07:55 PM
Today I was surprised to receive a letter from Mr. Kaneshiro replying to my letter quoted in post #64 of this thread.

Kaneshiro: "To clarify statements made on the program and to address the points made in the first major paragraph of your letter, in Hawaii it [bold]is legal[/bold] for a gun owner to keep a registered, legal firearm in his or her home of place of business [sic].  The definition of "home" would also include the person's front yard,  or property.  Therefore, the use of a registered firearm in one's own front yard in defense during a threatening situation is a legal use of a firearm under Hawaii law."

Of course this ignores about 3/4 of what I stated in the said paragraph.  Another example of the futility of attempting to use logic on an anti.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: tundah on February 27, 2011, 12:02:27 PM
All I gotta say is that I'm in total awe of the job HiCarry did on that bunch of mossbacked authoritarians.  :worship:

To HiCarry:
Most gratifying for me was the smug look you wiped off Boylans face when you answered his selected viewer question about how Gandhi and MLK would feel about the discussion, the best response anyone could muster was Case stammering out how he thought that was a set-up... priceless.  :rofl: To quote Mortal Combat parlance; Flawless victory! Thanks for being a classy and eloquent spokesman for our cause, I'm glad you're on our side.
Title: Re: PBS "Insights" doing firearms discussion
Post by: HiCarry on February 28, 2011, 10:17:45 AM
Anubis - Yeah, the classical avoid the issue tact...I want to ask him about the premise he promoted thatt the police have an obligation to protect individuals. What I found most disappointing was the fact that the law school dean did not jump in to correct Mr. Kaneshiro. It is, IMHO, a travesty that an educator, especiually of his caliber, could sit by and let someone promote something that he knew, or should have known, was incorrect. I guess he was more interested in his personal agenda rather that the truth.

tundah - Thanks. And, I think I have said it before, that wasn't a set up....I have offered to but the person that sent in that question a beer (or other beverage of their choice...)  :shaka: