2aHawaii
General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: gordo514 on November 04, 2013, 08:23:36 PM
-
Hi all-
I am preparing to expand my C&R collection and wanted to know the proper paperwork maze I need to navigate in order to make my purchases lawful. I am a 03 FFL holder and have updated the license to my new address on Oahu. If I purchase a Mosin online from an out of state source and have it shipped to my home, can I consider it an out of state purchase? Does it apply to pistols as well?
Thanks in advance for the help!
-
I never get a clear on pistols....but long as you update the batf with your addrss change you should be okay. I wanted to bring in a walther p38 and a older six shooter but hpd never gave me a clear answer. I would assume its similar to long rifle c&r but I'm not willing to risk it yet till I get a hpd answer
-
.
-
Q should know. He went thru the HPD and ATF wringer
-
No.
As long as your record indicates that your ffl address is on Oahu, and you order online and have it shipped here, it will be considered a local purchase, and will fall under the same regulations for local pistol purchases: permit tom acquire, 2 week waiting period, etc. HPD is cracking down on people trying to circumvent the system, so don't try and be slick and pretend its an out of state purchase, because they will check which state it came from and know which states do not allow such purchases. Also, the firearms admin makes daily calls to the local ATF to check on things they find suspicious, so unless you have got your ffl regulations and letters from the assistant director on lock down to prove what you want to do is legal, you are going to get screwed big time.
The only way for this not to happen is if you physically purchase the firearm out of state.
Edit: long guns are fine, as long as you have a permit to acquire; it is still considered an in-state purchase.
that's weird, i was looking into getting my C&R and called HPD to ask about buying a c&r handgun. the woman told me that i wouldn't need a handgun permit to acquire or anything to order a curio handgun, specifically a CZ-82. if i remember correctly i think she also said something about not having to register it.
so i actually would have to get a permit to acquire with a 2 week wait and then register it?
-
.
-
That woman is wrong. Show up to the window with a pistol that has not been approved for purchase with a permit to acquire, and you are setting yourself up for problems, as well as have them further hone in on C&R licensees. Because you are 'ordering' online, you are still having the pistol sent to your local address. Anything coming into Hawaii via your FFL license is considered an in-state purchase, which subjects it to local pistol regulations. The only time this is not applied is if you are not buying a pistol for your own personal use or collection, in which case you can just fax in the papers. However, because you are an 03/C&R, this is for personal ownership, and thus subject to the same laws as everyone else.
Save yourself the heartache and listen to me. I've already danced to this tune with the top people at HPD.
So, does that mean you have to apply for the permit and wait the 2 weeks BEFORE the pistol is in your hands, or are you allowed to store it at home during the waiting period? Obvious answer would be "who would know the difference?"
Also, what documents are needed when you bring a C&R pistol or rifle to register? Anything other than the 03 FFL, permit to acquire, and ID? Invoice or sellers information?
Mahalo!
-
Take the C&R booklet that says your firearm qualifies with you in case you run into problems.
-
You can buy any firearm listed as a c&r and have it shipped directly to you. That includes c&r pistols. All you have to bring your paperwork, ffl, and firearm and let HPD know that it is a c&r purchase.
-
.
-
Thanks for all the replies and information! Sounds like a long gun shouldn't be too hard, so long as you already have the permit to acquire. Once I have the firearm shipped to my home, I need to bring the following to HPD to register it:
Unloaded, cased weapon
Permit to acquire (general long gun or individually issued pistol)
FFL
C&R book
Shipping slip/receipt of purchase
From the above replies, I also see that a C&R-eligible 12 round CZ-82 pistol would be denied a permit to acquire, since it exceeds Hawaii's 10 round handgun magazine limit. Guess I'll have to keep that on the backburner for now
Thanks again for the help. :thumbsup: I have spent the last few years in Florida and Texas, so all these regulations are new to me.
-
Figured I'd ask this question since this seems to be a good venue. What do you do if you want to register a C&R firearm that meets the current ATF standard for C&R, but isn't in the book (which hasn't been updated in over 4 years)? My dad has an old Sears & Roebuck 22LR long rifle (pre-1968, older than 50 years old) that I would like to have, we both have 03FFL's so he can ship direct to me. However, that rifle is not in the C&R book although it meets the rolling 50 years C&R rule.
-
.
-
.
-
Q,
Thanks for the reply. For documentation I will have to investigate, this rifle was bought by my great-grandparents back in early 1960's so original paperwork is out of the question. I also don't think the rifle has a serial number, which wasn't a requirement pre-1968 GCA. If I have to get a serial added its not worth it to me.
-
So, does that mean you have to apply for the permit and wait the 2 weeks BEFORE the pistol is in your hands
Yes: that means you need to contact the seller, obtain the pistol info, then head to HPD and request a permit to acquire just like any other pistol.
What happens after you obtain the C&R pistol permit but in the few days it's valid for there are problems in shipment (e.g., seller delays shipment, shipment is delayed by carrier, etc.). You then receive and log the C&R pistol but your permit is no longer valid?
-
My experience with HPD and C&R pistols, two now, has been pretty straight forward. Circuitous, but workable. This is unless something has changed.
My package to the thought proof bullet proof window has been:
A current permit to acquire always a long gun permit, but current
A signed copy of your C&R, They will keep it.
*A copy of the page from the ATF book with the piece high lited, and /or I guess that proof of more than 50 years old. I suggest a copy of the page that states that 50 yrs or more is legit.
A copy or original of the receipt from the supplier
The piece of course, properly packaged, hard case.
Other than that do the paper work and it it is treated like a bring in from out of state. Just do it within the required time 72hrs?
* Yes this is outdated 2007 or so. Work with your supplier on this.
You can order without a magazine and get a legal one through the aftermarket. With both of mine this was not an issue.
-
.
-
Q,
I probably neglected to mention, but the rifle is in California. The rifle would be "given" to me, but since interstate familial transfers have to go through an FFL regardless (and both me and my dad have our own 03 FFL licenses) it would be the same as if I purchased a C&R through any standard retail establishment. At this point it would seem easier to have my dad transfer the rifle to OGC or Ready on the Right and do the FFL transfer that way, avoiding the entire C&R process entirely. Just proves the point behind Hawaii's convoluted registration process-to make things as humanly difficult as possible.
-
.
-
The problem as I see it is the documentation that the rifle is 50 years old. I don't know how stringent HPD's requirements are on that for proof. In order to avoid that issue I could do the transfer through the 01 FFL, but as you said that entails the transfer fee and totally negates the purpose behind the C&R license.
I would love to see some legislation that added C&R firearms to HI registration exemption list. But then again I wish the whole thing went away, so if the gun control groups can use incrementalism, so can we! :shaka:
-
.
-
The problem as I see it is the documentation that the rifle is 50 years old. I don't know how stringent HPD's requirements are on that for proof. In order to avoid that issue I could do the transfer through the 01 FFL, but as you said that entails the transfer fee and totally negates the purpose behind the C&R license.
I would love to see some legislation that added C&R firearms to HI registration exemption list. But then again I wish the whole thing went away, so if the gun control groups can use incrementalism, so can we! :shaka:
I would write a letter to the firearm company. It will take some time, but it might help with registration if HPD balks at whatever else you can find via Google. It might also be of interest to you or another collector if you sell it.
Send as much info as you can: model name/numbers, any graphics, engravings, etc., and vital statistics: barrel length, overall length, caliber, magazine capacity, finish, part numbers, .... Include pictures of all sides, close-ups of identifying characteristics, and any other images you think would be useful.
If the company gets enough information along with sharp, good quality photos, they may be able to issue you a letter stating year of manufacture among other interesting facts.
You never know. It's worth a shot. You might find it has a history you never knew about. :shaka:
GL!
-
Yes: that means you need to contact the seller, obtain the pistol info, then head to HPD and request a permit to acquire just like any other pistol.
As for documents, you will need your 03FFL, the shipping / delivery receipt, a copy of the page which lists the firearm in the C&R booklet, and other standard paperwork for pistols. This is why you can't just ship it to yourself and then apply, because they will know exactly when you received the firearm.
When did HPD adopt this policy in regards to C&R pistols? This is news to me.
-
.
-
I have never understood the logic behind the requirement to have HPD visually inspect the firearm for registration, at least for purchases from a dealer. Even in the gun control paradise of California all pistol registration is done at the point of sale, no visit to the police, no paperwork. HPD already requires the dealer to fax over the firearm information, information that is legally binding. You would think that would be enough, but another duplicative level of bureaucracy MUST be created.
It would be really nice if HPD got with the program like the other county police departments and at least allowed registration to occur at ALL police stations. If resource-strapped places like Maui, Big Island, and Kauai can do it, why can't Oahu?
-
Ok, just so that I'm straight on the procedure for acquiring C&R handguns and long guns, my understanding is that the following procedure applies:
C&R handguns
1. Obtain handgun info from online C&R seller
2. Apply for Handgun permit from HPD;
3. Acquire C&R Handgun from online C&R Seller once permit has been approved by HPD
4. Bring all your crap down to HPD to register the C&R handgun within 72 hours of receiving same.
C&R Long Guns
1. Acquire C&R Long gun from online C&R seller
2. Bring all your crap down to HPD to register the C&R long gun inside of 72 hours of receiving same.
Does this sounds right?
-
.
-
Sweet. Thanks for all the help! Should help streamline the process as much as possible
-
I understand that you can write to BATFE for a determination of whether a particular firearm is C&R if it doesn't appear in its list but short of that, how would you establish that a firearm is a curio or relic if the documents provided by the seller do not establish the manufactured date? The BATFE C&R lists my rifle but specifies a S/N range that my rifle falls outside of. I know my rifle was manufactured in 1937 and that the last production date is 1958 so my rifle qualifies as C & R. I chanced the registeration with HPD yesterday just to see what HPD would say. HPD declined the registration and said it was my burden to establish that the rifle is C&R (which was expected) and asked me for verification of the manufacture date. HPD refused to tell me what would satisfy their concern short of a letter from BATFE but then started asking me for copies of the seller's invoice hoping that it would show the date, printouts from websites establishing the date and other possible sources of information. HPD indicated in so many words that all they are interested in is papering their file to justify the registration.
-
I understand that you can write to BATFE for a determination of whether a particular firearm is C&R if it doesn't appear in its list but short of that, how would you establish that a firearm is a curio or relic if the documents provided by the seller do not establish the manufactured date? The BATFE C&R lists my rifle but specifies a S/N range that my rifle falls outside of. I know my rifle was manufactured in 1937 and that the last production date is 1958 so my rifle qualifies as C & R. I chanced the registeration with HPD yesterday just to see what HPD would say. HPD declined the registration and said it was my burden to establish that the rifle is C&R (which was expected) and asked me for verification of the manufacture date. HPD refused to tell me what would satisfy their concern short of a letter from BATFE but then started asking me for copies of the seller's invoice hoping that it would show the date, printouts from websites establishing the date and other possible sources of information. HPD indicated in so many words that all they are interested in is papering their file to justify the registration.
As I stated earlier here, the firearm manufacturer can often provide written documentation that their product was produced in a certain year/date range. It may be quicker to go that route than the government path (BATFE).
Enjoy the paper chase!!
-
The only problem with getting information from the manufacturer for firearms 50+ years old is that the company itself might be long since out of business, and any potential successor company might not have those records available. That is the problem I am running into.
-
Anybody here know the phone number for Waffenfabrik Bern in Switzerland and can speak Swiss? ;D
-
Farknocker, are you trying to register a Swiss K31? I thought that was in the C&R list....
Love my K31, but ammo is hard to fine here in Hawaii. Only shop that I know of that carries ammo for it is WGS, and he's been out nearly all year. They are supposed to be getting a big shipment in a few weeks.
-
Anybody here know the phone number for Waffenfabrik Bern in Switzerland and can speak Swiss? ;D
Waffenfabrik Bern (English: Weapon Factory Bern), also known as W+F Bern, was an arms manufacturer in Bern, Switzerland and was a government-owned corporation.
https://www.facebook.com/pages/Waffenfabrik-Bern/103119476394363# (https://www.facebook.com/pages/Waffenfabrik-Bern/103119476394363#)
:(
-
Farknocker, are you trying to register a Swiss K31? I thought that was in the C&R list....
Love my K31, but ammo is hard to fine here in Hawaii. Only shop that I know of that carries ammo for it is WGS, and he's been out nearly all year. They are supposed to be getting a big shipment in a few weeks.
US Dept. of Justice, BATFE Firearms Curios or Relics List (2007 ed.) lists a "Swiss Schmidt Rubin, Model 1931/55 rifles, cal. 7.5mm, S/Ns 1001 to 5150". The supplments to the list (found on the BATFE's website) make no mention of the K31.
Funny thing is, I have yet to find anything on the web which suggests that rifles bearing S/Ns 1001 through 5150 exists.
See:
http://candrsenal.com/rifle-swiss-karabiner-1931/ (http://candrsenal.com/rifle-swiss-karabiner-1931/)
http://oldmilitarymarkings.com/schmidt_rubin.html#manufacture (http://oldmilitarymarkings.com/schmidt_rubin.html#manufacture)
-
Huh, weird that it would have the serial number limitation. The Model 31/55 would be correct for a K31, which is just the common designator here in the US for the rifle. I got mine through AIM Surplus and had Al Mongeon do the transfer, so I didn't deal with the C&R side of the registration.
-
What's weirder is that there doesn't appear to be K31 bearing the S/Ns mentioned in the list.
-
.
-
I was successful at registering a C&R Long Gun that did not appear on the BATFE 2007 Ed. of the Firearms Curio or Relics List (or any existing supplement for that matter) this morning.
This is what I presented to HPD:
1. Hawaii Drivers License;
2. Long gun permit;
3. Signed copy of my C&R FFL Permit;
4. Original bound Firearms C or R List (to show that long gun is listed but not in the specified S/N range);
5. Copy of the sales invoice from the online seller which shows it's name and address as well as the manufacturer and importer of the firearm, it's year of manufacture, S/N, Model and Caliber;
6. Entire copies of the webpages taken from the links I posted previously. The webpages show the serial numbers of the rifles produced and the year of manufacturer. Both webpages corroborated the manufactured year; and
7. A copy of 27 CFR Sec. 478.11 (applicable section defining C & R to include firearms "manufactured at least 50 years prior to the current date, but not including replicas thereof;").
HPD returned all of the documents to me except my signed copy of the C&R FFL Permit because I told them they could keep it. Note, when you purchase C&R firearms and provide the seller with a copy of the permit, you make a copy of the original permit and you sign the copy. The signed copy is then used. The original permit should remain unexecuted so that unsigned copies may be generated for later use.
The officers were cool and the whole process took 30 min.
-
I was reading through this old thread trying to find an answer regarding purchasing C&R handguns online and some say no problem, just take it to HPD and register it, while others have responded that you have to apply for your permit to acquire FIRST before receiving the gun.
Please, I need to know! ready everyone........ok go!
:shaka:
-
I was reading through this old thread trying to find an answer regarding purchasing C&R handguns online and some say no problem, just take it to HPD and register it, while others have responded that you have to apply for your permit to acquire FIRST before receiving the gun.
Please, I need to know! ready everyone........ok go!
:shaka:
The reason for the C&R is so you can purchase it online and receive directly in the mail. Then take it to HPD and register it. Without your C&R FFL you cannot legally receive it directly. And the seller would be in violation of the law if they sent it directly to you without having a copy of your C&R FFL on file.
-
Inspector,
I have a FFL 03 license, and a long gun permit to acquire so I can have long guns shipped directly to my home. What about handguns though?
Do I have to apply for a handgun permit to acquire first? I think the C&R dealers will UPS me handguns as long as I am have my FFL 03 license, but what happens when I go to HPD to register it?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Inspector,
I have a FFL 03 license, and a long gun permit to acquire so I can have long guns shipped directly to my home. What about handguns though?
Do I have to apply for a handgun permit to acquire first? I think the C&R dealers will UPS me handguns as long as I am have my FFL 03 license, but what happens when I go to HPD to register it?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sorry, misread your question. As far as long guns are concerned, your golden. But for handguns, you will have to take a class and pass the test and earn your certificate. Once you have your certificate you then have to go down and get the handgun permit. Once you have that you are good to go with C&R handguns. Just order the handgun and then take it down to HPD after it arrives at your front door.
-
Okay, I'll bite. Where's a good place to look for some curios? :shaka:
-
Okay, I'll bite. Where's a good place to look for some curios? :shaka:
Here is a website that lists most of the C&R deals but not all of them. But at least it tells you which websites are selling C&R guns.
https://www.slickguns.com/cr-deals
Best thing to do in my opinion is to go out to each website referenced at Slick Guns and see what they have for sale. I have dealt with most of them and can say they are pretty good to deal with. Oh, Sarco at e-Sarco.com is an interesting place. Some people refuse to buy anything from them but I found them to be pretty good. There used to be a place called Samco but they went out of business. They had a huge inventory at great prices. Too bad they went under. Aim Surplus is a little higher priced but usually have good to excellent guns so it may be worth paying a little extra.
I am not an expert by any means. So I know there are more places. For instance Firearms News (The old Shotgun News) will have a place or two you won't find in Google unless you dig really deep. And my black powder buddies all have their fav websites which mostly sell antique arms which does not require a C&R but if you watch them they sometimes get some C&R deals. And then there is Century Arms. You can't get into most of their website until you send them your C&R. But once you log in there are literally hundreds of C&R guns and parts you can buy. Some names I recognize from the thread about guns you would never buy again. Like Lorcin, Raven, etc.
-
Unless there are new rules, you DO NOT need the training affidavit NOR the handgun permit to register a C&R qualified handgun.
Please see this thread for details. It's pretty straight forward.
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=17226.msg158387#msg158387
-
Unless there are new rules, you DO NOT need the training affidavit NOR the handgun permit to register a C&R qualified handgun.
Please see this thread for details. It's pretty straight forward.
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=17226.msg158387#msg158387
That's interesting because every time I have gone to register a long gun and/or hand gun HPD asked for my appropriate permit(s). Why do you think they did this?
-
That's interesting because every time I have gone to register a long gun and/or hand gun HPD asked for my appropriate permit(s). Why do you think they did this?
Did you acquire from out of state?
-
Did you acquire from out of state?
Yes. Does that make a difference?
As a matter of fact the oriental officer who is big on the C&R guns challenged me one day saying that the place I bought the gun from does not sell C&R guns. Then proceeded to go out to their website and found out otherwise.
-
Yes. Does that make a difference?
The C&R FFL protects intrastate commerce. The state can't interfere with your purchases from out of state. The Hawaii pistol permit is called "PERMIT TO ACQUIRE." You are already cleared to acquire, else you could not receive in the mail directly, right?
If you buy locally, then you might as well save the hassle of listing that C&R in your collection. Just do the normal permit and wait thing. Selling later will be much easier if it's not under your C&R license. Still have to enter it in your C&R book, but it doesn't flag you as a business by the ATF if you try selling a few C&R guns at once..
When I called HPD, they told me no training affidavit and no handgun permit. They only need the long gun permit to show you had a background check.
Like I said, it might change, but this is how I did it before.
-
The C&R FFL protects intrastate commerce. The state can't interfere with your purchases from out of state. The Hawaii pistol permit is called "PERMIT TO ACQUIRE." You are already cleared to acquire, else you could not receive in the mail directly, right?
If you buy locally, then you might as well save the hassle of listing that C&R in your collection. Just do the normal permit and wait thing. Selling later will be much easier if it's not under your C&R license. Still have to enter it in your C&R book, but it doesn't flag you as a business by the ATF if you try selling a few C&R guns at once..
When I called HPD, they told me no training affidavit and no handgun permit. They only need the long gun permit to show you had a background check.
Like I said, it might change, but this is how I did it before.
K Thanks!!!
-
Yes. Does that make a difference?
As a matter of fact the oriental officer who is big on the C&R guns challenged me one day saying that the place I bought the gun from does not sell C&R guns. Then proceeded to go out to their website and found out otherwise.
That is a totally irrelevant challenge. As a collector, you are considered a licensee, and anyone, FFL or not, can ship to you as long as they follow the laws about delivery address, carriers and markings.
As long as the seller gave you all their correct information, that's all that's required. HPD can't require you to only buy from other collectors. That's just stupid beyond any rational argument!
May a nonlicensee ship a firearm by common or contract carrier?
A nonlicensee may ship a firearm by a common or contract carrier to a resident of his or her or her own State or to a licensee in any State. A common or contract carrier must be used to ship a handgun. In addition, Federal law requires that the carrier be notified that the shipment contains a firearm or ammunition, prohibits common or contract carriers from requiring or causing any label to be placed on any package indicating that it contains a firearm and requires obtaining written acknowledgement of receipt.
[18 U.S.C. 922(a)(2)(A), 922(a)(5), 922(e) and (f); 27 CFR 478.30 and 478.31]
https://www.atf.gov/firearms/qa/may-nonlicensee-ship-firearm-common-or-contract-carrier
May a nonlicensee ship a firearm through the U.S. Postal Service?
A nonlicensee may not transfer a firearm to a non-licensed resident of another State. A nonlicensee may mail a shotgun or rifle to a resident of his or her own State or to a licensee in any State. The Postal Service recommends that long guns be sent by registered mail and that no marking of any kind which would indicate the nature of the contents be placed on the outside of any parcel containing firearms. Handguns are not mailable. A common or contract carrier must be used to ship a handgun.
[18 U.S.C. 1715, 922(a)(5) and 922 (a)(2)(A); 27 CFR 478.31]
https://www.atf.gov/firearms/qa/may-nonlicensee-ship-firearm-through-us-postal-service
To whom may an unlicensed person transfer firearms under the GCA?
A person may transfer a firearm to an unlicensed resident of his or her State, provided the transferor does not know or have reasonable cause to believe the transferee is prohibited from receiving or possessing firearms under Federal law. There may be State laws that regulate intrastate firearm transactions. A person considering transferring a firearm should contact his or her State Attorney General’s Office to inquire about the laws and possible State or local restrictions.
Generally, for a person to lawfully transfer a firearm to an unlicensed person who resides out of State, the firearm must be shipped to a Federal firearms licensee (FFL) within the transferee’s State of residence. The transferee may then receive the firearm from the FFL upon completion of an ATF Form 4473 and a NICS background check.
A person may loan or rent a firearm to a resident of any State for temporary use for lawful sporting purposes, if he or she or she does not know or have reasonable cause to believe the person is prohibited from receiving or possessing firearms under Federal law. Another exception is provided for transfers of firearms to nonresidents to carry out a lawful bequest or acquisition by intestate succession. This exception would authorize the transfer of a firearm to a nonresident who inherits a firearm under the will of a decedent.
A person may transfer a firearm to a licensee in any State. However, a firearm other than a curio or relic may not be transferred interstate to a licensed collector.
[18 U.S.C 922(a)(5) and 922(d); 27 CFR 478.30, 478.32]
https://www.atf.gov/firearms/qa/whom-may-unlicensed-person-transfer-firearms-under-gca