2aHawaii

General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: beekeeping1341 on January 01, 2015, 07:52:44 AM

Title: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: beekeeping1341 on January 01, 2015, 07:52:44 AM
This is my first post as a member here, and any forum period so bear with me here lol. I am strongly considering building my own ar with top of the line parts but would I be better of just getting a complete rifle lime a noveske? I was planning on using a noveske barrel and bcg anyways. If it helps at all the build I'm planning is running around 2600 bucks, sans optics...so far ;) are bullpups even seriously worth considering? I'm attracted to the idea of bullpups but most are pretty pricy and have shitty triggers that you'll need to upgrade anyways. I appreciate Amy of your thoughts/ ideas. Oh and my rifle is going to be for shtf, and anything else it needs to be for. Thoughts on 6.8 spc would be great too
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: Paul96734 on January 01, 2015, 08:00:58 AM
Welcome to the forum.

Please check out this older thread as it may answer some of your questions:

https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=13986.0
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: TastesLikeMetal on January 01, 2015, 08:37:19 AM
Welcome to the forums, if it's for shtf have you considered training your bee's to attack humans...  That would be badass :thumbsup: :stopjack:
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: ren on January 01, 2015, 09:32:43 AM
Welcome to the forums, if it's for shtf have you considered training your bee's to attack humans...  That would be badass :thumbsup: :stopjack:

(http://oldcatholic.us/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/swarm-of-bees.jpg)
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: edster48 on January 01, 2015, 10:06:31 AM
Welcome to 2A!
As you can see from some of the early responses we're kind of crazy here, but in a fun way. Don't worry, the guys start to grow on you { kind of like that fungus your doctor warned you about }.    >:D

As to your question, it depends on a few things.

Do you have some basic mechanical skills?

Are you willing to invest in the tools needed to accomplish the build?

Do you have the patience to work through the fitment and function issues that will arise?

If you answered "yes" to all these questions, building your own AR could be for you!

I built my own, with some help from my son, an experienced armorer, and I chose mostly Noveske myself. I went with a Rainier Arms barrel and Nib bcg. Also a CMC 3.5 lb. trigger. I saved a buttload of money compared to purchasing a complete Noveske rifle and it shoots great. With a $2,600 budget you should be able to build an awesome rifle! I spent about half that on mine. Good luck on your build, look forward to seeing it!

Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: dafrtknocker on January 01, 2015, 10:07:25 AM
Do both, buy a cheap AR, then build your 'Dream Gun', because you always need a backup.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: oldfart on January 01, 2015, 10:08:22 AM
Welcome aboard.
If you are a competent rifle marksman, then go for whatever tickles you pickle.
If not, then buy a decent ar and invest in time and ammo to become proficient.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 01, 2015, 10:34:41 AM
With a $2600 budget, you can buy a top tier AR.

That's the way to go.

Most people that build AR's fall into 1 of 3 categories...

1)  build on a budget guys trying to save money
2) tinkerers that just want to say that they built it
3) minute of angle chasers that want absolutely every single new and/or proven piece on their rifle to have 1/8" moa accuracy
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: dogman on January 01, 2015, 10:53:58 AM
Welcome Beekeeping and Happy New Year All!
You mention SHTF rifle, bullpups and $2600.00 build. If SHTF, a bullpup is not a bad choice and also fun to shoot. A Tavor and Geissele trigger pack are around two grand. Pick up two or three stripped AR lower receivers to register at the same time and build later after you get some tools and knowledge. Good luck!
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: z06psi on January 01, 2015, 11:15:11 AM
Tavor!!!!!!!!  I say skip the Geissele trigger.  I removed the extra spring and have had zero issues. Midwest industries fore end with the light and a good red dot.


(http://i204.photobucket.com/albums/bb142/redrumssZ06PSI/6c466839-380a-49e2-882d-d2fc2e2dbfbd_zpse01cfa58.jpg) (http://s204.photobucket.com/user/redrumssZ06PSI/media/6c466839-380a-49e2-882d-d2fc2e2dbfbd_zpse01cfa58.jpg.html)
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: JHanawahine on January 01, 2015, 11:18:22 AM
I like the idea of building my own...but would buy a top tier rifle if I had the money
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: z06psi on January 01, 2015, 11:31:22 AM
For comparison and they have the same length barrels, range and purpose.

(http://i204.photobucket.com/albums/bb142/redrumssZ06PSI/20141128_125110_zpse9774faa.jpg) (http://s204.photobucket.com/user/redrumssZ06PSI/media/20141128_125110_zpse9774faa.jpg.html)
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: aieahound on January 01, 2015, 12:04:48 PM
Do both, buy a cheap AR, then build your 'Dream Gun', because you always need a backup.

+1

2 is 1, 1 is none.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 01, 2015, 12:06:04 PM
For comparison and they have the same length barrels, range and purpose.

(http://i204.photobucket.com/albums/bb142/redrumssZ06PSI/20141128_125110_zpse9774faa.jpg) (http://s204.photobucket.com/user/redrumssZ06PSI/media/20141128_125110_zpse9774faa.jpg.html)

Who's going to be the first to say it?
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: edster48 on January 01, 2015, 12:09:45 PM
With a $2600 budget, you can buy a top tier AR.

That's the way to go.

Most people that build AR's fall into 1 of 3 categories...

1)  build on a budget guys trying to save money
2) tinkerers that just want to say that they built it
3) minute of angle chasers that want absolutely every single new and/or proven piece on their rifle to have 1/8" moa accuracy

I have to admit, I fall into at least 2 of those categories!

1. I'm a cheap bastard, and I want the best bang for my buck.

2. I enjoy building and working on mechanical things and figuring out how they work.

3. Accuracy is always a goal, though I don't think I'd chase it to the 1/8th MOA level.

I think you left one out though. Function.
 After reading about and seeing people at the range have all manner of issues with even "high end" AR's I wanted something that would perform under the most adverse of conditions, even when subjected to abuse and lack of maintenance. Basically an AR with the reliability of an AK. I based my build on my sons AR due to the fact that after uncounted 3 gun matches, nearly 30,000 rounds, getting dirt and debris inside the gun, and never cleaning it { he says "when it starts to sound shitty, I squirt some oil in it"} it has NEVER malfunctioned. That's right, never, not once. Oh yeah, it still shoots sub MOA! I chose the parts with this in mind, and I haven't been disappointed. Not one single issue from the very first shot, and it shoots sub MOA. Added benefits are that I know the rifle intimately and in the unlikely event I do experience an issue, I'll be able to readily fix it myself.

Not an argument, just my personal line of reasoning. Everyone should do what suits their needs best.

Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: macsak on January 01, 2015, 12:14:56 PM
Who's going to be the first to say it?

 :wave:
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: z06psi on January 01, 2015, 12:33:21 PM
Who's going to be the first to say it?

Let me guess.  The front sight is on backwards.  My weapon and it doesn't matter with those sights.  Not one bit.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: drck1000 on January 01, 2015, 12:36:01 PM
Is this your first AR? (Sorry if I missed it if you mentioned)

If it's your first AR, I would highly recommend going to with a good quality AR and ammo to get familiar with it. When it comes to building ARs, to me, it's a out getting the exact configuration that you want and that can usually cost just as much and if not more than a complete gun. With a $2600 budget for a SHTF purpose gun, your options are pretty wide open.

Regarding bullpup a, I have limited experiences with them, but I'd love to own a Tavor or FS2000. However, those things aren't cheap...
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: macsak on January 01, 2015, 12:37:45 PM
Let me guess.  The front sight is on backwards.  My weapon and it doesn't matter with those sights.  Not one bit.

nope
 :crazy:
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: z06psi on January 01, 2015, 12:43:23 PM
nope
 :crazy:

Keep your circle of trust then.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: dogman on January 01, 2015, 12:50:11 PM
Let me guess.  The front sight is on backwards.
My guess is it has something to do with does size matter and macsak's role  ;)
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: macsak on January 01, 2015, 12:52:18 PM
Keep your circle of trust then.

sorry, man
not trying to give you a hard time
king keoni is fishing for someone to say, "that's what she said" in response to you saying
For comparison and they have the same length barrels, range and purpose.
and i am trying not to take the bait
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 01, 2015, 01:15:33 PM
sorry, man
not trying to give you a hard time
king keoni is fishing for someone to say, "that's what she said" in response to you saying
For comparison and they have the same length barrels, range and purpose.
and i am trying not to take the bait

Give in to the dark side, young skywalker
Title: .
Post by: Q on January 01, 2015, 01:56:38 PM
.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: Rocky on January 01, 2015, 02:44:02 PM
sorry, man
not trying to give you a hard time
king keoni is fishing for someone to say, "that's what she said" in response to you saying
For comparison and they have the same length barrels, range and purpose.
and i am trying not to take the bait

I thought it was
  "The black one is bigger".   O0
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: beekeeping1341 on January 01, 2015, 03:00:23 PM
Tavor!!!!!!!!  I say skip the Geissele trigger.  I removed the extra spring and have had zero issues. Midwest industries fore end with the light and a good red dot.


Wow that's pretty damn bitchin right there.....I'm in the service though and the only thing that concerns me is the manual of arms and the apparent inability to use the environment around as weapon support...I've never used a bipod even before the military because I could prop my rifle up on rocks or logs or against a tree...and it really doesn't look like you can do that with the tavor...am I wrong? What kind of accuracy are you getting put of them? Cause in shtf accuracy is a big deal, the 5.56 can't defeat cover like other calibres so shots have to be precise at range. I would really like a chance to pull the trigger...before I pull the trigger ;) but if the tavor is accurate I'm all over it
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: z06psi on January 01, 2015, 03:06:10 PM
I am in the service as well. From the trigger area to end of the fore end is o.k. for what you want. I have the 16" version but they also have an 18". Accuracy wise it's the same as an M4. 300 yds is not a problem. Shooter and ammo has the most to do with this. Hell my Kriss in .45 ACP can reach out to 200 yds.

You are welcome to shoot it.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: beekeeping1341 on January 01, 2015, 03:37:30 PM
I am in the service as well. From the trigger area to end of the fore end is o.k. for what you want. I have the 16" version but they also have an 18". Accuracy wise it's the same as an M4. 300 yds is not a problem. Shooter and ammo has the most to do with this. Hell my Kriss in .45 ACP can reach out to 200 yds.

You are welcome to shoot it.

Really? Cause if its like the m4 that's good for me, not sure what branch you're in but we have to qualify with m4's at 500 yards, so if its capable of that I'm fine with it. Do you have any experience with the Aug a3? And can your tavor run with gem 3 pmags? Cause I have a shit ton of those. I'll send you a pm about getting together sometime, cause that does sound good. Ammos on me!!
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: z06psi on January 01, 2015, 09:30:46 PM
The barrel size is the same so I don't see why not. Yes it uses any AR-15 standard magazines.  Sent a a PM back.  :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: jonjon on January 01, 2015, 10:00:45 PM
Come out to the next HDF shoot and you will get a chance to see what everyone is running. During the free shoot I would be more than happy to let you tryout my ar's and I bet other members would be willing to let you test out their firearms if you bring some ammo. :shaka:

You can also save a lot of money by purchasing a noveske upper and putting together your lower. :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: s197 on January 02, 2015, 08:55:17 AM
Buy the upper and build the lower would be a good compromise. Also for SHTF I wouldnt go 6.8spc simply because you want highly readily avail ammo and that would be 223/556
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: new guy on January 02, 2015, 10:03:18 AM
.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: beekeeping1341 on January 02, 2015, 10:29:32 AM
Come out to the next HDF shoot and you will get a chance to see what everyone is running. During the free shoot I would be more than happy to let you tryout my ar's and I bet other members would be willing to let you test out their firearms if you bring some ammo. :shaka:

You can also save a lot of money by purchasing a noveske upper and putting together your lower. :thumbsup:

That would be super great, I'd just feel like some freeloader though if I showed up without any weapons of my own lol and asked to fire others, even if I was providing the ammo. And yeah that's what I was thinking too, just buying the upper....but the bcm kmr is lighter then the noveske noveske NSr...but damn the nsr looks great on their gen 3 uppers!!! I know I shouldn't want my shtf rifle to be super aesthetically pleasing...but itd be nice!!!
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: macsak on January 02, 2015, 11:15:21 AM
That would be super great, I'd just feel like some freeloader though if I showed up without any weapons of my own lol and asked to fire others, even if I was providing the ammo. And yeah that's what I was thinking too, just buying the upper....but the bcm kmr is lighter then the noveske noveske NSr...but damn the nsr looks great on their gen 3 uppers!!! I know I shouldn't want my shtf rifle to be super aesthetically pleasing...but itd be nice!!!

just saw an awesome noveske infidel at SEC less than an hour ago that's under your budget
but i think the AK/AR combo idea is a good one too
bullpups are a compromise, especially in terms of the trigger due to the long, complex geometry involved

pm sent in a minute re:range days
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: z06psi on January 02, 2015, 03:23:02 PM
just saw an awesome noveske infidel at SEC less than an hour ago that's under your budget
but i think the AK/AR combo idea is a good one too
bullpups are a compromise, especially in terms of the trigger due to the long, complex geometry involved

pm sent in a minute re:range days

Multi calibers are coming out as well. The new ARAK-21 is tempting if I didn't have both and M4 and a SLR107. Maybe I should sell both and get an ARAK? 
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 02, 2015, 04:09:16 PM
That would be super great, I'd just feel like some freeloader though if I showed up without any weapons of my own lol and asked to fire others, even if I was providing the ammo. And yeah that's what I was thinking too, just buying the upper....but the bcm kmr is lighter then the noveske noveske NSr...but damn the nsr looks great on their gen 3 uppers!!! I know I shouldn't want my shtf rifle to be super aesthetically pleasing...but itd be nice!!!

Okay, since we're getting into the SHTF conversation, let me add this...

You'll want to have a common magazine/caliber for various weapons in a SHTF scenario.

The Tavor,SCAR,AR platform, Sig 556, etc, all use the same magazines.

The great thing about that is everyone in the family (or friends) can run the same mags and ammo while still enjoying their weapon of choice.

If you're looking for a SHTF rifle, that might be something to consider.

When you run out of ammo, you'll be able to find more for sure.

Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: sworbeyegib on January 02, 2015, 04:13:57 PM
A couple of my own musings on buying vs building... as well as a few of your other inquiries.

-If this is your first gun, then buy a complete rifle. Learn the ins and outs of the workings. Figure out the things you like and don't like about the gun. Put that knowledge to use when you start your first build.

-Factor in the costs of any tools and set ups you will need to do a good job if you do not already own them. Better yet, find someone that has done it before and do it with them, with their tools.

-Saving money by building an AR is partly a waiting and opportunistic game. You could just go on any site and add everything you want to your shopping cart... but to really save money, involves surfing around for special deals and sales. Could very well be the difference between a few hundred dollars.

-Bullpups can be a love/hate sort of thing. Only bullpup that has gotten my motor running is the Tavor.

-6.8spc works well on paper,  and the 6.8 seems to mostly be popular with hunters on the mainland where caliber restrictions do not allow them to use 5.56 (which is legal in Hawaii btw). If I were to choose a different chambering though, I'd probably go with .300Blackout. That being said, I think the 5.56 is perfectly fine for a defensive rifle. After all, we can load up with soft points if we like.

-$2600 is a lot of cheddar. That gives you a lot of options. Heck, you probably set up 2 mil-spec ARs with optics for that much if you shop around right.

Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: jonjon on January 02, 2015, 06:59:59 PM
That would be super great, I'd just feel like some freeloader though if I showed up without any weapons of my own lol and asked to fire others, even if I was providing the ammo. And yeah that's what I was thinking too, just buying the upper....but the bcm kmr is lighter then the noveske noveske NSr...but damn the nsr looks great on their gen 3 uppers!!! I know I shouldn't want my shtf rifle to be super aesthetically pleasing...but itd be nice!!!


Come to to the HDF shoot as one of our guest and you won't be treated as a freeloader  :shaka:

Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: crazy cat on January 03, 2015, 10:08:56 PM
I've built several AR-15s over the years; some thoughts based on my experience.

For a SHTF rifle, you'll want a chrome lined barrel. (How do you define SHTF?)

Building a accurate AR-15 is easy; float a good barrel.  Really, that's it. 

A good trigger helps, but for a SHTF rifle, reliability is more important than having a whole bunch of adjustments, and anything fitted will wear out sooner than you think.  I like the Rock River Arms 2 stage.

Make sure the gas tube is STRAIGHT in the upper receiver so the key doesn't bind; this may take some fiddling. 

Don't use a torque wrench; anywhere between 30lbs and 80lbs is fine, but the gas tube has to be centered in the hole.

All other things being equal, a 1 in 12 twist will be more accurate with 55gr ball than a 1 in 9 (or 7).  But the 1 in 12 won't fully stabilize 62gr bullets (think 6MOA), and is hopeless with anything heavier.

If you don't shave regularly, you want a fixed stock.  Telescoping stocks pinch.

With a 20" barrel, effective range is around 200yds (before the bullet slows down so much that it doesn't do much damage)   With a 16" barrel, it's more like 50yds.  This isn't an accuracy issue (if anything, shorter barrels are more accurate). it's a velocity issue.

Most optics are useless in heavy rain.  Even ACOGs.  The ELCAN is the only scope I've seen that is still usable with water on the lenses.  Yes, I know it's too big and makes a lightweight AR-15 top heavy.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: mauidog on January 04, 2015, 12:42:23 AM

Most optics are useless in heavy rain. Even ACOGs.  The ELCAN is the only scope I've seen that is still usable with water on the lenses.  Yes, I know it's too big and makes a lightweight AR-15 top heavy.

I agree with everything else crazy cat said here, except for the optic in rain.

If you are talking about a magnified optic, then yes, water on the lens is an issue.

If, however, you are using a 1x holographic red dot, like an AimPoint PRO, then the water should not be a problem.

You are supposed to use both eyes when using a 1x  CQB optic.  I can leave both the front & rear lens covers closed on my PRO and see the red dot through the clear rear cover using my right eye.  The target is seen with the left eye. 

Together, both eyes give me a red dot on the target in the same spot I would see were I looking all the way through the scope. 

It's one of the cool things about red dots.  If you're in a hurry to shoot, you don't have to open the covers on the PRO -- just make sure to leave the power turned on (the battery lasts about 3 years if left on at the mid level brightness).

Once you add a magnifier to the red dot, however, you need to close the left eye -- that is, unless you have super powers that can magnify the left eye's image to match the scope!!   :D  Only a 1x optic will permit you to have both eyes open, just like iron sights.

 :shaka:

Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: stangzilla on January 04, 2015, 10:08:35 AM
for a SHTF rifle, reliability is more important than having a whole bunch of adjustments

Go to the dark side.....

Get an AK.   ;)
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: aieahound on January 04, 2015, 10:20:31 AM
Pick up talula's bull pup sks in the classifieds for $650 then build or buy your dream AR for $2K.

Bam, mission accomplished.  Bull pup, Ak platform and AR.

P.s.
I thought a 16" barreled AR was effective out to about 300 yards velocity wise (enough velocity to get the yaw and fragmentation)
I am not in the military nor a lawyer.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: ren on January 04, 2015, 10:37:02 AM
P.s.
I thought a 16" barreled AR was effective out to about 300 yards velocity wise (enough velocity to get the yaw and fragmentation)
I am not in the military nor a lawyer.

I don't know about all these generalizations that a certain caliber is not effective out to xx yards.
If I've been hit with a .223/5.56 at 300 yards I'd go down and yell for a medic. I won't ask if it was a 16" or 20" barrel. One hit in a large artery and a person will bleed out.
Any first hand accounts of what it is like to be hit with a certain caliber at a certain distance? Those are the people I'd like to hear from.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: mauidog on January 04, 2015, 10:58:52 AM
I don't know about all these generalizations that a certain caliber is not effective out to xx yards.
If I've been hit with a .223/5.56 at 300 yards I'd go down and yell for a medic. I won't ask if it was a 16" or 20" barrel. One hit in a large artery and a person will bleed out.
Any first hand accounts of what it is like to be hit with a certain caliber at a certain distance? Those are the people I'd like to hear from.

This looks pretty well thought out  ...  even though the author doesn't mention ever being shot by any caliber bullet including the 5.56/.223 variety!   >:D

Effective Range of Your 223 or 5.56 Rifle

Quote
In this post I'm going to discuss the maximum effective range of the most common bullet weight and type, 55gr full metal jacket (FMJ).  As many people
know the standard 55gr full metal jacket projectile's primary wounding capability comes from fragmentation.  There is wounding performed by
hydrostatic shock as well, and of course the path of the bullet.  If a bullet itself hits a major blood vessel or vital organ it can of course be lethal. 
But when a bullet expands or fragments it greatly increases both the wound channel and the potential to damage something vital.
Quote
Most experts suggest the necessary velocity to ensure reliable fragmentation is 2700 fps.
Quote
16", the most common barrel length sold in AR-15 carbines and the shortest length available for general sale, gives us a muzzle velocity of of 3125.
Fragmentation range extends out to just over 100 meters, not much longer than the 14.5" barrel.

The second most common barrel length for AR-15 rifles is 20".  The M193 round gets 3250 fps and a range of right around 150 meters. 
This gives us a 50% increase in effective range over the 16" barrel.
Quote
All of these calculations were done around the military spec M193 5.56 NATO cartridge.  If instead you use .223 Winchester ammo offered by Winchester,
Remington, PMC or other companies, your velocity could be 100 fps lower than M193, as .223 is loaded to a lower pressure than 5.56 NATO.  If you
are using Wolf, Brown Bear or Silver Bear .223 ammo, your velocities could be 150 fps slower.  That can reduce effective fragmentation ranges effectively. 
Using steel cased Wolf .223 ammo in a 11.5" short barrel rifle gives almost no fragmentation capability.
Quote
In no means is this an attempt to talk people out of using 55gr ball ammunition for defense.  It is an ideal cartridge for defensive work, especially in residential
areas where light obstacles (like interior walls) will cause it to fragment very quickly and reduce the chance of missed shots striking or hurting unintended targets. 
But if it is the ammo you chose to use, you should understand it's capability.  Once you extend past it's fragmentation range, you are likely better off using another
ammunition type.  For instance, the 55gr TSX bullet made by Barnes should offer reliable expansion down to 1,800 fps.  This extends the range quite a bit at which
it offers good terminal ballistics.  A reasonable person could practice with 55gr FMJ ammo and use the TSX bullet for hunting or defense to extend your effective range.

http://angry-peasants.blogspot.com/2012/08/effective-range-of-your-223-or-556-rifle.html (http://angry-peasants.blogspot.com/2012/08/effective-range-of-your-223-or-556-rifle.html)
Title: .
Post by: Q on January 04, 2015, 11:50:44 AM
.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: mauidog on January 04, 2015, 12:12:38 PM
If the discussion is now AK vs AR, go with the AK.

Standard AK ammo is 123gr, while AR ammo is 55gr.  One of the main objectives of adopting the NATO 5.56 cartridge:  it weighs less than half that of .30 caliber sized AK and .308 rounds, allowing troops to carry at least double the number of rounds based on weight.

So, while the standard for NATO/US forces is 5.56, that doesn't mean it's the best choice for all possible situations. 

For SHTF, the AK will have almost the same effective range as an AR15, assuming the accuracy of the AK you have is good.  The  terminal velocity of the AK is similar to a small handgun caliber with non-expanding ammo.

In battle, the general opinions I've read say the M16 is better than the AK for longer range accuracy (within the effective range of that barrel's length).  But the AK proved more lethal once the fight was up close and personal, due to the one-shot-kill effectiveness of the 7.62x39 round compared to the NATO 5.56x45 round.

Based on the overall effectiveness, the lighter 5.56 allows you to carry more ammo than the AK ammo .... because you are probably going to need more!! 

Then there is the argument that the AK will keep firing without cleaning for next to infinity, while the DI AR15 needs to be cleaned whenever you take a rest break!  Reliability under less than ideal conditions might be another factor for choosing the AK.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 04, 2015, 03:30:17 PM
With a 20" barrel, effective range is around 200yds (before the bullet slows down so much that it doesn't do much damage)   With a 16" barrel, it's more like 50yds.  This isn't an accuracy issue (if anything, shorter barrels are more accurate). it's a velocity issue.

Allow me to be the first to call bull$#!t on this.

Anyone who tells you that the effective range of a 5.56 or 7.62x39 rifle is 50 yards is absolutely idiotic.

I am willing to bet you my house that you can stand up at 300 yards and I can use my 16" AR/AK/SCAR/Tavor with iron sights very "effectively."

Well beyond your purported 50 yards or 200 yards.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: z06psi on January 04, 2015, 04:07:56 PM
With a 16" barrel, it's more like 50yds. 

WTF? We all need to hear your rationale on this one.  :wtf:
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: z06psi on January 04, 2015, 04:08:41 PM
Allow me to be the first to call bull$#!t on this.

Anyone who tells you that the effective range of a 5.56 or 7.62x39 rifle is 50 yards is absolutely idiotic.

I am willing to bet you my house that you can stand up at 300 yards and I can use my 16" AR/AK/SCAR/Tavor with iron sights very "effectively."

Well beyond your purported 50 yards or 200 yards.

Yes that is bullshiot!!!
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: crazy cat on January 04, 2015, 04:53:08 PM
This looks pretty well thought out  ...  even though the author doesn't mention ever being shot by any caliber bullet including the 5.56/.223 variety!   >:D

Effective Range of Your 223 or 5.56 Rifle

http://angry-peasants.blogspot.com/2012/08/effective-range-of-your-223-or-556-rifle.html (http://angry-peasants.blogspot.com/2012/08/effective-range-of-your-223-or-556-rifle.html)

.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: new guy on January 04, 2015, 05:08:57 PM
.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: ren on January 04, 2015, 05:56:58 PM
Fifty Cent was shot NINE times

(http://www.50centnews.com/images/50_Cent_bullets.jpg)

GGG UNIT! :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: tribaldread on January 04, 2015, 05:57:59 PM
Das why I said fo' get bohf!!!

Seriously though, quality ARs and AKs can both be had now, at discounted prices.

Why not get both?

You will have two rifles (versus just one), and you'll be able to become familiar with and proficient in the use of both the AR platform in .223/5.56 and the AK platform in 7.62x39.

Again, just my opinion.  :shaka:

+1 Just get both  :thumbsup: :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: z06psi on January 04, 2015, 11:14:38 PM
.
That's bullet fragmentation range. Not effective range given a barrel length and round type.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: mauidog on January 04, 2015, 11:36:15 PM
That's bullet fragmentation range. Not effective range given a barrel length and round type.

Hmmm?  I thought for a firearm to be "EFFECTIVE", it needed to inflict a wound adequate to disable the target.

If you read that article again, if specifies "As many people know the standard 55gr full metal jacket projectile's primary wounding capability comes from fragmentation." 

Therefore, the round's effectiveness is directly related to the 55gr 5.56 bullet's ability to fragment after impact:  effectiveness = wounding capability = fragmentation

Fragmentation is not the only means of wounding, as the article also states, but the PRIMARY wounding capability of the 5.56 round COMES FROM FRAGMENTATION.

With fragmentation being the desired effect when the bullet strikes the target, the effective ranges listed in the article ARE the maximum distances you can shoot a standard AR-15 round (M193) through a variety of barrel lengths while still achieving adequate fragmentation.

Quote
In this post I'm going to discuss the maximum effective range of the most common bullet weight and type, 55gr full metal jacket (FMJ).  As many people know the standard 55gr full metal jacket projectile's primary wounding capability comes from fragmentation.  There is wounding performed by hydrostatic shock as well, and of course the path of the bullet.  If a bullet itself hits a major blood vessel or vital organ it can of course be lethal.  But when a bullet expands or fragments it greatly increases both the wound channel and the potential to damage something vital.  It's a morbid topic, but if you use a firearm for hunting or defense, you want it to be effective, so it's an important discussion.
Title: .
Post by: Q on January 05, 2015, 02:27:13 AM
.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: Surf on January 05, 2015, 07:10:30 AM
There is some good stuff here, but some very misinformed comments.

Building is a plus and a minus.  With current costs, from a financial standpoint building does not make sense for your average person at this time  Even for those who may get discounted pricing for various reasons, even pricing direct from the factory to their factory armorers, building a base rifle is still not a big savings over current pricing.  Now if you want the satisfaction of doing it yourself despite costs, go for it.  Do your research first.  Yes this rifle is one of the easiest platforms to assemble, but those who say it is as simple as lego's are somewhat correct but generally misinformed. 

Since the AR/M4 shares commonality of parts it simplifies the process.  If you use quality parts with good build technique then most often then not, you are good to go.  Lesser quality parts can be problematic which are often the result of a "tolerance stacking" issue.  If you do have an issue, trouble shooting is more difficult for those who are new to the system.  I might suggest m4carbine.net to do research if you build.  Read, read and read more.  Then if you have questions ask.  The members over there are helpful to those who have already attempted to help themselves by doing their own reading and research.  They are less forgiving to those who want everything spelled out in their own thread.  Most answers can be found by searching.  You can try ar15.com but too much BS there.

I personally build all of my own rifles because I do a lot of gun work professionally and I am heavily experienced on this particular platform.  I get the right pricing, have all the tools and have been doing it for a long time.  I pick and choose what parts I want from the start, so there is no need for a base rifle and then upgrading it.  Quite frankly I build a better rifle than I can buy.  However for most individuals a quality base rifle and upgrading is more often the way to go.  Or the next step as mentioned is buying the complete upper and putting together the lower. 

Torque values are important but not a huge issue for those who work around torquing things all the time.  The barrel torque does matter for accuracy.  Over tighten a barrel nut and accuracy can diminish and I am not talking about over torque as in beyond the 80ftlbs, I am talking about a torque spec that still falls within milspec values but can diminish barrel accuracy.  There is a good range of torque value that we find is more conducive to accuracy.  Over torque a muzzle device and you might again screw up accuracy by "trumpeting" your muzzle end.  There are quite a few things that most experienced DIYers or even most factory trained armorers do not understand.  Small things individually can be, well small, but stack them up together and they can be a big deal.  Good or bad.   

The .223 / 5.56 bullet efficacy quoted in this thread is not exactly correct or more so does not tell the entire story.  The fragmentation topic discussed here and linked in this thread is in regards to statistics on FMJ rounds and at which velocity fragmentation occurs.  These numbers vary greatly when it comes to soft point or various rounds that are built to induce expansion perhaps via hydraulics or impact deformation.  We should understand that fragmentation and penetration are 2 very different topics.  The #1 consideration on efficacy of a projectile is penetration first and foremost above any other considerations.  If the round and the fragments do not have the ability to reach or pass through vital blood bearing vessels then it is nowhere near as effective.  Fragmentation is only beneficial if penetration is correct.  Of course if you can get both, better yet. 

Think of it this way.  If you get shot with a .308 in a soft blood bearing organ, not a CNS disruption and it goes through and through and the same with a .223/5.56 that goes through and through, the size of the hole difference is not so great.  Anyone who want to start quoting permanent vs. non permanent wound cavity, hydrostatic, kinetic energy, save it.  In other words, just because a .223/5.56 does not fragment but still penetrates correctly, that is what we want.  Expansion and fragmentation is only a bonus which was a plus for that round, but not a necessity.  We have been proving that well for the last decade plus. 

Is it the best in long range engagements?  Not by any stretch.  Is it the best at short range?  No, but it is a very good all around caliber out of a weapon platform that is reliable, shoots with ease and is accurate at long range.  Anyone who questions effective range, I was shooting 18x30 steel at 920 yards pretty easy.  What was the ballistic efficacy of the round at that distance?  Not sure, but I can say 100% that I wouldn't want to get hit with it and that it would probably ruin your day, your week, the month, year or the rest of your life.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: z06psi on January 05, 2015, 08:01:12 AM
Hmmm?  I thought for a firearm to be "EFFECTIVE", it needed to inflict a wound adequate to disable the target.

If you read that article again, if specifies "As many people know the standard 55gr full metal jacket projectile's primary wounding capability comes from fragmentation." 

Therefore, the round's effectiveness is directly related to the 55gr 5.56 bullet's ability to fragment after impact:  effectiveness = wounding capability = fragmentation

Fragmentation is not the only means of wounding, as the article also states, but the PRIMARY wounding capability of the 5.56 round COMES FROM FRAGMENTATION.

With fragmentation being the desired effect when the bullet strikes the target, the effective ranges listed in the article ARE the maximum distances you can shoot a standard AR-15 round (M193) through a variety of barrel lengths while still achieving adequate fragmentation.

All I have to ask is how many people have you shot with a M4?  23 years in the Army, 3 wars, and 5 deployments says you can put an enemy down at greater than 50 yards with an M4.  I have done it myself. You can internet speculate all you want and read someone else's science experiment and maker your own decisions.   :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: mauidog on January 05, 2015, 08:05:31 AM
All I have to ask is how many people have you shot with a M4?  23 years in the Army, 3 wars, and 5 deployments says you can put an enemy down at greater than 50 yards with an M4.  I have done it myself. You can internet speculate all you want and read someone else's science experiment and maker your own decisions.   :thumbsup:

The article lists the effective range for a 14.5" - 16" barrel with M193 ammo at over 100 meters.  A 20" barrel get you out to around 150 meters.

So, I don't see why you are arguing against a 50m/50 yards number.  That was Crazy Cat's estimate, not the article's.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: z06psi on January 05, 2015, 08:09:30 AM
The article lists the effective range for a 14.5" - 16" barrel with M193 ammo at over 100 meters.  A 20" barrel get you out to around 150 meters.

So, I don't see why you are arguing against a 50m/50 yards number.  That was Crazy Cat's estimate, not the article's.

Even 100 yards is bad information. 150 years is bad information.  There is an effective range for the M4 weapons system.    500m
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: mauidog on January 05, 2015, 08:11:51 AM
Even 100 yards is bad information. 150 years is bad information.  There is an effective range for the M4 weapons system.    500m

What barrel length?  Using what ammo? 
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: mauidog on January 05, 2015, 08:19:28 AM
Quote
You're going to have to define 'Effective Range'.

Range at which a well trained soldier can hit a point target (plastic Ivan)? about 500M

Range at which a well trained soldier can hit an area target (Ivans in a squat formation)? about 800M

Range at which the round can still produce a 'lethal' wound by the old Army Standards (about 70ft-lbs IIRC - the actual figure is in Hatcher's Notebook) so that gives you well over 1000yards.

The range at which the round will fragment? That depends entirely on the round used. For M193 that would be 100y for the 14.5" and about 125y for the 16". Better rounds like the 75gr OTM will extend that to the 150-200y range. Again lots of variables in here.

Range at which YOU can effectively hit the vial zone of a moving target that is taking cover? Expect it to be less than 100y.

http://www.ar15.com/archive/topic.html?b=3&f=118&t=271133 (http://www.ar15.com/archive/topic.html?b=3&f=118&t=271133)
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: mauidog on January 05, 2015, 08:20:34 AM
Even 100 yards is bad information. 150 years is bad information.  There is an effective range for the M4 weapons system.    500m

Don't be so sure about that number.  The target would have died of old age already, so...... yeah!!    :rofl:
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: z06psi on January 05, 2015, 08:21:23 AM
M193 – Ball
M855 – Ball (Green Tip)

M196 – Trace
M856 – Tracer (Red Tip)


Standard US Military loads with a standard issue 16" barrel.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: z06psi on January 05, 2015, 08:22:30 AM
Don't be so sure about that number.  The target would have died of old age already, so...... yeah!!    :rofl:

Here.  Go stand at 400 yards naked and I will take 3 shots with my Tavor and tell me if it hurts.

(http://i204.photobucket.com/albums/bb142/redrumssZ06PSI/SuperTroopers_zps26edd742.jpg) (http://s204.photobucket.com/user/redrumssZ06PSI/media/SuperTroopers_zps26edd742.jpg.html)
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: ren on January 05, 2015, 08:23:42 AM
Little things to learn about building - echoing Surf's experience. On my match service rifle, the flash hider is hand tight andg lued on, I read that the AMU does this with theirs. Never experimented with barrel nut torque values, as I dont have the patience or budget. The biggest improvement is floating the barrel. If you are using iron sights there are some inferior ones such as a DPMS I had years ago. Dead clicks, didnt track well. A lot has to do with how the threada are cut. Anyways, lil things one learns along the yellow brick road.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: drck1000 on January 05, 2015, 08:43:12 AM
I've built several AR-15s over the years; some thoughts based on my experience.

For a SHTF rifle, you'll want a chrome lined barrel. (How do you define SHTF?)

Building a accurate AR-15 is easy; float a good barrel.  Really, that's it. 

A good trigger helps, but for a SHTF rifle, reliability is more important than having a whole bunch of adjustments, and anything fitted will wear out sooner than you think.  I like the Rock River Arms 2 stage.

Make sure the gas tube is STRAIGHT in the upper receiver so the key doesn't bind; this may take some fiddling. 

Don't use a torque wrench; anywhere between 30lbs and 80lbs is fine, but the gas tube has to be centered in the hole.

All other things being equal, a 1 in 12 twist will be more accurate with 55gr ball than a 1 in 9 (or 7).  But the 1 in 12 won't fully stabilize 62gr bullets (think 6MOA), and is hopeless with anything heavier.

If you don't shave regularly, you want a fixed stock.  Telescoping stocks pinch.

With a 20" barrel, effective range is around 200yds (before the bullet slows down so much that it doesn't do much damage)   With a 16" barrel, it's more like 50yds.  This isn't an accuracy issue (if anything, shorter barrels are more accurate). it's a velocity issue.

Most optics are useless in heavy rain.  Even ACOGs.  The ELCAN is the only scope I've seen that is still usable with water on the lenses.  Yes, I know it's too big and makes a lightweight AR-15 top heavy.
No experience with the ELCAN (too damn expensive), but I will say that my Aimpoints (Comp M4s and T-1s) have been through classes and training in heavy rain and no problems.  Even heavy snow with temps down to around 10 F and no problems, at least with the optic itself.  Yes, they are all 1x optics, but I didn't notice any effects from the rain or snow.  This was for ranges from about 7 yards or so and then out to about 200 yards.  In the same class with heavy snow and freezing temps, another shooter had an Leupold 1-4x and it didn't seem to be negatively affected by the weather. 

Regarding ACOGs, I've shot with them, but mostly in good weather conditions, as in mostly dry.  Why do you feel that they are useless in the rain?  From just water droplets on the lens? 
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: drck1000 on January 05, 2015, 08:49:19 AM
SNIP

Based on the overall effectiveness, the lighter 5.56 allows you to carry more ammo than the AK ammo .... because you are probably going to need more!! 

Then there is the argument that the AK will keep firing without cleaning for next to infinity, while the DI AR15 needs to be cleaned whenever you take a rest break!  Reliability under less than ideal conditions might be another factor for choosing the AK.
I haven't shot my AK that much, but I will say that a fully loaded steel AK mag is a LOT heavier than a fully loaded USGI/AR mag!  I have some Bulgarian polymer mags that help reduce the weight, but even then, the fully loaded mags are very much noticeably heavier than fully loaded AR mags.  Then try multiplying that by say 3-4, let alone trying to carry 7 or more.   

Regarding cleaning of the AR/M4 system, while I agree that the AR/M4 is more sensitive to maintenance, I feel that the AR/M4, if properly lubed and maintained is capable of reliability under less than ideal conditions.  Sure, I'm not going to try to run an AR/M4 with a ham and cheese sandwich in the action (I have to find that video), but I have ARs that I've put more than 2,000 rounds through with nothing more than some lube here and there to the BCG. 
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: crazy cat on January 05, 2015, 09:31:58 AM
No experience with the ELCAN (too damn expensive), but I will say that my Aimpoints (Comp M4s and T-1s) have been through classes and training in heavy rain and no problems.  Even heavy snow with temps down to around 10 F and no problems, at least with the optic itself.  Yes, they are all 1x optics, but I didn't notice any effects from the rain or snow.  This was for ranges from about 7 yards or so and then out to about 200 yards.  In the same class with heavy snow and freezing temps, another shooter had an Leupold 1-4x and it didn't seem to be negatively affected by the weather. 

Regarding ACOGs, I've shot with them, but mostly in good weather conditions, as in mostly dry.  Why do you feel that they are useless in the rain?  From just water droplets on the lens? 

Yes, I've been out in the rain with an ACOG, trying to see a pig at 50yds or so.  After that experience, I did some tests (getting both lenses covered with drops, dipping in a puddle, etc)  and decided to just stick with iron sights.

As for the "effective" range of a .223; I've shot a lot of pigs over the years, but I've never shot at a person.  I've heard that pigs are harder to put down than any other mammal, so maybe I'm just jaded, but I've had better overall luck with a .30 Carbine (with soft points, every pig has dropped where it was)) than a .223.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: drck1000 on January 05, 2015, 10:44:41 AM
Yes, I've been out in the rain with an ACOG, trying to see a pig at 50yds or so.  After that experience, I did some tests (getting both lenses covered with drops, dipping in a puddle, etc)  and decided to just stick with iron sights.

As for the "effective" range of a .223; I've shot a lot of pigs over the years, but I've never shot at a person.  I've heard that pigs are harder to put down than any other mammal, so maybe I'm just jaded, but I've had better overall luck with a .30 Carbine (with soft points, every pig has dropped where it was)) than a .223.
Trying to see the pig?  So the water droplet distorted the field of view enough that you couldn't even see the pig?  Wow!  Which power ACOG?  The 4x?  Interesting experience.  I'll have to see if I can try that next time I'm shooting with my buddy who has an ACOG.  When you did your tests, did you notice a change in POI relative to the POA if there was a water droplet over or near the reticle?  Or was the distortion primarily in the clarify of the field of view? 

As for your experience with the effectiveness of .223?  What sort of ammo were you using?  FMJ?  BTHP?  Soft points?  On occasion, we'll do drills where you have to try to shoot 4x4s off a table.  If you try to shoot them with FMJ, they zip right through them.  Use a soft point, and they seem to dump a lot more energy into the 4x4.  While I'm not saying there's a direct correlation to effect on flesh, just that ammunition choices can have a significant effect.  I have not personally seen what .223/5.56 FMJ, BTHP, OTM, soft points, or whatever have done on humans.  I'll just have to take the experts word for it. That said, I would expect 5.56 to be "effective" well beyond 200 yards.  Of course shot placement would be key. 
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: Heavies on January 05, 2015, 11:25:43 AM
Water droplets on any optic can throw your POI WAYYYYY off.  At closer range this may not effect to so much as to miss the target.  But it may have you impacting at an area not intended.. Food for thought.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: drck1000 on January 05, 2015, 11:47:08 AM
Water droplets on any optic can throw your POI WAYYYYY off.  At closer range this may not effect to so much as to miss the target.  But it may have you impacting at an area not intended.. Food for thought.
I figured it could, just no personal experience with 1x Aimpoints.  For the class, it was for defensive use of carbine, not precision, so hits on a zone were acceptable.  When we were shooting at 200 yards, it was more to demonstrate how the POI changes at different distances as opposed to precision. 

I assume that hunters do so in a variety of conditions.  Scope caps probably help, but any "tricks" that can be employed to avoid this.  Like those caps to eliminate or reduce light from reflecting off of the lens (kill flash), but I've only used those for 1x optics.  I've seen them on ACOGs, but I've never used them with those. 
Title: .
Post by: Q on January 05, 2015, 12:16:49 PM
.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: Heavies on January 05, 2015, 01:00:21 PM
That is false.

Maximum effective range, for both M4 and M16, have always been 300m.

And most standard Army units assign a designated marksman with a modernized m14 platform at ranges at and beyond 400m, so I'm not sure why your unit(s) are using an M4 at those ranges, unless your unit(s) didn't have the funds to do so.

A well trained and proficient marksman can hit a man sized target at 600 yards with a rifle discussed.   I have seen this many times. A soft target hit with a projectile in the right spot at this distance is going down.
Title: .
Post by: Q on January 05, 2015, 01:14:26 PM
.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: drck1000 on January 05, 2015, 01:54:40 PM
A well trained and proficient marksman can hit a 1000 yard target with a mosin; still doesn't mean the maximum effective range of that weapon system is 1000 yards.

And as stated, most Army units provide a modernized M14 platform to their best shooters on the platoon/squad level, precisely for the reason that it is a far superior platform for long distance applications as it has a longer maximum effective range.

And before anyone tries to quote FM 3-22.9 in order to prove that the MER is 500m at a point target, let's exercise some common sense. A standard range is set up to 300m for the average soldier. 90% of people on a standardized range have trouble effectively engaging live-action targets at these ranges with an M4, unless they have an optimized optic. And beyond these ranges, only seasoned individuals with lots of trigger time, training and optimized optics can effectively utilize the platform to it's maximal capability. If the true effective range of the M4 platform was beyond 300m, most standardized military ranges would be implementing targets at such ranges.

The average Joe is not going to effectively or efficiently engage targets at ranges beyond 300m with a standard M4 platform, so it really doesn't matter what a book says. This is coming from some of the top shooters in the Army that we had the privilege to train with during the combat rifle marksmanship course.

I hear you.  Depends on what one is referring to when mentioning "effective" range.  Effective as in ability to put a round on a point or area target?  Or with sufficient velocity to fragment, expand, or whatever ballistic effect.  Or with sufficient energy to damage, wound, etc. 

Similar to the topics of "build vs buy", the topic of effective range, barrel length, etc has been discussed a lot on M4Carbine and with a LOT of "real life" information.  Like any online forum, you take the BS with the good info.  It takes some time to weed through what is what, but still great information to be had.  And lots of great discussion where it becomes apparent who is writing/speaking from first hand experience and who is regurgitating what they've heard.  The latter isn't necessarily bad as long as they are passing on good information, but sadly, that's not often the case. 

Personally, without a magnified optic, I would have trouble making out a 12" x 18" target at say 400 yards let alone try to make hits consistently.  With something with at least 4x magnification, then that helps tremendously, but more for seeing and identifying the target.  I've love to have a  USO 1-8x on an AR that put together with precision in mind, but glass like that is $$$$!!! 
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: aieahound on January 05, 2015, 02:08:35 PM
So should He build it or buy it ?    :D

Sorry if I took it off topic but Cat's 50 yd comment threw me for a loop.  :wacko:
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: dustoff003 on January 05, 2015, 02:23:05 PM

So should He build it or buy it ?    :D

Sorry if I took it off topic but Cat's 50 yd comment threw me for a loop.  :wacko:
With his budget like others have recommended buy one and build one.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: Surf on January 05, 2015, 02:38:59 PM
So should He build it or buy it ?    :D

Sorry if I took it off topic but Cat's 50 yd comment threw me for a loop.  :wacko:
At this time with prices as they are it makes more sense that he buys a high quality rifle since it can be purchased right now for a very low cost.  Haven't seen these low of prices in a long long time and at these prices a high quality rifle manufacturer rifle is a no brainer IMO.  If things sway and prices climb, building becomes more appealing. 

Now I will stray a bit again.....As for the max effective range, some here are confused by "effective range" and "fragmentation range" or the distance / velocity at which a .223 / 5.56 round will fragment.  They are entirely different things.  Even if you go with the 3 or 4 common definitions of "effective range" or "max effective range", fragmentation has nothing to do with it.  Even more so, I am not sure that it is understood that a FMJ will react different than a soft point when it comes to fragmentation and numbers will vary a good deal.  You don't need a bullet to fragment to kill and if you hit someone (soft target) with a .223 / 5.56 out to 1000 yards you can still kill them or take them out of the fight.  That is pretty darn effective.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: Heavies on January 05, 2015, 05:01:25 PM
@ 600 yard, the 5.56 green tip round is still going supersonic.  Don't know if that is enough to fragment, but I am sure it is enough to cause some hurt.  As for "effective range" I am reading it as, can the projectile cause a target to be disabled?  Then yes I believe a well placed hit will disable the target.  As for "well trained marksman"  From talking to a trainer, many can't hit shit at 25 meters with a freaking rifle, so does that mean the effective range for that rifle is <25M? 

That's all I'm saying.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 05, 2015, 05:27:11 PM
The bottom line is that every human being in the world, except for crazy cat, agrees that rifle rounds are lethal beyond 50&150 yards.

 :closed:

 :stopjack:
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: Heavies on January 05, 2015, 05:33:44 PM
The bottom line is that every human being in the world, except for crazy cat, agrees that rifle rounds are lethal beyond 50&150 yards.

 :closed:

 :stopjack:
:thumbsup:
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: crazy cat on January 05, 2015, 07:39:11 PM
The bottom line is that every human being in the world, except for crazy cat, agrees that rifle rounds are lethal beyond 50&150 yards.

 :closed:

 :stopjack:

LOL..Lethal; sure, I've killed pigs with a .223.  The problem is that sometimes they don't drop, they run off into the forest and I don't find them until they start to smell.

55gr soft points don't penetrate enough, and sometimes (3 times I can remember), they bounce off the skull.  64gr soft points weren't any better.  68gr hollow points deform (but don't fragment, even at 70yds with a 20" barrel) and penetrate about 8", so unless you clip the spinal cord, the pig doesn't go down.  55gr ball actually seems to have the best balance of penetration and expansion; it penetrates about 8" and then blows up, but still doesn't dump enough energy to reliably drop a 150lb pig.

FWIW, I once bounced a 7.62X39 (steel cased, steel jacketed) soft point from an SKS off a pigs skull and had her run off, apparently uninjured. 
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: jonjon on January 05, 2015, 08:27:51 PM
LOL..Lethal; sure, I've killed pigs with a .223.  The problem is that sometimes they don't drop, they run off into the forest and I don't find them until they start to smell.

55gr soft points don't penetrate enough, and sometimes (3 times I can remember), they bounce off the skull.  64gr soft points weren't any better.  68gr hollow points deform (but don't fragment, even at 70yds with a 20" barrel) and penetrate about 8", so unless you clip the spinal cord, the pig doesn't go down.  55gr ball actually seems to have the best balance of penetration and expansion; it penetrates about 8" and then blows up, but still doesn't dump enough energy to reliably drop a 150lb pig.

FWIW, I once bounced a 7.62X39 (steel cased, steel jacketed) soft point from an SKS off a pigs skull and had her run off, apparently uninjured.

Than maybe you should start hunting with a pellet gun  :thumbsup:

http://youtu.be/OUEwxg32s6Y (http://youtu.be/OUEwxg32s6Y)


 :stopjack:

Like I said earlier - buy the upper build the lower  :shaka:
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: robtmc on January 05, 2015, 08:55:53 PM
What a bunch of wankers, just build a .7.62/.308 AR and have the best of all worlds, other than light ammo loadout.  A well placed round trumps spray an pray every time.

Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: z06psi on January 05, 2015, 09:08:06 PM
What a bunch of wankers, just build a .7.62/.308 AR and have the best of all worlds, other than light ammo loadout.  A well placed round trumps spray an pray every time.

I have a RRA LAR-08 with less than 100 rounds through it for the OP.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: mauidog on January 05, 2015, 09:22:31 PM
I have a RRA LAR-08 with less than 100 rounds through it for the OP.

Buy ... build .. it doesn't matter! 

The bad guy will kill you with his Mosin Nagant long before he's within your 50-150 yard effective range anyway!    :shake:
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: z06psi on January 05, 2015, 09:35:03 PM
Lol. I have a .338 lapua that says otherwise.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: ren on January 05, 2015, 09:39:03 PM
  :rofl:
The bottom line is that every human being in the world, except for crazy cat, agrees that rifle rounds are lethal beyond 50&150 yards.  :rofl:
  [LOLabove]
 :rofl:           :rofl:        :rofl:       :rofl:           :rofl:     
         :rofl:       :rofl:
 :rofl:         :rofl:             :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: SpeedTek on January 05, 2015, 10:59:55 PM
BUILD Good parts are really reasonable now..........

(To all my buddies......My $600 AR is still more accurate that half you guys out there with or without sights! LOL)
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: crazy cat on January 06, 2015, 09:28:51 PM
Apparently, some people have problems with reading comprehension:

LOL..Lethal; sure, I've killed pigs with a .223.  The problem is that sometimes they don't drop, they run off into the forest and I don't find them until they start to smell.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: z06psi on January 07, 2015, 06:16:35 AM
Apparently, some people have problems with reading comprehension:

But they still die.  Therefore lethal.
Title: Re: Build or buy an ar 15
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 07, 2015, 01:39:51 PM
But they still die.  Therefore lethal.

 :worship: