2aHawaii
General Topics => Off Topic => Topic started by: eyeeatingfish on November 02, 2015, 05:52:08 AM
-
I have been wondering and hoping that HPD has some sort of plan in regards to the gun registration list if we are ever invaded by a foreign nation. I don't expect that anyone here would know but just throwing it out there as a conversation piece.
I would imagine any foreign military would go straight to HPD and demand a list of all gun owners so they could take away all the guns. I think it would be wise of someone at HPD to destroy the records in the event that we were ever invaded.
-
I have been wondering and hoping that HPD has some sort of plan in regards to the gun registration list if we are ever invaded by a foreign nation. I don't expect that anyone here would know but just throwing it out there as a conversation piece.
I would imagine any foreign military would go straight to HPD and demand a list of all gun owners so they could take away all the guns. I think it would be wise of someone at HPD to destroy the records in the event that we were ever invaded.
Wolverines!
-
I think that would be pretty far down on the "to do" list.
Sounds like job for the wolverines!
-
you mean like this?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vmrYVJWwBfE
Chief Kealoha would gladly give out a list of all the gun owners in the City of Honolulu because that's one thing less his dept. has to do....
.
.
.
as long as his mailbox is safe and secure :thumbsup:
just kidding
Happy Monday.
I have faith that our own officials would not cave in without a fight to some foreign nation invasion.
Besides they don't have to
They have hoards of "undocumented" immigrants to do that.
“The supreme art of war is to subdue the enemy without fighting.”
― Sun Tzu, The Art of War
-
It was enough to stop japan from trying to just stomp on over. I think it was said something like if we try to march in there would be a armed American behind every blade of grass.
-
Wolverines!
I think we should stick to our native habitat, so maybe..MONGOOSES!!! :shaka:
-
To me a foreign occupation or tyrannical government would not worry about registration lists. Many will be arrested without cause regardless.
Plus those of us still around would be out of ammo anyway. ;)
-
It was enough to stop japan from trying to just stomp on over. I think it was said something like if we try to march in there would be a armed American behind every blade of grass.
"You cannot invade mainland America. There would be a rifle behind every blade of grass."
Admiral Isoruku Yamamoto
They could easily have taken Hawaii had they brought an invasion force with them on December 7th 1941. I doubt the islands would have taken more than 6 weeks to fall. The mainland would've been an entirely different story. You have to remember they didn't really want "war" with the U.S. They wanted us out of the way, so they could consolidate their gains in China and Southeast Asia. They figured we would sue for peace after such a stunning loss of our naval power in the pacific. It probably would've worked too, considering the political climate at the time, had the Japanese embassy in D.C. gotten the message delivered before the attack as intended.
-
Let's say there was a totalitarian country out there bat shit crazy enough to take the United States head on - let's just call them country X. And let's say country X did manage to successfully invade the islands. They can have the list for all the good it would do them.
Just like Dirty pointed out, the parts of the population would rise up against this aggressor. Not all would take up arms and resist, but many would. Just think, who of us here would let ourselves be subject to living out the rest of our days in "chains"?
To me that's not living. I'd rather go out on my own terms than live in "slavery" - better to die on my feet than live on my knees.
-
HPD has some sort of plan in regards to the gun registration list if we are ever invaded by a foreign nation.
(http://i.imgur.com/3UwUaw2.gif)
(http://i.giphy.com/O5NyCibf93upy.gif)
(http://i.giphy.com/Ic97mPViHEG5O.gif)
More like they will probably just hand the list over.
-
I'm more worried about HPD having our info and knocking on the door.
-
I'm more worried about HPD having our info and knocking on the door.
Thats exactly what would have happened if the 50BMG law had passed.
There are less than 100 of these firearms registered in the State. Small enough to manage a confiscation team.
-
Just like Dirty pointed out, the parts of the population would rise up against this aggressor. Not all would take up arms and resist, but many would. Just think, who of us here would let ourselves be subject to living out the rest of our days in "chains"?
To me that's not living. I'd rather go out on my own terms than live in "slavery" - better to die on my feet than live on my knees.
That sounds romantic and all, but have you ever been on the receiving end of a navy warship missile? Perhaps a drone equipped with .50 or 20mm rounds and/or rockets? How about facing a symmetrical force of 1,000, let alone 10,000, with full infantry, armor, aircraft and navy support, in a direct assault on your position?
A lot of people have this image burned into their mind that it's going to turn out like Red Dawn, with 2a owners coming together to fight the evil occupying army and that they are simply going to roll over, because we are so much superior to them after watching magpul dvds; this simply isn't the case. Even those of us who have served in the military and deployed do not know what it's like to fight a large scale symmetrical force, let alone a large asymmetrical force, and we haven't had any experience in this realm since WWII. Imagine what Afghanistan or Iraq would be like if there were no rules in place for the US, and how quickly the populations would have been wiped out if Total War had been declared; that's what would probably happen if nation X would invade and reached occupation, because nation X would likely be a nation that doesn't give a shit about the rules and will do everything to win.
People really need to start reading legitimate symmetrical and asymmetrical warfare doctrine and stop letting movies influence their outlook on such situations. It's easy to say you will fight to the death and that you would rather die on your feet than live on your knees, but when the lives of your loved ones, neighbors, friends and/or hundreds or thousands of people hang in the balance, it's not as easy a choice as people think it is.
-
I have little doubt our elected officials would roll over like a crack whore for a $10 bill.
They'd do anything to keep their status and save their own skins.
The vast majority of the populace would go along, just promise them their cable and UH sports won't be interrupted.
-
That sounds romantic and all, but have you ever been on the receiving end of a navy warship missile? Perhaps a drone equipped with .50 or 20mm rounds and/or rockets? How about facing a symmetrical force of 1,000, let alone 10,000, with full infantry, armor, aircraft and navy support, in a direct assault on your position?
A lot of people have this image burned into their mind that it's going to turn out like Red Dawn, with 2a owners coming together to fight the evil occupying army and that they are simply going to roll over, because we are so much superior to them after watching magpul dvds; this simply isn't the case. Even those of us who have served in the military and deployed do not know what it's like to fight a large scale symmetrical force, let alone a large asymmetrical force, and we haven't had any experience in this realm since WWII. Imagine what Afghanistan or Iraq would be like if there were no rules in place for the US, and how quickly the populations would have been wiped out if Total War had been declared; that's what would probably happen if nation X would invade and reached occupation, because nation X would likely be a nation that doesn't give a shit about the rules and will do everything to win.
People really need to start reading legitimate symmetrical and asymmetrical warfare doctrine and stop letting movies influence their outlook on such situations. It's easy to say you will fight to the death and that you would rather die on your feet than live on your knees, but when the lives of your loved ones, neighbors, friends and/or hundreds or thousands of people hang in the balance, it's not as easy a choice as people think it is.
Good points. An armed public might be a deterrent but if it came down to the public fighting a professional military, we wouldn't stand much of a chance. We might slow them down though.
-
The only strategic benefit of Hawaii to any invading "country" is China, It has a population of over 1 BILLION with a standing active army of 2 MILLION. You'd run out of ammunition just trying to defend yourself.
Hawaii may be invaded and the Sun will die, but not in our lifetime.
-
The only strategic benefit of Hawaii to any invading "country" is China, It has a population of over 1 BILLION with a standing active army of 2 MILLION. You'd run out of ammunition just trying to defend yourself.
Hawaii may be invaded and the Sun will die, but not in our lifetime.
When was the last time China invaded a country that wasn't on it's immediate borders? That is not Chinese military doctrine, and invasion of countries outside it's immediate vicinity is only used in last ditch efforts and worst case scenarios.
And Hawaii is the most central land mass between Asia and North America, which gives it's controllers the ability to refuel and replenish supplies at the mid-point between the two continents, have a standing army ready to deploy at the halfway point between the two continents, and reduces the distance for Intercontinental Ballistic Missiles by over 3,000 miles, meaning lighter grade missiles that cost less can be far more effective.
I'm sure there are a lot more countries interested in Hawaii than China, especially if they are vying for control of the world.
-
Good point, Q. If China was going to invade a country across the ocean, it would be Taiwan.
-
Good point, Q. If China was going to invade a country across the ocean, it would be Taiwan.
Taiwan has mandatory gun registration , including black powder hunting guns. and permit to own (shotguns/ 22 only) are only giving to wealthy skeet club members.
Illegal guns/ homemade guns in the hands of the underground are not traceable.
-
That sounds romantic and all, but have you ever been on the receiving end of a navy warship missile? Perhaps a drone equipped with .50 or 20mm rounds and/or rockets? How about facing a symmetrical force of 1,000, let alone 10,000, with full infantry, armor, aircraft and navy support, in a direct assault on your position?
A lot of people have this image burned into their mind that it's going to turn out like Red Dawn, with 2a owners coming together to fight the evil occupying army and that they are simply going to roll over, because we are so much superior to them after watching magpul dvds; this simply isn't the case. Even those of us who have served in the military and deployed do not know what it's like to fight a large scale symmetrical force, let alone a large asymmetrical force, and we haven't had any experience in this realm since WWII. Imagine what Afghanistan or Iraq would be like if there were no rules in place for the US, and how quickly the populations would have been wiped out if Total War had been declared; that's what would probably happen if nation X would invade and reached occupation, because nation X would likely be a nation that doesn't give a shit about the rules and will do everything to win.
People really need to start reading legitimate symmetrical and asymmetrical warfare doctrine and stop letting movies influence their outlook on such situations. It's easy to say you will fight to the death and that you would rather die on your feet than live on your knees, but when the lives of your loved ones, neighbors, friends and/or hundreds or thousands of people hang in the balance, it's not as easy a choice as people think it is.
I'm not under any illusions of my chance and don't fancy myself an asymmetric guru ODA Ranger Delta SEAL. I see it this way, Country X is going to kill anyone they want whenever they want to - so anyone they capture is dead anyway. I'd rather go out at the time a place of my choosing.
-
China doesn't need to invade an island like ours - they can build islands :thumbsup:
(http://i2.cdn.turner.com/cnnnext/dam/assets/150217160111-china-janes-images-large-169.jpg)
-
When was the last time China invaded a country that wasn't on it's immediate borders? That is not Chinese military doctrine, and invasion of countries outside it's immediate vicinity is only used in last ditch efforts and worst case scenarios.
China probably would not have to invade Hawaii , but would be invited into Hawaii. Back in February a news article said that China would arm Hawaiian separatists if the U.S. continues to arm Taiwan. Maybe too much tinfoil but would the Kingdom welcome China's military support or if we lost the 25th would the dear leader keep Schofield open for Chinese troops to train at. These scenarios are not impossible compared to the headlines today.
Imagine the HVB's happy dance when China says they will send 500,000 tourists. Only problem is all will be male in their 20-30's and want to stay in Wahiawa.
-
China doesn't need to invade an island like ours - they can build islands :thumbsup:
(http://i2.cdn.turner.com/cnnnext/dam/assets/150217160111-china-janes-images-large-169.jpg)
They can only build islands on reefs, not in the middle of the pacific ocean.
-
When was the last time China invaded a country that wasn't on it's immediate borders? That is not Chinese military doctrine, and invasion of countries outside it's immediate vicinity is only used in last ditch efforts and worst case scenarios.
And Hawaii is the most central land mass between Asia and North America, which gives it's controllers the ability to refuel and replenish supplies at the mid-point between the two continents, have a standing army ready to deploy at the halfway point between the two continents, and reduces the distance for Intercontinental Ballistic Missiles by over 3,000 miles, meaning lighter grade missiles that cost less can be far more effective.
I'm sure there are a lot more countries interested in Hawaii than China, especially if they are vying for control of the world.
Hawaii would certainly be of interest to Russia I think.
-
Hawaii would certainly be of interest to Russia I think.
What does Hawaii offer Russia of military or political importance that Cuba can not?
-
What does Hawaii offer Russia of military or political importance that Cuba can not?
Russia would need to navigate around Australia/Indonesia and Africa just to get to Cuba, which is a great distance to travel; requires a lot of resources, more than they needed in the Afghan conflict.
Russia likely wouldn't want to navigate around South America to get to Cuba, because that puts it too close to the US, and would be too expensive.
Hawaii is in the middle of the Pacific Ocean, the halfway point between Asia and North America, and can sustain life on a large scale; that's what makes it so valuable, and why Russia would be interested if the US bailed out.
-
Russian Hawaiians
-
Russia would need to navigate around Australia/Indonesia and Africa just to get to Cuba, which is a great distance to travel; requires a lot of resources, more than they needed in the Afghan conflict.
Russia likely wouldn't want to navigate around South America to get to Cuba, because that puts it too close to the US, and would be too expensive.
Hawaii is in the middle of the Pacific Ocean, the halfway point between Asia and North America, and can sustain life on a large scale; that's what makes it so valuable, and why Russia would be interested if the US bailed out.
That answers why Hawaii is a better location than Cuba from a ocean voyage perspective. Assuming planes still fly and can get to both islands, again, what political or military purpose would either island serve Russia?
In other words, is there a risk of Russia attacking the US Mainland? If not, what's the benefit of controlling Hawaii militarily or politically? Russia is already a stone's throw from Japan. It's not like they need a stopping point to get to the rest of the Pacific Rim.
-
This is all pretty entertaining. If we were invaded, firearms registration records would be the least of our worries. The idea that an invading force will track you down that way is just FUD used in movies for dramatic effect. But since this is a hypothetical, I'm pretty sure things would fall in line with what Q said. It won't be about who has guns, but who is willing to take them up and become a threat.
In reality, Hawaii has never been a target for invasion and the likelihood of it in the modern age of warfare is nonexistent. Our location being of strategic value ended with the age of sail and the only natural resources we have is fresh water and a little agriculture. Just think of the logistical requirements for an invasion then occupation and you'll see it's never going to happen.
-
This is all pretty entertaining. If we were invaded, firearms registration records would be the least of our worries. The idea that an invading force will track you down that way is just FUD used in movies for dramatic effect. But since this is a hypothetical, I'm pretty sure things would fall in line with what Q said. It won't be about who has guns, but who is willing to take them up and become a threat.
In reality, Hawaii has never been a target for invasion and the likelihood of it in the modern age of warfare is nonexistent. Our location being of strategic value ended with the age of sail and the only natural resources we have is fresh water and a little agriculture. Just think of the logistical requirements for an invasion then occupation and you'll see it's never going to happen.
There's a twist to the plot if Hawaii were invaded compared to Calumet, CO, in the movie Red Dawn. Hawaii has a pretty substantial military presence. Personnel, arms, ammo, heavy weapons, protective gear, high tech weapons, comms, Intel, and other in-place supplies.
Add to that the civilian population, law enforcement, the weapons, ammo, and gear available from those sources, and the vast Naval assets in port, deployed, and in transit, I believe any force that attempted to invade would have to catch our forces by total surprise. I hope we learned some valuable lessons from the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor that will give us much earlier warning than we had on that day.
-
Hawaii would certainly be of interest to Russia I think.
Not really. Since the fall of the Soviet Union, Russia has been a regional power, like China, but with far less global influence.
-
There's a twist to the plot if Hawaii were invaded compared to Calumet, CO, in the movie Red Dawn. Hawaii has a pretty substantial military presence. Personnel, arms, ammo, heavy weapons, protective gear, high tech weapons, comms, Intel, and other in-place supplies.
Add to that the civilian population, law enforcement, the weapons, ammo, and gear available from those sources, and the vast Naval assets in port, deployed, and in transit, I believe any force that attempted to invade would have to catch our forces by total surprise. I hope we learned some valuable lessons from the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor that will give us much earlier warning then we had on that day.
Without a doubt our military presence would be a factor, but even without it there would be no threat of invasion. And that might be the case if Congress ever revisits the DoD report .
I think where we might differ is on the civilian population & law enforcement. Other than those with prior service, I don't put much into their combat effectiveness or willingness to fight.
BIG thumbs up for referencing the classic and knowing where. :thumbsup:
-
Without a doubt our military presence would be a factor, but even without it there would be no threat of invasion. And that might be the case if Congress ever revisits the DoD report .
I think where we might differ is on the civilian population & law enforcement. Other than those with prior service, I don't put much into their combat effectiveness or willingness to fight.
BIG thumbs up for referencing the classic and knowing where. :thumbsup:
Well, you're just not playing by the rules! :D
The topic supposes Hawaii has been invaded. Taking the invasion out of the equation changes the premise entirely.
Given Hawaii's pineapples and kukui nuts are enough to push another country into invasion, would our gun registration list pose a problem for legal gun owners?
My previous answer wasn't explicit, but what I was implying was, the invasion would have a very difficult time succeeding to a point where that registration list would ever be a problem for us.
Plus, there is a huge former military, reserve, guard, and military family member population who have the willingness and aptitude, if not current training, to augment the existing active military forces. Even if everyone can't fight, there are plenty of behind the lines jobs needing to be done! :thumbsup:
-
Well, you're just not playing by the rules! :D
The topic supposes Hawaii has been invaded. Taking the invasion out of the equation changes the premise entirely.
Given Hawaii's pineapples and kukui nuts are enough to push another country into invasion, would our gun registration list pose a problem for legal gun owners?
My previous answer wasn't explicit, but what I was implying was, the invasion would have a very difficult time succeeding to a point where that registration list would ever be a problem for us.
Plus, there is a huge former military, reserve, guard, and military family member population who have the willingness and aptitude, if not current training, to augment the existing active military forces. Even if everyone can't fight, there are plenty of behind the lines jobs needing to be done! :thumbsup:
RUUUULLES are for FOOOOLs :-\...but ok fine. I'll play along and amend my last, "there would be no little threat of invasion". Are we applying standard ROE for the invading force or is it a total war scenario for this "protect our nuts" hypothetical? Ah, doesn't matter....I agree it would be difficult (I want to say impossible) before any registration list would be taken. By that time, gun owners would have had the time to GTFO or surrender their weapon one bullet at a time.
Maybe you missed the prior service part or just misread it. I have no doubt that the warrior ethos is still in those you mentioned and that they'll remember their training and fight. It's the "pure" civilian that I question. I'm not sure what your MOS was (or rating, I'm fairly certain you're no squid) , so perhaps we have differing ideas of what invasion means. But there is no "behind the lines", anyone capable of doing so would have to either take up arms and fight or not.
-
A lot of pure civilians did some real damage in Vietnam and Afghanistan.
Guerrilla warfare.
Catch 'em in the jungles with the hunters.
Mongooses !
-
China probably would not have to invade Hawaii , but would be invited into Hawaii. Back in February a news article said that China would arm Hawaiian separatists if the U.S. continues to arm Taiwan. Maybe too much tinfoil but would the Kingdom welcome China's military support or if we lost the 25th would the dear leader keep Schofield open for Chinese troops to train at. These scenarios are not impossible compared to the headlines today.
Imagine the HVB's happy dance when China says they will send 500,000 tourists. Only problem is all will be male in their 20-30's and want to stay in Wahiawa.
First of all, that article is incorrect as there is no such thing as "Hawaiian separatists". Hawaii is illegally occupied by the US based on both US and International Law. Secondly, you ask, "would the restored Hawaiian Nation welcome China's military?" The correct answer is a resounding yes, but not because of politics; but because of Hawaii Kingdom Law which declared to the International community that Hawaii was a neutral State similar to Switzerland. Consequently, all navies around the World would be welcomed in Hawaii's ports as long as they pay their port fees and leave when their stay is over.
Kuleana
-
Good point, Q. If China was going to invade a country across the ocean, it would be Taiwan.
If China decides to invade Taiwan, it would be invading a province of China. Taiwan is not an internationally recognized country nor has any legal basis to become one.
Kuleana
-
First of all, that article is incorrect as there is no such thing as "Hawaiian separatists". Hawaii is illegally occupied by the US based on both US and International Law. Secondly, you ask, "would the restored Hawaiian Nation welcome China's military?" The correct answer is a resounding yes, but not because of politics; but because of Hawaii Kingdom Law which declared to the International community that Hawaii was a neutral State similar to Switzerland. Consequently, all navies around the World would be welcomed in Hawaii's ports as long as they pay their port fees and leave when their stay is over.
Kuleana
Oh, here we go again with the imaginary Hawaiian Kingdom bullshit.
Well, the good thing is that if China or Russia (or anyone else for that matter) ever came to Hawaii, they would wipe these Hawaiian kingdom asshats off the planet. Most people can't stand their bullshit, most people don't care, so I highly doubt countries with the track records of Russia and China would give two shits either.
Consequently, all navies around the World would be welcomed in Hawaii's ports as long as they pay their port fees and leave when their stay is over.
Love how you proclaimed yourself emissary to the kingdom of fairy world, btw, and are telling us how it is going to be.
I might as well declare myself Emperor of the Oceania while I'm still ahead...Empires beat kingdoms, so suck it Hawaiian Kingdom; I rule you.
-
First of all, that article is incorrect as there is no such thing as "Hawaiian separatists". Hawaii is illegally occupied by the US based on both US and International Law. Secondly, you ask, "would the restored Hawaiian Nation welcome China's military?" The correct answer is a resounding yes, but not because of politics; but because of Hawaii Kingdom Law which declared to the International community that Hawaii was a neutral State similar to Switzerland. Consequently, all navies around the World would be welcomed in Hawaii's ports as long as they pay their port fees and leave when their stay is over.
Kuleana
Of course there are no Hawaiian Separatists...if there were the US govt. would squash 'em. You guys ike the luxury of freedom but are too chicken shit to separate yourself from the very country that provides it.
Chinese Navy pay your port fees? :crazy: :crazy: :crazy: :crazy: :crazy: :crazy: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
They build islands on reefs. They would probably say F*CK your fees b!otch!!! :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: The Chinese are all about bringing resources back to the motherland. They'd rape Hawaiian lands.
-
First of all, that article is incorrect as there is no such thing as "Hawaiian separatists". Hawaii is illegally occupied by the US based on both US and International Law. Secondly, you ask, "would the restored Hawaiian Nation welcome China's military?" The correct answer is a resounding yes, but not because of politics; but because of Hawaii Kingdom Law which declared to the International community that Hawaii was a neutral State similar to Switzerland. Consequently, all navies around the World would be welcomed in Hawaii's ports as long as they pay their port fees and leave when their stay is over.
Kuleana
Well there we go, no invasion just the open door.
-
This is all pretty entertaining. If we were invaded, firearms registration records would be the least of our worries. The idea that an invading force will track you down that way is just FUD used in movies for dramatic effect. But since this is a hypothetical, I'm pretty sure things would fall in line with what Q said. It won't be about who has guns, but who is willing to take them up and become a threat.
In reality, Hawaii has never been a target for invasion and the likelihood of it in the modern age of warfare is nonexistent. Our location being of strategic value ended with the age of sail and the only natural resources we have is fresh water and a little agriculture. Just think of the logistical requirements for an invasion then occupation and you'll see it's never going to happen.
Even if Russia might not want to occupy the islands, they might see value in ensuring the USA doesn't occupy the islands. An occupation might not meant to be forever either, just temporarily for the purposes of a war.
-
First of all, that article is incorrect as there is no such thing as "Hawaiian separatists". Hawaii is illegally occupied by the US based on both US and International Law. Secondly, you ask, "would the restored Hawaiian Nation welcome China's military?" The correct answer is a resounding yes, but not because of politics; but because of Hawaii Kingdom Law which declared to the International community that Hawaii was a neutral State similar to Switzerland. Consequently, all navies around the World would be welcomed in Hawaii's ports as long as they pay their port fees and leave when their stay is over.
Kuleana
So..... You're saying that the "Hawaiian Nation" would do the same thing that led to the supposed "occupation" by the U.S. and hope for a different outcome?
That goes a long way towards explaining why so many people here vote "D" despite the idiocy we see in our state government.
-
So..... You're saying that the "Hawaiian Nation" would do the same thing that led to the supposed "occupation" by the U.S. and hope for a different outcome?
That goes a long way towards explaining why so many people here vote "D" despite the idiocy we see in our state government.
You need to reread the history what led to the illegal take-over by the United States. The illegal takeover was instigated primarily by greedy American-Born Hawaiian nationals who conspired with expansionist leaning officials within the US Government at the time.
For another take-over to happen again in Hawaii by say Russia or China would require similar ethnic Russian or Chinese-Born Hawaiian nationals within Hawaii to do the same.
Kuleana
-
You need to reread the history what led to the illegal take-over by the United States. The illegal takeover was instigated primarily by greedy American-Born Hawaiian nationals who conspired with expansionist leaning officials within the US Government at the time.
For another take-over to happen again in Hawaii by say Russia or China would require similar ethnic Russian or Chinese-Born Hawaiian nationals within Hawaii to do the same.
Kuleana
Uhh, right. Because there aren't any "Russian or Chinese born Hawaiian Nationals" here now? Because Russia and China don't have "expansionist" policies?
Please read up on current events regarding Crimea and the Spratly islands.
-
Uhh, right. Because there aren't any "Russian or Chinese born Hawaiian Nationals" here now? Because Russia and China don't have "expansionist" policies?
Please read up on current events regarding Crimea and the Spratly islands.
The jury as to the sovereignty of Spratly Islands is still up for contention as it is currently being claimed by many nations, not just China. As for Crimea, the people of that country held a referendum to cede from Ukraine and asked to join the Russian Federation. Russia did not invade and take Crimea by force.
Kuleana
-
Let's put this to rest with one simple question for Kuleana, so we can get :stopjack:
Kuleana: have you renounced your American citizenship yet? Being that the occupation of Hawaii is illegal in your eyes, that must also mean your American citizenship is illegal as well. So have you renounced your American citizenship and embraced your Hawaii National citizenship yet? If not, why?
I will gladly pay for you to free yourself from the unbearable chains of bondage that the US has put on you; let me know when you are ready if you haven't done so already.
OK, :stopjack:
-
.
-
WTF... didn't this discussion already happen in another thread?!?
Yup.
Hawaiian kingdom advocates always seem to find ways to infiltrate a discussion to promote their bullshit ideas about imaginary kingdoms and how their magical unicorn government still exists, yet get awfully quiet when you ask if they have renounced their citizenship, or what they would do if someone would be willing to pay for the entire trip to have them renounce their citizenship.
-
Even if Russia might not want to occupy the islands, they might see value in ensuring the USA doesn't occupy the islands. An occupation might not meant to be forever either, just temporarily for the purposes of a war.
Wanting to and having the ability to do so are important factors to any scenario. As I said in the previous post, both Russia and China are regional powers. Anyone with a knowledge of what that means and basic military history would understand. Neither nation will take invasive actions outside (or near to) their contiguous areas. If you think it'd be to start a war? Well, they can easily start a war with actions closer to home, think: Kuril Islands/Japan, Taiwan, South Korea, etc....REGIONAL.
I'm sure none of this is going to satisfy your "but why?", "how come?", or "what if?" line of thinking, so lets just go back to: "HPD plan for gun registration list if Hawaii ever invaded?". No plan. None needed. Not going to happen. List is not relevant.
-
Barring a world war or something similarly disruptive, the most likely "invader" would be some kind of world government police entity like the UN.
Under the guise of "legitimacy" and how our state seem to support feel-good big-government type officials, HPD might be ordered to share / willingly share the list over in exchange for some funding in the spirit of kumbaya and cooperation.
Isn't this already happening at the federal level? Not much more of a jump for this to happen in a global level. Plus it would happen without any bloodshed.