2aHawaii

General Topics => Preparedness and Survival => Topic started by: blackheart0311 on December 29, 2015, 09:56:31 PM

Title: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on December 29, 2015, 09:56:31 PM
Anyone got any tips on making a vegetable garden with red dirt?  Will it take a year with compost and everything to rejuvenate the soil?

Any recommendations?

Thanks!
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on December 30, 2015, 12:05:11 AM
Anyone got any tips on making a vegetable garden with red dirt?  Will it take a year with compost and everything to rejuvenate the soil?

Any recommendations?

Thanks!

Yeah: don't.



How much area do you plan on working with?

Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on December 30, 2015, 08:51:58 AM
Around a 3x6 area.  Kinda small.

I was thinking dig in with some compost and rich soil. 
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Rocky on December 30, 2015, 09:35:30 AM
Buying compost and rich soil is stupidly expensive. 
Buying dirt is like buying water.  :crazy:

Make your own dirt and compost. :geekdanc:
Now is not the best time to plant and you've got till spring to build up the soil.
Start your compost pile right in your proposed garden area then till/turn it into the red dirt soil before planting.  :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on December 30, 2015, 09:45:04 AM
Buying compost and rich soil is stupidly expensive. 
Buying dirt is like buying water.  :crazy:

Make your own dirt and compost. :geekdanc:
Now is not the best time to plant and you've got till spring to build up the soil.
Start your compost pile right in your proposed garden area then till/turn it into the red dirt soil before planting.  :thumbsup:

Exactly why I want to start doing soil stuff now...

How long does it take to make adequate compost? 
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on December 30, 2015, 09:49:33 AM
Around a 3x6 area.  Kinda small.

I was thinking dig in with some compost and rich soil.

Where do you live
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on December 30, 2015, 10:12:11 AM
Where do you live

Waikele area.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on December 30, 2015, 11:22:20 AM
Waikele area.

Go to the Menehune Magic processing facility in Kapolei and pick up a cubic yard of soil. If you can't pick it up all at one time, they sell it in 1/4 cubic yard.

If you can afford it, I suggest mixing in cinder rocks at a ratio of 5:1, compost:cinder

Build a (2) 3x3 raised beds, 8-12 inches deep. You can use wood or cinder block; whatever floats your boat.

Till the soil under the beds about 6-12 inches down, and mix in an equal part of compost.

Fill the beds with the rest of the compost until it is approximately 2 inches from the top.

Let this sit for 2 weeks before planting, watering once a week if dry.


I build gardens for people, and raised beds are the best bet for people with clay soil.


Making compost can take up to a year and must be done correctly; just go buy some already made stuff to get going, and then start making your own.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on December 30, 2015, 11:22:49 AM
.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: bass monkey on December 30, 2015, 12:25:21 PM
You can also make your own bio char fairly easy and cheaply. Just "season" it, I know that's the wrong term, before you throw it into the garden so it doesn't bind any nutrients for your plants
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on December 30, 2015, 03:36:15 PM
Q:  Thanks!  What's the recommended ratio of soil to compost to start off with?

bass monkey:  I had to google what biochar is... but makes sense since the old "slash and burn" worked back in the day.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on December 30, 2015, 07:56:51 PM
Q:  Thanks!  What's the recommended ratio of soil to compost to start off with?

bass monkey:  I had to google what biochar is... but makes sense since the old "slash and burn" worked back in the day.

Just make a raised bed and fill it with pure compost. Another option to look into is the Mittleider Method, which is essentially hydroponics using a special growing media. Personally, I prefer option one because it's more"natural" and better for the aina.

I've been making biochar for about 3 years now, and you really need know what you are doing if you plan on using it. It's not so forgiving during the first season, but line wine gets better with age. Also, it's a long term investment in your soil, so build right the first time so it lasts as long as possible.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on December 30, 2015, 09:14:16 PM
Just make a raised bed and fill it with pure compost. Another option to look into is the Mittleider Method, which is essentially hydroponics using a special growing media. Personally, I prefer option one because it's more"natural" and better for the aina.

I've been making biochar for about 3 years now, and you really need know what you are doing if you plan on using it. It's not so forgiving during the first season, but line wine gets better with age. Also, it's a long term investment in your soil, so build right the first time so it lasts as long as possible.

Pure compost as soil?  Would I need to reinforce it with NPK, calcium, sulfur, or magnesium?

And I want to for sure do this right from the beginning.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Teichi on December 31, 2015, 08:46:38 AM
Tree trimmers dump shredded material near city gardens/parks and it is free for the taking. Look for the the stuff that has been sitting a while. Watch out for the centipedes.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: dustoff003 on December 31, 2015, 09:19:58 AM

Tree trimmers dump shredded material near city gardens/parks and it is free for the taking. Look for the the stuff that has been sitting a while. Watch out for the centipedes.
There are usually piles at the SGT Smith community garden across Kamehameha Hwy. from Wheeler AAF also.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Rocky on December 31, 2015, 09:39:14 AM
Pure compost as soil?  Would I need to reinforce it with NPK, calcium, sulfur, or magnesium?

And I want to for sure do this right from the beginning.

 Usually don't  plant in straight compost, too "hot" with ammonia, nitrogen and bacteria.
Immature compost can also rob nitrogen from the soil
Compost is  generally used as an additive to enrich soil and to hold moisture or as a topping around plants to further enrich soil, hold moisture and deter weeds from growing around plants.
(ever notice when compost is placed around plants, nothing grows in it?).

  We make our own compost with our yard clippings / cut grass (sans weeds or seeds), chicken coop poop and pine shavings.
   Some kitchen scraps that don't go to worms or chickens are also added.

  We "Hot Compost" which means we actively water, turn and aerate our pile (pile #1) to keep the pile "Hot"and get decent compost in 3-4 months.
The heat comes from the bacteria/bacteriea and chemicals and resulting in heat
Tilling the pile, making things are cut as small as possible and managing the green to brown ratio makes it quicker.

  "Cold" or "Lazy" composting is just throwing everything in a pile and letting nature take it's course which will take about a year.
After Pile #1 reaches a decomposed, wet yet separable state, it is usable for tilling into soil or as a topping or our pile #2.

  Pile #2 goes into an aerated garbage can for a while to cook for a couple months more.
It's then spread out on the driveway and separated further and allowed to dry slightly
This gives you what you buy bagged in the store.

  To be even further opcd'd,  I might add a little of our worm poop, (vermacast) and maybe a bit of sand and back into a container that is not ventilated and let that sit covered for a couple months more.
Now I have dirt and feel as though i have actually created earth, how Godlike.
(How's that working for you DL ?)
This dirt should still be "cut" as it is nutrient omnipotent.

  Yes, you can cheat and buy soil and that may be a good way for you to start and get plants in the ground or raised bed OFF of the ground.
We usually dig the hole, fill with good soil and plant.
When the plant has cycled thru life, the soil is further enriched when we till the soil to repeat the process.

Having a good a compost system backed by a worm farm to me is essential for gardening.
I'l be damned if I ever "BUY" dirt or compost again.
Your compost pile and dirt should never smell bad, but "earthy"?)

You might also be interested in the bucket method, depends on what you are planting.
Bucket method is AWESOME for greens like spinach, Kale, lettuce etc...

Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on December 31, 2015, 10:56:54 AM
Thanks guys!

Rocky:  Someone had mentioned the bucket method to me.  That may be the way I am going. 

I went to Lowe's last night just to take a look at what they have there.  I noticed the bagged soil and soil mixes they had there, had lots of wood chips in them... I am planning to mix whatever soil I use (bought or not) with menehune magic compost.  Would I be able to mix the red dirt I have in my yard with compost and use that with some vegetable fertilizer?


All you guys talking about compost and biochar seem to have a pretty good operation going on.  Haha.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Rocky on January 03, 2016, 08:40:17 AM
Thanks guys!

Rocky:  Someone had mentioned the bucket method to me.  That may be the way I am going. 

Actually, the bucket method I was talking about is a cheap & lazy type of hydroponics.
2.5 gallon bucket with holes in top and filled with fertilized water 
Posted some where here in this topic or maybe Off Topic.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: bass monkey on January 03, 2016, 08:52:37 AM
Actually, the bucket method I was talking about is a cheap & lazy type of hydroponics.
2.5 gallon bucket with holes in top and filled with fertilized water 
Posted some where here in this topic or maybe Off Topic.

What kind of fertilized water do you put? Do you have a home blend?, cause I'm sure you could also buy hydroponic type stuff.
This looks like a great idea though, I might have to do this in another location where there is no yard, just lanai/balcony space.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Rocky on January 03, 2016, 01:27:47 PM
What kind of fertilized water do you put? Do you have a home blend?, cause I'm sure you could also buy hydroponic type stuff.
This looks like a great idea though, I might have to do this in another location where there is no yard, just lanai/balcony space.
You can use hydroponic stuff, worm juice, your own blend.. whatever is specific to what your growing.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on January 03, 2016, 07:49:05 PM
Interesting. 

Rocky: What's the purpose for having the lid on and only growing through the holes?
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: hvybarrels on January 03, 2016, 08:56:02 PM
There's a SoilWeb app for iphone and android that will give you the soil type for your gps coordinates. It's not probably not worth your time to get it tested unless you are using a large area but if it's bright red then chances are it's high in manganese and aluminum, low in calcium, zinc, boron, and ph. Being that close to industrial sites I'd encourage you to use raised beds and mix your own using commonly found ingredient lists in order to avoid accidentally ingesting toxic waste and heavy metals. Square Foot Gardening is a good book for beginners and if you can follow a recipe to bake a cake from scratch then the most difficult part will be chasing down the shopping list.

The most exciting development in organic ag right now is worm compost tea sprayed directly under the leaf and fed through drip line. It actually release some chemical compounds that can match the size gains of Miracle Grow/NPK bombs, with the added benefit of your veggies not tasting like plastic.

You'll also need to look into pesticides like Neem Oil, Entrust, and Pyganic because the bugs are brutal and unfortunately overspraying has made a lot of them (especially Diamondback Moth) immune to a lot of stuff. Overspray also kills the mini-wasps that are their natural enemies, as well as other beneficial insects that you want hanging around to keep the aphids, mites, and thrips under control. Use sparingly and rotate often.

Then there are of course birds, plant diseases, infected feral cats using it like a litter box, and scariest of all the Rat Lung Worm which actually rots away chunks of your brain and turns people into either stuttering idiots or violent psychopaths.

It's totally worth it, just make sure you wash your harvest really well and keep your tools clean.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: hvybarrels on January 03, 2016, 09:01:56 PM
http://www.malamaopuna.org/ratlung/needtoknow.php

More info on Rat Lungworm. Keep that Sluggo handy and kill those snails and slugs whenever you see them. Just don't lick your fingers after you pick them up.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: GZire on January 04, 2016, 11:05:12 AM
http://www.malamaopuna.org/ratlung/needtoknow.php

More info on Rat Lungworm. Keep that Sluggo handy and kill those snails and slugs whenever you see them. Just don't lick your fingers after you pick them up.


Pretty gnarly stuff that happened to that kid from the Big Island several years back.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on January 04, 2016, 05:41:28 PM
http://www.malamaopuna.org/ratlung/needtoknow.php

More info on Rat Lungworm. Keep that Sluggo handy and kill those snails and slugs whenever you see them. Just don't lick your fingers after you pick them up.

Sounds like a good time!
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: yurcarmeean on January 04, 2016, 08:18:50 PM
Usually don't  plant in straight compost, too "hot" with ammonia, nitrogen and bacteria.
Immature compost can also rob nitrogen from the soil
Compost is  generally used as an additive to enrich soil and to hold moisture or as a topping around plants to further enrich soil, hold moisture and deter weeds from growing around plants.
(ever notice when compost is placed around plants, nothing grows in it?).

  We make our own compost with our yard clippings / cut grass (sans weeds or seeds), chicken coop poop and pine shavings.
   Some kitchen scraps that don't go to worms or chickens are also added.

  We "Hot Compost" which means we actively water, turn and aerate our pile (pile #1) to keep the pile "Hot"and get decent compost in 3-4 months.
The heat comes from the bacteria/bacteriea and chemicals and resulting in heat
Tilling the pile, making things are cut as small as possible and managing the green to brown ratio makes it quicker.

  "Cold" or "Lazy" composting is just throwing everything in a pile and letting nature take it's course which will take about a year.
After Pile #1 reaches a decomposed, wet yet separable state, it is usable for tilling into soil or as a topping or our pile #2.


Q or Rocky:
 
Can a cold/static compost pile be transformed back to a hot/wet/ biologically healthy compost pile?  If so, will watering and tilling be enough?  Thanks
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: macsak on January 04, 2016, 08:47:37 PM
Q or Rocky:
 
Can a cold/static compost pile be transformed back to a hot/wet/ biologically healthy compost pile?  If so, will watering and tilling be enough?  Thanks

yes, till and water, but the key part is getting the carbon:nitrogen ratio to be ideal
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on January 05, 2016, 11:25:31 AM
yes, till and water, but the key part is getting the carbon:nitrogen ratio to be ideal

Science bitches!
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on January 05, 2016, 11:52:22 AM
yes, till and water, but the key part is getting the carbon:nitrogen ratio to be ideal

Why till and water
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: macsak on January 05, 2016, 12:08:54 PM

Why till and water
add air and moisture and get some bacterial action going
Then the pile should heat up once the C:N ratio gets closer to ideal
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: macsak on January 05, 2016, 12:09:10 PM

add air and moisture and get some bacterial action going
Then the pile should heat up once the C:N ratio gets closer to ideal

Am I missing something?
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on January 05, 2016, 12:13:05 PM
Am I missing something?

Yes...that info is completely false.

Try again.  :grrr:
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: macsak on January 05, 2016, 12:19:56 PM
Yes...that info is completely false.

Try again.  :grrr:

so then edumacate us, Q
 :worship:
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Rocky on January 05, 2016, 04:04:04 PM
Am I missing something?

Air comes from more than tilling.
Container/bin what have you must have holes (heat rises)
Interesting. 

Rocky: What's the purpose for having the lid on and only growing through the holes?
You  must plant your seeds/seedlings in some type of medium (soil, peat, sphagnum moss etc..). The holes hold little aerated cups (forgot the technical term right now) that hold the medium in which you place your seedlings.
The medium absorbs the fertilized water which feeds the seed's/seedlings which grow roots through the medium and cup and down into the fertilized water.
As the water level go's down, the roots grow longer to keep n contact with the water.
phew

Instead of buying the ..  Ahh yes,  PETI POTS !, I used the "bark" from coconut trees to make a little peti pot cone and it worked fine
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on January 05, 2016, 08:33:50 PM
so then edumacate us, Q
 :worship:

I could explain it, but I will let the master do so:



https://youtu.be/nNMdWnfjs8s

https://youtu.be/XLJohF5h2y4

https://youtu.be/1aE4nfC5cYE

https://youtu.be/58UKUbRjrr8
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: macsak on January 05, 2016, 08:54:38 PM
I could explain it, but I will let the master do so:

mahalo for that, Q
but his question was about cold compost -> hot compost
not about soil and crops
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on January 05, 2016, 09:03:06 PM
mahalo for that, Q
but his question was about cold compost -> hot compost
not about soil and crops

Watch the videos.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on January 05, 2016, 11:03:29 PM
Do they count as college credits?  Maybe for Botany?
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Jl808 on January 06, 2016, 12:24:12 AM
Watched the video.. pretty cool stuff, Q.  Thanks for sharing!
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: yurcarmeean on January 07, 2016, 10:59:05 PM
thanks
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: hvybarrels on January 08, 2016, 08:02:56 PM
No-till is notoriously difficult in the tropics, specifically because there is no winter to kill off the bugs and no-till systems give them plenty of places to hide. It's not impossible, but this definitely ain't the mainland. With red soil you're going to have to incorporate organic matter at a rate of 10-20 tons per acre (about 1/4 inch layer of finished compost on the surface), and using a no-till system that would take forever. Better to give it a boost by adding your amendments and tilling it in, then put in a cover crop and see what happens before committing to an expensive mistake. Your cover will tell you if there's something wrong. 

Regardless everyone should have a backyard compost pile or a worm bin for kitchen scraps, and know how to use them. If you commit to no-till you can use the compost for seedling starters. Making the black stuff is super fun and rewarding.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: yurcarmeean on January 08, 2016, 09:16:10 PM
the health of my worm bin declined. I'm not exactly sure how it happened: either i   
1. neglected to turn it for an extended period of time or
2. too much scrap caused it to be too wet to sustain the worms
or both

now its a bug magnet, what's the best plan of action to turn my pile back into worm paradise?
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: macsak on January 08, 2016, 09:26:03 PM
the health of my worm bin declined. I'm not exactly sure how it happened: either i   
1. neglected to turn it for an extended period of time or
2. too much scrap caused it to be too wet to sustain the worms
or both

now its a bug magnet, what's the best plan of action to turn my pile back into worm paradise?

more likely too much scrap causing the bin to start to smell/attract bugs
bugs, especially ants seek out water/moisture
but bugs are part of the worm bin ecosystem
add paper/cardboard/coconut coir to soak up some of the moisture and add some airspace
make sure not adding fat, protein, or acidic foods/fruits/vegetables
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on January 08, 2016, 10:55:36 PM
the health of my worm bin declined. I'm not exactly sure how it happened: either i   
1. neglected to turn it for an extended period of time or
2. too much scrap caused it to be too wet to sustain the worms
or both

now its a bug magnet, what's the best plan of action to turn my pile back into worm paradise?

Start over
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on January 08, 2016, 11:21:36 PM
No-till is notoriously difficult in the tropics, specifically because there is no winter to kill off the bugs and no-till systems give them plenty of places to hide. It's not impossible, but this definitely ain't the mainland. With red soil you're going to have to incorporate organic matter at a rate of 10-20 tons per acre (about 1/4 inch layer of finished compost on the surface), and using a no-till system that would take forever. Better to give it a boost by adding your amendments and tilling it in, then put in a cover crop and see what happens before committing to an expensive mistake. Your cover will tell you if there's something wrong. 

Regardless everyone should have a backyard compost pile or a worm bin for kitchen scraps, and know how to use them. If you commit to no-till you can use the compost for seedling starters. Making the black stuff is super fun and rewarding.

Incorrect.

Because we do not have the same seasonal effects of temperate climates, biodegradation does not stop in tropical climates. Therefore, stuff is always 'composting'. Also, because things do not cool down, bugs are always present in a tropical climate, so it doesn't matter what you do unless you implement controls like insecticides, fungicides, etc.

The no-till presented in the videos are not the only form of no-till.

Forests dropping litter are no till,
Grass plains burning and regrowing are no till,
chopping and dropping and/or chop-and-char is also no till.

Tilling is specifically turning the soil to 'put oxygen into it', but all it does is destroy the microbial web that was formed by microorganisms and allow the next generation of microorganisms to feed of the previous generation. Repeated till eventually destroys all the nutrients and microbial life, at which point your land becomes marginal and unable to sustain life without nutrient inputs. 

You can easily implement no-till gardening with rotational cover crops by simply planting cover crops before and after a main crop is planted and harvested, then pulling them up and dropping them and/or chopping and dropping them prior to the next planting. This does not disturb the microbial web and keeps the soil 'healthy'.



'Organic material' is a general term that is not general understood.

Compost is organic material,
leaf litter is organic material,
rocks are organic material,
shit is organic material.

All but one of these breaks down into methane and carbon dioxide extremely quickly in tropical climates, so 'adding organic material' really doesn't do anything but add nutrients to the soil for short periods of time, typically 2-5 years before it completely decomposes.

What needs to happen is the reestablishment of CARBON in the soil. This can be done by inputting multiple thick layers of wood chips. The top layer of wood chips insulates the layers of wood chips from oxygen and biodegredation, thus slowing the biodegradation of the material and keeping it out of the methane and carbon cycle for a longer period of time. However, it will eventually re-enter the carbon cycle if it is utilized by other organisms that use it to create a carbon structure, i.e. trees.

The best form of carbon to reintroduce into the soil is natural charcoal, also known as biochar. Biochar is a fixed form of carbon with an estimated half-life of 1,000-10,000 years, so it completely removes carbon from the carbon cycle and fixes it to the soil for many generations. Biochar is also extremely absorbent, and thus absorbs and stores nutrients and minerals for extended periods of time for organisms that may utilize them. The structural profile of biochar also allows the colonization of various microbes that make up the soil web, as there is enough surface area in one handful of biochar to cover an entire football field. The final and most important aspect of biochar is it's ability to combine with dirt (clay, silt and sand) and organic matter, which in turn creates water soluble aggregates and forms the foundational basis of soil.


Another note on organic material: most of the nutrients for plant based microorganisms in the are not found in the growing media / soil, but in the trees and plants themselves. This is because of the rapid decomposition rate that takes place in the tropics due to the climate, which does not allow sufficient layers of organic material to build up over long periods of time. (remember: in temperate climates with a winter, it takes approximately 100 years to build just 1 inch of top soil naturally in the wild). Many people will claim that they live in very fertile areas, but this is because the soil they may grow in was untouched and allowed to build for hundreds of thousands of years, and cannot be replaced once exhausted

Because of this, tropical growing experts recommend that we focus on food trees rather than vegetable crops, as trees primarily mine their own nutrients in the soil via their root structure, then build the top soil by dropping their leaves (which contain all the minerals mined from the roots) in fall.

This is why I focus on pioneer trees and bamboo as a source for creating carbon in the soil, and resilient food trees like breadfruit and maya nut for food crops as they essentially take care of themselves.



As far as worm farms, I think they are a complete waste of time unless you have a fine tuned system that will not fail whatsoever, which is never the case. It is far more effective and efficient to utilize a microbial based composting system like bokashi, a better biological composting organism like black soldier flies or simply using foods craps and manure to make bio-fertilizers. The only worms I care about these days are the ones that are already present in the soil.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: macsak on January 09, 2016, 05:55:33 AM
a better biological composting organism like black soldier flies

were you able to get BSF going?
i remember a few years ago you saying that you weren't attracting BSF

my compost tumbler has BSF in it, but it sems like they are only really prevalent in the first 3 months or so of the year
usually by the middle of january or so, i cannot add stuff to the bin fast enough because the mass of larvae eats everything
but after winter is pau, there are only a few larvae at a time
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Rocky on January 09, 2016, 01:48:04 PM

   Till, no-till, Bio-char thermal decomposition, rotational cover crops,growing fruit trees to feed the soil,slash and burn, black soldier flies and worm farms and Gatorade (It's what plats crave !).
That's a lot to do before you get to plant a few tomatoes in a 3 x 6 area (which is about the size of my desk ! )

If you are ever coming up to the country around PCC, give me a call and I'll hook you up with some stuff to get you going.
 :shaka:
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: bass monkey on January 09, 2016, 02:48:43 PM
   Till, no-till, Bio-char thermal decomposition, rotational cover crops,growing fruit trees to feed the soil,slash and burn, black soldier flies and worm farms and Gatorade (It's what plats crave !).
That's a lot to do before you get to plant a few tomatoes in a 3 x 6 area (which is about the size of my desk ! )

If you are ever coming up to the country around PCC, give me a call and I'll hook you up with some stuff to get you going.
 :shaka:

How far up?
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on January 09, 2016, 06:39:20 PM
   Till, no-till, Bio-char thermal decomposition, rotational cover crops,growing fruit trees to feed the soil,slash and burn, black soldier flies and worm farms and Gatorade (It's what plats crave !).
That's a lot to do before you get to plant a few tomatoes in a 3 x 6 area (which is about the size of my desk ! )

If you are ever coming up to the country around PCC, give me a call and I'll hook you up with some stuff to get you going.
 :shaka:

Rocky:  Thanks!

I watched all four videos Q.  interesting stuff.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: yurcarmeean on January 09, 2016, 11:16:47 PM
Rocky:  Thanks!

I watched all four videos Q.  interesting stuff.

+1 

the no-till soil structures reminded me of hydroton used for aquaponic medium, interesting how the no till soil floats in water
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on January 09, 2016, 11:22:26 PM
were you able to get BSF going?
i remember a few years ago you saying that you weren't attracting BSF

my compost tumbler has BSF in it, but it sems like they are only really prevalent in the first 3 months or so of the year
usually by the middle of january or so, i cannot add stuff to the bin fast enough because the mass of larvae eats everything
but after winter is pau, there are only a few larvae at a time

Yup, they sell them now.

BSFs need their bin under some kind of tree so the mature flies can colonize it and have someplace hang out.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on January 09, 2016, 11:25:04 PM
   Till, no-till, Bio-char thermal decomposition, rotational cover crops,growing fruit trees to feed the soil,slash and burn, black soldier flies and worm farms and Gatorade (It's what plats crave !).
That's a lot to do before you get to plant a few tomatoes in a 3 x 6 area (which is about the size of my desk ! )

If you are ever coming up to the country around PCC, give me a call and I'll hook you up with some stuff to get you going.
 :shaka:

So why not spend $20 for half a cubic yard of compost and fill a raised bed like I recommended in the beginning.

It's not going to get any cheaper or easier than that.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Rocky on January 10, 2016, 09:30:39 PM
How far up?

 Polynesian cultural Center (aka PCC)
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Rocky on January 10, 2016, 09:41:54 PM
So why not spend $20 for half a cubic yard of compost and fill a raised bed like I recommended in the beginning.

It's not going to get any cheaper or easier than that.

The original post was...
Anyone got any tips on making a vegetable garden with red dirt?  Will it take a year with compost and everything to rejuvenate the soil?

Any recommendations?

Give a man a fish.....
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on January 11, 2016, 12:22:35 AM
The original post was...
Anyone got any tips on making a vegetable garden with red dirt?  Will it take a year with compost and everything to rejuvenate the soil?

Any recommendations?

Give a man a fish.....

I'm pretty sure I the sources and information we all provided gave him the tools to catch his own fish in the future.

If he is willing to wait 2 years to grow vegetables, then fine; do what we recommended for working with the soil he already has.

I assumed he wanted to start now, and you can't really beat the cost of compost at menehune magic kapolei.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: hvybarrels on January 12, 2016, 11:48:56 AM
I second HEP compost. It's still pretty "hot" but can't beat the price. The greatest benefits will be 6 months down the line when it breaks down more and starts up a healthy microbe colony, so do it asap.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on January 17, 2016, 10:23:13 PM
Update:  I've decided to go with the bucket method, since my operation will be on the smaller side.  Gonna be using HEP with UH Seed Labs and others. 

I'll post pics soon!
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on January 17, 2016, 11:33:47 PM
Update:  I've decided to go with the bucket method, since my operation will be on the smaller side.  Gonna be using HEP with UH Seed Labs and others. 

I'll post pics soon!

Make sure you add a moisture retention media and something for drainage.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Rocky on January 18, 2016, 07:58:43 AM
Update:  I've decided to go with the bucket method, since my operation will be on the smaller side.  Gonna be using HEP with UH Seed Labs and others. 

I'll post pics soon!
What are you planting ?
  ::) 8) :P  :rofl: :shake: :crazy: :sleeping:
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on January 18, 2016, 03:15:20 PM
Soy Bean Kahala (anyone know if I can move the Soy Bean down lower in the soil to fix the leggyness?)
(http://i793.photobucket.com/albums/yy219/dat_one_v6_mustang/20160118_144051_zpsb9jeukfj.jpg)

Top Left: Pole Bean Poamoho
Top Middle: Sweet Corn Hawaiian Supersweet #9
Top Right: Lettuce Anuenue (Leggy... should have started them outside... also dropped in a few too many seeds... hopefully I can separate them when transplanting...)
Bottom Middle: Soy Bean Kahala
(http://i793.photobucket.com/albums/yy219/dat_one_v6_mustang/20160118_144156_zpshukivccd.jpg)

Lettuce Manoa (picked up a 4 pack from Lowe's as small seedlings)
(http://i793.photobucket.com/albums/yy219/dat_one_v6_mustang/20160118_144040_zpswkbs6ocq.jpg)

Any tips or suggestions?  I think I should have started all my seeds outside... I put them by a window but... apparently not doing anything for them...
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Rocky on January 18, 2016, 07:09:14 PM
Soy Bean Kahala (anyone know if I can move the Soy Bean down lower in the soil to fix the leggyness?)
(http://i793.photobucket.com/albums/yy219/dat_one_v6_mustang/20160118_144051_zpsb9jeukfj.jpg)

Top Left: Pole Bean Poamoho
Top Middle: Sweet Corn Hawaiian Supersweet #9
Top Right: Lettuce Anuenue (Leggy... should have started them outside... also dropped in a few too many seeds... hopefully I can separate them when transplanting...)
Bottom Middle: Soy Bean Kahala
(http://i793.photobucket.com/albums/yy219/dat_one_v6_mustang/20160118_144156_zpshukivccd.jpg)

Lettuce Manoa (picked up a 4 pack from Lowe's as small seedlings)
(http://i793.photobucket.com/albums/yy219/dat_one_v6_mustang/20160118_144040_zpswkbs6ocq.jpg)

Any tips or suggestions?  I think I should have started all my seeds outside... I put them by a window but... apparently not doing anything for them...

I'd try the leafy stuff (Manoa lettuce, Lettuce Anuenue  spinach, Kale Collard greens) in the hydroponic  bucket method I posted earlier.
it grows fast
Also, corn does not replant well ( at least for us it did n't.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on January 18, 2016, 07:26:59 PM
I'd try the leafy stuff (Manoa lettuce, Lettuce Anuenue  spinach, Kale Collard greens) in the hydroponic  bucket method I posted earlier.
it grows fast
Also, corn does not replant well ( at least for us it did n't.

Yup. Corn didn't do well in my bucket garden either.

The lettuce selections above are good, but keep them in a partial-shade area. Lettuce is a cool weather crop, and excess heat will cause it to bolt.

Kale is also a temperate weather crop. It CAN grow, but it's not meant to in Hawaii weather. I suggest attempting to grow tree collards, purple variety if you can find it.

The real question is: are you growing for nutrient density / health reasons, or are you growing to just put the space to use?

If you are attempting to grow the healthiest types of crops, then you need to reevaluate your intended purposes and select crops that are acclimated to tropical temperatures / climates, as well as provide the greatest nutrient profile.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on January 18, 2016, 09:03:41 PM
Yup. Corn didn't do well in my bucket garden either.

The lettuce selections above are good, but keep them in a partial-shade area. Lettuce is a cool weather crop, and excess heat will cause it to bolt.

Kale is also a temperate weather crop. It CAN grow, but it's not meant to in Hawaii weather. I suggest attempting to grow tree collards, purple variety if you can find it.

The real question is: are you growing for nutrient density / health reasons, or are you growing to just put the space to use?

If you are attempting to grow the healthiest types of crops, then you need to reevaluate your intended purposes and select crops that are acclimated to tropical temperatures / climates, as well as provide the greatest nutrient profile.

Mainly, I am trying to build a skill-set. 

And come on guys, don't be soo gentle.... Let me know what you guys think.  Any suggestions?
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on January 18, 2016, 09:16:11 PM
Mainly, I am trying to build a skill-set. 

And come on guys, don't be soo gentle.... Let me know what you guys think.  Any suggestions?

Yeah: lift the buckets off the ground.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on January 18, 2016, 09:19:33 PM
Yeah: lift the buckets off the ground.

Why's that?
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on January 18, 2016, 11:46:56 PM
Why's that?

Are there holes in the bottom?
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on January 19, 2016, 07:48:40 PM
Are there holes in the bottom?

Yes.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on January 20, 2016, 02:05:29 AM
Yes.

Then you want to keep it off the ground to prevent potential exposure to pathogens, detrimental nematodes and pests, which may enter your growing media through the drain holes.

Also, keeping it off the ground is better for drainage.

If you are going to create a controlled environment for your plants to grow in, might as well do it right so they don't get jacked up via exposure.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on January 20, 2016, 06:52:03 AM
Then you want to keep it off the ground to prevent potential exposure to pathogens, detrimental nematodes and pests, which may enter your growing media through the drain holes.

Also, keeping it off the ground is better for drainage.

If you are going to create a controlled environment for your plants to grow in, might as well do it right so they don't get jacked up via exposure.

Makes sense.  Thanks!
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: MauiLeatherwork on January 20, 2016, 08:30:08 PM
The book Growing vegetables in Hawaii by Oshiro is really helpful. If you are at sea level, you'll be growing different veggies than what I grow at 3,000 ft.

I will suggest chayote squash if you have room for it. Easy to let it climb a fence in the corner of a yard. It pays to check with friends and neighbors in your area to see what performs well for them. If you could grab some sweet potato vine free from a friend, or some dry land taro...those are the sorts of things you can try growing without paying $ for them at the store.

Romaine is a nice lettuce to grow.  I love manoa lettuce but the romaine grows largest with smooth leaves. Cherry tomatoes are easier than all other varieties. Our acidic soils lack calcium. If you don't provide enough calcium building blocks for your tomato plants the fruits will have black spots at the bottom as they turn from green to red.

Pepper plants are happy in the heat. Hawaiian chili, Thai dragon, Serrano, bell, etc

Many plants can be planted deeper after seeking stage.

Also don't forget you can take the pineapple crown that you slice off the store bought fruit and plant that right into the soil. It takes a long time (2 years?) till it grows to bear fruit, but if you have the space it can be amusing to try.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on January 20, 2016, 08:36:52 PM
The book Growing vegetables in Hawaii by Oshiro is really helpful. If you are at sea level, you'll be growing different veggies than what I grow at 3,000 ft.

I will suggest chayote squash if you have room for it. Easy to let it climb a fence in the corner of a yard. It pays to check with friends and neighbors in your area to see what performs well for them. If you could grab some sweet potato vine free from a friend, or some dry land taro...those are the sorts of things you can try growing without paying $ for them at the store.

Romaine is a nice lettuce to grow.  I love manoa lettuce but the romaine grows largest with smooth leaves. Cherry tomatoes are easier than all other varieties. Our acidic soils lack calcium. If you don't provide enough calcium building blocks for your tomato plants the fruits will have black spots at the bottom as they turn from green to red.

Pepper plants are happy in the heat. Hawaiian chili, Thai dragon, Serrano, bell, etc

Many plants can be planted deeper after seeking stage.

Also don't forget you can take the pineapple crown that you slice off the store bought fruit and plant that right into the soil. It takes a long time (2 years?) till it grows to bear fruit, but if you have the space it can be amusing to try.

Agree with Chayote, but plant (2) if you do.

If you can obtain wild cherry tomatoes, they are the best as they have acclimated to our climate.

Agree on peppers; far more nutrient dense and easier to grow than tomatoes.

Takes about 3-5 years to grow a pineapple.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Rocky on January 21, 2016, 01:01:17 PM
Then you want to keep it off the ground to prevent potential exposure to pathogens, detrimental nematodes and pests, which may enter your growing media through the drain holes.

Also, keeping it off the ground is better for drainage.

If you are going to create a controlled environment for your plants to grow in, might as well do it right so they don't get jacked up via exposure.
And slugs/snails  >:D
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Rocky on January 21, 2016, 01:07:07 PM
Agree with Chayote, but plant (2) if you do.

If you can obtain wild cherry tomatoes, they are the best as they have acclimated to our climate.
AND I HAVE AN ISSUE WITH THAT LITTLE F'N YELLOW BEE LOOKING FLY WHICH ALWAYS STINGS MY TOMATOES, CUCUMBERS, GREEN PEPPERS, BITTER MELON AND STUFF ( OH YEAH, BITTER MELON GROWS GOOD)

Agree on peppers; far more nutrient dense and easier to grow than tomatoes.

YOU CAN ALSO "CARPET BOMB' WITH BLUE LAKE BEANS 
they're fast and furious

Takes about 3-5 years to grow a pineapple.
LOL, MINE BEEN GROWING FOR 8 YRS
NEVER HAVE PRODUCED  :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on January 21, 2016, 01:47:26 PM
AND I HAVE AN ISSUE WITH THAT LITTLE F'N YELLOW BEE LOOKING FLY WHICH ALWAYS STINGS MY TOMATOES, CUCUMBERS, GREEN PEPPERS, BITTER MELON AND STUFF ( OH YEAH, BITTER MELON GROWS GOOD)

Make some lactic acid bacteria liquid solution and apply it to the leaves.

If that doesn't work, use a neem, dish soap and some type of organic insecticide soap in a spray bottle.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Rocky on January 21, 2016, 09:56:22 PM
Make some lactic acid bacteria liquid solution and apply it to the leaves.
does Lactic acid bacteria come from dirty boob breast milk from trippers ?

If that doesn't work, use a neem,(work my kidneys enough) dish soap and some type of organic insecticide soap in a spray bottle.(didn't work)
neither did garlic,chili pepper water (fried some plants), cooking oil and more.
Pretty much try to bag paper or plastic. They even sting through nylons
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on January 22, 2016, 08:55:21 PM
Thanks guys! 

Anyone have experience with UH Seed Labs kaala bell pepper?  None of my seeds have sprouted, out of about 10... I planted them 12 days ago and still nothing.

Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on January 22, 2016, 08:56:02 PM
Make some lactic acid bacteria liquid solution and apply it to the leaves.

If that doesn't work, use a neem, dish soap and some type of organic insecticide soap in a spray bottle.

The dish soap doesn't harm the leaves?
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: macsak on January 22, 2016, 10:07:12 PM
The dish soap doesn't harm the leaves?

i think he is talking about one using neem, not regular dish soap
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on January 22, 2016, 10:10:45 PM
i think he is talking about one using neem, not regular dish soap

Ahh ok.  I'll have to look into it. 
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on January 22, 2016, 11:08:51 PM
The dish soap doesn't harm the leaves?

No, dish soap does not hurt the leaves. You have to use as 'pure' a soap as possible, so dawn scent free is the best.

The soap is necessary because it strips the smothers pests and helps penetrate the waxy coating of their exoskeletons, which allow organic pesticides to enter their body more readily.

You can also use diatomaceous earth, but that is pretty much a last resort for organic approaches, as it is indiscriminate.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on January 23, 2016, 11:13:46 AM
No, dish soap does not hurt the leaves. You have to use as 'pure' a soap as possible, so dawn scent free is the best.

The soap is necessary because it strips the smothers pests and helps penetrate the waxy coating of their exoskeletons, which allow organic pesticides to enter their body more readily.

You can also use diatomaceous earth, but that is pretty much a last resort for organic approaches, as it is indiscriminate.

Good to know.  Thanks!
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on February 02, 2016, 10:07:23 PM
Organic fertilizer go!
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on February 02, 2016, 11:45:22 PM
Organic fertilizer go!

You don't need any right now unless you see deficiencies.

Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Aiea78 on February 03, 2016, 01:21:30 AM
help.  what is this whitek stuff underneath the leaves.  it killed my bell pepper plant.

other than that the basil and the bok choy some leaves get those leaf crawler trails.

I get much better luck growing fruit than veggies.

Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on February 03, 2016, 02:07:44 AM
help.  what is this whitek stuff underneath the leaves.  it killed my bell pepper plant.

other than that the basil and the bok choy some leaves get those leaf crawler trails.

I get much better luck growing fruit than veggies.

The tunnel lines are leaf miners, the white spots are either mildew or white fly and the rot at the end of the leaf is likely blight.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Aiea78 on February 03, 2016, 01:39:32 PM
The tunnel lines are leaf miners, the white spots are either mildew or white fly and the rot at the end of the leaf is likely blight.

mahalo Q.  I got these from home depot need to go back and get some sprays or something.  my Hawaiian chili plant has been cranking out the deadly little red beasties and looking forward to making makewatah and stuff :)

the white powder stuff is freaking flies I shook the leaf and a bunch flying around wtf where come from.  gonna' baggie that plant and sadly throw away. 

giving a "coastal strawberry" plant a go and it's doing good.  I just hope not miniature decorative fruit instead of normal eating kind?  my kumquat tree the fruits look like olive size but this the first ones and the plant barely a foot tall.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on February 03, 2016, 07:39:02 PM
mahalo Q.  I got these from home depot need to go back and get some sprays or something.  my Hawaiian chili plant has been cranking out the deadly little red beasties and looking forward to making makewatah and stuff :)

the white powder stuff is freaking flies I shook the leaf and a bunch flying around wtf where come from.  gonna' baggie that plant and sadly throw away. 

giving a "coastal strawberry" plant a go and it's doing good.  I just hope not miniature decorative fruit instead of normal eating kind?  my kumquat tree the fruits look like olive size but this the first ones and the plant barely a foot tall.

If you ever run into problems with flies again, use 1-2 tbsp of dawn dish soap to 1L of water; spray top and bottom of leaves either before sun up or after the sun starts to set.

If that doesn't help. add equal ratio of pure neem oil to the mix.

If that still doesn't work, go to a pet or feed store and locate diatomaceous earth, and then apply with a plant duster. This must be used as a last resort as DE is indiscriminate and will kill beneficial insects as well.

I'm waiting for a recipe from the Korean Natural Farming system to be made available that is possible the safest and most effective insecticide that doubles as a fungicide as well.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on February 03, 2016, 08:24:25 PM
You don't need any right now unless you see deficiencies.

The bottom leaves of my tomato plants are yellowing.  They get adequate water.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on February 03, 2016, 10:00:26 PM
The bottom leaves of my tomato plants are yellowing.  They get adequate water.

Bottom leaves are fine, as this is old growth.

Main thing is that the main leaves (that form the main section and/or canopy) are not yellowing.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on February 05, 2016, 11:19:22 PM
Bottom leaves are fine, as this is old growth.

Main thing is that the main leaves (that form the main section and/or canopy) are not yellowing.

Thanks!
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on February 08, 2016, 10:48:59 PM
Anyone know what's going on here?  The edges of my polebean leaves are drying up.  The dried portion are very dry and "crispy" feeling.  The inside of the same leaf feels almost normal.  It works its way from the rim of the leaves to the insides, as you can see in the 2 leaves in the back.

Thanks

(http://i793.photobucket.com/albums/yy219/dat_one_v6_mustang/20160208_071105_zpsyosnpims.jpg)
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on February 08, 2016, 11:39:58 PM
Anyone know what's going on here?  The edges of my polebean leaves are drying up.  The dried portion are very dry and "crispy" feeling.  The inside of the same leaf feels almost normal.  It works its way from the rim of the leaves to the insides, as you can see in the 2 leaves in the back.

Thanks

(http://i793.photobucket.com/albums/yy219/dat_one_v6_mustang/20160208_071105_zpsyosnpims.jpg)

Overwatering.

I can tell from the picture that the soil is drenched.

Did you add the aerating media like I told you? If not, straight compost will have a consistency of clay over time, only it will also retain water, causing root rot.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on February 09, 2016, 07:32:53 AM
Overwatering.

I can tell from the picture that the soil is drenched.

Did you add the aerating media like I told you? If not, straight compost will have a consistency of clay over time, only it will also retain water, causing root rot.

Over watering? Ok. I only water once a day in the mornings. I took the picture when I watered. In the morning before watering, if it didn't rain, the top layer of soil is kinda dry.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on February 09, 2016, 09:36:12 AM
Over watering? Ok. I only water once a day in the mornings. I took the picture when I watered. In the morning before watering, if it didn't rain, the top layer of soil is kinda dry.

Did you add drainage/aerating media, i.e. cinder rocks?
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on February 09, 2016, 03:57:22 PM
Did you add drainage/aerating media, i.e. cinder rocks?

The Menehune Magic Potting Soil is supposed to include cinder...
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on February 09, 2016, 05:54:24 PM
The Menehune Magic Potting Soil is supposed to include cinder...

It doesn't.

Whoever told you that lied to you, as menehune magic does not sell product mixed with cinder. They do, however, sell cinder on it's own.

So now you know what the problem is, I would recommend getting a soil moisture meter off amazon. Test both from the bottom and from the drainage holes in the bottom. Do not water unless the meter says it is dry.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on February 11, 2016, 08:10:30 PM
It doesn't.

Whoever told you that lied to you, as menehune magic does not sell product mixed with cinder. They do, however, sell cinder on it's own.

So now you know what the problem is, I would recommend getting a soil moisture meter off amazon. Test both from the bottom and from the drainage holes in the bottom. Do not water unless the meter says it is dry.

Is black cinder different?  This is a picture of the Potting Mix from Menehune Magic.
(http://i793.photobucket.com/albums/yy219/dat_one_v6_mustang/20160211_193153_zps6go8ikkv.jpg)
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on February 11, 2016, 10:29:39 PM
Is black cinder different?  This is a picture of the Potting Mix from Menehune Magic.
(http://i793.photobucket.com/albums/yy219/dat_one_v6_mustang/20160211_193153_zps6go8ikkv.jpg)

Did you buy the bag or did you get bulk from the yard?

I assume you got it in bulk.

Anyway, the amount of cinders in the bagged product is very minimal.

You want a MINIMUM of 2:1 compost to drainage media.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on February 12, 2016, 06:56:16 AM
Did you buy the bag or did you get bulk from the yard?

I assume you got it in bulk.

Anyway, the amount of cinders in the bagged product is very minimal.

You want a MINIMUM of 2:1 compost to drainage media.

Ahh ok.  That sounds like a lot.  I'll try cut back on watering. 

And no... I have the bag product.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Rocky on February 12, 2016, 10:31:26 AM
The dish soap doesn't harm the leaves?

I heard to use "Organic" soap which I will try next.,Instead of throwing out your white fly plants, just spray them "vigorously" with a hose to get rid of them
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on February 12, 2016, 11:03:51 AM
I heard to use "Organic" soap which I will try next.,Instead of throwing out your white fly plants, just spray them "vigorously" with a hose to get rid of them

That's aphids, not white flies.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Aiea78 on February 12, 2016, 12:26:54 PM
yah I tried rinsing them off.  too late it's dead Jim. 

at least the basil is rocking.  making pesto next :) 

update:  pesto rocked! blended with pine nuts, EVOO, parm and sea salt.  tossed in pasta and 21/25 shrimpos - YUM

bad news now the damn white fly/powdery crap is attacking everything, the hawaiian chili and the bok choy.  the plants with delicate leaves.  unaffected the pineapple and the kumquat so far.  the lilikoi is farther away in the yard and no problem yet.  oh yeah and the dragon fruit "limbs" doing ok too really got to move them to permanent loc where they will cascade down a rock wall :) 
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on March 01, 2016, 07:00:08 AM
yah I tried rinsing them off.  too late it's dead Jim. 

at least the basil is rocking.  making pesto next :) 

update:  pesto rocked! blended with pine nuts, EVOO, parm and sea salt.  tossed in pasta and 21/25 shrimpos - YUM

bad news now the damn white fly/powdery crap is attacking everything, the hawaiian chili and the bok choy.  the plants with delicate leaves.  unaffected the pineapple and the kumquat so far.  the lilikoi is farther away in the yard and no problem yet.  oh yeah and the dragon fruit "limbs" doing ok too really got to move them to permanent loc where they will cascade down a rock wall :)

What's the update for the white fly/powdery stuff?
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Aiea78 on March 02, 2016, 03:43:37 PM
What's the update for the white fly/powdery stuff?

not much.  the bell pepper is dead.  the Hawaiian chile plant struggling but still kicking.  the basil probably not last much longer either is getting tall skinny and sparse.  the bok choy still growing.  I don't like spraying chems on stuff going to eat.  I kinda' gave up on infected plants.  pineapple is kicking ass.  very hardy plants!
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on March 02, 2016, 09:12:26 PM
not much.  the bell pepper is dead.  the Hawaiian chile plant struggling but still kicking.  the basil probably not last much longer either is getting tall skinny and sparse.  the bok choy still growing.  I don't like spraying chems on stuff going to eat.  I kinda' gave up on infected plants.  pineapple is kicking ass.  very hardy plants!

Sounds like you lost a lot...

What bell peppers are those?  I've got Kaala Bell Peppers from UH Seed Lab going now.  They're still seedlings though.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on March 02, 2016, 10:51:47 PM
not much.  the bell pepper is dead.  the Hawaiian chile plant struggling but still kicking.  the basil probably not last much longer either is getting tall skinny and sparse.  the bok choy still growing.  I don't like spraying chems on stuff going to eat.  I kinda' gave up on infected plants.  pineapple is kicking ass.  very hardy plants!

If you want help, I do consulting and build gardens for people.

Kind of hard to know exactly whats going on unless I can see.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Aiea78 on March 03, 2016, 07:29:40 AM
no worries these are just single plants in a pot for test.  I admit had some dreams of finding acreage and working it but the reality is not going happen.  so will leave behind only the hardiest of plants making it on their own now - 5-7 pineapple, lychee / rambutan I forget which I planted, the lilikoi, an orange tree and greenery (including all the noxious weeds haha!).  I started 2 little blueberry plants but who knows if will make it, so far so good.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on March 03, 2016, 02:56:57 PM
no worries these are just single plants in a pot for test.  I admit had some dreams of finding acreage and working it but the reality is not going happen.  so will leave behind only the hardiest of plants making it on their own now - 5-7 pineapple, lychee / rambutan I forget which I planted, the lilikoi, an orange tree and greenery (including all the noxious weeds haha!).  I started 2 little blueberry plants but who knows if will make it, so far so good.

Pinapple take 3-5 years to fully mature; not worth it except for hobby gardening.

Lychee does best in a true subtropical setting that can reach cooler temperatures, like nu'uanu.

Citrus is ok, but can be hard if you receive too much rainfall.

Blueberry is suitable for Hawaii, but you must give it a lot of nutrients and make sure the soil remains acidic.



Pots are ok for sprouting and growing to transplant stage, but not necessarily good for growing to completion. Excess moisture and lack of oxygen create too many problems. I started using self-watering container gardens, but eventually moved away from it due to too many problems.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on March 08, 2016, 07:20:55 PM
Damn wind today is crazy for the garden...
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Aiea78 on March 16, 2016, 12:18:40 AM
no illussions of becoming a farmer here, not going to happen in my old age so just for fun gardening.   I can see only the hardiest of plants/trees make it outside.  veggies are the most labor intensive and need special care to be successful.   best for you to eat and most expensive  and that is why we don't get them much from plate lunches and the like, only get the cheapest most worthless food/starches.  they could put 3 scoops of mac salad on the plate and I wouldn't eat more than half a scoop.  where's the beef indeed.  so avg lunch now close to if not $10 even fast food.  that just trips me out.

had the house painted.  bok choy ruined as didn't move the box.  que sera sera.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on March 16, 2016, 07:03:12 AM
no illussions of becoming a farmer here, not going to happen in my old age so just for fun gardening.   I can see only the hardiest of plants/trees make it outside.  veggies are the most labor intensive and need special care to be successful.   best for you to eat and most expensive  and that is why we don't get them much from plate lunches and the like, only get the cheapest most worthless food/starches.  they could put 3 scoops of mac salad on the plate and I wouldn't eat more than half a scoop.  where's the beef indeed.  so avg lunch now close to if not $10 even fast food.  that just trips me out.

had the house painted.  bok choy ruined as didn't move the box.  que sera sera.

This is why I moved away from vegetables (aside from the hardiest, drought tolerant and nutrient dense varieties) and shifted my focus to agroforestry.

I got to speak to one of the world's leading experts on permaculture in tropical environments, and he stated that while vegetables can and should be grown in the tropics to an extent, the focus should be on tree crops. He went on to explain that because we have no true winter, biological processes, decomposition and pests are a constant throughout the year, which does not allow the adequate building of soil. It takes 2-4x as long for tropical areas to build soil as it does in temperate climates, unless manual processes are introduced in order to build the soil.

He also stated that because of the lack of soils, most of the nutrients found in the soil tend to be absorbed and held in by the trees, with Hawaii serving as a perfect example.

Trees are much easier to deal with than vegetable crops, though the downside is that they take years to get to fruiting stage, and tend to only have one particular part of the year that they provide their crops, unless they are those that flower and fruit throughout the year.

I think this is why Hawaiians focused on the staple crops of sweet potato, breadfruit and kalo, as these three crops do not need good soil to grow in, especially with regards to the breadfruit.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on March 31, 2016, 09:59:26 PM
Good information.

I wish my HOA would allow fruit trees.........
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: bass monkey on May 29, 2016, 10:06:22 AM
Didn't read through the thread, but decided to just add my question in here.
Im starting up my container garden.  Will be gardening out of 5 gallon buckets 3x1x1 containers and whatnot.  Plan to grow  vegetables, tomatoes, eggplant and leafy greens from seeds.  Planning to start the seeds in the buckets/containers then let them grow out, wont transplant.  Im trying to figure out what kind of soil I need.  Do I start with potting mix, Top soil?  Any brand recommendations? 
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: 83rdrecon on May 31, 2016, 05:33:41 PM
Didn't read through the thread, but decided to just add my question in here.
Im starting up my container garden.  Will be gardening out of 5 gallon buckets 3x1x1 containers and whatnot.  Plan to grow  vegetables, tomatoes, eggplant and leafy greens from seeds.  Planning to start the seeds in the buckets/containers then let them grow out, wont transplant.  Im trying to figure out what kind of soil I need.  Do I start with potting mix, Top soil?  Any brand recommendations?
make your own compost.  Used coffee ground, banana peels and eggshells all crunched up.  You can mix 5050 with regular topsoil as well. 
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: bass monkey on May 31, 2016, 08:42:50 PM
Thanks for the reply.
Yes I've got a few piles cooking right now, but they won't be ready for a while. Will probably add them into the established garden.  My pile is wood chips and kitchen scraps. Also got a worm bin going.
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: passivekinetic on June 01, 2016, 02:00:06 PM
This is a great thread. I need to bookmark it for future reference. Thanks to all for sharing!
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Rocky on June 01, 2016, 09:51:55 PM
Didn't read through the thread, but decided to just add my question in here.
Im starting up my container garden.  Will be gardening out of 5 gallon buckets 3x1x1 containers and whatnot.  Plan to grow  vegetables, tomatoes, eggplant and leafy greens from seeds.  Planning to start the seeds in the buckets/containers then let them grow out, wont transplant.  Im trying to figure out what kind of soil I need.  Do I start with potting mix, Top soil?  Any brand recommendations?

https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=21494.msg194113#msg194113
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: blackheart0311 on June 16, 2016, 12:50:31 PM
Didn't read through the thread, but decided to just add my question in here.
Im starting up my container garden.  Will be gardening out of 5 gallon buckets 3x1x1 containers and whatnot.  Plan to grow  vegetables, tomatoes, eggplant and leafy greens from seeds.  Planning to start the seeds in the buckets/containers then let them grow out, wont transplant.  Im trying to figure out what kind of soil I need.  Do I start with potting mix, Top soil?  Any brand recommendations?

Been out of country for a little bit.  Just got back. 

I used Hawaiian Earth Products Potting Mix (purple bag).  Each bag is $5.45 if you pick it up from them.  It's even cheaper if you get it by the truckload; that is, if you have the space for that.

I'll upload a picture of my garden later.  It's going pretty good.  I'd say tomatoes are the easiest to grow.  I've also got bell peppers, pole beans, soybeans, and kale.  Too hot for lettuce now...

I'd just like to say, many on here are a great help!
Title: Re: Vegetable Garden and Red Dirt
Post by: Q on June 16, 2016, 08:24:50 PM
I'm starting to learn Mittleider Gardening.

Browse YouTube to see the results