2aHawaii
General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: new guy on August 17, 2016, 07:37:16 PM
-
.
-
.
-
On the contrary, people who think that firearms should only be owned by the govt. are the most unintelligible, ignorant, and naive compared to firearms owners.
-
.
-
The left has consistently portrayed firearm owners as unintelligent, inarticulate, and/or uneducated.
My experience has been contrary to such portrayals, and regardless of socio-economic categorizations, I personally believe that the ownership of firearms (and support of the 2nd Amendment) transcends any attempts from the left to diminish or repress our constitutional rights to keep and to bear arms.
I know of contractors, physicians, teachers, dentists, attorneys, architects, engineers, medical technicians, politicians, and consultants who own and support ownership of firearms.
I just felt compelled to support the silent minority (majority?), and provide a forum to more openly discuss this issue.
Feel free to chime in, as you deem necessary/appropriate.
61 guests and 19 Members currently online.
Sack the fuck up, take a position, and be prepared to defend such position. :thumbsup:
One of the biggest problems with the firearm debate is that both sides have turned the issue into an US versus THEM.
Maybe one day you guys will figure out that the debate is actually about firearms and it ISN'T about Republicans versus Democrats, nor is it about right versus left, nor is it about conservatives versus liberals, nor is it about race, religion, gender, sexual orientation, et cetera.
If you're looking for people to support your belief that rights under the 2nd shall not be infringed, then maybe you should stop alienating other people based purely on their stances on other, non-firearm issues.
Yes, there are Democrat gun owners, gay firearm owners, and even "Liberal" gun owners. But to say to them, "YOU can't be one of US," is just stupid.
NOTE: i edited this post to include quotations from new guy's prior posts
-
.
-
I would ask why do the groups you singled out constantly and viciously attack the rights of all citizens to be armed, including themselves?
How do we get the left gun owners to value their rights to armed self defense and gun ownership rights over their pre-existing desire to strip those same rights?
-
I would ask why do the groups you singled out constantly and viciously attack the rights of all citizens to be armed, including themselves?
How do we get the left gun owners to value their rights to armed self defense and gun ownership rights over their pre-existing desire to strip those same rights?
Being a democrat or on the left and being anti-gun are not synonymous, that is the first thing we need to recognize. A liberal can be pro gun.
Personally I think we need to engage them with facts in a civil manner. I realize this does not always work but I haven't seen a method that proves more successful at this point. Alienating them is probably the worst step we can take.
Some we never will convince. For the rest, we have to beat the propaganda campaign. On top of facts some good emotional arguments or anecdotes would be in order.
-
At the meeting with Espero, the anti-gun lady who worked for the Navy commented that "there are no scholarly types here who can comment on the law being discussed" (paraphrased).
She was quickly rebutted by another young woman who actually holds two degrees. I'm 100% sure there are other people in the audience who holds advanced degrees who didn't chime in.
Someone mentioned that they overheard one of the 2a-neutral teacher who was there say something like "I didn't know the pro-2a people were so well informed and educated."
-
One word: emotions.
The anti-gun, anti-2A supporters are responding to emotional pleas and calls to "do something to stop this epidemic of gun violence." "No other developed country in the world has these kinds of mass shootings."
It's difficult to combat a "feeling" with logic, facts, and historical proof. It's always difficult to change someone's opinion once they are convinced the anti-gun stance is correct. If they could be swayed to accept guns as useful tools and part of an enjoyable activity/sport BEFORE they develop negative opinions, the anti-gun groups would see much less support. Of course, that will never happen as long as the media pushes anti-gun rhetoric to keep the controversy fresh and in our faces.
-
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2diNojgJF9c (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2diNojgJF9c)
-
.
that's why I support term limits.
F*ckin elitism.
They forget they were elected by us to serve.
-
In general, the anti-gun folks that I come across know little to nothing about guns. Even worse, many have their views and opinions shaped by what they've seen on TV, video games, etc. They are essentially ignorant of many of the truths and facts behind guns and generally are ok with their ignorance. They know what they know and don't confuse them with the facts. Many of these people are the wives/SO of shooter friends. They often go on and on about "common sense gun control" and "we have to do something with the gun problem that we have in America" and that "why should a civilian have to own a rifle that can shoot down an airplane". Well, I've embellished a little there, but that's kind of the point of the stuff that these ignorant people will believe and end up parroting. Super frustrating.
Yeah, I will try to talk some sense into them. Offer to take them to the range to see that it's safe and that the recoil from an AR15 won't blow them off their feet.
Like mentioned before, a lot of it has to do with emotion. It's an irrational fear of guns and not something that is easily swayed. Sort of reminds me of how the uneducated in poor/slummy parts of the world is susceptible to all sorts of propaganda. Same thing with myths about guns, firearms owners, etc. On top of that, those who are anti-gun seem to be able to spew all sorts of myths and inaccurate to just false "facts" about guns, while the pro-2A people are constrained to facts, truths, etc.
Many times, it boils down to how to you convince an ignorant person that they are ignorant. >:(
-
that's why I support term limits.
F*ckin elitism.
They forget they were elected by us to serve.
That's a completely different topic, but I totally agree.
Just a quick one and then :stopjack:
Why is it that in election years, congress magically figure out the budget ahead of time and on non-election years, they always either go down to the wire or need continuing resolutions?
There should be a way that we get to vote on their pay increases, benefits, etc.
Letting the rats guard the cheese.
-
That's a completely different topic, but I totally agree.
Just a quick one and then :stopjack:
Why is it that in election years, congress magically figure out the budget ahead of time and on non-election years, they always either go down to the wire or need continuing resolutions?
There should be a way that we get to vote on their pay increases, benefits, etc.
Letting the rats guard the cheese.
Simple fact is, the public has horrendous long term memory, and the short tern gets shorter all the time.
-
... and yet it is about left versus right.
From your posts, you are obviously from the legal profession.
But, will you deny that the assailment of the 2nd amendment has not come from the left?
I never raised the issue of race, religion, gender, or sexual orientation, nor injected such issues into this conversation.
... YOU did.
I personally look to ALL races, creeds, genders, sexual orientations to support our collective 2nd Amendment rights.
... your opinion may vary, and I may personally disagree with your perspective, but I definitely and unequivocally support your right to express your opinions, unmarred by my personal opinion.
I'm not going to deny that the a strong majority of the vocal anti-gun crowd typically lean to the left. at the same time, however, we cannot take the Left as a whole and assume that all of them are in opposition to your pro-2nd viewpoints.
one of the reasons why i bring this up is because i am sometimes appalled by the things that are posted on this forum. usually i can appreciate a good debate, but some of the very vocal members here write very hateful things--and sometimes those hateful posts encourage more hateful speech. in some cases, these threads quickly die, but sometimes they continue living and evolve into a sort of echo chamber where other members are goaded into jumping onto a "hate" bandwagon.
it is for that reason that i am sometimes ashamed to associate myself with this forum. i don't want others to perceive me as being a member of a group that inspires and instigates hate.
at the same time, like you said, i too respect your right to express yourself.
I would ask why do the groups you singled out constantly and viciously attack the rights of all citizens to be armed, including themselves?
How do we get the left gun owners to value their rights to armed self defense and gun ownership rights over their pre-existing desire to strip those same rights?
you pose two very good questions. i don't have those answers.
i'd like to point out, however, that there might be ways that we could encourage pro-gun support from these groups. here's a good example--there were a lot of articles that came out in the wake of the Pulse shooting that were related to the overnight spike in Pink Pistol membership. http://www.rollingstone.com/culture/features/pink-pistols-lgbt-gun-owners-unite-in-arming-gay-community-20160628
although the pro-gun supporters amongst the LGBT community, as manifested in the Pink Pistols organization, is a minority within a minority, we should embrace them and laud them for their choice to openly break from the traditional perception of the LGBT community as a whole.
similarly, i read an interesting article about an organization called the "Liberal Gun Club." http://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-ol-patt-morrison-nra-liberal-gun-club-20160617-snap-story.html
all in all, if the goal is to prevent the erosion of gun rights, then wouldn't it make more sense to gather as many people together as possible so that there is a stronger and more diverse base among the supporters?
as a side note, i'm curious as to why "new guy" erases a lot of his posts and replaces them with a full stop. i don't mean to start drama, but i'm just wondering what the reason is.
-
Even tho some people on the left support 2A they still vote for the left. That basically destroys their pro 2a feelings. It dosent matter how much they want the second amendment to be around and if they think that firearms are a freedom that all people should have. If they vote in leadership that dosent then that right gets eroded an eliminated by their feelings for other matters. Unless they can be convinced to vote otherwise they should be written of and the effort should be used elsewhere.
The fact of the matter is American politics have become so broken from the republic that they were designed to be. It has become majority rules no matter what (democracy), instead of majority rules as long as it dosent infringe on the rights of others. The federal government has got to the point where they are destroying individual states rights and controlling more and more of our lifes.
The government has literally spent the last 20 years brainwashing kids and young adults into believing that leftism (socialism, Communism, progressiveness) is the only way forward, That doing what they are told is right (by the government) is for the greater good, even if that means eroding the individual liberty's and freedoms of others. Leftism is all that is taught in schools these days from Kindergarten all the way through university. Leftism is rampant in this country and if you dont go along with it you are shamed or attacked for your beliefs
-
that's why I support term limits.
F*ckin elitism.
They forget they were elected by us to serve.
They don't forget. They just don't care once they are in office. They would care if they had term limits and had opponents to run against them at every election.
-
In general, the anti-gun folks that I come across know little to nothing about guns.
Many times, it boils down to how to convince an ignorant person that they are ignorant. >:(
....
I'm going to remember that. :thumbsup:
-
^+1
That's a classic quote drck :thumbsup:
Regarding the sideways topic in this post.
Left, Right
Can't we all just get along ?
I'm a left leaning Democrat who loves guns and the Constitution.
Not mutually exclusive, contrary to popular belief.
( although Aiea78 and my brother have reasoned me toward the center, but that's another story)
(Also wouldn't vote for Hillary though or Schatz )
Extremists are extremists no matter what flag they fly under.
That doesn't make the whole group extremists.
The way Democrats and Liberals are talked about on this forum we've alienated 80% of the State's population.
Probably a lot of people who support 2A.
Then we talk about voter base ? :wacko:
Why do you think there's so many guests (lurkers) and not members at any one time ?
( right now 39 guests, 16 members )
-
The way Democrats and Liberals are talked about on this forum we've alienated 80% of the State's population.
Probably a lot of people who support 2A.
It dosent matter if 100% of them support the 2A, If they vote for representatives that dont. it means nothing.
-
Are you saying Democrat candidates can't support 2A ?
Think about what State you're in.
Turning the State Conservative Republican is a pipe dream.
Aiea had 2 pro2A Democratic candidates running for House this last election.
NRA left me a message urging me to vote for a Democrat candidate. (Sam Kong)
-
To the left leaning people on this forum -- Thank you for being here and for caring enough about our individual rights as people.
To the right leaning people, thank you for being here and for being at the forefront of protecting our individual rights from those who want to take them away.
And also, thank you to the centrist / independents who bridge the gap and see both sides.
That said, there is a point here that should not be missed.
The R (right) is a MINORITY in Hawaii. The R is an important part but has little ability to make a change in the votes, considering how Hawaii votes.
I hate to say it but the left / progressive leaning Ds are the MAJORITY voters in Hawaii. Yes, the Ds are part of the problem. MORE IMPORTANTLY, they have to be part of the solution if there is to be any change in Hawaii regarding our gun rights.
If all we do is preach to the choir (R), then there will be nothing new, same old same old.
We need to help educate the D and the undecideds, and that begins by not alienating them for other non-2a beliefs.
We need pro-2a allies on all sides, and that involves having a dialogue and showing them why 2a rights are important and why it's worth fighting for.
-
I support people using whatever bathroom they want to use.
#genderneutralbathroomsmatter
-
.
-
... plus we all know what's going to happen to the internet on 10/01/16, right? :wave:
Am I missing something? What happens to the Internet on 10/1/16? I think it's a joke. (Right?) But, with all the craziness going on, something could be brewing... please enlighten me.
-
Am I missing something? What happens to the Internet on 10/1/16? I think it's a joke. (Right?) But, with all the craziness going on, something could be brewing... please enlighten me.
We (Meaning the U.S. Government) relinquishes control of Internet naming to ICANN. It won't really affect us directly but it could allow foreign nations such as China and Russia some influence over the Internet. Especially the DNS services. If ICANN remains independent then I can't imagine anything bad could come of this. But if they allow a country to influence their control I would guess they could possibly assert some controls over the Internet. Especially since ICANN will be headquartered in California. Be prepared for a price increase though.
-
Thanks Big All. I heard a little about this but I need to research some more.
Sent from my SM-G935T using Tapatalk
-
One word: emotions.
The anti-gun, anti-2A supporters are responding to emotional pleas and calls to "do something to stop this epidemic of gun violence." "No other developed country in the world has these kinds of mass shootings."
It's difficult to combat a "feeling" with logic, facts, and historical proof. It's always difficult to change someone's opinion once they are convinced the anti-gun stance is correct. If they could be swayed to accept guns as useful tools and part of an enjoyable activity/sport BEFORE they develop negative opinions, the anti-gun groups would see much less support. Of course, that will never happen as long as the media pushes anti-gun rhetoric to keep the controversy fresh and in our faces.
I don't think it is all feelings. I think some are just tricked by anti-gun propaganda and don't bother to investigate further.
-
I don't think it is all feelings. I think some are just tricked by anti-gun propaganda and don't bother to investigate further.
Do you have studies, statistics or other proof of your conclusion?
Name one "trick" that isn't tied to an emotional response. Fear is their greatest weapon, and talking about high capacity mags, weapons of war, assault weapons and wild west outcomes is pure emotional appeal.
-
I find it's a good experience to see what people on the far side think. I suggest you checkout www.democraticunderground.com which is a website for the extreme <1% of the Democratic party. See their views in the general forum on a variety of topics, and they have gun control forums too. Comments are censored where posts are deleted, and you get suspended or banned for taking opposing views even if you are factually correct. They are 100% for constitutional rights as long as they agree with them.
This post isn't to knock Democrats, it would be like saying all Muslims are terrorists. We here are the 1% of gun owners, and it's a good experience to see how the opposite 1% think. They have a lot of myths about gun owners.
-
Do you have studies, statistics or other proof of your conclusion?
Name one "trick" that isn't tied to an emotional response. Fear is their greatest weapon, and talking about high capacity mags, weapons of war, assault weapons and wild west outcomes is pure emotional appeal.
No, I don't have statistical data, that is why I said THINK.
One trick is citing data that is inaccurate or out of context.
Don't underestimate your opponents by thinking their only arguments for gun control are purely emotional. And don't continue to insult them or you only push them further into their corner. Don't let your emotion get the best of you. If you want to engage your opponent in a working dialogue then you have to avoid insulting them or alienating them despite your frustration or irritation.
-
No, I don't have statistical data, that is why I said THINK.
One trick is citing data that is inaccurate or out of context.
Don't underestimate your opponents by thinking their only arguments for gun control are purely emotional. And don't continue to insult them or you only push them further into their corner. Don't let your emotion get the best of you. If you want to engage your opponent in a working dialogue then you have to avoid insulting them or alienating them despite your frustration or irritation.
Once again deflecting and dodging. That's a made-up, unsupported general belief. I asked for a specific example: NAME ONE TRICK. I gave you 4 specific gimmicks they use, and each is tied to an emotional description/use.
-
Once again deflecting and dodging. That's a made-up, unsupported general belief. I asked for a specific example: NAME ONE TRICK.
That is a trick. You take statistics out of context and present them in a way that makes it seem like it means or supports something different.
You trick someone into a certain position by presenting them with an inaccurate picture.
-
That is a trick. You take statistics out of context and present them in a way that makes it seem like it means or supports something different.
You trick someone into a certain position by presenting them with an inaccurate picture.
Either you ARE that stupid, or you are trolling again.
Which statistic are you referring to in your answer? Name the statistic -- you know, labels and numbers?
-
Either you ARE that stupid, or you are trolling again.
Which statistic are you referring to in your answer? Name the statistic -- you know, labels and numbers?
Are you talking to a mirror? I already told you I am not referring to a specific data set. Read my post before you reply.
I am talking about a general tactic. I am not referring to a specific instance where anti-gun advocates tricked someone to their side. I am saying that this is one way in which people can be anti-gun without being emotional about it.
For someone who decries the emotion behind anti-gun advocates, you sure display a lot of emotion in your reasoning and response.
-
Are you talking to a mirror? I already told you I am not referring to a specific data set. Read my post before you reply.
I am talking about a general tactic. I am not referring to a specific instance where anti-gun advocates tricked someone to their side. I am saying that this is one way in which people can be anti-gun without being emotional about it.
For someone who decries the emotion behind anti-gun advocates, you sure display a lot of emotion in your reasoning and response.
I asked for a specific example, and you can't answer the question. So, you divert and deflect by arguing the meaning of what you did post.
Typical.
-
(http://www.clipartkid.com/images/267/time-out-seat-by-kids-korner-available-at-amazon-as9wbr-clipart.jpg)
-
(http://i.imgur.com/ANFYk5a.png)
-
I asked for a specific example, and you can't answer the question. So, you divert and deflect by arguing the meaning of what you did post.
Typical.
I thought that you, as someone well seasoned in gun rights debate, wouldn't need a specific example. Since it happens so often and is mentioned here regularly I figured it would be preaching to the quire.
But in case you have really never noticed a gun control group misusing statistics, here is an example.
They frequently cite that 30,000 people a year are killed by firearms while neglecting to mention that 2/3rds are suicides.
Do you truly believe that they never misinform people or do you just enjoy causing a ruckus?
-
I thought that you, as someone well seasoned in gun rights debate, wouldn't need a specific example. Since it happens so often and is mentioned here regularly I figured it would be preaching to the quire.
But in case you have really never noticed a gun control group misusing statistics, here is an example.
They frequently cite that 30,000 people a year are killed by firearms while neglecting to mention that 2/3rds are suicides.
Do you truly believe that they never misinform people or do you just enjoy causing a ruckus?
Now explain how mis-reporting and inflating the percentage is not an emotional appeal?
The only reason for using such an inflated number is to get the person reading it to FEEL bad the number is that huge.
Giving the correct number would not be so compelling emotionally.
See how this discussion thing works? It is much more civil when you participate instead of trying to be right ALL THE TIME!
-
Now explain how mis-reporting and inflating the percentage is not an emotional appeal?
The only reason for using such an inflated number is to get the person reading it to FEEL bad the number is that huge.
Giving the correct number would not be so compelling emotionally.
See how this discussion thing works? It is much more civil when you participate instead of trying to be right ALL THE TIME!
I wouldn't consider it inherently an emotional response. Someone can simply reason that 30,000 lives lost to guns is unacceptable. Many believe that gun control will reduce that number thus they support gun control.
Is the desire to prevent death emotional? If it is then aren't we all guilty of it?
Ignorance of facts by misinformation is not inherently emotional. Remember the video of the politician holding up an AR-15 saying it could fire 30 rounds a second? Someone can look at that video and decide that it is simply too dangerous, not out of emotion but out of their reasoning, but in the end they based their position on inaccurate data. Nuclear weapons shouldn't be in the hands of regular people, and I can arrive at this conclusion without emotion. Someone who is pro gun control may believe, though misinformation, that gun control would solve our violence problem. This doesn't mean that person is being emotional about it just because they choose wanting to solve our violence problem over protecting our rights.
-
Either you ARE that stupid, or you are trolling again.
Which statistic are you referring to in your answer? Name the statistic -- you know, labels and numbers?
Why are you getting all bent on if it is emotion or reasoning?
What does it matter?
The point is that the anti gun activists use erroneous and twisted data to sway those who may be undecided and ignorant of the facts over to agreement with asinine gun control measures.
The very difficult part of this whole thing is that their side only need to convince the majority to sit down and shut up, then they are free to do as they please with stripping rights. On the other hand, our side has the task of not only educating the middle majority, but also getting people energized enough to get into action.
-
I wouldn't consider it inherently an emotional response. Someone can simply reason that 30,000 lives lost to guns is unacceptable. Many believe that gun control will reduce that number thus they support gun control.
Is the desire to prevent death emotional? If it is then aren't we all guilty of it?
Ignorance of facts by misinformation is not inherently emotional. Remember the video of the politician holding up an AR-15 saying it could fire 30 rounds a second? Someone can look at that video and decide that it is simply too dangerous, not out of emotion but out of their reasoning, but in the end they based their position on inaccurate data. Nuclear weapons shouldn't be in the hands of regular people, and I can arrive at this conclusion without emotion. Someone who is pro gun control may believe, though misinformation, that gun control would solve our violence problem. This doesn't mean that person is being emotional about it just because they choose wanting to solve our violence problem over protecting our rights.
Is the desire to prevent death emotional? Not by itself. But when the proposed solution is to (1) infringe on everyone's rights due to abuses by a mathematically insignificant subset,
and (2) creating laws that would have prevented 0 (zero, nada, none) of those deaths, then, yes, it is an emotional decision.
Every one of Obama's appeals is emotional:
We are the only advanced country with these kinds of mass shootings.
The NRA resists these common sense laws, even though 90% of their members say different.
30,000 shootings per year ....
The only reason for a 30 round magazine is to kill lots of people as quickly as possible.
Nobody needs an AR-15, which is often the mass murderer's weapon of choice.
We need universal background checks to prevent guns from being in the wrong hands.
Whether the statement is true or not is irrelevant. He would not have said any of those had they not been geared toward fear and emotion.
Democrats operate on emotional pleas. Facts turn people off, but emotions drive them to the polls!
-
Is the desire to prevent death emotional? Not by itself. But when the proposed solution is to (1) infringe on everyone's rights due to abuses by a mathematically insignificant subset,
and (2) creating laws that would have prevented 0 (zero, nada, none) of those deaths, then, yes, it is an emotional decision.
Every one of Obama's appeals is emotional:
We are the only advanced country with these kinds of mass shootings.
The NRA resists these common sense laws, even though 90% of their members say different.
30,000 shootings per year ....
The only reason for a 30 round magazine is to kill lots of people as quickly as possible.
Nobody needs an AR-15, which is often the mass murderer's weapon of choice.
We need universal background checks to prevent guns from being in the wrong hands.
Whether the statement is true or not is irrelevant. He would not have said any of those had they not been geared toward fear and emotion.
Democrats operate on emotional pleas. Facts turn people off, but emotions drive them to the polls!
They are misinformed, that is why they don't realize the laws they support would have little to no effect. Some might know but I think the average voter isn't as informed about the issue as us. Yes, we all know that the gun control measures being proposed would not make a significant difference but do they?
Even if their decisions are emotional, whether justified or not, when we talk to them I don't think it benefits us to push the emotion issue. I also don't think it is safe to make such a blanket statement about such a huge portion of the population. Even conservatives make emotional arguments sometimes.
-
Mods, please delete or lock thread.
-
It's difficult to change peoples minds on guns by words alone. They actually have to see it for their minds to change and it's a culture change, so it's a long term change that may take a decade or two. Change movies where ordinary citizens with CCW help take down a bad guy. Have news stories on shooting competitions and the high school air rifle teams. Take a friend, coworker, or neighbor with you to the range every month. Sit down and have a non-political chat with your legislator about how you enjoy shooting. Gather up all the victims of crimes and have them tell their crime story about how they couldn't defend themself, and how the police didn't help them. Build good relations with the regular police patrol officers. Work with womens and youth groups.
The gun community is the source of the problems. Many gun owners just keep to themselves or just hang out with other gun owners, instead of building good relations with the community. Hardly anyone volunteers for stuff except a handful of people even though many say gun rights are very important to them. And even then the gun community doesn't support those few hard working volunteers. There's little support or mentorship for new shooters. and the list goes on and on. We are the problem and that has to be changed first before we convince the anti-gunners to change. I feel we need a totally new way of thinking to reverse things.
IBTL
-
When you start shouting and arguing, people stop listening. I think that's the problem we have communicating with this legislature.
...and this thread.