2aHawaii

General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: kala201 on January 02, 2012, 06:46:35 PM

Title: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: kala201 on January 02, 2012, 06:46:35 PM
Ok so one of my resolutions was to finally breakdown and by a handgun.  My SO loves to shoot but most often I'm too lazy dig out the rifles and the target stand.  So I figured it was time to buy a pistol so we could go to the steel plates side with it and my M&P 15-22.  She shot a CZ that she really liked but I was looking for something more along the lines of a striker fire type of gun.  We went down to OGC and she handled a couple of S&W she said felt comfortable in her hand.  Read lots on the internet about the SD9 and the M&P series but was interested in hearing about what your guys wives or girlfriends shoot.  I'm leaning towards the 92FS SwissK has for sale in the classifieds section because of the price and the battlefield testedness (is that a word?) of that gun.  It doesn't fit the striker fire design I wanted but I'm not set on that being the only way.  I'm open to suggestions.  The only criteria I have right now is fits her hand well and is chambered in 9mm.  The other thing I don't much care for in terms of design is that rear safety on guns like the Kimbers and XD's where you have to have a complete solid grip to for the gun to fire.  Any suggestions?
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Pit808 on January 02, 2012, 07:10:51 PM
92's are pretty big in the grip if im not mistaken.  Not sure how big your wife's hands are, but the m&p 9 with small insert (every display will have the Med inserts on it 99.99% of the time) is unbeatable for a full size pistol IMHO.  Hold a m&p with small insert and I almost guarantee your search is over.  As long as she can rack the slide that is. My m&p is easier to rack than the g19 it replaced (she had a hard time with the g19).  My wife likes the m&p best, followed by a j frame and cz 82 tied for 2nd.  9mils she has shot were G19, M&P, 1911 govt.
 :shaka:
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: crazyazzmofo on January 02, 2012, 07:20:37 PM
i was thinking a s&w m&p or a glock 26 or 19 for my "old lady"...she has small hands...she likes my sig but too powerful at .40 for her... :shaka:
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: kong on January 02, 2012, 07:53:10 PM
If she likes the CZ why not get it for her?  It is what she is more comfortable shooting than what you want in my opinion.  One of the IDPA guys I used to shoot with had a CZ.  He was an older gent and a hell of a shot with the CZ.  Also, if you live in a pro-gun state that allows regular capacity magazines, I believe the mag capacity for a 9mm CZ is 17 rounds with it being pretty ergonomic.  Best bet is to go to a LIFE course or find a bunch of buddies that have a few handguns and try theirs out.  I am hoping next HDF range day to make it out and you/her can a few of my pistolas.

Oh also not a big fan of subcompacts G26 since the grip is shortened but the circumference is similar to all the G19/G17 family (hence magazine interchangeability), the sight radius is shortened (whats easier to shoot rifle or pistol?) and manipulation is a bit more difficult.  I believe also, ITTS trainer Scott Reitz wrote an article about full size thru subcompact sized pistols, just forgot what date it was.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: bass monkey on January 02, 2012, 08:13:54 PM
I have a xd9mm 4" barrel.  Its a nice gun.  Easy and fun to shoot.  Pretty smooth.  Went and shot it today with one of my friends.  She says she likes it too, smoother and feels better then her sig 40sw.
Overall its a nice gun.  And that rear saftey thing you talking about, not much of a problem and it doesnt get in the way.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: kala201 on January 02, 2012, 08:24:12 PM
Thanks for all your guys input.  We took the LIFE class and the one offered at Magnum, that one was a big let down.   She's shot a lot of different handguns.  She really doesn't like Sigs.  The thing I'm worried about is in a panic or stressful situation is her ability to manipulate the gun.  Right now she has a bad habbit of adjusting the gun in her hand to get the perfect grip like she learned in class.  I told her it just has to be grab and go. 

Yeah the 92fs is a big frame but in the classes she shot it and liked it.  Part of it is the weight.  In the LIFE class the female instructor and her hit it off and she learned a lot.  For a very small girl you guys should watch my girl shoot a .357 mag.  Everytime I watch her I have to pick my jaw up off the ground, talk about solid recoil management.

The M&P just might be the way to go.  But still looking for input. 

Mahalos
Title: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: sirkaiks on January 02, 2012, 08:27:32 PM
someone gotta buy the s&w bodyguard .380. supposed to be thin and tailored for women. i noticed that females like the sig 229 9mm cause it doesnt have too much kick.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: vooduchikn on January 02, 2012, 08:27:42 PM
Thanks for all your guys input.  We took the LIFE class and the one offered at Magnum, that one was a big let down.   She's shot a lot of different handguns.  She really doesn't like Sigs.  The thing I'm worried about is in a panic or stressful situation is her ability to manipulate the gun.  Right now she has a bad habbit of adjusting the gun in her hand to get the perfect grip like she learned in class.  I told her it just has to be grab and go. 

Yeah the 92fs is a big frame but in the classes she shot it and liked it.  Part of it is the weight.  In the LIFE class the female instructor and her hit it off and she learned a lot.  For a very small girl you guys should watch my girl shoot a .357 mag.  Everytime I watch her I have to pick my jaw up off the ground, talk about solid recoil management.

The M&P just might be the way to go.  But still looking for input. 

Mahalos

Get here a wheel gun. Wife had same concerns....likes to shoot semi autos, but concerned about something not going right when/if it goes down. Got her a ruger LCR in .357mag, pretty mindless.  No safety, double action (good trigger I might add), no hammer to snag on anything, good ergonomics. Loaded it up with .38 special +P speer gold dots. Getting her some speed loaders and will work her up to .357 mag later.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: MantisClaw on January 02, 2012, 08:35:56 PM
My girlfriend has a preference for revolvers but that's mainly due to similar issues with racking slides.  She can lock them back but that takes time and her method wouldn't be viable should she need to clear a malfunction under stress.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: kong on January 02, 2012, 08:57:10 PM
Found the article though it relates more to off-duty carry/CCW.  Also, revolvers are great for women and anyone not investing a substantial time in training.  If one cylinder doesn't go bang pull the trigger again until you have had 5-7 trigger pulls then reload.

"Off Duty Carry by Scott Reitz

 I spent thirty years on LAPD. Over twenty six of those were in Metropolitan Division and ten of those were in SWAT. I ran in service classes for divisions and specialized units throughout the department during my last fifteen years or so on the department. Thirty years of being intimately involved in the teaching and application and subsequent defense of deadly force issues, teaches one many lessons. The subject of off duty carry is often disregarded to the detriment of many who have found themselves in such critical situations.
    There have been many off duty deadly force encounters that I am aware of. Very few of these entailed the proverbial, ‘White Knight’ riding to the rescue. Most of the encounters have been self defense in nature. They have been officers who have found it necessary to defend either themselves or their immediate family. Few of these encounters afforded the officer any other option other than deadly force when reviewed from a reasonable perspective.

This fact alone, should raise the question of just why and how an officer should carry off duty. There have been officers that I am aware of who do not carry weapons in an off duty status. This is entirely a personal choice that one may regret.  Their response when queried as to why they don’t carry off duty is that, ‘they aren’t looking for trouble.”  Neither is any sane individual but most officers that find themselves in critical situations never envisioned that they would be there in the first place and almost all of these encounters are as a direct result of the suspect’s actions not theirs! These are officers who are going about their lives and suddenly find themselves confronted by the unpredictability of life.

We have had officers who have had to run to save their lives from knife wielding suspects, Officers forced to the prone in banks with guns to their heads who were completely at the suspect’s mercy etc. None of these are very heartening experiences. The decision to carry should be weighed with the simple fact in mind that life and all that comes with it is unpredictable and that deadly force can come at you from any corner at any moment. This does not mean by the way, that the Officer is paranoid or seeking out such encounters but rather that he is aware that this can occur and he may want to comport himself accordingly.  Officers frequently carry much smaller side arms off duty than they would on while on duty. This comes at a price. Those of you that have been through my training are familiar with the realistic drills and targets that we present during these evolutions.

Moving targets, partial targets, low level light scenarios, speed reloads, malfunction clearances etc. are all thrown at you at a realistic pace and within a realistic framework. Imagine trying to accomplish the same result that you are pushed with when using your standard side arm but now you are using a two inch, five shot revolver or a very compressed semi-automatic and is no longer a drill but a very real life and death encounter. It would be that much harder to accomplish and you may have not have even considered the following. Traditionally, Officers train much more with the standard fire arm than they ever will with the smaller off duty carry pistol. As a point of fact, I would imagine that Officers probably will put less than 200 rounds through these smaller pistols during their entire career and almost none of these rounds will be fired in realistic training scenarios. Smaller pistols are harder to control, harder to manipulate and have a shorter sight radius that lends to more potential error in sight alignment by the shooter.


Consider the following. If you are off duty you have no body armor, no shotgun, no rifle, no communication, and no police vehicle with ballistic side panels, no immediate access to air support and no partner.  In point of fact those with you may be more of a tactical detriment than an asset. If there was any time when you needed a pistol that you are intimately familiar with, that you have shot extensively and ultimately depend on for its unfailing reliability this is it!  This would not be the time to sport a two inch five shot that you have trouble attaining hits with at seven yards. The mid sized pistols that are just a step below full size would be the best compromise if that is your choice. Personally, I carry a full sized pistol that I know works when I want it to, that is accurate and dependable and one that I have practiced with through the years.   There is nothing that I have to adapt to on the spur of the moment. I know the pistol and what I can accomplish with it and that is security enough. In all my years I was never involved in a single off duty incident.   That doesn’t mean that it can’t happen tomorrow though. Trying to guess when or where, or if it will come, is a fairly difficult proposition.  Murphy’s Law seems to be prevalent in most off duty situations.   When I ask Officers who were involved in such shootings whether they expected it, the overwhelming majority responded “no”.
   

Since we have had shootings in churches, in driveways, on the beach, on family trips, in their neighbor’s yards etc. this is not an altogether unrealistic response. One simply doesn’t know what life may throw at you. Whether you choose to carry off duty and if you do, what you choose to carry may very well mean the difference of living to enjoy all that you have sought to accomplish.
Note: I’d be interested to know how many of you carry off duty.  Please send me your comments & thoughts."
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Pit808 on January 02, 2012, 08:59:17 PM
Speaking of revo's, my night stand gun is a S&W 640-1 .357mag with crimson trace grips.  Went with this as the nightstand gun for the reasons mentioned above.  My wife doesn't shoot as much as I'd like, so I tried to make it as easy as possible.  Put the red dot on the target and let her rip  :thumbsup:
For recreational shooting the 4" M&P is alot easier for her to shoot.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: kala201 on January 02, 2012, 09:03:45 PM
Get here a wheel gun. Wife had same concerns....likes to shoot semi autos, but concerned about something not going right when/if it goes down. Got her a ruger LCR in .357mag, pretty mindless.  No safety, double action (good trigger I might add), no hammer to snag on anything, good ergonomics. Loaded it up with .38 special +P speer gold dots. Getting her some speed loaders and will work her up to .357 mag later.

Voodu-

That might be worth looking into.  We didn't want a compact, because Hawaii doesn't yet and may never freely allow conceal carry.  And knockdown factor is a concern too.  I work construction and see a lot of guys strung out on various things and so I really worry about my girlfriend.  Our dogs will do anything to protect us, but against an assailant high on drugs and armed with a knife they are only likely to slow him down long enough so she can get to the gun.  The .38 +P is supposed to be a good self defense round.  She wanted a semi-auto because that's what a friend of ours told her is best.  But like you guys said a wheel gun maybe the way to go.

I wish I had more money to buy two or three different guns and then sell off the ones that didn't work for her.  After talking to Daniel at KGS we may do his handgun safety class to try out his HK's and a few others.  Last time I talked to him he said he had an FN 5-7 he was going to test and review.  That's my good friend from Alaska's daily carry and what he swears by.  Hopefully I can get some trigger time on that bad boy if we do take his class.  If my gf's hands weren't so small, that is what I would buy because it's easy to shoot due to the small amount of kick.  The only problem is the grip is so big because the 5-7 round is actually a small rifle round.

As to that rear safety thing on the XD's I its guess more of a personal preference and frame of mind thing.  If for some reason my girlfriend or even myself are ever in an awkward postition, like for example pinned on the bed or ground in an attempeted rape where she can't get the needed grip but can still pull the trigger without injuring herself... you can see where I'm going.  The operator needs to be the one responsible for safe gun handling.
Title: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Jl808 on January 02, 2012, 09:06:49 PM
I had the same question when I recently got my first handgun for me and my SO.  First 9mm is a good choice due to lower cost of ammo (practice more) and lower recoil for the lady.

I had ruled out all SIGs because my SO and I disliked the grip, ruled out all revolvers because I wanted magazines, and (for no reason whatsoever) had not really looked into the S&W M&P.  After much research and a couple of visits to gun shops, I was deciding between the following 9mms:

1. Glock 17
- $500+ range
- good price, simple to use, simple to clean

2. Springfield XD9
- $500+ range
- good price, simple to use, simple to clean

3. HK P2000
- $800+ range
- very quality feel and felt really good

I had really wanted to like the HK but couldn't be sure whether it was going to be worth the extra $300.  It was really nice to hold except that it felt like it had a really long trigger pull.

I heard good things about the CZ75s but did not have any shop to test-hold one locally. 

To stick to my budget, I ended up with the XD9 which is in the same category as the Glock.  There are a lot of folks that really like Glocks but Springfield had a special at the time where the XD came with nightsights and 5 magazines (instead of he normal 2).  Oh yeah, the Glock has crappy plastic sights which should probably be replaced as soon as possible. 

Money saved went to buy extra ammo and save up for the next purchase.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 02, 2012, 09:18:30 PM
Get here a wheel gun. Wife had same concerns....likes to shoot semi autos, but concerned about something not going right when/if it goes down. Got her a ruger LCR in .357mag, pretty mindless.  No safety, double action (good trigger I might add), no hammer to snag on anything, good ergonomics. Loaded it up with .38 special +P speer gold dots. Getting her some speed loaders and will work her up to .357 mag later.

Voodu-

That might be worth looking into.  We didn't want a compact, because Hawaii doesn't yet and may never freely allow conceal carry.  And knockdown factor is a concern too.  I work construction and see a lot of guys strung out on various things and so I really worry about my girlfriend.  Our dogs will do anything to protect us, but against an assailant high on drugs and armed with a knife they are only likely to slow him down long enough so she can get to the gun.  The .38 +P is supposed to be a good self defense round.  She wanted a semi-auto because that's what a friend of ours told her is best.  But like you guys said a wheel gun maybe the way to go.

I wish I had more money to buy two or three different guns and then sell off the ones that didn't work for her.  After talking to Daniel at KGS we may do his handgun safety class to try out his HK's and a few others.  Last time I talked to him he said he had an FN 5-7 he was going to test and review.  That's my good friend from Alaska's daily carry and what he swears by.  Hopefully I can get some trigger time on that bad boy if we do take his class.  If my gf's hands weren't so small, that is what I would buy because it's easy to shoot due to the small amount of kick.  The only problem is the grip is so big because the 5-7 round is actually a small rifle round.

As to that rear safety thing on the XD's I its guess more of a personal preference and frame of mind thing.  If for some reason my girlfriend or even myself are ever in an awkward postition, like for example pinned on the bed or ground in an attempeted rape where she can't get the needed grip but can still pull the trigger without injuring herself... you can see where I'm going.  The operator needs to be the one responsible for safe gun handling.

That's one of the cool things about Daniels class.
He brings like 20 pistols.
Title: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: vooduchikn on January 02, 2012, 09:22:47 PM


  Oh yeah, the Glock has crappy plastic sights which should probably be replaced as soon as possible. 

nothing wrong with the factory sights imho. They are much tougher than you think.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: myanmar1 on January 02, 2012, 09:39:25 PM
FWIW my wife likes her Glock 17, and loves her 1911.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: kala201 on January 02, 2012, 09:44:28 PM
I really should start another thread for this but I was wondering how many of you have a full size airsoft replica of your primary handgun?  My neighbor is originally from Washington state where he has his CCW card.  His carry gun is a 92FS.  He has an airsoft version of that gun which he uses to practice drawing from holster, presentation of gun and firing.  He said while you don't get the full 100% experience you do get a the feel of things like "I can't wear that its hard to draw" or "I don't like my holster here, lets try this".  And then you also get the chance to develop muscle memory because the more exepensive ones have all the same controls and lockback after firing the last BB and one can practice keeping track of how many rounds fired when doing tactical reloads.  This maybe something I do too depending which gun we end up getting.
Title: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Jl808 on January 02, 2012, 10:22:49 PM
I really should start another thread for this but I was wondering how many of you have a full size airsoft replica of your primary handgun?

Not I but good idea!
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: SpeedTek on January 02, 2012, 11:00:06 PM
Also good to consider is a gun that can convert to 22lr.
 I have a Walther P38 9mm with a 22lr conversion and I have my son practice on a 22lr.
It actually helped him in control of the pistol when he goes back to the 9mm rounds.
I would like to get something more modern when I see a good deal !
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Old Guy on January 02, 2012, 11:48:20 PM
About the Beretta 92/96 series.

Just had a range session with a forum member and his wife.  She has smaller hands.

She ended up liking the Full sized Beretta best.  She felt it had the kindest recoil.

Yes, she is aware that the grip is large for her hands, but she said she likes it and she will Learn

to use it effectively.  She likes it, that's really all that matters.  No gun is a perfect fit.

My Wife is in the same situation.  She's shot a lot of different guns. 

Her Favorite is a Beretta 92/96.  She also says, if she likes the gun, she'll learn and adapt to it.

Don't forget, if your SO isn't happy with Her gun, she will Not want to go shooting with you.

If she likes it, then you will have your range buddy.

FYI:  Beretta does have a 22 kit for $369.  It is made in small batches, 35 to 50 every now and then.  Sells out in a couple of days.

Just take off the slide and barrel, replace with the 22 slide/barrel and magazine.   Gives great practice with your 92/96 gun.

Wife liked it so well that I got a used police 92 and made it into a full size 22.
Title: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Jl808 on January 03, 2012, 12:13:57 AM
Huh interesting.... My wife also said she liked shooting the beretta 92.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: crazyazzmofo on January 03, 2012, 12:48:31 AM
i wanted to get the bodyguard .380 for my girl but i hear that for a small gun that it got plenty kick...plus i heard that it malfunctions after so many rounds...im having second thoughts about that one...
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Pit808 on January 03, 2012, 01:08:24 AM
i wanted to get the bodyguard .380 for my girl but i hear that for a small gun that it got plenty kick...plus i heard that it malfunctions after so many rounds...im having second thoughts about that one...

Hey crazy, If you are looking at 380's I would check out the CZ 83.  Cost about $350 new and is a SOLID DA/SA gun.  I have three CZ 82's (9mm mak version but pretty much identical other than caliber and trigger guard) and they are very nice shooters and fit the hand very well. 

http://www.jgsales.com/cz-83-380acp,-3.8in.-new-p-3885.html (http://www.jgsales.com/cz-83-380acp,-3.8in.-new-p-3885.html)
You would just need the 10rd mag instead of the 12 rounders.  JG swapped mags for me on a CZ 82 I got from them. The 82 and 83 use the same mags.

 :shaka:
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Inspector on January 03, 2012, 06:30:43 AM
With my experience with the ladies wanting to get into shooting I found most of them felt more comfy with a revolver. I have taught many a GF and Wife (Have had 3) and a few of my nieces. Only one chose a semi-auto and the one she chose was a Beretta .22. I found that the .38/.357 seems to be the best combo of low recoil and choice of self defense ammo. I found that medium frame or large frame (If they can handle it) seem to be favs of the ladies I dealt with. I found that once they get over being scared of guns and shooting them they will eventually want to get to know semi-autos a little more. The problem is that I found most women don't like dealing with the stiffness of the spring loaded slide. Which is why the revolver seemed to be the fav of the gals I taught. Combine that with ease of cleaning and not having to take the gun apart and the revolver seems to be the choice of those ladies who who are truly interested in getting into shooting. Oh, and revolvers are not prone to misfeeding due to limp wristing or week wrists of some ladies. JMHO
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: kala201 on January 03, 2012, 08:59:12 AM
Yeah my girlfriend liked the Beretta 92 too.  When we did the handgun safety class over at Magnum that was the one gun she gravitated towards the most especially when we had to practice the double tap.  She said it was easier for her to control and that she was able to get back on target faster.

Ok but her is my concern... (again maybe overthinking) I would like her to be able to fire it one handed if needed.  For example when we have kids if she has to protect and hold our child behind her she will only have one hand on the gun.  Right now a j-frame is starting to look like a winner when it comes to that.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: GZire on January 03, 2012, 09:10:03 AM
Get here a wheel gun. Wife had same concerns....likes to shoot semi autos, but concerned about something not going right when/if it goes down. Got her a ruger LCR in .357mag, pretty mindless.  No safety, double action (good trigger I might add), no hammer to snag on anything, good ergonomics. Loaded it up with .38 special +P speer gold dots. Getting her some speed loaders and will work her up to .357 mag later.

Voodu-

That might be worth looking into.  We didn't want a compact, because Hawaii doesn't yet and may never freely allow conceal carry.  And knockdown factor is a concern too.  I work construction and see a lot of guys strung out on various things and so I really worry about my girlfriend.  Our dogs will do anything to protect us, but against an assailant high on drugs and armed with a knife they are only likely to slow him down long enough so she can get to the gun.  The .38 +P is supposed to be a good self defense round.  She wanted a semi-auto because that's what a friend of ours told her is best.  But like you guys said a wheel gun maybe the way to go.

I wish I had more money to buy two or three different guns and then sell off the ones that didn't work for her.  After talking to Daniel at KGS we may do his handgun safety class to try out his HK's and a few others.  Last time I talked to him he said he had an FN 5-7 he was going to test and review.  That's my good friend from Alaska's daily carry and what he swears by.  Hopefully I can get some trigger time on that bad boy if we do take his class.  If my gf's hands weren't so small, that is what I would buy because it's easy to shoot due to the small amount of kick.  The only problem is the grip is so big because the 5-7 round is actually a small rifle round.

As to that rear safety thing on the XD's I its guess more of a personal preference and frame of mind thing.  If for some reason my girlfriend or even myself are ever in an awkward postition, like for example pinned on the bed or ground in an attempted rape where she can't get the needed grip but can still pull the trigger without injuring herself... you can see where I'm going.  The operator needs to be the one responsible for safe gun handling.
Kala - I have pretty small hands/short fingers.  I've been using a Sig P220 in some form or another for a good long while.  I too need to shift my hands on the handle to get a better finger placement on the DA pull.  SA is OK.  So anyhow, I've been looking at different handguns recently as well and finally settled on a full sized 1911 in 45 (single stack) as, believe it or not, the grip is actually pretty small in comparison to other pistols.  I had tried my friend's M&P 45, but I just didn't like how it felt...........both the trigger pull and the snappiness of the recoil. 

My friend still has a M&P 9 mm that he changed the trigger out and changed the recoil spring on too.  It is a completely different gun.  Trigger is much better and the (heavier) recoil spring has tamed down that perceived recoil.  So much so that I'm actually considering buying one (although I do love my 45 acp guns).

With regards to that FN.  I haven't held one in a long time, but I don't think the handle is all that big.  The round if you compare it side by side with other pistol rounds is actually not that large.

The recommendations:
Beretta 92 - nice pistol.  You still need to transition from a DA to a SA pull.  As with all semi autos it's going to take more practice to become proficient as compared to a wheeled gun.  For a beginner I'd opt for a wheeled gun.
S&W M&P 9 - nice pistol.  Very good as you can change the grip panels to accommodate different hand sized.  As with other polymer framed guns you can also shave them down, stipple them, etc.  Very flexible.
Glocks - don't know much about which model is which, but I'm sure there's one out there that would suit her needs.
H&K P30 - nice pistol.  Very pricey compared to the M&P and Glocks.
Springfield XD - don't know much about these at all, but I hate the grip safety in addition to the trigger safety.  I think it's overkill and not in a good way.

Magazine safeties - some pistols out today have magazine safeties.  The gun won't fire without the magazine in.  I think that's foolish for a SD firearm to have.  I strongly suggest whatever you get to make sure that the gun doesn't have this feature.

S&W M&P 340 CT:
http://www.smith-wesson.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/Product4_750001_750051_765780_-1_757783_757781_757781_ProductDisplayErrorView_Y (http://www.smith-wesson.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/Product4_750001_750051_765780_-1_757783_757781_757781_ProductDisplayErrorView_Y)
Pricey, but if you are looking for a SD firearm, then IMHO you should be willing to pay several hundred dollars more.  I'm not advocating this particular model, but more the features it has.  Small grip, Crimson Trace laser, 357 mag allows extended practice with 38 spl and shorter practice with the magnum rounds, internal hammer (no worries about snags).  It's a revolver so as a new shooter won't have to worry about more complex clearance under stress that can happen with a semi auto.  Unlike a semi auto you could actually reliably fire several rounds while still having the firearm in a jacket pocket.  One more thing to think about.........if it will be used for carry, then weight will be a huge concern.  It's not going to be fun to shoot a lightweight, but you probably wouldn't have to do that, but you would need to carry it a lot and that would be a greater factor IMO.


Lots of stuff to think about.  Even more so if you intend for this to be a SD gun for your gal.  If it's a range/plinker, then not so much thought is required.  In any case with most things firearms related it will be a compromise.  Main thing is you are aware of your choices and what they mean when you make your decision.



I really should start another thread for this but I was wondering how many of you have a full size airsoft replica of your primary handgun?  My neighbor is originally from Washington state where he has his CCW card.  His carry gun is a 92FS.  He has an airsoft version of that gun which he uses to practice drawing from holster, presentation of gun and firing.  He said while you don't get the full 100% experience you do get a the feel of things like "I can't wear that its hard to draw" or "I don't like my holster here, lets try this".  And then you also get the chance to develop muscle memory because the more expensive ones have all the same controls and lockback after firing the last BB and one can practice keeping track of how many rounds fired when doing tactical reloads.  This maybe something I do too depending which gun we end up getting.
Your friend makes good sense.  I have an airsoft Sig P226 that I use as my counterpart to my actual Sig P220 Elite primary. I have an airsoft 1911 5" that is the counterpart to my full sized 1911 that I intend to switch over to as my primary this year.  I have a Blackhawk Serpa holster for the Sig as well as a Comptac.  I've got some Raven holsters on order for the 1911's.  I've been lazy and need to work on getting a target set up so I can shoot my airsoft pistols inside my house.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: GZire on January 03, 2012, 09:12:46 AM
i wanted to get the bodyguard .380 for my girl but i hear that for a small gun that it got plenty kick...plus i heard that it malfunctions after so many rounds...im having second thoughts about that one...
What kind of malfunctions are you talking about?


Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: SpeedTek on January 03, 2012, 11:55:05 AM
Back in the day I ran through a ipsc course with a Walther ppk/s .380
And it was very difficult. The kick is a lot harder then some
Mid frame 9mm. I learned why a 380 should only be a
Backup.  You lose a lot of time on re-aiming.

I wonder if they have any open shooting like that
Today?
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: kong on January 03, 2012, 12:36:44 PM
Full size has more weight behind it to mitigate recoil compared to a light weight pistol.  Also, target loads are different from full power sd ammo.  Revolver or pistol you will still need to train and if kids are involved you will need to train with them in a scenario or at the minimum plan out what you will do including calling the police.  There is no right answer to tactics.  The only right answer in a confrontation is that you and your family live through it.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 03, 2012, 12:48:15 PM
Full size has more weight behind it to mitigate recoil compared to a light weight pistol.  Also, target loads are different from full power sd ammo.  Revolver or pistol you will still need to train and if kids are involved you will need to train with them in a scenario or at the minimum plan out what you will do including calling the police.  There is no right answer to tactics.  The only right answer in a confrontation is that you and your family live through it.
:thumbsup:

Definitely plan and practice.
My wife gives me a funny look every time we go through the practice drills but God forbid, if something happens, we will be prepared.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: GZire on January 03, 2012, 01:51:56 PM
Full size has more weight behind it to mitigate recoil compared to a light weight pistol.  Also, target loads are different from full power sd ammo.  Revolver or pistol you will still need to train and if kids are involved you will need to train with them in a scenario or at the minimum plan out what you will do including calling the police.  There is no right answer to tactics.  The only right answer in a confrontation is that you and your family live through it.
:thumbsup:

Definitely plan and practice.
My wife gives me a funny look every time we go through the practice drills but God forbid, if something happens, we will be prepared.

I've always thought that you'd just run into your safe room and wait for the bad guys.  When they hit the hallway you pull a cord dropping your collection of firearms on them crushing them to death and also plugging up entry to the saferoom until the LEO's can arrive on scene to clear the house.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 03, 2012, 02:50:23 PM
Full size has more weight behind it to mitigate recoil compared to a light weight pistol.  Also, target loads are different from full power sd ammo.  Revolver or pistol you will still need to train and if kids are involved you will need to train with them in a scenario or at the minimum plan out what you will do including calling the police.  There is no right answer to tactics.  The only right answer in a confrontation is that you and your family live through it.
:thumbsup:

Definitely plan and practice.
My wife gives me a funny look every time we go through the practice drills but God forbid, if something happens, we will be prepared.

I've always thought that you'd just run into your safe room and wait for the bad guys.  When they hit the hallway you pull a cord dropping your collection of firearms on them crushing them to death and also plugging up entry to the saferoom until the LEO's can arrive on scene to clear the house.
:rofl: :rofl:
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: crazyazzmofo on January 03, 2012, 03:51:34 PM
i wanted to get the bodyguard .380 for my girl but i hear that for a small gun that it got plenty kick...plus i heard that it malfunctions after so many rounds...im having second thoughts about that one...

Hey crazy, If you are looking at 380's I would check out the CZ 83.  Cost about $350 new and is a SOLID DA/SA gun.  I have three CZ 82's (9mm mak version but pretty much identical other than caliber and trigger guard) and they are very nice shooters and fit the hand very well. 

http://www.jgsales.com/cz-83-380acp,-3.8in.-new-p-3885.html (http://www.jgsales.com/cz-83-380acp,-3.8in.-new-p-3885.html)
You would just need the 10rd mag instead of the 12 rounders.  JG swapped mags for me on a CZ 82 I got from them. The 82 and 83 use the same mags.

 :shaka:

hey pit...thanks for the info! i will definitely check it out...i've been looking for a while and it doesn't help that she don't wanna go an look...LOL  :shaka:

i wanted to get the bodyguard .380 for my girl but i hear that for a small gun that it got plenty kick...plus i heard that it malfunctions after so many rounds...im having second thoughts about that one...
What kind of malfunctions are you talking about?




i heard in the earlier versions that after x amount of rounds the hammer was failing to engage on the first pull...it then took sometimes up to 5 pulls before firing...i heard other stories of the trigger not returning after firing...this was the earlier models so with everything the first models always have bugs...i probably will be looking into it more...do a little more research  :shaka:
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: GZire on January 03, 2012, 05:25:28 PM
^^^Scary friggen stories man.  If they are true then the R&D guys were not doing their job when developing the firearm.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: bass monkey on January 03, 2012, 07:23:58 PM
I would have to agree about the sig and their long trigger pull.  My friend has a SigP226 and the trigger is so long.  I think he said its a double trigger.  Could be wrong though.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: GZire on January 04, 2012, 05:29:02 PM
I would have to agree about the sig and their long trigger pull.  My friend has a SigP226 and the trigger is so long.  I think he said its a double trigger.  Could be wrong though.

Double action (only)?
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Inspector on January 04, 2012, 06:47:35 PM
The standard Sig is a single/double action trigger. Because it is a double action you have a lot of take up before you get to the single action trigger. The advantage to this system is you can use the decocker and lower the hammer on a loaded chamber. So your first shot will be double action and every shot thereafter is single action with a long take up. It takes some getting used to, but is quite safe to carry with a loaded chamber. Plus that single action trigger is so sweet right out of the box.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: crazyazzmofo on January 04, 2012, 06:54:31 PM
The standard Sig is a single/double action trigger. Because it is a double action you have a lot of take up before you get to the single action trigger. The advantage to this system is you can use the decocker and lower the hammer on a loaded chamber. So your first shot will be double action and every shot thereafter is single action with a long take up. It takes some getting used to, but is quite safe to carry with a loaded chamber. Plus that single action trigger is so sweet right out of the box.

i love the single action on my 229...i like to practice with the double action first pull but if anything were to happen i've been practicing loading my weapon and pulling the hammer back to put me straight into single action  :geekdanc:
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Inspector on January 04, 2012, 07:02:33 PM
i love the single action on my 229...i like to practice with the double action first pull but if anything were to happen i've been practicing loading my weapon and pulling the hammer back to put me straight into single action  :geekdanc:
I have a 228 and I love the single action on it as well. I also practice with double action then transition to single action. If we ever get CCW here it will be my first choice for carry.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: crazyazzmofo on January 04, 2012, 07:10:58 PM
i love the single action on my 229...i like to practice with the double action first pull but if anything were to happen i've been practicing loading my weapon and pulling the hammer back to put me straight into single action  :geekdanc:
I have a 228 and I love the single action on it as well. I also practice with double action then transition to single action. If we ever get CCW here it will be my first choice for carry.

yup...if we EVER get CCW...229 by my side...all day everyday!!!
Title: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: vooduchikn on January 04, 2012, 07:52:08 PM
The standard Sig is a single/double action trigger. Because it is a double action you have a lot of take up before you get to the single action trigger. The advantage to this system is you can use the decocker and lower the hammer on a loaded chamber. So your first shot will be double action and every shot thereafter is single action with a long take up. It takes some getting used to, but is quite safe to carry with a loaded chamber. Plus that single action trigger is so sweet right out of the box.
the double single is nice to have for a carry gun. The double is great for folks who are jumpy on the draw and may nd before they get on target. The reset on the sig single is short and very nice. I would practice drawing double action/decocked, pulling through the first shot and then moving to follow up shots. Cocking the hammer back is pointless imho.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: crazyazzmofo on January 04, 2012, 07:54:33 PM
The standard Sig is a single/double action trigger. Because it is a double action you have a lot of take up before you get to the single action trigger. The advantage to this system is you can use the decocker and lower the hammer on a loaded chamber. So your first shot will be double action and every shot thereafter is single action with a long take up. It takes some getting used to, but is quite safe to carry with a loaded chamber. Plus that single action trigger is so sweet right out of the box.
the double single is nice to have for a carry gun. The double is great for folks who are jumpy on the draw and may nd before they get on target. The reset on the sig single is short and very nice. I would practice drawing double action/decocked, pulling through the first shot and then moving to follow up shots. Cocking the hammer back is pointless imho.

i'll try it out  :shaka:
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: vooduchikn on January 04, 2012, 09:35:15 PM
The standard Sig is a single/double action trigger. Because it is a double action you have a lot of take up before you get to the single action trigger. The advantage to this system is you can use the decocker and lower the hammer on a loaded chamber. So your first shot will be double action and every shot thereafter is single action with a long take up. It takes some getting used to, but is quite safe to carry with a loaded chamber. Plus that single action trigger is so sweet right out of the box.
the double single is nice to have for a carry gun. The double is great for folks who are jumpy on the draw and may nd before they get on target. The reset on the sig single is short and very nice. I would practice drawing double action/decocked, pulling through the first shot and then moving to follow up shots. Cocking the hammer back is pointless imho.

i'll try it out  :shaka:

Oh yeah, probably don't need to say this, but...dry fire practicing this won't work, you need to first round to fire/cycle the slide so that the firearm is single action, your trigger will be all double action unless you actually fire a round.  When/if I carry my sig, it is round in the chamber, hammer decocked (double action trigger). This is the way the SIG is designed to be carried. It isn't designed to be carried singe action (hammer back) like a 1911. 

I started my wife off on the SIG because it had a long "first" trigger pull. This way if she did have to draw down on someone/thing she might be less apt to put a round in the ground or worse, shoot someone/something that she didn't have to (including herself on the draw) becuase of a very light trigger pull.  She now has a double action only revolver in .357 for the same reasons.  My Sig has a VERY light single action trigger and short reset. 

I went to Glocks a while back and haven't looked back.

Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: crazyazzmofo on January 04, 2012, 10:03:19 PM
The standard Sig is a single/double action trigger. Because it is a double action you have a lot of take up before you get to the single action trigger. The advantage to this system is you can use the decocker and lower the hammer on a loaded chamber. So your first shot will be double action and every shot thereafter is single action with a long take up. It takes some getting used to, but is quite safe to carry with a loaded chamber. Plus that single action trigger is so sweet right out of the box.
the double single is nice to have for a carry gun. The double is great for folks who are jumpy on the draw and may nd before they get on target. The reset on the sig single is short and very nice. I would practice drawing double action/decocked, pulling through the first shot and then moving to follow up shots. Cocking the hammer back is pointless imho.

i'll try it out  :shaka:

Oh yeah, probably don't need to say this, but...dry fire practicing this won't work, you need to first round to fire/cycle the slide so that the firearm is single action, your trigger will be all double action unless you actually fire a round.  When/if I carry my sig, it is round in the chamber, hammer decocked (double action trigger). This is the way the SIG is designed to be carried. It isn't designed to be carried singe action (hammer back) like a 1911. 

I started my wife off on the SIG because it had a long "first" trigger pull. This way if she did have to draw down on someone/thing she might be less apt to put a round in the ground or worse, shoot someone/something that she didn't have to (including herself on the draw) becuase of a very light trigger pull.  She now has a double action only revolver in .357 for the same reasons.  My Sig has a VERY light single action trigger and short reset. 

I went to Glocks a while back and haven't looked back.

yeah...maybe if i ever make it to magnum i can try it out...
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: vooduchikn on January 04, 2012, 10:09:13 PM
The standard Sig is a single/double action trigger. Because it is a double action you have a lot of take up before you get to the single action trigger. The advantage to this system is you can use the decocker and lower the hammer on a loaded chamber. So your first shot will be double action and every shot thereafter is single action with a long take up. It takes some getting used to, but is quite safe to carry with a loaded chamber. Plus that single action trigger is so sweet right out of the box.
the double single is nice to have for a carry gun. The double is great for folks who are jumpy on the draw and may nd before they get on target. The reset on the sig single is short and very nice. I would practice drawing double action/decocked, pulling through the first shot and then moving to follow up shots. Cocking the hammer back is pointless imho.

i'll try it out  :shaka:

Oh yeah, probably don't need to say this, but...dry fire practicing this won't work, you need to first round to fire/cycle the slide so that the firearm is single action, your trigger will be all double action unless you actually fire a round.  When/if I carry my sig, it is round in the chamber, hammer decocked (double action trigger). This is the way the SIG is designed to be carried. It isn't designed to be carried singe action (hammer back) like a 1911. 

I started my wife off on the SIG because it had a long "first" trigger pull. This way if she did have to draw down on someone/thing she might be less apt to put a round in the ground or worse, shoot someone/something that she didn't have to (including herself on the draw) becuase of a very light trigger pull.  She now has a double action only revolver in .357 for the same reasons.  My Sig has a VERY light single action trigger and short reset. 

I went to Glocks a while back and haven't looked back.

yeah...maybe if i ever make it to magnum i can try it out...

Nah don't spend your hard earned cash to do something you should be able to do anyways,  Go to the January HDF shoot. I'll bring mine and show you what I am talking about....
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: crazyazzmofo on January 04, 2012, 10:22:23 PM
The standard Sig is a single/double action trigger. Because it is a double action you have a lot of take up before you get to the single action trigger. The advantage to this system is you can use the decocker and lower the hammer on a loaded chamber. So your first shot will be double action and every shot thereafter is single action with a long take up. It takes some getting used to, but is quite safe to carry with a loaded chamber. Plus that single action trigger is so sweet right out of the box.
the double single is nice to have for a carry gun. The double is great for folks who are jumpy on the draw and may nd before they get on target. The reset on the sig single is short and very nice. I would practice drawing double action/decocked, pulling through the first shot and then moving to follow up shots. Cocking the hammer back is pointless imho.

i'll try it out  :shaka:

Oh yeah, probably don't need to say this, but...dry fire practicing this won't work, you need to first round to fire/cycle the slide so that the firearm is single action, your trigger will be all double action unless you actually fire a round.  When/if I carry my sig, it is round in the chamber, hammer decocked (double action trigger). This is the way the SIG is designed to be carried. It isn't designed to be carried singe action (hammer back) like a 1911. 

I started my wife off on the SIG because it had a long "first" trigger pull. This way if she did have to draw down on someone/thing she might be less apt to put a round in the ground or worse, shoot someone/something that she didn't have to (including herself on the draw) becuase of a very light trigger pull.  She now has a double action only revolver in .357 for the same reasons.  My Sig has a VERY light single action trigger and short reset. 

I went to Glocks a while back and haven't looked back.

yeah...maybe if i ever make it to magnum i can try it out...

Nah don't spend your hard earned cash to do something you should be able to do anyways,  Go to the January HDF shoot. I'll bring mine and show you what I am talking about....

im pretty sure i know what your talking about...practice practice practice...i was thinking of getting a glock too...something my "old lady" can use...probably a 9mm...when in january is the HDF shoot?
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 04, 2012, 10:59:09 PM
The standard Sig is a single/double action trigger. Because it is a double action you have a lot of take up before you get to the single action trigger. The advantage to this system is you can use the decocker and lower the hammer on a loaded chamber. So your first shot will be double action and every shot thereafter is single action with a long take up. It takes some getting used to, but is quite safe to carry with a loaded chamber. Plus that single action trigger is so sweet right out of the box.
the double single is nice to have for a carry gun. The double is great for folks who are jumpy on the draw and may nd before they get on target. The reset on the sig single is short and very nice. I would practice drawing double action/decocked, pulling through the first shot and then moving to follow up shots. Cocking the hammer back is pointless imho.

i'll try it out  :shaka:

Oh yeah, probably don't need to say this, but...dry fire practicing this won't work, you need to first round to fire/cycle the slide so that the firearm is single action, your trigger will be all double action unless you actually fire a round.  When/if I carry my sig, it is round in the chamber, hammer decocked (double action trigger). This is the way the SIG is designed to be carried. It isn't designed to be carried singe action (hammer back) like a 1911. 

I started my wife off on the SIG because it had a long "first" trigger pull. This way if she did have to draw down on someone/thing she might be less apt to put a round in the ground or worse, shoot someone/something that she didn't have to (including herself on the draw) becuase of a very light trigger pull.  She now has a double action only revolver in .357 for the same reasons.  My Sig has a VERY light single action trigger and short reset. 

I went to Glocks a while back and haven't looked back.

yeah...maybe if i ever make it to magnum i can try it out...

Nah don't spend your hard earned cash to do something you should be able to do anyways,  Go to the January HDF shoot. I'll bring mine and show you what I am talking about....

im pretty sure i know what your talking about...practice practice practice...i was thinking of getting a glock too...something my "old lady" can use...probably a 9mm...when in january is the HDF shoot?

January 21
What kind of pistol you got?
What do you want to shoot?
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: TeamSDSHawaii on January 04, 2012, 11:18:34 PM
Just an fyi... took my new Glock 17 Gen 4 out a couple weeks back... (9mm)

NO Jamming problems at all!!! Glock seems to have that problem resolved on the gen 4.....

My first Glock... need to get used to the "trigger safety" ... I was pulling harder than I should have and was shooting to the right...

Other than that I love that fricken gun!!!

The Mags are a PIA to load though... you need the helper to load the last half of the rounds... spring is way stiff!

Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: kala201 on January 04, 2012, 11:24:35 PM
We may have to go back and try out a Sig again.  By most likely going to get a S&W M&P. She said that that one felt the most comfortable and she liked the smoothness of the slide when she went  to rack it.

If Hawaii ever loosens up its stranglehold on my choice of carry would be a full size, especially after reading that artiicle.  A Beretta 92 would be my first choice.!
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: vooduchikn on January 04, 2012, 11:27:51 PM
Just an fyi... took my new Glock 17 Gen 4 out a couple weeks back... (9mm)

NO Jamming problems at all!!! Glock seems to have that problem resolved on the gen 4.....

My first Glock... need to get used to the "trigger safety" ... I was pulling harder than I should have and was shooting to the right...

Other than that I love that fricken gun!!!

The Mags are a PIA to load though... you need the helper to load the last half of the rounds... spring is way stiff!

Hmmmm. I put over 10k through one my GEN 3s, never a jam and only two cleanings. Not sure Glock ever had a problem with jams.

Regarding the shooting right thing, are you a lefty?

Stiff spring is great! No last round fail to feed......
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: crazyazzmofo on January 05, 2012, 12:00:47 AM
The standard Sig is a single/double action trigger. Because it is a double action you have a lot of take up before you get to the single action trigger. The advantage to this system is you can use the decocker and lower the hammer on a loaded chamber. So your first shot will be double action and every shot thereafter is single action with a long take up. It takes some getting used to, but is quite safe to carry with a loaded chamber. Plus that single action trigger is so sweet right out of the box.
the double single is nice to have for a carry gun. The double is great for folks who are jumpy on the draw and may nd before they get on target. The reset on the sig single is short and very nice. I would practice drawing double action/decocked, pulling through the first shot and then moving to follow up shots. Cocking the hammer back is pointless imho.

i'll try it out  :shaka:

Oh yeah, probably don't need to say this, but...dry fire practicing this won't work, you need to first round to fire/cycle the slide so that the firearm is single action, your trigger will be all double action unless you actually fire a round.  When/if I carry my sig, it is round in the chamber, hammer decocked (double action trigger). This is the way the SIG is designed to be carried. It isn't designed to be carried singe action (hammer back) like a 1911. 

I started my wife off on the SIG because it had a long "first" trigger pull. This way if she did have to draw down on someone/thing she might be less apt to put a round in the ground or worse, shoot someone/something that she didn't have to (including herself on the draw) becuase of a very light trigger pull.  She now has a double action only revolver in .357 for the same reasons.  My Sig has a VERY light single action trigger and short reset. 

I went to Glocks a while back and haven't looked back.

yeah...maybe if i ever make it to magnum i can try it out...

Nah don't spend your hard earned cash to do something you should be able to do anyways,  Go to the January HDF shoot. I'll bring mine and show you what I am talking about....

im pretty sure i know what your talking about...practice practice practice...i was thinking of getting a glock too...something my "old lady" can use...probably a 9mm...when in january is the HDF shoot?

January 21
What kind of pistol you got?
What do you want to shoot?

I got a sig p229 .40...wanted to try (actually get my girl to try) out some 9mm glocks...s&w m&p 9mm...s&w bodyguard .380...
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 05, 2012, 06:57:15 AM
The standard Sig is a single/double action trigger. Because it is a double action you have a lot of take up before you get to the single action trigger. The advantage to this system is you can use the decocker and lower the hammer on a loaded chamber. So your first shot will be double action and every shot thereafter is single action with a long take up. It takes some getting used to, but is quite safe to carry with a loaded chamber. Plus that single action trigger is so sweet right out of the box.
the double single is nice to have for a carry gun. The double is great for folks who are jumpy on the draw and may nd before they get on target. The reset on the sig single is short and very nice. I would practice drawing double action/decocked, pulling through the first shot and then moving to follow up shots. Cocking the hammer back is pointless imho.

i'll try it out  :shaka:

Oh yeah, probably don't need to say this, but...dry fire practicing this won't work, you need to first round to fire/cycle the slide so that the firearm is single action, your trigger will be all double action unless you actually fire a round.  When/if I carry my sig, it is round in the chamber, hammer decocked (double action trigger). This is the way the SIG is designed to be carried. It isn't designed to be carried singe action (hammer back) like a 1911. 

I started my wife off on the SIG because it had a long "first" trigger pull. This way if she did have to draw down on someone/thing she might be less apt to put a round in the ground or worse, shoot someone/something that she didn't have to (including herself on the draw) becuase of a very light trigger pull.  She now has a double action only revolver in .357 for the same reasons.  My Sig has a VERY light single action trigger and short reset. 

I went to Glocks a while back and haven't looked back.

yeah...maybe if i ever make it to magnum i can try it out...

Nah don't spend your hard earned cash to do something you should be able to do anyways,  Go to the January HDF shoot. I'll bring mine and show you what I am talking about....

im pretty sure i know what your talking about...practice practice practice...i was thinking of getting a glock too...something my "old lady" can use...probably a 9mm...when in january is the HDF shoot?

January 21
What kind of pistol you got?
What do you want to shoot?

I got a sig p229 .40...wanted to try (actually get my girl to try) out some 9mm glocks...s&w m&p 9mm...s&w bodyguard .380...

I have a couple 9mm's and 380's that I can bring to the HDF shoot.
She can shoot any of those, I'll have 9mm ammo but bring any .380 ammo that you want to shoot. I don't have any 380 ammo right now.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Pit808 on January 05, 2012, 07:01:48 AM
Ill bring my m&p9, cz82, and s&w k frame 38 to the shoot. U guys are welcome to shoot em.  :shaka:

Oh, and my sub 2k  ;)
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: crazyazzmofo on January 05, 2012, 07:48:13 AM
The standard Sig is a single/double action trigger. Because it is a double action you have a lot of take up before you get to the single action trigger. The advantage to this system is you can use the decocker and lower the hammer on a loaded chamber. So your first shot will be double action and every shot thereafter is single action with a long take up. It takes some getting used to, but is quite safe to carry with a loaded chamber. Plus that single action trigger is so sweet right out of the box.
the double single is nice to have for a carry gun. The double is great for folks who are jumpy on the draw and may nd before they get on target. The reset on the sig single is short and very nice. I would practice drawing double action/decocked, pulling through the first shot and then moving to follow up shots. Cocking the hammer back is pointless imho.

i'll try it out  :shaka:

Oh yeah, probably don't need to say this, but...dry fire practicing this won't work, you need to first round to fire/cycle the slide so that the firearm is single action, your trigger will be all double action unless you actually fire a round.  When/if I carry my sig, it is round in the chamber, hammer decocked (double action trigger). This is the way the SIG is designed to be carried. It isn't designed to be carried singe action (hammer back) like a 1911. 

I started my wife off on the SIG because it had a long "first" trigger pull. This way if she did have to draw down on someone/thing she might be less apt to put a round in the ground or worse, shoot someone/something that she didn't have to (including herself on the draw) becuase of a very light trigger pull.  She now has a double action only revolver in .357 for the same reasons.  My Sig has a VERY light single action trigger and short reset. 

I went to Glocks a while back and haven't looked back.

yeah...maybe if i ever make it to magnum i can try it out...

Nah don't spend your hard earned cash to do something you should be able to do anyways,  Go to the January HDF shoot. I'll bring mine and show you what I am talking about....

im pretty sure i know what your talking about...practice practice practice...i was thinking of getting a glock too...something my "old lady" can use...probably a 9mm...when in january is the HDF shoot?

January 21
What kind of pistol you got?
What do you want to shoot?

I got a sig p229 .40...wanted to try (actually get my girl to try) out some 9mm glocks...s&w m&p 9mm...s&w bodyguard .380...

I have a couple 9mm's and 380's that I can bring to the HDF shoot.
She can shoot any of those, I'll have 9mm ammo but bring any .380 ammo that you want to shoot. I don't have any 380 ammo right now.

Ill bring my m&p9, cz82, and s&w k frame 38 to the shoot. U guys are welcome to shoot em.  :shaka:

Oh, and my sub 2k  ;)

Thanks KK and Pit!!! Now the biggest problem of all...getting the woman to come with so she can try em out! LOL!!  :shake:
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 05, 2012, 08:00:54 AM
The standard Sig is a single/double action trigger. Because it is a double action you have a lot of take up before you get to the single action trigger. The advantage to this system is you can use the decocker and lower the hammer on a loaded chamber. So your first shot will be double action and every shot thereafter is single action with a long take up. It takes some getting used to, but is quite safe to carry with a loaded chamber. Plus that single action trigger is so sweet right out of the box.
the double single is nice to have for a carry gun. The double is great for folks who are jumpy on the draw and may nd before they get on target. The reset on the sig single is short and very nice. I would practice drawing double action/decocked, pulling through the first shot and then moving to follow up shots. Cocking the hammer back is pointless imho.

i'll try it out  :shaka:

Oh yeah, probably don't need to say this, but...dry fire practicing this won't work, you need to first round to fire/cycle the slide so that the firearm is single action, your trigger will be all double action unless you actually fire a round.  When/if I carry my sig, it is round in the chamber, hammer decocked (double action trigger). This is the way the SIG is designed to be carried. It isn't designed to be carried singe action (hammer back) like a 1911. 

I started my wife off on the SIG because it had a long "first" trigger pull. This way if she did have to draw down on someone/thing she might be less apt to put a round in the ground or worse, shoot someone/something that she didn't have to (including herself on the draw) becuase of a very light trigger pull.  She now has a double action only revolver in .357 for the same reasons.  My Sig has a VERY light single action trigger and short reset. 

I went to Glocks a while back and haven't looked back.

yeah...maybe if i ever make it to magnum i can try it out...

Nah don't spend your hard earned cash to do something you should be able to do anyways,  Go to the January HDF shoot. I'll bring mine and show you what I am talking about....

im pretty sure i know what your talking about...practice practice practice...i was thinking of getting a glock too...something my "old lady" can use...probably a 9mm...when in january is the HDF shoot?

January 21
What kind of pistol you got?
What do you want to shoot?

I got a sig p229 .40...wanted to try (actually get my girl to try) out some 9mm glocks...s&w m&p 9mm...s&w bodyguard .380...

I have a couple 9mm's and 380's that I can bring to the HDF shoot.
She can shoot any of those, I'll have 9mm ammo but bring any .380 ammo that you want to shoot. I don't have any 380 ammo right now.

Ill bring my m&p9, cz82, and s&w k frame 38 to the shoot. U guys are welcome to shoot em.  :shaka:

Oh, and my sub 2k  ;)

Thanks KK and Pit!!! Now the biggest problem of all...getting the woman to come with so she can try em out! LOL!!  :shake:

You're on your own with that one.   :rofl:
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: GZire on January 05, 2012, 09:42:57 AM
The standard Sig is a single/double action trigger. Because it is a double action you have a lot of take up before you get to the single action trigger. The advantage to this system is you can use the decocker and lower the hammer on a loaded chamber. So your first shot will be double action and every shot thereafter is single action with a long take up. It takes some getting used to, but is quite safe to carry with a loaded chamber. Plus that single action trigger is so sweet right out of the box.
the double single is nice to have for a carry gun. The double is great for folks who are jumpy on the draw and may nd before they get on target. The reset on the sig single is short and very nice. I would practice drawing double action/decocked, pulling through the first shot and then moving to follow up shots. Cocking the hammer back is pointless imho.

i'll try it out  :shaka:

Oh yeah, probably don't need to say this, but...dry fire practicing this won't work, you need to first round to fire/cycle the slide so that the firearm is single action, your trigger will be all double action unless you actually fire a round.  When/if I carry my sig, it is round in the chamber, hammer decocked (double action trigger). This is the way the SIG is designed to be carried. It isn't designed to be carried singe action (hammer back) like a 1911. 

I started my wife off on the SIG because it had a long "first" trigger pull. This way if she did have to draw down on someone/thing she might be less apt to put a round in the ground or worse, shoot someone/something that she didn't have to (including herself on the draw) becuase of a very light trigger pull.  She now has a double action only revolver in .357 for the same reasons.  My Sig has a VERY light single action trigger and short reset. 

I went to Glocks a while back and haven't looked back.

yeah...maybe if i ever make it to magnum i can try it out...

Nah don't spend your hard earned cash to do something you should be able to do anyways,  Go to the January HDF shoot. I'll bring mine and show you what I am talking about....

im pretty sure i know what your talking about...practice practice practice...i was thinking of getting a glock too...something my "old lady" can use...probably a 9mm...when in january is the HDF shoot?

January 21
What kind of pistol you got?
What do you want to shoot?

I got a sig p229 .40...wanted to try (actually get my girl to try) out some 9mm glocks...s&w m&p 9mm...s&w bodyguard .380...

I have a couple 9mm's and 380's that I can bring to the HDF shoot.
She can shoot any of those, I'll have 9mm ammo but bring any .380 ammo that you want to shoot. I don't have any 380 ammo right now.


Anyone wanna do a meet and greet this Saturday at Kokohead?  I put a new short trigger in my 220 and I need to try it out.  Can bring the other hardware too.  If not, then I'm doing SRGC on Sunday.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 05, 2012, 11:34:28 AM
The standard Sig is a single/double action trigger. Because it is a double action you have a lot of take up before you get to the single action trigger. The advantage to this system is you can use the decocker and lower the hammer on a loaded chamber. So your first shot will be double action and every shot thereafter is single action with a long take up. It takes some getting used to, but is quite safe to carry with a loaded chamber. Plus that single action trigger is so sweet right out of the box.
the double single is nice to have for a carry gun. The double is great for folks who are jumpy on the draw and may nd before they get on target. The reset on the sig single is short and very nice. I would practice drawing double action/decocked, pulling through the first shot and then moving to follow up shots. Cocking the hammer back is pointless imho.

i'll try it out  :shaka:

Oh yeah, probably don't need to say this, but...dry fire practicing this won't work, you need to first round to fire/cycle the slide so that the firearm is single action, your trigger will be all double action unless you actually fire a round.  When/if I carry my sig, it is round in the chamber, hammer decocked (double action trigger). This is the way the SIG is designed to be carried. It isn't designed to be carried singe action (hammer back) like a 1911. 

I started my wife off on the SIG because it had a long "first" trigger pull. This way if she did have to draw down on someone/thing she might be less apt to put a round in the ground or worse, shoot someone/something that she didn't have to (including herself on the draw) becuase of a very light trigger pull.  She now has a double action only revolver in .357 for the same reasons.  My Sig has a VERY light single action trigger and short reset. 

I went to Glocks a while back and haven't looked back.

yeah...maybe if i ever make it to magnum i can try it out...

Nah don't spend your hard earned cash to do something you should be able to do anyways,  Go to the January HDF shoot. I'll bring mine and show you what I am talking about....

im pretty sure i know what your talking about...practice practice practice...i was thinking of getting a glock too...something my "old lady" can use...probably a 9mm...when in january is the HDF shoot?

January 21
What kind of pistol you got?
What do you want to shoot?

I got a sig p229 .40...wanted to try (actually get my girl to try) out some 9mm glocks...s&w m&p 9mm...s&w bodyguard .380...

I have a couple 9mm's and 380's that I can bring to the HDF shoot.
She can shoot any of those, I'll have 9mm ammo but bring any .380 ammo that you want to shoot. I don't have any 380 ammo right now.


Anyone wanna do a meet and greet this Saturday at Kokohead?  I put a new short trigger in my 220 and I need to try it out.  Can bring the other hardware too.  If not, then I'm doing SRGC on Sunday.

I'm going to be at Kokohead on Saturday.

What's SRGC?
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: GZire on January 05, 2012, 01:27:27 PM
The standard Sig is a single/double action trigger. Because it is a double action you have a lot of take up before you get to the single action trigger. The advantage to this system is you can use the decocker and lower the hammer on a loaded chamber. So your first shot will be double action and every shot thereafter is single action with a long take up. It takes some getting used to, but is quite safe to carry with a loaded chamber. Plus that single action trigger is so sweet right out of the box.
the double single is nice to have for a carry gun. The double is great for folks who are jumpy on the draw and may nd before they get on target. The reset on the sig single is short and very nice. I would practice drawing double action/decocked, pulling through the first shot and then moving to follow up shots. Cocking the hammer back is pointless imho.

i'll try it out  :shaka:

Oh yeah, probably don't need to say this, but...dry fire practicing this won't work, you need to first round to fire/cycle the slide so that the firearm is single action, your trigger will be all double action unless you actually fire a round.  When/if I carry my sig, it is round in the chamber, hammer decocked (double action trigger). This is the way the SIG is designed to be carried. It isn't designed to be carried singe action (hammer back) like a 1911. 

I started my wife off on the SIG because it had a long "first" trigger pull. This way if she did have to draw down on someone/thing she might be less apt to put a round in the ground or worse, shoot someone/something that she didn't have to (including herself on the draw) becuase of a very light trigger pull.  She now has a double action only revolver in .357 for the same reasons.  My Sig has a VERY light single action trigger and short reset. 

I went to Glocks a while back and haven't looked back.

yeah...maybe if i ever make it to magnum i can try it out...

Nah don't spend your hard earned cash to do something you should be able to do anyways,  Go to the January HDF shoot. I'll bring mine and show you what I am talking about....

im pretty sure i know what your talking about...practice practice practice...i was thinking of getting a glock too...something my "old lady" can use...probably a 9mm...when in january is the HDF shoot?

January 21
What kind of pistol you got?
What do you want to shoot?

I got a sig p229 .40...wanted to try (actually get my girl to try) out some 9mm glocks...s&w m&p 9mm...s&w bodyguard .380...

I have a couple 9mm's and 380's that I can bring to the HDF shoot.
She can shoot any of those, I'll have 9mm ammo but bring any .380 ammo that you want to shoot. I don't have any 380 ammo right now.


Anyone wanna do a meet and greet this Saturday at Kokohead?  I put a new short trigger in my 220 and I need to try it out.  Can bring the other hardware too.  If not, then I'm doing SRGC on Sunday.

I'm going to be at Kokohead on Saturday.

What's SRGC?


SRGC  =  Schofield Rod & Gun Club

SRGC will be shooting up at CR-2 on Schofield this Sunday. 
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: bass monkey on January 05, 2012, 06:05:18 PM
Im down for a meet and great on saturday.  What time?
I can bring my XD9 and 45 if you want
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 05, 2012, 06:46:14 PM
Im down for a meet and great on saturday.  What time?
I can bring my XD9 and 45 if you want

OK, GZire & bass monkey.

It seems there are enough to play shootemup at the range. What time you guys want to meet and What do you guys want to bring?

I'm down for pistols, rifles, shotguns, plinking, spit balls, rock throwing, etc...
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Inspector on January 05, 2012, 07:34:36 PM
Got room for an old guy with a Glock and Sig? Also, I have a newly modified 22 plinking rifle I have not tried out yet.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 05, 2012, 09:20:02 PM
Got room for an old guy with a Glock and Sig? Also, I have a newly modified 22 plinking rifle I have not tried out yet.

Of course.

I guess we'll be plinking?

I'll bring my Glock17C and CZ75 (9mm's)

Who's in?
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: bass monkey on January 05, 2012, 09:27:53 PM
What time we looking at? I'm thinking around 12. Kinda late I know sorry
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: crazyazzmofo on January 05, 2012, 10:02:26 PM
DANG!!! i cant make it this weekend!! AHHHHHHHH!!!  >:( im definitely gonna try make it on the 21st tho...
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 05, 2012, 10:46:44 PM
What time we looking at? I'm thinking around 12. Kinda late I know sorry

12 works for me.

High noon. (Silhouette range?)

It gives me time to go early and shoot other disciplines.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 05, 2012, 10:47:49 PM
im definitely gonna try

Is this the definition of an oxymoron?
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: crazyazzmofo on January 05, 2012, 11:29:22 PM
im definitely gonna try

Is this the definition of an oxymoron?

Lol...like I said earlier I definitely will...the try part is bringing the woman with! Lol...any help is appreciated! LOL!!!
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Pit808 on January 06, 2012, 12:21:11 AM
Got room for an old guy with a Glock and Sig? Also, I have a newly modified 22 plinking rifle I have not tried out yet.

Of course.

I guess we'll be plinking?

I'll bring my Glock17C and CZ75 (9mm's)

Who's in?

Hey KK,
Any chance you could bring that cz 75 on the 21st? I've been wanting to check one out. 
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: kala201 on January 06, 2012, 02:48:20 AM
Damn can't make it.  My other half has been bugging me to go shoot too.

Crazy- maybe we can do a thing where everyone can bring their SO? I know my girlfriend would love that, then she wouldn't be the only girl and neither would your wife.  I don't know how many others would be down for something like that.  I had a death in my family so this month is shot for me.

Gzire- if you don't mind me asking how did you qualify to join the SRGC? Right now I'm waiting for my new contractor's badge.  Its supposed to be an upgraded one which they say should almost bring us up to civilian DOD status.  I hope I can get in.
Title: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: sirkaiks on January 06, 2012, 06:46:59 AM
What time we looking at? I'm thinking around 12. Kinda late I know sorry

12 works for me.

High noon. (Silhouette range?)

It gives me time to go early and shoot other disciplines.
what time to you guys get there? last week i went at 830 and was 3rd on the waiting list...
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 06, 2012, 07:12:04 AM
Got room for an old guy with a Glock and Sig? Also, I have a newly modified 22 plinking rifle I have not tried out yet.

Of course.

I guess we'll be plinking?

I'll bring my Glock17C and CZ75 (9mm's)

Who's in?

Hey KK,
Any chance you could bring that cz 75 on the 21st? I've been wanting to check one out.

No problem  :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 06, 2012, 07:14:13 AM
What time we looking at? I'm thinking around 12. Kinda late I know sorry

12 works for me.

High noon. (Silhouette range?)

It gives me time to go early and shoot other disciplines.
what time to you guys get there? last week i went at 830 and was 3rd on the waiting list...

If I shoot rifles, I'm there by 7:30am.
Everything else, 8:00am.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: GZire on January 06, 2012, 09:01:25 AM
I was thinking about doing the handguns for those who want exposure to different platforms.  If no Kala/crazyazzmofo, then no go for me as I'll be shooting the next day anyway.

I'm off to the mainland the week of the 16th, so it's a no go for the next week/two


Maybe for the newer guys/others if you want to do a meet on Saturday, Jan 28th?  Should give plenty of time to get the significant others on board and plan for it.  These are the handguns that I've got and you folks can shoot (BTW I was thinking on the metallic side);

(45 acp)   H&K USP Match
(45 acp)   Sig P220 Elite
(45 colt)   Uberti 1860 SAA w/conversion to metallic cartrdige
(38 spl/357 mag)   S&W 686 6"
(45 colt/454 casull/460 SW mag)   S&W 460 5"

Sorry, but the 1911 is in the mainland getting worked on and I don't think it'll be back in time for an end of the month shoot.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: kala201 on January 06, 2012, 11:11:30 AM
Jan 28 should be open for me, but if we wait until February I should have a handgun by then.  The only bad day for me in February is the 11th.  If we go to the silhouette side I'll bring my still virgin M&P 15-22 .  Bought in October cleaned it put it away and haven't had a chance to shoot it yet.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Inspector on January 06, 2012, 12:20:53 PM
So are we meeting at 12 noon at the Silhouette range? Just making sure I am on the same page.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 06, 2012, 12:23:11 PM
I'll be there at 12.

Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 06, 2012, 12:25:02 PM
Crazy, GZ, you guys going?
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: GZire on January 06, 2012, 12:59:58 PM
Sorry KK I'm out for this weekend. 
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Jkeone808 on January 06, 2012, 02:46:39 PM
I'll be there at 12.

I can only stay for an hour maybe butI'll be there around 12 at the plinking side I'll see you there.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: crazyazzmofo on January 06, 2012, 04:01:03 PM
sorry...cant make it this weekend... :( try for the 21st for the HDF and 28th might be better...gives me more time to plan out and get stuff done...  :shaka:

thanks everyone for trying to accommodate...i really want the girl to find herself a comfortable firearm that she can just practice with so shes ready for any situation...THANKS EVERYONE!!!  :shaka:
Title: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: sirkaiks on January 06, 2012, 05:27:17 PM
ahhh i gotta work tomorrow.. guess I'm gonna shoot on sunday. i cant wait for the 21st though!!!
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: kala201 on January 23, 2012, 08:35:09 AM
Ok so we, actually more I with the SO other's blessings, have finally settled on the S&W M&P 9mm.  It was comfortable in her hand and the slide was easy for her to rack.  Going down to OGC to do the paper work now and then off to HPD to file for the permit.  The one we wanted was the Springfield EMP, but that was way out of my budget.  Anyone on the forum have one?  How do you like it?
Title: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: sirkaiks on January 23, 2012, 05:23:36 PM
i've shot my friends one, it's pretty comfortable... last saturday ogc was selling them for 459. one of those one day deal things. if i had extra cash at that time, i would of bought one.
Title: Re: Handgun Recommendations
Post by: Kingkeoni on January 23, 2012, 05:28:20 PM
i've shot my friends one, it's pretty comfortable... last saturday ogc was selling them for 459. one of those one day deal things. if i had extra cash at that time, i would of bought one.
^
The M&P of course.


As for the EMP, it is a real nice gun.

A little too small for my liking (grip size) but it feels solid and shot well for me.

I also have a M&P and really like it a lot.
I've never had any problems with mine and it is very accurate.

You won't be disappointed with it.