2aHawaii

General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: punaperson on January 27, 2017, 06:31:39 AM

Title: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on January 27, 2017, 06:31:39 AM
Must have proof of hunting license. Well, it's a start. At least it broaches the subject, though as written wouldn't allow even a hunter to use the suppressor at a range to dial in their rifle with the suppressor on it. People might want to call the sponsors and thank them and ask for modifications to allow range use.

http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=1589&year=2017
(includes link to full text of bill)

HB1589     

Measure Title:   RELATING TO HUNTING SAFETY.
Report Title:    Firearms; Noise Suppressors; Hunting
Description:    Authorizes licensed hunters who comply with state firearms law to possess and use firearm noise suppressors while hunting. Authorizes the manufacture and sale of firearm noise suppressors for licensed hunters who comply with state firearms law.

Introducer(s):   YAMANE, CREAGAN, DECOITE, HAR, ITO, KONG, MCKELVEY, OSHIRO, SAY, TOKIOKA

Sort by Date       Status Text
1/25/2017   H   Introduced and Pass First Reading.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: macsak on January 27, 2017, 07:23:25 AM
Must have proof of hunting license. Well, it's a start. At least it broaches the subject, though as written wouldn't allow even a hunter to use the suppressor at a range to dial in their rifle with the suppressor on it. People might want to call the sponsors and thank them and ask for modifications to allow range use.

http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=1589&year=2017
(includes link to full text of bill)

HB1589     

Measure Title:   RELATING TO HUNTING SAFETY.
Report Title:    Firearms; Noise Suppressors; Hunting
Description:    Authorizes licensed hunters who comply with state firearms law to possess and use firearm noise suppressors while hunting. Authorizes the manufacture and sale of firearm noise suppressors for licensed hunters who comply with state firearms law.

Introducer(s):   YAMANE, CREAGAN, DECOITE, HAR, ITO, KONG, MCKELVEY, OSHIRO, SAY, TOKIOKA

Sort by Date       Status Text
1/25/2017   H   Introduced and Pass First Reading.

note the people who introduced this bill, they are the "gun-friendly" portion of the legislature- please be sure to thank them and support them
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: zippz on January 27, 2017, 09:21:42 AM
This is the smart way to do it, there is no way the legislature would pass a general law allowing suppressors.  Most people think suppressors are only used by assassins and terrorists.  This law gets the foot in the door for hunters so legislators can see it's not a bad thing to have.  Then a few years down the road they could amend the law to allow anyone to have and use a suppressor.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 27, 2017, 10:11:22 AM
This is the smart way to do it, there is no way the legislature would pass a general law allowing suppressors.  Most people think suppressors are only used by assassins and terrorists.  This law gets the foot in the door for hunters so legislators can see it's not a bad thing to have.  Then a few years down the road they could amend the law to allow anyone to have and use a suppressor.

Like Zippz said,

1) Allow hunting but no use on range
2) Allow usage at range (to zero rifle with suppressor)
3) Allow non hunters to acquire
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on January 27, 2017, 11:09:31 AM
Like Zippz said,

1) Allow hunting but no use on range
2) Allow usage at range (to zero rifle with suppressor)
3) Allow non hunters to acquire

This would decriminalize ownership/possession of suppressors in general.  Having a treaded barrel on a handgun that's coincidentally a similar caliber to your hunting firearm would presumably be legal.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 27, 2017, 11:49:31 AM
This would decriminalize ownership/possession of suppressors in general.  Having a treaded barrel on a handgun that's coincidentally a similar caliber to your hunting firearm would presumably be legal.

We need to use padding when wording stuff so anti 2a reps don't vote against it.  So if we tell them the rifle shoots different when having a suppressor and we need range time to practice...
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 31, 2017, 02:38:29 PM
Trying to submit testimony but it won't let me, saying I have to allow cookies. This is using Safari so I tried Opera but still giving me the same message. Checked both cookies settings and neither seem to set to deny cookies. Anyone else having a problem?
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on January 31, 2017, 05:08:37 PM
Trying to submit testimony but it won't let me, saying I have to allow cookies. This is using Safari so I tried Opera but still giving me the same message. Checked both cookies settings and neither seem to set to deny cookies. Anyone else having a problem?
I submitted three separate testimonies earlier in the day using Firefox/Windows. The site signs me out automatically in a relatively short period of time though, so I have to sign in again by the time I get the next piece of testimony written and ready for submission. They don't want to make it too easy for us to express our bothersome views to them you know. And what's with the 72 hour notice of committee hearing, and thus 48 hour notice to submit testimony that will definitely make the 24 hour prior to  hearing cutoff? Seems like they should have to give at least a weeks notice.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: omnigun on February 01, 2017, 06:31:17 AM
Good bill but its kinda important to be able to test at the range.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: Jl808 on February 07, 2017, 08:37:00 PM
Bill scheduled to be heard by WAL on Friday, 02-10-17 9:00AM in House conference room 325.   
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: macsak on February 07, 2017, 10:13:31 PM
Bill scheduled to be heard by WAL on Friday, 02-10-17 9:00AM in House conference room 325.

k guys this is it- SUBMIT TESTIMONY NOW!!!:
2/7/2017: Bill scheduled to be heard by WAL on Friday, 02-10-17 9:00AM in House conference room 325.
http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=1589&year=2017
HB1589 Firearms; Noise Suppressors; Hunting
RELATING TO HUNTING SAFETY.
Authorizes licensed hunters who comply with state firearms law to possess and use firearm noise suppressors while hunting. Authorizes the manufacture and sale of firearm noise suppressors for licensed hunters who comply with state firearms law.
Hunting; Supressors; Support
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on February 08, 2017, 06:45:21 AM
k guys this is it- SUBMIT TESTIMONY NOW!!!:
2/7/2017: Bill scheduled to be heard by WAL on Friday, 02-10-17 9:00AM in House conference room 325.
http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=1589&year=2017
HB1589 Firearms; Noise Suppressors; Hunting
RELATING TO HUNTING SAFETY.
Authorizes licensed hunters who comply with state firearms law to possess and use firearm noise suppressors while hunting. Authorizes the manufacture and sale of firearm noise suppressors for licensed hunters who comply with state firearms law.
Hunting; Supressors; Support
The Chair and Vice Chair of this committee are co-sponsors of the bill, so I'm believing they will "guide" this bill through the committee hearing with some care and concern.  ;) (It will have to also be heard in the Judiciary committee, and there are some real, uh, "likely opponents" on that committee...). Still, the more testimony the better. At least ten (10) right? In a state with 1.4 million people...
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: sgtlmj on February 08, 2017, 08:33:35 AM
News of this hit the local paper: 
http://thegardenisland.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/bill-aims-to-legalize-firearm-noise-suppressors/article_7b7cb904-2cfb-500e-b162-b7af795fc47d.html (http://thegardenisland.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/bill-aims-to-legalize-firearm-noise-suppressors/article_7b7cb904-2cfb-500e-b162-b7af795fc47d.html)

-I also contacted the ASA (http://americansuppressorassociation.com (http://americansuppressorassociation.com)) in hopes that they can do a news blast about it. 

-Testimony submitted.

-Email sent to all of the sponsors addressing the target shooting omission.

reptokioka@capitol.hawaii.gov, repyamane@Capitol.hawaii.gov, repcreagan@Capitol.hawaii.gov, repdecoite@Capitol.hawaii.gov, rephar@Capitol.hawaii.gov, repito@Capitol.hawaii.gov, repkong@Capitol.hawaii.gov, repmckelvey@Capitol.hawaii.gov, repmoshiro@Capitol.hawaii.gov, repsay@Capitol.hawaii.gov
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: drck1000 on February 08, 2017, 05:38:12 PM
Just for a few emails. One from HRA and others from HRA members notifying of hearing this Friday for HB1589.

If so, believe the website should be open for testimony.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: London808 on February 08, 2017, 06:12:40 PM
Please copy and paste to your social media feeds,

On Friday, February 10, the House Water and Land Committee will hear House Bill 1589, sponsored by Representative Ryan Yamane (D-37).  This legislation would allow the use of sound suppressors while hunting in the state of Hawaii.

Currently, 40 states allow the use of suppressors while hunting.  Sound suppressors attached to firearms (less accurately called "silencers") are an additional tool available to help protect hearing, increase accuracy and safety, and reduce noise complaints by surrounding residents.  While suppressors do not eliminate the sound of a firearm, they do reduce the muzzle report of a firearm, reducing the risk hearing damage.  Additionally, suppressors help increase accuracy by reducing felt recoil and shot “flinch.”  Suppressors also help reduce noise complaints from neighbors, which are frequently used as an excuse to close hunting lands throughout the country.

please submit testimony to the committee through the Hawaii Legislature website.  In order to submit testimony, you will need to create an account. 

http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=1589&year=2017

IF YOU WANT TO USE A SUPPRESSOR IN HAWAII YOU MUST SUBMIT TESTIMONY, MAKE AN ACCOUNT AND SUBMIT IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL.

SHARE THIS POST FOR MORE SUPPORT.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: zippz on February 08, 2017, 11:07:10 PM
I'm new to hunting and suppressors.  Do you need to use subsonic ammunition with rifle suppressors or will suppressors still lower the sound sufficiently with standard ammo to prevent hearing damage?
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on February 08, 2017, 11:15:18 PM
I'm new to hunting and suppressors.  Do you need to use subsonic ammunition with rifle suppressors or will suppressors still lower the sound sufficiently with standard ammo to prevent hearing damage?

Lots of variables to consider before answering that.

Here's a good article on all things suppressor :)

Scroll down to the "Ammunition" section.

http://www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2016/04/04/beginners-guide-suppressors-part-3/
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on February 08, 2017, 11:24:20 PM
https://youtu.be/P-HNB80YI3g
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on February 08, 2017, 11:30:08 PM
https://youtu.be/DtenI4zMwWM
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on February 08, 2017, 11:31:11 PM
https://youtu.be/Q5ALp8-d3dQ
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: zippz on February 08, 2017, 11:59:07 PM
Thanks, I'll look into the article Flapp.  I was thinking hunting rounds like 308.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: zippz on February 09, 2017, 12:01:47 AM
What organizations can we seek help from to submit testimony?  The NRA already submits testimony for all the bills.  I sent a message to the National Shooting Sports Foundation (NSSF) who supports firearms retailers and ranges to see if they can help us out on this one.  I wrote to US Concealed Carry Association (USCCA) for the CCW bills.   I also wrote to the SAF.

Know of any audiologist group that could testify?
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: sgtlmj on February 09, 2017, 08:07:29 AM
What organizations can we seek help from to submit testimony?  The NRA already submits testimony for all the bills.  I sent a message to the National Shooting Sports Foundation (NSSF) who supports firearms retailers and ranges to see if they can help us out on this one.  I wrote to US Concealed Carry Association (USCCA) for the CCW bills.   I also wrote to the SAF.

Know of any audiologist group that could testify?

American Suppressor Association, as I mentioned earlier.  I contacted them, but some more paying members from Hawaii would help convince them to spend some effort here.  It's only $25/year for a membership.  They are largely responsible for pushing the HPA that was introduced the first days of the new Congressional session. 

Also to answer your earlier question, a suppressed .308Win firing full power loads is still loud, but in a hunting scenario it's easy to forgo ear pro for a few shots.  Suppressors also reduce the recoil of the firearm, and in many cases improve accuracy due to the more efficient channeling of the gasses.  Best part about having suppressors here, is that it's a tight space with lots of mountains and valleys for the report of a firearm to bounce off of.  Suppression largely reduces the oomph of the sound to travel very far.  Being on the other end of a suppressed firearm, it's hard to hear which direction the shot came from. 

I will push hard for this legislation.  I have a half-dozen cans back on the mainland just sitting in a safety deposit box because I couldn't legally bring them here. 
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: sgtlmj on February 09, 2017, 08:09:57 AM

IF YOU WANT TO USE A SUPPRESSOR IN HAWAII YOU MUST SUBMIT TESTIMONY, MAKE AN ACCOUNT AND SUBMIT IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL.

SHARE THIS POST FOR MORE SUPPORT.

I left testimony yesterday, but none has shown up yet.  I got an email confirmation.  How long does it take to be reviewed and posted?
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: Turbo-Mag on February 09, 2017, 08:14:22 AM
Submitted my testimony
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: zippz on February 09, 2017, 08:21:21 AM
Good news, the NSSF will write testimony for the bill and USCCA will look into helping us with our CCW bills.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: changemyoil66 on February 09, 2017, 08:21:28 AM
I submitted my testimony and so did a friend.  But my friends one was kind of extreme from what he was telling me. 
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: changemyoil66 on February 09, 2017, 08:22:16 AM
Good news, the NSSF will write testimony for the bill and USCCA will look into helping us with our CCW bills.

I was looking at the USCCA firearm liability insurance policy.  The biggest benefit is the NRA one you have to pay 1 time. Where as the USCCA, you can make monthly installments.  But in the end, they're about the same price.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on February 09, 2017, 08:36:45 AM
I left testimony yesterday, but none has shown up yet.  I got an email confirmation.  How long does it take to be reviewed and posted?
The deadline to submit testimony is 24 hours prior to the committee meeting time, and the submitted testimony typically will show up online not too long after that deadline. The "late" testimony will often be posted just prior to the meeting beginning.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on February 09, 2017, 08:51:40 AM
I submitted my testimony and so did a friend.  But my friends one was kind of extreme from what he was telling me.
I'll be looking for the "extreme testimony"...  :shaka:
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on February 09, 2017, 09:54:32 AM
The deadline to submit testimony is 24 hours prior to the committee meeting time, and the submitted testimony typically will show up online not too long after that deadline. The "late" testimony will often be posted just prior to the meeting beginning.
Okay, I need to contradict myself here. Apparently I drew a wrong conclusion based upon afternoon meeting times and testimony being posted in the afternoon. Or maybe not. Let me explain. I called the senates clerk's office, and after being put on hold was told that the testimony is posted just prior to the committee meeting. I said that seemed weird to me since the testimony is due 24 hours prior to the meeting and it would be available for publication at that time. On the other end of the phone: dead silence. Okay. I called the house clerk's office and asked the same question. Hold. Then told "it should be posted 24 hours prior to the hearing". Okay, but it's not. "Let me send your call over to Yamane's... no, Kong's office (she said something that I couldn't make out about "he's responsible for hdufythdcn"). She transferred my call. After about 30 seconds a couple of noises on the line. Then: dead. Disconnect. Dial tone. I give up. I gotta get out to work.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: astroboy on February 09, 2017, 10:30:39 AM
testimony sent to house leadership
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: zippz on February 09, 2017, 10:50:27 AM
For testimonies, from what I see is a worker has to gather the testimonies from the website, in person, email, and phone the scans and posts it.  I imagine that could be hundreds or thousands for testimonies per day so the postings seem to be at random times before the hearing.

Ill usually see the testimony posted, then late testimony posted right before, then they get more printouts at the hearing plus those submitting in person or orally testifying.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on February 09, 2017, 12:21:50 PM
For testimonies, from what I see is a worker has to gather the testimonies from the website, in person, email, and phone the scans and posts it.  I imagine that could be hundreds or thousands for testimonies per day so the postings seem to be at random times before the hearing.

Ill usually see the testimony posted, then late testimony posted right before, then they get more printouts at the hearing plus those submitting in person or orally testifying.
Are you saying that there is one person for the entire Hawaii state legislature responsible for collecting and posting all the testimony for all the bills before all the committees? Would you happen to know how to contact that person? Do you know if there is any requirement that ("on time") testimony be posted within any particular interval prior to the committee hearing on that bill, or any requirement that it be posted at all? Thanks.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: zippz on February 09, 2017, 12:29:06 PM
Ill try and find out more how they do it tomorrow.  I'm assuming its done by a central office and not each reps office.

I went to the hearing on corrections officers CCW and they did not have any testimony posted online, but had it at the hearing.  I don't think they had my testimony I submitted

UPDATE:  They just posted testimonies online for the corrections CCW bill and mine was included.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: mamalukino on February 09, 2017, 12:41:49 PM
Testimony sent.:shaka:
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on February 09, 2017, 12:59:09 PM
Ill try and find out more how they do it tomorrow.  I'm assuming its done by a central office and not each reps office.

I went to the hearing on corrections officers CCW and they did not have any testimony posted online, but had it at the hearing.  I don't think they had my testimony I submitted
I read the testimony online the day before the hearing (including mine), and the late testimony was there just prior to the hearing.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: changemyoil66 on February 09, 2017, 01:11:41 PM
Are you saying that there is one person for the entire Hawaii state legislature responsible for collecting and posting all the testimony for all the bills before all the committees? Would you happen to know how to contact that person? Do you know if there is any requirement that ("on time") testimony be posted within any particular interval prior to the committee hearing on that bill, or any requirement that it be posted at all? Thanks.

Because this is a pro 2A bill, I wouldn't be surprised if its 1 person working on this.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: bass monkey on February 09, 2017, 06:09:49 PM
Please remember that when submitting testimony, select weather you oppose or support the measure.  It automatically defaults to "comments only"


I just submitted my testimony
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: bass monkey on February 09, 2017, 06:41:17 PM
Also just wrote thank you emails to the introducers
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on February 10, 2017, 08:38:07 AM
It's now 8:32 AM, less thirty minutes prior to the committee hearing beginning, and no testimony is posted at the HB1589 website. So I guess if a person wanted to read the testimony opposing the bill in order to submit testimony countering the arguments or evidence presented by the opposition, well, you can't. This system is so corrupt. 72 hour notice of hearings, then 24 hour notice of "on time" testimony due, then no publication of testimony prior to the hearing required. Where does it end? I spoke to a number of legislator staff members yesterday by phone, and they all basically said that it's all about "power", and those in power have no interest in making things any easier for those not in power to gain any leverage. Thus, a bill to require a minimum 5 working day notice of hearings, requirement to publish all thus far received testimony 24 hours prior to the hearing, requiring a hearing on a bill if a certain percentage of members vote to hold a hearing (rather than it being up to one single person, the committee chair), etc. would get nowhere because the committee chairs would not hold a hearing on a bill requiring them to hold hearings on bills!  :crazy:

Update: 9:02 AM "No testimony available at this time."

Update: 9:16 AM "No testimony available at this time."  >:(
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: zippz on February 10, 2017, 10:39:32 AM
At the State Capitol to support HB 1589, legalize suppressor for hunting, with Harvey from HRA, Dan from NRA ILA, and 2a enthusiast Jon.  There were about 200 testimonies in support from organizations, hunting groups and hunters, businesses, and the firearms community.  There were about 5 to 10 opposed mainly from HPD and animal rights groups.

This is the first step.  We need more testimony.  For everyone who submitted testimony, ask a friend to do the same for the next hearing.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: 338KID on February 10, 2017, 11:08:10 AM
Keep up the good work guys . Thanks for all the hard work and time put into this .
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: changemyoil66 on February 10, 2017, 11:33:26 AM
At the State Capitol to support HB 1589, legalize suppressor for hunting, with Harvey from HRA, Dan from NRA ILA, and 2a enthusiast Jon.  There were about 200 testimonies in support from organizations, hunting groups and hunters, businesses, and the firearms community.  There were about 5 to 10 opposed mainly from HPD and animal rights groups.

This is the first step.  We need more testimony.  For everyone who submitted testimony, ask a friend to do the same for the next hearing.

Did the NRA fly in special just for this hearing?
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on February 10, 2017, 12:14:19 PM
At the State Capitol to support HB 1589, legalize suppressor for hunting, with Harvey from HRA, Dan from NRA ILA, and 2a enthusiast Jon.  There were about 200 testimonies in support from organizations, hunting groups and hunters, businesses, and the firearms community.  There were about 5 to 10 opposed mainly from HPD and animal rights groups.

This is the first step.  We need more testimony.  For everyone who submitted testimony, ask a friend to do the same for the next hearing.
And... what did the committee do with the bill? (Still no testimony online at 12:13...)
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: Turbo-Mag on February 10, 2017, 01:51:28 PM
says it passed with amendments ...8 ayes and 1 excused... :thumbsup:

How do you find out what the amendments are?
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: London808 on February 10, 2017, 03:28:51 PM
says it passed with amendments ...8 ayes and 1 excused... :thumbsup:

How do you find out what the amendments are?

I belive it now goes for a full vote, and then if it passes there to the govoner for signing. Being the dick that he is tho, he might veto it tho.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: London808 on February 10, 2017, 03:31:16 PM
Testimony is up

http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/Session2017/Testimony/HB1589_TESTIMONY_WAL_02-10-17_.PDF (http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/Session2017/Testimony/HB1589_TESTIMONY_WAL_02-10-17_.PDF)
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: London808 on February 10, 2017, 03:38:55 PM
Ready for some fiction.

Dear Chair Yamane and Members:
SUBJECT: House Bill No. 1589, Relating to Hunting Safety
I am David Nilsen, Acting Major of the Records and Identification Division of the
Honolulu Police Department (HPD), City and County of Honolulu.
The HPD opposes House Bill No. 1589, Relating to Hunting Safety.
This bill proposes changes to various sections of Chapter 134 of the Hawaii Revised
Statutes to allow the use of noise suppressors or silencers by hunters. This bill also authorizes
the manufacture and sale of noise suppressors or silencers in the state of Hawaii. The HPD
does not agree that the use of firearms in the act of hunting poses a threat to the hearing of the
hunter. The number of rounds fired by a hunter while engaged in the hunt will not be significant
enough to endanger the hunter's hearing. The HPD believes that allowing noise suppressors or
silencers to be legally obtained in the state of Hawaii will only make their use in the commission
of criminal acts more common. Having these dangerous items readily available will only
potentially increase gun violence.
The HPD strongly urges you to oppose this bill.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: macsak on February 10, 2017, 03:39:18 PM
says it passed with amendments ...8 ayes and 1 excused... :thumbsup:

How do you find out what the amendments are?

it should be posted in the next few days on the link to the bill
it may have to go to another committee or two before it gets to the floor, then even if it passes the floor vote, it needs to get combined with any companion senate bills in conference committee before it gets to the governor
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on February 10, 2017, 04:09:10 PM
it should be posted in the next few days on the link to the bill
it may have to go to another committee or two before it gets to the floor, then even if it passes the floor vote, it needs to get combined with any companion senate bills in conference committee before it gets to the governor
This bill will next go to (and face a much tougher crowd than the WAL committee) the House Committee on Judiciary (JUD), chaired by Rep. Nishimoto. Now, or early next week, would be a good time to write and call him asking him to schedule a hearing for this bill. The person I spoke to the other day said that people calling and writing could make a difference, as he hasn't decided at this point to hold a hearing or not. I'd think a thousand phone calls at the beginning of next week could be persuasive... 4, or 12, not so much. Also submit testimony again once the hearing is (if it is) scheduled.

JUD
House Committee on Judiciary

Chair
Scott Y. Nishimoto
House District 21
Hawaii State Capitol, Room 421
phone: 808-586-8515
fax: 808-586-8519
repnishimoto@Capitol.hawaii.gov

While you're at it also ask him to schedule a hearing for HB410, one of the "shall issue" CCW bils (Kong), that bill is only referred to JUD, so that is the first and only possible hearing it will get. HB410 is "shall issue", concealed and open carry, 1 year term of license, good only in county of issue, and still has the "engaged in the protection of life and property" phrase that has been interpreted to exclusively mean "security guards". Once there is a hearing amendments can be suggested in testimony.

I'll post a separate thread with the other committee chairs to contact to ask for hearing for the other CCW bills and the handgun mag limit change bill. HB36 -> PBS, then JUD; SB 212 and SB213 -> PSM, then JDL

Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: zippz on February 10, 2017, 04:16:30 PM
Dan from the NRA flew in for this hearing, and also to meet with legislators and HRA.

This bill still has a long way to go.  It will probably go through more committees for hearings like judicial, public safety, etc, then it'll go to a vote, if passed it'll do a crossover from the House to the Senate for their hearings then for a Senate vote.  If amended, it'll go back to the house for another vote.  Then if everything passes up to that point, it goes to the Governor.  If he signs it then its law.  If he vetoes then it can go back to the legislature for an override.

If it does not pass or gets deferred at any point, it's dead.

This flowchart makes the process easier to understand:
(http://www.law.uh.edu/faculty/thester/courses/Statutory2015/Texas%20Legislative%20Process%20Flowchart.gif)
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: zippz on February 10, 2017, 04:59:06 PM
I got some clarifying info on testimony...

The NRA Alert emails are directed to legislators on the committee.  The NRA says it does not go into the official testimony, I forgot what the reason was.  It's an easy way to show support.

Phone calls to legislators do not get tallied into official testimony due to it must be in writing.  But it is an easy way to show support

The best way to submit testimony is through the legislative website.  Alternatively they will take emails, regular mail, hand in testimony.  They will also take oral testimony at the hearing followed up by written testimony submitted by the end of business that day.

The Vice Chair's office processes all of the testimony submitted, weed out duplicates, posts them online, and makes copies and sorts them for the committee packets.  They get swamped with testimony sometimes and have a short window to process them which causes the delays.

For the committee packets, the order is government agencies at the top, then organizations and businesses, then individuals.

Tips for writing testimony...be concise, include your name, include the bill number, and clearly state in the subject or beginning sentence that you support,oppose, or providing comments.

I'll draft up a quick guide.

Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: sgtlmj on February 11, 2017, 07:17:31 AM
The Robinson's over on Ni'ihau support it. That should be good enough.  :thumbsup:   That reminds me, I need to save up for an Eland hunt over there if this passes. 

Mahalo!
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on February 15, 2017, 07:29:00 AM
The Amended version of the bill is up. Still no provision, as I read it, and I certainly could have missed it, for using the suppressor at a range to sight-in a firearm.  :wtf: Of course still for hunting only. And the other hoops to jump through. Did I mention earlier that a 12-year-old can walk into a hardware store in New Zealand and buy a suppressor for $25, no questions asked?  :crazy:

HB1589_HD1

2/15/2017 Reported from WAL (Stand. Com. Rep. No. 360) as amended in HD 1, recommending passage on Second Reading and referral to JUD.

http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/session2017/bills/HB1589_HD1_.PDF, or

http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/session2017/bills/HB1589_HD1_.HTM

http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=1589&year=2017
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: sgtlmj on February 15, 2017, 08:05:21 AM
When I emailed the sponsors about the omission of target shooting, I made sure to include the following brief, but critical information:


-Suppressors change the point of impact from a non-suppressed firearm.
-Not being able to verify this shift before hunting could lead to an unsafe/inhumane situation.
-The change in impact could cause an unintentional miss.
-The hunter may not be able to insure a humane kill.
-Going to field with a rifle that you haven't verified the change in point of impact from an installed suppressor would be similar to putting a new sights or scope on your firearm and going hunting without ever having sighted it in.  The change isn't drastic in every instance, but it is always unethical for a hunter to go afield with an unverified zero.


I posted the emails of all the sponsors earlier in the thread. I only got one canned response, so I'm going to hit it again.  Feel free to use any/all of this info.

 :shaka:

Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on February 15, 2017, 08:15:02 AM
When I emailed the sponsors about the omission of target shooting, I made sure to include the following brief, but critical information:


-Suppressors change the point of impact from a non-suppressed firearm.
-Not being able to verify this shift before hunting could lead to an unsafe/inhumane situation.
-The change in impact could cause an unintentional miss.
-The hunter may not be able to insure a humane kill.
-Going to field with a rifle that you haven't verified the change in point of impact from an installed suppressor would be similar to putting a new sights or scope on your firearm and going hunting without ever having sighted it in.  The change isn't drastic in every instance, but it is always unethical for a hunter to go afield with an unverified zero.


I posted the emails of all the sponsors earlier in the thread. I only got one canned response, so I'm going to hit it again.  Feel free to use any/all of this info.

 :shaka:
I read all 170 pages of testimony submitted to the committee. At least six submissions, besides mine, clearly pointed out the need to zero the suppressed firearm at a range in order to conform to the ethics of humane hunting. Draw your own conclusion. Of course I also pointed out that it was absurd, not to mention likely unconstitutional, to extend lawful suppressor ownership and use only to hunters while hunting and not to all firearms owners for all firearms used for all purposes. They ignored that too. I never cease to be amazed...  :crazy:
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: changemyoil66 on February 15, 2017, 08:46:39 AM
I read all 170 pages of testimony submitted to the committee. At least six submissions, besides mine, clearly pointed out the need to zero the suppressed firearm at a range in order to conform to the ethics of humane hunting. Draw your own conclusion. Of course I also pointed out that it was absurd, not to mention likely unconstitutional, to extend lawful suppressor ownership and use only to hunters while hunting and not to all firearms owners for all firearms used for all purposes. They ignored that too. I never cease to be amazed...  :crazy:

Because Hawaii's law makers are so anti 2a, we need to take baby steps.  So first to legalize supps for hunting only.  Then next step would be at ranges to zero.  if we go all in at once, it has a higher chance of being denied. 
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: London808 on February 15, 2017, 09:06:15 AM
Because Hawaii's law makers are so anti 2a, we need to take baby steps.  So first to legalize supps for hunting only.  Then next step would be at ranges to zero.  if we go all in at once, it has a higher chance of being denied.

By default you would be able to use them for target shooting/zeroing in. IF the range lets you.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: London808 on February 15, 2017, 09:08:19 AM
When I emailed the sponsors about the omission of target shooting, I made sure to include the following brief, but critical information:


-Suppressors change the point of impact from a non-suppressed firearm.
-Not being able to verify this shift before hunting could lead to an unsafe/inhumane situation.
-The change in impact could cause an unintentional miss.
-The hunter may not be able to insure a humane kill.
-Going to field with a rifle that you haven't verified the change in point of impact from an installed suppressor would be similar to putting a new sights or scope on your firearm and going hunting without ever having sighted it in.  The change isn't drastic in every instance, but it is always unethical for a hunter to go afield with an unverified zero.


I posted the emails of all the sponsors earlier in the thread. I only got one canned response, so I'm going to hit it again.  Feel free to use any/all of this info.

 :shaka:

Creating a list of reasons for them to deny the bill, good job.

once legal ownership is allowed you would be able to use them at the range to Zero. This bill is about decriminalizing the ownership and the easiest sell for that is as a hunting/hearing protection tool.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on February 15, 2017, 09:13:47 AM
Because Hawaii's law makers are so anti 2a, we need to take baby steps.  So first to legalize supps for hunting only.  Then next step would be at ranges to zero.  if we go all in at once, it has a higher chance of being denied.
So what's your estimate for how many dozens of years of "baby steps" until Hawaii legalizes suppressors for all firearms and all firearms owners? You're claiming that unethical inhumane hunting practices (hunting with a non-zeroed firearm) are a "baby step" in the right direction? Or are you suggesting that the ethical humane ethos of hunters in strong enough that they would illegally zero their rifles at a range, or anywhere else while not hunting? Or that the legislators don't know that they are encouraging such illegal and/or unethical inhumane activity? I'll wager that 1. IF (a big "if") suppressors are legalized only for licensed hunters only while hunting 2. the illegal use of suppressors to zero a hunting firearm will rarely or never be cited or prosecuted and 3. that there will NEVER be any "carryover" in Hawaii from the "baby step" to legalization of suppressors in general for all purposes. I personally think all of that is bullshit, and I'm planning on writing all the members of the Judiciary committee and telling them so (leaving out the word "bullshit").
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on February 15, 2017, 09:19:17 AM

once legal ownership is allowed you would be able to use them at the range to Zero.
By default you would be able to use them for target shooting/zeroing in. IF the range lets you.

Where exactly do you see that in the bill? Where else would you be able to use suppressors "by default"? My rural ag-zoned property for target shooting (with or without a hunting license)? Elsewhere on my property, including in my home on a non-hunting firearm for self-defense purposes?
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: changemyoil66 on February 15, 2017, 09:22:00 AM
So what's your estimate for how many dozens of years of "baby steps" until Hawaii legalizes suppressors for all firearms and all firearms owners? You're claiming that unethical inhumane hunting practices (hunting with a non-zeroed firearm) are a "baby step" in the right direction? Or are you suggesting that the ethical humane ethos of hunters in strong enough that they would illegally zero their rifles at a range, or anywhere else while not hunting? Or that the legislators don't know that they are encouraging such illegal and/or unethical inhumane activity? I'll wager that 1. IF (a big "if") suppressors are legalized only for licensed hunters only while hunting 2. the illegal use of suppressors to zero a hunting firearm will rarely or never be cited or prosecuted and 3. that there will NEVER be any "carryover" in Hawaii from the "baby step" to legalization of suppressors in general for all purposes. I personally think all of that is bullshit, and I'm planning on writing all the members of the Judiciary committee and telling them so (leaving out the word "bullshit").

I'm claiming that our law makers are anti 2a.  So we need to tread slowly when introducing a bill that we all know that they compare silencers to Hollywood.  So taking 1,2 or even more years to allow until allowed for range usage is better than supps being totally illegal forever. We have to treat this bill like a child.  See what we can get away with even though it's our 2a right that states it shall not be infringed upon.
 I agree that it is an infringement of our 2a rights, but apparently our law makers don't think so and get away with it daily for years with no penalties.

So the issues with not being able to zero and causing inhumane treatment and safety concerns will be a reason we use later for range usage of supps.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on February 15, 2017, 09:41:06 AM
I'm claiming that our law makers are anti 2a.  So we need to tread slowly when introducing a bill that we all know that they compare silencers to Hollywood.  So taking 1,2 or even more years to allow until allowed for range usage is better than supps being totally illegal forever. We have to treat this bill like a child.  See what we can get away with even though it's our 2a right that states it shall not be infringed upon.
 I agree that it is an infringement of our 2a rights, but apparently our law makers don't think so and get away with it daily for years with no penalties.

So the issues with not being able to zero and causing inhumane treatment and safety concerns will be a reason we use later for range usage of supps.
Well, you didn't answer the question about how many dozens of years it would take for the "baby steps" incrementalism approach to result in legal ownership of suppressors for all firearms by all firearms owners. We're 7 and 5 years in the legal cases to allow CCW and/open carry in Baker and Young, and they appear headed for defeat, though the finalization of those cases is likely still years away. What leads you to believe that the legislature is any more likely to be accommodating than the courts?

I don't know the answer to this question, so it is not rhetorical, in the past 20 or 30 years how many Second Amendment rights have been restored to law-abiding Hawaii residents via the incrementalist "baby steps" approach? What infringing laws have been repealed one step at a time resulting in full, or near full, restoration of our rights to keep and bear arms? In that same time period how many laws have been passed that have further eroded/infringed our fundamental individual inalienable natural enumerated Second Amendment-protected civil rights?
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: London808 on February 15, 2017, 09:46:18 AM
Where exactly do you see that in the bill? Where else would you be able to use suppressors "by default"? My rural ag-zoned property for target shooting (with or without a hunting license)? Elsewhere on my property, including in my home on a non-hunting firearm for self-defense purposes?

Part of hunting is making sure that your firearm is in a functional state, this includes zeroing your firearm. Where do you zero your firearm ? The range.

Do you have a suitable range setup on your property ?

If it was fitted to a firearm that is suitable for hunting and you used it for self defense then i would say its legal.

Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: 338KID on February 15, 2017, 09:51:09 AM
So when can I order ? I don't need to zero at a public range and got my hunters ed card ready 😂✌🏽✊🏿
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: changemyoil66 on February 15, 2017, 10:02:18 AM
Well, you didn't answer the question about how many dozens of years it would take for the "baby steps" incrementalism approach to result in legal ownership of suppressors for all firearms by all firearms owners. We're 7 and 5 years in the legal cases to allow CCW and/open carry in Baker and Young, and they appear headed for defeat, though the finalization of those cases is likely still years away. What leads you to believe that the legislature is any more likely to be accommodating than the courts?

I don't know the answer to this question, so it is not rhetorical, in the past 20 or 30 years how many Second Amendment rights have been restored to law-abiding Hawaii residents via the incrementalist "baby steps" approach? What infringing laws have been repealed one step at a time resulting in full, or near full, restoration of our rights to keep and bear arms? In that same time period how many laws have been passed that have further eroded/infringed our fundamental individual inalienable natural enumerated Second Amendment-protected civil rights?

I can't answer your question about how many years will it take because I do not have a crystal ball.  The point is that over the years, many have tried to restore our rights fully.  This doesn't work because majority of the bills get denied.  So lets try a different approach (baby steps).  Like Gabbards proposal of the 17rd mag limit.  If that gets approved, lets try for 30rd STANAG mags which fit in AR's.  Then 60rd drums and so forth. 

Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on February 15, 2017, 10:07:37 AM
Part of hunting is making sure that your firearm is in a functional state, this includes zeroing your firearm. Where do you zero your firearm ? The range.

Do you have a suitable range setup on your property ?

If it was fitted to a firearm that is suitable for hunting and you used it for self defense then i would say its legal.
You haven't shown me any parts of the proposed bill that would substantiate your claims.

Here are quotes from the actual bill:

Accordingly, the purpose of this Act is to improve the safety of hunters in Hawaii by authorizing:

     (1)  Licensed hunters who comply with state firearms law to possess and use firearm noise suppressors while hunting.

§134-5  Possession by licensed hunters and minors; target shooting; game hunting.  (a)  Any person of the age of sixteen years[,] or over, or any person under the age of sixteen years while accompanied by an adult, may carry and use any lawfully acquired rifle or shotgun [and], suitable ammunition, and a suitable firearm noise suppressor while actually engaged in hunting [or target shooting] or while going to and from the place of hunting [or target shooting]; provided that the person has procured a hunting license under chapter 183D, part II.

* * * * *
Seems to me that they've gone to lengths to clearly make a distinction between the legality of suppressor use ONLY while hunting (or to and from the hunting area) and emphasize that by deleting the legality of using it for target shooting or to and from a target shooting location.

How do you read that language and come to a different conclusion?
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on February 15, 2017, 10:30:58 AM
I can't answer your question about how many years will it take because I do not have a crystal ball.  The point is that over the years, many have tried to restore our rights fully.  This doesn't work because majority of the bills get denied.  So lets try a different approach (baby steps).  Like Gabbards proposal of the 17rd mag limit.  If that gets approved, lets try for 30rd STANAG mags which fit in AR's.  Then 60rd drums and so forth.
I wasn't expecting a psychic prediction for which you will be held accountable. I was hoping someone who is advocating for a particular strategy as being "more effective" to state a rough timeline of what could be expected from that strategy. What's the difference for seeking the actual restoration of our rights and getting nothing, and asking for a crumb and getting it in 20 or 40 or 100 years (or never)? I guess I'd rather fight for my full rights and lose than beg and grovel and get tossed a crumb and then be expected to show them gratitude like a slave. And I doubt they've tossed many, or any, crumbs re Second Amendment rights, but I don't know, and that's why I ask for examples.
 
There is no mag limit for rifle mags. If you're talking about an AR pistol, well, that's totally illegal anyway, and that will get changed when hell freezes over. There is no hearing scheduled for the mag limit bill. By your thinking that bill should be to change the handgun mag limit to 11. Then 10 years later try for 12. (This is a re-introduction of Senator Gabbard's bill from 2007, when he proposed a 15 round limit. He introduced this at my request and after seeing a list of all the current handguns that have 17 round standard capacity magazines was willing to change it to 17.) That bill isn't about a "number". It's totally irrational and random that they selected a particular number (in the New York SAFE Act it is 7). It's about control, making their arbitrary and capricious, irrational and illogical will imposed upon lowly citizens with the force of threatened violence (unless you are willing to head to prison peacefully because 12, not 10) for literally meaningless (in terms of the proclaimed "public safety") violations (what if you have a 10 round magazine and one in the chamber? I mean, if the "danger" is really "11", but "10" is "safe", then the mag capacity limit should be 9, right?).

Again, in the past 20 to 30 years give me the examples of rights in Hawaii being restored via the incrementalist "baby steps" approach. If it's a strategy that works, there must be some examples, right?
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: changemyoil66 on February 15, 2017, 10:38:06 AM
I wasn't expecting a psychic prediction for which you will be held accountable. I was hoping someone who is advocating for a particular strategy as being "more effective" to state a rough timeline of what could be expected from that strategy. What's the difference for seeking the actual restoration of our rights and getting nothing, and asking for a crumb and getting it in 20 or 40 or 100 years (or never)? I guess I'd rather fight for my full rights and lose than beg and grovel and get tossed a crumb and then be expected to show them gratitude like a slave. And I doubt they've tossed many, or any, crumbs re Second Amendment rights, but I don't know, and that's why I ask for examples.
 
There is no mag limit for rifle mags. If you're talking about an AR pistol, well, that's totally illegal anyway, and that will get changed when hell freezes over. There is no hearing scheduled for the mag limit bill. By your thinking that bill should be to change the handgun mag limit to 11. Then 10 years later try for 12. (This is a re-introduction of Senator Gabbard's bill from 2007, when he proposed a 15 round limit. He introduced this at my request and after seeing a list of all the current handguns that have 17 round standard capacity magazines was willing to change it to 17.) That bill isn't about a "number". It's totally irrational and random that they selected a particular number (in the New York SAFE Act it is 7). It's about control, making their arbitrary and capricious, irrational and illogical will imposed upon lowly citizens with the force of threatened violence (unless you are willing to head to prison peacefully because 12, not 10) for literally meaningless (in terms of the proclaimed "public safety") violations (what if you have a 10 round magazine and one in the chamber? I mean, if the "danger" is really "11", but "10" is "safe", then the mag capacity limit should be 9, right?).

Again, in the past 20 to 30 years give me the examples of rights in Hawaii being restored via the incrementalist "baby steps" approach. If it's a strategy that works, there must be some examples, right?

I guess we can try restoring our 2a rights by both means.  Full blown and baby steps or any other way we didn't think of yet.  2 is better than 1 or not even trying at all.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: sgtlmj on February 16, 2017, 08:08:22 AM
Creating a list of reasons for them to deny the bill, good job.

once legal ownership is allowed you would be able to use them at the range to Zero. This bill is about decriminalizing the ownership and the easiest sell for that is as a hunting/hearing protection tool.

This list was sent to the co-sponsors. Why would they suddenly deny the bill because I pointed out that they missed a very important aspect of using suppressors?
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on February 16, 2017, 08:44:20 AM
This list was sent to the co-sponsors. Why would they suddenly deny the bill because I pointed out that they missed a very important aspect of using suppressors?
All those committee members were informed by testimony at the committee hearing, if not before, of that defect in the bill, yet they chose NOT to amend the bill to allow for that obviously necessary use to conform to the standards of ethical humane hunting practices. Why?
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on February 16, 2017, 08:50:52 AM
All those committee members were informed by testimony at the committee hearing, if not before, of that defect in the bill, yet they chose NOT to amend the bill to allow for that obviously necessary use to conform to the standards of ethical humane hunting practices. Why?

If people used suppressors at the range, the noise level would be too low for HK residents to complain.    :shake:
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: sgtlmj on February 16, 2017, 04:45:17 PM
All those committee members were informed by testimony at the committee hearing, if not before, of that defect in the bill, yet they chose NOT to amend the bill to allow for that obviously necessary use to conform to the standards of ethical humane hunting practices. Why?

I've only lived here for 3 months, and have asked "why" not a few times in trying to understand how the HI laws work. I would think that they either don't think it'll grow any legs, or they are just putting forth just enough effort to keep some of their constituents happy so they can point to pro-2A activity next election cycle. 
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on February 17, 2017, 08:23:12 AM
I've only lived here for 3 months, and have asked "why" not a few times in trying to understand how the HI laws work. I would think that they either don't think it'll grow any legs, or they are just putting forth just enough effort to keep some of their constituents happy so they can point to pro-2A activity next election cycle.
Wow. And I thought I was "cynical". Just kidding. I believe there is enough evidence in general to substantiate such a view as "realistic" rather than "cynical". That said, in this particular case I'll be curious to see what happens at the next committee hearing, if one is even scheduled, and how the eight original co-sponsors advocate for the bill.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: microwaveman on February 26, 2017, 06:44:41 PM
Im a three year implant into Hawaii and cant really sort out what this bill passage by the Senate means, Does it go to the "HI House" now or to the Gov to become Law.


Once Law will other BATF laws apply or only  Hawaiian suppressor laws.... can we make our own without the US Fed Transfer Act of $200 ? If we cant can we just bring from mainland with us?

From what I understand this is only the second reading, 13 more steps to go until Governor signs or vetos


Not clear on what we can do at all.

Aloha

Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: sgtlmj on February 27, 2017, 01:55:19 PM
Once Law will other BATF laws apply or only  Hawaiian suppressor laws.... can we make our own without the US Fed Transfer Act of $200 ? If we cant can we just bring from mainland with us?



NFA will always apply until it's repealed or modified. Even in states that allow NFA items, you still must buy them on a Form 4 ($200), or make them yourself on a Form 1 ($200).
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: 6716J on March 10, 2017, 10:50:21 AM
So the NRA-ILA site is saying this is dead...
"Unfortunately, House Bill 1589, legislation that would legalize the use of suppressors while hunting, failed to meet deadlines and is now dead for the 2017 legislative session.  Your NRA-ILA will be back next year to continue the fight for the passage of this important bill."

Looking at the Hawaii Leg site it doesn't say crap. So how do we know...? http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=1589&year=2017
 (http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=1589&year=2017)
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: suka on March 10, 2017, 07:34:20 PM
NFA will always apply until it's repealed or modified. Even in states that allow NFA items, you still must buy them on a Form 4 ($200), or make them yourself on a Form 1 ($200).

Form 2's are free!
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: zippz on March 10, 2017, 08:06:10 PM
So the NRA-ILA site is saying this is dead...
"Unfortunately, House Bill 1589, legislation that would legalize the use of suppressors while hunting, failed to meet deadlines and is now dead for the 2017 legislative session.  Your NRA-ILA will be back next year to continue the fight for the passage of this important bill."

Looking at the Hawaii Leg site it doesn't say crap. So how do we know...? http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=1589&year=2017
 (http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=1589&year=2017)

It didn't "crossover" to the senate so it's dead.  Technically it could be kept alive for this year, but those are astronomical odds.  Could be resurrected next year.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: sgtlmj on March 13, 2017, 11:17:37 AM
Form 2's are free!

Free + 07FFL + SOT + ITAR.  ;)
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: suka on March 13, 2017, 10:40:07 PM
Free + 07FFL + SOT + ITAR.  ;)

Opps,  sorry I mean a Form 5    :thumbsup:
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: 6716J on March 14, 2017, 10:47:25 AM
It didn't "crossover" to the senate so it's dead.  Technically it could be kept alive for this year, but those are astronomical odds.  Could be resurrected next year.

Well they said we couldn't go to the moon, and yet we did. Here's hoping....
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on March 14, 2017, 11:36:30 AM
Well they said we couldn't go to the moon, and yet we did. Here's hoping....
The problems posed by the physics of getting to the moon pale in comparison to overcoming the problems of exercising our right to keep and bear arms in this statist hellhole.

It "only" took 8 years after Kennedy proposed the Appollo manned lunar landings to accomplish that task. According to former Hawaii county chief Kubojiri, to his knowledge no one in Hawaii county has EVER received a CCW license. When did the clock start on making NFA items legal in Hawaii?
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: 6716J on March 14, 2017, 12:00:24 PM
The problems posed by the physics of getting to the moon pale in comparison to overcoming the problems of exercising our right to keep and bear arms in this statist hellhole.

It "only" took 8 years after Kennedy proposed the Appollo manned lunar landings to accomplish that task. According to former Hawaii county chief Kubojiri, to his knowledge no one in Hawaii county has EVER received a CCW license. When did the clock start on making NFA items legal in Hawaii?

so maybe by 2164 we'll go to a shall issue state?

Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: punaperson on March 15, 2017, 06:42:31 PM
so maybe by 2164 we'll go to a shall issue state?
I'd tone down the optimism a bit.  :shaka: Ginsburg will probably still be on the SCOTUS bench then.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: London808 on March 15, 2017, 07:07:13 PM
Well they said we couldn't go to the moon, and yet we did. Here's hoping....

lol YOU THINK WE WENT TO THE MOON
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: nathanm14fan on March 16, 2017, 08:03:49 AM
A little bit of levity here guys - the bill passed in ONE committee, and didn't even make it out of there without revisions. Despite having 10 co-sponsors, it was never even HEARD in the second committee (JUD). Not surprising to me in the slightest. Absent a full court press by the NRA, HRA (both highly unlikely) and a sea-change in advocacy by the average Hawaii gun owner AND pro-2A citizens, we aren't going to get anywhere legislatively in this state.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: 6716J on March 16, 2017, 12:52:52 PM
lol YOU THINK WE WENT TO THE MOON
Wait so are you saying they faked it?

These guys say otherwise...
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: zippz on March 17, 2017, 01:02:42 PM
A little bit of levity here guys - the bill passed in ONE committee, and didn't even make it out of there without revisions.

It was a small step, but not a giant leap.

The good thing is it was created and supported by a group of democrat legislators.
Title: Re: HB1589 Hawaii Suppressor Legalization (for Hunters Only)
Post by: michaelkih on October 13, 2018, 02:43:02 PM
I'm new to hunting and suppressors.  Do you need to use subsonic ammunition with rifle suppressors or will suppressors still lower the sound sufficiently with standard ammo to prevent hearing damage?

This is an old thread, but I feel like answering this question.

First, I mostly live on Kauai,  it also live in Texas where I collect machine guns and suppressors and am also an FFL/SOT dealer with a business partner.

With rifle rounds, suppressors make standard ammo bearable.  One or two shots with one is a huge difference from without, and you will be fine.  Technically not hearing safe, but it’s way way better.  Use subsonic rounds, and with most suppressors you will now be in the hearing safe range for all day shooting.

With pistol rounds it’s the same.  The are quieter and slower, but super sonic is still. It really hearing safe.  It’s close and fine for a couple shots though.  45acp on the other hand is already subsonic.  It’s laughably quiet with standard ammo.  Same thing with 22 ammo.  Standard ammo shot through a good 22 can, like a dead air mask, is laughably quiet.  Add subsonic ammo to the mix, and holy balls, it AWESOME!

This is cool to see.  I doubt it will pass, but if so, I’ll djust finitely be bringing my license here as I’m sure I have more experience shooting suppressed guns or all types and brands than most on Kauai.  Also, I love to help and teach others! 

Thank your pro gun legislatures!!