2aHawaii
General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: SpeedTek on February 28, 2012, 10:46:53 AM
-
Someone told me there was an arrest at KHSC this Sunday? someone was selling a illegal gun?
I never heard anything about this. anyone else?
-
Well I bought a 22lr conversion for my POF ar but I did not get arrested nor I see any squad cars.
I was there for the funshoot from 9:30 to 1:00
I did see Carter and his coworker taking a home safety class right next to us and I though it was funny to see Carter of OGC and Daniel of KSG within the same area lol.
-
Was at the pistol range from about 8:30am to around 11:30am. Didn't see or hear a thing.
-
I was at the Rifle and Sil side since 1pm and left at 4pm. I heard this this morning.
-
I was at the Bullseye from 10-11 and Silhouette from 11-2, didn't see anything. btw, does anyone keep their registration papers with them when at the range? I don't, but I think I will start just in case.
-
That's shady.
-
i heard someone got arreseted for reporting his guns stolen when he was at a shopping center after the range. i think his backpack with a couple pistols and a shotgun in the back seat missing. my brother told me he got the info from some hawaii news iphone app.
-
I heard that Whitney Houston died of a crack cocaine overdose.
-
I was at the Bullseye from 10-11 and Silhouette from 11-2, didn't see anything. btw, does anyone keep their registration papers with them when at the range? I don't, but I think I will start just in case.
Always just in case
-
I carry copies. I've never been asked though.
-
I don't keep copies; not required to do so. No reason anyone would ever see them anyways.
-
I carry copies. I've never been asked though.
Even if you were asked, why would you show someone? It's really none of their business.
-
Even if you were asked, why would you show someone? It's really none of their business.
this
-
^^^ someone told me that if asked by the ROs to show the registration and you don't have it, they can make you leave. I really can't recall who it was, but I think I was told this by a gun store owner. But I'm glad to know that I don't need to carry copies. One less thing to lose.
-
^^^ someone told me that if asked by the ROs to show the registration and you don't have it, they can make you leave. I really can't recall who it was, but I think I was told this by a gun store owner. But I'm glad to know that I don't need to carry copies. One less thing to lose.
i call bullshit.
-
^^^ someone told me that if asked by the ROs to show the registration and you don't have it, they can make you leave. I really can't recall who it was, but I think I was told this by a gun store owner. But I'm glad to know that I don't need to carry copies. One less thing to lose.
Its none of their business, in *FACT* its prohibited by law. You are not required to disclose ANY gun registration information to ANYONE other than the police when you register the gun.
This is why we can't FOIA the CCW permits, Open Carry permits etc, because disclosure of that info has already been 'sealed' so to speak by law.
-
^^^ I'm glad I asked.
-
This is interesting:
http://www.civilbeat.com/articles/2011/05/26/11194-hawaii-doesnt-require-lost-gun-reports/ (http://www.civilbeat.com/articles/2011/05/26/11194-hawaii-doesnt-require-lost-gun-reports/)
-
Even if you were asked, why would you show someone? It's really none of their business.
Thanks for the clarification. This was before 2ahawaii.com and HDF.
Much appreciated.
-
This is interesting:
http://www.civilbeat.com/articles/2011/05/26/11194-hawaii-doesnt-require-lost-gun-reports/ (http://www.civilbeat.com/articles/2011/05/26/11194-hawaii-doesnt-require-lost-gun-reports/)
So... Once again Hawaii's BS gun laws punish a citizen for doing the 'right' thing when his firearms where stolen. Even though he could have been free and clear by not saying a word. :wtf:
http://www.khon2.com/news/local/story/Car-break-in-at-shopping-center-leads-to-firearms/GPyOQmMjTkGpkWDFbU2a4A.cspx (http://www.khon2.com/news/local/story/Car-break-in-at-shopping-center-leads-to-firearms/GPyOQmMjTkGpkWDFbU2a4A.cspx)
-
^
To be honest, he is the one who broke the law in the first place. I'm not saying I agree with the law, nor am I going to martyr him for being honest for reporting it; it would've been more irresponsible and akin to criminal mentality if he didn't report it. We have to remember that he brought this upon himself. He didn't choose to get robbed, but he did choose to take his guns to the mall. I'll admit, albeit very rarely, I'm guity of doing the same thing. It's infringingly inconvenient to go all the way home, then go back to the supermarket just because you have the car and your wife called to ask you to pick up a carton of milk.
Having said that.....this bullshit law needs to be fixed, sugu. We should work together to point out how this law demonizes innocent people who simply needed to or wanted to make a stop somewhere along the way to or from their place of residence or sojourn.
-
^
To be honest, he is the one who broke the law in the first place. I'm not saying I agree with the law, nor am I going to martyr him for being honest for reporting it; it would've been more irresponsible and akin to criminal mentality if he didn't report it. We have to remember that he brought this upon himself. He didn't choose to get robbed, but he did choose to take his guns to the mall. I'll admit, albeit very rarely, I'm guity of doing the same thing. It's infringingly inconvenient to go all the way home, then go back to the supermarket just because you have the car and your wife called to ask you to pick up a carton of milk.
Having said that.....this bullshit law needs to be fixed, sugu. We should work together to point out how this law demonizes innocent people who simply needed to or wanted to make a stop somewhere along the way to or from their place of residence or sojourn.
+1
-
^
To be honest, he is the one who broke the law in the first place. I'm not saying I agree with the law, nor am I going to martyr him for being honest for reporting it; it would've been more irresponsible and akin to criminal mentality if he didn't report it. We have to remember that he brought this upon himself. He didn't choose to get robbed, but he did choose to take his guns to the mall. I'll admit, albeit very rarely, I'm guity of doing the same thing. It's infringingly inconvenient to go all the way home, then go back to the supermarket just because you have the car and your wife called to ask you to pick up a carton of milk.
Having said that.....this bullshit law needs to be fixed, sugu. We should work together to point out how this law demonizes innocent people who simply needed to or wanted to make a stop somewhere along the way to or from their place of residence or sojourn.
There could never be criminal intent. Even if you had a law that required you to report your guns being stolen, if they were stolen from a place you couldn't have it, the 5th amendment says that you can't self incriminate -- which would be exactly what this man would have done. He had a constitutional guarantee to not have to report his gun stolen; I certainly would never have.
-
So... Once again Hawaii's BS gun laws punish a citizen for doing the 'right' thing when his firearms where stolen. Even though he could have been free and clear by not saying a word. :wtf:
http://www.khon2.com/news/local/story/Car-break-in-at-shopping-center-leads-to-firearms/GPyOQmMjTkGpkWDFbU2a4A.cspx (http://www.khon2.com/news/local/story/Car-break-in-at-shopping-center-leads-to-firearms/GPyOQmMjTkGpkWDFbU2a4A.cspx)
The law is BS, but this guy was also not very smart.
-
:)
-
:)
-
Another point to add. You don't have to be the registered owner of a firearm to fire or possess it. Guns can be lent out, for those that didn't know. Just read through the Hawaii Revised Statutes section 134. All responsible gun owners should be familiar with most of HRS 134. Know what you can and can not do and prevent yourself from being violated.
Could be wrong, but, I don't believe you can lend a handgun for any amount of time. Correct me if I'm wrong.
-
Could be wrong, but, I don't believe you can lend a handgun for any amount of time. Correct me if I'm wrong.
This all depends on our definition of "lend." If lend means I can't let you touch the gun in my presence, then well we are screwed lol (we would have no way of teaching classes). If it means you can't leave my sight my firearm, then we are good, because this is what we all do right now. Right now you are correct though, you can only lend out long guns.
-
Hypothetical question. My SO is legal to handle firearms. I go on vacation, there is a home invasion, my handgun is the easiest accessible firearm for defense, she shoots intruder. Probably never happened in hi before to case study. I know yanal, but, what do you think the repercussions would be?
-
Hypothetical question. My SO is legal to handle firearms. I go on vacation, there is a home invasion, my handgun is the easiest accessible firearm for defense, she shoots intruder. Probably never happened in hi before to case study. I know yanal, but, what do you think the repercussions would be?
I don't know how much this helps, but before Uncle Sam sent me away from Hawaii, I was worried about my guns rusting and I called someone in HPD about whether I can have a friend take care of them for me. She said that as long as my pistol didn't leave my house, it's cool. Your SO should be fine, I guess.
I have another related question. Is it possible to register a gun under a trust in Hawaii, like NFA firearms can where they're legal, so my hopefully-soon-to-be can take "my" handguns to the range if she wanted?
-
:)
-
People who are married can get joint custody of weapons. You and your spouse can have joint registration. I wish they could do that for children of age.
-
I don't know how much this helps, but before Uncle Sam sent me away from Hawaii, I was worried about my guns rusting and I called someone in HPD about whether I can have a friend take care of them for me. She said that as long as my pistol didn't leave my house, it's cool. Your SO should be fine, I guess.
I have another related question. Is it possible to register a gun under a trust in Hawaii, like NFA firearms can where they're legal, so my hopefully-soon-to-be can take "my" handguns to the range if she wanted?
oh my god if I had a $ everytime some idiot at HPD said something that is totally not legit lol.
Technically, under the law, your SO could be prosecuted for possession of a unregistered firearm. However, it would be so stupid and get smacked down so hard they would likely never even try to convict. The choice of evils defense would be soooo strong and compelling, even in bleeding heart hawaii you would likely get off with no problem.
Defendant takes the stand:
"I Didn't want to get raped and murdered, I feared for my life and there was a criminal in my house"
/notguilty.
-
People who are married can get joint custody of weapons. You and your spouse can have joint registration. I wish they could do that for children of age.
I wonder if this applies to civil unions yet. It's crap like this that makes me want to just put all my guns in a trust.
-
Funtimes already replied, but you and he are correct. Handguns can not be loaned. I was not detailed in my statement.
For real?
Ok, funtimes, pit808, bananaclip, nihonjin, speedtek, mojo & vooduchikn, give me back the guns I loaned you guys.
-
For real?
Ok, funtimes, pit808, bananaclip, nihonjin, speedtek, mojo & vooduchikn, give me back the guns I loaned you guys.
Shhhhh :P I'm already ona watch list!
-
Shhhhh :P I'm already ona watch list!
D'oh. :o
For the uninformed, I would like to point out... IT'S JUST a JOKE.
-
The man was arrested on 3 counts of "place to keep" and was released pending investigation.
What's that supposed to mean?
???
Terry, 230RN
-
^^^3 firearms not properly kept at home, place of business, place of sojourn maybe?
-
What's that supposed to mean?
???
Terry, 230RN
In Hawaii you can only legally transport a firearm to: HPD for registration/transfer of registration, from a retail establishment after purchase and then home or HPD for registration prior to home, to and from a retail establishment for servicing (gunsmithing) or to the range and back home. The arrest was affected ecause the individual admitted to leaving the range and stopping at the mall. He did not go directly home. He was in violation of the letter of the law but I agree with Nihonjin in that it should only be one count, the shotgun and not three as the two handguns were never visually nor physically verified by the arresting officer to be at the locatin.
-
This comment pertains to the arrest of the man who reported his guns stolen and not the KHSC arrest.
I think the news article lacks sufficient information regarding the charges levied against the victim to really determine whether the charges are inappropriate. The victim may have violated the laws regarding the storage of firearms in the vehicle as opposed to simply transporting the firearms between permissible places. The article mentions that an unloaded shotgun was in the back seat of the victim's vehicle but it didn't say if the shotgun was cased in a rigid receptacle. The victim could have violated the law if his firearms were not properly transported.
-
Sucks he was trying to do the right thing, but by reporting all the guns he had in the car he is admitting guilt and evidence that could be used against him for the charges. Do i think its right? Not at all, but he gets the three counts because he admitted to having more than one in the car. I think thats more than enough evidence in the LEOs eyes to charge him.
Btw, if i am leasing a farm, can i legally carry on my land? Its not technically mine but i am leasing it.
-
^^^For me, I'd say yes, but I'm no attorney.
I'd talk to an attorney and have him take a look at your lease agreement.
-
Btw, if i am leasing a farm, can i legally carry on my land? Its not technically mine but i am leasing it.
I would say yes as most states recognize your place of residence or where you call your home is the structure at the address on your drivers license, regardless of whether you are renting or owning it, apartment, townhouse, single family home, farm, penthouse or other dwelling.
I am not a lawyer and I did not stay in a Holiday Inn Express last night.
-
Just putting it out there, 1.) depending on where you are, and where the ag property is, you could be in violation of Federal School zone law. For instance, even if we could carry on our 'property' or "curtilage," which is quite different from your home, there is no exemption to get us out of the school zone rules. You would have to go see the case against the California guy who was open carrying and then picked up on school zone violations. Essentially, the judge ruled that as soon as there is an opening to your property it becomes 'public property.'
This has some significant complications, because under the ruling if you were in your garage, and then opened the door.... your garage became public property if you didn't have a fence enclosing it.
I would like to point out that most legal things consider the 'residence' to be the physical structure, not the property. I.e. you shoot someone that was just on your land, you are going to go jail. You shoot someone in your house, they have broken into your residence and you are probably getting off.
All that aside, I would say no (unless you were hunting, or if it was a long gun).
-
In Hawaii you can only legally transport a firearm to: HPD for registration/transfer of registration, from a retail establishment after purchase and then home or HPD for registration prior to home, to and from a retail establishment for servicing (gunsmithing) or to the range and back home. The arrest was affected ecause the individual admitted to leaving the range and stopping at the mall. He did not go directly home. He was in violation of the letter of the law but I agree with Nihonjin in that it should only be one count, the shotgun and not three as the two handguns were never visually nor physically verified by the arresting officer to be at the locatin
OK, thanks.
Sounds like an "infringement" to me. Three of them, in fact.
Also sounds like "charge-piling-on," or "throwing the book at him," which is a despicable tactic of prosecutors. Glad he didn't spit on the sidewalk, to boot.
Terry, 230RN
-
They did drop the jay walking ticket, though. Apparently he didn't use the crosswalk as he raced to a payphone to report the theft. :wacko:
-
They did drop the jay walking ticket, though. Apparently he didn't use the crosswalk as he raced to a payphone to report the theft. :wacko:
Yes, but the no no-fault insuarance and expired safety vilolations are just flat out mean.
-
Yes, but the no no-fault insuarance and expired safety vilolations are just flat out mean.
I'm all for seizing vehicles of people who routinely don't carry insurance.
-
In Hawaii you can only legally transport a firearm to: HPD for registration/transfer of registration, from a retail establishment after purchase and then home or HPD for registration prior to home, to and from a retail establishment for servicing (gunsmithing) or to the range and back home. The arrest was affected ecause the individual admitted to leaving the range and stopping at the mall. He did not go directly home. He was in violation of the letter of the law but I agree with Nihonjin in that it should only be one count, the shotgun and not three as the two handguns were never visually nor physically verified by the arresting officer to be at the locatin.
Like it or not, the gentleman incriminated himself by saying he had the handguns there at the mall and subsequently stolen. So, he was charged with three counts of "place to keep" firearms. The police do not need to verify that the guns were there to charge him. The courts will decide if the charges stick. It would be like someone admitting to killing someone where there was physical evidence that supported the confession but no body. Do you think the police wouldn't be able to charge him with murder/manslaughter?
-
It appears that the situation is somewhat analogous to a motor vehicle operator who was rear ended and who called the cops for assistance and getting cited for not carrying his no-fault insurance card and registration and operating his vehicle with an expired safety. Most people would probably have no problems with this occurrence.
-
It appears that the situation is somewhat analogous to a motor vehicle operator who was rear ended and who called the cops for assistance and getting cited for not carrying his no-fault insurance card and registration and operating his vehicle with an expired safety. Most people would probably have no problems with this occurrence.
I don't equate the two to each other as I don't feel there is anything wrong ethically/morally with carrying and storing firearms in your vehicle.
I look at it more like this. The company says to take your laptop home at the end of the day because they don't want it stolen. Well you don't and it gets ripped off. Now because some criminal stole your stuff from a secured location you are going to take heat? What do you do? Make up a story that it was in your house and got stolen from there?
-
I don't equate the two to each other as I don't feel there is anything wrong ethically/morally with carrying and storing firearms in your vehicle.
I look at it more like this. The company says to take your laptop home at the end of the day because they don't want it stolen. Well you don't and it gets ripped off. Now because some criminal stole your stuff from a secured location you are going to take heat? What do you do? Make up a story that it was in your house and got stolen from there?
It is crappy but, in this case the law is clear.
You are not allowed to stop at shopping centers with firearms in your vehicle. If it gets stolen out of your vehicle and you report it to the police, you are admitting to a violation of the law.
This reminds me of an episode of "Cops" that I saw.
On the episode, a trucker calls the police and when they get there, he reports that while he was receiving fellatio from a prostitute, she stole his drugs.
The LEO looked astounded and asked him "Are you sure that you want to report this?"
The trucker was insisting. So he got arrested for soliciting a prostitute. Hahaha, sucks but true.
-
Hahaha, sucks but true.
I assume this pun was intended. ;D
-
Hahaha, sucks but true.
I assume this pun was intended. ;D
:D
-
It is crappy but, in this case the law is clear.
You are not allowed to stop at shopping centers with firearms in your vehicle. If it gets stolen out of your vehicle and you report it to the police, you are admitting to a violation of the law.
This reminds me of an episode of "Cops" that I saw.
On the episode, a trucker calls the police and when they get there, he reports that while he was receiving fellatio from a prostitute, she stole his drugs.
The LEO looked astounded and asked him "Are you sure that you want to report this?"
The trucker was insisting. So he got arrested for soliciting a prostitute. Hahaha, sucks but true.
I agree that it sucks.
I wonder how it would have played out if the guy had an apartment in the Ala Moana Hotel?
-
my 2 cents:
Shopping mall parking lot; I do not leave anything in my vehicle if it is of value to me. Gun would be one of those things.
Ignorance of the law; Ignorance - nuff said.
Responsible gun owner: Cowboy the $%ck up!!! own your mistakes,
The law; If not happy with it, get a petition, talk to your representative, get behind it and change the law.......work the system.
Again my 2 cents
Peace
-
5:00 PM
2 hand guns
1 shotty
sounds like one of our funshoots buddies but who?
feel bad for the person though.