2aHawaii
Tools and Uses => Firearms and Accessories => Topic started by: changemyoil66 on September 12, 2018, 10:23:30 AM
-
Looking into it now and there are so many vids out there that show the results on ballistic gel with cloth and without. Thru objects and no object, etc...
Short barrel, full size.
Then of course there are the "well HPD uses it, that's why I use it" for liability purposes (other persons attorney trying to make you look like a crazy murderer).
And now there are not only HP, but some other polymer stuff that looks like a twist (Underwood), or the tumbling type.
So what you all think is the most reliable for 9mm and available here.
Currently got Remington HTP JHP +P. And it cycles fine in the VP9 and CZ P10C. Running Critical D in the S&W 9C because it states do not use +P ammo.
-
Looking into it now and there are so many vids out there that show the results on ballistic gel with cloth and without. Thru objects and no object, etc...
Short barrel, full size.
Then of course there are the "well HPD uses it, that's why I use it" for liability purposes (other persons attorney trying to make you look like a crazy murderer).
And now there are not only HP, but some other polymer stuff that looks like a twist (Underwood), or the tumbling type.
So what you all think is the most reliable for 9mm and available here.
Currently got Remington HTP JHP +P. And it cycles fine in the VP9 and CZ P10C. Running Critical D in the S&W 9C because it states do not use +P ammo.
I do not own any firearms, ammo, nor reloading components
-
For 9 mm, Gold Dot 124 gr (regular pressure). Primarily because of proven and tested performer and readily available locally for a decent price. I've tested POI against the typical 115 gr FMJ that I shoot and they are pretty much the same out to 25 yards, so good for my purposes.
For 40 S&W, I still have some Remington 155 gr (I think) HP ammo that a college buddy gave me when he was a Fed LEO firearms instructor. I haven't shot with that ammo much and don't really shoot my 40 S&W much these days.
For .223 Rem, Gold Dot 62 gr and Hornady American Gunner 55 gr HP match. Both readily available locally and for a decent price. Did my own testing "backyard" style testing on the ammo as well as verified POI with the FMJ ammo that I shoot regularly. The Gold Dot stuff is also pretty well tried and true and tried the Hornady stuff because it was on sale.
-
1775 milsurp musketballs, because that's what the constitution covers.
-
9mm Luger 115 gr FTX® Critical Defense®
Since their inception, conventional hollow point pistol bullets have performed well, but have
never delivered 100% reliability, especially in self-defense situations. The patented Flex Tip®
technology used in Critical Defense® ammunition eliminates the clogging and inconsistency
that often plagues hollow point bullets. Hornady® achieved this by using the same tip material
used in LEVERevolution® ammunition.
All Critical Defense® ammunition is loaded in nickel-plated cases for increased visibility in low-light
situations. Premium low flash propellants deliver proven performance, even in very short-barreled
handguns, and won't disrupt your vision. Reliable expansion and dependable terminal performance
can be counted on for concealed carry and personal protection.
https://www.hornady.com/ammunition/handgun/9mm-luger-115-gr-ftx-critical-defense#!/
(https://i.imgur.com/gv8uoHD.jpg?1)
-
Federal HST 9mm 124 grain standard pressure is what I use.
After researching many hours and viewing many ballistic tests I believe HST is the best performing defensive handgun round for the widest range of scenarios. Also through my research it seems that HST is one of the best performers in other calibers and weights as well.
And as for defensive AR rifle round. I use varmint type ammo to help prevent overpenetrarion. The specific ammo I have is 50 grain gray polymer tipped from federal.
The AR rounds should not overpenetrate. And in the case of a miss, it seems they give the best chance of breaking apart after passing through thin walls.
-
Winchester PDX1 125 grain HP, but I plan to switch to Hornady critical defense
I also have my reloaded XTP, which I practice with more bc its cheaper. But these would be backup rounds when my factory rounds run out bc I've heard shouldn't use reloads for self defense.
What are your thoughts on reloads for self defense?
-
I prefer 124 gr +P Gold Dots. Its always one of the most highly recommended loads and can usually be found. Doctor Gary Roberts is the SME on this stuff. I don't remember where its posted but if you search his name, you'll find his recommended list. Any of those should be solid.
-
The HPD ammo, Speer 124 gold dot standard pressure.
Because I can make a cheap reload that looks and shoots like the real thing.
So I can afford to practice at about 7 bucks a box/50
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=15665.msg146433#msg146433
part2
https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=15673.msg146449#msg146449
-
What are your thoughts on reloads for self defense?
IIRC OldFart had a post about this and how he was called to court or something to testify about the reloads.
-
IIRC OldFart had a post about this and how he was called to court or something to testify about the reloads.
....
No.
I was asked to identify the bullet as being fired from a particular caliber of pistol.
The point was that sharp attorneys will drill deep looking into every aspect of a shooting.
Hence my position that it is best to use common acceptable ammunition, like hpd issue.
-
1775 milsurp musketballs, because that's what the constitution covers.
Supplemented with foul language? ;D
I prefer 124 gr +P Gold Dots. Its always one of the most highly recommended loads and can usually be found. Doctor Gary Roberts is the SME on this stuff. I don't remember where its posted but if you search his name, you'll find his recommended list. Any of those should be solid.
Where have you been getting the +P stuff?
I used to have a bunch of Federal Hydrashocks. Those were supposedly “the best” around the mid to late 90s. Stuff was pretty darn expensive d though. Since going to GDs, haven’t looked at the federal stuff again.
A buddy made some ballistic gel and we shot it up. He used too much tint so it was hard to see the track. That and we wanted to test a bunch of different bullet heads and loading. After a few shots, was too hard to tell between them and the gel was too expensive to make a bunch of blocks.
-
Speer gold dot 124gr 9mm. What law enforcent uses. Its a good round and I dont have time to research different types out now
-
Thanks all for the replies. I'm going to pick up some GD when I can.
-
Thanks all for the replies. I'm going to pick up some GD when I can.
I believe SEC has 124 gr and 147 gr, both for around $25-28ish per box of 50. I try to buy some here and there. I bought some 147 gr one time when they were out of 124 gr. I was going to tear POI between the 124 and147, but haven’t had a chance. Think would be close enough for most “defensive occasions”.
-
I believe SEC has 124 gr and 147 gr, both for around $25-28ish per box of 50. I try to buy some here and there. I bought some 147 gr one time when they were out of 124 gr. I was going to tear POI between the 124 and147, but haven’t had a chance. Think would be close enough for most “defensive occasions”.
prob gonna go tomorrow to pick up 1 box to test fire it in the P10C and VP9. Then if everything works fine, grab a few more boxes.
Gonna stick with Critical D for the M&P 9C, since it's a 3.5 inch barrel.
-
prob gonna go tomorrow to pick up 1 box to test fire it in the P10C and VP9. Then if everything works fine, grab a few more boxes.
Gonna stick with Critical D for the M&P 9C, since it's a 3.5 inch barrel.
CMO, one box is not going to tell you much either way
if it misfires, you will not know if it's just that box, or the firearm, or truly a problem
and if it works, it is also not a representation of reliability to continue a test run of that ammo
-
CMO, one box is not going to tell you much either way
if it misfires, you will not know if it's just that box, or the firearm, or truly a problem
and if it works, it is also not a representation of reliability to continue a test run of that ammo
I know some folks who run a box of 50 FMJ and call things all good. . .
-
I know some folks who run a box of 50 FMJ and call things all good. . .
There's no one-size-fits-all answer for this.
How often do you practice with that gun?
Do you always practice with your HD/SD ammo, or only use cheaper range ammo?
Do you have mag/s for HD, and others for range practice?
If you practice often, then maybe 100-200 rounds of defense ammo is sufficient for an initial function test. After that, you should continue to fire that ammo at each practice, at least 50-100 rounds or more.
That'll keep your ammo rotated. The worst thing you can do is leave your defense ammo at home, shoot bulk ammo at the range, then load the same old HD ammo in the same untested mag for protection. Refresh your ammo at least every few months, not only to have fresh ammo, but to continue making sure your pistol and magazine is functioning perfectly with it by using up the old stock.
If you use a revolver, then mags are not an issue. Otherwise, I have range mags that get scuffed and dirty, and HD mags that only see bullseye practice time. My 2 HD mags run HD ammo exclusively. I always have a spare mag loaded next to the pistol for malfunction/reload. Two is one -- one is none.
If you have any issues with your chosen ammo cycling or firing, do some troubleshooting. Could be the gun needs cleaning, might be a mag issue, or you might want to test other brands/versions of HD ammo. Once you think you have the issue corrected. Restart the testing by running 100-200 rounds through it again. If you get 4 boxes to run cleanly start to finish without any issues, I'd trust that ammo.
-
For me, I initially shot a box of 50 GDs to verify. Was “good enough” with that to load up mags with them. My intent was to shoot more defensive ammo here and there.
Yeah, I agree no rule for it. Personal preference and comfort level. I want to shoot often, but it’s not consistent. Or at least as consistent as I would like. Personally, I would not be super confident taking a brand new gun, shooting a box of 50 FMJ range fodder and say the gun is GTG, but I know many who have. Up to them really.
Everyone has their rules about what their standard is for a firearm for them to trust it. I’ve seen some folks say 1,000 rounds and no malfunction for them to trust the gun. I can’t say for sure both my Glock 17s did that, but they are my go to defensive handguns.
-
I like the Gold Dot series from Speer. I have heard good things about them and they seem to perform very well in the ballistic gel videos on youtube as well. They have nickel plated casings as well for reliability.
I have gold dot 9mm, .308, and 5.56. I just ordered a .22 mag revolver and I plan on getting gold dot rounds for that gun as well.
I believe HPD uses them as well so I guess I fall into that category of if it is good enough for them its good enough for me too.
-
I like the Gold Dot series from Speer. I have heard good things about them and they seem to perform very well in the ballistic gel videos on youtube as well. They have nickel plated casings as well for reliability.
I have gold dot 9mm, .308, and 5.56. I just ordered a .22 mag revolver and I plan on getting gold dot rounds for that gun as well.
I believe HPD uses them as well so I guess I fall into that category of if it is good enough for them its good enough for me too.
"i believe"?
LOL
-
"i believe"?
LOL
When you're issued free ammo, might as well use it at home, too.
BTW, Speer doesn't make a Gold Dot rifle bullet or cartridge in 5.56. And the smallest Gold Dot handgun caliber they offer is a hollow point .251 bullet -- no cartridge.
So, I find it odd (but somehow not shocking) that EEF has 5.56 Gold Dots now and also plans to buy .22 magnum Gold Dots later, when neither exists. :rofl:
UPDATE:
After typing that, I had a thought. When I double-checked the LAW ENFORCEMENT ONLY website, Speer DOES make a .22 WMR for Cops. And what do you know? They also make a .223 round for LAW ENFORCEMENT, but no 5.56.
I guess I should have realized he shops where the Cops shop. :geekdanc:
-
When you're issued free ammo, might as well use it at home, too.
BTW, Speer doesn't make a Gold Dot rifle bullet or cartridge in 5.56. And the smallest Gold Dot handgun caliber they offer is a hollow point .251 bullet -- no cartridge.
So, I find it odd (but somehow not shocking) that EEF has 5.56 Gold Dots now and also plans to buy .22 magnum Gold Dots later, when neither exists. :rofl:
UPDATE:
After typing that, I had a thought. When I double-checked the LAW ENFORCEMENT ONLY website, Speer DOES make a .22 WMR for Cops. And what do you know? They also make a .223 round for LAW ENFORCEMENT, but no 5.56.
I guess I should have realized he shops where the Cops shop. :geekdanc:
Both of those Gold dot 223 and 22 wmr are sold on the civilian market and can be bought easily online and in some stores on the mainland for sure. It might just be that no one locally stocks them normally.
-
Both of those Gold dot 223 and 22 wmr are sold on the civilian market and can be bought easily online and in some stores on the mainland for sure. It might just be that no one locally stocks them normally.
Okay, I was looking in the "Bullets" section. If you go to "Ammunition", there's a .22 WMR available. But, all the ammo listed is handgun calibers. No rifle ammunition other than SBR in .38 +P and .40S&W.
If you want the rifle ammo, it's still going to be in the LE series.
http://le.vistaoutdoor.com/ammunition/speer/rifle/default.aspx
-
About 2 years ago when i got my first AR, i went to KGS and inquired. I got 2 boxes of what Dan suggested. But i threw the boxes away, so i have no idea what brand they are.
Next trip to vegas, im gonna see if the LE gold dots 223 are available.
Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk
-
GD 223 Rem 62 gr is readily available locally. I think the 55 gr one as well. Last time I saw, I think they were around $17-18 per box of 20.
-
I also have some federal hst in 45acp
I hear hornady critical duty is good
https://youtu.be/ivQnspp_iFU
https://youtu.be/EOMxp7WGKNU
https://youtu.be/8PBPjYu_5ow
-
When you're issued free ammo, might as well use it at home, too.
BTW, Speer doesn't make a Gold Dot rifle bullet or cartridge in 5.56. And the smallest Gold Dot handgun caliber they offer is a hollow point .251 bullet -- no cartridge.
So, I find it odd (but somehow not shocking) that EEF has 5.56 Gold Dots now and also plans to buy .22 magnum Gold Dots later, when neither exists. :rofl:
UPDATE:
After typing that, I had a thought. When I double-checked the LAW ENFORCEMENT ONLY website, Speer DOES make a .22 WMR for Cops. And what do you know? They also make a .223 round for LAW ENFORCEMENT, but no 5.56.
I guess I should have realized he shops where the Cops shop. :geekdanc:
Yeah, because cops carry a lot of .22 WMR pistols :crazy:
BTW it is marketed for law enforcement, it isn't law enforcement only, anyone can buy them.
But I do credit you for retracting the statement you initially made out of ignorance. :thumbsup:
-
Yeah, because cops carry a lot of .22 WMR pistols :crazy:
BTW it is marketed for law enforcement, it isn't law enforcement only, anyone can buy them.
But I do credit you for retracting the statement you initially made out of ignorance. :thumbsup:
I wish I could give you credit for being gracious, but your insult ruined any points you earned.
I guess that's typical for you, huh?
-
I wish I could give you credit for being gracious, but your insult ruined any points you earned.
I guess that's typical for you, huh?
I reply in kind. Don't throw punches if you don't want me to throw them back.
-
I reply in kind. Don't throw punches if you don't want me to throw them back.
Glad you're holding yourself to that higher standard you pretend to believe in.
-
Glad you're holding yourself to that higher standard you pretend to believe in.
:wacko: :stopjack:
-
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q0M4qPSrc00
-
SNIP
Damn that round is pretty expensive. It would be cool to see how these perform against SWC loads. A friend made some ballistic gel and it's not cheap, so understand that it's expensive to do tests like these.
I only have FMJ for my .38 SPL revolver, but I had been looking around for defensive loads.
-
these XTP heads are a little cheaper
I just reloaded some in 44 and 45 over the weekend. going to test out how the feed in the 45
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J8y5p640m-o
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W5pWEU8qX7g
-
I don't use my pistol as my primary home defense firearm, but when it was, I opted for Federal HST 9mm 124gr.
These were hard to find on island, but Security Equipment Corp had them in 50 round boxes.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-lGqdMdbir0
-
https://youtu.be/Qw__ZHIXUeg
I thought the tests in this video was interesting. Pork ribs! ;D
He’s an admitted fan of GDs, but sounds like he’s done a bunch of testing on his own. I’m not saying that he’s an SME or should be trusted, but also interesting in that seems like he did his own research and testing. As a wise man once told me, “trust but verify”.
-
https://youtu.be/VZObknkfoq0
-
His gel is dirty as hell. But damn the HUGE diff between the 45 CD and the 9 CD.
-
I just reloaded some 230 grain 45acp XTP's this past weekend. expansion and penetration not as good as CD rounds, but still pretty good. expands to .657" and penetration 15.5"
bought a few boxes of XTP in 45, 44, and 357 bc they were on sale a while back
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Ct33tKvpKo
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MEQOiEPMJ9U
-
^^That vid was awesome. It showed the bullet stopping just at the end of the gel. I was waiting for a pop.
-
I just reloaded some 230 grain 45acp XTP's this past weekend. expansion and penetration not as good as CD rounds, but still pretty good. expands to .657" and penetration 15.5"
bought a few boxes of XTP in 45, 44, and 357 bc they were on sale a while back
I thought you loaded up some and did your own tests in ballistic gel. Good to see people do their own tests and share, but also better if you know the person doing the testing.
How about a 1911 9 mm vs 45 ACP challenge? ;D