2aHawaii

General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: drck1000 on July 24, 2019, 07:30:22 AM

Title: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: drck1000 on July 24, 2019, 07:30:22 AM
Listening on my way to work. Why need testimony to confirm statements in the report? Seems like D strategy is to try to insert their speculation and Miller seemed to not take the bait. Seems like R strategy is to dig further and Muller seems to be resisting. Overall, I think Muller is more at risk for tripping up than anything. I’m actually quite impressed at his responses to questions from both sides.

Overall, complete waste of time.
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: changemyoil66 on July 24, 2019, 09:05:26 AM
DNC strategy will be to pick on 1 phrase he says and run that story on the fake news for weeks.

The part that I saw was that he stated collusion and conspiracy are 2 different things.   But then called out that on page X, it says they are the same.  Then he says "go by the report". 

My TDS suffering coworker is watching it on her computer.  I want to add salt to the wound.
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 24, 2019, 09:55:20 AM
Dems are trying to get him to say the only reason Trump wasn't charged was the DOJ policy against charging a sitting president, and that the obstruction "evidence" he included in Vol 2 was enough to charge obstruction.

Without that, they've got nothing.

Republicans are beating him up over spending 2 years and $35M to investigate the Russian interference but stopped short of investigating any Russian involvement not potentially linked to the Trump campaign.  US citizens went to prison based on the investigation, but not one was charged with anything remotely related to Russian interference, collusion, conspiracy, or anything else.

The guy who started the entire dossier rumor which was the FBI used to start the investigation lied 3 times to the FBI as was stated in the Mueller report.  Yet, he was never charged with a crime, unlike Trump team members who went to prison for the exact same charges.  Mueller couldn't even remember that initial guy was named in the report until the (R) Senator Jim Jordon told him what page it was on.

Mueller is defending his work.  He's not answering questions.  He's said "I can't get into that" as a default position repeatedly even if the information is already in his report.  This hearing is a joke.
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: ren on July 24, 2019, 11:45:58 AM
there goes that buzz word "exoneration"
That is not the duty of the special counsel nor in a court.
In court there is guilty or not guilty. There is no innocent conclusion.
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: zippz on July 24, 2019, 12:11:07 PM
Hearing is a win for Trump and improves his chances for reelection a little.  Now he just has to learn when to shut up so he can win.

He needs a minder that follows him around and gives advice on if he should say or tweet things.  Put a shocking dog collar on Trump.  If Trump says something like

Trump "Think I'll tweet about kicking Omar out of the country"
Minder " that's not a good idea"
Trump "I'll do it anyways....". Bbzzzzzzttttt.
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: changemyoil66 on July 24, 2019, 01:07:07 PM
Hearing is a win for Trump and improves his chances for reelection a little.  Now he just has to learn when to shut up so he can win.

He needs a minder that follows him around and gives advice on if he should say or tweet things.  Put a shocking dog collar on Trump.  If Trump says something like

Trump "Think I'll tweet about kicking Omar out of the country"
Minder " that's not a good idea"
Trump "I'll do it anyways....". Bbzzzzzzttttt.

You're missing it.  That unfiltered statements is what people want to hear.  Many are tired of PC sugar coated answers or statements.  And remember, he never named who should leave the country.  The 4 moron took it upon themselves to out themselves that they're the ones that hate the nation that he's talking about.  Strategic plan if you ask me.  Got them to out themselves.

Example how he handled N. Korea.  "I got a bigger button and it works".  Months later, peace talks.  A year later, he strolls into N. Korea showing of his imaginary ball (meme).
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: changemyoil66 on July 24, 2019, 01:09:16 PM
KJU: wanna hold my imaginary ball? Its super cool.

Trump: yeah, youre right. Its super cool.

KJU: i want my ball back. (https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20190724/0566c4bba0b5e31f47ec5b01f39c2fe8.jpg)

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: zippz on July 24, 2019, 01:13:14 PM
You're missing it.  That unfiltered statements is what people want to hear.

Don't need votes from Trump supporters.  We need votes from the undecided and those in the middle who will decide the election.  Those people don't like the unfiltered messages.  Trump barely won the last time because a lot of people didn't vote or were strongly against Hillary.  That may not happen again.
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: changemyoil66 on July 24, 2019, 01:30:32 PM
Don't need votes from Trump supporters.  We need votes from the undecided and those in the middle who will decide the election.  Those people don't like the unfiltered messages.  Trump barely won the last time because a lot of people didn't vote or were strongly against Hillary.  That may not happen again.

I think he's more focused on the electoral votes.  Hope his results will sway those undecided for popular vote and the recent removal of illegal voters.  IIRC, 1 county in CA removed about 10,000 illegal voters who were registered to vote recently.  But I do think it's a losing battle because the DNC controls the media.  So he needs to keep up the strong counter attacks to maintain that strong, don't take crap from nobody persona.

My father only has access to the fake news and had no idea of the good things he has done.  But he's so brain washed by them, after laying it down, his response is "Trumps racist" or "Trumps in bed with Putin".
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: changemyoil66 on July 24, 2019, 01:58:19 PM
I would assume if he toned it down and changed his attitude, he might lose some of his base because it will look like "he's playing ball".
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 24, 2019, 07:51:09 PM
Don't need votes from Trump supporters.  We need votes from the undecided and those in the middle who will decide the election.  Those people don't like the unfiltered messages.  Trump barely won the last time because a lot of people didn't vote or were strongly against Hillary.  That may not happen again.

I think if the Dems put up another Hillary-level nominee in terms of personality or poor campaigning, the lack of Dem-voter-turnout will effectively be votes for Trump.  After 4 years of "Orange Man Bad", there's not much hope that platform will energize anyone.

Can't wait to see what "October surprises" the two parties spring on us over a year from now!  :rofl:

Then there's the Dem's tactic of "We hate you!  Vote for us!!" that pushed so many away from the party (and Hillary) in 2016:

https://youtu.be/YnHiJ9QW2yk
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 24, 2019, 10:11:30 PM
I have listened to most of the first hearing and here is the takeaway I have so far.

Both the dems and republicans are grandstanding a lot here. A lot of "questions" for Mueller they already know the answer to or are not really questions.
The democrats keep trying to get Mueller to say something they can use against the president.
The republicans are ranting about the investigation sometimes with no appreciation for the difficulty and nature of what Mueller was assigned to do. A couple we unnecessarily rude.

There were a few questions by republicans that did show issues with Mueller's report and investigation. One was about why the initial guy who reported falsely of a Russia-Trump partnership and why he wasn't prosecuted for lying to the FBI. There were a couple others about why this or that wasn't done. Now there may be perfectly good answers to some or all of those questions but Mueller didn't do much to address those. Some of the questions Mueller just declined to get into however certain question he stated that others within the FBI are investigating related aspect and directed them to those investigators.

As for Mueller, it wasn't his best showing. He appears to possibly be having a hearing problem. That combined with the quickly said run on questions made him seem to be lost at some points. He also spoke in a sort of old man voice which doesn't mean anything but for sure will be used against him. I will say that he still appeared to have his wits though. He was careful and deliberate in most of the things he said. He had to retract one statement afterwards which may be due to him not having caught the whole question originally. Overall I found him to be trustworthy. He didn't try to sink Trump and he didn't try to defend Trump despite having the power give the democrats or the republicans something big.

I will sympathize with the difficult job he was faced with though. The questioners had their questions preplanned and Mueller had to ask page numbers and sections so he could reference them while answering. And given the importance, the cope, and the size of the investigation he had to do it is hard to do it without someone finding some valid criticism. Just talking to the committee like he did is tough.

There was a bit of criticism over why Mueller would even make a statement about exoneration though in this specific circumstances I agree with Mueller's publicly doing so. There was some critique over why Mueller didn't present a yes or no finding which was odd because not all investigations are going to be a clear yes or no. They re-touched on the issue of the legal counsel guidelines that a sitting president cannot be indicted which has been covered already.

Bottom line we really didn't get much out of what I heard except for a few fair criticisms of Mueller's investigation.
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 24, 2019, 10:14:25 PM
Don't need votes from Trump supporters.  We need votes from the undecided and those in the middle who will decide the election.  Those people don't like the unfiltered messages.  Trump barely won the last time because a lot of people didn't vote or were strongly against Hillary.  That may not happen again.

Indeed. If Hillary and the DNC hadn't treated Bernie so bad they likely would have had enough of his supporters for for her to beat Trump. In some ways Trump got lucky there, he won because democrat infighting.
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 24, 2019, 10:19:43 PM
there goes that buzz word "exoneration"
That is not the duty of the special counsel nor in a court.
In court there is guilty or not guilty. There is no innocent conclusion.

There are times where an investigation can lead to an actual exoneration.

Say someone accused you of stealing their car at a certain time and location. Police investigate and find solid proof that you were somewhere else at that date and time. That would be an example of when someone could be deemed innocent and exonerated.

In this case it is practically impossible to fully exonerate Trump of the accusation due to the nature and scope of the alleged crime.
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 24, 2019, 11:16:33 PM
There are times where an investigation can lead to an actual exoneration.

Say someone accused you of stealing their car at a certain time and location. Police investigate and find solid proof that you were somewhere else at that date and time. That would be an example of when someone could be deemed innocent and exonerated.

In this case it is practically impossible to fully exonerate Trump of the accusation due to the nature and scope of the alleged crime.

Wrong.  There's a reason why courts only return verdicts of Guilty and Not Guilty.

They don't say "Innocent" or "Exonerated".  In fact, it's an age old smear tactic used by loser prosecutors when speaking to the press after losing.  "Not guilty" isn't the same as "Innocent."

As was highlighted in the hearing, you'll never find one single investigation that declares someone "exonerated".  It doesn't exist.

You can be ruled out as a suspect, but that doesn't PROVE INNOCENCE BEYOND A SHADOW OF A DOUBT.  In your hypothetical, people have been in two place at once, as has happened in the case of twins.  Someone identifies the twin as the thief, but you (the one arrested) actually did it.  You then use your twin's alibi, like video of him in another place, as evidence.

So, yeah, exonerating is not part of the judicial system, including investigations.  You're either charged, or you're not.  Suspects are quick to claim exoneration, but that's not accurate, even for Trump.

Mueller was wrong to ever make the statements about obstruction.  That's like the police and DA posting your investigation file online for all to see, even though you were never charged.  Just the dirt found in the investigation is enough to cast doubt on your character for most.  And you never had a chance to defend against the accusations on court.  Not a fair way to run a justice system.
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: punaperson on July 25, 2019, 10:21:38 AM
Nolte's take... pretty damn funny.

https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2019/07/25/nolte-robert-mueller-isnt-senile-he-was-a-dirty-cop-forced-to-take-the-witness-stand/

Robert Mueller Isn’t Senile; He Was a Dirty Cop Forced to Take the Witness Stand

They told us Robert Mueller was Captain America: Crusader for Truth, and instead we got George Costanza and all the inept deception, sweaty stalling, and blundering dishonesty that comes with him.
Special Counsel Robert Mueller’s bumbling, stumbling, grumbling, tumbling, crumbling testimony Wednesday before the U.S House of Representatives was not only karma on steroids, it once again proved just how  brilliant the American Constitution is.

You see, the sublime spectacle of watching Robert Mueller’s reputation go up in flames, flames ignited by his own corrupt report and fueled by three years of the establishment media’s hoax machinery, would not have been possible without the Separation of Powers, without the ability of one branch of government to hold the other in check,

Did you see what happened yesterday… Captain America is a partisan monster, a Resistance Vengeance Machine whose precious purview included nothing that matters — Christopher Steele: Not in my purview, bro. The FISA warrants to spy on a sitting president: Not on my purview, bro. Russia’s role in the Steele Dossier: You are totally harshing my purview, bro. Hillary Clinton and the DNC’s role in the Steele dossier: Why are you all up in my purview, bro?  The Obama administration’s unprecedented unmasking of Trump officials: Purview, bro. The FBI spying on a presidential campaign: Watch me purview, bro. James Comey’s leaks: I hardly know the man. Fusion GPS: What is this Fusion GPS you speak of?

Oh, but what is in Walter Mitty’s purview?

Paul Manafort’s taxes.

[Etc.]
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: drck1000 on July 25, 2019, 10:32:00 AM
What I want to see more of is getting into the questions about validity of evidence and how/why this went so far based on a lie. Like the War of 5 Kong’s wouldn’t have been started if they knew Rhaegar didn’t tape Lyanna  ;D
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: zippz on July 25, 2019, 11:36:55 AM
The problem with the investigation is it started off wrong.  Seems their starting point was Trump is certainly guilty and we have to find the evidence.  Instead of investigating Russian collusion with Trump as a possible suspect and working up the case to find out the truth.

They had a hard time finding evidence of Trump's guilt and when they couldn't find it, they kept digging for it and it's why the case took so long. At some point they must've realized that they weren't going to find anything but didn't want to be wrong, felt the pressure, and needed to justify all the time and money spent on the case so they kept digging hoping for a miracle.
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: changemyoil66 on July 25, 2019, 12:37:11 PM
There are times where an investigation can lead to an actual exoneration.

Say someone accused you of stealing their car at a certain time and location. Police investigate and find solid proof that you were somewhere else at that date and time. That would be an example of when someone could be deemed innocent and exonerated.

In this case it is practically impossible to fully exonerate Trump of the accusation due to the nature and scope of the alleged crime.

A senator did bring that up to Mueller.  In all his years of investigating, he has never mentioned exoneration in any of his reports. So why now?  Another senator brought a few thick books with him about the judicial system, law, and constitution and no where does it say a special consul has the power to exonerate anyone.

HPD's job isn't to prove innocents or guilt.  It's to gather evidence.  And in some cases, they even detain you while they collect said evidence.  Regarding your example, would HPD ever make a statement  that the X is innocent or exonerated?  Or will HPD just say "there's no evidence that supports X stole the car".
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 25, 2019, 10:13:29 PM
Wrong.  There's a reason why courts only return verdicts of Guilty and Not Guilty.

They don't say "Innocent" or "Exonerated".  In fact, it's an age old smear tactic used by loser prosecutors when speaking to the press after losing.  "Not guilty" isn't the same as "Innocent."

As was highlighted in the hearing, you'll never find one single investigation that declares someone "exonerated".  It doesn't exist.

You can be ruled out as a suspect, but that doesn't PROVE INNOCENCE BEYOND A SHADOW OF A DOUBT.  In your hypothetical, people have been in two place at once, as has happened in the case of twins.  Someone identifies the twin as the thief, but you (the one arrested) actually did it.  You then use your twin's alibi, like video of him in another place, as evidence.

So, yeah, exonerating is not part of the judicial system, including investigations.  You're either charged, or you're not.  Suspects are quick to claim exoneration, but that's not accurate, even for Trump.

Mueller was wrong to ever make the statements about obstruction.  That's like the police and DA posting your investigation file online for all to see, even though you were never charged.  Just the dirt found in the investigation is enough to cast doubt on your character for most.  And you never had a chance to defend against the accusations on court.  Not a fair way to run a justice system.


Notice that in my comment I said a police investigation could find you innocent, I didn't mention a jury.

Yes it is not of the same legal status as a juries decision but it is possible the an investigation could be said to prove someone innocent under certain situations.

Normally I would agree about Mueller's statements but this isn't just anyone, this is the president who sits beyond the reach of the federal justice system. It is a unique situation with a unique dynamic. To say its not fair because Trump was never charged is misleading because Mueller didn't have the ability to charge Trump. He was between a rock and a hard place and I think he did the best thing he could. Present the findings and let congress do their thing and voters do their thing.
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 25, 2019, 10:17:54 PM
Nolte's take... pretty damn funny.

https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2019/07/25/nolte-robert-mueller-isnt-senile-he-was-a-dirty-cop-forced-to-take-the-witness-stand/

Robert Mueller Isn’t Senile; He Was a Dirty Cop Forced to Take the Witness Stand

They told us Robert Mueller was Captain America: Crusader for Truth, and instead we got George Costanza and all the inept deception, sweaty stalling, and blundering dishonesty that comes with him.
Special Counsel Robert Mueller’s bumbling, stumbling, grumbling, tumbling, crumbling testimony Wednesday before the U.S House of Representatives was not only karma on steroids, it once again proved just how  brilliant the American Constitution is.

You see, the sublime spectacle of watching Robert Mueller’s reputation go up in flames, flames ignited by his own corrupt report and fueled by three years of the establishment media’s hoax machinery, would not have been possible without the Separation of Powers, without the ability of one branch of government to hold the other in check,

Did you see what happened yesterday… Captain America is a partisan monster, a Resistance Vengeance Machine whose precious purview included nothing that matters — Christopher Steele: Not in my purview, bro. The FISA warrants to spy on a sitting president: Not on my purview, bro. Russia’s role in the Steele Dossier: You are totally harshing my purview, bro. Hillary Clinton and the DNC’s role in the Steele dossier: Why are you all up in my purview, bro?  The Obama administration’s unprecedented unmasking of Trump officials: Purview, bro. The FBI spying on a presidential campaign: Watch me purview, bro. James Comey’s leaks: I hardly know the man. Fusion GPS: What is this Fusion GPS you speak of?

Oh, but what is in Walter Mitty’s purview?

Paul Manafort’s taxes.

[Etc.]

Funny but stupid. There is no real evidence that Mueller was dirty or biased. At best a few circumstantial bits that would prompt fair questions but that's about it.

If Mueller was dirty and against Trump he would have found a way to sink Trump. Democrats wanted him to but he didn't even give them a bone, claims of him being dirty are stupidly empty.
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 25, 2019, 10:30:10 PM
A senator did bring that up to Mueller.  In all his years of investigating, he has never mentioned exoneration in any of his reports. So why now?  Another senator brought a few thick books with him about the judicial system, law, and constitution and no where does it say a special consul has the power to exonerate anyone.

HPD's job isn't to prove innocents or guilt.  It's to gather evidence.  And in some cases, they even detain you while they collect said evidence.  Regarding your example, would HPD ever make a statement  that the X is innocent or exonerated?  Or will HPD just say "there's no evidence that supports X stole the car".

When it comes to police comments I have seen so many in news interviews. They might say the investigation cleared the accused, they might say the complaint was unfounded, they might say the accused was innocent, etc. I don't think their statements on such things follow any legal guideline or represent a legal status. Of course some of it would depend on the nature of the investigation where something accusations could never be disproven but others could be disproven.

Here is how I see Mueller's statement about exoneration.
#1 Trump publicly claimed he was exonerated which kind of prompts everyone to look back at Mueller and want to know if it is true
#2 Mueller probably knew that he would be called to testify to his findings and the question would come up anyway
#3 I think Mueller knows that the average person does not understand criminal legalize and might misunderstand his findings
#4 Mueller probably knew that the news would spin it in all different ways so to avoid that go straight to clearing up the question about exoneration so pundits couldn't put as much spin.
#5 This isn't your average accused individual so ideas about what is normal don't always work well.

That is my theory about why Mueller made the statement he did.


Now I could be wrong but I have a hunch that if a victim called up a prosecutor who wasn't filing charges against the accused and they asked the prosecutor whether the accused was exonerated the prosecutor would likely answer that the accused was not exonerated. Any prosecutors on 2A?
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 25, 2019, 10:34:56 PM
The problem with the investigation is it started off wrong.  Seems their starting point was Trump is certainly guilty and we have to find the evidence.  Instead of investigating Russian collusion with Trump as a possible suspect and working up the case to find out the truth.

They had a hard time finding evidence of Trump's guilt and when they couldn't find it, they kept digging for it and it's why the case took so long. At some point they must've realized that they weren't going to find anything but didn't want to be wrong, felt the pressure, and needed to justify all the time and money spent on the case so they kept digging hoping for a miracle.

I think the counter point to that is that the nature of the accusation is so serious and the accused in such a high position that they would want to be very thorough. Imagine they hadn't dug deep and something came up years later, everyone would look back and lament at what a terrible investigation they did.
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 25, 2019, 10:51:00 PM

Notice that in my comment I said a police investigation could find you innocent, I didn't mention a jury.

Yes it is not of the same legal status as a juries decision but it is possible the an investigation could be said to prove someone innocent under certain situations.

Normally I would agree about Mueller's statements but this isn't just anyone, this is the president who sits beyond the reach of the federal justice system. It is a unique situation with a unique dynamic. To say its not fair because Trump was never charged is misleading because Mueller didn't have the ability to charge Trump. He was between a rock and a hard place and I think he did the best thing he could. Present the findings and let congress do their thing and voters do their thing.

Mueller had the ability to state whether the President committed a crime.  Mueller never said that.  He signed a report his staff wrote that smeared Trump by listing things he did that they decided isn't criminal.

Mueller was a figurehead.  His anti-Trump/Pro-Hillary staff of 14 Democrat lawyers did all the work and drafted the report.  Vol 2 was their consolation prize to the Dems in Congress, so they have something to continue the witch hunt.  Vol 2 never should have existed.  They focused 100% on the Trump team investigating tax returns and taxi medallions, but not one word of their investigation into the actions that the FBI counter-intelligence investigation was predicated on.

Mueller was tasked to perform a counter-intelligence investigation into Russian election interference and possible US citizen involvement.

Mueller turned it into a criminal investigation.  The things they chose to not investigate would have been the first things an intelligence officer would have looked into, such as who first reported the collusion? Why was the Steele Dossier used to secure the FISA warrants if they were unverified? Why was Mueller not worried about bias in the Special Counsel's office even after the FBI started firing one Trump-hater after another?  Surely he should have worried that any accusations of bias would bring into question any negative findings.

Mueller should have never been appointed Special Counsel. He obviously has outlived his ability to actually run a competent investigation.
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: macsak on July 26, 2019, 03:20:08 PM
Any prosecutors on 2A?

it's quite obvious that you don't see the irony of you asking someone to admit on the forum that they are a prosecutor...
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 26, 2019, 03:46:59 PM
Mueller, regarding the Steele Dossier:  That part of the investigation predated me, by at least 10 months.

So, if there had been any election interference, it would have also been before Mueller was appointed.

Mueller proved one thing:  He was not running the investigation, nor did he draft that report.

Need to change the name from "The Mueller Report" to "Office of Special Counsel's Staff Report on their efforts to get Trump."
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: changemyoil66 on July 26, 2019, 10:42:30 PM
Sir what is your name?

Mueller : what page arw you referring to?

The cover sir

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 26, 2019, 11:07:51 PM
Mueller had the ability to state whether the President committed a crime.  Mueller never said that.  He signed a report his staff wrote that smeared Trump by listing things he did that they decided isn't criminal.

Mueller was a figurehead.  His anti-Trump/Pro-Hillary staff of 14 Democrat lawyers did all the work and drafted the report.  Vol 2 was their consolation prize to the Dems in Congress, so they have something to continue the witch hunt.  Vol 2 never should have existed.  They focused 100% on the Trump team investigating tax returns and taxi medallions, but not one word of their investigation into the actions that the FBI counter-intelligence investigation was predicated on.

Mueller was tasked to perform a counter-intelligence investigation into Russian election interference and possible US citizen involvement.

Mueller turned it into a criminal investigation.  The things they chose to not investigate would have been the first things an intelligence officer would have looked into, such as who first reported the collusion? Why was the Steele Dossier used to secure the FISA warrants if they were unverified? Why was Mueller not worried about bias in the Special Counsel's office even after the FBI started firing one Trump-hater after another?  Surely he should have worried that any accusations of bias would bring into question any negative findings.

Mueller should have never been appointed Special Counsel. He obviously has outlived his ability to actually run a competent investigation.

Mueller could have come out and said Trump committed a crime but as others have pointed out it wouldn't be fair to say he committed a crime when he doesn't have the ability to charge him with a crime. He presented the findings and left it up for congress to decide what to do with it. That is the best way to keep his hands clean.

What evidence is there that Mueller's whole team was anti-Trump/pro-Hillary? Yeah you had three people who were found making comments which rightly got them removed from their position but that doesn't mean his whole team was biased.

The FISA warrants were issued before Mueller was appointed to investigate. I don't know why Mueller didn't go back and investigate the Steel dossier more. That is a fair criticism in my opinion and maybe there is even a good answer to it, but I don't know. Mueller was tasked with investigating Russian involvement with anyone in the Trump campaign and was authorized to prosecute any criminal violations arising out of the investigation.

The complaints about Mueller just don't make sense. He is somehow a Trump hater who was only investigating crimes by Trump and his buddies yet in the end he didn't say Trump committed a crime. He didn't even give the democrats a bone when he could have said all manner of things to try and hurt Trump.
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: drck1000 on July 28, 2019, 07:59:30 AM
The plot thickens

https://www.foxnews.com/politics/papadopoulos-heads-to-greece-to-retrieve-10k-in-safe-as-senate-investigators-request-bills
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 28, 2019, 10:34:28 AM
Mueller could have come out and said Trump committed a crime but as others have pointed out it wouldn't be fair to say he committed a crime when he doesn't have the ability to charge him with a crime. He presented the findings and left it up for congress to decide what to do with it. That is the best way to keep his hands clean.

What evidence is there that Mueller's whole team was anti-Trump/pro-Hillary? Yeah you had three people who were found making comments which rightly got them removed from their position but that doesn't mean his whole team was biased.

The FISA warrants were issued before Mueller was appointed to investigate. I don't know why Mueller didn't go back and investigate the Steel dossier more. That is a fair criticism in my opinion and maybe there is even a good answer to it, but I don't know. Mueller was tasked with investigating Russian involvement with anyone in the Trump campaign and was authorized to prosecute any criminal violations arising out of the investigation.

The complaints about Mueller just don't make sense. He is somehow a Trump hater who was only investigating crimes by Trump and his buddies yet in the end he didn't say Trump committed a crime. He didn't even give the democrats a bone when he could have said all manner of things to try and hurt Trump.

Your argument is inconsistent.  Why even have a Special Counsel investigation if the inability to charge Trump with any crime also made it "unfair" to state whether or not Trump committed acts that satisfied the elements of a crime?

Mueller stated there was no evidence to support the accusation that Trump nor anyone related to his family or campaign, committed collusion or conspiracy with anyone from Russia with efforts to interfere in the 2016 election , BUT, when it came to obstruction, the rules were different?  If Mueller can't charge Trump with a crime, he could have very easily charged ANYONE ELSE who helped Trump obstruct the investigation.

Mueller stated point-blank that his investigation was NOT OBSTRUCTED.  But, that somehow doesn't mean Trump didn't commit the crime of obstruction?  Are you serious?

The entire investigation was predicated on a HOAX, yet Mueller purportedly didn't investigate the underlying facts that started the alleged crimes?


As for Mueller's team, this is the MOST POLITICAL INVESTIGATION IN US HISTORY, but political biases weren't even discussed among the DEMOCRATS hired to run it? LOL!!

https://youtu.be/FsPsfrkZxiE


No power to "exonerate":

https://youtu.be/VijjacEjSkI


DOJ OLC opinion on indicting a sitting president:

https://youtu.be/Y6CYXdspaBY


Legal analysis on obstruction during hearing:

https://youtu.be/N7FQwToqIT8


Biased investigation:

https://youtu.be/m1nV30JSUyc
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 28, 2019, 10:00:53 PM
Your argument is inconsistent.  Why even have a Special Counsel investigation if the inability to charge Trump with any crime also made it "unfair" to state whether or not Trump committed acts that satisfied the elements of a crime?

Mueller stated there was no evidence to support the accusation that Trump nor anyone related to his family or campaign, committed collusion or conspiracy with anyone from Russia with efforts to interfere in the 2016 election , BUT, when it came to obstruction, the rules were different?  If Mueller can't charge Trump with a crime, he could have very easily charged ANYONE ELSE who helped Trump obstruct the investigation.

Mueller stated point-blank that his investigation was NOT OBSTRUCTED.  But, that somehow doesn't mean Trump didn't commit the crime of obstruction?  Are you serious?

The entire investigation was predicated on a HOAX, yet Mueller purportedly didn't investigate the underlying facts that started the alleged crimes?

The way I see it Mueller was screwed no matter what he did. If he said Trump should be charged with a crime he would get criticized by one side. If he said Trump should not be charged with a crime he would get criticized by the other side. I think the smartest thing he could do is just investigate and present the findings to congress and let them decide what to do with the findings.

As for the obstruction you are right, Mueller could have charged anyone else however there wasn't really evidence that anyone else did anything. The whole argument for an obstruction charge is based entirely on Trump's comments and actions so I don't think there was anyone else to look at there. The fact that Mueller's investigation was never obstructed does not mean that no one attempted to obstruct. One does not have to be successful in obstructing an investigation to have violated the law. Thats why people can be charged with attempted crimes like attempted murder, attempted theft, attempted obstruction, etc.

Now correct me if I am wrong but Mueller never said there was no evidence, he just said there was not sufficient evidence to charge anyone with conspiracy. (colluding with Russia)

I think it is a fair question to ask why Mueller didn't focus more on the legitimacy of the report that started it all. Maybe there was enough evidence that could have led him to report back there is insufficient evidence to warrant an investigation but on the other hand if there remained a reasonable possibility that the allegation was true then I think, in this case, it is better to be safe than sorry. Take a rape case for example, there is rarely any proof that a rape actually happened, only an allegation but police still investigate it as if it were true. This may have been what Mueller was doing but its hard to know for sure since we didn't get an explanation out of him as far as I understand. Like I said, it is a fair question.
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 28, 2019, 11:30:17 PM
The way I see it Mueller was screwed no matter what he did. If he said Trump should be charged with a crime he would get criticized by one side. If he said Trump should not be charged with a crime he would get criticized by the other side. I think the smartest thing he could do is just investigate and present the findings to congress and let them decide what to do with the findings.

** Wrong.  The Special Counsel's duty was to the Attorney General, not Congress.  He was mandated to submit a CONFIDENTIAL REPORT TO THE USAG.  Period.  He did that, and Barr made the decision to make it public.  Congress is not part of the executive branch.  If they wanted to run things, they could have (and should have) formed a bi-partisan committee to do it, instead of letting the FBI investigate their own hoax.

As for the obstruction you are right, Mueller could have charged anyone else however there wasn't really evidence that anyone else did anything. The whole argument for an obstruction charge is based entirely on Trump's comments and actions so I don't think there was anyone else to look at there. The fact that Mueller's investigation was never obstructed does not mean that no one attempted to obstruct. One does not have to be successful in obstructing an investigation to have violated the law. Thats why people can be charged with attempted crimes like attempted murder, attempted theft, attempted obstruction, etc.

Now correct me if I am wrong but Mueller never said there was no evidence, he just said there was not sufficient evidence to charge anyone with conspiracy. (colluding with Russia).

** You're wrong.  Mueller said a lot of things, then contradicted himself, both verbally and in the report itself which was obviously drafted by someone other than Mueller.  You're trying to split hairs, as if actions alone that MIGHT BECOME evidence is actual evidence when it can't be -- by definition.

The presumption of innocence requires evidence to establish all elements of a crime in order to charge the subject with that crime.  If Mueller finds 1, 2, or 3 elements, but no evidence of the 4th required element, it's as iff the first 3 do not exist, because without ALL the evidence of a crime, there WAS NO CRIME.  Taken separately, they are evidence of nothing more than the individual acts themselves.

Analogy:  I look in your fridge and cabinets and find butter, eggs, vanilla extract, sugar, baking powder, salt and buttermilk. All you're missing to make a tasty vanilla cake is flour. Can I call what you have a cake?  No.  Can I call those items cake ingredients?  No, not until they are mixed together and baked(assuming flour is added) or you tell me you intend to use them to make a cake.  (Most people intending to commit a crime don't give investigators the courtesy of stating their intentions.) You call them what they are -- individual items that MAY be used for any variety of things, including a cake.  But, without the flour, you'll never be able to call it a cake -- ever.

The cake (obstruction) never existed.  Therefore, there can be no ingredients (evidence) of it.


I think it is a fair question to ask why Mueller didn't focus more on the legitimacy of the report that started it all. Maybe there was enough evidence that could have led him to report back there is insufficient evidence to warrant an investigation but on the other hand if there remained a reasonable possibility that the allegation was true then I think, in this case, it is better to be safe than sorry. Take a rape case for example, there is rarely any proof that a rape actually happened, only an allegation but police still investigate it as if it were true. This may have been what Mueller was doing but its hard to know for sure since we didn't get an explanation out of him as far as I understand. Like I said, it is a fair question.

** He was on a witch hunt, plain and simple.  It was an obstruction trap.  The Dems hoped (believed) Trump would fall into the Nixon hole of obstruction and be impeached.  The big difference:  Nixon actually obstructed the investigation by having a portion of a tape (evidence) erased.  The assumption is that part of the tape was evidence of Nixon's knowledge of the break-in. 

Trump never colluded, conspired or coordinated with the Russians to interfere with the election.  There was no evidence to destroy.  There was no crime to cover up.  Trump knew the only crime the Dems could use is if he obstructed the investigation.

Most of the "acts" Mueller included in Vol II were lawful, Constitutional acts the President can perform, such as firing Comey and Mueller.  After the FBI IG investigation, it was Rosenstein who actually recommended Comey's firing.  And if Mueller was fired, the Special Counsel and its task would continue on under another appointee.  There is no way Trump could obstruct by firing Mueller.  The only way would be to tell the USAG to stop the investigation completely.  Never happened.

Volume II was a political smear job created by Dem loyalists on Mueller's team.  it never should have been created.


Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: changemyoil66 on July 29, 2019, 10:13:01 AM
Don't forget that Barr made the report unredacted and available to all members of congress, but to be kept and read only at a secure location.  Only 2 DNC congressmen showed up.  Maybe if the others read the report, then we wouldn't need Mueller's testimony.

Reminds me when your mom does your book report for you and then the teacher ask you questions about the book.
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 29, 2019, 01:25:55 PM
Don't forget that Barr made the report unredacted and available to all members of congress, but to be kept and read only at a secure location.  Only 2 DNC congressmen showed up.  Maybe if the others read the report, then we wouldn't need Mueller's testimony.

Reminds me when your mom does your book report for you and then the teacher ask you questions about the book.

I seriously believe Mueller was past time for retirement.  He should have never been appointed SC.  i think he was selected because Comey knew he could be easily manipulated by his team, and the team could be stacked with Clinton supporters and Trump haters.

Mueller may have been sharp in his younger years, but the performance he gave at the hearings was just sad.  I half expected to see a nurse interrupt to give him his meds.  Either he's in the beginning stages of dementia, or he's in need of a hearing aid and too narcissistic to wear it.
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 29, 2019, 09:46:35 PM
** Wrong.  The Special Counsel's duty was to the Attorney General, not Congress.  He was mandated to submit a CONFIDENTIAL REPORT TO THE USAG.  Period.  He did that, and Barr made the decision to make it public.  Congress is not part of the executive branch.  If they wanted to run things, they could have (and should have) formed a bi-partisan committee to do it, instead of letting the FBI investigate their own hoax.

That doesn't disprove anything I said. He did what he was supposed to. Congress called him to testify and he did. You are attacking Mueller for the actions of congress.


Quote
** You're wrong.  Mueller said a lot of things, then contradicted himself, both verbally and in the report itself which was obviously drafted by someone other than Mueller.  You're trying to split hairs, as if actions alone that MIGHT BECOME evidence is actual evidence when it can't be -- by definition.

Just because you claim someone wrong doesn't make it so. You are the one splitting hairs. You are obviously looking at the report and the testimony with a desired outcome. Your assessment is anything but objective. Yes Mueller misspoke a few times, he even came back and corrected a comment. You clearly are trying to ignore that attempted crimes are real still real crimes.  Outside of a few bits Mueller was consistent and careful in his comments. At least a few of the comments he made that raises issues may be due to hearing issues. Both sides came at him asking questions they already knew the answer to and grandstanding. Mueller was smart in referring to his report so heavily so they couldn't try to trip him up. Its clear that is what the democrats and republicans were trying to do.


Quote
The presumption of innocence requires evidence to establish all elements of a crime in order to charge the subject with that crime.  If Mueller finds 1, 2, or 3 elements, but no evidence of the 4th required element, it's as iff the first 3 do not exist, because without ALL the evidence of a crime, there WAS NO CRIME.  Taken separately, they are evidence of nothing more than the individual acts themselves.

Analogy:  I look in your fridge and cabinets and find butter, eggs, vanilla extract, sugar, baking powder, salt and buttermilk. All you're missing to make a tasty vanilla cake is flour. Can I call what you have a cake?  No.  Can I call those items cake ingredients?  No, not until they are mixed together and baked(assuming flour is added) or you tell me you intend to use them to make a cake.  (Most people intending to commit a crime don't give investigators the courtesy of stating their intentions.) You call them what they are -- individual items that MAY be used for any variety of things, including a cake.  But, without the flour, you'll never be able to call it a cake -- ever.
The cake (obstruction) never existed.  Therefore, there can be no ingredients (evidence) of it.

And what ingredient (element) do you say is missing in obstruction? You are assuming an element is missing just because Mueller didn't come out and say Trump committed obstruction.



Quote
** He was on a witch hunt, plain and simple.  It was an obstruction trap.  The Dems hoped (believed) Trump would fall into the Nixon hole of obstruction and be impeached.  The big difference:  Nixon actually obstructed the investigation by having a portion of a tape (evidence) erased.  The assumption is that part of the tape was evidence of Nixon's knowledge of the break-in. 

There is no proof it was a witch hunt. Mueller didn't give the democrats a single bone and made them look foolish yet somehow you are still determined to attack Mueller. Why? because he didn't defend Trump strong enough?


Quote
Trump never colluded, conspired or coordinated with the Russians to interfere with the election.  There was no evidence to destroy.  There was no crime to cover up.  Trump knew the only crime the Dems could use is if he obstructed the investigation.

How do you know that? Did you manage to prove a negative? I will point out that Mueller never said there was no evidence, only that there was insufficient evidence. See again, you are reading into it desiring a certain outcome.


Quote
Most of the "acts" Mueller included in Vol II were lawful, Constitutional acts the President can perform, such as firing Comey and Mueller.  After the FBI IG investigation, it was Rosenstein who actually recommended Comey's firing.  And if Mueller was fired, the Special Counsel and its task would continue on under another appointee.  There is no way Trump could obstruct by firing Mueller.  The only way would be to tell the USAG to stop the investigation completely.  Never happened.
Volume II was a political smear job created by Dem loyalists on Mueller's team.  it never should have been created.

It would have never even became an issue if Trump didn't make the stupid comments he made, but be ready to have your mind blown... I actually agree that I don't think there is enough evidence to convict Trump of collusion. He was either smart enough or lucky enough that his comments managed to walk a fine line of gray area.
Again, if it were a witch hunt Mueller's testimony would have clearly been different. What guy holds a 2 year investigation to frame Trump and comes out of it not giving the democrats all the ammo they want? Mueller could have said something to sink Trump, to ensure he didn't get a second election but he didn't.
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: ren on July 29, 2019, 10:01:00 PM
Meuller was a racist.
Title: Re: Muller Testimony to House Committee
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 30, 2019, 02:29:39 AM
Mueller was smart in referring to his report so heavily so they couldn't try to trip him up.

Smart?  More like dependent.  It apparently wasn't very hard to trip him up.   :rofl:

https://youtu.be/C65RZZzM4As