2aHawaii

General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: zippz on February 26, 2020, 02:34:24 PM

Title: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: zippz on February 26, 2020, 02:34:24 PM
HPD had a press conference today to gain support for the gun control bills tomorrow, using the deaths of their two officers to push their agenda.  Backed up by legislators Rhoads, Lee, and Takayama.

They never did something like this before and are in panic mode.  Your efforts are paying off.

Currently only on FB, check the Hawaii news now website later.
www.facebook.com/KITV4/videos/995359614199497/
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: zippz on February 26, 2020, 02:36:13 PM
Here are things you can do.  NOTE you must submit testimony even if you submitted in the past prior to Feb 21st.

1.  Submit testimony our our website today https://hifico.org/224jud/
2.  Submit through the NRA link:. https://www.nraila.org/articles/20200225/hawaii-house-to-vote-on-anti-gun-bills
3.  Come out to the Senate JDC vote hearing tomorrow if you're free at 930am capitol basement room 016.
4.  Call your district representative and senator.  Voice your support for gun rights.  https://hifico.org/districtmaps/
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: stangzilla on February 26, 2020, 04:00:22 PM
police are there to enforce the law , not lobby to change laws.
shame on HPD and the stupid Chief of police for being politicians

not once did HPD tell the public that they have the right to defend themselves in their home or at their place of business with deadly force if necessary.  the only thing that they say is "call 911" 
911 is a joke!!!
you need something to protect yourself until 911 arrives.

thank you HIFICO for all you do!   :shaka:
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: ren on February 26, 2020, 06:02:28 PM
Our tax dollars hard at work in eroding our rights...
https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2020/02/27/police-chief-makes-public-plea-lawmakers-ahead-votes-tougher-gun-control-measures/ (https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2020/02/27/police-chief-makes-public-plea-lawmakers-ahead-votes-tougher-gun-control-measures/)



He may have illegally obtained the rifle and ammunition from a gun collection possibly owned by Cain’s husband, who died in 2005.

One of the bills being considered close that loophole.
   :crazy:

Something that is already illegal ("Jerry Hanel MAY have illegally obtained") is considered a "loophole"? And everything is speculation since all the evidence was destroyed in the fire.

“When a gun owner dies that estate doesn’t close until the police certify that the firearms in that estate have been properly transferred or disposed of,” explained Representative Gregg Takayama, Chair of the Public Safety Committee.

Private property is PRIVATE.

Gregg Takayama, Chris Lee and Karl "Toadie" Rhoads don't represent the People anymore...nor does HPD Chief Susan Ballard. All they want is to turn us all into victims so we can rely more on government.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: oldfart on February 27, 2020, 01:50:49 AM
Private property is private!

This should set off all kinds of alarms for everyone.
What I have in my estate is none of hpd's business.
I doesn't matter if it's a gun, knife, or dirty underwear.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: punaperson on February 27, 2020, 08:30:49 AM
Private property is private!

This should set off all kinds of alarms for everyone.
What I have in my estate is none of hpd's business.
I doesn't matter if it's a gun, knife, or dirty underwear.
Dude, THERE IS NO SUCH THING as "private property" in communism (currently frequently and lyingly referred to as "democratic socialism").

Guns are just the first item to be subject to confiscation for "the greater good". If the inherent racism, income inequality, social injustice, etc. are to be rooted out of the inherently corrupt free market capitalist system all objects must be subject to total control/confiscation/elimination by our betters/comrades. Earth and people-destroying things such as cars, factories, etc. that depend on fossil fuels must be eliminated, etc. And... you think that's your money?
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: 25actual on February 27, 2020, 08:58:33 AM
I heard a rumor that the two officers at the diamond head incident were killed by an 2-shot elephant rifle. So how is a magazine ban relevant to that case. :wtf:
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: groveler on February 27, 2020, 11:59:21 AM
I heard a rumor that the two officers at the diamond head incident were killed by an 2-shot elephant rifle. So how is a magazine ban relevant to that case. :wtf:
Interesting. 
Most Holland and Holland rifles start around  $12,000 and go up from there; and the ammo is $10 to $40 each shot.
Holland and Holland are the only two barrel rifles that come to mind.
A Barrett Light 50 is only ~$6500 and $5 per shot, in Semi Auto.
A horrible waste of guns to give to the HPD.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: tillamook on February 27, 2020, 04:16:50 PM
Any bets on the mag ban for next year?  I say 5 rounds.   
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: punaperson on February 27, 2020, 05:13:55 PM
Any bets on the mag ban for next year?  I say 5 rounds.
I'm just guessing, of course, but they might put a serious effort into banning "assault weapons", because... they are battlefield weapons of war that have no place on our streets nor in civilian hands.

But... given that they are all liars and ignoramuses, I wouldn't be surprised by anything they come up with to fuck us over even more than they have already. They won't rest until we've all been disappeared or assigned to re-education camps. That's what they do. See: Stalin, Hitler, Mao, Pol Pot, Castro, etc.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: hvybarrels on February 27, 2020, 08:53:11 PM
Why is HPD acting like a wing of the legislative branch? Not only are they writing bills but they are running press conferences with law makers and rolling twenty deep in black limos to hearings wearing full uniform. Did they take time off the clock to work on activism for the past couple of days? What would happen if some rogue HPD officers showed up and supported concealed carry wearing their uniforms and on duty? How would that affect their careers?

These and more valid questions were brought up today.

It seems like we have clearly stepped into impropriety territory and if there are restrictions for non-profits engaging in political activity then it definitely seems like there should be limits for unelected socialist institutions.

We need a real Sheriffs Department. This Homeland Security gestapo crap has gone too far.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: zippz on February 28, 2020, 12:16:43 AM
What would happen if some rogue HPD officers showed up and supported concealed carry wearing their uniforms and on duty? How would that affect their careers?

Interesting, perhaps a question to be asked before the police commission....
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: stangzilla on February 28, 2020, 03:44:59 PM
(https://reformedmusings.files.wordpress.com/2013/02/guns-didnt-kill-6-million.jpg?w=500&h=650)
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: robtmc on February 28, 2020, 04:04:47 PM
A horrible waste of guns to give to the HPD.
I would bet some large $$ that those guns go into some cop's collection as soon as the heat dies down.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: stangzilla on February 28, 2020, 04:17:24 PM
I would bet some large $$ that those guns go into some cop's collection as soon as the heat dies down.

"the firearms were destroyed in the fire"  is what they will say
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: eyeeatingfish on February 28, 2020, 08:35:03 PM
police are there to enforce the law , not lobby to change laws.
shame on HPD and the stupid Chief of police for being politicians

They probably have to do whatever they are told to do by the Mayor. Lots of government departments will put input or request laws be made or altered.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: eyeeatingfish on February 28, 2020, 08:41:08 PM
What would happen if some rogue HPD officers showed up and supported concealed carry wearing their uniforms and on duty? How would that affect their careers?

There is probably some internal policy that prevents individual officers from speaking on behalf of the department so the officers could get disciplined. If they came on their own time and explained that their opinions are their own and not representative of the department then they could not be disciplined because they have the right to free speech.

I wonder what would happen if they publicly stated they could not, or would hesitate, to support a particular firearm law because they believed it may be unconstitutional? That would be a little different situation where they could say something publicly and have a defense
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on February 28, 2020, 08:42:31 PM
They probably have to do whatever they are told to do by the Mayor. Lots of government departments will put input or request laws be made or altered.

Yet, those other "government departments" aren't enforcing the laws they push to be enacted on the public at large while enjoying exemptions for themselves.  Are the Cops really convinced (with no evidence) that these laws reduce crime, or are they merely trying to make sure they are more well armed than "We, the people?"
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: Heavies on February 28, 2020, 09:16:28 PM
If police department "brass" are going to act like politicians, perhaps they should be elected and serve in cycles like politicians.  (WITH TERM LIMITS!)
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: ren on February 28, 2020, 09:25:41 PM
If police department "brass" are going to act like politicians, perhaps they should be elected and serve in cycles like politicians.  (WITH TERM LIMITS!)

Can we suggest a bill for that?
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: bingbong on February 29, 2020, 10:28:52 AM
Yes, even the tyrannical have 1A rights.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: changemyoil66 on February 29, 2020, 11:26:17 AM
There is probably some internal policy that prevents individual officers from speaking on behalf of the department so the officers could get disciplined. If they came on their own time and explained that their opinions are their own and not representative of the department then they could not be disciplined because they have the right to free speech.

I wonder what would happen if they publicly stated they could not, or would hesitate, to support a particular firearm law because they believed it may be unconstitutional? That would be a little different situation where they could say something publicly and have a defense
HPD or any officer would never state they will not enforce any unconstitutional laws. We live in a police state.

See current laws as an example. And the excused used that will help them sleep better at night will be "im just following orders".

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: eyeeatingfish on February 29, 2020, 10:22:16 PM
HPD or any officer would never state they will not enforce any unconstitutional laws. We live in a police state.

I wouldn't put money on that bet.

Quote
See current laws as an example. And the excused used that will help them sleep better at night will be "im just following orders".

Or they don't believe them to be unconstitutional.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: 6716J on March 01, 2020, 09:00:02 AM
HPD or any officer would never state they will not enforce any unconstitutional laws. We live in a police state.

See current laws as an example. And the excused used that will help them sleep better at night will be "im just following orders".

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

I wouldn't put money on that bet.

Or they don't believe them to be unconstitutional.

Based on how they act, they will follow the orders and not stand up for the peoples rights and the Constitution. How many HPD officers showed up to hearings in uniform to speak against the proposed laws? Oh yeah...none. Are they afraid of being fired or other disciplinary actions? It's why they have SHOPO and the citizens review board to ensure officers aren't punished punitively for doing the right thing.

Can any HPD officer in this forum state for the record in the same sentence that they are HPD and will defend OUR rights as written in both the US and Hi Constitution? That they won't enforce the Red Flag law? That they believe in open or concealed carry?

How about just carry 10 round magazines like us little people are forced to? You know, in a show of solidarity. I won't hold my breath.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 01, 2020, 09:26:10 AM
I wouldn't put money on that bet.

Or they don't believe them to be unconstitutional.
Let me rephrase, publicly state, like how many sheriffs have.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: ren on March 01, 2020, 11:40:10 AM
I wouldn't put money on that bet.

Or they don't believe them to be unconstitutional.

there's quite a few here on this forum...have any of them voiced their opinions on anything pro2A?
You'll read about guns, gear and training but that's it.
At this point it's disheartening but not surprising.
I was very impressed by the courage of that retired detective who spoke at the Senate Committee hearing a few weeks ago. :shaka: If he's a member of this forum I take back my statement.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: Heavies on March 01, 2020, 05:15:19 PM
there's quite a few here on this forum...have any of them voiced their opinions on anything pro2A?
You'll read about guns, gear and training but that's it.
At this point it's disheartening but not surprising.
I was very impressed by the courage of that retired detective who spoke at the Senate Committee hearing a few weeks ago. :shaka: If he's a member of this forum I take back my statement.

Don't rock the boat mentality...  along with 90% of the Hawaii gun owners.  If all Hawaii gun owners would vote and take a stand, these law breakers(makers) wouldn't dare
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 01, 2020, 06:32:00 PM
there's quite a few here on this forum...have any of them voiced their opinions on anything pro2A?
You'll read about guns, gear and training but that's it.
At this point it's disheartening but not surprising.
I was very impressed by the courage of that retired detective who spoke at the Senate Committee hearing a few weeks ago. :shaka: If he's a member of this forum I take back my statement.
"When i retired, i turned in my badge, gun, cuffs, and radio. Now in just like all these everybody else".

HPD non brass should be on our side. 1 day, they will be just like everyone and forced to defend themselves with a handicap (mag limit, no ccw, no taser, etc..)

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 01, 2020, 08:57:21 PM
there's quite a few here on this forum...have any of them voiced their opinions on anything pro2A?


I don't know which users are cops so I don't know but cops tend to be pretty pro gun so...

Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 01, 2020, 09:03:07 PM
Based on how they act, they will follow the orders and not stand up for the peoples rights and the Constitution.

?

Quote
How many HPD officers showed up to hearings in uniform to speak against the proposed laws? Oh yeah...none. Are they afraid of being fired or other disciplinary actions? It's why they have SHOPO and the citizens review board to ensure officers aren't punished punitively for doing the right thing.

I don't think speaking in uniform against department policy would be protected by the union.

Quote
Can any HPD officer in this forum state for the record in the same sentence that they are HPD and will defend OUR rights as written in both the US and Hi Constitution? That they won't enforce the Red Flag law? That they believe in open or concealed carry? How about just carry 10 round magazines like us little people are forced to? You know, in a show of solidarity. I won't hold my breath.

Not a question I can answer. They might not hold the same views on constitutionality as you though so understand there would be some wiggle room on understanding what they believe to be constitutional or not.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: hvybarrels on March 01, 2020, 11:41:49 PM
Not a question I can answer. They might not hold the same views on constitutionality as you though so understand there would be some wiggle room on understanding what they believe to be constitutional or not.

Will we all sound like this when we are released from the re-education camp?
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 02, 2020, 12:12:48 AM
I don't know which users are cops so I don't know but cops tend to be pretty pro gun so...

Please provide objective, documented data (surveys, interviews, public statements) which support your assertion.  Otherwise, what you posted is merely your unsupported opinion.  "Feelings".
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: RSN172 on March 02, 2020, 05:12:18 AM
I strongly believe cops in general are pro gun.
For themselves, not for you or me.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: robtmc on March 02, 2020, 06:45:39 AM
I strongly believe cops in general are pro gun.
For themselves, not for you or me.
Precisely how I see it. 

For them to be armed while the sheep are not is the perfect situation for them.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: Rocky on March 02, 2020, 07:44:38 AM


I don't know which users are cops so I don't know but cops tend to be pretty pro gun so...

OMFG    :o  :wtf:

I never thought I would agree with EEF, but EVERY PO I know personally is pro 2a.
Even gone as far as saying " I know you would have my back " if the situation arose.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: 6716J on March 02, 2020, 07:59:49 AM
There is probably some internal policy that prevents individual officers from speaking on behalf of the department so the officers could get disciplined.

But rolling 20 deep with the Chief is okay... Intimidation is a great thing.

Again, one day they will all be just lowly citizens, but then again as retired HPD the rules don't apply to them either.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: drck1000 on March 02, 2020, 08:27:02 AM

I never thought I would agree with EEF, but EVERY PO I know personally is pro 2a.
Even gone as far as saying " I know you would have my back " if the situation arose.
I think I saw a blue moon last night.  Better watch out for those monkeys. . .  :rofl:

But seriously, I don't know that many POs, but I have met the range with regards to 2a.  Some that are really into firearms, pro 2a, etc.  Then there are those that "only LE should have firearms".  Then are those that frankly seem to care less about firearms and just view it as a requirement for the job (I mean I'm exaggerating. . .).  One of my best friends a cop and we used to hang out with his former partner quite often.  He's one that pretty much only shot at qualification.  We used to joke around that we should challenge one day at the silhouette range.   ;D
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: stangzilla on March 02, 2020, 09:31:42 AM
funny how the chief says we don't need guns to defend ourselves, at the same time she is wearing a pistol on her hip
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: Heavies on March 02, 2020, 10:52:59 AM

....snip     They might not hold the same views on constitutionality as you though so understand there would be some wiggle room on understanding what they believe to be constitutional or not.

From the 1790s to the 1930s Americans knew exactly what the second Amendment was about. After the Democrats trashed and destroyed the right in 1934, it's all been a racist privileged shitshow since.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 02, 2020, 12:43:32 PM
From the 1790s to the 1930s Americans knew exactly what the second Amendment was about. After the Democrats trashed and destroyed the right in 1934, it's all been a racist privileged shitshow since.

This is why we need to fight and not give an inch.  As a result of our forefathers, this is where we end up today.

10rd magazine today, 7rds next.  Then 5 rds, then 3rds.

Saw a banner asking for assault weapons to have 3rd mag limits just like shotguns do for hunting and how we protect geese more than our children.  The response by pro 2a: It's illegal to hunt children.

IIRC, this was in MA.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: 6716J on March 02, 2020, 02:39:13 PM
This is why we need to fight and not give an inch.  As a result of our forefathers, this is where we end up today.

10rd magazine today, 7rds next.  Then 5 rds, then 3rds.


Cass Sunstein...NUDGE

Don't do it all at once. Just a nudge and it will get there. It's why they went for 7 in NY. 1911 has 7 round as stock. But agree they will push for 5 then 3 in all firearms
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: Kuleana on March 02, 2020, 04:09:01 PM
From the 1790s to the 1930s Americans knew exactly what the second Amendment was about. After the Democrats trashed and destroyed the right in 1934, it's all been a racist privileged shitshow since.

Exactly what my ultimate point has been.

The America everyone has been taught to believe is not the America of today.  We can debate what events and dates when it began its transformation, but the fact is the new America is beginning to take shape and there is nothing that is going to stop its evolution in the years to come.

From what we see in the erosion of the US Constitution and Bill of Rights, especially in the slow, but steady state-by-state repealing of the 2nd Amendment; the new America is headed to becoming a true fascist police state.  The migration of the liberals and democrats as well as influx of illegal immigrants to historically Republican and conservative states will further tip the national and local election scales that will support this change. 

Stay Tuned for More!

Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: 6716J on March 02, 2020, 07:08:21 PM
Exactly what my ultimate point has been.

The America everyone has been taught to believe is not the America of today.  We can debate what events and dates when it began its transformation, but the fact is the new America is beginning to take shape and there is nothing that is going to stop its evolution in the years to come.

From what we see in the erosion of the US Constitution and Bill of Rights, especially in the slow, but steady state-by-state repealing of the 2nd Amendment; the new America is headed to becoming a true fascist police state.  The migration of the liberals and democrats as well as influx of illegal immigrants to historically Republican and conservative states will further tip the national and local election scales that will support this change. 

Stay Tuned for More!
Woodrow Wilson....
 Then the New Deal

Sent from my SM-G970U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 03, 2020, 09:39:23 PM
Will we all sound like this when we are released from the re-education camp?

If the constitution were so perfectly worded that no one could ever misinterpret the meaning we wouldn't need the supreme court. Obviously that's not the case and there are disagreements about various meanings from the most basic of us to the experts in constitutional law.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 03, 2020, 09:40:41 PM
Please provide objective, documented data (surveys, interviews, public statements) which support your assertion.  Otherwise, what you posted is merely your unsupported opinion.  "Feelings".

Just an observation, not quite an opinion and not at all feelings. And you seem to think opinion and feeling are interchangeable. They are not.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 03, 2020, 10:34:23 PM
If the constitution were so perfectly worded that no one could ever misinterpret the meaning we wouldn't need the supreme court. Obviously that's not the case and there are disagreements about various meanings from the most basic of us to the experts in constitutional law.
Thats because people who have agendas are using morons to support it. And we as citizens  have evolved from using force to using the courts to settle disagreements. Which the people with agendas know.

The constitution is clear. Its not like shakespear wrote it in his jibberish or in chinese.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: Brystont1 on March 03, 2020, 10:46:31 PM
If the constitution were so perfectly worded that no one could ever misinterpret the meaning we wouldn't need the supreme court. Obviously that's not the case and there are disagreements about various meanings from the most basic of us to the experts in constitutional law.

The constitution doesn’t have to be perfectly worded. We have contextual evidence from our founding fathers explaining exactly what the meant when they wrote each amendment. It’s not like they wrote the 2nd amendment and said “Ok! We now leave it up to you to interpret what we meant”.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: hvybarrels on March 04, 2020, 11:10:52 AM
If the constitution were so perfectly worded that no one could ever misinterpret the meaning we wouldn't need the supreme court. Obviously that's not the case and there are disagreements about various meanings from the most basic of us to the experts in constitutional law.

That does not give you an excuse to make up the laws as you see fit. We see where you are going with this, Officer. The problem is that you have not really thought it through yourself. When the law breaks the law there is no law.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 04, 2020, 09:53:38 PM
That does not give you an excuse to make up the laws as you see fit. We see where you are going with this, Officer. The problem is that you have not really thought it through yourself. When the law breaks the law there is no law.

On the contrary I have given it a lot of thought and find constitutional law quite interesting.

People who have spent decade studying the constitution don't even all agree on everything in it so there has to be a certain amount of leeway when you look at the decision of a police officer who may have only studied constitutional law for a few weeks in some academy.

Its a pipe dream to think the constitution is so clear that everyone can easily understand it and if they don't come to the same conclusion as you that they are wrong.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 04, 2020, 09:56:23 PM
The constitution doesn’t have to be perfectly worded. We have contextual evidence from our founding fathers explaining exactly what the meant when they wrote each amendment. It’s not like they wrote the 2nd amendment and said “Ok! We now leave it up to you to interpret what we meant”.

Contextual evidence and the writings of founding fathers do play a role in helping to understand and apply the constitution but they have their limitations as well.

Personally I think the language of the constitution has to be the primary way to apply the constitution but that is getting into a bit of a separate topic so I will stop there.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: macsak on March 04, 2020, 10:10:33 PM
Contextual evidence and the writings of founding fathers do play a role in helping to understand and apply the constitution but they have their limitations as well.

Personally I think the language of the constitution has to be the primary way to apply the constitution but that is getting into a bit of a separate topic so I will stop there.

that never stopped you before...
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: ren on March 05, 2020, 09:03:55 AM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mxtu228bYFw

her explanation begins at 2:57
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: oldfart on March 05, 2020, 09:14:14 AM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mxtu228bYFw

her explanation begins at 2:57
===========
that's so funny and tragic on so many levels
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: changemyoil66 on March 05, 2020, 01:54:35 PM
The constitution doesn’t have to be perfectly worded. We have contextual evidence from our founding fathers explaining exactly what the meant when they wrote each amendment. It’s not like they wrote the 2nd amendment and said “Ok! We now leave it up to you to interpret what we meant”.

To anyone with a brain the words "shall not be infringed" is clear.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 06, 2020, 09:41:32 PM
that never stopped you before...

Sure it has. If you want to debate constitutional interpretation, feel free to start a thread for it.  :stopjack:
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: Brystont1 on March 06, 2020, 11:57:26 PM
Contextual evidence and the writings of founding fathers do play a role in helping to understand and apply the constitution but they have their limitations as well.

Personally I think the language of the constitution has to be the primary way to apply the constitution but that is getting into a bit of a separate topic so I will stop there.

What part of the 2A and it’s supporting contextual evidence limits it’s correct interpretation?
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: RSN172 on March 07, 2020, 06:37:49 AM
What part of the 2A and it’s supporting contextual evidence limits it’s correct interpretation?
Too bad neva have Hawai'i Pidgin bac den.  Den no mo problem undastan.

“So nobody oppress us, da peopo kin carry any kine weapon dey lik, wea eva dey lik.”
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: robtmc on March 07, 2020, 11:07:32 AM
Exactly what my ultimate point has been.

The America everyone has been taught to believe is not the America of today.  We can debate what events and dates when it began its transformation, but the fact is the new America is beginning to take shape and there is nothing that is going to stop its evolution in the years to come.

From what we see in the erosion of the US Constitution and Bill of Rights, especially in the slow, but steady state-by-state repealing of the 2nd Amendment; the new America is headed to becoming a true fascist police state.  The migration of the liberals and democrats as well as influx of illegal immigrants to historically Republican and conservative states will further tip the national and local election scales that will support this change. 

Shocked, I am, you finally posted something I find true and accurate.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 07, 2020, 11:41:40 AM
Exactly what my ultimate point has been.

The America everyone has been taught to believe is not the America of today.  We can debate what events and dates when it began its transformation, but the fact is the new America is beginning to take shape and there is nothing that is going to stop its evolution in the years to come.

From what we see in the erosion of the US Constitution and Bill of Rights, especially in the slow, but steady state-by-state repealing of the 2nd Amendment; the new America is headed to becoming a true fascist police state.  The migration of the liberals and democrats as well as influx of illegal immigrants to historically Republican and conservative states will further tip the national and local election scales that will support this change. 

Stay Tuned for More!

Every country goes though peaks and valleys in its social and political landscape.  It's the natural order of things.

We are not a British Colony.

We are not pushing Westward to settle and tame the vast majority of the North American continent.

We are not fighting to end slavery or prevent states from seceding from the US.

We are not taking weeks to travel a few hundred miles to get somewhere,

We are not waiting weeks or even days for written news to reach us so we know how friends and family are doing.

We are not waiting for the local newspaper to be on the street to know what's going on in the country and the world.

We have politicians who live their entire lives in government office now whereas those positions were originally intended to be a short-term side gig, as the office holders maintained their own farms or businesses in the meantime.

We are not being served by our press corps.  They view us as their servants, providing billions of dollars per year in revenue so they can feed us their biased and sensationalized nonsense rather than real news.

Our schools no longer teach real history.  The teachers/system interject their own opinions and biases into the lectures which shapes the minds of graduates.

The society and political arena have changes as technology has changed.  What you may have been "taught to believe" in the last 90 years is going to be different than what you were taught to believe 5 years ago.

I don't believe your premise is correct.  What YOU and I were taught to believe was taught long before the Liberals got ahold of the schools.  What they apparently are being taught to believe now is "Socialism works," "Conservatism = Fascism" and "America is just an evil, oppressive empire that owes its residents free everything because wealth = greed, and greed = evil."

#distressed

The problem isn't that our ideals don't represent the current state of things.  It's that so many have been taught those ideals are a lie, which created a vacuum in people's lives that has been filled for some with a belief in big government and lack of faith in individual responsibility.

That's my take on it from a bird's eye view.  It's easier to convince people their ideals and beliefs are wrong when you only point to where there are failings while ignoring the accomplishments and positives.  Reminds me of the story of the Ten Commandments, and the constant nay-saying by Dathan.  He blamed Moses for every road block the Jews encountered when leaving Egypt until the people finally started to believe in his words and not so much in what Moses taught them.

People are too easily convinced a system is bad when confronted by evidence that not everything is perfect.  It's far easier to give up than to continue to work toward an ideal.  True, that ideal might be unattainable for now, but I guarantee it'll never happen if we stop trying.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: Kuleana on March 08, 2020, 07:03:41 PM
"Our schools no longer teach real history.  The teachers/system interject their own opinions and biases into the lectures which shapes the minds of graduates."

Nothing wrong with critical reflection, as long as all perspectives are considered.



"What they apparently are being taught to believe now is "Socialism works,"

Socialism does work if utilized pragmatically.



"Conservatism = Fascism"

Today's neoconservatism is fascism.



"America is just an evil, oppressive empire that owes its residents free everything because wealth = greed, and greed = evil."

America is an empire that has become a welfare state because it allowed its ultrawealthy to predominantly own, control, and monopolize the majority of the nation's wealth and resources.

Greed is a necessary virtue needed to become ultrawealthy.  Although it may not be evil, it certainly does not benefit society to have ultrawealthy people running the show.



"#distressed"

With the US Constitution and the Bill of Rights slowly being rescinded by the powers-that-be in this country, I believe being in a state of distress is an understatement.

 

"People are too easily convinced a system is bad when confronted by evidence that not everything is perfect.  It's far easier to give up than to continue to work toward an ideal.  True, that ideal might be unattainable for now, but I guarantee it'll never happen if we stop trying."

You are essentially advocating beating on a dead horse, as similarly thinking as though Hawaii will eventually become 2nd Amendment friendly one day.

Wake up, America is DONE.  Having Trump as President is only delaying the inevitable.

For example, you really think America will maintain its Bill of Rights?

Tell that to the all of the Police Department's in America who are against the 2nd Amendment.

Tell that to all the Congressmen in US House and Senate who refuse to repeal the Patriot Act.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 08, 2020, 07:28:54 PM
"Our schools no longer teach real history.  The teachers/system interject their own opinions and biases into the lectures which shapes the minds of graduates."

Nothing wrong with critical reflection, as long as all perspectives are considered.



"What they apparently are being taught to believe now is "Socialism works,"

Socialism does work if utilized pragmatically.



"Conservatism = Fascism"

Today's neoconservatism is fascism.



"America is just an evil, oppressive empire that owes its residents free everything because wealth = greed, and greed = evil."

America is an empire that has become a welfare state because it allowed its ultrawealthy to predominantly own, control, and monopolize the majority of the nation's wealth and resources.

Greed is a necessary virtue needed to become ultrawealthy.  Although it may not be evil, it certainly does not benefit society to have ultrawealthy people running the show.



"#distressed"

With the US Constitution and the Bill of Rights slowly being rescinded by the powers-that-be in this country, I believe being in a state of distress is an understatement.

 

"People are too easily convinced a system is bad when confronted by evidence that not everything is perfect.  It's far easier to give up than to continue to work toward an ideal.  True, that ideal might be unattainable for now, but I guarantee it'll never happen if we stop trying."

You are essentially advocating beating on a dead horse, as similarly thinking as though Hawaii will eventually become 2nd Amendment friendly one day.

Wake up, America is DONE.  Having Trump as President is only delaying the inevitable.

For example, you really think America will maintain its Bill of Rights?

Tell that to the all of the Police Department's in America who are against the 2nd Amendment.

Tell that to all the Congressmen in US House and Senate who refuse to repeal the Patriot Act.

No, I am advocating for setting lofty goals that create a country that idealizes individual freedom.  You say Socialism works.  Socialism by definition cannot exist with individual liberty,  Socialism only exists as a collective society -- taking what you make, giving to to those who want or need it, while giving you the fruits of others' labor with no opportunity to provide what you might deem fair value for either.  That's not freedom.  That's serfdom.  Of course, those who do the taking and giving get a lion's share, because they have that power -- the power people like you would willing give them out of some misguided hatred for "the ultra wealthy".  We live in a country that's raised the standard of living level higher for the poor than any in the last 100 years.  Equal opportunity -- not equal outcome.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: Kuleana on March 08, 2020, 09:52:31 PM
"You say Socialism works.  Socialism by definition cannot exist with individual liberty,  Socialism only exists as a collective society -- taking what you make, giving to to those who want or need it, while giving you the fruits of others' labor with no opportunity to provide what you might deem fair value for either.  That's not freedom.  That's serfdom."

Critics of socialism always characterizes socialism as absolutes, as you do.  I am one who is not a die hard fan of any particular economic ideology, but an ideological pragmatist.  America was founded and has incorporated many elements of socialism for decades.  Social security, the veterans administration, the five day/ 40 hour work week, the federal armed forces, the militia, etc. are all applications of socialism.
.
The concept of freedom is not dependent of some political/economic ideology, but rather a human right that can only be affected by those who wish to legally or illegally restrict that right.



"We live in a country that's raised the standard of living level higher for the poor than any in the last 100 years."

The standard of living for any country is often attributed to the relative wealth that nations possesses.  This view while not incorrect is only partly true.  Rather, the standard of living of a nation is more correlated to the technological progress of that nation.



"Equal opportunity -- not equal outcome"

I agree with this premise, but that is not what we have in America.


Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 08, 2020, 10:00:55 PM
"You say Socialism works.  Socialism by definition cannot exist with individual liberty,  Socialism only exists as a collective society -- taking what you make, giving to to those who want or need it, while giving you the fruits of others' labor with no opportunity to provide what you might deem fair value for either.  That's not freedom.  That's serfdom."

Critics of socialism always characterizes socialism as absolutes, as you do.  I am one who is not a die hard fan of any particular economic ideology, but an ideological pragmatist.  America was founded and has incorporated many elements of socialism for decades.  Social security, the veterans administration, the five day/ 40 hour work week, the federal armed forces, the militia, etc. are all applications of socialism.
.
The concept of freedom is not dependent of some political/economic ideology, but rather a human right that can only be affected by those who wish to legally or illegally restrict that right.



"We live in a country that's raised the standard of living level higher for the poor than any in the last 100 years."

The standard of living for any country is often attributed to the relative wealth that nations possesses.  This view while not incorrect is only partly true.  Rather, the standard of living of a nation is more correlated to the technological progress of that nation.



"Equal opportunity -- not equal outcome"

I agree with this premise, but that is not what we have in America.

Being a "fan" is irrelevant.  If you have a better plan that's been tested and proven to work better, then please, educate us.

In the meantime, using the greatest Super Power in the world to experiment on by implementing policies already proven by Socialist countries to fail is irresponsible.  You tell me I'm advocating for beating a dead horse, yet this dead horse (Capitalism / market-based economic policies) seems to still have quite a bit of life left in it -- or have you not seen the jobs numbers that were 100,000 new jobs beyond last month's expectations?

What YOU are advocating for is implementing an idealistic fantasy that has never worked, and it's only through arrogance and ignorance would anyone say, "Well, that's because ALL THE OTHER PLACES didn't do it the right way ... and I'm much smarter than they were!"

 :wacko:
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 08, 2020, 10:10:26 PM
What part of the 2A and it’s supporting contextual evidence limits it’s correct interpretation?

There are a number of ways in which we can look at the constitution to interpret it. Textualism, originalism, pragmatism, etc.
https://fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R45129.pdf

Using certain historical records to make a case for what the founders meant (originalism) has certain limitations in how accurate or how complete a picture can be painted about a part in the constitution.I believe that textualism is a better and more reliable way of interpreting the constitution.  I don't discount the historical records, they do serve a purpose in supporting our right to own firearms however I don't base my whole interpretation of the second amendment on them.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: Heavies on March 09, 2020, 07:02:44 AM
There are a number of ways in which we can look at the constitution to interpret it. Textualism, originalism, pragmatism, etc.
https://fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R45129.pdf

Using certain historical records to make a case for what the founders meant (originalism) has certain limitations in how accurate or how complete a picture can be painted about a part in the constitution.I believe that textualism is a better and more reliable way of interpreting the constitution.  I don't discount the historical records, they do serve a purpose in supporting our right to own firearms however I don't base my whole interpretation of the second amendment on them.


Isn't the whole idea of the great United States of America experiment and experiment in the premise of personal responsibility and liberty?  Interpreting the 2A in a view of government control of a persons arms seem counter intuitive.

There are portions of the original document the actually limit personal human freedom, and through the cost of blood and sacrifice, many of these portions have been struck from the document.

I don't see a reason to ADD government intervention into the document to limit personal freedom.  In fact, when such ideas were attempted, it went very badly...
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: Brystont1 on March 09, 2020, 08:21:38 AM
There are a number of ways in which we can look at the constitution to interpret it. Textualism, originalism, pragmatism, etc.
https://fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R45129.pdf

Using certain historical records to make a case for what the founders meant (originalism) has certain limitations in how accurate or how complete a picture can be painted about a part in the constitution.I believe that textualism is a better and more reliable way of interpreting the constitution.  I don't discount the historical records, they do serve a purpose in supporting our right to own firearms however I don't base my whole interpretation of the second amendment on them.

But that’s my point. Why does a “case have to be made”? Why do people have “their” interpretation? When we start talking about “my interpretation” it sounds a bit like “my truth”. It’s either the truth or it’s not. It seems like those who like to interpret the constitution the way they see fit are basically making the constitution useless as they use their interpretation to make whatever laws fit their narrative.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: groveler on March 09, 2020, 10:14:57 AM
But that’s my point. Why does a “case have to be made”? Why do people have “their” interpretation? When we start talking about “my interpretation” it sounds a bit like “my truth”. It’s either the truth or it’s not. It seems like those who like to interpret the constitution the way they see fit are basically making the constitution useless as they use their interpretation to make whatever laws fit their narrative.
" It seems like those who like to interpret the constitution the way they see fit are basically making the constitution useless as they use their interpretation to make whatever laws fit their narrative."
You have nailed the essence of the Democrat party.
The party that rules this state, and cheats the rest of us out of our
rights.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on March 09, 2020, 10:18:39 AM
But that’s my point. Why does a “case have to be made”? Why do people have “their” interpretation? When we start talking about “my interpretation” it sounds a bit like “my truth”. It’s either the truth or it’s not. It seems like those who like to interpret the constitution the way they see fit are basically making the constitution useless as they use their interpretation to make whatever laws fit their narrative.

This is the result of having 20+ pages of listings in the local yellow pages for "Lawyers".

Multiply that by the number of medium-to-large cities across the country, and also factor in a 5-times multiplier for DC.
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: Kuleana on March 09, 2020, 08:36:03 PM
"If you have a better plan that's been tested and proven to work better, then please, educate us."

For starters, to make America really GREAT again:

Domestically - No more immigration of any kind, end private central banking, and repeal any laws that hamper the Bill of Rights.

Internationally - End all military alliances, withdraw all military forces to CONUS only, focus on policing all borders, and no foreign aid of any kind.

Take care of America and Americans first!



"You tell me I'm advocating for beating a dead horse, yet this dead horse (Capitalism / market-based economic policies) seems to still have quite a bit of life left in it -- or have you not seen the jobs numbers that were 100,000 new jobs beyond last month's expectations?"

Those stats always lie.

Can you tell me what kind of jobs were created and what jobs were lost last month?



"What YOU are advocating for is implementing an idealistic fantasy that has never worked, and it's only through arrogance and ignorance would anyone say, "Well, that's because ALL THE OTHER PLACES didn't do it the right way ... and I'm much smarter than they were!"

I am not advocating anything, other than taking a hard look at what really is happening economically in the US and then implement any program that can address those issues regardless of what -isms they come from.

Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: ren on March 09, 2020, 09:19:58 PM
this thread went out to Mars..
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: macsak on March 09, 2020, 09:28:44 PM
this thread went out to Mars..

#distressed
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: hvybarrels on March 09, 2020, 09:28:52 PM
this thread went out to Mars..


I blame coronavirus
Title: Re: HPD press conference for mag ban
Post by: ren on March 09, 2020, 09:44:53 PM
#covid19
#infected