2aHawaii

General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: SpeedTek on June 28, 2012, 10:12:39 PM

Title: Happened tonight.
Post by: SpeedTek on June 28, 2012, 10:12:39 PM
A dog got loose from up the street. A Rottwieler/Pit Bull mix. It killed the cat next door. Then it came into our yard and was attacking our chicken cage. My son grabbed a 22 rifle and was going to shoot the dog. I told him to stop. If he did shoot it was it right?
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: Kevin on June 28, 2012, 10:35:33 PM
Where do u live?  If in Hawaii cry u prob get in trouble. I think u r not supposed to discharge a firearm near residence unless in self defense. But if no one calls the cops then everyone goes home happy. One shot one kill, I don't think people will notice, but like I said where u live makes a difference
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: SpeedTek on June 28, 2012, 10:40:40 PM
Pearl City. I know that if human life is in danger on your property then it may be justified. But you cant run with a gun off your property. Any bullets that leave your property you are responsible. But since the dog was only attacking other pets it is not justified.

The neighbors cat that was killed was torn in half. They found the parts 10 feet apart!
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: WCMTWS on June 28, 2012, 10:49:44 PM
I would have shot it, or atleast whacked it with the stock.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: Teichi on June 28, 2012, 10:53:05 PM
Can I borrow that dog? There is a feral cat infestation around my office.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on June 28, 2012, 11:34:59 PM
You are just in shooting the dog in protection of yourself and/or your property (which would include your animals.)

If you did go outside and the dog approached you then you can shoot it given it's violent behavior and that it is loose. People might say that you should have stayed inside but there is no requirement that you retreat from an aggressive dog. If the dog was going around threatening everyone then a shooting would be justified. If you just heard the dog killed a cat and it was walking around happy then it is a little less justified. You basically need to first make sure that any rounds will not hit anyone else. Then you need to be able to articulate why you killed the dog. That the dog had displayed signs of violence, was on the loose, was going into other people's property, and was aggressive towards someone. Even if the dog was not aggressive towards you a shooting could still be justified.
You know that this dog just killed a cat and you also know (for example) that a nearby neighbor has a 2 year old who is outside, still justified to shoot the dog. I have seen cases where an owner shot two other dogs who were attacking his dogs and it was deemed justified.

A .22 would not be my first choice to kill a large dog though.

If you call the cops be sure to advise them that a family member is armed so they do not get any surprises.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: Inspector on June 29, 2012, 06:03:06 AM
Correct me if I am wrong but under the law animals (as pets or farm animals) are considered possessions such as a car or home is. We are not allowed to protect our possessions with a firearm.

So if a pitbull kills your cat it becomes a civil matter and a possible endangerment to the general public. Also, I believe it would be prudent to report the dog getting loose and killing a cat and going after chickens to animal control. There is probably a law that if your pitbull gets out so many times (usually 3) then it can be removed from the premises and the owner fined. It is good to report this as if it is you or your dog or cat that is kill or injured such reports will help you in a civil court case.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: Heavies on June 29, 2012, 06:07:35 AM
Can I borrow that dog? There is a feral cat infestation around my office.

Me too.  Cats around my house are getting bad.  Can I shoot the cats instead? lol

I had this sort of thing happen to me a while back, however the dog did not kill any other animals, and I was able to scare the animal out of my property.  The owner got a good 'talking' to.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: wirecounter on June 29, 2012, 03:15:28 PM
Me too.  Cats around my house are getting bad.  Can I shoot the cats instead? lol

A pellet gun (Remington NPSS .22) would do the trick without the attention that comes with discharging a firearm.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: crazy cat on June 29, 2012, 07:21:57 PM
Cats or rats, take your pick.....
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: spanner1751 on June 29, 2012, 07:30:11 PM
I think that you did the right thing. Even though you might have been right to shoot the dog, it's not worth the chance of getting arrested, thrown in jail, and having to hire a lawyer. Here in Hawaii, the only time that I would even think of using a firearm would be to defend myself or a family member inside my house.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on June 29, 2012, 07:40:28 PM
Correct me if I am wrong but under the law animals (as pets or farm animals) are considered possessions such as a car or home is. We are not allowed to protect our possessions with a firearm.


You are allowed to protect your possessions though. This means that were a dog attacking your pet you could attempt to rescue your pet. If while trying to rescue your pet the dog becomes aggressive towards you then absolutely you could use your firearm.

TO a certain extent you can use a firearm to protect your property. If you see someone breaking into your car in your garage you are justified in presenting your firearm at the individual. Shooting is a separate issue of course.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: hvybarrels on June 29, 2012, 09:23:24 PM
this is why i want to move out of the city.

"have you seen my dog?"

"Nope."

Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: SpeedTek on June 29, 2012, 09:31:31 PM
this is why i want to move out of the city.

"have you seen my dog?"

"Nope."

Dog Adobo? or Mongolian Dog?

My dad use to make a excellent Mongolian Dog....(RIP)
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: hvybarrels on June 29, 2012, 09:42:45 PM
Ha ha Scooby Snacks
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: HiCarry on July 02, 2012, 10:02:54 AM
You are justified in shooting the dog if you are in fear of death or injury to yourself or a third party....protecting your animal by shooting the dog probably wouldn't fly....but in the process of protecting your animal using other means the dog then tries to attack you, you'd then be justified in using the firearm....
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: DuckFat on July 03, 2012, 10:10:17 AM
Use a baseball bat?
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: TeamSDSHawaii on July 03, 2012, 11:22:09 PM
Second the bat...

Pretty sad when we have to be so careful in the safety and defense of our lives and loved ones on our own property in Hawaii....

A loose vicious animal on your property, thats threatening ANYTHING on your property should be a legal grounds to stop that threat by any means necessary... including a firearm.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: antoinebugleboy on July 04, 2012, 12:47:15 AM
I think you did the right thing telling your son not to shoot.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: Surf on July 04, 2012, 07:11:11 AM
* The following is a hypothetical scenario and is for discussion purposes only.  This is not legal advice or a suggested course of action to any type of incident. * 

As eluded to above you have the right to attempt to stop the vicious dogs actions.  If at any time you feel that you or another is in jeopardy of serious bodily injury or death, you may act accordingly.  You would want to ensure that you do not fire errant shots that could fall into the Reckless Endangering section.  It would also take a persistent investigator, then need a pretty hard core prosecutor to even wish to accept such a case of Reckless Endangering, much less prosecute one if it resulted from an individual fighting for their life against a vicious animal.  Of course never say never and the perfect storm can happen, but in this type of incident I cannot recall such a case off the top of my head.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: DuckFat on July 04, 2012, 11:00:28 AM
Correct me if I am wrong but under the law animals (as pets or farm animals) are considered possessions such as a car or home is. We are not allowed to protect our possessions with a firearm.
Hmm, this makes me wonder. I can see not using a firearm to protect your property from another human's actions. But, what about protecting your property from a nonhuman, in this case a pet/possession? Is the farmer not allowed to shoot the fox in his chicken coop?
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: Inspector on July 04, 2012, 12:01:12 PM
Hmm, this makes me wonder. I can see not using a firearm to protect your property from another human's actions. But, what about protecting your property from a nonhuman, in this case a pet/possession? Is the farmer not allowed to shoot the fox in his chicken coop?
Play this situation out in the country and ask yourself if any other farmers would even hear the shot. And if any did would they care and call the police? If the police even bothered to show up you would have plenty time to bury the evidence so to speak.

Now play this situation out in the city where it actually happened and ask your self the same questions. When the cops come to the door they will do what they feel is necessary (ticket/arrest?) considering you discharged a firearm within city limits and endangered other humans. The police would probably say you should have stayed inside and called the police.

Now if the fox/pit bull was attacking another human........
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: Old Guy on July 04, 2012, 01:28:39 PM
S  S  S

If you don't know, I'm not teling.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 05, 2012, 01:40:45 AM
Play this situation out in the country and ask yourself if any other farmers would even hear the shot. And if any did would they care and call the police? If the police even bothered to show up you would have plenty time to bury the evidence so to speak.

Now play this situation out in the city where it actually happened and ask your self the same questions. When the cops come to the door they will do what they feel is necessary (ticket/arrest?) considering you discharged a firearm within city limits and endangered other humans. The police would probably say you should have stayed inside and called the police.

Now if the fox/pit bull was attacking another human........

The shooting could be justified without the animal actually attacking another human.
The rules about the use of deadly force apply when humans use deadly force on other humans, not to animals.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: dubya on July 05, 2012, 10:26:53 AM
http://www.staradvertiser.com/news/breaking/143419486.html?id=143419486 (http://www.staradvertiser.com/news/breaking/143419486.html?id=143419486)

... hits rather close to home (no pun intended).
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 05, 2012, 01:55:19 PM
http://www.staradvertiser.com/news/breaking/143419486.html?id=143419486 (http://www.staradvertiser.com/news/breaking/143419486.html?id=143419486)

... hits rather close to home (no pun intended).

From what I heard from someone who lives in the area that story is BS for starters.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: dubya on July 05, 2012, 03:48:36 PM
From what I heard from someone who lives in the area that story is BS for starters.

In all honesty, I'm not much concerned about the veracity of Mr. Chun's assertion... in my mind, it sounds like the task of determining the truth behind the story is something that will be soon be presented to a jury comprised of Mr. Chun's peers.  I referenced the article largely due to certain similarities that appear in both the OP's situation and Mr. Chun's assertion, but notwithstanding the truth of the story, what is clear is this:  Mr. Chun was arrested and charged with reckless endangerment, and other unspecified charges.

What I am concerned about is posts that positively assert (without benefit of caveat or disclaimers) that firing a rifle at a dog, to defend chickens in a chicken cage, in a densely-populated Oahu neighborhood, like Pearl City, is justifiable.

Aside from the myriad of potential public safety issues that such advisement can create, the fact is, no one can say with absolute certainty that such an act is "justifiable."  The statutes, rules, and regulations that we must abide by can be "grey" and open to interpretation.  To further complicate (mahalo, Kevin!  :shaka:) the matter, case-specific facts do have a bearing upon the final disposition of any case.

I applaud the OP's decision to keep his son from firing a round at the offending dog.  This serves as an excellent display in self-restraint that OP's son can reflect upon, perhaps when confronted with a situation in the future when OP's son is alone and forced to make a snap decision that could potentially have final and definitive consequences.

Also, please note that the question in the original post reads, "If he did shoot it was it right?"  I submit that one can be "right" (subjective issue) in their actions, while still be criminally or civially liable for such actions.

*Caveat*  This post is not intended to serve as, nor should it be construed as, legal advice.  ;)
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: pastordennis on July 05, 2012, 07:57:36 PM


Big Island police are investigating an attempted robbery which occurred on Wednesday night (July 4) in Kailua-Kona.

Shortly before midnight, a man described as a Caucasian male entered the Lako Street Chevron armed with a handgun and demanded money from the 46-year-old male cashier working behind the counter. The cashier refused the demand for money and the suspect fled from the area.

The suspect was described as being in his late teens to early 20’s, between 150 and 160 pounds, and as having a fair complexion. He was wearing a dark colored hooded sweat shirt, shorts, shoes and mirrored sunglasses.

He fled in a light colored four door sedan traveling in an unknown direction.

Police advise the public not to approach this man if they see him or know where he is.

Police ask that anyone with information on his identity or whereabouts call Detective Sean Smith at 326-4646, extension 262, or the Police Department’s non-emergency line at 935-3311.

Tipsters who prefer to remain anonymous may call crime Stoppers at 961-8300 in Hilo or 329-8181 in Kona and may be eligible for a reward of up to $1,000. Crime Stoppers is a volunteer program run by ordinary citizens who want to keep their community safe. Crime Stoppers doesn’t record calls or subscribe to caller ID. All Crime Stoppers information is kept confidential.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: pastordennis on July 05, 2012, 07:59:11 PM
Here we go again. But we dont need conceal carry.....its all good till someone gets killed. I got my daughter in law a 38 spcl. Once shes trained in aug. its all hers.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: pastordennis on July 05, 2012, 08:01:04 PM


Big Island police are investigating an attempted robbery that reportedly occurred in the Puna District on Monday (July 4).

A 20-year-old Kea’au man reported that at about 1 a.m. Monday, he picked up a man in the area of highway 11 near the Shipman Industrial park entrance. He reported that after traveling south on Route 11 in a light green Honda, he turned into the Fern Acres subdivision in Puna and the male passenger attempted to carjack him. The victim said that while attempting to steal the vehicle, the suspect was injured and was last seen running into the bushes.

The victim was not injured during the incident. He described the suspect as a “hapa” or mixed-race man in his 20s, about 5-foot-9 to 5-foot-10. He was last seen wearing a dark hooded jacket over a white T-shirt and dark blue knee-length jeans shorts. He may have an injury to his left thigh area.

Police are investigating this incident as a first-degree attempted robbery and ask that anyone who may have knowledge as to the identity of this individual call Detective John Rodrigues Jr. at 961-2382.

Tipsters who prefer to remain anonymous may call Crime Stoppers at 961-8300 in Hilo or 329-8181 in Kona and may be eligible for a reward of up to $1,000. Crime Stoppers is a volunteer program run by ordinary citizens who want to keep their community safe. Crime Stoppers doesn’t record calls or subscribe to caller ID. All Crime Stoppers information is kept confidential.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: pastordennis on July 05, 2012, 08:02:35 PM
RELEASE

Big Island police are investigating a robbery in Hilo early Wednesday (March 9).

A 56-year-old Hilo man was approached by three men on Banyan Drive near Lihiwai Street at 2 a.m. They assaulted him and removed his backpack and wallet.

Fire/rescue personnel took the victim to Hilo Medical Center for treatment of his injuries.

Police ask that anyone with information about this case call the Police Department’s non-emergency line at 935-3311.

Tipsters who prefer to remain anonymous may call Crime Stoppers at 961-8300 in Hilo or 329-8181 in Kona and may be eligible for a reward of up to $1,000. Crime Stoppers is a volunteer program run by ordinary citizens who want to keep their community safe. Crime Stoppers doesn’t record calls or subscribe to caller ID. All Crime Stoppers information is kept confidential
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: pastordennis on July 05, 2012, 08:03:55 PM


Big Island police have arrested a 25-year-old Kailua-Kona man in connection with a shooting Friday (July 1) in the parking lot of a local business on Kuakini Highway.

Responding to the 6:10 p.m. call, officers learned that a 54-year-old Kailua-Kona man had been shot during a foot chase that occurred after the 25-year-old male acquaintance attempted to steal the victim’s wallet. The suspect fired a dark colored pistol at the victim striking him in the shoulder and then fled the area in a sport utility vehicle.

The victim was taken to the Kona Community Hospital, where he was treated for a puncture wound caused by a pellet and then released.

On Sunday (July 3) police located and arrested Andrew M. Wanat while in the parking lot of an apartment complex on Kuakini Highway for suspicion of attempted robbery and assault.

Police also recovered a black Co2 pellet gun believed to be the weapon used during the shooting incident.

Wanat is being held at the Kona police cellblock while detectives with the Area II Criminal Investigation Section continue the investigation into the circumstances of the shooting.

UPDATED MEDIA RELEASE (7/5/11)
Andrew M. Wanat

Andrew M. Wanat

Big Island police have charged a 25-year-old Kailua-Kona man arrested Sunday (July 3) in connection with a shooting Friday (July 1) in the parking lot of a local business on Kuakini Highway.

Andrew M. Wanat was charged at 5 p.m. Monday (July 4) with first-degree attempted robbery and second-degree assault. His bail was set at $12,000.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: pastordennis on July 05, 2012, 08:05:04 PM
This guy has been in my cell block more than once. We really need concealed carry here. What ya think guys?????
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: pastordennis on July 05, 2012, 08:05:57 PM
Share on google_plusone
Share on gmailShare on printfriendlyMore Sharing Services

john-reeceA 59-year-old Kailua-Kona man has been charged with attempted murder and other offenses in connection with a domestic dispute Wednesday, Dec. 17.

Kona patrol officers responded to a report of a domestic argument Wednesday evening on Haoa Street in Kailua-Kona. Upon arrival, they determined John Reece had wrapped a belt around his wife’s neck and attempted to strangle her. The 50-year-old victim screamed for help and neighbors had come to her assistance. The woman had been able to flee from the home.

The officers arrested Reece for felony abuse of a family/household member.

After consulting with prosecutors, detectives from the Juvenile Aid Section charged Reece on Thursday, Dec. 18 with second-degree attempted murder, first-degree terroristic threatening and felony abuse of a family/household member. His bail was set at $22,000.

He is being held at the Kona police cellblock pending his initial court appearance.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: pastordennis on July 05, 2012, 08:07:59 PM
Share on google_plusone
Share on gmailShare on printfriendlyMore Sharing Services

UPDATED MEDIA RELEASE (10/18/09)
Emil Delao

Emil Delao

Police have charged an Arizona man in connection with an attempted robbery Wednesday (October 14) along Ali’i Drive in Kailua-Kona.

Emil Delao of Tucson, Arizona, was charged at 2:30 p.m. Saturday (October 17) with attempted robbery, kidnapping and terroristic threatening.

An 18-year-old woman reported that she was walking by the rock wall of Hale O Kane Park at 8:45 p.m. Wednesday when a man began speaking to her, followed her and told her he was going to rob her. As the woman tried to run away, the man knocked her down and she screamed. The screams attracted passersby and the suspect fled the scene without taking anything.

The woman was not injured.

Police investigation led to Delao’s arrest Thursday afternoon at the Kona airport, where he was waiting to catch a scheduled flight to the mainland.

Delao is being held at the Kona police cellblock in lieu of $6,000 bail pending an initial court hearing scheduled for Monday.

MEDIA RELEASE (10/15/09)

A 56-year-old Arizona man is in police custody in connection with at attempted robbery Wednesday (October 14) along Ali’i Drive in Kailua-Kona.

An 18-year-old woman reported that she was walking by the rock wall of Hale O Kane Park at 8:45 p.m. when a man began speaking to her, followed her and told her he was going to rob her. As the woman tried to run away, the man knocked her down and she screamed. The screams attracted passersby and the suspect fled the scene without taking anything.

The woman was not injured.

Police investigation led to the arrest Thursday afternoon (October 15) of Emil Delao of Tucson, Arizona, at the Kona airport, where he was waiting to catch a scheduled flight to the mainland.

Delao is being held at the Kona police cellblock pending charges while detectives from the Area II Criminal Investigations Section continue the investigation.

Police ask that anyone with information about the case call Detective Myra Iwamoto at 326-4646, extension 281, or the Police Department’s non-emergency line at 935-3311.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: pastordennis on July 05, 2012, 08:08:21 PM
when will enough be enough?
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: pastordennis on July 05, 2012, 08:09:52 PM


A Waikoloa man is in police custody in connection with a robbery in South Kohala.

At 6:15 a.m. Thursday (September 10), South Kohala patrol officers responded to a report of a robbery at the Kings Shops, where someone had entered a store through a door that was unlocked for deliveries and removed liquor and other items.

When a witness attempted to follow the man as he exited the store, the man pulled out a knife or similar sharp object and threatened the witness.

At 10:30 a.m., police found the suspect, 24-year-old Casey Leitch, at the Queens Shops and arrested him after a foot chase. He is being held at the Kona police cell block pending charges while detectives continue the investigation.

 
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: pastordennis on July 05, 2012, 08:10:37 PM
Share on google_plusone
Share on gmailShare on printfriendlyMore Sharing Services

MEDIA RELEASE

Hawai’i Police Department detectives are investigating a reported home invasion robbery in Hilo on Thursday (July 23).

A 59-year-old man reported that an unknown masked male brandishing a firearm entered his Kino’ole Street home through the back door. The intruder confronted the victim and told him to secure a dog that was running loose. After the victim secured the dog in a portable kennel, he was struck on the head and he lost consciousness. Upon regaining consciousness, he discovered that he had been bound with duct tape on his mouth, wrist and lower legs.

The suspect made off with an undetermined amount of cash.

The victim was taken to Hilo Medical Center, where he was treated and released.

The suspect is described as thin, about 160 pounds. He was reportedly wearing blue jeans and a dark long-sleeved shirt with a dark nylon stocking over his face and a dark stocking cap. He spoke in pidgin. The firearm was described as a silver pistol.

Police ask that anyone with information on this robbery call Lieutenant Mitchell Kanehailua at 961-2252 or the Police Department’s non-emergency line at 935-3311. Tipsters who prefer to remain anonymous may call Crime Stoppers at 961-8300 in Hilo or 329-8181 in Kona. All Crime Stoppers information is kept confidential.

 
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: pastordennis on July 05, 2012, 08:11:40 PM


Hawaii Police are investigating a robbery reported early Monday, Jan. 12 in Hilo.

At about 2:40 a.m., South Hilo patrol officers responded to a report of a man being assaulted at Kalakaua Park in downtown Hilo.

Sometime between 2:30 a.m. and 2:35 a.m. Monday, an unidentified Caucasian man approached the victim and asked if he wanted to buy marijuana. Another man, described as Hawaiian, struck the victim on the head with what is being described as a metal object.

He then stole an undisclosed amount of cash from the victim.

The Caucasian man fled the area on foot, and other man fled riding a bicycle.

The Caucasian suspect is described as in his 20s, approximately 5-foot-7, 170 pounds with short hair. He was swearing a black hat and dark shirt.

The Hawaiian man is described as in his 20s, approximately 5-foot-5 with short, curly black hair.

The victim was treated for his injuries at Hilo Medical Center and later released.

Police ask anyone who may have witnessed the incident or who has any information about the suspects to call the Police Department’s non-emergency line at 935-3311. Tipsters who prefer to remain anonymous may call Crime Stoppers at 961-8300 or 329-8181.
Title: Happened tonight.
Post by: hnl.flyboy on July 05, 2012, 08:15:44 PM
I feel ya, Pastor Dennis. Right now all we can do is pray for Mr. Baker's case, that the hearts and minds of those who make the decisions over us be moved to allow us to defend ourselves, and support HDF in their legal battle. All that legal stuff is expensive. I'm thankful Hawaii was blessed with Mr. Baker and his tenacity. I'll be making another donation to HDF when I find a job.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: pastordennis on July 05, 2012, 08:35:10 PM
God bless you flyboy. Amen
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: Kevin on July 05, 2012, 11:06:37 PM
.  To further complicated the matter, case-specific facts do have a bearing upon the final disposition of any case.


I think u meant complicate not complicated but if I get in trouble I will hire u as my defense attorney : ) half of the big words I needed to use google to find out da definition
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: dubya on July 06, 2012, 07:33:28 AM
Mahalo, Kevin.  Duly noted and revision made.  Thank you, good sir.  :shaka:

Also,  http://www.bigislandnewscenter.com/police-seeking-james-coffey-for-puna-shooting (http://www.bigislandnewscenter.com/police-seeking-james-coffey-for-puna-shooting)

Possible theme music:  Guns n' Roses, "I Used To Love Her."
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: HiCarry on July 06, 2012, 04:39:21 PM
Pastor Dennis, may I suggest that you document the above crimes in the "Armed Crimes" section of the general topics section of this forum? It was intended to capture all these stories for future reference, with the idea that having them in one place would ease retrieval when necessary.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on July 07, 2012, 09:23:48 AM
In all honesty, I'm not much concerned about the veracity of Mr. Chun's assertion... in my mind, it sounds like the task of determining the truth behind the story is something that will be soon be presented to a jury comprised of Mr. Chun's peers.  I referenced the article largely due to certain similarities that appear in both the OP's situation and Mr. Chun's assertion, but notwithstanding the truth of the story, what is clear is this:  Mr. Chun was arrested and charged with reckless endangerment, and other unspecified charges.

What I am concerned about is posts that positively assert (without benefit of caveat or disclaimers) that firing a rifle at a dog, to defend chickens in a chicken cage, in a densely-populated Oahu neighborhood, like Pearl City, is justifiable.

Aside from the myriad of potential public safety issues that such advisement can create, the fact is, no one can say with absolute certainty that such an act is "justifiable."  The statutes, rules, and regulations that we must abide by can be "grey" and open to interpretation.  To further complicate (mahalo, Kevin!  :shaka:) the matter, case-specific facts do have a bearing upon the final disposition of any case.

I applaud the OP's decision to keep his son from firing a round at the offending dog.  This serves as an excellent display in self-restraint that OP's son can reflect upon, perhaps when confronted with a situation in the future when OP's son is alone and forced to make a snap decision that could potentially have final and definitive consequences.

Also, please note that the question in the original post reads, "If he did shoot it was it right?"  I submit that one can be "right" (subjective issue) in their actions, while still be criminally or civially liable for such actions.

*Caveat*  This post is not intended to serve as, nor should it be construed as, legal advice.  ;)

indeed, it is not something to take lightly, thats why I stressed the need to articulate the danger and provide examples where shooting would and would not be justified.
Title: Re: Happened tonight.
Post by: pastordennis on July 07, 2012, 02:02:47 PM
Hicarry......duly noted. Thank you
Pastor Dennis